In this episode, the neuropsychiatrist Dr. Jesús Ramírez Bermúdez is explaining what psychosis is, how schizophrenia manifests, and how we can help individuals with this diagnosis to stay in reality. Dr. Jesús Ramírez Bermúdez will share his medical experience and guidance in understanding mental disorders.
This interview is very rich with answers to philosophical questions about reality and existence. Also, after watching this episode, you will know when we have hallucinations without a mental illness.
Enjoy! Don't forget to like and subscribe, please.
00:00:00 Introducing Dr. Jesús Ramírez Bermúdez 00:01:38 Psychosis vs. schizophrenia 00:05:06 Hallucinations can appear not only in psychosis 00:06:09 What are delusions? 00:06:58 Distinguishing between a delusion and a real danger 00:08:45 Why isn't imagination a delusion? 00:10:50 Who brings a patient to a psychiatrist? 00:12:48 The definition of mental illness 00:13:43 Harmful behavior during psychosis 00:16:00 Typical delusions in psychosis 00:16:46 Diagnostic criteria for schizophrenia 00:17:45 Schizophrenia vs. existential crisis 00:18:44 Disconnect from reality and patient's own self 00:20:35 Body awareness and pain disorders in schizophrenia 00:22:01 Loss of agency and delusions of control 00:24:56 The ability to feel pleasure in schizophrenia 00:26:07 Typical hallucinations in schizophrenia 00:27:47 When schizophrenia is an opportunity 00:29:20 Is talking to yourself normal? 00:32:21 Conceptual disorganization in schizophrenia 00:33:51 Metaphor or disorganization of thinking? 00:36:49 When and why does schizophrenia manifest? 00:39:01 Genetic risk factors 00:42:27 Cannabis use as a risk factor 00:45:04 Risks during pregnancy and delivery 00:46:18 Human cruelty as a risk factor 00:49:04 Hypotheses on causes of schizophrenia 00:51:04 Anatomical brain abnormalities in schizophrenia 00:52:34 Dopamin dysfunction in schizophrenia 00:53:38 Diversity in patients with schizophrenia 00:55:35 How to help a person with schizophrenia if you are a friend/researcher/clinician
hi my name is velissa welcome to my
Channel about brain research thank you
for
watching when I was a teenager I watched
a movie called A Beautiful Mind this is
a story about one genius American
mathematician who had
schizophrenia and um this movie
Illustrated very well that there is no
differences in perception for the
patients with schizophrenia for the per
perception of hallucinations or
experiences of the real
life and when you start to realize how
the human brain during this pathology
can be enigmatic and cruel it gets
terrifying but the more we know about
some pathologist the more opportunities
we have to control it and to help people
and my today guest is a famous
professional in this this
field uh my guest is uh Dr Jus Ramirez
bermudes he's a neuros psychiatrist from
the National Institute of Neurology and
neurosurgery of
[Music]
Mexico
[Music]
oh
[Music]
hi thank you for
coming no thanks a lot to you I'm I'm
pleased to be here to talk about
schizophrenia and perhaps another forms
of
psychosis can you please explain what's
the difference between psychosis and
schizoprenia
yes of course so uh perhaps we can uh go
into into the example that you were
sharing the example of John fores Nash
the famous mathematician and Noel priz
in economy I think that um that suffered
from from schizophrenia so uh as you uh
were saying uh he suffered from several
symptoms like uh
hallucinations and delusions and even
some uh really disturbing uh Behavior Al
problem problems no like like uh
engaging in some kind of um paranoid
behavior and thoughts and also even some
aggressive behavior at some moment of of
his illness so uh those are some of the
symptoms of
psychosis uh I I should explain then
that psychosis is a syndrome a clinical
syndrome or a psychopathological
syndrome if you will in which uh the
main characteristic is um a significant
disturbance in reality testing or
reality monitoring and reality in the
conceptualization of reality in the
perception of reality and in the
relationship with reality so uh this
means that the patient uh cannot uh
engage in what we would call normal Al
perception the normal perception of uh
external objects of the external world
and uh instead the patient uh suffers
from different forms of
hallucination most typically auditory
hallucinations for instance uh the
perception of voices uh that sometimes
are offensive or that even give orders
to the patient and and that certainly
happens in in the in the movie right in
the Beautiful Mind movie at some point
the voices tell uh John Nash to hurt I
think he uh his wife for instance no so
so it can be very disturbing orders that
the patient receives um in a
hallucinatory manner of course but but
then again there can also be visual
hallucinations and and this is more
common in patients with other forms of
brain disease like for instance I see a
lot of patients with
um with autoimmune psychosis autoimmune
enalis leading to psychosis and U in in
in that specific uh disorder visual
hallucinations are more prominent as may
be also the case for instance in Lou
body dementia and
others anyway visual hallucinations
auditory hallucinations or other form of
sensory hallucinations like tacti
hallucinations or oratory hallucinations
may be also present in psychosis now
hallucinations are not enough to say
