420,000 Casualties: Why The Somme Was So Deadly For Britain

Historical Identity
26 followers
37 Video Views·Aug 21, 2025
Few battles have a stronger hold on the British consciousness than the Somme. Discover why this disastrous battle took such a heavy toll on the British Army and if this heavy price was truly worth it.
Discover the past on History Hit with ad-free exclusive podcasts and documentaries released weekly presented by world renowned historians Dan Snow, Suzannah Lipscomb, Matt Lewis and more. Get 50% off your first 3 months with code 'TIMELINE' 👉 https://access.historyhit.com/
You can find more from us on:
/ timelinewh
/ timelineworldhistory
/ timelinewh
This channel is part of the History Hit Network. Any queries, please contact [email protected]
It's now 100 years since the end of the First World War,
a conflict that claimed the lives of over three-quarters
of a million British men.
Now, featuring rare and previously
unseen personal testimony, alongside newly restored
archived film, this groundbreaking three-part
series will tell the story of the Great War
as never before.
From the suffering and sacrifice experienced
by the men on the front line.
The corpses there, they all had ratchets
in the cage of the chest.
And when you disturbed them, the ratchets ran out of the chest.
You can't forget things like that.
To the dramatic change in women's lives on the home front.
I felt when I was working on munitions,
I really thought, oh, I haven't got any brothers to go and fight.
I'm doing the next best thing.
And I was quite pleased to be able to do it.
In this film, we'll hear from those who
survived the horrors of the song.
We met, oh, a hurricane of bullets.
They actually, they whizzed by my ears.
You know, ping, ping, ping, ping, ping, ping, flying by my ears
like that.
And from those who were left with physical and mental scars.
They amputated my foot through the ankle.
I make no bones about it.
I really cried my eyes out when I saw the results.
This is the story of the tragedy and turmoil
of Britain's Great War.
In 1916, after more than a year of stalemate on the Western Front,
Allied commanders planned a major new offensive
against the German army.
It would take place along a 16-mile stretch of the River Somme.
And, if all went according to plan, result in a decisive victory.
It was supposed to be a joint offensive with France.
But in February, the Germans attacked the city of Verdun,
over 150 miles away.
And many French divisions were diverted there,
where they would suffer enormous casualties.
As a result, the main responsibility for the Somme offensive
fell to the British.
Led by new commander-in-chief, Sir Douglas Haig,
they were so confident of victory,
they allowed film cameras to record the event.
They would capture one of the most infamous and costly battles
of the entire war.
People said that Haig was wrong
in making us go and fight the enemy.
Damn it, we couldn't sit there forever.
We got to get on with the job.
The French had been badly, very nearly knocked out.
And we got to get on with the job,
kill them to kill the Germans.
We got to do as we were told by our senior officers
and do our best to prevent this country
being taken over by some enemy.
Well, we wanted to fight the Germans anyway.
Blinking old Kaiser and his son, we used to hate them people.
You're only younger, you see what I mean, you're younger.
You're full of excitement, I suppose.
All together now,
It's a long way to Tipperary
It's a long way to go
It's a long way to Tipperary
To the sweetest girl I know
Goodbye Piccadilly
Farewell Leicester Square
It's a long, long way to Tipperary
But my heart's right there
It's a long way to Tipperary
Arriving at the front were the latest recruits
to Secretary of State for War Lord Kitchener's Volunteer Army,
which by then numbered around two and a half million men.
Many were in one of the new so-called Powell's Battalions,
made up of volunteers from the same town, village or workplace.
Young people like myself were saying,
we'll show those Germans, we'll push them back home.
It was just the thoughts of really young men
who didn't know any better.
Others had lied about their age to be there.
I was 16, but I said I was 18.
I told them I was 18, but I was only 16.
So patriotic, that's why.
It was just so patriotic.
That was our feeling those days.
And I went to the Battle of the Somme,
sort of, where I was sent to, the Battle of the Somme,
and to a place called Feat Powell.
