Palau vs. Illegal Fishing: Protecting Sharks and the Oceans | Big Blue Wild 2020

Ocean Whispers
4 followers
#nature #animal
In 2009, Palau created a shark sanctuary that protects over 100 shark species. In 2014, they established the world's largest marine sanctuary, a no-take zone for foreign commercial fishing. But can Palau keep illegal fishing fleets at bay?
Palau, a small island nation in the west of the Pacific Ocean,
and home to one of the world's first shark sanctuaries.
A refuge against the brutal practice of predatory fishing.
Fishermen catch the sharks, cut the fins and throw them back in the water.
Pirates and unlicensed hunters still go around these waters,
encouraged by the international black market of restricted fish.
Now the war has begun.
Palau has entered a high-risk battle for the seas.
Retaining suspicious ships is no longer enough.
We will not release these ships just to be re-fueled with more crew,
more fuel, more equipment and go straight back to Palau
to continue catching our fish. We no longer tolerate that.
This is a challenge between Davi Golias, who will be able to determine
how the rest of the world will defend its threatened seas.
Blue immensity.
In the southwestern reef of the Palau archipelago,
at a diving point known as the Blue Corner, something rare begins to happen.
Hundreds of zanclues gather at the time of reproduction.
A ritual that can only be seen once a year,
usually on the days before the full moon of January.
Zanclues are a kind of reef fish.
They usually form large groups with 200 or 300 members each.
They all swim together along the reef, going and coming,
making very distinct movements.
It's a beautiful dance, beautiful to watch.
A beautiful dance that invites the predators.
White-clawed reef sharks approach the zanclues.
Generally, when large groups form at the time of reproduction,
this attracts many predators. It's a very clear sign for the predators.
When they start to notice a very large number of a certain fish,
a larger number of predators soon approaches as well.
It's as if someone had touched a sign calling them to lunch.
Yellow, white and black stripes distinguish each zanclue.
This makes it more difficult for a predator to understand
where the fish ends and another starts.
This defense method is known as disruptive coloring.
The white and elongated dorsal fins
also make the fish look bigger,
in order to discourage potential predators.
Even so, despite these defense mechanisms,
the zanclues become vulnerable during mating.
Few will survive the large number of predator attacks in the next few days.
This type of agglomeration is unusual,
even in Palau, where coral gardens
usually overflow with spectacular examples of marine life.
Palau is a set of more than 200 islands spread across the west of the Pacific
at approximately 1,600 km east of the Philippines.
Hundreds of kilometers of the blue ocean surround the archipelago.
Few places on this planet are as isolated as Palau.
The local population has approximately 20,000 inhabitants
scattered on different islands.
Most live in Coror, its main shopping center.
The entire country is only 500 square kilometers,
being smaller than the city of Chicago.
As there are very few industries generating pollution,
the waters of Palau are exceptionally clean.
More than half of the gross domestic product comes from tourism.
And among the most popular tourist destinations
are the mushroom-shaped rocky islands,
ancient relics among the coral reefs,
carved by the erosion caused by the waves
and covered with flowers in touch with the color of emerald.
But its greatest attraction is hidden at the bottom of these bright lagoons.
One of the richest reef ecosystems in the world.
This is home to 1,500 species of fish,
500 species of coral,
and more than 100 species of sharks and stingrays.
The Palau reefs house more coral fish and other invertebrates
per square kilometer than almost any other place on Earth.
And they are known as the Serengeti of the Seas.
As you can see, looking around here, we have a really beautiful landscape.
And our water is very, very clean,
because the mass of land closest to here is more than 1,000 kilometers,
which would be the Philippines.
Here too, it is not exactly the easiest place to get around the world.
So tourism is not so busy,
it never reaches the same level as a place like the Bahamas, for example.
So we can dive in crystal clear waters,
full of different fish, and usually with few divers.
A huge herd of gunfish parades through the reef,
feeding on zooplankton.
Three great ocean currents converge in Palau,
bringing species from the Indian and Pacific Oceans.
But the abundance of life around here is mainly due to marine geology.
Palau is located at the top of a submarine mountain
formed 70 million years ago.
