#Ocean#Shark#Conservation For generations, families in Belize have made their living by fishing the ocean, a tradition that includes the shark trade. But as shark populations began to dwindle, the future of both the fishers and the ecosystem became uncertain. This documentary tells the story of an incredible, unexpected collaboration between marine scientists and local fishermen. Instead of clashing, they worked together to find a solution that protects marine life while also securing a sustainable future for the community. By using science-backed strategies and invaluable local knowledge, they created a powerful new model for conservation. This is how Belize became a world leader in responsibly managing ocean resources, proving that protecting the "jaguars of the ocean" is not only possible but beneficial for everyone involved.
00:00 Belize's Conservation Success Story 01:57 Protecting Sharks: The Ocean's Jaguars 02:21 Balancing Conservation 14:41 Building A Community's Trust 23:36 Sustainable Shark Fishing
Beautiful bellies,
abundant tropical rainforests, towering jungle mountains, and vivid coral reefs.
With nearly 36 percent of its land and 20 percent of its ocean territory
safeguarded within protected reserves, this small developing country stands out
as a world leader in conservation. We have had a long history of conservation,
both from the terrestrial side and also from the marine side. Belize recently made a bold
commitment to preserving its stunning offshore ecosystems for future generations with a pledge
to extend marine protections to 30 percent by 2026. This move marks more than four decades
of sustainable management informed by science. In the late 80s and 90s, they established the
world's first jaguar reserve, the Coxcomb Basin Wildlife Sanctuary, that was based on research by
several people including Dr. Alan Rabinowitz. Using data collected from remote cameras and
animal tagging, Panthera founder Alan Rabinowitz, a world expert on wild cats,
inspired the Belizean government to protect its critical jaguar habitat in 1986. Today,
marine scientists are using similar methods to inform management decisions about critical shark
habitat, effectively creating the Coxcomb of the sea. So we do all those same things here on the
atolls but for sharks, sort of the jaguars of the ocean. Shark populations here serve not only an
essential ecological role in the reef system but they are paramount to the country's tourism
industry and national fisheries, requiring the government of Belize to strike a delicate balance
between stakeholders. Conservation goes hand in hand with the livelihood. If you conserve
something it doesn't mean you cannot fish it, it just means that you need to now operate in a more
sustainable manner to ensure that you have this fishery for a very long time, not just for you
but for your kids. In a pioneering collaboration, marine scientists and local fishers work together
to collect data on shark abundance inside and outside of protected areas. 173. These long-term
surveys provide the fisheries department with what they need to manage shark populations
sustainably. The most efficient and most effective management plan that you can have is one where the
people who actually use the resource want to be involved, care about it, and want to protect it.
More than 20 years in the making, these collaborative efforts to better understand
shark behavior have already resulted in marine conservation successes. How are scientists,
fishers, and managers working together to build more sustainable fisheries in Belize?
And what does the future hold for local shark populations, the jaguars of the sea?
The Belize Barrier Reef forms part of the second largest coral reef system in the world.
This UNESCO World Heritage Site is home to a diverse array of marine life including top
predators like lemon sharks, nurse sharks, tiger sharks, and Caribbean reef sharks.
Sharks are an iconic species. They play an extremely important role in maintaining the
balance in our reef ecosystem and it's important for us to have them there and to have them
in the numbers that they play that role. Shark populations in Belize are also integral to the
tourism industry and national financial security. Regionally, they're essential to the livelihood
of local fishers who sell their catch in the international shark meat trade.
In Belize City, the nation's resource managers bear the responsibility of weighing these demands
and keeping shark populations healthy. The balancing between conservation and
sustaining livelihood of fishers has always been a challenge in all fisheries
and that is the reason why when we implement management measures it needs to be backed up
by science. It's not something that we just want to protect a species but we need to know why.
The Belize Fisheries Department has long partnered with ocean scientists like
Moat Marine Laboratory's Dr. Damien Chapman to provide critical data about life on the reefs.
