The narration explores the Chinese Communist Party’s brainwashing network, structured in three levels: official channels, self-media, and speech control. Official channels, like CCTV and textbooks, define narratives and guide public opinion on events like Tianshui’s lead poisoning. Self-media, including influencers like Hu Xijin, amplify propaganda, while subtler creators weave patriotic content into unrelated topics. Speech control, using AI and sensitive word lists, fosters isolation to suppress dissent. The narrative critiques selective reporting, such as Xinhua’s portrayal of Japanese textbooks, which misrepresents their use to fuel anti-Japanese sentiment. Despite past effectiveness, economic decline and incidents like Huangyang Tiantian are weakening control, with sarcastic online commentary outpacing pro-government voices, signaling a shift in public opinion.
00:00:00 Intro 00:42:12 Unveiling the Propaganda Machine 01:11:14 The Power of Official Narratives 02:22:20 Distorting History for Control 03:13:16 The Textbook Conspiracy Unraveled 05:11:16 Exposing Selective Truths 06:51:07 The Media’s Mainstream Deception 08:44:03 The Reach of Self-Media Influence 09:53:11 Hidden Propaganda in Everyday Content 11:42:14 Controlling the Digital Sphere 14:15:13 Silencing Dissent Through Isolation 16:06:13 The Crumbling Facade of Control
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Shong. Welcome to digging
into China, where we explore China in
depths to reveal unique perspectives.
China currently has many little pinks,
but the issue lies not with them, rather
with the vast brainwashing network
constructed by Chinese Communist Party
CCP. When people think of the CCP
brainwashing, they often first point to
the internet firewall, which prevents
many Chinese from accessing the truth.
However, the firewall is merely one
component of the CCP's extensive array
of brainwashing tools. In this episode,
we will examine how the CCP orchestrates
its brainwashing efforts. The CCP's
brainwashing network operates within a
broad framework, which I categorize into
three levels. These levels continuously
shape our perceptions, the information
we receive, and our understanding of the
world. They are at the top official
channels, in the middle social media
platforms and at the bottom speech
control. Together these three levels
intervenes to form the entire
brainwashing network. Let us begin with
the top level official channels. These
include the state-run media such as the
CCTV, the CCP's spokesperson
departments, various official media
outlets, and the CCP's textbooks. These
are the most authoritative voices
directly controlled by the CCP. They
hold the power to define all matters in
China, guide the public opinion and
deliver the final word on significant
issues. For instance, the recent lead
poisoning incident in Tian or the
earlier hangen incident. Official
statements set the definitive tone for
these events. Moreover, many issues are
amplified by these official channels,
such as the Japanese nuclear wastewater
controversy. Some may view CCP official
reports as blatantly false, like claims
before the Russia Ukraine war that Putin
would not invade or explanations during
the Iraq war about why Saddam Hussein
remained unperturbed.
Such propaganda is easily recognizable
as a force. However, not all official
narratives are so transparent. Consider
an example. On July 7 this year, the
anniversary of the Lou Gold Bridge
incident, Shin Hua Net published an
article titled The Truth About the Lo
Bridge Incident Missing from Japanese
Textbooks. This was clearly intended to
criticize Japan and a few anti-Japanese
sentiment. The article was not unique to
Shin Hua. Multiple outlets, including
CCTV, published the same piece, a
coordinated release. What impression
does such a headline create? It suggests
that most Japanese have not acknowledged
World War II's mistakes, that Japan
remains steeped in militarism, and that
its attitude toward admitting fault
contrast sharply with the Germany's. I
too was influenced by this perspective
in my youth. Yet upon closer examination
of Shinua's article, the truth it
presents diverges significantly from
reality. Why does Shinua claim Japanese
textbooks distort history? It cites two
passage from Japanese textbooks. One
from Tokyo Shoo Publishing and one from
Raya Shos publishing describing the Lugo
Bridge incident. Tokyo Shosaki's taxport
states in July 1937 Japanese and the
Chinese forces clashed near the Lugo
Bridge outside of Beijing sparking the
sign of Japanese war. Ray Washiki's
version reads on July 7, 1937. During a
nighttime military exercise near the
Lugo Bridge outside of Beijing, Japanese
forces were fired upon by unknown
sources. At the dawn on July 8th,
Japanese forces attacked the National
Revolutionary Army's positions leading
to combat. For comparison, Chinese
history textbooks state the Japanese
military used a missing soldier as a
pretext to demand entry into Wamping
City for a search, which when refused
escalate into a military conflict. Is
the Shinua's report about the Japanese
textbooks fabricated? No. The textbooks
do contain those descriptions. Tokyo
Shoseki's account is not particularly
problematic. It is simply lacks detail.
