The Conservator, The Apprentice, and The Problem Part 3

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
1 Video View·Aug 8, 2025
Aug 1, 2022
The first 1,000 people to use the link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: https://skl.sh/baumgartnerrestoration...
--
The arrival of a large, complicated and possibly important painting to the studio was a perfect opportunity to introduce a young conservation apprentice to the highs and lows of working with problematic paintings.
--
Support me on Patreon
/ baumgartnerrestoration
Official Baumgartner Merchandise
https://teespring.com/stores/bfars-store
Follow me on
Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration
Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration
How this content was made
Support for this video comes from Skillshare, which offers thousands of inspiring classes
for creative and curious people on topics including illustration, design, photography,
video, freelancing, and more.
Moment of truth.
Hopefully we used the correct side and we didn't glue this to the painting.
See how flat it is?
And you can really tell the benefit of shaving off the back.
Yeah, there's no groove.
There's no groove.
There's no bump.
Now obviously there's still a little bit, you can see where like the stitching is, but
that was always there.
So this is going to catch the light much less than it was before.
So that's really a critical improvement.
It's also much more stable.
But just as good as the seam is, if you come over here, you can see areas that don't look
good.
Yeah.
These are the areas where there were tears and the massive amount of overpainting that
was just kind of layered on top of the painting.
This is now standing proud because the canvas is flat.
So this was depressed beforehand and now it's been raised up.
So this is all going to have to get removed.
You can see it kind of really bad.
Yeah, it catches the light and it really draws your eye to it.
I mean, aside from the color being totally wrong, the texture is wrong.
And that's one thing that whoever did this work just wasn't conscious of.
So you know, we'll take the win on the seam, but we're definitely going to have our work
cut out for us here.
Just lift it off like this.
Got it?
Yep.
All right.
Let your side down like that.
All right.
And then we'll swing around and watch out for the edges of the table.
There we go.
Perfect.
Look at how bright this painting is going to be once all the grime and the varnish is
removed.
Like all this little, these bright areas coming through here, all of that varnish coming off,
it's going to be such a different painting.
And that all got like pulled off because of the washi kozo, right?
Because...
Yeah.
So clearly the varnish bond with the painting was weaker than the fish gelatin and kozo
bond with the varnish.
And so when we pulled off that washi kozo, yeah, a lot of the surface grime came off.
Kind of that gray sooty stuff that we saw last time.
But also some of the varnish just came off.
And that's probably because the varnish is deteriorated.
It's really oxidized and polar.
So the bond with the paint is kind of failed and the bond with the fish gelatin was really
strong and fresh.
So pulling it off, we kind of get a little sneak peek at what it's going to look like.
So let's see what we got.
So there are a lot of areas that we have to test and a lot of painting that we're going
to have to figure out how to clean.
And so I have a whole bunch of different solutions, solvents, detergents, soaps.
Where do you think we should start with this?
What do you think would be the best area to test first?
I personally like testing on an area with a high concentration of white for a couple
of reasons.
One, we generally know what white is going to look like.
It's going to be white, bright.
We're testing, you're going to go with like a variety, you said solvents, soaps, gels.
I mean, you said you have your suspicions about which one's going to be successful,
but why do you just try to break it up between the three different realms of cleaners?
We have three different things we have to remove from this painting.
So first we have the accumulated surface grime, which the washi kozo and fish skeleton pulled
up some.
Then we have the varnish.
And then we have the overpainting.
And those are each going to take unique approaches and a different suite of materials to remove.
What removes the accumulated surface grime will not remove the varnish.
And what removes the overpaint will not remove the accumulated surface grime.
So we really do have to break it up into stages.
And it may take two stages, four stages.
It may take six rounds of cleaning to get this completely cleaned.
And that really just depends on kind of the layering of what's on the painting.
So that's why we have to do all these tests and investigate.
We can't just, you know, get a mop and do it in one fell swoop.
Not yet.
I mean, as much as I would like to do that, particularly for big paintings like that,
you have to start small and with precision so that you know what you're doing.
So I'm going to just start putting on some different detergents to see about the surface
grime.