that a person is suffering from
psychosis because for instance there is
another condition the Charles Bonet
condition in which a blind person has
visual hallucinations that maybe very
complex hallucinations they can see a
vivid scenery of uh Birds animals or
persons uh appearing in their me in
their visual Fields but they are not
psychotic because they acknowledge that
these images are hallucinatory so they
don't mistake this images for real
objects in the external world so they
they know the difference and and and
this is important because then the
problem of
psychosis entails a problem in reasoning
or a problem in the rational capacities
of the subject uh and and this takes us
to the second uh symptom that that that
we need to discuss which which is the
problem of delusions so uh in in
delusions the the patient makes
um uh a false uh statement about the
world or about himself
for for instance uh some patients may
have uh paranoid delusions uh thinking
that uh someone in for instance in their
own families is trying to harm their
them uh for for instance um I have a lot
of patients that reject food because
they think that they are receiving a
poison uh so uh that would be for
instance a kind of dilution of course
the clinician needs to be sure that the
delusion uh that the statement is not
true right because it can be the case
that someone is trying to poison you so
uh we we don't take uh the statements at
face value but we need to make some
research with the family with friends
with the patient and sometimes the
delusions themselves are so to speak
impossible that was one of the original
criteria uh that were offered by Carol
Jaspers a famous philosopher and uh
psychiatrist that made this uh book The
wrote this book The the general
Psychopathology and he said that
delusions then uh had this
characteristics of being impossible no
uh so uh for instance uh some some
patients say will will say that they uh
in a silver
star uh in the Middle Ages and they
landed in Australia and then and then
they came by walking all the way from
Australia to Mexico no across the
Pacific Ocean by walking so in in that
case the content of the delution itself
is enough uh to say that the uh that the
content is is false as it cannot be true
on
Common Ground assumptions right unless
everything that we know about science is
is false no which can also be a
possibility but I don't think it's more
often the uh the actual truth so um well
just to summarize in in delusions the
patient makes a false statement about
the world or himself or herself but also
there is a very strong conviction a very
strong belief so as you were saying
previously delusions can be terrifying
because the patient um is not amused by
this um by these beliefs as would be the
case for instance of of an artist a poet
a novelist that can create uh imaginary
Landscapes or stories but actually for
instance uh I don't know talking knows
that all his world is an imaginary an
imaginary world no the the Middle Earth
and Hobbits and everything uh he himself
is perfectly aware that it is an
imaginary landscape but not in the case
of of delusions so I I will tell you an
example no a patient of of my own was a
a man uh and who was 82 years old and he
believed that his wife uh who was 79
years old was um engaging in um in a he
was she was being unfaithful to him with
three men who were young men uh in their
third in her their 30s and uh they were
having origies in the in the in the
living room in the kitchen and all parts
of his house so he was really angry with
with the wife and he even uh hit her uh
twice and that was the reason why the
the relatives the sons of the couple
take took him to the hospital because of
the aggressive behavior so by by
pointing to this example oh I'm I'm
sorry you you had a question yeah please
yes immediately just because uh patients
with psychosis and as a consequence with
schizophrenia uh can
distinguish the real facts from the F
from the FSE facts how does this first
meeting with a a clinician or with a
psychiatrist
happen who who takes care about them how
of they reach the hospital yes that
that's a very important uh aspect of of
clinical practice a very important
problem because uh when you you as a
clinician uh clinical psychologist a
psychiatrist a neurologist or any other
mental health professional when when you
as a clinician uh take care of a patient
it is usually or in every case in fact
because the patient or their relatives
or their loved ones have already decided
that the patient has a problem so uh
then
the the patient is brought to the
hospital uh because the loved ones or or
the spouse or the patient himself or
herself decided that there was a
significant mental health problem or a
physical health problem sometimes they
don't have a precise
conceptualization of of the problem but
they think it is truly problematic the
behavior for instance the aggressive
behavior in the case I was I was sharing
no so in in that example the the the
patient truly believes know that her
wife his wife is being
unfaithful uh and he really is having
this aggressive behavior that is truly
dangerous so this takes us to one of
basic concept uh from Jam Wakefield
which is that mental illness can be
conceived as having uh a harmful
dysfunction a cognitive or mental
dysfunction leading to a harmful
