Mayor Ortiz Jones talks about Spurs arena city council vote

The media
244 followers
Hey folks, thanks for joining us today. I wanted to be very clear about a very
important vote for our community which is this Thursday.
As you all know, negotiations have progressed between the City staff and
with the Spurs and there is a term sheet that there is some agreement on
that the City Council now needs to to vote on.
I have been very clear. I think our community
deserves an independent economic impact study to help us understand
the true costs, the true benefits of the arena.
This is not a hard ask. I think I have been very clear that I
want the Spurs here. I want a good deal and I think we can confidently
work with our community if we have confidence
in the data. At this point, the only data that we have is from the Spurs'
consultant. I think our community deserves an
independent economic impact study so that
if that comes back and says, you know what, Spurs numbers, those were actually
right on, then great. And if it corroborates what they put forward, then
wonderful. If something is different though, then
we owe it to our community to explain what that discrepancy is based on.
Okay, this is just basic due diligence. I think it's also really important, based
on the feedback that I have received to my office, folks, our community, our
neighbors, they want a say. They want to review the
information and they also want to say on that term sheet. They want to say on
that.
I don't think it's surprising to anybody that
a 1.3 billion dollar arena that the city would be on the hook for
489 million, it should come as a shock to no one
that folks in this community would like to provide some feedback
to their city council member before that city council member
votes on their behalf. That it should not be shocking in any
way to anybody that is serious about representing those to their constituents.
So, frankly, I got some
grumblings that there may be some folks that were going to push for an August 21st
vote. And again, I wanted to ensure that our
community, we preserved our decision space.
So, I asked the city manager to put that resolution
for vote on Thursday. So, it does two things.
The city council would not vote on a term sheet until we had that independent
economic study
done by a firm with no connection to the spurs,
at least as good as what Philadelphia got when they were considering this with
the 76ers. And it must, and it must help us
understand how this would impact our general fund.
Do not come up here and say we need more cops, more this, more that,
and then not have an understanding of how this deal is going to impact our
general fund. That is disingenuous. So, that's the first condition,
independent impact study with all that I just described.
And then two, city council members, you must have, they must have, and I know
folks want to do that, they will have two in-person engagements
with their constituents to get their feedback on that independent study and
on the draft term sheet before their council member votes on
that. Before, not after.
This is just basic due diligence. This is what the people of San Antonio
deserve. This is what the people of San, let me say that again.
This is what the people of San Antonio deserve.
The thing is, you go ask my colleagues that are pushing for August 21st,
you go ask them, what's up with August 21st? What's up with that?
They don't have an answer. They don't have an answer. There is
nothing driving August 21st. That is not a deadline by anybody's standards.
It's not. Well, some folks want that deadline, I get it.
But when you're serious about this, that August 21st, there's no deadline there.
Frankly, August 28th is also not a deadline. We actually have lots of time
to get this done and we should do right by our folks. We don't do this every two
weeks, right? $489 million. Don't you want to
make sure we all have clarity on the costs and
benefits of that? And again, the people want to be heard on this.
My concern, let me say it again, I want a deal with the Spurs.
I want a deal with the Spurs. My concern, based on the feedback that I
have received, is that Spurs fans are so
disenfranchised. How it's gone up, how these negotiations have gone up
until this point has left such a bad taste in their mouth.
Spurs fans are saying, on principle, I love the Spurs, but on principle,
I will vote against this in November if something doesn't change. So I think we
owe the people and this independent economic impact study
and the community engagement, I think that actually will help us
bring people along and have the confidence that they need to vote in
November. I think this actually helps us. It doesn't delay anything.
I think once people have the benefit of this information,
people will, I think, gladly vote in November, but not if they feel like
something has been rushed, not if they feel like something has been
pushed down their throats, especially as, again, they can drive
throughout many parts of our community, in particular the east side,
where too many broken promises have shown us why
we need to do our due diligence this time.
Let me also say again, I want to deal with the Spurs, right? Okay,
let me see if we're good. Okay, I'm happy to take a couple
questions. Mayor, a couple weeks ago, back on August
6th, when this first came up and you proposed to pause,
it was clear that you were in the minority of the council at the time.
In the last week and a half, what's changed that makes you think you're
going to get a vote to go your way in a few days? Well, I think what's
important is folks are not recognizing just how
fast some folks are wanting this to move, right? I think folks are expecting that
there's going to be more public engagement,
but people pushing to have a vote on August 21st,
the term sheet wasn't shared until this morning.
You had some council members saying, I'm ready to vote on that. Vote on what?
You haven't even seen it. So that's my concern,
is I wanted to make sure that we're preserving this decision space
for our constituents, make sure we get that independent impact study,
and make sure that we are hearing from our folks. Again, we have the time to do
this. You go ask them. Each of you should ask each of those
council members why August 21st is so important. When
you have a good answer, you let me know. One of the things we've heard, ma'am, is
that they...
So the five, well, I will, well, I think you know it's for sure seven. It's for
sure district 10. It is district three.
It is also district four, I think was part of that,
and I'm blanking on who's the last one, and district one.
District one, thank you. And how would you like the field to look different,
the term sheet to look different? I wanted, look,
the independent economic impact study, we need that
to help us understand what our feedback should be on the term sheet.
