世界航海/海軍歷史 原汁生肉 Ship vs Ship, 1 vs 1 - Why you don't see them here
王者风范
22粉絲
7 次觀看·2025年9月6日
大家好,歡迎收看這個視頻,是由Squarespace贊助的
正如你剛纔看到的,Squarespace是一個很強大的工具
可以建立網站、小市場、網上店鋪
甚至可以建立會員區和討論區,如果你想
正如你所知,我用了Squarespace來建立了我的網站
所以這次我想讓你們看看
如何輕鬆地把東西添加到你的網站上
這裡是圖像庫
如果我轉到圖像庫
然後選擇增加
從這裡我可以選擇擁有的圖像庫
這讓我轉到這個菜單
然後我可以選擇圖像庫
我選擇了圖像庫5
當它出現的時候,我決定把它叫做
英國鋼鐵
這裡,很漂亮地輸入了
我選擇剪輯
轉到圖像控制板
刪除已存在的圖像
輸入一些新的圖像
上載到我的硬碟
選擇一堆英國鋼鐵圖像
從Mrs.Drakos親自掃描和上載的檔案
然後在幾秒的上載時間
它們開始出現
我可以選擇其中一張圖像
然後給它一個名字
在這個情況下是HMS Belisle
然後點擊完成
然後我現在有一個很好的名字圖像
但假設我喜歡圖像大一點
那就很簡單
改成一張圖像一張圖像
這樣就完成了
然後我可以回到主要的檔案
我認為這需要一點清晰
因為這裡有兩個不同的連接方式
我決定選擇文字連接
而不是按鈕連接
然後我會刪除按鈕
並加上文字連接到其他檔案
然後我再點擊新的英國鋼鐵圖像
點擊連接
選擇檔案
選擇英國鋼鐵圖像的檔案
然後就完成了
所以我告訴檔案我完成了剪輯
點擊連接看看是否正在運作
然後就完成了
而這張HMS Camperdown的圖像
並不符合我設定的圖像圖像圖層
這個圖像圖層
你可以看到
如果你打開新的圖層
它仍然在最高解析度
我可以隨時增加另一個圖層
連接到同一張圖像圖像圖像圖像圖層
但無論如何
如果你想體驗一個相似的
簡單的使用體驗
那就去squarespace.com
獲得免費測試
遊玩一下
如果你覺得你準備了
將該網站推出到公眾領域
就去squarespace.com.com.com
你現在可以在螢幕上看到
為了儲存10%
你第一次購買一個網站或領域
所以再次感謝Squarespace
贊助這個視頻
資金會直接進入
美國旅遊基金
這會產生更多圖像
給這個網站
所以這是一個很好的循環性
無論如何
繼續看今天的視頻
好
所以
這和航空產品有直接關係
然而
這視頻是關於
為什麼我不做某些事情
而不是關於
任何的歷史課
雖然有
多個小歷史課
所以這不符合
一個星期天視頻的標準
這就是為什麼
這個視頻是星期天
但是
我認為
希望很多人
仍然會覺得很有趣
那就是
正如名字所指
航空對航空視頻的
比較
為什麼我不做
日常的星期天視頻
有些人都知道
我偶爾
給我的意見
在航空對航空對戰
的乾淨導航
但是乾淨導航
是一個比較短的規格
每個人的問題
都可以
如果有人問我問題
我回答問題
這是一個
我做的
主觀判斷
而不是
星期天視頻
我正在展示
更多的事實基礎資訊
這不是說
乾淨導航
沒有事實
它有事實
因為我做研究
但是它也有
意見基礎答案
和事實基礎答案的機會
現在
說到這裡
有六個主要原因
為什麼我不再做
星期天視頻
的視頻
你知道
有一次
我做了
但是
希望
我會嘗試
給你一些意見
為什麼
第一個問題
航空對航空對戰
對比
我們會用
航空對戰
航空對戰的例子
因為這是
大部分的問題
但是
你可以大規模地
應用
任何航空
它們不孤單
在大多數
大多數
大多數的情況下
因為
沒有一艘航空
想要和平對戰
如果
一艘航空
可以令情況不公平
那麼它們
會盡全力
做到
同時
在大多數的情況下
早在航空對戰時期
沒有人
派出戰艦
沒有任何救援
除非他們
處於
非常非常嚴重的困境
甚至在航空對戰時期
如果
你輕輕地定義
戰艦為船
你可能會發現
一個奇怪的三艘航空
但是
這個奇怪的三艘航空
有多少次
變成了
這個奇怪的三艘航空
被淹沒或被捕
甚至
三艘航空
曾經和一些朋友
你肯定不會有
一艘三艘航空
獨自飛行
除非
你肯定
它的安全
你還會有
至少一艘航空
或兩艘航空
或其他航空
至少在
目的地
你會發現
像是
飛彈
或航空
的威脅
所以
到了
20世紀
這就
變得
越來越明顯
例如
Yamato
被派出
Operation Tango
它經常被
稱為
Yamato的
最終任務
是的
它是
但是
它也帶來了
幾十艘救援艇
例如
蘇格蘭戰爭
一艘
日本戰鬥艇
面臨
多少
是的
一百多艘
美國戰鬥艇
即使不是
必須
發射
它
還有很多
支援的元素
航空艇
毀滅艇
PT艇
等等
而且
它並不是
自己的
另一艘戰鬥艇
和Megami
和一些毀滅艇
其餘的
沒有
長時間
參與
最終對戰
是
你知道
所以
有些人會想到
經常複雜的細節
如果他們
還活著
那當然
這並不是
一對六的情況
這絕對不是
一對一的情況
就算是
歷史上
的情況
甚至
如果
蘇格蘭戰鬥艇
都失敗
這仍然會是
一艘航空艇對一艘航空艇的戰鬥
而不是一對一的戰鬥
當你看到
Denmark Strait的戰鬥
或Bismarck的最後行動
事實上
奇怪的是
這並不是一場
戰鬥
在任何情況下
這並不是一對一的戰鬥
Bismarck在第一場
不擁有Prinz Eugen
在第二場
在第一場
有Norfolk
Suffolk
Hood和Prince of Wales
即使航空艇
無法完全
進入
而在
第二場
對戰
有Nelson
Rodney
和King George V
但也有Dorsetshire
和一群毀滅者
和幾艘航空艇
和Mark Royal
在附近
如果他們需要
但是
這仍然不是一對一的戰鬥
那麼
你可能會想
肯定有些戰鬥
但如何對付
北海岸戰鬥
Sharnhorst和Duke of York
是的
技術上
如果從表面層面來看
但那是
Sharnhorst
一旦失去
其載彈毀滅者
和Duke of York
和Jamaica
和Belfast
和Sheffield
和Norfolk
和一群毀滅者
是的
Sharnhorst和Duke of York
可能仍然是
不公平的戰鬥
為了Duke of York
但是
英國人不需要
玩得公平
他們不想這樣
所以他們帶了一群朋友
和Duke of York
只是為了確保
Sharnhorst沒有逃走
所以
當你去尋找
單艘航空艇
和單艘航空艇的行動
其實非常難
找到任何
這意味著
任何歷史上的前提
你可以從
那兩艘航空艇
或各種航空艇
對抗彼此
或一艘航空艇的
總結
甚至
航空艇
作為一體
作為一艘航空艇
我猜
或那種航空艇
做出了什麼
在一艘航空艇中
你能在
其他
複雜的情況下
根本不存在
就算是
Kirishima vs. Washington
後來的
仍然包括
美國毀滅者
南卡魯地亞
和一堆
日本船
而
Kirishima vs. Washington
戰爭
你可以說
是一場
1V1
發生的情況
只因為
日本在
南卡魯地亞
而
華盛頓
得到了
多於
Kirishima的
回彈
總結
第一點
有很少
真正的
1V1
大多數艦艇
尤其是
首都艦艇
戰鬥時
他們不會
在
和朋友
除非
他們被迫
進入
非常危險的
所以
這是一個
非常不真實
和
很少
歷史基礎
的
第二點
時間
和
天氣
合作
是
非常
影響
戰鬥
的
現在
有兩個
主要的方式
影響戰鬥
和
兩種
主要的方式
首先
最永恆的
時間
和
天氣
所以
我們假設
這裡有
某種
天氣
因為
晚上
是一種
天氣
相信
不
如
南卡魯地亞
但是
如果
是
早上
下午
或
下午
這將
影響
準確
的
望遠鏡
這是
在
康納戰爭中
在
多次
戰爭中
簡單來說
如果
太陽
升起
或
降落
有
時期
是
對
和
對
船
的
即使
船
在
同一位置
這
在
快速的
時間
上
改變了
原因
是
如果
太陽
在
陰下
也就是
半小時
的
陽光
升起
和
降落
在
你的
高度
這
意味著
船
靠近
太陽
的
差異
船
在
遠處
有
優勢
因為
船
靠近
陰下
的
會
被
陽光
影響
船
在
遠處
會
很難
找到
因為
它仍然
很
暗
沒有
光明的背景
讓它被影響
而且
我們在
20世紀
尤其是
