EVERYTHING CULTURALLY WRONG WITH MULAN 2020 (And How They Could've Been Fixed)

Asian Mythology
12 followers
Aug 10, 2025 #Asianmythology #Supernatural
Have you ever seen a movie that pissed you off so badly you make a whole YouTube channel just to
roast it? That's me with Mulan 2020. Mulan brought me here. And now here are the things that must be
said. First of all, if you didn't know, the majority of the production staff on this movie are white.
A white director, a white costume designer, and four white screenwriters. And yes, it shows. It's
filled with like European fantasy stuff like witches, dark magic, and duels to the death.
And interpreted traditional Chinese concepts in a way that only showed a surface level understanding.
So the story starts off with Mulan's dad, Hua Zhou, telling Mulan's story to their ancestors.
I mean, okay. You can already feel that they fully intend on making this movie seem Asian by throwing
a bunch of words around like ancestors, honor, family. And anyway, Mulan is introduced as a girl
who already enjoys training to fight. This is an immediate departure from the ballad Disney claims
to be trying to adapt. Because in the ballad, Mulan starts off sighing at a weaving loom. She was a
very typical woman of her time. But it's her determination to save her father that drives her
to transcend her abilities and become a great warrior. In this movie, with Mulan starting off
as brave and powerful, it doesn't leave much room for character development. And she doesn't end up
And at this point in the movie, her dad is all, if you had a daughter whose qi was this powerful,
could you tell her that only a son could wield qi? This was the part that really gave me pause.
And it's like one minute into the movie. What is qi? It's life energy. It flows through everyone,
not just boys. It's the basis of acupuncture. In traditional Chinese medicine, it flows through
the human body in a network of meridians. Acupuncture is when you stick needles in
those meridians to manipulate someone's qi flow. Yes, qi is a common buzzword in wuxia stories,
or what white people call martial art movies, which are based in the Daoist belief that you
can gain supernatural abilities by using qi. But you do it by cultivating that qi. That's a word
this movie could have used to make it feel more right, but it didn't. Then the camera pans to
where Mulan lives, a distinctly southern Chinese tulou. Why is this a problem? Mulan is an iconic
northern Chinese tale. She lived in an era called the northern and southern dynasties,
which meant China was split in two back then. The emperor of a northern dynasty would not go to the
southern dynasty to conscript troops. This is an example of Disney getting facts wrong solely for
the pretty aesthetic, because tulou are pretty and they like they look very exotic, I guess.
In the tulou, little Mulan chases a chicken onto a roof and falls, but does a bunch of sweet
maneuvers and lands on her feet to the astonishment of everyone. Again, she's established
as having an impressive ability right in childhood. Her mom becomes worried that because of these
abilities, Mulan won't find a husband because people will call her a witch. That's just like
not how women are demonized in Chinese culture. Like more likely she'd be called an evil spirit,
especially a fox spirit, hulijing, or some kind of demon. The dad then comes outside and tells Mulan
that they have a statue of a phoenix in front of their ancestral shrine because it's the emissary
of their ancestors. Personally, I haven't heard of anyone whose family has like an emissary for
their ancestors. What ancestors do in Chinese culture is send your dreams. This is called
tuomeng, and they ask you to do like just weird ----. Mulan's like, oh no, then it's super bad
that I broke her during my chicken chasing. And the dad is like, nah, phoenixes rise from the ashes.
This isn't a huge problem because eastern phoenixes and western phoenixes have gotten so muddled and
confused with each other that even like native Chinese people don't like, they mix it up too.
But I have to point out that traditionally Chinese phoenixes don't do the whole rise from ashes
thing. They're just there to look beautiful and graceful and to be a good omen to the empire when
they're seen. Her dad goes all, your qi is strong, Mulan, but qi is for warriors, not daughters.
