Difficulty of reconstructing sword & shield combat from early periods (eg. Viking)

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
7 Video Views·Aug 15, 2025
Hi guys, Matt Easton here of Scholar Gladiatoria.
So a topic that I have got asked a lot about over the last few years,
that I've been making a couple of years that I've been making videos,
is the question of sword and shield.
And the main thing people want to know is where they can find sources or manuals
for studying sword and shield, but also what my views are on sword and shield.
Well, this, I will try to keep this, it is a massive topic,
and so I'll have to make numerous videos about this in the future.
But this is essentially a video to set the scene, I suppose,
set the basic, the very big picture context,
so that I can revisit specific aspects of the topic in future videos.
First up, there are no early period sword and shield treatises, unfortunately.
And there are no real detailed descriptions of how
a sword and a shield were used together, okay, until you get into the 15th century.
So in terms of early medieval, like the Viking era sword and shield I'm holding here,
in terms of the early medieval sword and shield stuff,
it is all pure reconstruction and essentially what I would term,
rather than strictly speaking, pure historical fencing,
in other words, studying a historical fencing treatise
and just doing it to how it's described and practising it until you get good at it,
rather than pure historical fencing, it is actually verging on experimental archaeology,
that is, taking the fairly minimal set of facts that we know,
we know the statistics of the swords and the shields,
and we've got some pictures of them in use,
and we've got some saga-type description of them in use,
descriptive accounts of them in use, but not very detailed.
And we've got later period sources, and I'll come back to this point in a minute,
we've got later period sources that use two weapons
that we can maybe inform earlier period stuff with.
This is really all we've got to go on.
Now, there are a number of people around the world,
particularly in Europe, I have to say,
I'm not that aware of any people really leading it in America at the moment,
but in Europe we've got a couple of people
who've really been working on, particularly Viking era,
sword and shield for a long time.
The first one who I'm sure will be known to many of you is Roland Borczeka,
who I know from numerous events over the years,
and he's a very nice guy.
He has a Facebook page, which if you're on Facebook,
I highly recommend you like and follow, which is called Dimmikator,
I'm imagining how a German might pronounce it,
I would imagine an American,
but I'll put the link underneath this video.
And the other person who's worked a lot with Viking era weapon combinations,
including, of course, sword and shield, is Colin Richards.
Now, they do both have contrasting interpretations.
That is not surprising because we don't have any real sources to go on.
And this is really the topic of this video,
is that really you are working on,
when you're working with these type of weapon sets
that you don't have explicit treatises for,
you're really in the kind of we'll never really know territory.
And that's not a bad thing.
The good side of that is that you've got to apply your brain
a little bit more creatively.
You've got to refer to many different sources.
You don't have the easy option of just reading the manual.
And you've got to have almost a more holistic
and kind of wider view of martial arts and how weapons should be used.
However, the downside is,
firstly, you'll never really know whether you've got it right or not.
And secondly, you're very likely to come up
with a very different interpretation from someone else
who might have a completely equally valid interpretation.
And you come to completely different conclusions.
And that can unfortunately create conflict,
which is not necessarily necessary.
And that's another point of this video.
So what sources are there that we can look at?
What actual technical sources are that we can look at
for sword and shield combat?
Well, first of all,
if you're interested in 16th century sword and shield,
you're in luck,
because there are a range of particularly Italian
sword and shield sources.
For example, Marazzo from 1536
and Manciolino from 1531.
In Bolognese, which is the tradition of Bologna,
in Bolognese fencing that both Marazzo and Manciolino are part of,
and in fact, two of the earliest authors of,
there was a very strong tradition
of both sword and buckler and sword and shield use.
Now, the sword and shield sections of Marazzo and Manciolino are not big.
They don't give you an awful lot to work on.
However, they do give you something to work on,
which is fantastic.
That's great.
However, remember that the type of shield that they're using
is really quite different to a boss-held Viking shield, for example.
They're using what's called a rotella.