behavior for the patient himself or
herself or for others and it's important
to keep that in mind because often
psychiatrists or other mental health
professionals are accused of uh path of
pathologizing normal Behavior so uh
that's an important critique and we
always have to take it seriously but
then just to finish this initial
statement about psychosis it is then uh
a clinical syndrome that can be due to
many causes it entails a significant
failure in reality assessment leading to
uh sometimes a harmful Behavior or a
dangerous Behavior sometimes a dangerous
behavior for for the patient uh
themselves not not necessarily
aggressive behavior it's it is not
common that patients have aggressive
behavior although they can have
aggressive behavior but for instance the
patient had can reject completely food
and Beverages and and then that can lead
to uh an important health issue for the
patient so those are examples no but
anyway is is a syndrome it can be due to
many causes and one of the conditions
perhaps the best known condition is
schizophrenia uh now we will talk more
about schizophrenia uh but I should say
just that to uh to diagnose
schizophrenia we need many times to rule
out other diseases that can lead to
psychosis you've just mentioned that um
it is not obligatory that the patient
will Express this aggressive behavior
and um my question is how uh
heterogeneous or homog homogeneous uh
psychosis uh could be there's a lot of
the diversity there's a lot of
heterogenity inside the inside this
diagnosis um aggressive behavior can be
one of the signs that are present but
more often it is not present
and and this is important to mention
because aggressive behavior can come
from any other uh kind of uh social or
psychological problem right um I I don't
want to uh contribute to the stigma that
uh relates psychosis and aggressive
behavior however patients with psychosis
may have aggressive behavior sometimes
but it is there's a lot of diversity
within this uh kind of diagnosis uh
patients may have hallucinations or and
most of the time delusions but there can
be all sorts of topics inside the
delution sometimes it will be jealousy
delusions like in the ello syndrome or
nistic delusions like in the cotard
syndrome or it may be also um
misidentification
delusions like in the case of the
Capgras delusion in which the patient um
thinks that their relatives are
imposters so uh there are many forms of
of psychosis but the common um the the
common uh feature is the disturbance in
reality monitoring how do you diagn
schizophrenia in patients I guess that
with schizophrenia patients even more
different between each other yes that
that's that is right and that is also um
a problem now I I should say that there
are some General Diagnostic criteria
like those that were uh developed by the
World Health Organization in the
international classification of disease
now we have the 11th version uh there
are also the criteria from the American
Psychiatric association but I I will
tell you my own process that combines
those criteria and uses other criteria
coming from psychopathological tradition
because those criteria um somewhat uh
simplistic sometimes and leading to
false positives or false negatives so
the the first thing for me is uh that
the patient with schizophrenia
experiences a profound change in their
own subjective experience and their own
behavior a profound change not not a
trivial change like for instance I could
go through a an existential crisis and
start asking about what is the nature of
reality or whatever but that is not a
feature of Psychopathology in this case
most patients yeah fortunately because
otherwise we would many of us will have
will be diagnosed as having a mental
illness right anyway so the the patients
typically typically undergo uh a stage
that is called a prodromal stage or a
prodrome so in in in this pral stage uh
some important features of disturbed
mental experience appear for instance um
the patients have the feeling that
things are changing in a strange and
disturbing way as if uh for instance the
surroundings are not familiar anymore or
even themselves are not familiar with
themselves for and and so so some
patients have may may uh have some
disturbances in bodily selfhood for
instance the patient can think that uh
their own sense of presence is not the
same as
before like uh if they were not the same
as before in a not very clear way
sometimes the patient can go even to a
delusion that they are a different
person but that is not common it it is
mostly like if the patient feels like
he's not the same anymore but he cannot
clearly Express how and they can also
think that their uh voluntary uh
behavior is not as fluid and natural as
before for instance a patient used to
play basketball and now he thinks that
he doesn't know exactly how to do it uh
he doesn't know EXA exactly how to use
the ball how to engage with other people
and in fact disturbances in social
cognition are very frequent in that
stage the patient doesn't feel this um
naturality this U uh fluidity that we
usually have this spontaneity in normal
conversation
so these are some symptoms that may be
present in the prod room but I think you
had a question or a comment or I wanted
to ask about Pro propri acception so
when the patient describes that uh his
or her um sensation of the body is
