Why Going Directly to the Listing Agent Won't Save You Money

Hawaii Property Market
5 followers
1 Video View·Aug 7, 2025
🏡 Thinking about contacting the listing agent directly to save money on your Hawaii home purchase? Think again!
In this video, Real Broker reveal why going directly to the listing agent doesn't work the way most buyers think it will - and could actually cost you MORE money.
Chapters
0:00 Intro
1:17 Why buyers will not get a discount by going directly to the listing agent
3:10 What is a Buyer Representation Contract
13:42 the pitfalls of calling a agent on Zillow
Julie Ziemelis | RS-85062
808-785-2898
365 Hawaii Group
ΓEA⅃ Broker
[email protected]
Are you a home buyer and you think by going to the listing agent directly that you're going to
save money? It doesn't work that way. I'm Julie Zemelis and I'm Amber Lane. We're with 365 Hawaii
and Real Broker and we're going to explain to you what you can do instead.
Okay so why are we having this conversation with you guys right now? Well obviously we're in a
shifting market and what's happening is that there's a lot more buyers out there who are
seeing that the market's actually softening. So they think that they're going to get a deal not
just on the price but by going directly to the listing agent. And what we have found when that
happens is that it doesn't work the way that they think. So because we've been in a market where
affordability has been quite an issue and prices are high, buyers think that they can get a better
deal if they can cut out the buyer's agent and go straight to the listing agent and possibly get a
lesser price. And Julie has an interesting story about just that. Right so what's happened is that
we have a couple listings and specifically let me tell you a story. One of our partners is in a
position where she had an investor from California actually call her directly and basically demand
a discount on the house because he was coming directly to her. And I've heard from other buyers
and I've seen it happen that buyers think that somehow they're going to get two or three percent
off the basic price of the house because they've come to them directly. And let's talk about why
that doesn't work. It doesn't work that way and the reason why is because there's a lot of
liability involved in real estate and the seller nor the seller's agent nor the seller's brokerage
wants to take on all of that liability for both clients. What the ideal situation actually is
is that there is a seller's agent that's representing the seller and has the fiduciary
responsibility for the seller and that there is a buyer's agent for the buyer who has the buyer's
fiduciary responsibility. And that way it helps eliminate quite a bit of liability where both
agents are explaining to their client exactly what's going on in the transaction, the contracts,
what's in their best interest and negotiating on their behalf. And also just so you guys know
that because we also just did this a woman from the mainland we were about to work with her and
she hadn't actually called us yet first and she wanted to buy a farm land and so she contacted
the selling agent directly and the selling agent basically said do you have an agent that you're
working with already? And what I have found from some of my friends that are working in Kona is
that they say go get your buyer's agent. Go get someone. They'll tell you to go get an agent or
they'll connect you with an agent because they do not want to take on the liability of representing
two different clients. It's just it's not a good idea for anyone and that is why there is a seller's
agent and there is a buyer's agent. Right and also um I think because when I was first looking
at you know real estate I thought when they said I'm a great negotiator I thought they were
negotiating on the purchase price. There is more to negotiate you guys than the purchase price.
When you get your termite inspection, your property inspection, things come up and then
all of a sudden now you're negotiating repairs and you're negotiating roofing. So having your
buyer's agent completely separate than the seller's agent who's working for the seller
to be able to negotiate that for you that's where you're going to save some money. Okay so one thing
too that you know you pay us to have real estate licenses for is that what we have a thing is called
agency which is who is working for whom and one of the things that the National Association of
Realtors has put out you might have heard about it is called the buyer's representative agreement.
Now this has been around for a long time. This isn't just happened in the last year and a half
but um tell us a little bit you know because she's really awesome about telling you about this.
Tell us exactly kind of what the buyer's rep does and how does it work for sellers and buyers.
So some states do this mandatory. They practice this so you might be familiar with it. Hawaii has
been very lax with it. Now it's a requirement nationally across the board. Every state and every
agent has to do this. In order to show you any homes we have to have the buyer sign a written
contract the buyer's agreement so that it formalizes our relationship in writing and it has
us take the time to sit down and explain to you exactly how our relationship works. So it talks
about agency who's working for who. It lets us describe that to you. It talks about what dual
agency is which is when the agent is representing both the buyer and the seller so that you know
that what the responsibilities are there. It talks about the responsibilities of the agent. It talks
about the responsibilities of the client and then it also spells out things like compensation how
much we're getting paid and the time that we're representing you and some other little terms as
well. So one of the things that people think is that if they go directly to the seller's agent
that they'll get a lesser price a better deal but in the listing agreement where the seller's agent
is has a contract with a seller a lot of times they'll have compensation written in so if there's
a buyer that's coming in who doesn't have an agent they're asking for more money to to facilitate
that deal. That gives them a lot more work on their plate. They have to explain all the contracts to
you. They have to explain the timeline. They have to do more communication. They have to work with
your lender and your title company and you opening up the house for inspections and all the different
things and it's more liability. It's more liability for the agent more liability for the brokerage.