Once again, completely misunderstanding what qi is. Qi is not the force. It's not this
mystical oriental force. It's basically another physiological thing like blood. Would you say
blood is for warriors, not daughters? No, you wouldn't. Her dad also tells Mulan it's time to
hide her gift away. Hmm. So they gave Mulan a superpower. They made her Asian Elsa. In my opinion,
that immediately takes away a huge part of what makes Mulan such a great character because Mulan
is not a character who was born great. She works for that and that's a very like eastern story
thing. The protagonists of eastern stories, they work hard for their abilities. Then the title card
appears and the camera goes to the Silk Road in northwest China. A Silk Road trader comes across
the witch played by famous Chinese actress Gong Li. She can step on me. Now the witch is actually
a character that gave me pause way back when the trailer dropped because China doesn't have witches.
Witch is such a charged word and evokes such a specific idea that it's confusing when you
use it in a Chinese context because the specific idea doesn't exist in Chinese culture. Yet this
movie went with the common western ideal of witch, a woman who can do magic and is ostracized by
society because of it. Now there are women in ancient China who can do magic like shamanesses,
soothsayers, but those women are respected and generally hold high positions in the court. And
there are women who are criminalized for using magic such as like a court lady using a voodoo
doll against one of her rival concubines. It happens all the time. But their crime is trying
to harm someone, not doing magic in general. There's no persecution that happens specifically
because you are a woman and you're using magic. Honestly there's an easy fix to the witch's entire
character. Don't make her human, make her a bird spirit instead. A big thing in Chinese myth is the
spirit of animals or even inanimate objects cultivating their way into taking human form.
That she would be persecuted for because like she's not human. One fix and her character would
have made so much more sense. She even has the existing abilities of a spirit. Possession,
shape-shifting, she's got it. This is why Disney should have just hired a Chinese screenwriter,
because they could have just changed some words in their script and not look like other clowns.
Anyway, movie. The Possessed Traitor goes to what looks like a western Chinese garrison city.
I'll give credit where credit is due. They got the general look right. Most cities in ancient
China were walled and you had to go through a guarded gate like that to get in. And then the
Rourans arrive. This is where they try to be more accurate to the original ballad than the cartoon.
In the cartoon they used Huns. Inaccurate and racist. Rourans are indeed the correct group of
nomadic people that Mulan would have fought. But fun fact, Mulan is most likely from the
Northern Wei Dynasty, which is established by another nomadic people, the Xianbei. The ballad
even refers to her emperor as the Great Khan. Anyway, the soldiers at the gate shoot an arrow
at the Rouran leader. He catches it with his bare hand, then shoots it back at the city,
which is a signal for the witch to reveal her true form. Now it's unclear if she possessed
the Silk Road Traitor or like took on his appearance. Very unclear. But she takes down
some soldiers from the inside and then the rest of the Rourans scurry straight up the wall.
Now I've seen some complaints about this part. It doesn't deserve it. Scaling walls is a common
trope in wuxia media. At this point I've accepted that the movie is not historical fiction like
originally promised. It's historical fantasy, which is fine. I don't mind supernatural elements
in a retelling. Happens all the time in great Chinese literature. Half of great Chinese
literature is just fantasy fan fiction of historical events. My problem is that many of
supernatural elements in this did not feel Chinese. Anyway, the Rourans take the city and
then the witch takes possession of a soldier to sneak into the imperial city, which is clearly
modeled after Chang'an or Xi'an as it's now called, the ancient capital of China. You can
tell by the Great Wild Goose Pagoda lookalikes in the background. That's a thousand euro building
that you can still visit in Xi'an. This shot is accurate. What's not accurate is what's happening
in the city. This shot. This is the main stairs of the palace. I even know exactly where it's shot.
The palace of the king of Qing and Hengdian. China loves its period dramas so much and they made a
whole city that's like a replica of an ancient Chinese city just to shoot dramas in. In ancient
China, these fancy court ladies wouldn't just be hanging out with officials on these stairs.