We call the coral reefs now a social ecological system. So you have the animals, the corals,
the sharks, the fish, but you have to have the human element considered as well. You know,
I love sharks. I don't want to see any sharks die but I have to acknowledge that the shark
fishermen need to make a livelihood and their children need to make a livelihood so we need
find a balance that works for everybody. These people who are closest to the actual resource
have an important role at the end of the day to contribute to the long-term survival,
conservation, and sustainability of that very small-scale fishery that they've been involved
in for generations. In 2014, as then head of the Fisheries Department, Beverly Wade convened the
National Shark Working Group, a task force of scientists, managers, NGOs, and fishers charged
with making knowledge-based recommendations for the fisheries. Key to this working group are the
fisher folk of Riversdale, a small village of a hundred residents just 50 miles down the coast
from Belize City. The local families here have been fishing these reefs for generations. I've
been fishing for quite a while but my parents, my aunt, my mom, they're doing fishing before us.
My uncle, Roy, he used to do shark land before us and back in the days there was plenty of shark,
plenty. Way back when I was a kid, they started to buy whole sharks and we used to try to get one or
two but we couldn't get them. They were so big. There was giant seven, eight-foot, ten-foot
bull sharks. I've been fishing like four to five years. I saw a lot of sharks in my life, big schools.
I grew up in the fishing industry. I grew up with my grandparents and they were fisher folks
so I started off like hand line fishing and then when I was about 15, I started working
sharks with Omar. For me, it's a fun job. Some other people that might think, you know, you're
killing out the sharks but it's a fisheries. It's a good way of making a high income beside
lobster and other fishing. Unlike the wasteful and ecologically destructive practice of shark finning
in which only the fin of the shark is harvested, shark fishers in Belize land the entire fish as
part of the regional shark meat trade with Guatemala. When we fish shark, we use everything
of the shark. We sell the meat. We use also the liver to make oil. You know, we use everything
from the animal. We don't catch where we don't need and we don't throw away and we do it in a good way.
In 2018, the Riversdale Fishers began working on the water with Damien Chapman's research team
to tag and release sharks, providing invaluable knowledge along the way.
We share a lot of information with certain areas. We even give them local names like
like we got here we call it Hammerhead Alley. Certain areas, certain time of the month that
certain like certain species would gather a certain area so you're gonna share that
information with them too. You know, it's a kind of back and forth. Working with the fishers has been
rewarding in so many levels. They're just so knowledgeable of the area, the species, the
habits, the seasons, what affects them, you know, what gear is best to use with them. It's literally
taken them a lifetime right to figure it out so I'm certainly not going to figure it out in my
five-year, six-year PhD so I mean working with them has been paramount to the success of what we do
for sure. This unique collaboration is the result of long-term trust-building by both fishers and
researchers. Its origins lie more than two decades in the past and 30 miles offshore at Glover's Reef.
So Glover's Reef is a coral atoll. It's one of only four coral atolls in the whole western
hemisphere so it's a really special environment and it has a research station run by Wildlife
Conservation Society. It's been my home away from home for about 23 years. Set up in 1993
as a no-take fishing area, Glover's Reef Marine Reserve is where Damien Chapman and his team
conduct the bulk of their shark studies in Belize. There's two kinds of research that we do here
broadly speaking. There's theoretical stuff, very academic, and there's a big chunk of our research
that's very applied which means it's stuff that the government needs to know, the fishermen need
to know in order to manage a sustainable fishery. That's things like how abundant are they, how is
that changing over time, that's critical information for management. There are very few places throughout
the world that are actually tracking abundance within protected areas let alone in places where
they're not fished. They usually track abundance inside and outside at one point in time but what's
really important for management is that we get these long-term abundance trends over time.
So we use baited remote underwater video stations or BRUVs as a sampling tool to get an idea of sort
of like sharks per hour, how many sharks you see for every hour you put down. All right camera
recording. It's basically an action camera on a frame with one kilo of bait stuck in the front
and it attracts animals all kinds of fish including sharks in and then of course they get
caught on camera and gives us a way to get a sense of how many there are in a given area. Okay here we go.
From 2006 to 2016, scientists and volunteers watched hundreds of hours of BRUVs surveys
to track the abundance of sharks at Glover's Reef. They logged nurse sharks, a nationally
protected species, as well as lemon sharks and hammerheads. But their most significant finding
concerned Belize's iconic Caribbean reef sharks. The Caribbean reef shark is a really important
species. They are important because they are tourism resources so people come and pay money
to see them swimming and they are one of the most abundant predators on coral reefs in this region.