Some of Kitchener's recruits preparing for battle on the Somme
already knew what it was like to go over the top,
having fought at Luce in 1915,
where 16,000 men were killed in two weeks of fighting.
I thought to myself, when we went on the Somme,
I thought, oh, well, never mind.
If my time comes, I don't want to pull it.
Let's hope it's sudden.
If I've got to go, I've got to go.
Let's hope it's sudden.
That's the way I've got it.
I never, I always dreaded
losing an arm or a leg.
Well, we knew what we were in for.
We were there to do a job.
We couldn't get out of it.
We were told to do a job, and we did it.
I might have been afraid, I'd expect.
I was afraid the second time.
Yes, no doubt about it, we were afraid.
Young fellows, 18, 19, married men
with a couple of kids going over the top like that,
and they're crying their eyes out,
wondering what's happening to the people at home.
At home, Britain's children were having to come to terms
with the fact that their fathers were away fighting.
But their pride in having seen their dad
in uniform before he left
was a memory that gave comfort to some.
I can remember, mum took us out for the day, isn't it,
to Dover Castle, and we were so thrilled about it,
because we could look out, there's some slits in the wall,
and right, and we were told to look across,
and we could see France there,
and then, of course, we had to see dad drilling the men.
We were, naturally, over the moon
to stand there and see our dad.
But then, as a child, you would, wouldn't you think?
You think your dad's the, you know, one and only.
When first I started school,
my first teacher was a Mr. Brown,
and he was very nice.
We'd all adored him,
because we'd never had a male teacher before.
There'd always been female teachers, you know?
So we were thrilled to bits.
And the first day he went through the register,
he was going through all the names,
and he says, oh, we have a mod.
♪ To the guard for the black bat knight
♪ And flow me to the guard
He said, stand up, mod.
So I stood up, and he crooked his finger to come here,
and he says, I'm a singer, you know,
and that's my favourite song,
come into the garden, mod.
And he says, you're the first one I've ever come across
that had that name.
So he says, that'll be our song, won't it?
And, oh, of course, I was thrilled to bits.
And every time he wanted me to come out,
he used to sing, come into the garden, mod.
And then the next thing, he was called up,
and he went away.
On the 24th of June, 1916,
the Allies launched a massive artillery bombardment
on the Somme in an attempt to destroy German defences.
In seven days, over a million and a half shells
were fired at the enemy lines.
We were all convinced that this was the push
which was to end the war.
We were certainly very impressed
with the thunder of the bombs.
We loved the guns because it started all at once.
And terrific.
And it went on and on and on.
Thunder, thunder, thunder.
With the practice here, you could pick out
the individual types of gun firing.
Well, at times, it's indescribable.
You might get about 12 guns,
battery, I don't know what they call them,
till they're all firing at the same time.
Another time, it'd be one after the other.
Tens of thousands of shells had been sent over
to the German line.
And the day before we were supposed to go over the top,
an officer, a ranking officer,
got on his horse and said to us,
tomorrow, lads, tomorrow, men,
you go and take the German trench.
I say that because I know you'll take the trench.
There's no trench there.
There's no wire there.
It'll all be pounded by our guns.
And you could just walk over and carry your guns
as you would carry a bag.
At 7.30 a.m., the men would go over the top
toward the German lines.
As the time approached, they made their final preparations.
We moved up into the front line trench.
Every man was given a packet of woodbarns.
Stupid thing to say, but I went over there
so he had not really lived in the duller.
And that sort of overall sea red,
I don't know why, but it doesn't matter.
And zero hour, it was 7.30, I think it was a lovely morning,
and over the top we went.
They just shouted, come on, lads, said the sergeant.
And that's, you got to go over the top the best you could.
Well, the one next to you would be about a yard away from you
or two yards away on the other side of you.
Straightforward and aligned.
You're not holding each other's arms, you just move forward.