A rotella, sometimes known as rondash
in arms and armor books for some reason,
a rotella is essentially a domed round shield.
It looks a little bit like a hoplite shield
and, in fact, might have had its inspiration in classical sources
because, of course, in 16th century Italy,
they loved anything that was Greek or Roman.
And the rotella is strapped to the arm like a heater shield is.
It's strapped to the arm, it's round and it's domed.
So it's very different to the Viking shield.
The Viking shield is held in the hand like a buckler and it's flat,
which completely changes how you would use the shield in general.
Not only that, but, of course, it's a different period.
The 16th century is very different to the 9th or 10th century.
OK, so if we're trying to reconstruct Viking martial arts,
yes, it may be very useful to look at a 16th century Bolognese source.
However, it might be that the way that they use a strapped domed shield
is utterly different to how someone in the 9th century
would have used a boss-held flat shield.
So that's the next thing.
The periods are completely different.
If, for example, we wanted to reconstruct the way that
an arming sword was used in the 14th century,
which we sort of know, OK,
we sort of know how arming swords were used in the 14th century,
thanks to Fiore and some of the German sources.
If we wanted to reconstruct 14th century arming sword
and we looked at 16th century sidesword, which are similar weapons,
if we just copied Marozzo's sidesword,
we wouldn't get something that was very similar
to 14th century arming sword, unfortunately.
It is similar and you can certainly see,
when you've got both sources there to compare,
you can certainly see the similarities,
but you can also see the differences.
And if we just picked up a medieval arming sword,
a 14th century arming sword,
and used it like a 16th century sidesword,
then you'd actually be doing something quite different.
So the problem is, even if the weapons are the same,
then sometimes the system changes because of context changes.
Next up, the weapons themselves can be superficially similar,
but actually be quite different.
So there are some fundamental differences with swords in the 16th century
in terms of hand protection.
And the fact that you start to have knuckle bows and finger rings
really quite changes how it is, generally speaking, safe to use a sword.
Obviously, it becomes safer to have the hand further forward
because you've got things protecting the hand.
A medieval arming sword, or of course, a Viking era sword,
not really safe to do that because you've got your hand chopped off.
So actually, if you were looking to use a medieval arming sword by itself,
you'd be best looking at the medieval arming sword sources
or the Messer sources because they're from the same period
and have a weapon which has similar considerations,
not all the same though.
Messer is not used exactly the same as an arming sword,
but it's used in a similar way.
So there's all sorts of minefield with using what we often term in HEMA frog DNA,
and this is a reference to the film Jurassic Park,
where, of course, they use frog DNA to reconstruct dinosaurs.
And what they end up with aren't actually really dinosaurs.
They look like dinosaurs, but they can change their gender.
Now, that's science fiction.
However, it's a good analogy for our purpose
because if you use frog DNA, the problem is you've got frog DNA
and it might enable you to recreate something,
but you're not actually really recreating something.
You're recreating 95% of it, hopefully,
but you always have 5% that's different.
And in fact, you might have a bigger percent
or a more important percentage, should we say.
It might be that final 5% that's really, really important.
So it's always a minefield using later sources.
So we've got the Bolognese sources.
We've got some other Italian sources that use rapier and shield,
but, of course, the rapier is even more different
from a medieval-type sword, medieval cut and thrust sword,
than a sidesword is.
So generally speaking, the rapier and shield sources
are even more different, probably,
from how these might be used than the Bolognese rotella and sidesword.
But if we go back into the 15th century,
we do, in fact, have a series of sources
that are in German treatises from the 15th century
that deal with the use of the so-called duelling shield
with either a sword or a club.
Now, the duelling shield is called that
essentially because it was part of the weapon set
that was given to commoners, not knights,
to commoners to fight judicial combat.
That is, if I was accused of sleeping with my brother's wife
and I disputed that and I got into a fight with my brother about it,
we went to court and the judge decided,
OK, well, I can't tell which of you is right.
And my brother said, I want trial by combat.
And I said, I agree.