While long line surveys showed a stable population of these reef sharks for more than a decade,
in 2016 researchers saw a drastic decline of the species in the BRUVs recordings.
This data resulted in what Damien's team refers to as a red flag.
A red flag is something that we see in our data that tells us that the sharks are going in the
wrong direction. That means their populations are going down and a lot of that was because
of fishing along the boundary. So it was perfectly legal for these guys to be fishing
but they were fishing just too close to the edge and picking off the reef sharks that would swim a
little ways out. So we were able to share our data with the Belize Fisheries Department and
the National Shark Working Group so that they were able to act quickly, come together and make
a decision about what the best management strategy would be to protect sharks moving forward.
With this data in hand, the National Shark Working Group recommended a two-mile extension
of the Marine Reserve boundary around all three protected atolls. This buffer zone was made
official by the Fisheries Department in 2020. So the fishermen can still fish but they're just
further away so they'll pick up the sharks like tigers that they want to get but they'll leave
the baby reef sharks alone so that they can grow up and reproduce and maintain a healthy
population in the protected area. Damien's team is also documenting species abundance using
longline shark surveys. While they now work hand in hand with the Riversdale Fishers,
this collaboration was not always an assured success. After seeing the National Shark Working
Group gain traction, Beverly Wade encouraged researchers to work even closer with local
fishers and tap into their extensive on-the-water knowledge. It's funny because when Beverly first
brought us together we sort of go in there and sitting across the table. They're suspicious that
I'm just here to close everything down. I'm here thinking they're not going to trust me, they don't
want to maybe don't want to listen to what I have to say about the red flag. Damien came and so we
decided to have a meeting and he come with a different approach to us. He comes and said
listen Fisher guys from Riversdale and we want to work along with you. What you start to realize is
fishermen are very interested in sharks and they know things about sharks I don't and vice versa.
So we started talking about the animals, talking about our lives and over a period of time a rapport
builds and so I learned how much they make shark fishing every day and so I was able to find
funding to sort of hire them to tag instead of kill and that arrangement has been fantastic.
They call like you guys could still fish shark, do some scientist research and we'll meet in the
middle. To me it was a good idea that he came to us like that because man if it was like something
here that come like you guys gotta stop fishing shark like then I'll be like man how you expect me
to feed my family you know. I do this from my dad, my grandpa. This is something that went on from
generation to generation here in Belize. The way we work with the scientists and we have a good
working relationship because it's it's both ways. We agree to some he says he agrees to some he says
and it's not a one-way thing it's not like I'm the scientist you're gonna do this this this because
then that wouldn't work right but a lot of scientists are like that they're like this is
what you're gonna do and it won't work like that with fishermen because we're self-employed we're
used to being our own boss since day one. I think Belize need more more scientists like that that
work directly with the fishers and I don't like the idea of just banning it's not all just about
the money so I'll pay you to just quit fishing. To me I don't see it as fair because it's our
industry and it's our country so if we can work together it's better not only for me for everyone.
After four years of working together Damien's team and the Riversdale fishers are a smooth
running operation conducting nighttime shark surveys on nearly pitch black waters.
Once the long lines they set earlier have had a chance to settle
the team returns to check the baited line for shark catches.
When we're fishing the long lines we normally leave them for two hours because we're trying
to balance not spooking the sharks by driving around so we want to leave it so that they have
time to get caught but we don't want to leave them on the hook too long because you know we
want to minimize the stress on the animal in general so we try to check them as much as possible.
When a shark is caught on the line like this nurse shark the team works swiftly to minimize
injury to the animal and to themselves. They use a tail rope to secure one end
and hold the head firmly by the line where the hook has embedded itself in the mouth.
The sharks caught on the long line get caught in the lip because we use a special kind of a hook
called a circle hook that is designed to get them that way. Now it's probably not pleasant for them
to get hooked but you have to keep in mind these are animals that eat fish that are covered in
spines they eat stingrays that sting them in the mouth so injuries around the mouth area heal very
quickly so it's not entirely stress-free for them but it's relatively painless. So once we have the
animal secured alongside the boat we take some important body measurements. Those measurements
are useful because scientists take them uniformly so if I take that measurement and I know a fellow
colleague takes that measurement I know it was taken in a very standardized way and we can share
information about the same species. Researchers then record if the shark is male or female.