This is a solemn place, especially when there's like an imperial meeting going on right behind
them in the great hall, that building above the stairs. In the meeting, the chancellor reports
that the Rourans have taken six northern garrisons in a coordinated attack and everyone was slaughtered
except for that one soldier. Before the chancellor and the emperor finish their discussion, the
soldier cuts them off to say his report, which felt iffy to me because a normal soldier would never do
that. They would never cut an emperor off. It would have felt more natural for the emperor to ask him to
speak. The soldier, which is actually the witch in disguise, reports that the Rouran and their leader
fights alongside a woman whose qi is beyond imagining. Again, this is like saying her blood
is beyond imagining. What would feel more natural here is to talk about the way she uses her qi, not
her qi itself. Her abilities are beyond imagining. There, two words. And it would have even made more
sense to a non-Chinese audience. Then the emperor is like, there is no place for witches in this
kingdom and also that they are not afraid of dark magic and will destroy the Rouran army and their
witch. It's so something straight out of a European fantasy. But it leads to the emperor
issuing that infamous decree that demands one man out of every family to join the army. By the way,
the emperor is played by Jet Li. Did you recognize him? I didn't. I didn't for like the whole movie.
Jet Li, what happened to you? Why did Disney make you ugly or did you just get ugly? Oh my god.
So it cuts to the streets of the capital where the soldier shifts into the witch, then shifts
into a bird. So it is shape-shifting then? I don't know. Not possession? It's so unclear.
So she flies all the way to the Rouran camp which is clearly inspired by Mongolian yurts.
She tells the, for some reason, half-naked Bori Khan about the army being assembled and he's like,
you have proven useful, witch. This pisses her off and she's like, not witch, warrior. And declares
that she could tear him to pieces before she blinks. This line, this line is important. This
line is important and yet the script forgets about it and leads to the most infuriating scene of the
entire movie. You'll see. Bori Khan says that she wouldn't hurt him because what she really wants is
to be accepted and belong somewhere where her powers wouldn't be vilified. Turns out she was
exiled to the desert for being a witch. All right, I guess. But his logic is that once they take over
China, then she can make sure she's accepted. Okay, so why can't she use her incredible power
to take the throne for herself? And don't tell me a woman can't be emperor. Wu Zetian did it.
She'd be laughing at you from Chinese hell. After this conversation, it cuts to grown-up Mulan. Yay.
Played by Chinese-American police brutality supporter Liu Yifei. Yay. While she's riding
a horse, she spots two rabbits running beside her. She goes home and tells her family about this,
theorizing that one rabbit was male and the other was female. But you can't really tell
why they're running that fast. This is a reference to the final lines of The Ballad of Mulan, which
talks about how male and female rabbits can be identified by their facial features, but when
they're running side by side you can't tell anymore. So Mulan forcefully gendering the
rabbits anyway defeats the entire point of the line and makes for a very clumsy reference.
If they wanted to do it right, they should have had her meet the rabbits while they're grazing on
the ground and be like, oh you're a boy and you're a girl. And then they all run off and she realizes
she can't tell anymore. That's the point of the line. Mulan's mom cuts her very exciting story off
to tell her that the matchmaker has found her an auspicious match. Honestly, this is the only part
of the script that feels Chinese. It's very your Asian mom trying to introduce you to some son of
her co-worker. It's very that. It's got that energy. Mulan begrudgingly accepts and then it
cuts to a very YouTube DIY montage sequence of her getting a makeover with an instrumental of
Now the makeup elements that get put on her are historically accurate. I have some infographics
of them on my Instagram. I'll link them below. But it doesn't change that they interpreted these
elements in like the ugliest possible way. There are ways to do this makeup style that wouldn't
make someone look like a clown. I know they did this for comedic effect, but it doesn't sit right
with me that they chose to exaggerate traditional Chinese makeup to a super ugly degree for a cheap
joke. A joke that's not even funny. There are like no moments in this movie that make you laugh.
And then the matchmaker does this whole sequence that's clearly only in this movie for trailer
purposes. Like, oh we're elegant. We're fine. These are the qualities we see in Mulan. The change from
the cartoon sequence is that here it's actually Mulan's sister that ruins it because she gets
freaked out by Spider. Mulan does some Spider-Man 1 cafeteria scene maneuvers to catch the falling
tea set, but her hair unravels and she falls anyway and the tea set is shattered. And for some
reason she is blamed for this fiasco instead of her sister. Okay. Also in the background of this
shot, oh my god. So red couplets are something put beside doors in Chinese culture to celebrate the
New Years, but they have specific rules. And this couplet does not meet those rules. The lines are
even from literature written several centuries after this era. It basically says, may all lovers
in the world become great couples in the end. And may all couples in the world all be earnest
lovers. In Chinese these lines do not make a good couplet. So the Hua family is walking through the
tulou in shame when suddenly the imperial messenger shows up and announces the conscription.