That's why we have these beautiful scarps
coming down the sides of Palau.
So we have very deep moorings, and an incredible marine geology.
The water that comes from the depths is very cold and rich in nutrients,
which increases the fertility of the shallowest coral reefs,
and that attracts all this great diversity of marine animals.
We have pelagic fish, large herds of fish,
and some impressive shark species.
It's very rare to dive and not see a shark in Palau.
And then depending on where you are, what time of day,
and also what time of month,
we can sometimes see hundreds of sharks at one diving point.
But this paradise of predators has been fatal to many of them.
In the mid-1980s,
shark fishing in Palau became very popular,
driven by the great demand for shark barbatana soup,
a coveted symbol of wealth in some Asian countries.
For years, shark hunters wandered through these waters impunely.
Shark barbatana extraction is a predatory practice,
very destructive, which has been increasing
because of the demand for certain things, like shark barbatana soup.
And what happens is that the fishermen catch the sharks,
cut the barbatanas, and throw them back in the water,
usually still alive.
But without the barbatanas, the sharks cannot survive.
So this is very destructive.
They take just a piece of the shark,
but leave the rest to die in the ocean.
Shark hunters have looted these waters for decades.
Then, in 2009, the government of Palau decided to act,
creating one of the world's first shark sanctuaries,
and declaring shark fishing illegal in the region.
The shark sanctuaries extend for more than 600,000 square kilometers,
an area about the size of France.
Today, sharks are fundamental to international tourism,
which drives the economy of Palau.
A lot of divers come here just to see the sharks.
Then the government decided to protect these species.
In addition to the ecological benefit for the sharks themselves,
this also brings a great economic incentive to the country.
A study carried out in 2012 calculated the value of the population of Palau sharks.
A single live shark amounts to more than $170,000 per year in tourism.
Approximately $2 million throughout its life.
A dead shark can be sold at the port for about $100,
money that ends up in the hands of an illegal fisherman from another country.
In just one year, a live shark generates 1,000 times the value for the economy of Palau
than a dead shark.
Live sharks are responsible for injecting $18 million into the country's economy each year,
which is equivalent to 8% of Palau's gross domestic product.
So, if you're going to compare, this account doesn't close.
Basically, it's more profitable for a fisherman to sell fish
for the consumption of the divers who came to see the sharks
than to catch the sharks themselves.
Live sharks represent a source of profitable and renewable income for the next generations.
But the ban on hunting was also a potentially risky decision.
It could have compromised the sport fishing market coming from Asia.
However, ecotourism, when divers come to find the sharks up close, has only grown.
And the number of visitors to Palau continues to grow.
In recent years, marine researchers have noticed a clear change in these waters.
What has happened is that the shark population has stopped decreasing.
They lead a very healthy life in these waters,
and as the sharks are super predators, they are essential for the maintenance of the marine ecosystem.
Sharks hunt for efficiency.
They go after the slowest, weakest, and sickest fish,
preventing potentially devastating diseases from spreading.
In addition, by eliminating the weakest fish,
sharks contribute to the strengthening of the genetic heritage of the species they hunt.
And as the bigger and healthier fish tend to be the most fertile,
the result is to keep the general population of fish under control.
A sudden drop in the number of large sharks
can bring a series of consequences
by allowing the population of fish to grow too much,
disturbing the delicate balance of the ocean food chain.
Sharks are perfectly adapted to play their role as super predators here in the Reef,
a result of more than 450 million years of evolution.
Small organs in their mouths, called ampullae,
detect the electric impulses of other creatures.
Meanwhile, their hydrodynamic bodies, like torpedoes,
allow them to swim quickly to reach the prey.
In the culture of Palau, the shark means courage and strength.
That is why they usually adorn their traditional places of worship, known as bais.
Researcher Maria Maia Santagelo is collecting data
for a study on the population of sharks in Palau.
Okay, three, two, one.
So what we're doing is looking at the sharks individually,
how many you can see, what size they are, what's the sex of each one,
do they have certain patterns of behavior,
but we also have to consider how they are affected by certain things,
like the number of divers or environmental factors such as temperature and currents.