different can it be the problem of
propriate reception or no reception for
example uh is it a neurolog olical
problem excellent questions because uh
you have to rule out a neurological
problem of propioception in fact and you
also uh need to um assess for notion
because patients with schizophrenia may
have uh a different uh sense U no
receptive sense so for instance they
some may have uh an increased um threat
special for for pain leading sometimes
to uh disturbances in in in the pain
perception some sort of what we would
call sometimes pain asymbolia like the
the the pain is diminished in the
phenomenal uh experience or in the
behavior related to pain but that is not
always present but it may be present in
schizophrenia so certainly you need to
rule out propioceptive features
uh and nociceptive features may be
present but in schizophrenia in in the
prodr itself uh it's not exactly a
propioceptive problem more often we can
call it a a problem of agency which is
the
subjective um awareness of your own
actions so the the the patient may feel
as if their own actions are not being
guided by themselves as if as if their
own actions are not being decided by
themselves but by others so this leads
to the transition to psychosis in which
one of the most common forms of delusion
in schizophrenia is the delusions of
control so the patient will state that
uh they will state that they are not in
control of their own behavior of their
own voice of their own thought of their
own bodies and uh this can take many
many forms for instance a patient used
to say that he could not write by
himself but instead a demon was
controlling his writing so there in in
in in in the in the clinical space he
would start writing but he would said
that that was not his actual writing but
instead
uh the writing of a demon that had taken
possession of him so the patients can uh
make delusions with many different
contents but this is a common feature
sometimes they will say that h a witch
or a demon or a previous relative or a a
previous lover is taking control of
their minds and bodies and making them
do stuff they that they don't want to do
for instance a patient a patient would
go into um a classroom where I was
giving a class to my students and when I
asked to the patient why he was uh
coming into the classroom he would say
that he didn't that he didn't decide it
someone else decided it so this kind of
controlled delusions are very common in
schizophrenia and in fact they were
proposed as diagnostic criteria by Kurt
Schneider that was one of the most
important clinicians in the history of
the
concept now there there are other
important feat features so regarding
delusions controlled delusions are
perhaps one of the most uh important
ones now regarding hallucinations yeah
I'm I'm sorry vasilisa please ask Qui
it's okay it's absolutely normal um is
it true that paat with schizophrenia
cannot feel
pleasure no I I don't think that's true
uh they they can they can have pleasure
in many forms but uh perhaps it it is
true that many patients when when they
are very psychotic can uh have a a
disturbance in in the normal honic
capacities no the capacity to feel
pleasure so so
sometimes it may happen and also in The
Chronic stages where so-called negative
Sy symptoms uh
predominate uh many patients can have
features of apathy or an anonia and they
can in fact have a
reduction in what we call reward seeking
behavior and in uh the experiences of
pleasure but it is not a necess Neary
feature it may be
present thank you so what are other
uh so
uh another one of the most classic
features are the hallucinations right so
the the hallucinations can be in any uh
sensory modality but mostly they will
appear in the auditory modality for
instance um hallucination of
voices hallucinations of voices uh that
are uh human voices of course that are
calling the patient and telling the
patient many different uh messages
verbal messages so they can be regarded
as verbal a auditory ER hallucinations
or verbal
hallucinations uh sometimes the patients
uh you um hear that the that there are
many voices uh they can be male voices
or female voices and usually they talk
to each other they uh the voices comment
things between themselves ignoring the
patient sometimes or giving order to the
pat orders to the patient and often they
will comment the behavior of the patient
usually in a in a negative manner I mean
they they will will be offensive towards
the patient or or they would criticize
the behavior of the patient in a very
disturbing way because they can make
jokes about the patient they can um make
insults to the patient or as I was
saying before giving orders to the
patient sometimes also I should uh
clarify that uh the experiences
experiences can be very pleasant some
patients will have mystical EXP
experiences or exper
experiences in a creative manner uh so
so that is also part of the of the
illness and it's important to point it
out because when you make a
psychotherapeutic work with your patient
you you need to separate the harmful
aspects of the illness but also the the
meaningful aspects of the illness that
will allow for a
psychotherapeutic uh process uh and and
that is very important because otherwise
the patient can be can feel uh very
depressed now when when you give them
the diagnosis so it's an opportunity