Based on how you're agitating it, will you kind of go, oh, it's not really working, or
are you going to let it sit for a while longer?
You know, surface grime is generally pretty receptive to coming off.
It doesn't take a ton of agitation.
A little bit helps, but this painting, I don't think that this painting is incredibly dirty.
We've seen some in the studio that have been in bars that just like...
They smell like beer.
That's right.
They smell like beer and cigarettes.
Those are dirty.
And in those cases, this step would be really impactful.
But here it's not taking a ton off.
So now I'm switching to free solvents.
I've tested out some of the detergents, and the paint layer looks pretty stable, so I'm
moving to free solvents.
And these are solvent mixtures that, yeah, they act a little bit quicker, but I can feel
the varnish starting to soften and break down.
I can actually feel the difference when I'm rubbing on the varnish.
It's a really smooth, plastic-y feel.
Very slick.
You can even hear the difference, too.
You've got to get really close, but...
Yeah.
There's much more friction.
Yeah.
There's more friction, and so it makes a little bit more noise.
And the other thing that I can't explain is that you can smell it.
You can smell when the varnish has started to soften up and is swollen with the solvent
because it has a different smell.
And so you use all of these senses to gather the data points, and you can write them down.
You can keep them in your head.
It doesn't matter.
But you use them to inform what you're going to do, and then you remember them when you're
working.
Well, where would you like to test?
Oh.
Well...
I mean, I'm very curious about the red, because it is such a center point, and in my experience,
red is always a little bit...
Red is a little bit more fugitive, but we can go ahead and test it.
I mean, you have to learn this stuff, so...
The table is yours.
Okay.
No pressure.
So just like the previous spot, it's taking off a little bit of surface grime, but not
a ton.
So it would be perfectly fine to switch to...
This one?
Yeah.
To go to this one and see if this one, which did start to take off some of the varnish
over here, if it's going to do the same thing here.
And we know that it's not completely effective, but we're still taking an incremental approach
because we don't know about the colors underneath.
Right.
So what was your thought on that?
It worked better than the previous detergent, but feeling it, it feels slightly different
from area to area, but I don't think it's all the way through yet.
Yeah, I think you're right.
I think there's still a pretty thick layer of varnish on there.
So we'll go with now some free solvents.
So what's your assessment of the stability of the red and green?
I mean, it's very stable.
It's still pulling up varnish.
I haven't pulled up any red or green.
Yeah, that's great.
So that's good.
Yeah, no, that's great.
I mean, that's exactly what we want.
Predictable, a potential problem color has revealed itself to not be a problem.
So we're two for two now.
Now we need to take a look at some of this overpainting.
So I'm going to use three different solvent gels.
And here I am using the gel because I want the extended exposure.
I know that the free solvents aren't going to last long enough.
But based on the age of this, I mean, I will try to be optimistic, but experience sometimes
leads me to be pessimistic.
Realistic.
Realistic, yeah, maybe that's a better word, that this potentially could be very, very
difficult.
And you talked about manual means of removing it.
What does that look like?
Just take it in the back and hit the chop saw?
Yeah, you know, belt sander, sandblaster.
It looks like scraping.
Scalpel, dental tools, anything that we can use to break up or remove this physical layer
from what's underneath.
I am seeing some of the overpaint come off, right?
You can see it on the swab and you can see it here.
What it's revealing is this other layer underneath, which I suspect is white lead mixed with maybe
some red to make it this kind of pinkish color.
And white lead paint is just profoundly difficult to remove.
All of the things that make the white a stable place to test are now working against us here.
So I'm just going to try to manually chip down to the base layer to see how much there's
there and what we have.
You can see this color right here, that's the original paint layer.
And all of this pinkish stuff has just been gooped on over it.
I mean, this is not retouching, this is overpainting, this is the worst of the worst.
And so you can see that there's original paint under here.
That's what we want to get to.
What we can hope for and pray for is that this overpainting was applied on a dirty painting,
either surface grime or old varnish.
And those can act as a release layer that maybe this overpaint is bonded to a layer
of varnish or just grime that isn't really well bonded to the painting.
And so the tension that the scalpel puts on it will break that bond and chip it up.