The ideal is that we build a long-term database to monitor the shark population.
Being a protected sanctuary where the shark population can thrive,
Palau is of extreme importance for environmental conservation.
Every year, it is estimated that 100 million sharks are killed worldwide.
As they take decades to reach adulthood and produce few cubs,
sharks are vulnerable to excessive predatory fishing.
One third of the ocean shark species is at risk of extinction.
The data collected here can encourage the creation of other shark sanctuaries around the world.
Today, at the diving point, we saw a very large group of gray sharks from the Reef.
There weren't just one or two here and there.
There were some large ones, all together.
In general, the behavior that we saw is quite common.
They were just patrolling the area.
This patrolling behavior is a typical sign of the gray sharks from the Reef,
which circulate throughout the territory.
The gray sharks have developed a cooperative relationship with the white-tailed sharks.
The white-tailed shark is closer to the shallow waters,
where they hunt by forcing their bodies, which are more flexible, between the reefs' fins.
The gray sharks, on the other hand, swim further, in the deep waters.
At an average length of two meters, the gray sharks from the Reef are not the biggest fish here.
But when they swim in groups, they discourage other larger sharks,
such as the hammerhead shark, from invading their territory.
The distant cousins of the gray sharks can be easily identified
by the unique patterns of the spikes on their bellies.
Sharks, on the other hand, are difficult to catalog individually.
Traces such as scars caused by females during reproduction
help researchers to differentiate one shark from the other
and find clues about their seasonal behavior.
If we start to see a lot of females with scars, using a long-term database,
we can determine what is the breeding season of these sharks.
This way, in the future, we can speculate how many months it would take
for us to see young sharks after hatching.
The most important thing when you're going to dive with an animal as fascinating as a shark
is to know that you're in their space and you need to respect that space.
Sharks are super predators.
You can compare diving with them to a tour of the African plains with lions around you.
You have to respect them and keep your distance.
If you relax and just enjoy the view, they get curious and come closer.
Being an active marine researcher and diving guide in Palau,
Paul Collins has already done more than 5,000 dives.
I find sharks in almost all of my dives,
and I've never had a situation where I had to leave the water because of them.
Essentially, you're in their territory, you're in their domain.
People tend to imagine that sharks are hunters, killers, but they're not like that.
The powerful currents that make these waters ideal for sharks
can be a challenge for divers.
So that they can stay in the same place as they observe,
divers and researchers prefer to be anchored to the reef instead of going against the current.
Instead of swimming and fighting against the current just to not be taken away,
we use a hook and we're really stuck to the reef.
Then we can just relax and watch the sharks show in front of us, basically.
So we're right above the reef, at a 45-degree angle,
and you can stay there, relaxed, without spending a lot of air,
conserving energy, observing what's going on in that area.
From December to March, an incredible seasonal show takes place.
On the days before the full moon,
certain fish gather in large flocks for mating season.
Every year, this is the only opportunity they have to reproduce.
Depending on the species and the time of year,
the number of fish can vary from hundreds to thousands.
The typical mass show begins with large numbers of fish
migrating to the same location during the mating season.
For the Anclos, the high point of this season is from January to February.
Many times, the fish live together for days before reproducing.
They gather close to the edge of the reef,
at a point where the current can take the eggs to the open sea.
Far from the predators, there is spawning in the reef.
Spawning takes place during the flowing tide,
and when the tidal fluctuations are greater, on the eve of the full moon.
The Anclos practice pelagic spawning.
That is, every year they release their eggs and sperm
freely in the course of the water,
and the currents take the fertilized eggs to the open sea.
The exact moment of the spawning of these fish
has never been filmed or photographed.
The white-clawed sharks that roam in flocks threaten the fish.
These sharks came from far away from the reef,
attracted by the large number of fish gathered.
One of the most interesting things about these cardumes
that gather at the time of spawning is that they attract many of these predators.
The predators know that the reef is full of fish that they can eat,
so they take advantage of that.
The formation of the cardumes is a means for the fish to defend themselves from potential hunters.
The large number provides security.
When the cardume is attacked by a predator,
the chances of each fish becoming a prey decrease.