So you think that you're actually saving some money but it's actually that the seller's agent
is taking that money so instead of it going to a buyer's agent they're just taking more.
Yep and also just so you guys know that when you come in like that's called unrepresented buyer
and then if you come in with an agent it's it's it's basically a buyer's I mean so it's like it's
two different things you can come in without an agent and it's called unrepresented buyer
and then also a customer right um and so again when I've talked to a variety of eight of our
listing agents that see that company you're right the first thing they say is I don't want the extra
work. It is it now you're having to hold the home open for the extra work with the extra liability
and when you're supposed to be representing the seller selling their biggest asset and negotiating
on their behalf to get them the best price and the best terms to be able to work with a buyer
it's just it's tricky it's tricky we're talking about the most emotional investment of your life
there's so much emotions that come into it so you really need to have a neutral person who's not
emotionally tied to the this amount of money and shelter and your investment in your future
to be able to navigate such a touchy subject for people. I mean these are homes that people
maybe raise their families in or they've been in for 30 40 years spending families for generations
I mean so it's it's just a highly um volatile situation at times and um and for one agent to
be navigating both sides it gets really sticky really tricky and there's a lot of liability
involved and so most agents will absolutely not do it whatsoever um or they'll connect you with
another agent so that there there is someone that's representing the buyer right it's in the
best interest of everybody right and also um get this dual agency also can be people in the same
office yeah so dual agency is either like Julie representing both buyer and seller or it could be
Julie representing the buyer and Amber representing the seller because we are both that real broker
that's technically dual agency because you're actually the client of the brokerage not
necessarily the agent so when it's dual agency we're required to remain neutral in negotiations
so in that instance we would present you with the information the statistics the facts and you would
have to make the decision about the price that you want to ask or the credit you want to ask or
the negotiation part and then we would facilitate that for you but we would technically be representing
the best interest or we could not represent the interest of either client because they're both our
client right right and so if you're watching this and you're a seller and um I want you guys to also
realize what happens when this happens too is that um you might think okay well I'll just bring in
somebody and then my like my buddy and that way one person could just do both we have that going
on right now too um that's great if the two of you have already chosen a price and that you have an
as-is sale because you don't want to be negotiating on repairs and stuff so it can work in some
circumstances and that would basically the agent basically comes down basically does the paper and
that's so true I just had a transaction this past year it was a family that I've done several
transactions for and they this couple was actually buying their family's house they were already
living in it they'd been living in it for a while and the the aging parents were moving to a different
property and they were buying it from their family and they tried to do it on their own with an
attorney they spent a bunch of money with an attorney trying to do this and then they just
couldn't figure it out and and it's really interesting also because one of the mother-in-laws
is a realtor and it was even her that was like listen you guys really need to get a professional
involved in this to help you navigate this so I at that point um entered the scene that it was
kind of already in progress and I had to kind of take over and navigate the whole transaction
with them and in that case I represented the buyers and the the parents the sellers were
unrepresented and um you know we negotiated the commission accordingly for that but it was just
I it really affirmed the value of an agent because it was a it was a family transaction
something so easy it's seemingly easy and they still really needed the advice of a realtor and
someone really leading the way right and also um getting the actual price for the home because
yeah there was a big discrepancy yeah so here we go this is this is what's happening right now
um now that the these two people have said okay I'm gonna buy your house now this guy is looking
on Zillow and saying you know what I think it's really worth two hundred thousand dollars less
right and then they think that they're going to be able to do this by themselves it's like that's
another reason why you have a realtor right we know how to appraise a house either we get a
professional appraiser or we know how to run comps and it's not just looking down Zillow yeah
and so that's another thing too this this video is not exactly about the value of a realtor but
it kind of you can show you how it is that if you want to have less headaches less liability
right and you're thinking you're saving money but the long run that's not usually sometimes what
happens another thing I just want to say is that I've also had clients that contact the listing
agent directly um to go see a listing that they saw pop up and um because they didn't want to
bother me or because they wanted to make sure they saw it right away and you know they weren't
sure what my schedule would be but um please don't ever ever hesitate to contact your agent this is
what we do for a living if your agent is giving you a hard time maybe find another agent because