火箭射
尤其是
尤其
尤越
接近
尤越
所以
如果
British ships were highlighted against the sunset in that particular case
And the British ships had to fire into the darkness
Which made it much harder for them to see anything
So if a fight takes place at dawn or dusk
That might be the situation
But the situation flips around
Either a few minutes before or a few minutes after that first situation
Depending on which of the two circumstances you're looking at
Because if the sun is slightly higher in the sky
Then if we're talking the sun would side ship I guess
We'll be able to see the darkness would ship
Because now the sun is high enough to highlight it perfectly well
Against the background of the darker skies and seas
And in terms of the ship that previously or subsequently would have the cover of darkness
Now a low but full sun is going to shine right into the eyes
Of any optical range finding equipment
Which you know don't look at the sun generally
Especially don't look at the sun through a pair of high power magnification lenses
Because then you die
Well you might not die but you'll definitely have your eyes burned out
You'll probably wish you had died
And perhaps more importantly
You won't be able to tell anybody what the range is
And if you're lucky and you're looking at slightly offset
And you just get glare
You probably still won't be able to see all that much
So a fight that happens at sunrise or sunset
Could have some fairly major things shifting in favor or against a ship
Depending on exactly what time of day
And what time it is of the day in that particular period
Of course if you're fighting in the middle of the day
Then the sunlight should be broadly similar for both sides
But that's a very specific engagement
Out of the 24 hours that you might have
Or the engagement taking place over
And then you get to the weather involved
Which includes the hours of darkness
So anything that completely broadly obscures your ability to see
Whether that be fog, heavy rain, mist
Which I suppose fog and mist are similar
Plus obviously darkness
That can have a huge impact
Because some ships will have an ability to see through that
Or perceive things through that
Such as radar for example in World War II
Significantly better than ships of the other side
And when it comes to night
Obviously night fighting techniques
The Germans in World War I
The British and the Japanese in World War II
Would have a leg up over everybody else
Who was an Admiral Lee in most circumstances
So that can all have a fairly significant impact
So if you have a fight that in daylight hours
Might go one way
At night it might go another way completely
And that's before you take into account
What most people would think of as
Quote unquote actual weather
Things like high sea states
Because again
In perfectly calm daylight sea conditions
If you take the two-sharn horse
And put them up against a renowned class battle cruiser
I'd say it's probably fair to think
That the two-sharn horse
Would have an overall advantage
But then you get to something like
The action of Lofoten
Where exactly that scenario occurs
And a number of other factors
Which we'll talk about later aside
The extremely rough weather that's being faced
Had some rather deleterious material effects
Actually on both sides
But far more deleterious effects
On the sharn horse than it did on Renown
And that's partly because
Frankly Renown was a better sea boat
In the first place