Those on the edges of the cardume act as watchdogs,
helping to protect the rest of the group.
Usually, when predators come after a cardume or a very large group,
it can be a little confusing at first just to see so many fish moving together.
So what the predators do is just wait, keep an eye out
until a fish passes by that looks slower or weaker,
or they go after another smaller group to try again.
It's dawn in the east of the archipelago.
At a remote point in the reef,
thousands of gulf lucianus emerge from the depths
to spawn during the leaking tide.
These guys appear here only for about four days.
If you dived here five days before the full moon,
you'd be lucky to find two or three of them.
Now, if you dive a few days later,
you're going to see more than 10,000 fish.
For over four years, Paul Collins has been studying lunar cycles
He uses an acoustic measurement system
that sends signals to the bottom of the ocean
to record the depth levels.
So the data collected in three gulf lucianus leachate sites
is compiled into a geographical information processing system,
creating a 3D model of each fish meeting point.
What I found most interesting,
especially because of the gulf lucianus,
is that these three sites,
they all look almost identical underwater,
in terms of depth, proximity to the deep sea,
inclination and angle.
It's amazing.
It seems that this is simply the perfect habitat
for these species to come to spawn.
And even though these groups are more than 100 km away
and have never interacted,
they all chose the same type of site to reproduce.
It can tell us a lot of things.
It might be that, over time,
these fish have been more successful
at spawning at these sites.
Maybe at these sites,
the eggs are released into the open sea more quickly,
so they don't attract as much attention as the gulf lucianus predators.
This is a very, very good question,
a field of research that still needs to be explored more.
At spawning time,
males and females group up in conical formations
and climb up the water column
until they are 12 meters below the surface.
When they get there,
the two groups simultaneously launch their sperm and eggs.
The sperm swim through the water and fertilize the eggs.
But the mating ritual lasts only a few seconds.
Only the strongest and fastest fish are successful.
When the eggs hatch,
the gills of the gulf fish are still planktonic larvae
that float with the currents for weeks or even months.
When these larvae are already big and strong enough
to avoid predators,
they return to the gulf.
Sharks have arrived in large numbers,
interested in the fish gathered for spawning.
Suddenly, a gray shark from the gulf
appears and attacks the shark.
Here in the isolated coral reefs of Palau,
prey and predators wage a daily battle for survival.
But groups like this face a much more destructive threat.
The inconsequence of predatory fishing.
Sharks gather for spawning
in well-defined times and places,
easy to predict,
and the fishing vessels that pursue them seem insatiable.
Enormous nets can catch a whole herd in a matter of minutes.
Entire populations are devastated
and fishing resources are exhausted.
For centuries, the human population of Palau
has depended on these reefs for its survival.
It is a matter of food security.
Maintaining a constant source of food in the future
is a priority for the government.
In 2014, this small country at the forefront of shark protection
took a next step in its efforts for environmental conservation.
No foreigner is allowed to fish in these waters.
Today, Palau houses the largest marine sanctuary in the world.
A strip of the ocean almost the size of California.
It is hoped that this ban will help local fish populations
to recover from the brutal fishing practices
that have impacted the region so negatively.
The Napoleon fish, also known as the Napoleon podium,
is highly sought after by illegal fishermen.
It is among the largest fish in the Reef,
measuring 2 meters and weighing 180 kilos.
In Hong Kong, in southern China,
the Napoleon fish is highly sought after.
Each kilo on average is sold for more than US$1,100.
The population of Napoleon fish has decreased by 50% in the last 30 years.
Palau hopes that the ban on fishing
will protect this endangered species
before it is completely extinct.
But for a country without an army or navy,
fighting illegal fishing is not an easy task.
The Remelik is a Pacific class patrol ship,
32 meters long,
handed down by the Australian government.
It is Palau's largest weapon against the massacre caused by illegal fishing.
At any time of the day,
Palau's waters contain an average of 50 fishing boats,
including pirate ships loaded with prohibited cargo.
We've captured ships of people who were illegally fishing tuna,
as well as shark fins.
We've already found,
from a few fins on certain ships,
to hundreds of them on others.