Then comes a sequence of everyone knowing the dad is too old and frail to fight, but the dad is too
stubborn to give up. So Mulan sneaks off into the night with his armor and sword. A sword that has,
I just don't believe that it's a coincidence when it's the same three things in the exact
sequence. Loyal, brave, and true versus fidelity, bravery, and integrity. They're literally synonyms
of each other. Also a Chinese person wouldn't just have three random characters on their sword.
That is some white person tattoo nonsense. It would be the sword owner's name or at least a
And by the way there is no emotional impact to this decision scene. She just leaves and then
her family discovers this in the morning and they're immediately like, okay we have to keep
quiet about this or she's dead and we're all dead. That's it. That's it. Oh and there's no haircut
scene and if you're wondering why that is, it's because the original in the cartoon was historically
inaccurate. Men kept their hair as long as women back then because in Confucian beliefs your body
is a gift from your parents and you have no right to damage any part of it. Like people back then
even kept all their nails in a box if they cut them. And beards technically couldn't be shaved
too so all those clean-shaven pretty boys you see in C-dramas, not accurate. Mulan rides across some
vast landscapes with apparently only a supply of apples, which did not exist in China back in the
Northern Wei dynasty, but it's a minor, this is a minor complaint. She ends up in a canyon where
she sees a phoenix flying by. People have complained about this phoenix not being the right color
or something. It's like hot pink. Whatever. Honestly this is like not even remotely an important
issue that needs to be addressed. I don't care about the phoenix. Whatever. It's whatever for me.
I think it leads her to the training camp because she mentioned being lost before. In the camp,
Cricket is a human character now. His mother says he was born under an auspicious moon. I have never
heard a Chinese mother say that. Some commotion happens and it causes Mulan to be knocked over
by a hot guy who teases her, and in her attempt to channel toxic masculinity, she draws her sword
on him. He draws his sword too, but then their fight is interrupted by Donnie Yen. At night, Mulan
finds that she now has to deal with sharing a tent with dozens of half-naked men, but she gets around
the bathing issue by, well they call it showering in this for some reason, but she gets around that
issue by volunteering for night guard duty. Then comes the training montage. It comes with no iconic
song and is therefore boring as hell to watch. Remember that scene in the cartoon where she
figures out how to climb the pole using only the weights? Yeah, everybody remembers that scene
because it showed why she was cut out to be a great warrior, even though she like may not have
been as physically strong as the men. Here, there's no meaningful struggle. It doesn't show Mulan
bonding with the others in an effective way, except, well except there's a scene that's a
piss-poor adaptation of um the a girl worth fighting for scene. And in this movie, it's
straight up uncomfortable because it's it's just a bunch of guys blandly objectifying women.
Then comes a sparring scene where Mulan defeats her friend acquaintance-ish person Honghui with
her mystical superpowers. She berates herself Elsa style for showing her chi, which makes no sense
because if she's disguising herself as a man then showing her chi would not be a problem.
Then everyone comes in to congratulate her for being badass, but also to tell her that she
literally stinks because she hasn't taken a bath since she got here. So she goes to the lake to
take a bath, but Honghui rudely tries to join her. Um he's clearly taking the place of Shang from
the cartoon and has some like romantic-ish tension with her, but yeah. I think it's implied that he
realizes she's a woman, but there's no real confirmation and there's no real bond between
them either. There's no emotion in this movie, oh my god. Then it cuts to a meeting between the
12 Rouran tribes whose members resent that they're relying on a witch, which begs the question of why
the hell is she relying on them to find her place then? They like they don't even accept her. They
make plans to destroy another garrison, then it cuts back to the training camp where Donnie Yen
calls Mulan for a private meeting and says he thinks she's hiding something. But plot twist
that something is her powerful chi. She's like why are you hiding it? And she's like damn I don't know
when I'm in boy mode now I can do whatever I want. So then there's another montage with a voiceover
of Donnie Yen explaining chi in a way that feels slightly more accurate. Like he admits that it
flows in everyone, but it still has some weird wording that could be easily fixed. Like he says
only the most true will connect deeply to his chi. First of all it would be better phrased as
can cultivate their chi. And second, so you have to be honest to yourself to cultivate your chi?