I mean, we are now into the hoping and praying.
We're getting really optimistic.
Well, I mean, when faced with daunting odds, you either have to lean into optimism or go home.
And it's only noon, so.
But I mean, this is effective.
I mean, I can get it off.
It's not going to be fast.
So a mixed bag, right?
We found a way to effectively get the varnish off safely, which is great.
But we're running into some real problems with the retouching.
If I'm being optimistic, luckily, it is just areas that have retouching.
By and large, most of the painting is free of it.
So it will be areas of concentrated pain for us.
But we do have a solution.
As difficult as it is and as slow as it may be, we can affect positive change.
We can get this off.
Now, it's just a matter of us rolling up our sleeves and getting to work.
I didn't bring sleeves this week.
Oh, boy.
Well, then everything's a loss for us.
You know, as I spend more and more time in the studio with Kit,
trying to teach her conservation and business and all sorts of stuff,
it has become readily apparent to me just how hard it is to not only teach somebody,
but to learn as well.
I mean, Kit is good, but this is hard.
And of course, it takes me back to when I was in Kit's situation with my father
trying to learn conservation.
Now, my dad had this idea that if he just showed it to me,
I would just learn it.
I'd understand how to do the work and also why.
But of course, I didn't, because that's absurd.
And so I'd ask him questions about the technical aspect and about the why.
And he would get all flustered and yell at me and say,
I just showed it to you.
Can't you just learn it?
You know, learning is hard.
And when you're a kid, it kind of feels natural.
But as you get older, it gets really hard.
And even though I've been doing this for over two decades,
there is still plenty I don't know and tons for me to learn.
And as I teach myself new things, it feels really good.
Adding a tool to your toolbox broadens your horizons.
It makes you more capable.
It makes you more confident, too.
But luckily for me now, when I need to learn new things,
I don't have to rely upon a grumpy old Swiss man who
doesn't speak English very well and has the patience of an aunt.
Lucky for me, there's Skillshare.
For example, when I was building the clampinator, that huge clamping
table for panel paintings, I needed to learn how to 3D print.
So I turned to Lauren Slowik and her class, Introduction to 3D Printing,
An Easy Start to Your First 3D Design.
And I taught myself 3D printing.
But before that, when I started creating these videos,
I needed to learn about digital cameras.
So I turned to Adi Singh and his class, Learn Camera Basics for Videos,
A Beginner's Guide.
And then I had all this video I needed to edit.
So I turned to Video Editing with Final Cut Pro,
From Beginner to YouTuber, with Ali Abdaal.
And when I needed to learn how to do some upholstery for the Porsche
that's sitting in the back of my studio, tempting me to not actually do work,
I turned to How to Sew, How to Use a Sewing Machine and Tools by Jane Hassler.
But I don't only turn to Skillshare when I need a new skill.
Sometimes I just want one.
And when dealing with my kids and trying to teach them how to be creative
and let go of their inhibitions, Skillshare was there too,
with Start Drawing, three fun freeing exercises
to spark your creativity with Carly Coon.
So whether it's a need or a want, Skillshare has you covered.
Adding tools or just teaching you how to spark your creativity.
They're going to give you a free month, so you have nothing to lose.
The first 1,000 people to use the link on my description box or my code
will get a one-month free trial of Skillshare.
After making some more tests, I did end up deciding to use a gelled solvent.
I found that the free solvents were evaporating too quickly
to have a real effect on this painting.
You can see how much work it's going to take to remove this heavy,
heavy coating of varnish using a swab and free solvent.
And while using a free solvent is fine, sometimes the amount of abrasion
or working or agitating that one needs to do is borderline too much.
And that's when turning to a gelled solvent may be appropriate.
You see, the gelled solvent just gets painted on the surface.
And in a few minutes or seconds, depending on its efficacy and the varnish,
it can be lifted off with the swab.
And I don't have to scrub the paint layer.
Now, obviously, some parts of this varnish are still sticking in the impasto.
And those will have to be removed manually later.
But for right now, on the first pass,
I'm really just trying to get off as much varnish as I can as quickly as I can.
And in this case, switching to the gelled solvent was the right choice.
