Lee Smolin - Is the Universe Fine-Tuned for Life and Mind?

Truth exists
11 followers
Lee, the whole issue of the fine-tuning of the universe has become quite hot in recent decades.
Theologians talk about it, and physicists have perhaps reacted to that,
and now we have multiple universes.
Physicists, philosophers, theologians, all kind of mixed up in this.
How do you see it as a physicist looking at the issue of fine-tuning, and how do we explain it?
First, fine-tuning seems right.
Real?
Real. That is, as far as we know, Einstein's great question,
did God have any choice in the creation of the universe?
To the extent that we understand the fundamental laws, there was a choice.
We don't know any reason why the parameters of the Standard Model,
at least most of them, cannot be tuned,
and tuned to values where there would be no long-lived stars,
no many stable nuclei, and clearly no life.
It seems very easy to do, to tune any of these parameters to where there's no stars, no galaxies, no life.
I like to talk about the anthropic observation.
This is an observation that's been made,
and unless we have stuff drastically wrong, I think it's right.
Then the question is, what's the explanation?
This becomes part of the question of why these laws are not other laws.
It requires explanation.
So what could possibly be the explanation?
One is a fundamental theory, which can only come out this way,
in which case we should all become mystics,
that somehow the mathematics that enforces the consistency
creates exactly a universe which has 100 stable nuclei, roughly, long-lived stars, etc.
We should become mystics.
Then there's the strong anthropic principle, which is a religious view.
George Ellis' view, somebody that I respect because he's out front about it.
God made the universe so that there would be intelligent beings
who would realize there was this conundrum,
realize that the only answer could have been
that there was a God who made the universe so that we would exist,
so that rationally we would come to know his work and love him.
This is what George Ellis says.
And because it's out front, I respect it.
I don't think it's science, but I respect it.
Then there's the weak anthropic principle,
what the cosmologists, Martin Rees and so forth,
people that I respect, but I think that they're mistaken
because it's not science, in my view.
And in my view, every claim that the anthropic principle
has consequences for science rests on a logical fallacy.
I mean, there's this claim that Hoyle's argument,
which maybe you've heard about, that...
And Weinberg putting a bound on the cosmological concept.
They all have a logical fallacy in them.
If you like, I can tell you. It's very simple.
Here's their argument.
Carbon is essential for life.
In fact, the universe has lots of carbon in it.
Carbon could only have been made in certain processes and stars.
Therefore, there must be a certain reaction,
which Hoyle then predicted, and it was looked for,
a certain nuclear reaction, and it was seen.
What's the fallacy?
The first line of the argument,
that carbon is necessary for life,
plays no role in the argument.
The actual logical structure of the argument
is we observe carbon to exist in plentiful amounts.
Therefore, it must have been made.
Therefore, there must have been a process that makes it.
And in my reading, in all the cases
where some power is claimed for the anthropic principle,
there's a fallacy.
And so my sense...
You're saying it has no predictability.
It has no predictive power and no explanatory power.
Right, and therefore you're saying it's not science.
But that doesn't mean it's not true.
You may not like it or it may not be science,
but that doesn't ipso facto mean it's not true.
Yeah, so one way to say this is that
maybe the parameters of the Standard Model,
the masses of the particles and so forth,
move from the column of necessary truth
that science has to explain is necessarily true
to contingent truth, to aspects of the environment.
And maybe there are different environments
differently in different parts of the universe.
And we happen to live where we can.
So I think that's a...
If your first category is there's one absolute law,
second category is there's some intelligent designer,
which people are upfront about,
and the third is that there are multiple replications,
which is the multi-universe.
I think what you're saying is that maybe
those multiple replications are in the same universe
in different places or over different times
and either evolve temporally or spatially in some way.
But isn't it the same principle?
Either you generate it from many universes
or you generate it sequentially?
But before we go there,
should I tell you what I really think?
Yeah, I'd love to know.
Because yes, it might be true that
what it would mean if the scenario
in which there are these many independent universes
and the parameters are randomly distributed,
we live where we can live,
is that our explanation has come to an end.
There are things about the universe
that we cannot more deeply understand.
We can't understand why the electron is the mass it is.
There's no rational explanation
of the kind that we're used to in science
that leads to further predictions that we can check.
Maybe that's true, but it seems to me
it's way premature to give up.
So what I think about when I think about this
is first of all I look for an alternative.
Yeah, that's good.
I look for an alternative.
The place I look is following, as I was saying
when we were talking before,
the methodology of natural selection.
Because the biologists have shown
that you can answer questions like this
in a way that's predictive
using the methodology of natural selection.