Recently, we've captured ships
that were approaching the coast,
reaching the reefs to catch sea cucumbers
and reef fish.
This is a very worrying trend.
We who live on the islands of the Pacific,
here in Palau,
depend on the reefs and these resources for our survival.
It is enough for a large illegal boat
to fish at a certain point in the reef,
on a single night,
to devastate that area for several years.
This is a fishing boat from the Philippines,
docked on the docks.
We've already taken all the equipment off the ship.
Everything has already been placed in these boxes,
on land.
The fish were sold or donated to the public.
Most of the tuna cargo,
you can tell by the big eyes and the yellow beard,
had 20 tons of fish on board.
This is one of the illegal fishing boats
coming from the Philippines,
which the Palau Police seized in 2015.
The crews of the two combined ships
added up to a total of 54 members.
All of them were sent back to the Philippines
on one of the boats,
while this one was confiscated by the local authorities
who intend to sell it.
We are trying to protect our resources,
from everyone who doesn't have permission
or license to fish in this sea.
It's a real naval battle.
A single patrol boat is responsible
for protecting more than 500,000 square kilometers in the ocean.
Flagging the criminals is difficult.
Small illegal fishing boats
invade the waters of Palau,
fill their nets,
and soon return to the open sea,
where they are received by bigger ships,
in which the pirates can unload the illegal cargo
and refuel their fuel and ice
before returning to cause more damage.
They are getting smarter and smarter.
I'm sure that the illegal fishermen
keep in touch here and in other places,
where they see when the patrol boat is leaving
and they warn each other
so that they can stay away from the area for a while.
But then, when our boat returns to the port,
they return to work normally.
That's the biggest disadvantage of having only one patrol boat.
The Palau Navy Patrol uses a monitoring system
to monitor the activities of the authorized fishing boats,
while identifying those who operate illegally
in the restricted areas of Palau,
known as suspects.
When Remelik catches a pirate fishing boat,
armed police officers approach it.
If it contains fish caught illegally
or shark fins,
the police arrest the boat.
If the vessel is approached,
and if it is detained,
if the cargo is confiscated,
for the owner,
this is only part of the business of the fishing industry,
they probably don't even care
or already expect that a certain number of vessels
will be captured every year.
In order to prevent more illegal fishing boats
from entering the waters of Palau,
the government has decided to take extreme measures.
One of the things we have done
to try to deter these illegal fishing activities
is to make it economically unfeasible
for the companies behind these vessels
to keep sending them here.
Last year, we seized six Vietnamese ships
inside our reefs.
So the government of Palau decided
to remove all toxic or dangerous materials from these ships
and all fuel, all oil,
so that they could be taken to the open sea and burned.
It was a demonstration of strength
to show that we will never tolerate illegal fishing
in our waters again.
We are not going to release these ships
just to be refueled with more crew,
more fuel, more equipment,
and then go straight back to Palau
to keep catching our fish.
We burn all the ships in the sea
with minimal environmental impact,
but it is basically our way
of sending a message to the international community
to warn them, this is a serious problem,
we no longer tolerate this.
Either you are on our side, or this is what will happen.
There is a lot at stake.
Palau needs to protect the interests
of the local fishing market
and also the excellent conditions of the corals
that house its natural wonders.
Back to the diving point,
known as Canto Azul,
the steep coral walls are full of life.
A large herd of black-bearded barracudas
with more than 100 members follows the current.
The barracudas are large predators
and attack prey with two rows of sharp teeth,
like navels,
capable of slicing fish into small pieces
to facilitate digestion.
This ferocious and efficient technique
has served the barracudas well
for the last 50 million years.
Finding a herd of barracudas
can be a very intimidating experience.
They are all very large,
with a meter in length.
Although they themselves are already dangerous hunters,
the barracudas swim in herds
to protect themselves from other predators.
There are always bigger fish in the sea.
In these coral banks,
the gray sharks of the reef feed on barracudas.
But it is better for the sharks of Canto Azul
to think twice
before attacking a giant barracuda
swimming alone.
Unlike other types of barracuda,
this species is a large predator
that can measure up to 2 meters in length,
weigh up to 45 kilos
and swim at a speed of 55 kilometers per hour.