But also because of the alignment of the ships
Relative to where the weather was coming from
The wind and the waves
And as a result
Sharn horse and Gneisenau
Decided to make a break for it
Rather than trying to fight Renown
And Renown tried to chase them down
So you have this whole mixture of things
If you're going to set up a 1v1
Ship versus ship engagement
In a hypothetical
You've got to tell me
What time of day it is
What the weather conditions are like
And so on
And what the lighting conditions are like
And etc
Because any number of things
Could give one side or the other
A completely decisive advantage
Even if on paper
The other side has a massive advantage
So to cite another example
That sometimes gets asked
Bismarck versus Warspite
Sure
Put them in a flat calm
In the middle of the day
And Bismarck has a very, very
Significant advantage over Warspite
Put them in a night action
Perhaps in really bad heavy weather
And given that Bismarck
Either ends up with broken radar
Or knocks its own radar out quite often
Yeah
If it's extremely low visibility
Somewhat rough seas
And Warspite's got its radar working
Well Warspite actually has
Quite a significant advantage there
Which perhaps people
Definitely wouldn't expect
Again just comparing things on paper
And then third
You have the exact time period
Which is related to the equipment
That a ship will have
This is a huge and very, very
Difficult field to work your way through
And the reason for that is that
Equipment changes can make huge impact
On how well a battle is going to go
Especially when you're talking about
World War II
Because obviously World War I
I mean you have the question of
Did a ship have central director
Range finding or not
Okay that's somewhat important
But other than that
If you assume that
Either both ships have it
Or both ships don't have it
Most of the time you assume
Both ships do have it
Even if it might not be strictly true
If you match up two
World War I capital ships in 1914
And you match up the same
Two capital ships in 1918
Really the only major difference
Apart from the availability
Of the central director
Is probably going to be
If it's a versus a British ship
Have they got green boy shells or not
So it's not too bad an issue
At that point
At least from one perspective
Whereas in World War II
It's all over the shop
Radar, weapons bits, etc
All change quite dramatically
And even what kind of radar
Not just whether or not a ship
Has radar but what kind
Because are you talking about
For example if you're going to use
A US ship
Is it going to be carrying
A CXAM radar
Is it going to be using an SG radar
Is it going to be using
Some other form of radar
All of that
If you take your night engagement
Or bad weather engagement
Into account
Could make massive differences
To the performance of that vessel
Compared to whatever
It's going up against
And the existence of ships
Plays into this as well
Because another one I see
Trolled around the internet
Quite a lot
But fortunately hasn't come up
Too much on the channel
Iowa versus Bismarck
This is a match
That has no fair comparison
Why
Because Iowa was commissioned
Almost two years after
Bismarck was sunk
So shockingly
Even if we assumed for a moment
That the US and Germany
Had otherwise identical
Levels of technical progression
During World War II
Iowa is clearly going to have
A technological advantage
Because it benefits from
Two further years of
Radar and range finder
And radio etc. etc.