We might be granted the right to decide it under the eyes of God,
under the eyes of God to decide who is right
and who is just, who's lying and who's telling the truth, essentially.
And in some cases, and trial by combat
was actually historically very rare.
OK, that's the first thing.
I might do a video just about trial by combat in the future,
but it didn't happen very often.
However, the treatises that deal with fencing,
particularly in Germany, actually pretty much only in Germany,
loved to talk about trial by combat.
I guess it was a bit fetishised.
They thought it was pretty interesting, pretty funky
and it involved some interesting weapons.
And so the fencing masters making books thought,
yeah, I want to make a book about that
because that'll be an extra thing that'll look pretty funky in my treatise
and show the variety of things I can teach
and the reason that people should pay me lots of money to teach them.
Of course, not that many commoners would be able to afford
to pay for a fencing master at that period.
But anyway, it was interesting stuff.
So they put it in their treatise.
Now, the duelling shield is very long, it's very tall.
It's usually about as tall as a person.
And it has a pole all the way down the back
and then you hold pretty much like a boss held shield
and then a large board, okay?
And if you just Google Talhoffer duelling shield,
then you'll immediately see loads of examples on Google Images, for example.
Now, the duelling shield is big and it's heavy.
And very often what you see is the combat starts with the big duelling shield
and the sword or a club, it depends whether you're,
I think, in Sfarbia or Franconia or somewhere,
whether you get the club or the sword,
depends which part of Germany you're in essentially.
But you start off with shield and the sword or the club
and they show techniques using the duelling shield with the weapon.
They also then show techniques where the weapon's being dropped or abandoned
and the person's using their shield entirely as a weapon.
Now, remember that this thing is six foot long.
It's got a pole down the centre and has spikes on it,
top and bottom and on the sides in some cases.
So you can use the whole thing as a great big two-handed kind of cumbersome pole weapon.
Let's ignore that bit for a minute.
Those fights start off with sword and shield or club and shield.
That means that they're showing techniques that use a sword or a club
in conjunction with a boss held shield.
And this has been one of the primary sources that people have gone to
to try and reconstruct early Viking era sword or club combat with a shield.
Because mechanically, the boss held or centre held duelling shield
is somewhat similar to a boss held Viking shield in that it can pivot.
However, it's also pretty damn different.
It can defend your legs without having to move very much
because it goes all the way down to the floor like a kite shield.
It also goes up as well.
You don't ever have to really move the shield up here.
You can hold it in the middle and it protects everything
from above your head right the way down to the floor.
It's also very heavy and cumbersome.
That means that a lot of the time what the people are doing
is they're pivoting the shield and fighting around it.
Bam! They're doing this type of thing a lot.
So they're pivoting this really big shield because it's fairly big
but it's also fairly slow.
And in that time you can actually move the body around it like this.
Now, it is a great source for trying to reconstruct shield and sword use.
However, how similar is it to anything that came earlier?
Essentially, we don't know.
And so that's the main point of this video.
We have a handful of later medieval, in other words,
15th century German, 16th century Italian
sword and shield sources that we can look at to try and reconstruct earlier stuff.
The other thing to mention, of course, is we have sword and buckler.
We have a lot of sword and buckler material.
And many people would argue that actually our main source
for knowledge about how a shield and a sword are used together
is the sword and buckler material.
And a lot of people who've worked with the earliest medieval fencing treatise,
which is I-33, sword and buckler,
make that argument possibly completely validly
that you can reverse engineer a lot of what's shown in I-33
to the use of larger shields with a sword.
That might be correct.
Again, we just don't know.
However, the problem with it is, number one,
a buckler is very different to a shield because it's a completely different size.
That introduces all sorts of different factors.
There's a factor of weight.
There's a factor of angulation and size, mechanics.
Pushing an opponent's shield is very clearly, obviously, mechanically important.
Pushing a buckler doesn't really get you very far usually.
A buckler is a very different thing to a larger shield.