So I think, like, that's kind of the basic homework. It's kind of like the term
sheet's the test, and the economic impact study will help
you with the test, and prepare for the test,
because go look at that term sheet. Spurs get all of x.
Spurs get all of y. Spurs get all of z. Let's have an economic impact study that
helps us understand, hey, can we afford this?
Look at Philadelphia's economic impact study. You know what they considered
there? The number of corporate headquarters they had, the number of
people making over 150k. Those are the kinds of things that we
as a community also need to understand about how we can actually afford this.
This is a generational investment. We've seen this playbook before,
right? So let's have the courage, and we've got the time. Now we just need
the courage to ask the question. So it's not even about
how the term sheet is different. It's just, hey, are we all comfortable with the
information that we've been presented to go into these
negotiations eyes wide open? Again, I can't speak, I cannot speak to
what the former mayor and the former city council did, and how
they understood what due diligence is. But again, if we don't even have an
independent look at the cost of the Spurs arena and the true benefits of
that, and we're only relying on what the
Spurs have been presented, I think you all know this would not fly
in any other major city. You know that.
What would you like to see at the end of the day,
the picture? What would you like to see for you to feel comfortable
and then say, you know what, this looks like a good deal for the city.
I want an independent economic impact study. Somebody that has no connection,
somebody that is no in way in no way going to benefit from
this deal. I want them to look at the numbers, help
us understand. Again, I always reference that Philadelphia report because they
looked at some basic things. What are the local market conditions?
What is the economic and fiscal impact of this to the city,
in their case to the school district, but also to the state. And then
the basic question of, hey, can we actually afford this, right? Those are
basic things. I want to see that. I want to have, I want a good deal. I
think a good deal though requires that we
get the data and we hear from our constituents. So a lot of this is more
about the process, right? About the process, the
transparency that should have been done already, frankly. And so when, you know,
when you've got former elected saying, let's get this done.
Well, part of the reason we're having to do this is because the formers didn't do
what they needed to do. Okay.
You haven't heard from the opposition why they want to move forward.
The argument that we've heard is that voters,
whatever the council decides, they're going to be going to the ballot
on November to vote on this project. They need to have the terms.
You're saying that voters also need information on from an independent
survey or an independent analysis. Do you think the 11 weeks leading up to
this election are enough time to get that report
done and get the council feedback meetings that you want?
It should be. Yeah, look, again, the council has done their, excuse me, the
county has done their own calculus. I can't speak to the county's
approach. The county said, here's 311 million dollars,
no community benefits agreement. Oh, by the way, if you also need to leave early,
we're going to waive 88 million. I mean, that's quite a negotiating
approach. That will not be our negotiating
approach. Again, our calculus is different.
And I understand, you know, they can only, their timeline is also different, so
that's where they are. But, you know, what the county has done is
different than what we need to do. Due diligence, I think in our case,
must include an independent economic impact study and sufficient
feedback and input from our community. But if it's not done by the time that
they go to the polls, does that mean voters,
does that mean voters are going in with insufficient information because they
don't have the term sheet or the report thing? I would argue they're
going, they would be going in, if they didn't have that, they would be going in
with insufficient economic information to begin with.
Right? They need, the people deserve
an independent look at this. They don't deserve to be,
you know, just said, hey, here, trust us on this.
Trust but verify. And again, why the rush?
I keep coming back to that. Why the rush? Have them answer that question. That's a
key part of this.
Well, I mean, I think they're, you know, the city staff was responding to
direction that was provided to them. By who? By the previous administration, by
the previous mayors and the previous council.
Yeah. So I think the, when you do look, if you haven't already seen it, go look
at the CSL reports that were just provided
on the Alamodome and the Convention Center. Those are actually
much more in-depth and more on par, more similar to what the Philadelphia study
looks like. And so it then just continues to beg the
question of why couldn't we get that on the arena?
Why are we relying only on the Spurs' data? So
again, it just begs the question why we couldn't have that same look
at the Spurs arena. I know you said there's no timeline, but are you concerned about
any jeopardy to the deal with getting a positive report?
No. Mayor, so what you're saying is we always look for a second medical
opinion. We always look for a second legal opinion.
Yeah. We don't go with the first car. We look around. Is that your approach?
Well, we also try to get information, to your point, thank you for raising that.
When we, I mean, it looks like it's independent is a really important
part of that word, of that phrase, right? Yeah, we want to make sure that we're
getting information from somebody that could not be benefiting from a
from the decision one way or the other. So again, this is
basic due diligence that the people deserve. And we have the time for it. And
you know what? They're asking for it. They're asking for it. Okay. How do you
think the vote is going to shake out on Thursday when the council will be here?
Well, I mean, we'll see, right? We'll see. I mean, folks wanted to vote on the term
sheet even before they saw it, which to me is...
Thanks, Molly. One second. I think it's important if folks wanted to have a vote
on the term sheet, again, as I was kind of hearing grumblings about that, that we
have a vote, another approach, which is let's vote on this once we have more
information. And once we have actually talked to the people, people haven't
explained why anything is needed by the 21st. I'm also very shocked that folks
would want to move forward on this absent hearing from their constituents.
I think their constituents are going to have something to say about $489 million.
Thank you. Absolutely. Yeah, absolutely. I'll also be at Councilman White's
budget town hall today. So if y'all want to join me there, you can.
Thank you all. Thank you.