Advancements
Which Bismarck physically can't have
Because it was on the bottom of the ocean
And that's ignoring the fact
That obviously Iowa's design
Is also a more recent design
Which is why it's being built
And commissioned later etc. etc.
But that's perhaps less
Of a factor than the technological one
And this goes further
And this is one of the things
That really irritates me when I see it
People who take
The technological capabilities
Of a warship
After it's been upgraded
Because it happened to have survived the war
In a post-war environment
And then try to retroactively
Apply that to an engagement
With something like
Like Bismarck for example
Which sunk
Which was sunk in the
Beginning period of the war
You know 1941
Is the first third of the war
As far as most people are concerned
And actually before the US
Even gets involved in the war
But you know
The particular quote that I find
It really grinds my gears
Is anything to do with a US ship
You will almost always have
Someone who thinks they're being clever
Pop in with some variant of flavor
On a quote that
Reads something along the lines
Of I think it's USS North Carolina
Could be wrong on the exact ship
But I think it's that
Which is quoted as having
A fire control system so advanced
That it could run
Figure of eight patterns at full speed
Whilst maintaining a perfect
Radar guided lock on the target
For range and elevation
And therefore any US battleship
Will instantly have the advantage
Because it can just do
All sorts of weird and wacky maneuvers
And still maintain perfect
Range finder lock
And the other ship
Which doesn't have this technology
Will have to be
Sailing in a straight line
Or doing minimal maneuvers
To keep its own target lock going
And therefore the US ship wins
Or everyone goes home happy the end
The reason this irritates me
Beyond all reason
Is because that test
Yes it did happen
And yes US ships
Did have this capability
I'm not denying this
But that test happened
After World War II
After the final series of upgrades
To the battleship in question's
Range finder equipment
To claim this is representative
Of US battleship's
Combat capabilities
In World War II
At any point in World War II
You know whether it be 1941
Or 1944 or whatever in between
And that it applies universally
To all battleships
Including you know
The refitted standards and so forth
Is so hilariously inaccurate
As to be almost beyond comprehension
But you almost always see that
Quote trotted out
And it's like
Now you're just being silly
You're basically asking
Well what if a ship
In a theoretical 1V1 World War II matchup
Was equipped with technology
From the future
Well of course it's going to have
A huge technological advantage
At that point you might as well say
Well you know we're going to put
USS Iowa up against Yamato
And Iowa wins
Because it'll launch a bunch of
T-LAM Tomahawks
Or the Sea Keeper
Sea Attack versions of Tomahawks
Plus Harpoon Missiles
Yes Iowa had that technology
In the 1980s
Is it an entirely fair comparison
Not at all
Is it relevant to how the two ships
Would have stacked up in World War II
No
Stop it
I mean and by the same token
You can make equally trite arguments
Like well Bismarck versus Iowa
Bismarck clearly wins
Because Bismarck in 1941 exists
Iowa in 1941
Is still a partly completed hull
On the stock
So if we're doing a pure 1v1
Bismarck shows up and shoots up
The half completed hull of Iowa
And goes home happy the end
You know
You have to take into account
What time period you're talking about
If you want it to be
Not necessarily a fair fight
Because people don't
Navies don't want fair fights
But at least something
Approximating a meaningful comparison
So if you're going to do
Bismarck versus Iowa
Don't do Bismarck versus Iowa
Do Tirpitz versus Iowa
Because at least
Tirpitz and Iowa have a
Two to three year period
Where they actually exist
Contemporaneous with each other
And might actually have ended up
Fighting each other
But even so
Tirpitz is sunk during the war
So don't go pulling out the tired old
Oh yes well in the late 1940s
US battleships could do this
Therefore they'll do this to Tirpitz
No
Look at what the ships had at the time
So if you're going to do
An Iowa versus Tirpitz battle
I'd suggest maybe early 1944
Would be a good one to do
Maybe January 1944
But even then
You still have to be careful
Because of course
Ships are being upgraded all the time
So if a US battleship
Let's say North Carolina or Washington
Is launched and it has a CXAM radar
Great fine
Now at some point
That radar is going to be upgraded
And it's going to be upgraded again
And if we're putting it up against
For the sake of ease of argument
A German ship
Well the Germans start off
With something like C-Tact
Early version thereof
And they upgrade C-Tact a number of times
And then they have other radars
That they introduce
So even if you're going to have
At least a decent enough grace
To propose a fight at a time
When both ships physically exist
And therefore one isn't going to have
A massive either technological advantage
Or existence advantage over the other
You still have to be very careful
To avoid a bias
One way or the other
Of choosing a time and date
When one ship may have just received
The latest and greatest of
Of their nation's technology
And the other might have
A technological fit out
That's a year or two behind the times
Do you want to have Tirpitz
With it fighting on say
The first day after it's fitted
With the German equivalent
Of full radar guided
Blind fire technology
And put it up against
A U.S. battleship
That on that date
Hadn't had the same from the U.S.