also as any other illness right I mean
if you have diabetes it is uh diabetes
it is an opportunity for U improving
your nutrition for instance or making
more exercise so perhaps uh when when
you engage in the clinical field you
need to separate the aspect that could
lead to a positive therapeutic
relationship but anyway uh psychiatrists
are often uh consulted because they need
to deal with the dangerous problematic
distressful aspects of the of the
illness so hallucinations are an
important topic yes is it normal when we
talk with ourselves I think actually
that every one uh does it and in this
case when we are talking with
ourselves is it a herination or it is
not that that's an excellent question as
you were saying I think that most of us
T talk to ourselves in many ways mostly
silently but sometimes even alloud right
like uh when you're in front of the
mirror and you find yourself making some
gestures at as if you were talking to
someone else sometimes imagining that
you are talking to someone that you need
to say something to your couple or to
someone at work so you some kind of
practice what you're going to say or you
just imagine that you would like to say
something previously so you uh enact it
you uh you put it alloud and that is
perfectly normal I I I don't think that
is a hallucination
in the true sense because the it would
be a hallucination if you hear for
instance the voice of the other
person to which trying to
communicate um for instance I I can
imagine that I am talking with my couple
no because I had a fight so I need to
say some stuff but if I actually hear
the voice of my couple as if she was
present there then I could say it was a
hallucination and if this experience is
uh continuous
prolonged uh it doesn't uh disappear but
it in fact uh continues to be present a
lot uh through many days or weeks or
years then that would be characteristic
of a mental illness but anyway there are
even some people hearing voices and not
um suffering from psychosis because they
know they are V voices and in different
um in in different studies in the
community there are different
percentages some studies say that 10% of
the people may actually hear voices and
uh but it will be not disturbing so I I
would uh go back to our previous
definition if I think that those those
voices are real and I engage with them
and I don't and I am not able to
differentiate between real voices and
hallucinatory voices that would be a a
symptom of psychosis and possibly
schizophrenia but then to diagnose
schizophrenia we still need other
features uh one of the most common
features is what they call disorganized
thought or conceptual disorganization
and this is not so easy to explain but
usually when we communicate uh we
understand each others right I mean we
uh make statements that are
understandable for others and sometimes
we don't understand clearly what we're
saying but we can explain no uh so for
instance you will tell me tell me more
about the voices or tell me more about
the delusion so I will try to explain
and we ritually we normally reach a
level in which we feel that we are
understanding each other explaining to
each other and um those are the features
of a normal verbal communication but but
in the case of U conceptual
disorganization we have the feeling that
we don't understand what the other
people is saying and the other people
doesn't understand what we we are saying
so when we analyze actually the verbal
discourse we find that there are many
grammatical errors many logical errors
many uh problems in uh semantic
Association so for instance um the
patients may be doing indir direct
associations so they are connecting
things that we usually do not connect no
uh like metaphoric thinking it's very
actually yes
exactly like like a metaphorical
thinking you know that in in in poetry
we will use those resources no
metaphors and other uh resources to uh
convey uh more profound meanings or U
meanings that are cannot be said through
literal sentences right uh so it's it is
something like that but the difference
is that in the case of poetry the poet
can explain uh why they are using those
uh metaphors and it can be discussed on
on a level of rationality what those
metaphors uh signify or mean and and the
poet is doing it with a clear
consciousness of their own process even
if sometimes they cannot explain fully
how they came about with this specific
figure of speech but in in the case of
uh
schizophrenia uh the patient usually
cannot give an account sometimes they
don't uh they don't have a clear
Consciousness that they are making this
um atypical strange sentences that
cannot be fully understood by others and
this lead us to a fourth um dimension of
of analysis which is the cognitive
dimension
and I think this is very important
although it does not appear in the
American Psychiatric association um
criteria and this has been a a criticism
toward those criteria because initially
even before the concept of
schizophrenia uh Emil cre kpin in in
Germany uh coined the diagnosis or the
term uh of dementia precox
uh like um a form of dementia that was
appearing in very young people right so
he thought that the main feature of this
illness was uh actually having cognitive
significant important cognitive problems
now in thought but also in memory
attention and other cognitive uh