In the south, where German defenses were at their weakest,
the artillery bombardment was most successful
and Allied infantry faced the least resistance.
Actually, we had a very good day.
The Manchesters on our right were held up
and somebody else on our left was held up.
And that's why we had to stop, really.
Otherwise, some idiot said,
we're going to walk straight through to Berlin, but we couldn't.
But elsewhere, the bombardment failed
and the Germans emerged from deep dugouts
and waited with rifles and machine guns ready.
I was one of the first to get up over on the top.
We met, oh, how he could have bullets.
They actually, they winked by my ears,
you know, ping, ping, ping, ping, ping,
flying by my ears like that.
We were able to see the infantry going forward.
In some cases, they didn't get very far.
They were just wiped out.
If he were quick enough to drop down
when the Germans opened fire,
their bullets would go over the top of him.
But there was good money, it wound him
before he could drop.
Some of the chaps were lying around, you know,
arms off or in pain and so on.
Some, a fellow would give us a fag, you know.
But you couldn't help the poor soul.
You couldn't help him at all.
Tommy Gay had gone over the top
together with his best friend.
From the time we went up over the top,
went over together, Tommy, I never saw him anymore.
No, I never saw my, his name was Johnny Duck, yeah.
Never saw him anymore.
Must have had the bullet right away, yeah.
The British suffered over 57,000 casualties that day,
including over 19,000 men killed.
It remains the most costly day
in the history of the British Army.
They were just put down on stretchers,
pieces of fencing, pieces of wood,
just put down, left, and the awful stretcher bearers
went to get some more.
Oh, some of the men were calling for their mothers,
some were calling for girlfriends or wives.
It was a nasty sight.
I remember once I said to one,
have you got a mother and father?
And he said, I haven't got a mother, she's dead.
But I said to him, well, you'll be with her
in a few minutes, so don't worry.
That was all I said to him.
There wasn't anything else to say.
How can you describe seeing a mere handful of men come
where you were used to seeing a,
seeing a battalion,
and we weren't the only ones who felt sick.
The colonels were sitting in front
of what was left of their men, sobbing.
There were so few, so few men left.
I must have been the luckiest man on earth
to walk over the front with all that machine gun fire
and not one of those bullets got my name on it.
I must be the luckiest man on earth.
Absolutely the luckiest man in the world.
The first day of the Battle of the Somme
was a national tragedy,
but it was only the beginning of a long and bloody struggle
as along the battlefront,
most of the Allied objectives still lay in German hands.
Joining those already at the front
were more of Kitchener's volunteer army.
Among them, many inexperienced young officers
who would soon be leading their men over the top.
When I was 19,
I was posted to France
and there had been tremendous casualties
and I was obviously a replacement,
an officer in my time, a second lieutenant in my time.
His term of fighting was no more than six weeks.
Six weeks was the limit before he was killed or wounded.
The casualties, they were enormous.
It was all very sad,
but there was a hell of a war going on
and you've got to get on with it.
And you went there despite you might be wounded
or killed at any moment yourself.
The harm was throwing things at you all day long
and all night long very often
and I don't think you gave it much thought.
Throughout the summer of 1916,
Allied forces on the Somme went over the top time and again
as they fought for the objectives
they'd previously failed to take.
First of all, you're looking at your watch
to see zero hour.
And then you look and see that your men,
the men you're going to go over the top with,
are left and right, are equipped and ready to go.
And then you encourage them, right and left,
to go with you, all go together.
So you sort of shepherded them over as well as you could.
And that's the only description I can give you.
You were a shepherd.
Your one ambition is to get to the German wire safe and sound.
Get there before the Germans get you.
We knew we had to go over and shift Julie out of his trench.
We had that order, aye.
Sergeant was sure, get on, get on, aye.
You go down, you're getting a buck of a bloody thistle
if you're for shelter.
You went out and you saw men dropping right and left.
If you knew them as you would,
you felt for them very much, very much.