But might have had that
Technology refitted to it
Three or four months later
Again at that point
You're more looking for a result
Than asking what a rational
One v. one fair matchup is
So you then have to make the decision
Of are you going to be
Slightly more flexible with things
And say well you know
This was this nation's equivalent
Of a blind fire radar system
This is the other nation's
Equivalent of a blind fire radar system
Assuming that both nations
Actually developed such a thing
And maybe this ship was equipped
With it in the beginning of this year
And this ship was equipped with it
Nine months later or whatever
But we're going to assume
For the sake of our discussion
That they both have this system
And that one hasn't moved on
To better and greater things
And then you have at least
A meaningful comparison
You know the ships are equipped
With as good as each nation can get
Again assuming that they developed
Those systems
In terms of fire control
And it's reasonable
That they might have met up
In those circumstances
Had situations been different
Or maybe perhaps it's different ships
From a class
Because obviously not every ship
In a class gets the same refit
At exactly the same time
But this is the level of granularity
You have to go down to
When it comes to the time period
And the equipment
That the ships actually have
Otherwise as I say
It's more a case of
You're just looking for someone
To say something
That makes you feel good
Rather than actually asking
How would these two ships
Actually fare up against
The other one we've won
So again to take another
Again somewhat trite example
If you want to refight
Hood versus Bismarck
Obviously lots of people
Point to Denmark Strait
Oh clearly Bismarck is superior
Whereas you could say
Ah yes but no
What I was actually referring to
Was what would happen
If it was a fight in the 1925
Well Hood wins
Because Bismarck physically
Doesn't exist
But I mean
Most of the steel
That made up Bismarck
Is probably still iron
Or in the ground
At that point
So Hood wins
By virtue of mere existence
For the vast majority
Of its lifespan
And then you have the last
Couple of years
When Bismarck is
In something approximating
A combat capable condition
But it's bright and shiny new
And Hood is quite old
And has quite a few
Virgin and obsolete systems aboard
So there's another reason
Why it's very difficult
To pin down a meaningful
Ship versus ship comparison
Number four
Soft factors
That's a very very broad term
But one of the biggest issues
With soft factors
Is the quality of the crew
Because not only
Can a ship's crew quality
Be different
Even on a ship versus ship basis
So you might have ships
Of the same class
But if you pick one ship
That ship's crew
Might have been demonstrably better
Than another ship's crew
But also even for a given ship
As crew changes
And refits are done
And new crews are brought in
Old crews are sent out
The quality of an individual ship
May vary on a year by year basis
So again
Referencing the Lofoten incident
Renown had a reputation
As being an excellent gunnery ship
So if you are
Taking a ship versus ship comparison
And you're looking at
How would HMS Renown do
Against, insert
Enemy ship here
Do you factor in
That Renown is probably likely
To perform somewhat better
Than her on-paper stats would suggest
Simply because she seems to have
An elite crew
And an extremely good record of gunnery
Or do you ignore that
And insist you only look at
The on-paper statistics
In which case you're not asking
How would HMS Renown
Of World War II fame
Do against a ship of
Whatever designation
You're going to put up against her
You're asking
How would
A ship that happens to look
Like HMS Renown do
If it was crewed with
A bunch of average sailors
Which
Again
It's perhaps a valid technical exercise
If you assume that the other side
Also has a similar
Generic NPC crew
But
It's not exactly a comparison
Of the ships in question
It's more a comparison
Of technical paper stats
Which
Is less interesting
And much more easily done
On a spreadsheet
And to give another example
HMS Exeter
When she fought Graf Spee
She had
And this ties back in a little bit
To the time period in equipment
So when she fights Graf Spee
She has
Optical range finding
But
Has
Some pretty good gunners aboard
Despite the fact that she's mauled
From stem to stern
She manages to land
A few fairly important hits
On Graf Spee
Fast forward to
Her being an ABDA commander
And all of a sudden
Despite the fact that
It's a few years later
And her equipment
Has been upgraded
She now has
A lot more capability
In terms of radar
Her gunnery actually
Goes downhill quite a bit
But that's not the fault
Of the technology
In that particular case
She's had an entirely new crew
They're not quite green
But near enough
As makes no difference
Close to it
So instead of having
Perhaps slightly above
Average gunnery
But
Limitations on how well
She can fight in really bad weather
Which would be
If you put Exeter against
Something else in 1939
In 1941
Exeter can probably see
Anyone coming in any kind of weather
Thanks to her radar
But the chances of her actually hitting them
Are somewhat more remote
So when you take into account
These kinds of soft factors
You have to be very careful
About not just which ship you're picking