I've never heard that. It's always hard work. It's hard work that matters when you're cultivating chi.
During the montage another commander teaches them about how a great warrior can turn disadvantage
to advantage and how four ounces can move a thousand pounds, which is a popular martial
arts saying in China but it just sounds so weird translated into English because it's
translated very literally and the original in Chinese is like it sounds like more poetic than
this. God. So because the Rourans keep taking more garrisons the training class just gets deployed
ahead of schedule. They come across the remains of a battlefield and it's so disappointing because
it completely lacks the emotional impact of the scene of the cartoon. That cartoon transition
from that silly like um a girl worth fighting for scene to the harrowing massacred village
that's one of the like best cinematic transitions ever just because it was such a great moment that
showcased how like there truly were just boys who had no idea about the horrors of war and then
suddenly they're forced to confront it. In this movie I felt nothing. Nothing upon seeing all those
dead bodies. This is on par with when I went to see the Lion King live action in theaters and then I
felt nothing see Mufasa die. This is very bad. Spoilers. Sorry. Then comes a clash between the
army and the Rourans. It looks so pathetic. Like the most people they could get was like four random
buses of people. This cost 200 million dollars and yet I've seen C-dramas with a fraction of that
budget stretched across like 70 episodes and they have better war scenes than this movie.
Borikhan retreats immediately after getting showered with arrows and then the commander
orders the left flank to charge. And the left flank is apparently, I counted, 10 people.
They made 10 people go chase Borikhan, the leader of this tribe that they're struggling to fight.
9 of these 10 people obviously get decimated and the 10th is Mulan who can't die because
she's the protagonist. She decides to keep pursuing them anyway and ends up running into the
enemy witch who's all, hmm, you're lying to yourself and it's poisoning your chi.
I have, I've said enough about chi. Let's move on. So Mulan passes out for a bit while the main
battle rages on and then she wakes up, stares at the FBI model on her sword and she decides to shed
her father's armor, the thing that's protecting all of her vital organs from harm, and she loosens
her long hair so it's free to whip all in her face while she's trying to fight. It makes absolutely
no logical sense. They could have just shown her taking off her binder on her, under her armor.
She, she didn't need to let go of her father's probably very precious and expensive armor.
There are better ways to do this reveal. If only there was a good template to reference.
If only. So she comes back to the battle in her very impractical getup, starts doing backflips
on her horse, which freaks the Rorans out, I'd be freaked out too. And they run from her because
she's a witch. Their own witch turns into several swarms of birds to drive the imperial soldiers
into huddling under their shields. And then the Rorans destroy whole huddles using stone
throwing machines. Some people have said that nomads shouldn't have machines like this.
I don't care. I'm not a war nerd. I'm not getting into this. I got more ---- to, I got more ---- to
dissect. But Mulan gets the genius plan of triggering an avalanche to bury the Rorans.
She picks up several helmets and makes it seem like some imperial soldiers have crept up behind
the Rorans. So they send a flaming boulder at the snowy ridge. Somehow she outruns this avalanche
while the Rorans and what appears to be a considerable amount of her own comrades don't.
How fast is her horse? After the battle ends, Mulan walks up to her comrades like, sorry,
I'm a girl. Feel free to execute me if you want for this horrible betrayal. Man, that's, that's
so empowering. She gets expelled according to army laws instead. While she goes off to cry on
some barren mountains about this, the enemy witch appears before her and tries to convince her to
join her because she relates to Mulan's struggle. The witch like straight up tells her how Bori Khan
retreating was a fake out and his forces are actually heading to the capital. Mulan's like,
I know my place. Actual line, it is my duty to fight for the kingdom and protect the emperor.
Man, so empowering. Mulan immediately heads back to the military base and tells the army about
Bori Khan's plans. Donnie Yen is like, no, I won't listen to someone whose very existence is a lie.