As you went over, sort of climbing barbed wire,
my clothes was all ripped up like rags, sort of thing.
Climbing barbed wire here, barbed wire there, you know?
And then, what was I saying?
I was in a hell of a state, just in rags, I was in rags.
The advantage was always there to be used, if necessary.
When I say if necessary, that was what I meant to say,
if you got close enough to use them.
I'll tell you something, you know, about bayonet fighting.
There's more lads putting bullets into the enemy
instead of the bayonets.
And we weren't supposed to do that, you know.
It was either him or them.
And he was standing solid where they was on the move.
And I just pulled the trigger and down he would go.
It made you never forget this, never, not even to this day.
To think you shot a man, you know,
and do nothing at you.
That was how I used to always look at it.
And then again, he would say,
well, if I don't get him, he'll get me.
And my life was worth a hell of a lot to me.
That's how we were on, young and daft.
On the Somme, what was supposed to have been
a swift and decisive victory
had turned into a brutal battle of attrition.
Life was cheap, two penny.
It didn't matter how many men were killed or wounded,
as long as they attained a German trench,
which inevitably, and it happened many a time,
we held it for half a dozen hours
till they came back at us about twice or three times
and drove us back to where we originally started.
We were sent away again over the top
for the third time in succession, you know, in succession.
And of course, our object then was
to take the town of Gillimont.
When we got there, the Germans had retired a little bit
and one of them came along just on his own,
one German on his own,
and come back, and there was half a dozen of us lads
hiding in a shell hole.
We were in a shell hole, huddled together,
so we shouldn't be seen much.
And he went, the German come up to me
and he almost stabbed me, you know.
He was a good man to do me in.
He got his bayonet on the end of his rifle
and nearly stuck it into me.
But he touched my chest,
sort of, but he never stabbed me.
And of course I went cold, naturally.
But then he didn't stab me.
He took us, the four or five of us, out of the shell hole
and put us in a compound behind the German mine.
But that was a bad feeling, a very bad feeling, yeah.
The Allies captured the village of Gillimont
on the 6th of September, 1916.
The Battle of the Somme had entered its third month.
♪ Keep the hope fires burning ♪
♪ Though your heart is yearning ♪
♪ When the lads are far away they dream of home ♪
♪ There's a silver lining ♪
♪ Through the dark clouds shining ♪
♪ Keep the dark clouds right away ♪
♪ Till the boys come home ♪
We hoped, we wanted a Blighty wound, as much as anything.
We got to that stage that if we got a Blighty wound,
Blighty is an Indian word, as you probably know.
A home, Blighty being a home.
The best we could hope for was a wound
that wouldn't be able to be healed.
Well, take us home.
All my life I've had hunches and they've come true.
And I said to my friend,
what a nice morning for a cushy Blighty and home.
I have no earthly idea what came down or how it came down,
but I just had one stiffening bound
and I went like a poker.
And when I came to, I noticed that I was hit
behind the heel, which took the sole clean away.
The doctors had a look at me and I said
that I did not want to lose my foot, if possible.
But it was hopeless.
The foot had to go and that was that.
They put me on a table with a mattress.
I think it was in the kitchen that they did it.
And at last, let me say, I had the chloroform in those days.
And it was done.
I was warned by somebody who knew
that if, when you go first time into the theater,
so many nurses who attend their first operation
will faint when the first incision is made.
But if you make a point of looking over there
when they're doing the incision there,
and then turn your head afterwards,
if you don't see the first incision made, you're all right.
But if you see the blood oozing out, you're done for.
And I found that worked beautifully.
I've never fainted in the theater, yes.
They amputated my foot through the ankle.
And I can assure you, that was no easy job.
And it was extremely painful.
I can assure you, if I ever howled in my life
when I came out, I howled.
I made no bones about it.
I really cried my eyes out when I saw the results.
Jock was sent back to Britain,
where amputees and other wounded men
were becoming a common sight on the streets.