In just a matter of seconds, I have done what would have taken minutes with the free solvents.
And so the process is fairly simple.
Apply the gelled solvent, agitate it a little bit with the brush,
and come back and remove it.
And as always, I'm choosing to work in a defined object.
And that definition is created by the artist himself.
In this case, it's one of the wings.
And I'm staying in this wing because it is mostly white.
It is one pigment.
The surrounding colors are different.
And those paints may have different properties.
So by sticking to one area, I can ensure not only a more controlled cleaning,
but I can limit the chance that the gelled solvent,
or any solvent that I may be using, will be too aggressive or harm the painting.
There's a lot of painting to clean here.
And this one little cherub is going to take nearly an hour just to remove all of this old varnish.
There are a lot of cherubs.
There is a lot of surface area.
And as much as I wish I could take a big mop and just put this gelled solvent over the whole thing,
and then take a big old cloth and wipe it off, you just can't.
You may have to change your solvent.
You have to change the timing of solvent exposure.
And in working small, you can do that.
If you work too big, you may find yourself chasing yourself.
And that's never a good situation.
But one thing that is really fun about cleaning a painting in small sections
is the slow revelation of what the painting should look like.
Here, there are even some purples and pinks.
The skin is really delicate and beautiful.
None of that was visible under this old varnish.
It was so yellow, almost brown.
And it also just obfuscated some of the details and the sensitive brushwork that the artist created.
It was also hiding a lot of overpainting and poor retouching,
some of which is becoming clearer as we remove the old varnish.
And that is something that we're going to have to deal with later.
But for now, I am just reveling in seeing these colors,
in seeing the artist's fingerprint, their style, manifest in paint.
It's quite a sight to behold.
Where the solvents weren't able to get the varnish out of the little crevices in the impasto,
I can turn to dental tools and carefully work, pick, scrape, chip,
all of that embedded varnish and grime out.
It's slow going, but that's the way it has to be done.
And then, well, maybe we should just do it.
And the first step is to fill in the areas of paint loss.
Throughout the painting, there are tears, holes,
gouges, chips, and other areas where paint has flaked off.
And we need to create a receptive surface for the retouching.
Not only because if we just retouch over these divots, we'll see the textural difference,
but also the retouching needs something to stick to.
And this fill-in medium is that something.
So I will overfill the areas.
And I'm not terribly concerned about how much I use here.
The main goal is to fill in all of the little voids, including along the seam.
And Kit and I will work meticulously,
going over all of the areas of the painting where we find it's necessary.
And in some spots, I'll have to use a larger palette knife because the area of loss was larger.
Again, I'm not terribly concerned about overfilling.
I can always remove this fill-in medium with a little bit of water
or a little bit of water and solvent mixed together.
And after a few final passes, we will have completed this step.
And then we wait.
But while we're waiting for the fill-in medium to dry,
we can turn our attention to the stretcher.
Because of course, we will need this in a little bit.
And the first thing we want to do is remove this label from the stretcher manufacturer.
It may not necessarily be important to anybody,
but we still want to preserve it.
That's part of conservation.
Kit is using a brush with some water and saturating the paper.
The water will penetrate through and under the paper,
and a piece of film will prevent the evaporation.
And once it's had enough time to work on the animal glue, most likely rabbit skin,
Kit can slowly and very carefully remove this paper.
Now, the interesting thing is that paper, even when fully saturated,
isn't going to disintegrate.
It still has structure.
So we can lift it off.
We just have to be careful.
Now, there is some typing on the back, which is novel,
but not of great importance right now.
What we want to do is make sure that it dries flat.
So onto some release film, a blotter, and some weights.
Once the fill-in medium has had enough time to dry,
Kit and I can begin the ever-so-wonderful process
of removing all of that fill-in medium.
And we'll start with swabs,
and go over it with the swabs and some water,
and then our hands to try to rub off, lift off,
and, well, generally remove the excess.
Now, certainly there is an argument to be made
about not filling it over with excess,
and having this step go easier.
But this is actually pretty easy,
and it would take more time to not overfill.