Then Hong Hui, the love interest kind of dude, is like, you would believe Hua Jun. Why would you
not believe Hua Mulan? And then everyone else joins in like, I believe Hua Mulan. I believe Hua Mulan.
And so Donnie Yen, who was ready to execute her like 10 seconds ago, is all, all right, you will
lead us to the imperial city. Meanwhile, in the imperial city, a squad of about like a dozen
row ratted, very conspicuous ninja clothes sneak very conspicuously across the rooftops. The witch
takes the body of the chancellor and claims to the emperor that Bori Khan wants to duel him
at the construction site of a new palace. The emperor accepts. First of all, a duel between
heads of state, not a thing in China, not a thing. Secondly, the writers have clearly never seen a
sea drama because if they have, they know that a Chinese emperor can't even breathe differently
without a whole gaggle of Confucian scholars being like, your majesty, think thrice, don't do this.
So then the witch, disguised as the chancellor, gives fake orders to assemble literally every
guard in the city to a single courtyard. Somehow nobody dares to seriously question this order or
refuse it. They basically just wave it away as, oh, you're going to question the emperor? No.
It's so much that when Mulan and her battalion arrives, they waltz straight into the capital
and they don't see a single person in view. When they get to the courtyard, it turns out that every
guard in the city comes down to like 150-ish people. Do the writers have any idea how big
cities in ancient China were? Especially the capital? They have no excuse because they did
film in China, so there are like so many extras available if they wanted to fill that city and
give it a more realistic sense of scale. Of course, the minute Mulan's battalion arrives,
the Rourans close off the courtyard and attack the soldiers that assembled for some reason.
Meanwhile, the dumbass emperor actually rides to the new palace construction site like the dumbass
he is, and within half a second, archers take out the few personal guards he took with them,
and he starts doing bedsheet kung fu to fight back. When Borigun shows himself,
the emperor is all, how did you convince my chancellor to betray me?
Never mind that, like, he was the one who willingly agreed to this dumbass dual request.
So like the good Disney villain that he is, Borigun captures the emperor using an overly
complicated maneuver involving arrows and rope that gather into a net. Meanwhile, Mulan's comrades
slow down the Rouran in the city so she can rush to find the emperor. In the throne room though,
she finds the witch instead, who looks so right sitting on that throne. You know, I would have
forgiven, like, all of this movie's sins if they had dared to make the witch, like, take the throne
as a symbol, as an ultimate symbol of toppling the patriarchy. She has the power to kill both
the emperor and Borigun before they even blink, as she says. But no, we can't have nice things.
Mulan tells the witch to join her on the noble path because apparently everything will magically
turn out okay if you just out yourself to your oppressors. The witch is like, no, it's too late
for me, and turns into a bird form to fly out. Mulan chases her across the capital's rooftops.
Here they didn't even bother showing a few shots of civilians looking up at her, so it just feels
like the capital is empty and there are, like, 12 people in it. Back at the construction site,
Borigun lights up a bunch of furnaces with the intention of burning the emperor alive instead
of just killing him for some reason. They gotta- yeah, he has to- he has to delay it till Mulan
makes it there. Oh my god, he's such- he's such a devoted villain. In the middle of his villain speech,
the witch shows up and is all, the attack is meeting a fierce resistance from a woman leads
the army. A woman from a small village. Mulan arrives then and Borigun shoots an arrow at her.
Now, in the single most baffling moment of the movie, instead of obliterating Borigun before he
can blink like- like she said she could, the witch dives down and takes the arrow in Mulan's place
and then she dies. All that power and she just dies of self-sacrifice. This is not empowering.
A woman sacrificing herself is- is like the least empowering thing you can make a female character
do. I find it like outright offensive and apparently- apparently Borigun only has this one
arrow because Mulan heads into the construction site no problem. She and Borigun have a fight
in the rafters that I don't care about because, you know what, I am still mad at the witch dying
like that. At one point, Mulan loses her FBI sword to the furnaces and the emperor tells her to rise
up like a phoenix to fight for the kingdom and its people. The actual phoenix appears behind Mulan
and she knocks Borigun to the bottom of the construction site and frees the emperor.
Borigun's not dead. He shoots an arrow at them which the emperor catches with his bare hand
and then Borigun makes the most memeable face in the entire movie. Oh my god, it's so good.