For those sent home for treatment or convalescence,
there was often a chance of reconciliation with loved ones,
even if only temporary.
In 1916, my dad was wounded.
I don't know how, but came home on leave.
And I remember him sitting there and making a fuss of me
and singing at a gramophone
with a blooming great big horn, blue.
And he put this record on and then he was singing to me.
And when I told them how beautiful you are,
they'll never believe me.
That from this great big world, you've chosen me.
You know, to me, that was absolutely wonderful.
♪ And when I told how wonderful you are ♪
I don't know how long he was home, but it was lovely
having him home because he went back again.
As autumn approached, British casualties on the Somme
totaled around 200,000 men.
Progress remained slow, but the army was about to unleash
a secret weapon that would help to change
the course of the battle.
I was out in the trench out there with some others
and I could hear a purr, purr going on.
And I thought, what's that noise?
It's getting louder and louder now.
Stood on the fire step and I could see something moving.
What we call in Scotland, a steam road roller
with a big funnel on and a big heavy thing.
And I said, look, and they all started looking.
Some got up in the parapet and we could see
these things moving.
And behind them, there were probably four or five
or six soldiers running behind.
With a bin, it's fixed.
An armoured crawler, that's what I call them.
Of course, when we got in them and got moving around
with them, well, we knew exactly what they were for.
And the armaments, when we got inside and we saw
the armaments, we said, well, this is really it.
We never deviated the tanks for anything.
We had to go for previous dead and dead that you'd killed.
If they fell in your way, you had to go for them.
All feelings of humanity leaves you when you're fighting.
You say to yourself, well, it's either him or me.
See, so I got to get in first.
That's it, that's what you said.
So you've got no feelings of humanity right then.
Afterwards, yes, perhaps, yeah.
The tank was one of the most significant
military advances of the war.
But there were advances in medicine too,
including developments in blood transfusions,
x-rays and prosthetics.
However, in the days before antibiotics,
many wounds became infected as bullets and shrapnel
carried the filth of the battlefields into the body,
leading to gangrene, amputation and death.
Oh, the smell of gangrene.
That's a thing you never forget, a terrible smell.
I think anybody who's ever smelled it will tell you that.
You get it so quickly when there's a lot of infection about.
When I heard them mention gangrene, I was terrified.
They took my leg off from the ankle
to four, six inches below the knee.
That was a big one.
And I can assure you, it was sore, very sore.
And I felt it.
And I had, once again, I did a hell of a lot of crying.
Good, hefty stuff.
Pressing time was an ordeal at all for us.
The bandages that I had on had dried
and they had to be pulled away.
And much of the dressing adhered to the skin.
Throughout his ordeal, the woman responsible for Jock's care
was known to him only as Nurse Sutherland.
She was my nurse and she certainly looked after me
in every way.
It wasn't a case of attraction or anything.
It wasn't a case, she was good at her job.
Very good at her job.
She never spoke hardly except words of comfort.
And I did nothing else but cry.
And being a soldier, and being 20 or 21,
I didn't want to be more or less a child
and cry down, but cry I did, and plenty of it.
Back on the Somme, the first tanks went into action
on the 15th of September, 1916
during the Battle of Flair-Courcelette.
Although the early models were prone to mechanical failure
and the army was unsure how best to use them,
they still took the Germans completely by surprise.
They'd never seen anything like it before.
But when they saw we was armed with small guns
and machine guns, they gave up right away.
It's surprising.
We hadn't time to get on top of the trench
before they was out with their arms up.
And we passed them over to the infantry
and take back to base.
The rest, we could see some of the machine gunners
had got away and we could see them silhouetted
against the skyline with the machine guns
on their shoulders going like hell
back to the second and third lines.
We did a job that the infantry had been trying to do
for two years and they'd lost hundreds of thousands
trying to do it and couldn't.
And we did it in half an hour.
So you see.