And we could talk about why that is.
And then I wonder
what is the attraction
of the anthropic principle?
I have great respect for Martin,
Andre Linde,
Lenny Suskin,
these are my heroes, Steve Weinberg,
but I really want to ask them
what's the attraction of it for them
at this place and time?
And here's what I think, what I really think.
This is going outside of science.
What I really think is that
we have a bifurcation here
in the history of science.
Either we have to give up the view
that what we're looking for is something
which is timeless
and think that really
everything evolves
including possibly the laws.
And so the barrier
between physics and natural history
will break down.
Or
we have to make the following move.
We have to say
the world that we observe
which has all this evidence for change
and for even the laws changing
is
the wrong conclusion
because we just see a tiny piece of reality
and we invent an unobservable
much larger reality
which however, since we
invent it, can be timeless.
And we move the focus
from the ever-evolving world that we can see
to an imaginary
positive timeless world
in which we can talk
about probability distributions
and
apply the anthropic principle
in a timeless way.
So I think that the attraction
and the addiction to the idea
that what we're looking for is fundamentally timeless
is leading people
to prefer
imaginary
multi-universes.
I'm not talking about what's true.
Maybe they're right. Maybe I'm wrong.
I understand the methodology.
But it still seems to me that the methodology you're talking about
is very similar philosophically
because what you need to do is you need to solve
the fine-tuning problem. But everybody needs to do that.
That's where we all start.
We need to solve that.
And you and many people
are increasingly believed that
we're not going to solve it with one ultimate
theory
from which it's derived
unambiguously.
Although it would be wonderful if somehow
it was man-driven.
Steven Weinberg said the same thing. He would love it to be.
He just doesn't see it.
So now we have that situation.
We have to generate, therefore, a whole series
of different combinations
so that one of which can be
self-selecting
by our pick.
Guys generate it through a multi-universe.
Forgetting the physics. I'm just talking about the philosophy.
You're generating it through a natural selection
temporally or geographically
within the same spatial
space-time continuum.
Philosophically,
it's the same.
Here's what I think is different.
I think there's a different
understanding and attitude towards
the most fundamental issue
of all, which is time.
In the direction
that of
eternal inflation
and those kind of multiverses,
what they're
timeless reality.
What's most fundamental is the
probability distribution of different properties
amongst multi-universes,
which is static, doesn't change in time.
Time is only...
My colleagues believe that time is some
illusion which is emergent in some
situations at some scale, but it's
not fundamentally. Fundamentally, the universe
is timeless. I think they're
in the thralls of what I like to call
the nostalgia for the absolute.
This timeless absolute.
I think that
the other branch, the other
direction, leads to
thinking that time is
even more fundamental than we expected
before. Maybe
time is the only thing
that doesn't emerge.
Maybe space is emergent, maybe the
properties of elementary particles are emergent.
Again, in the sense of the condensed matter physicist,
in the sense of the biologist,
that it's properties of collections
of things that are not properties of things
which are smaller. A lot could be
emergent, but maybe time is not
emergent. And if time is the most fundamental
thing, then
you end up... I mean,
philosophically, I end up
with a very different...
looking for a very
different kind of explanation
in which
evolution through time, change,
causality, is
the key
actor in the explanation
as opposed to
pull back the focus
large enough and
nothing is changing.
My point again is that
what you're both doing at the same
time is trying to figure out
a mechanism to generate many different
snapshots
of the fundamental
laws of physics and the constant, so you can
get one that suits our world.
Everybody's trying to figure out
broad enough numbers
so you don't need some
intelligent designer. No, no, sure.
And my belief
is that if this
is to remain science, we have to do it
in a way that leads to predictions
that are checkable, that are falsifiable.
And my
understanding...
So you get the metaphor. One is you pull back
the focus and time goes away.
And everything becomes probabilities.
The other is you
extend the focus, not in
space, but going back in time.
The bottom line
is that through cosmological
natural selection, there are
predictions which are falsifiable.
And through eternal inflation, there are no
predictions which are falsifiable.
My understanding is that that's
not an accident. It's
because the methodology of
natural selection narrows
probability distributions,
gets you very, very far from
averages, from equilibrium,
gets you to structure
for the same reason that in biology
processes in time make structure,
make things that are more and more improbable,
means things are more and more checkable.
They're more and more
improbable things. The fact that you find
the same protein over
thousands of species doing
different things is highly improbable
but a consequence of natural selection.
So my sense is
that in the same way, natural selection
will generate things
which are true but improbable.
And that's how we're going to recognize
its action.