Because again
Take another example
With a lot of variations
The Queen Elizabeth class
Queen Elizabeth class battleship
In World War II
That could be something like
Malaya or Bahram
It could be Warspike
It could be Queen Elizabeth or Valiant
On paper
The latter two have
The greatest technological advantage
But in terms of soft factors
Warspike appears to be a case
Of actual living plot armour
So
If you factor in
The soft factor issues
Warspike will have
Quite a number of significant advantages
As opposed to
Any of her four sister ships
But then if you
If you account for the soft factors
But somebody who's reading or listening
To what you've published
Doesn't
Then that starts off
With a whole other set of arguments
Oh well no
You know
Warspike only has this
Technological capability
And this ship is
Technologically superior
Therefore this ship
Will always win
And you're just being silly
By asserting that it could
In any way shape or form
Stand a chance
It's like
OK
If that was a purely
Technical discussion
You might be right
But I've chosen to
Take the soft factors into account
Oh yes
Well you can't fully quantify them
They still existed
And you know
That kind of argumentation
Does also make it
Very difficult to do
A fair ship v. ship 1 v. 1
Because
Are you overestimating
The soft factors for one ship
Are you underestimating
The soft factors for another ship
Would somebody else's
Evaluation of those same
Soft factors come out
The same as yours
The further away
And this is the thing
The further away you get
From the strictly quantifiable
The more and more
Subjective it becomes
But if you ignore
Things like soft factors entirely
And go for purely what's on paper
Well then it's not
Actually representative
Of the historical vessels anymore
You're more creating
A kind of alternate universe
Dimension version of those vessels
Which is less informative
About their actual capabilities
And then we get to
Factor number 5
Misinformation
There's an awful lot of that
Out and about
And quite frankly
If you do a kind of
1 v. 1 ship v. ship
For anything
That has any kind of
If you like
Brand recognition
Or name recognition
You'll get the usual
Suspects crawling out
Of the woodwork
Going on with
About all sorts of
Weird and wonderful
But incredibly easily
Debunked things
To do with those ships
And to be honest
Even if you get technical
You have self-appointed
Technical experts
Who clearly actually have
No training or experience
In what they're talking about
But will shout
Very very longly and loudly
About things they
Frankly know nothing about
And anyone with
Any degree of education
Would tell them that
But because
They like the sound
Of their own voices
And they don't want to listen
Because they've made up their minds
They'll argue
Till the cows come home
And probably after
They've been turned into burgers
That their position is right
Because it's their position
And frankly
I've got better things to do
Than argue with people like that
Or have them clustering up
The comment section
And so as a personal reason
And I think a lot of other
Naval historians feel the same way
Certainly a lot of the ones
I've spoken to
The misinformation factor
Just makes things really
Really difficult to work through
And that's just to be honest
Misinformation for some parts
Of the audience
There's also a lot of
Misinformation out there
That hopefully as a historian
Who does a reasonable amount of research
You can cut through
But some things become
Such quote-unquote
Common knowledge
That you might be
Led into believing something
Not because you
Particularly believe it
But because perhaps
That's the only thing you've heard
For a very, very long time
And it sounds reasonable enough
So you kind of go with it
Because it doesn't seem to be
That important
But in actual fact
It could be very important
Or it could be completely wrong
And you open yourself up to
Legitimate accusations
Of not having actually
Conducted a fair
And reasonable assessment
Because of a blind spot
That you've hit
So for example
Let's take a one
That has a lot of discussion
Going on about it
Italian shells
So baseline
Yes, Italian shooting
And shell dispersion
Particularly
Has a number of recorded instances
Where it was hideously poor
So it could be easy to say
OK, well, I know that
It's been reported in a number of
Reputable journals and books
So I'm going to go into my 1v1
And assume that the Italians
Can't hit the board side of a barn
If they were locked in a barn
In fact, with something like the Littorio
You might think the Littorio
Couldn't hit the inside of a barn
If you built a special Littorio
Sized barn around it
But it's not actually
Necessarily the case
That's not to say
The Italian shell dispersion
Wasn't awful
In a lot of cases it was
But there were other cases
In which the Italian shells
Actually had fairly good dispersion
And the fact that
There is this variation
Means that there's actually
Quite a lot of interesting research
To be done
To try and figure out
Why this variable
Changes an awful lot
And I've mentioned
In Dry Docs and such
Some of the various competing theories
And we'll be looking at those
In more detail in the future
At some point as well
But then this presents
A difficulty when it comes to
Ship v. ship comparisons
With this misinformation