As a middle school history textbook, it
is not exhaustive and a Japanese
textbooks naturally emphasize their own
history. They focus more on how
militarists later manipulated the
government including Prime Minister
Fumato Konohi to launch a full-scale
invasion of China. A different emphasis.
However, Ray Shosiki's textbook does
conflict significantly with the Chinese
textbooks, effectively blaming China
while the Chinese version blames Japan.
One might argue that Shinua is correct.
Raya Shosiki's textbook encourages
Japanese to forget the disasters of
militarism and their past crimes. Yet,
this is where the CCP's brainwashing
reveals its cunning. The CCP exploits a
common Chinese misconception that
education is a state controlled and the
textbooks are governmentmandate.
Japan's textbook publishing system
differs. Having learned from the perils
of educational monopolies during the
militarist era, Japan enacted laws
allowing publishers nationwide to
produce textbooks with the government
conducting only limited reviews.
Publishers create their own textbooks
and the sales determine their success.
So how many copies does the history
textbook from Raya Shosiki criticized by
the CCP actually sell in Japan?
According to official Japanese
statistics, Ray Shosiki's textbook sell
only 78 copies annually nationwide.
These are purchased by private school or
donated by Raywa Shosuki to schools for
disabled students. The specifics are
unclear. Its adoption rate in public
schools is zero. No Japanese public
middle school uses it. This reviews
Shinua's sly tactic. Why include Tokyo
Shosiki's mild description of the Lugo
Bridge incident? Because Raya Shosuki
sales are too low to seem
representative. including Tokyo
Shosiki's makes the narrative appear
more mainstream. Examine Japan's
textbook sales. The top two are Tokyo
Shosuki with a 50% market share and the
Kakaku showing with 25% dominating the
history textbook market. I have already
outlined the Tokyo Shosuki's
description. The Koku showing accounts
reads, "The SinoJapanese war began in
July 1937 when Japanese and the Chinese
forces clashed near the Lugo Bridge
outside Beijing, triggering the Lugo
Bridge incident. Japanese forces later
invaded the southern China, occupying
Shanghai and the nationalist
government's capital, Nanjing. Notably,
the Koku shownen uses critical terms
like invaded and occupied to describe
the incident. A neutral report might
have flamed it differently. Text books
downplaying the Lugo Bridge incident
failed in Japan unused by any public
schools, signaling a setback for
militarist revival. The same event
reframed conveys an entirely different
meaning. Yet because of Raya Shosuki's
textbook, Shinua drags it out annually
for criticism. On August 15 last year,
Shinua criticized the same textbook for
its remarks on comfort women, using it
to represent all Japanese textbooks. Is
this anti-Japanese propaganda false? Not
entirely. It is selectively edited and
taken out of context. Similar tactics
are used in reports about the US, Japan,
South Korea, and Europe. Can one truly
guard against this? The CCP produces
dozens, even hundreds of such stories
daily? I can debunk a few, but not all.
Debunking them constantly would leave no
time for anything else. And many will
still be swayed by these narratives. The
CCP's brainwashing extends beyond
official media, leading us to the second
level, the internet, particularly key
opinion leaders. The most prominent
includes figures like Hui Jing or Jang
Wei way from outlets like Guang Chan.
These individuals operates in a
semiofficial capacity with access to
unique government resources, insider
information and early indications of the
government's stance. If Shin Hua is the
civil servant of the brainwashing
network, figures like Hui Jin are akin
to contract employees. Beyond these
semiofficial figures are crudder ones,
including external propaganda accounts
active on platforms like a Twitter. They
may not be part of the official system,
but still profit from it, resembling
temporary workers in the brainwashing
network. Their purpose is allow the CCP
to aggressively criticize the US or
fabricate rumors about the US and the
West. Official outlets like a state
media or CCP spokespeople must maintain
some regard for international image as
reckless statements could provoke
diplomatic conflicts. One might say,
I'll simply avoid their videos and post
to escape their brainwashing. It is not
so straightforward. At this level, there
are subtler actors, domestic Chinese
counter creators, focusing on other
topics such as history, military
affairs, gaming, or makeup. Many Chinese
know that a blogger seemingly unrelated
to politics might suddenly insert a
patriotic remark. This may not reflect
their personal views. The CCP's
cyberspace administration periodically
requires platforms and agencies to
identify loyal creators who are then
instructed to incorporate a patriotic or
even anti-Japanese, anti-American
content into their videos or live stream
for positive energy propaganda. This
includes denigrating foreign brands or
shouting slogans like eliminate the
Japanese during stream or participating
in positive energy campaigns. These
creators are compensated with traffic
boosts and some protection from bans.