With the help of the tank,
the Battle of the Somme finally ended
on the 18th of November, 1916
when the allies captured the village of Beaumont-Hamill.
In four and a half months of fighting,
British and Empire casualties totaled almost 420,000 men.
They'd advanced just six miles,
but they dealt a devastating blow to the German army.
But for some, the horrors weren't over yet.
I arrived at Beaumont-Hamill.
Then I was told to collect the newly killed dead,
which I did.
I took a little stretcher bearers.
Unfortunately, the stretcher bearers,
quite a number of them,
they were related to the ones who were dead
and this was a bit upsetting.
Then I was told to go back into the no man's land
or rather what was no man's land
and bury the old dead.
That is the dead of the new found in regiment
who had been killed there on July the 1st.
The first one I saw,
the first one I came across
with his hair growing,
hair growing out of his,
still growing from his face.
When I touched it, the rats ran out.
There was nothing left under the potty except a bone.
It seemed to be such a terrible waste of life.
After all they'd been through,
many of those who fought at the Somme
remained traumatized by their experiences.
It affects the nerves,
the noise and everything.
It gradually affects the nerves
and if you're a nervous person
or your nerves are any way bad at all,
it's going to affect you.
It makes you feel bad in yourself, real bad.
You begin to do like this
and I never did that before
and I couldn't believe myself at the time.
I couldn't believe it
that I thought my nerves would carry me
but no, it broke my nerve.
Cases of shell shock were identified as early as 1914
and ranged in their severity.
At the Battle of the Somme,
as many as 40% of all casualties
were also suffering from some form of the condition.
We were on the Somme for the whole of the time.
You couldn't help being a bit frightened, I think,
but you couldn't show it.
You've got to bottle it up.
That's why it put a great strain on one's nervous system.
I was troubled for a good many years
by a difficulty in speaking.
It was hardly a stammer, it was a stuttering
but I didn't sleep until four o'clock in the morning
and used to go up through the ceiling
and down again until a little bit.
But that was the aftereffect
of being shelled for 19 months and so on.
While some bore mental scars,
others were left to deal
with life-changing physical injuries.
To the public, they were heroes.
If we went out with some of the boys,
about a dozen of the boys, wounded boys,
we all went in a bus and we went into the movies.
We got in for nothing.
You were always a bit of a, what do you call,
an eye catcher.
They would always stop in the street and look at you
or some people would come up and talk to you.
Sometimes you'd get packets of cigarettes
or chocolates or things like that.
While he was recuperating,
Jock heard news of the woman who'd looked after him,
Nurse Sutherland.
She was, I think she was retiring.
So I wrote her and I said,
I'd come, if I'm coming down with my friend,
I'm coming down, we'll call and see her.
But about a week before we were due to leave,
I had a letter saying that she had died.
I don't know the cause or anything,
but she eventually died.
I miss her a lot.
In Fifeshire, schoolgirl Maude Cox
was waiting for news from her favorite teacher, Mr. Brown.
They used to send postcards to the school,
to see where he was and where he was getting on.
And then one day, the headmaster, Mr. Christie,
the whole round, we all had to go into the assembly hall.
And he put a big map on the board and he told us,
he says, now, Mr. Brown and the fiances of Miss Jessie
and Miss Jean Macleod, they'd all been killed
at a place called the Somme in France.
And he pointed it out on the map and put a cross on it.
And he said, now, I want you all to say the prayer
for the dead and then we'll sing the first verse,
oh God, our help in ages past.
And I want you all to walk very quietly home.
But I didn't go quietly home, I rushed home,
crying all the road.
And mother said, what was wrong?
I said, Mr. Brown's been killed.
He'll never sing, come into the garden, Maude, anymore.
I know she was comforting me, she says,
but he's not the only one, you know.
And you know, I took a long while to be comforted
because he was such a nice man.
♪ Come into the garden for the black bath night has flown ♪
♪ Come into the garden, Maude ♪
♪ I am here at the gate alone ♪