Is do you
If you assume that
Italian shell dispersion
Is always awful
Well you fall victim
To misinformation
If you assume that
It's always going to be good
You're going to get
A lot of people coming out
Of the word claiming
It was always bad
And if you ask
Well are we going to use
A situation where
The Italians have
Normal shell dispersion
Which they had in some instances
Or awful dispersion
Which they had in others
Well whichever one you choose
You're going to have
One group of people
Or the other
Clamoring that you've got it
Horribly wrong because of
The other
Or you're going to assume
Every third salvo is bad
And the other two are good
Or every third salvo is good
And the other two are bad
Which is completely ahistorical
But I
Is trying to play to both fields
And probably ending up
Not getting either
So I suppose this is probably
The most
I would say not necessarily
The most personal
I mean it is personal to me
But as I said
It is also relatively widespread
Amongst a fair number of
Naval historians
You can
With the proper amount of research
And reference materials to hand
Cut through misinformation
And all other factors aside
At least from this perspective
Present something
That is a decent
Factual comparison
But the amount of grief
You're going to get
From anything that has
Any kind of significant
Following going
Just makes it really difficult
To do the mental
Equivalent of getting up
In the morning and going
Right I'm going to face this
Because you know
What's going to happen
I mean I myself
In particular have come across
A few instances
Of some very loud people
Consistently decrying
What I've said
Not on anything
That has any basis in fact
But simply because
They have such a breathtaking
Misunderstanding of
Hydrodynamics and ship handling
Despite you know
There being literal textbooks
About this for both
Military and civilian sailors
That you can get online
And in bookshops
All over the place
But no apparently you know
500 years of ship handling
Knowledge and basic physics
That clearly doesn't matter
Because otherwise
It would be inconvenient
For their argument
And yeah I despair
About some of those people
At some point
You never know
I might get annoyed enough
Irritated or bored enough
To do a complete takedown
Of some of the
More interesting
Abrogations of physical reality
That people spout
But not today
Because we're talking about
Shipy ship
And reason number six
Our final reason
Random chance
That most beloved of things
The golden BB
The one in a million
You know
In any kind of
Shipy ship comparison
Whatever you come up with
Assuming that you control
For you know
Coming up with a circumstance
Where the ship is somehow alone
You've specified the time
Of the engagement
During the day
You've specified the weather
Conditions of the engagement
You've tried to make those
As reasonably fair as possible
You've looked at the time period
That the ships were in service
You've chosen a year
Where they were both in service
And they have
Broadly comparable
Technological outfits
For that year
You've controlled
One way or the other
For the soft factors
About whether or not
The crew might have been
Particularly good
Or maybe the ship had
Particularly difficult
Mechanical issues
At that particular point
Or whatever
You've eliminated
All the misinformation
That may be floating around
Surrounding that ship
And you construct
Your 1v1
And you're really
Really happy with it
And then some unhelpful person
Turns around and points out
That random chance
Means that when
A battle somewhat similar
To what you're proposing
Actually happened
It went a completely
Different way
Because something went
Horribly and spectacularly
Wrong or right
I suppose depending on
Which side of the equation
You're on
That can't ever be factored in
To a kind of
Rational calm calculation
And this happens all the time
I mean taking
Taking just the voyage of Bismarck
For example
You know
If you were to
Do a 1v1 ship vs. ship comparison
Of Hood vs. Bismarck
Prince of Wales vs. Bismarck
King George V vs. Bismarck
Or Rodney vs. Bismarck
You'd come out with
A bunch of different results
But when you look at
The actual way
That those four
British capital ships
Ended up fighting Bismarck
Hood received
What was basically
A one in a million
Unlucky hit
Exactly how that came about
You know
You can debate that
Mostly depending on
Whether or not
You believe that Hood
Was in the process of turning
And how far through the turn she was
That's a completely separate issue
To be discussed in another video
But
As long as you haven't
Fallen victim to the kind of
Misinformation that Hood
Had the same kind of
Ammunition handling capabilities
As you know
Something at the Battle of Jutland
For example
I think the broad consensus
Of historians is that
What happened to Hood
Was a very very very
Unlucky thing
That if you ran that same battle
A thousand times over
Probably wouldn't have occurred
But it did
In that battle
One in a million shot
Very very random chance
Equally
Prince of Wales
When she fought
Was obviously at the same battle
Fighting Bismarck
Neither ship sank the other
One of the
Prince of Wales' shells
Ended up
Puncturing the bow of Bismarck
Which reduced its speed
And reduced its range
Due to
Cutting off the
Supply of
Well
Contaminating a bunch of fuel tanks
