Black vs Chocolate Labrador Retrievers - is one REALLY better than the other? Surprisingly the coat color differences might be more than fur deep. I dive into their diverging histories, and what impact this has had on our modern pet labradors.
Find out everything you ever wanted to know about the amazing Labrador Retriever at https://thelabradorsite.com
If you'd like to check out the scientific studies I mention in this video they include:
Lofgren et al, Management and personality in Labrador Retriever dogs, Applied Animal Behavior Science, 2014. Van Rooy & Wade, Association between coat color and the behavior of Australian Labrador retrievers, Canine Genetics & Epidemiology, 2019. Pugh et al, Dogslife: a cohort study of Labrador retrievers in the UK, Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 2015. McGreevy et al, Labrador retrievers under primary veterinary care in the UK: demography, mortality and disorders, Canine Genetics and Epidemiology, 2018. Raffan et al, A Deletion in the Canine POMC Gene Is Associated with Weight and Appetite in Obesity-Prone Labrador Retriever Dogs, Cell Metabolism, 2016.
Black and chocolate coated Labradors both have plenty of admirers, but it might surprise
you to find out there's more to these gorgeous coats than just colour.
These equally beautiful dogs haven't always been appreciated on the same level.
In fact, for a good chunk of Labrador history, one colour was definitely, and quite horrendously,
the preferred pick.
And it's not just about history, today I'll be digging into the real differences beyond
appearance.
So whether you're a die-hard Black Lab fan, a lover of luscious chocolate coats, or simply
curious about these incredible dogs, stick around, we're about to uncover some surprising
stuff.
Chocolate Labradors and Black Labradors obviously both belong to the same breed, the Labrador
Retriever, which means they have the same ancestry and a lot of shared history.
But they haven't always been considered equal.
In fact, from the inception of the Labrador breed in the early 1800s all the way through
to the 1960s, Black Labs were much more desirable.
Chocolate Lab puppies, or liver as they were known at the time, were frequently culled
at birth, which seems shocking to us as modern dogs.
It's not clear if there was ever even any reasoning for this, besides a strong preference
for the look of the Black Dogs.
Then in the mid-20th century, Chocolate Labs started to appear in things like field trials
and at dog shows, and gradually, fortunately, their popularity started to rise.
These days both colours are popular as working dogs, show dogs, and obviously family pets.
However, the number of new Black Lab puppies every year is still consistently much higher
than the number of Chocolate Lab puppies.
And that's because black is a dominant genetic coat colour in the breed, so they're much
more commonly found.
Chocolate Labs have a recessive genetic, so each parent needs to carry the potential for
this trait for the brown colour to overpower the default black.
You can get both American and English Labs in black or brown shades, but most Chocolate
Labs have at least some show breeding in their lineage, as this is where the colour first
rose to popularity.
For this reason, lots of Chocolate Labradors have a stockier build than their Black Lab
cousins.
All Labradors are medium-large athletic dogs with handsome features and a dense double
coat.
Black Labs obviously have black fur, and Chocolate Labs have a fur that ranges from a sort of
mahogany to a deep dark brown.
In either colour, a small patch of white on the chest is okay, and Black Labs have black
noses and eye rims, and mid-to-dark brown eyes, whereas Chocolate Labs have brown noses
and eye rims, and light brown or hazel eyes.
Although all Labs weigh between 55 to 80 pounds, one UK study found that the Chocolate Labradors
weighed on average about three pounds more than the Black or Yellow Labradors.
But the biggest determiner of a Labrador's size and looks is their sex and whether they
come from show or working lines.
Male Labs are typically bigger than females, and Show Labradors, also known as the English
type, are shorter and stockier than the working ones.
Show Labradors are also more likely to still sport that famous Labrador otter tail.
So what about personality?
Do the differences between Black and Chocolate Labradors go any further than fur deep?
While it's a hotly contested topic, historically one of the reasons Chocolate Labs were less
popular as working dogs is because they were recorded as less intelligent and too boisterous.
Stereotypes like this have the potential to become self-fulfilling prophecies, with breeders
starting to focus on producing litters that aren't black and bred specifically for work.
So what does the research say?
Well in 2014, researchers at the Edinburgh University surveyed owners of nearly 2,000
Labradors in the UK.
They reported Chocolate Labs were noisier, more likely to become agitated when ignored,
and more excitable than black dogs.
But on the other hand, a 2019 survey of 225 Labradors in Australia didn't find any evidence
at all that Chocolate Labs were more likely to be hyperactive or aggressive.
In many ways, the results raise more questions than they answer.
Is one study right and one wrong?
Are both right, but the link between colour and temperament is only established in breeding
lines in some countries?
Or is this link a result of other factors, like Chocolate and Black Labs being raised
differently?
Perhaps Black Labs are more likely to be destined for field work, for example?
Respondents to both the British and Australian surveys were also asked to give a measure
of their lab's trainability.
In both sets of results, Chocolate Labs were regarded as less trainable than Black Labs.
And what's more, according to the Australian study, Black Labs who carried the brown coat
gene but didn't express it, were also perceived as less trainable.
This is interesting because it supports the idea that trainability may have a genetic
component which linked to the gene for the brown coat colour, and discernible even when
the trainer doesn't know that the gene is present.
So is this bad news for Chocolate Labs?
Well, it's important to appreciate that Chocolate Labs are still very intelligent
dogs who respond well to positive reinforcement training.
And what we can't tell from the studies is the background of the human trainers behind
the dogs.
For example, someone who works their lab or participates in field trials will have a much
higher training expectation than a family who keep their dog as a pet.
When it comes to choosing between a Chocolate or a Black Labrador as a pet, even reach the
level of training where any difference in ability ever becomes apparent anyway.
What about health?
Well, in the UK, a 2018 study of Labrador life expectancy reported that Chocolate Labradors
have a shorter-than-average lifespan.
It was, in fact, quite significant in that particular study, with Chocolate Labradors
showing 10.7-year lifespan compared to 12.1 for the other colours.
However, the researchers couldn't speculate whether that applies to Labradors in other
countries too.
In the UK as well, a review of veterinary records of 2,074 labs also found that Chocolate
Labradors were more likely to experience ear infections and hot spots than Black or Yellow
Labradors.
However, they found them less associated with the POMC gene, which is linked to excessive
appetite.
In terms of exercise, Chocolate and Black Labs are perfectly matched.
Their energy levels will hinge much more on the breathing lines than their coat colour.
Labs from working lines tend to be more driven and motivated to work, and they might need
more daily exercise before they're ready to relax at home.
Whereas English Labs can be more content to go with the flow, and, dare I say it, a little
more sedentary.
So does that mean one colour makes a better pet than the other?
Well, any colour of Labrador can be the perfect pet in the right home, and we're fortunate
that Labrador's popularity means that we have more evidence about the effect of coat colour
than any other dog breed, but there are still lots of missing pieces in the research.
It's possible that Chocolate and Black Labradors may have slightly different temperaments,
and potentially that Chocolate Labradors might have slightly worse health or a shorter lifespan
compared to Black Labs.
But it's not clear how much these differences are a result of having been rather neglected
and out of favour for most of Labrador history.
Chocolate Labs are just as loving and loyal as Black Labs, so it's possible that with
as much attention to breeding for health and personality, they too could be just as long-lived
and trainable.
Only time will tell.
But what do you think?
Do you agree with the differences between Chocolate and Black Labs in the surveys that
we've looked at today?
What's your own experience?
Let us know in the comments section, and if you want to find out more about the wonderful
Labrador Retriever, then pop over to the Labrador site.