this is what we do for work this is this is our job so I am thrilled to show any house that you
want to see and um and it really is the way it works I think a lot of people don't understand
how realtors work and how we get paid and how this whole process goes but um you should have
an agent you should interview agents you should have an agent explain the buying process to you
and the market to you you should have a written formal agreement the buyer's representation
representation contract signed and then you should go out and see houses with that agent
and then when you find a house that you're ready to make an offer on that agent will
prepare the offer and at that time you're going to be quite versed in um how it all works because
that agent has been educating you all along the way right and you have a relationship with them
at that point as well right and you've sat down told you everything that they're going to do for
you yeah right hey so I just want to tell you guys a story and this is how we can like lead
into the buyer's rep agreement um we had this happen to us twice where um people were looking
at houses now this was like when the housing market was a little more on fire um and so what
they did was they were using two agents at the same time without telling each other
and they were saying basically to themselves whoever gets me a house first I'll go with them
and that is like you guys and then when I faced them on one time they said what I didn't know
that was bad well you guys can imagine the amount of time and effort that we put into showing houses
and being you know with all the stuff that's on top of you know keeping an eye on the market for
you so that's another reason why the buyer's agreement exists as well is that we know now
that you know that you're only working with one person and what's your thoughts yeah I think it's
it's common where you think you're working with one client you're showing them homes I've been
in a situation where I wrote six offers for a family during the unicorn market and in COVID
one of them being on my husband's birthday I spent all day writing an offer and getting it off
and then lo and behold I find out later they had contacted me and said they were going a different
direction and then I had found out directly after that conversation that they were already in escrow
for another house with another agent and it's a big backstab when something like that happens
because you're really working really hard for this client and doing everything you can to help them
get into a home and you you think you are representing them and they were actually working
with another agent for however long that was so that's also part of it is that you know that we're
trying to eliminate that from happening if for some reason you're not happy with your agent well
one please let us know I would love to do whatever I can to meet your expectations but also
it's the right thing to do right it's kind of like it's an ethics experience right it's
etiquette it's ethics yeah and also um don't you believe too there's the aloha spirit that exists
on this island and you know it's a small island and so doing that kind of stuff okay I have to
believe that these people in their hearts know that they're playing agents against one another
when they do the whole like you know I didn't know that was happening this is again why we
formalize these agreements right yes a lot of people don't realize this but most people are
looking on zillow zillow is like the number one place to look for homes obviously so when you hit
that contact an agent button button some people think that you're contacting the listing agent
directly that's not how it works there's realtors that pay zillow a lot of money in order to get
leads so you're getting connected with a random agent who's paying zillow to get leads and they're
meeting you at the house because again no one wants to have the seller doesn't want to represent
the seller's agent doesn't want to represent the buyer as well so um just so you know you're not
getting in touch with the listing agent and really what you should do instead if you see
that home on zillow is contact the agent that you already are working with that you have assigned
buyer's rep with and they are happy to show you that home we're at 365 hawaii we are a team we
work together if for some reason i'm not available to show something we have julie we have eric we
have someone that's going to cover you and make sure that you get to see that home and we are
very involved in the realtor community we're very involved in the local community here we have our
pulse on the market um we live and breathe real estate so if for some reason you're looking to
if you're looking to sell please get in touch with us we are happy to help you we would love
to be interviewed and julie take it away okay so actually actually i'll tell you too um i love the
fact that so many people actually call us directly and say i want to use you because of these youtube
channel videos that we do we give away so much information for free and we're real people we
tell you the real story we're going to tell you hey you know sign a buyer's agreement so um please
get in contact with us and also if you want to know more information subscribe to this real estate
channel and also uh ring the bell so you could actually get the notifications and also we have
our 365 hawaii re.com where you can actually go and look what's on the market directly right now
you'll get you know signed into our um our background um uh scrm you could say and i will
reach out to you directly if you are ready to go and we'll set up a zoom call um you can work with
amber you can work with eric you can work with me our team and we'll make sure that you are well
taken care of we have a ton of testimonials so that we actually know what we're doing and we do
it with aloha and finesse so with that we will say aloha
