Alexander Vilenkin - Is the Universe Fine-Tuned for Life and Mind?

Truth exists
11 followers
Alex, the question of the fine-tuning of the universe, it seems, has emerged into both
scientific controversy and public controversy in the last just couple of decades, even though
maybe the universe has always been fine-tuned. We're suddenly really focusing on this fact that
so many laws of physics and the constants of physics have to be just within a very
small boundaries in order to permit life and human sentience to be here.
This provokes enormous controversy. Tell me about the controversy and tell me where you
fit in that controversy. Well, yeah, that's right. It appears that the universe is fine-tuned in the
sense that there are about 30 constants of nature which take some specific value. If you look at
these numbers, they look like totally random numbers. However, if you change these numbers,
even slightly, the properties of our universe can change quite dramatically.
Generally for the bad. Yes, generally for the bad.
The question is, what do we make of that? This suggests the image of the creator who was
meticulously fine-tuning these constants so that we could arrive on the scene.
You have a nice image in your book. I'm reminded of this nice old man in a beard having 30 knobs
and he's playing with each one and doing it just to get it right.
That's right. This is one possibility. There is quite a different image of the creator which can
lead to the same observable result. This is the creator who creates universes very haphazardly,
at random, but creates a huge number of them.
Then most of these universes, of course, will be no good from our point of view,
but there'll be nobody there to complain about it.
Then if you ask in this picture of the world, where do we expect to find ourselves?
The answer is in a bio-friendly universe which allows us to exist.
That argument, if you will, sounds, when you first hear it, as so obvious it's meaningless.
We sometimes call it tautology. It means we're just repeating the same point because
we can only exist where we can exist. But in fact, there's more in this.
Right. This is the so-called anthropic principle which says that we can only exist in those
universes or in those parts of the universe which allow for the existence of life.
Of course, this is trivially true. There is no dispute about that.
The question is, if indeed this picture describes our world, that we have these multiple regions with
diverse properties, and this is why the universe appears to be fine-tuned,
the real question is how do we test this?
We have come some way towards the goal of testing this because, of course, to start with,
you need a theory that describes these multiple universes.
Because if I tell you just there are many universes with different properties,
you will ask me, okay, how many universes with this property, how many with that?
So you need a theory that will describe this ensemble of universes.
Once you have that, you can say, okay, now we have this mathematical description of this
ensemble of universes, and we live somewhere, most of them are uninhabited, some of them are
inhabited, some of them have intelligent creatures, and we can ask where in this ensemble we are most
likely to find ourselves. So we can try to make statistical predictions. We cannot predict
anything with certainty in this statistical kind of picture, but we can try to make statistical
predictions, and in fact one of such predictions has already been confirmed.
This is the prediction of the non-zero cosmological constant.
So that may be our first evidence for the multiverse.
Okay, let me see if I have this straight. We start off with general agreement that there
is fine-tuning, whether we like it or not, that there are these 30, 32 parameters,
constants of nature, that are within a very fine band, and we have to be able to come up
with an explanation. Okay, one explanation you said is a very nice creator who's playing with
the dials to make one perfect universe. Another is a creator or a force or a process or whatever
that creates an infinite number, a very large number, multi-universe, each one with a different
set of parameters so that one or more has the sentient life, and that's the one we're in,
so we think that one is special. Is there a third possibility that there is only,
at the end of the day, the final physics, that those constants of physics, which look random,
as you said, look totally like wildly random numbers, really have some fundamental
force to them, that they can only be what they are because of something more fundamental?
And so there's one universe, but you don't need a creator, you don't need anything, because
that's the only way those constants could have been. Sure, of course, when I say creator,
as you said, you can replace it by some other metaphor. But yes, sure, and this is what most
physicists were hoping for, that indeed there is, for the reason of mathematical consistency,
or some people would say for the reasons of beauty of the theory, for whatever reason,
there is one theory which is the true theory of the universe, and we were hoping that someday
we will, from that theory, will derive the values of all these constants of nature.
And they will be by force, and there could not have been otherwise. That's right.
It's interesting you're using the past tense in that, you're saying physicists were thinking,
or we were hoping, and that indicates to me that in the present tense, there's maybe some doubt
that you're going to find that. Yeah, many physicists are now doubting it, although there are
people like David Gross, Paul Steinhardt, who believe that this actually is what is
going to happen. But I think there is no question that despite tremendous effort
to explain the constants of nature from fundamental theory,
there is very little to show for that effort. And you don't seem to be radiating a lot of
confidence that physicists will ultimately find that one absolute
law that will absolutely by force make the constants the way they are. You don't have
a lot of confidence in that. Well, most hopes were related to string theory,
which in a way is a unique theory, in the sense that it has just one constant in it.
So people were hoping that, okay, from that theory, we will derive all these,
the constants of nature that we call constants are low energy constants that are derivable from
the theory. But it turns out that string theory appears to admit a lot of different environments,
lots of different vacuum characterized by different values of these low energy constants.
So that would mean that what we hope would solve the problem by making one way the only way
is just maybe making the problem worse because it itself is emerging into a very large number
of possibilities. That's right. So does that mean you're left with literally one of two
options, either a multiverse generated, however, in whatever random manner, or some sort of
intelligent process that created the one universe that works? Well, I go for multiverse.
And I think that there is another issue which is related to the cosmological constant,
which is the parameter that is particularly difficult to explain. It has contributions,
huge contributions from all known particles, but somehow these contributions cancel one another
to 120 points, decimal places. This is pretty much impossible to explain. And so far,
no explanation has been suggested other than this multiverse picture. It is hard to disprove that
the value was selected by design, but it does look like it is a product of entropic selection.
The reason is that there is a range of values of the cosmological constant that is consistent with
the formation of galaxies and evolution of life. This is a narrow range, which includes zero,
actually. And if it is a random selection, we have many regions with different values of this
cosmological constant, we expect to find ourselves somewhere in the middle of that range. And this is
actually what we observe. So what we observe is perfectly consistent with this such random
entropic selection. On the other hand, if you think of design, I would think the designer would
choose some more special value, for example, zero. And in fact, if the value of the cosmological
constant were fine-tuned more, for example, much closer to zero than it is, it would be very hard
to explain it through the multiverse hypothesis, and that would be evidence against this hypothesis.
