Alexander Vilenkin - Considering God's Existence?

Truth exists
11 followers
Alex, as a cosmologist who has literally your fingers, and when you write your equations,
you're writing the equations of the beginning of the universe, and you are describing the
potential multiverse, the enormity of all there is, even way beyond our observable universe.
And when you see this incredible majesty, do you ever reflect on the concept of God,
in whatever definition, not necessarily a traditional God, the way maybe in popular
culture, but the sense of something transcendent? Do you ever do that?
The simple question that I can answer immediately is that about personal God,
and that I don't believe. The God who concerns himself with human affairs,
I don't think we have much evidence for that. As for more abstract God,
some people suggest the level of abstraction, which I think makes the concept pointless.
If we identify God with the laws of nature, I don't see why we need another term for
the laws of nature.
Right. Okay, those are two boundaries. So have you eliminated everything else, or is there some
remainder? You've eliminated a personal God, you don't see the evidence, fair enough. You say
you're not happy with renaming the laws of nature God, because that doesn't accomplish
very much, unless you're adding something to the laws of nature, which you don't want to do.
So by doing those two things, eliminating a personal God and not willing to rename the
laws of nature, is there any remainder? Is there any space that is left over?
Well, there is a big mystery, which is consciousness, and we have no idea how it works.
It could be that there is a lot more to the universe that we can imagine in that regard.
So there may be some role for consciousness that we haven't yet imagined, and I am open
to entertain all sorts of crazy ideas.
So you would then see consciousness as something, potentially, not for sure,
but potentially independent of the laws of physics, and if so, then it would introduce
something different into the nature of reality, if there is.
Well, right. So if consciousness is just an epiphenomenon, in the sense that it just goes
along with the laws of physics, determine our behavior, and consciousness just reflects
these natural processes.
The cause is one direction. The physics cause the consciousness. We think we're conscious,
but consciousness has no independent existence to influence the laws of physics.
That's right. So from my point of view, this is not a very satisfying picture of consciousness,
but when I say that, I immediately think that, okay, why should it be satisfying?
I mean, the idea is not to find the picture of the world that
pleases you, but the picture of the world which is true.
That's exactly right.
But as I say, since we don't really understand what consciousness is,
there is at least the possibility that it has some independent degrees of freedom,
and what they could be, I wouldn't speculate.
When you go from the laws of physics, and you see those as predating whatever the origin
of the universe was, and indeed, you postulate that you can have mechanisms to go from nothing,
from absolutely nothing, no matter, no space, no time, from there to something,
and that something through inflation causes the Big Bang, etc. So you can go
from nothing to something, but you need the laws of physics to do that.
Certainly, a good number of those laws have to be in place.
Do the existence of those laws, independent of anything else, give you a sense that there
may be something extra in all there is, other than what we commonly call the physical world?
It appears that there should be, because where do these laws exist?
We have the universe originating from nothing.
When we say that, this nothing means no matter, no space, and no time.
So the laws of nature that describe the appearance of the universe in this context
should have some platonic existence outside of matter, space, and time.
And we can ask, what is the medium in which they exist?
Normally, people, at least often people, think that the medium of mathematics is the mind,
that mathematics is a human invention. Mathematicians actually often think that
they're discovering mathematics, that mathematics exists there objectively, and they're discovering
it. So whichever it is, there is some platonic realm where the mathematical laws of physics
exist, even prior to the universe.
It's interesting that mathematicians and some physicists, but mathematicians really do,
to a large majority, really feel that way, that they're not inventing things,
but really discovering it, and they do independent existence. A lot of philosophers,
I would say, believe the opposite, that it's constructs of the human mind, and
approximations of reality, and not real reality.
However that argument goes about the nature of math, I like, for example, where does the number
four come from, the concept of four? You can imagine no universe, no space, no time, but
how can you imagine existence without the concept of four? I mean, it seems impossible,
so I agree with you. But what you do is you take the laws of physics, which are
seemingly more complicated than simple mathematics, and have those as a precursor
to everything. And once we give you the laws of physics, I mean, you can make a lot of things.
You've been very resourceful, very creative in making things once you have those laws of physics,
but it's getting those laws of physics and having them just right,
I mean, that's pretty interesting, where they come from.
Well, that's a really baffling question. Where they come from, why they have this particular
form and not some other form? We can imagine many mathematically consistent possible
universes described by different laws. And, you know, as Stephen Hawking said,
what is it that breathes fire into the equations? Why this particular set of laws is chosen?
And who did the choosing?