This guy doesn't have any natural enemies
at the bottom of the sea.
It's a very, very, very agile fish.
It's a complete predator.
It was amazing to see her approaching.
You could count every tooth in her mouth.
I'm even surprised to see how big her teeth are.
So, she's a beautiful animal
that we don't see every day.
But the giant barracuda came to Canto Azul
with a specific purpose,
to visit its cleaning station.
They come to this area,
stop in the middle of the water
and have their mouth wide open,
and let the cleaners swim
all over their body
and pick up any parasites.
We do have, especially,
the little dentists and doctors of the reef.
The cleaning stations
are one of the favorite places
of the great and majestic
giant barracuda of Palau,
the second largest type of fish in the ocean,
but there are also other species of giant barracuda in the reef.
A marble ray
and a sandfish ray
that rest on the sandy soil.
We saw a ray today.
When we approached,
it started to lift the little hole,
the very tip of its body,
just a little bit,
but usually it's a warning sign.
It's a warning that
it's not happy with our presence.
It's also a good sign
that it's about to get up and leave.
So, when we got closer,
that's exactly what it did.
It lifted the little hole,
got out of the sand, turned around
and disappeared in the blue sea.
From the majestic rays
and dazzling coral reefs
to spectacular mating rituals
and hypnotic carnage of fish,
Palau houses
one of the most fantastic
underwater ecosystems on the planet.
A brilliant example of marine conservation.
A place that protects the largest predators in the ocean
from the devastating practices of illegal fishing.
What was especially special about Palau
being the first shark sanctuary on the planet
is that we became a great example for the rest of the world.
It was essential that someone had the initiative
to stimulate the creation of other marine protection areas around the world.
Since then, other countries have also mobilized.
For example, Maldives, Honduras, the Bahamas.
They've all created shark sanctuaries.
That's why Palau was so important
as a leader in the creation of shark sanctuaries around the world.
A place where sharks are inseparable from culture
and where they define the terms
for incredible underwater encounters.
We can observe the animals in a completely natural environment.
You don't have to feed them or install fences
to attract the sharks.
We can see them as they normally live,
which is very good, and they're already used to us.
Physiologically, they're amazing animals,
but also as divers, the more time we spend in the water,
the more time with the sharks,
the more respect we get for them.
We realize they're so important for the ecosystem
because they have to stay here,
and because we have to protect them
because they keep the ocean healthy.
The best thing that a diver can do
is visit a marine sanctuary.
So we not only recognize the ecological importance of these sharks,
but we also promote the local economy
of a community that's decided to protect the sharks
instead of hunting them.
We're beginning to see an increase in tourism in Palau,
which, for the country's economy, is very good.
But we have to balance this more carefully
to avoid any impact against the Reef.
Maybe we should police the area a little more
and really prepare our guides
so that they serve as an example for the people who visit us.
Because this is a preserved environment,
and it needs to stay that way.
So the guides are essentially the guardians
of the underwater environment of Palau.
It would be like visiting the Serengeti.
You don't throw garbage in the Serengeti.
You have to respect the place where you are
and not cause any impact.
A remote island chain in the Pacific
continues its battle of Davi-Golias
against powerful and illegal forces.
A battle that, without a doubt,
will continue in the near future.
The patrol ship operations here in Palau
have been essential to protect the waters,
but the area is too big
and we need to increase our capacity.
The region is too large to patrol with a single ship.
Despite the obstacles,
Palau will not back down in its fight
to protect the reef
from the attacks of illegal fishermen
from other countries.
Palau's efforts to protect itself
will determine the future
of this paradisiacal archipelago.
The small country at the forefront
of shark conservation
that decided to ban any foreign fisherman
from giving a chance
to its threatened species to resist.
The sea is essential for our survival.
Basically, every day, local fishermen
go out to work, to feed their families.
The people of the Pacific Islands
are always deeply connected to the ocean.
It is it that defines us, that sustains us,
and that makes us who we are.
To attack the ocean is to attack
directly our conditions of survival.
It is part of our identity, really.
Without it, we would not be here.