Such covert propaganda is nearly
impossible to evade. You might be
watching a makeup vlogger, an education
vlog, or gaming vlog, or a car vlogger,
and they suddenly they subtly insert a
soft patriotic or procccp messages. Most
viewers may not even notice even without
the positive energy propaganda, creators
undergo regular training to avoid
expressing dissent against the
government. During major events, the CCP
issues directives prohibiting commentary
on certain topics. To succeed as a
content creator in China, a degree of
party loyalty is often necessary.
Another subtle method is the CCP's
infiltration beyond the firewall. One
might assume the outside world is beyond
the CCP's reach, but they employ long
armed jurisdiction, including buying
influence, a tactic among others even
less scrupulous. Among overseas Chinese
opinion leaders, there are three camps,
staunchly anti-CCCP, pro-CCCP, and the
reformist. The pro-CCCP camp mirrors
domestic official insiders. I wish to
focus on the reformist camp which often
holds greater influence than the staunch
anti-CCCP camp. This dynamic stems from
the CCP's tiered suppression system. For
staunch anti-CCCP vloggers, returning to
China is unthinkable and even abroad
safety is not guaranteed. Some face
death threats. For instance, Teacher
Lee, an anti-CCCP vlogger, has been
harassed by local gangs, followed and
had a paint splashed on his door,
forcing frequent relocations. Even his
fans in China have been targeted.
Reformist vloggers, often called
rational, balanced, or objective
centrists, fare better abroad. They face
little CCP harassment and can often
return to China. I do not criticize
these centrists. They opposed the little
pings and contributed to public
enlightenment. However, the CCP's tear
pressure tactics shaped online
environment. Intense intimidation,
harassment, and persecution marginaliz
staunch anti-CCCP voices. Reformists
facing lighter pressure are more likely
to persist. Some staunch anti-CCCP
figures become centrists, not always due
to exhaustion, but by shifting to
discuss economic or social issues
without directly criticizing Shiin Ping,
participating in June 4th protest,
opposing the Communist Party outright or
aligning with groups like Fong Gong. Why
do many anti-CCCP voices become
centrist? The CCP is a strategic. They
know anti-CCCP voices cannot be entirely
silenced online, especially abroad where
censorship is limited. Thus, they target
staunch anti-CCCP figures, leaving
mostly centrists. This differential
treatment foster an environment where
centrists thrive, increasing their
numbers and influence, allowing their
views to resonate more widely. Having
covered the first two levels, the third
is direct and severe. Speech control
within China. Ordinary Chinese have
little voice. The CCP's sensitive word
list is expensive. Nearly anything can
be deemed sensitive. For example, terms
related to shiing ping include but are
not limited to thin necked bottle, meat
bun, we need the poo, 200 pounds,
porter, unchanging shoulders, zero out
emperor and assignments. Beyond
employing vast numbers of internet
police, the CCP now uses AI to monitor
sensitive words. Why such effort to
control speech? Beyond the suppressing
disscent, it fosters a sense of
isolation in Chinese society.
Imagine opposing the CCP but finding a
video comment section filled with
pro-CCCP voices or believing
anti-Japanese sentiment is wrong yet
seeing comments vilifying Japan. How
could you feel? You might retreat into
apathy assuming all is well. Or you
might question yourself wondering if you
are mistaken. Or you might despair
believing the Chinese are beyond the
saving. Whether retreating into a pathy
becoming a little pink or concluding
China is hopeless, these are outcomes
the CCP desires. The CCP does not fear
one or two dissenting voices. They fear
people realizing that common sections
and their surroundings are filled with
anti-CCCP sentiment. If being a little
pink made one the outlier, many might
turn against the CCP due to conformity,
a prevailance of anti-CCCP voices could
inspire thoughts of overthrowing the
party. Thus, isolating anti-CCCP
individuals is critical. The CCP's three
tier brainwashing network was highly
effective in the past. Just 11 years ago
in 2012 when Xiinping assumed power the
online environment was relatively open
with hopes for democratic reforms. In a
mere 11 years it has transformed into a
landscape dominated by little pinks with
many dissident and even relatives
turning from denters to supporters. This
shift is not solely due to the firewall
but the collective impact of the three
tier network. However, with China's
economic downturn and numerous incidents
like the Tian lead poisoning, the
Hangyang Tentan earring case and the Ho
sewage incident, public opinion is
shifting again. The CCP's control over
discourse is weakening. Increasingly,
people use a sarcasm and veiled
criticism to bypass speech controls. In
many video comment sections, sarcastic
mockery now surpasses little pink
remarks. Lies remain lies and we are no
longer in that closed era. Public
opinion today is already improved from a
few years ago and continues to evolve. I
believe in two more years, China's
public opinion will look different
still. Thank you so much for watching.
If you find this video helpful, please
like it, drop a comment below, and hit
the subscribe button right here. It
really helps YouTube suggest my video to
others. I'll be back with more content
soon. Until then, be well.