But there is yet another problem with it,
in that there isn't only one way of using a sword and buckler.
If we look at I-33 and then we look at Marazzo,
so we look at a 14th century German source
and we look at a 16th century Italian source,
you know what?
They have fairly different ways of using the sword and buckler.
And in fact, if we look at some of the 15th century German stuff,
some of that looks quite different to I-33 as well.
So it seems like sword and buckler,
which was probably the most popular civilian sidearm set
for the 13th, 14th, 15th centuries, varied quite a bit.
It varied by teacher, by area, by perhaps buckler type.
If we look at the Bolognese traditions,
we see that they use both small round bucklers
and larger squarer bucklers,
which are corrugated to potentially bind against an opponent's blade better.
And there are even Hungarian type bucklers,
which are shown in Paulus Kal,
which go down the forearm and have a kind of spiky bit on them.
So there's a lot of variety.
It's very different and there are different techniques.
As I mentioned, the Bolognese treatises even have different sections
for square buckler versus round buckler.
That's not to say they're completely different,
but they have different techniques,
depending on whether one's slightly bigger and squarer than the other one.
So man, it is a minefield.
It is relatively easy to reconstruct lost or forgotten martial arts
where we have a book, where we have a treatise telling us how to do basic things.
How to step, how to cut, the different angles of the cup,
the different portions of the blade you can cut with,
and the different types of thrusts and the different angles of thrusts.
These are all things that are contained in I-33,
which is the earliest sword and buckler source,
or Doebringer or Fury Delivery,
which are the earliest longsword sources,
or indeed for dagger as well, certainly in Fury.
So by 1400, we actually know a shed load about how to use longswords,
sword and buckler, dagger, medieval wrestling,
because we've got it described explicitly in the books.
Anything that's not described explicitly in the treatises
is always going to be a real uphill struggle
of trying to pull together different sources
and put them together in a way that might work
with the different weapon set in a different time period
with different, perhaps, considerations about combat.
Very, very difficult to do.
But, I want to finish by saying,
the people who are leading this research
into old, undocumented, essentially,
shield and sword or shield and spear,
old, undocumented fighting systems,
which were obviously very developed in their own time,
those guys, Roland Wolcheka, Colin Richards,
you know, Thrand and Elgrim,
and various other people who are out there,
and there's particularly a few groups in Germany
and the Netherlands working on this stuff,
and I know at least one in Italy as well,
and in France also.
Those guys, all of you, you have my utmost admiration.
I don't want you to take this video in any way
as a negative thing.
This is a video intended for the mass of people
who maybe don't know that much about HEMA
and who assume that we have documented systems
for all of the different weapon sets,
which we don't.
It's relatively easy to take one rapier treatise,
Salvatore Fabrice, for example,
and learn his rapier system,
especially, obviously, if you have a good teacher to go to.
It's relatively easy to pick an Italian or German
longsword system and learn it from the book
with some help, with some partners, and so on.
It is really, really difficult to come up
with plausible systems using weapons
where we don't have documentation,
detailed, technical documentation
for what they actually did with them
and how they actually fought.
Inevitably, we will all come up
with slightly differing interpretations
because we've got so little material to work on.
Those of you guys out there,
particularly Roland Warchecker, I have to say,
have my utmost admiration.
I'm very interested in this topic
and I will hopefully learn lots
from all of you in coming years,
but it is a difficult, difficult task,
and I don't want anyone out there
to underestimate what the guys like Roland
and Colin and others out there,
what those guys are doing.
What they're doing is very, very difficult
and it's far more difficult for them
to make convincing reconstructions
to convince other HEMA people like me
who study the documented systems
pretty much mostly or only.
It's very difficult for them to make
or recreate convincing systems that convince us
so you should respect those guys a lot.
So there we go, guys.
I'm sure I'll talk a lot more about,
generally, sword and shield
and spear and shield combat
and shields in general in future videos,
but really, respect goes out to the guys
working with these essentially undocumented systems
and trying to bring them back.
Cheers, guys.
