Direct vs Indirect Brewing | Don Mei

TEA & Brewing
11 followers
3 Video Views·Aug 7, 2025
Let's geek dive into a Gong Fu Tea brewing masterclass showing the differences between direct of Gall brewing and Indirect or Rim brewing.
You will be surprised about the effect that this small change makes to your brews.
Hey teaheads! This is Don from Mei Leaf. In this video, direct versus indirect extraction.
This video is one of our Gong Fu brewing masterclasses. I've done several of these before. I'll put
links in the description below. All of these masterclasses are designed to geek-dive into
the intricacies of Gong Fu brewing so that you can level up your skills, and brew any
tea that you want, according to your own tastes, simply by instinct. Today we're going to be
testing out the difference between direct extraction and indirect extraction. What do
I mean by this? Well, if I take these leaves and put them into the pot, or the Gai Wan,
and I pour my hot water directly on the leaves, then that's what I call direct extraction.
I also call it gall extraction. The reason is, in China, the ball of leaves in your pot,
or Gai Wan, is called the tea gall. It comes from gallbladder, which is not particularly
appealing. But the idea is that when you pierce the tea ball with the water, when you brew
directly, then you are going to extract, potentially, a little bit more bitterness
whilst making a stronger extraction. The opposite is indirect extraction. I like to call it
rim brewing as well, because what you're doing is pouring the water on the rim. So you're
not pouring directly onto the leaves, but you're pouring on the rim, and therefore you're
getting indirect extraction. But does it make a difference? So we're going to test this
out today. I've got eight Immortals Dan Cong here. Beautiful, beautiful tea. If you've
not tasted this tea it is spectacular. We're going to be brewing in Gai Wans, but I wanted
to show you here a Chao Zhou clay pot. Notice that the edges of this Chao Zhou clay pot
are sloped inwards, and therefore it's more suited to direct brewing, because your leaves
are going to be in here, so you're more likely to pour directly in the middle. You can't
really do rim brewing like you can here, where you can pour on the rim and the water
goes in. But if you wanted to do indirect, or rim brewing, with a pot that's this shape
then, essentially, you would be just tapping the pot, getting the leaves towards the front
half of the pot, and then pouring your water directly towards the back of the pot. That's
the way that you would do that. So I thought I'd just share that tip with you, because
I'm going to be brewing in Gai Wans today, but I just wanted to show you that it is possible
to do indirect brewing with any kind of pot, within reason, so you can always pour indirectly.
So we're going to warm up these Gai Wans. It's very important, because of the fact that
when you're rim brewing the water is going to be hitting the porcelain first, and therefore
will potentially cool down a little bit more than if you pour directly on the leaves. So
if we bring the Gai Wans to temperature then it's going to have less of an effect. So we
want to compare directly the difference between direct versus rim brewing, without thinking
so much about whether or not the temperature of the water is going to be majorly different
between them. So I'm just going to give this some time, roll them around a little bit so
that they warm up. As I said, we've got eight immortals. You can do this test with any tea
you want, and it will work. I've tested it with green tea. I've tested it with Puerh
tea. All sorts of teas. You will notice a difference. All of the differences in these
brewing master classes are sort of incremental differences. They may be small. We'll see
in this one. I haven't done the test with Dan Cong, but they may not be a huge difference.
But when you add up all the different skills that you pick up from these master classes,
and apply them to a session, you'll find that it makes a big difference to the quality of
your brews. All right, so I'm going to pour this water into my Dong Dao Beis, and we're
immediately going to put these leaves in. I'm not going to waste too much time. I'm
not going to do a whole sensorial appreciation of those dry leaves now, because I just want
to... Well, hold on. Yeah. Oh! Stone fruit, juicy cherry notes, peach notes, but not so
much like Mi Lan. A little bit more incense-y and woody as well. Just a gorgeous tea. All
right, so we're going to rinse these. I'm going to do rim, because I'm very conscious
of the fact that I don't want to start to influence things too much. So we're going
to rinse these over our little frog here. There you go. Okay, so now these are exactly
the same, right? Both rinsed, exactly the same batch of leaves, exactly the same amount
of leaves, and exactly the same temperature water. Just check my temperature. Yep, that
is very, very hot, 98 degrees. Okay, so we're going to go direct with this one, and indirect
on that one, and I'm going to count in my head the difference in seconds between my
brews so that we pour at the same time. Here we go. So 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10. So
there you go. Rim brewing versus direct brewing. A little bit more water here, just to make
sure I get everything even. Let's pull these aside. Let's get our Gong Dao Beis ready,
and we're going to be brewing for 30 to 40 seconds. I want to get a nice, strong extraction
here so that we really pick up the difference between them. Now, do you think that that's
going to make a difference, pouring directly on the leaves versus the rim? How much of
a difference do you think it will make? In my experience, it depends a lot on the leaves,
but let's see with Dan Cong. So I'm pouring now. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10. So again,
same amount of time, give or take one second, and here we have our test. Direct, or ghoul
brewing, versus indirect. Of course, the effect is going to be different as you go
through the session, and we'll talk about the practical applications of this in a little
bit. So here we go. Color difference? Not much. I'm using these very, very cute little
white cups here, just so you can really see the color. Not much color difference, I think
you'll find. I would say just the tiniest bit lighter, this one, but very, very small
almost, imperceptible. Right, let's go with direct, or ghoul brewing, first. So I'm getting
lots of great aromatics. I'm getting creaminess. I'm getting tropical fruits, some pineapple.