And cutting off the supply to
Still more fuel
Of all the places on Bismarck to hit
That was a very
Lucky random shot
As it turned out
Again
Would that have happened
That particular shot
If
You ran that battle
A thousand times over
Probably not
I mean it's got
A slightly higher chance
Of happening than
Hood's magazine detonation
But not a dramatically
Higher one
And yet it had
A huge outcome
On what happened
To Bismarck
Further down the line
And then you look at
Bismarck's final stand
I mean well
In the intervening period
You've also got the torpedo
Although that's not a ship
1v1
But you've got the torpedo
That hit Bismarck
And jammed its rudder
Again
A very unlucky
Random chance shot
That's not really
Gonna come up in a
Statistical analysis
If you're looking at
The most likely factors
And then
Going to the actual
Final battle
Relatively early
In the engagement
In my opinion Rodney
Although there is some
Argument that possibly
It was King George V
And some people even say
Possibly even Dorsetshire
But you know
Somebody
Smashed up Bismarck's
Primary fire control
Equipment and communications
There with
As well as
Almost certainly
Killing
Most if not all
Of the senior command staff
And that happened
Pretty early on
And that basically
Paid to Bismarck's ability
To continue to fight
Now there were
A few intrinsic design
Vulnerabilities in Bismarck
That perhaps made that
Slightly more likely to happen
But again
It's a very small area
Of the ship
That could have been hit
At that particular stage
In the engagement
To cause that to happen
And if the shells
Had landed anywhere else
Then Bismarck
Might have scored some hits
On somebody
Before it went down
And it had a whole bunch
Of other things
That were weighing it down
In the case of flooding
Quite literally
But that was one
Very random chance shot
If you were going to
You know run a 1v1
Based purely on paper statistics
Are you going to say
That well actually no
A few minutes in
Bismarck's going to have
Its fire
Main fire control
And senior command staff
Shot away
So then for the rest
Of the battle
It's a negative modifier
And F was almost
Certainly going to lose
Most people would say
No that's completely unfair
That's unlikely to happen
Yes and you'd be correct
But it did happen
So you see
Even in that one voyage
How many random chances
Are there
All of which are
Statistically very unlikely
All of which actually happened
And in a way
That almost comes in
Almost into bias as well
Because with all these
Very random
Very low probability
Things that could happen
Do you ignore them completely
Well that's relatively unrealistic
Because well look at that voyage
Look at most battles
Between various capital ships
You know the number of times
A statistically unlikely thing happens
Is actually surprisingly
Statistically quite likely
It's just they're all
Very different things
Unless you're at Jutland
When everything's exploding
So ignore them
You're ignoring reality
Factor them in
It becomes very difficult
To decide where
You're going to allocate them
Are you going to look at
The historical records
And say well this
These things kept happening
To these ships
So for this nation ships
I'm going to say this is a much
Likely chance of this happening
Or are you going to
Randomly distribute these
Random factors across
And when are they going to happen
Because to be honest
Losing your main fire control equipment
Is pretty bad
But if it happens half an hour
Into the engagement
Well the battle's probably
Been decided by then
So whoever gets their
Main fire control equipment
Knocked out
The other side is probably
Already massively on fire
And sinking anyway
So it's probably not going to affect
Things all that much
But in the first five minutes
Of engagement
That's going to be basically
Make or break
So again
Kind of like the soft factors
It's very difficult
To actually apply
Those random chance factors
But ignore them
And you end up ignoring
So much of what
Historically happened
Again you're verging
Much more towards a paper
Spreadsheet simulation
Of what might have happened
Between ships that just so
Happen to look like
Some historical things
So there you have it
At the end of what is possibly
The longest fun
Friday video thus far
Ship versus ship comparisons
Why they are difficult to do
And why I no longer
Really do them in Wednesday videos
Hopefully you can understand
Where I'm coming from on this
And maybe some of these points
Will help you work out
Which ship versus ship comparisons
That you might see elsewhere
Are something close to valid
Which are just you know
Basically not even worth the text
That was put into them
And perhaps if you're
Trying to work out
Some of these things
In your own head
Who would win
If you get this ship
Versus that ship
This fleet versus that fleet
Whether it be a bandle ship
An aircraft carrier
Cruiser destroyer sub etc
Maybe it will help you conduct
Something that's perhaps
A little bit fairer
Than it might otherwise have been
In any case
Look forward to the discussions
In the comments below
And see you again in another video
That's it for this video
Thanks for watching
If you have a comment or suggestion
For a ship to review
Let us know in the comments below
Don't forget to comment on the pinned post
For dry dock questions