They also take a small skin clipping for genetics and make a simple piercing in the primary dorsal
fin where they attach a numbered tag. Finally after removing the hook from the mouth the shark is
released. So most sharks need to swim to be able to breathe so when we release it we really want
to make sure the shark is oriented correctly and that it feels like it's swimming on its own
because you can feel them kicking their tail. Nurse sharks are able to breathe while they're
just sitting on the bottom but most of the sharks we handle aren't they do need to swim.
When smaller individuals like this newborn Caribbean reef shark are caught
they're brought into the boat to complete the survey workup. Some species that we catch are
definitely more vulnerable to the stress of being caught and handled. Caribbean reef sharks tend to
be a little bit more delicate especially the little ones so we want to make sure that we're
doing a workup pretty efficiently and if we do come across an animal no matter what species it
is that it's very weak we won't do a workup and we'll release that animal because it's not worth
killing it to get the information. There we go so this is the belly button this is only a
a couple of months old she's probably born late summer so let's put him back in the water and get
out of here. Working alongside the fishers from Riversdale has also revealed to the researchers
critical gaps in survey information sometimes even the very presence of a particular shark
species in a given region. The tiger shark for example before they started working on us they're
like there's not tiger sharks in Belize like Belize doesn't have tiger sharks but that doesn't mean
it's not in Belize it's just that they might not know where to catch that species and we the
fishermen who's been doing it forever knows where that species is. Tiger sharks are really difficult
to get in fact my fishing skills are nowhere near up to par I have to work with the shark fishermen
and it turns out all of my survey gear the baited cameras and the long lines were all too shallow
really to be catching tigers to get tigers you have to go deep. When we do catch tiger sharks
we have access to a certain kind of satellite tags that are referred to as spot tags that go
on to the first dorsal fin of the tiger shark. The way that the spot tag operates is that as soon as
the dorsal fin of that individual breaks the surface of the water it's going to emit a signal
to satellites and that gives us an approximate location for the individual. The satellite tags
are really a vital piece of information because the tiger sharks are quite different from the
reef sharks or nurse sharks because those species they'll stay in one location so you can make a
protected area and you're good to go. With the tiger shark they move around a lot some of them
have gone to the United States some of them have gone to Cuba several have gone to Honduras and
Guatemala so they travel and that tells us that those are the countries that Belize needs to
engage with in order to ensure that the tiger shark fishery maintains the sustainability in
the long term. Tiger sharks as a fishery make up a large volume of the regional shark meat trade
and as such can also have an impact on food security. People depend on shark meat not just
for livelihood in terms of income generation but it is also a very important protein source
for coastal communities globally so it becomes even more important to sort of take a step back
and look at the bigger picture in the sense of you need more regional management of a fisheries as
opposed to a more localized domestic national management. This unique collaboration between
scientists, fishers and managers is a shining example of how creating sustainable fisheries
requires more than just sharing knowledge and gathering data. It also entails a persistent
effort to establish enduring trust and the courage to embrace different perspectives.
My entire career in fisheries management it was always there's a discussion about how do we form
that nexus between the science and the management part or the science and the use part and these
group of shark fishers in Belize and the researchers that they've been working with
have actually formed that nexus that's not very common. I love working with the fishermen and
what's really cool and this survey is showing us is we're seeing an increase in the reef sharks
again so they're rebounding back to the levels we used to see the conservation is actually leading
to more sharks you know it's nice to get a policy in place and we can all celebrate but to see
something that's working and there's more sharks in the water is really gratifying and it's great
for everybody. You know I appreciate a lot that they do for us and you know I like what I tell
Dr. Chapman I love doing my work and I love working with them you know it's a good thing
for our community for you know Riversdale here so I told him man as long you guys keep this going
I'm down for it. The collaboration with Dr. Chapman and his team is very important to us
we are very proud to say that we are one of the leading countries in terms of shark management.
In Belize we're on the right track we feel very proud we're a country that we're using the resource
but we're using it responsibly and we're an example that it can be done responsibly and I
think that our shark fishers are proud of it too because they're central to all of this.
Most shark species are threatened and we need more examples like what we're doing here and
it's very good for us coming from a small little country like Belize
to know be in a position to show the world how it should be done.