But the moment that it hit my mouth my instinct was bright. When I say bright I mean bracing,
mineral. Now Dan Congs are well-revered and renowned for having that bite and that minerality,
and I feel that the extraction on this is very, very mineral-rich. Bracing, awakening,
and the texture on my tongue afterwards is noticeably dry. I know that that will give
way to juiciness, but right now I'm getting a catch on the back of my throat. Indirect
brewing, wow! It is a big difference. Instantly, the level of minerality has been dialed down
a dramatic amount, and the texture is just so much softer. Much softer. It does not leave
me with anywhere near the same amount of dryness. I would say it's at least 30 to 40 percent
less dry. Again, not necessarily a good thing or a bad thing. Some people like to have a
more bite and physicality in their tea, but if I had to choose my favorite it would be
going towards indirect brewing. Let's give this another taste. Much less dry. Much softer.
But you could certainly say that there is a slight loss of those refreshing, bright
notes. Again, small, small incremental changes. Oh! In this case it's not so small. Wow! Now
that I've gone back to that one, so much more minerality. It's like much rockier, much more
of this bright, slatey sort of quality to it. So much more minerality. You would have
thought that the water would be totally different. You would have thought that this would be
a lot more mineral-rich, harder water. And yeah, much, much, much more of that pull,
astringency, the puckering. I'm getting that dry sensation on the top of my tongue, and
eventually it dissipates into a nice, fruity juiciness. Wow! Try this experiment yourself.
I'm telling you, the difference is big, big with these Dan Congs. My experience varies
according to the tea. The susceptibility towards bringing out dryness, or minerality, is one
of the key factors. The delicacy of the leaves is another key factor here, in terms of the
difference. We're going to brew these up one more time, just to show that it wasn't a fluke.
And you know what? This time I'm going to switch it around. Let's see. That's an interesting
experiment. We're going to Guo brew the one we did indirect. Now, of course, we are now
no longer identical, because they've been brewed differently, but let's give it a go.
One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten. There you go. Rim-brewed.
So we'll see whether or not the two Gai Wans, the two different brews, show the same characteristic,
even though we've switched them around. As I said, if you're brewing in a Chao Zhou clay
pot, or any pot which has this shape, then just make sure you bump up all of the leaves
towards the front end, and pour to the back. If you do it the other way around then when
you're pouring you're not going to have the water going through the leaves. So I recommend
and then pour around the back. Okay, here we go. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven,
eight, nine, ten. There you go. Again, there or thereabouts, without getting too crazy,
with stopwatches. These have been extracted at the same length of time, direct, indirect.
Let's try indirect first. Cheers, everybody. Lovely balance. I'm getting some minerality,
a little bit of that sort of this bright flooding of minerality that comes across the tongue,
and just gives you a sense of awakening, freshness, but nothing too dry. Now let's try the direct
brewed. So much more physicality on there, a lot more astringent, and certainly more
mineral extraction. So what is happening here? Well, clearly, by pouring directly on the
leaves what you're doing is you are making a stronger extraction, because the solvent
is hitting the leaf directly, and in my opinion, it's extracting more out of the middle part
of the leaf, and is just bringing out more of the sappy taste, the inner leaf material,
which has more of that bite and astringency. Whereas when you're brewing, rim-brewing or
indirect brewing, then you're having less extraction from the inside of the leaf, and
you're getting a more balanced extraction, I would say. In this case, for some teas,
you may prefer to brew direct, but in this case you're getting a more balanced extraction,
more of the aromatics that live on the outside of the leaf, coupled with some of the inner
leaf material being pulled out as well, and you're getting, I would say, a much more balanced
brew out of it. So in my opinion, this type of brewing, indirect brewing, works very well
for teas that have a tendency towards excessive minerality, or potentially excessive bitterness.
So let's talk practically about when you may use direct brewing versus indirect brewing.
Well, I think that it's obviously a matter of choice. It's a matter of what you want
to get out of your tea experience, so there is no right or wrong. But in my opinion, teas
which have a tendency towards more astringency, more bitterness potentially, and are just
leaves, or thinner leaf material, I would say is more suited to starting off with indirect
brewing and testing it out. So we're talking about Dan Congs, which have so much mineral
brightness to them that you want to just attenuate, potentially. We're talking about green teas,
with their delicacy and their high levels of catechins, which contribute to the astringent
and bitter nature of tea. But I'm also talking about black teas, potentially black teas that
are made from smaller leaf pickings. You just want to be a bit careful about not over-extracting
them from your first brew. However, on the other side, sometimes you've got teas that
need a little bit more work in terms of the extraction. You don't want to play around
with temperature, or already temperature is maxed out. I'm talking about maybe darker,
ball-rolled Oolongs. I'm talking about those Wu Yi rock Oolongs. I find that those kinds
of teas can benefit from gore brewing, or direct brewing. But it really is a matter
of experimentation and taste. And of course, you're also going to be adapting through your
session. So at the beginning, you may want to hit some ball-rolled Oolong directly, just
to sort of get that extraction going, get that leaf to start to open up, pull out some
of those sappy, inner-leaf materials, as well as the aromatics, whilst the balls are
opening up. And then, as the session progresses, you may want to start to move to rim-brewing.
So you know, it varies. Also, sometimes you may find that after you've really gone through
lots of infusions with a particular tea, and it's really not extracting as much anymore
maybe you're at the sort of eighth, ninth, tenth infusion, then you may want to definitely
hit it in the middle of the tea gall, directly on the leaves, just to really max out your
final infusions of that session. Experiment. Play around. Let me know your thoughts between
direct gore brewing and indirect rim-brewing. Have a play. I'm sure you'll be surprised
at the results. That's it teaheads. Check out our other videos, taste our teas wherever
you are in the world by browsing Mei Leaf.com, and come visit us if you're ever in London.
Other than that, I'm Don from Mei Leaf. Thank you for being a part of the revelation of
true tea. Stay away from those tea bags, keep drinking the good stuff, and spread the word,
because nobody deserves bad tea. Bye.