Now, in some areas where the fill-in was large,
I can use a dampened piece of wool felt as a buffing pad,
and I can go over it and remove it and flatten it.
It's effectively the same thing as sandpaper,
but the wool won't scratch the surface of the painting
as would an abrasive sandpaper.
And then, once I've removed all of the excess,
I can go over the painting one more time
to clean off any residual fill-in medium
and get a better idea of what it looks like.
Of course, we have to stretch this painting,
and it's going on the original support.
After talking with the client,
we decided, in an effort to keep costs down,
and because this support was fine,
we didn't need to replace it.
The addition of the interleaf also makes using this support,
which may be slightly undersized, possible
because the canvas isn't going to be prone to flexing.
Now, if we didn't do the interleaf,
I probably would have suggested using a larger stretcher,
something with more weight or more crossbars
to better support the painting.
Now, the tacking procedure for a big painting
is the same as for a little painting,
except I'm using slightly heavier weight tacks here
because the painting is larger
and just because I want to make sure
that there is a really good bond.
Also, using heavier tacks
means that I have to use less of them,
which I think is better.
I don't want to put a tack every half inch.
I'd rather put them every inch and a half.
That's a distance that I've found that works
in most paintings.
Now, even though this painting has an interleaf,
I'm not really stretching it.
I'm still going to take the same approach
and tack the center of each end.
This will make sure that the center of the painting
is as taut as possible and stable,
and then I can work towards the corners on each side.
And because this is a big painting
and because Kit has never seen this before,
I'm going to take a mouthful of tacks and spit them.
This approach is something that was adopted
from upholsterers who,
needing to work in tight areas and work fast,
would spit the tacks
because they are readily available in their cheek
and, well, it's fast.
And that helps when you're working
on a really big painting.
Now, once I've done the two long sides,
I will turn my attention to the shorter sides
and repeat the process as before,
making sure that I cover all of the area,
evenly distributing these tacks,
and trying not to land myself in the emergency room.
I have switched over to a tray of tacks,
which is possible because they are easily reached,
whereas before I couldn't quite get to them,
hence needing to spit the tacks.
And as I come to each corner,
I'm going to tuck and fold the canvas in.
This helps make a tight joint at the point of expansion.
When this stretcher is keyed out,
this area will receive the most tension
and having two layers of canvas without any seam here
is really beneficial to making sure
that the canvas doesn't fray or separate.
And also, it just makes a really tight joint.
And then we can flip it over
and start finishing up the back,
an important area that almost nobody ever sees
or really makes mention of,
but it's still pretty important.
There is all this excess canvas
that we need to trim down and tack.
And using a much lighter weight tack,
Kit and I can go across and deal with this excess material.
Let's see who wins.
Spoiler, I do.
I've been doing this 20 plus years.
Come on.
And finally, the keys go into the corners.
Now, even though this is a stretcher,
the painting doesn't need to be keyed out
because it's got an interleaf.
It really can't be stretched.
But we still put keys in,
not only because they belong there,
but because they will help hold the stretcher together.
They'll take up any gaps in that mortise and tenon joint
and make sure it's tight.
And to make sure that we don't lose these keys in transit
or over time as the wood expands and contracts,
I've drilled holes in them.
I fed some fishing line through
and I've tied it and tacked it down.
This is going to make sure that if they come loose,
they stay put.
And finally, we need to mount that label
that we took off the stretcher.
Now, in preparing this on a piece of acid-free museum board,
Kit noticed that it didn't say stretcher,
but it said steecher.
And it said Leopold Steecher.
And through a bit of research,
we learned that Leopold Steecher
was the nephew of Charles or Karl Steecher,
a German-born painter who moved to Paris to study his craft
and then ended up in Wichita, Kansas,
where he was well-known for painting copies of masterworks
until his death in 1924.
It looks like I might need to have a conversation
with my client.
Hi, Larry?
Yep, it's Julian.
How are you?
No, no, I'm great.
I'm great.
Yeah, well, that's exactly why I'm calling.
I have an update on the progress
that we've made thus far on the painting.
And I would like to share some information
that we found while we were working on the piece.
And we'll learn about the results of that conversation
in the next episode.