And then the emperor throws the arrow in the air and Mulan kicks it. Kicks it into Borigun,
killing him. I don't understand this movie's obsession with Mulan kicking things.
Especially arrows. Why? Then it cuts to the battle in the city. All of Mulan's comrades have
conveniently survived. So all the villains die and all the heroes survive. Great.
Act Splendid. And then it cuts to the imperial city celebrating the victory.
Mulan is for some reason presented in the court in the presence of both
the officials and the court ladies in the open, which would never happen. The cartoon Mulan's
voice actress, Wen Ming Nan, she makes a cameo and I feel so bad because they put her in such
an ugly cheap looking dress. The emperor offers Mulan a position in his imperial guard but Mulan
chooses to go home instead, which is how the ballot ended, but that doesn't mean I have to
like it. As Mulan leaves the imperial city, the pseudo love interest dude has a moment with her
but they don't kiss or anything, which thank god. She goes home. It's supposed to be emotional but
it's not emotional because the movie did a terrible job of building up her bond with her
family. Her battalion shows up hot on her heels, which how does she not see them behind her? Like
five seconds behind her. And they present her with a new FBI sword. Yay. Oh but this one instead of
the three FBI virtues, it has a fourth virtue. Xiang, filial piety or devotion to family as this
movie translates it. Great. Thankfully the movie ends on the battalion asking her to reconsider
the emperor's offer and she smiles in a suggestion that like she's going to take it this time.
But good. She doesn't have to give up her prestigious opportunities for her family.
God you could have both. So I went into this movie expecting it to be bad just because like I was on
Twitter and then people were like oh my god Mulan. So like I was expecting it to not be good but still
it was like so much worse. Not just because like even if you push aside all of the weird inaccurate
Chinese cultural details, it's just a terrible movie with no eternal logic and no emotional
moments whatsoever. No emotional moments. No funny moments. And like nothing is earned.
No character arc. Just ugh. So like why is it a problem for white people to write a story that's
like so deeply rooted in an underrepresented culture? Well they put their weird orientalist
interpretations on things and the story just doesn't end up feeling familiar to people of
that actual culture. Which I find yeah this movie was disrespectful. And you know what P.Collywood
is the costume designer. Apparently Disney paid for her to travel around Europe in the museums
with the eluded Chinese artifacts. And then also like she traveled around China for several weeks
to soak up the culture. And they could have just hired someone who grew up in that culture
who doesn't need to be like sent on to sent on trips. It's like they're trying to make things
more difficult for themselves. So why does it matter that this movie isn't some like documentary
of um ancient China? Isn't it just a kid's movie? Well it is a kid's movie that fails to do the job
it promised to do. Which is to make a faithful adaptation of the Ballad of Mulan. It's very clear
that they just like threw a western fantasy story onto a aesthetically Chinese world to go for that
sweet sweet Chinese box office. Because honestly like money is the only thing Disney cares about.
It's very clear. So they it's like they want the money of Chinese people but they don't want to
respect Chinese people. This movie doesn't tell a story that feels culturally Chinese. It doesn't
bridge any gaps of understanding between cultures. It doesn't really make you interested in Chinese
culture because like so many elements they presented were either oppressive or ugly. You
know some might argue that the cast was all Asian so it's fine but the cast usually actors usually
don't have any input on the screen. Actors are also contractually obligated to say nice things
about the movie. I mean it's great what this movie has done for Asian representation on the screen
but that doesn't mean that this movie should be immune from critique. It was a giant missed
opportunity to do better and Disney should do better. If it wants the money of Asian people
do better Disney. Anyway if you made it to the end of all of that I bet you're bored just sitting at
home in quarantine. And you know who am I to critique Disney? Well I am an actual Chinese
person who spent half my life in China and I know quite a bit about Chinese history and I'm a sci-fi
and fantasy author. My debut novel Iron Widow comes out fall 2021 from Penguin Random House
and it's a Pacific Rim meets The Handmaid's Tale retelling of China's only female emperor Wu Zetian.
Add it on Goodreads if you're interested. I'll drop a link below. Bye!