processes so uh an extensive body of of
uh of
research led by neuropsychologists and
cognitive
neuroscientists has um informed us that
uh most patients with schizophrenia have
uh significant cognitive problems even
before they receive medication yes
please so uh I wanted to ask you about
age of the patients the first episode of
um psychotic
experience generally observed in uh the
Adolescent time and sometimes in the
childhood so first the facts the fact is
that most people with schizophrenia will
will develop um the illness during their
late adolescence and during the their
You Youth I mean uh most cases cases
will will start between uh 20 years of
age until 30 years of age there are some
V there are some variants there but most
cases will be diagnosed uh in youth in
late adol ad adolescence and youth uh
schizophrenia in children is atypical
it's very atypical although um important
researchers have shown that it can be
the case some patients can develop
schizoph
in childhood but it's atypical and it it
is also atypical for per persons to
develop schizophrenia above for instance
40 years old there are forms of um late
onset schizophrenia but it it is also
atypical so whatever this problem is it
is linked to those uh ages no and there
are a number of scientific
hypothesis some hypothesis are psychos
social hypothesis other hypothesis are
even uh historical social um hypothesis
and and most hypothesis are a mix of
psychological and neuroscientific
hypothesis trying to explain why most
cases appear in in those ages now uh
regarding the the problem of genetics or
uh
acquired um acquired um
path causes pathology uh well so it has
been known for over 100 years that uh
most cases of schizophrenia present with
uh some form of familial
aggregation uh so there is a genetic
risk factor no uh for for for instance
the classic numbers would be that in the
general population the frequency of the
illness is somewhat Bel below
1% but if you have a first degree
relative then your risk is about 10% and
if you have for instance if you're two
father's uh your your father and your
mother uh your two parents have uh the
illness then the uh the risk is uh about
25% grossly
and if you have a monotic twin then your
risk is about 50% in some studies even
above no 70% there are some variability
in those numbers but uh what we can see
is that uh the close the closer the the
genetic uh pool is uh the higher the
risk becomes so
that is that is an important feature uh
the numbers vary some somehow but the
the the this figure remains all around
the world there are studies in Taiwan
studies in China studies in Latin
America in the US and Europe and all
around it it is mostly the same now the
problem is that a specific genetic cost
like uh an abnormal Gene a mutation in a
gene uh has not been
identified as happens in other genetic
uh problems like Huntington's disease no
in Huntington's disease you can say that
there is a mutation in a specific uh
Gene not in schizophrenia however there
are some uh genetic disturbances like um
disturbances in the 22 chromosome uh
that uh are linked to
have uh an increased risk like 10-fold
or 20 fold or even 50 fold risk of
having schizophrenia so I would say that
the genetic research is uh underway it
has not revealed a specific cause what
we have is mostly studies of genetic
epidemiology that are very strong but
they don't tell us the complete story so
there is also much skepticism about this
in some academic communities because it
can also be the case and and this is an
important hypothesis to consider that
some forms some cases of what we call
schizophrenia are linked to specific
genetic um problems or issues and some
cases perhaps are not some cases could
be more developmental so we need to go
to other risk factors besides the
genetic risk factors not so long ago I
found a great paper where researchers
compared uh risk development uh
schizophrenia between uh people who had
some uh genetical mut mutations that
were associated with schizophrenia and
cannabis
use and they found that the cannabis use
increases the risk to acquire
schizophrenia uh twofold fourfold higher
depending uh how often um people smoke
uh cannabis based uh substances so could
you please tell about cannabis because
I'm again I'm terrified by the wave of
legalization of cannabis also I'm living
in Europe it is uh true for Europe too
and I'm terrified how people IGN ignore
this scientific background and
scientific messages about the link of
cannabis use and
psychoses yeah yeah that that is exactly
right I think that the research in that
area is very robust so uh you you can
actually say that uh the use of cannabis
mainly the The Chronic and intense use
of cannabis uh is linked to uh an
increased risk RK two fold fourfold in
different studies there are different
numbers in different studies but it
increased significantly the risk uh of
having uh a psychotic episode the first
psychotic episode and more specifically
schizophrenia uh so my my message there
would be that it is very important for
um societies to consider this risk
factor mainly because it uh has been
seen that the early use of cannabis in
adolesence and young people is uh linked
to to this problem so uh it is a
especially vulnerable age for the use
specifically of cannabis I mean there
are studies linking other drugs no like
hallucinogens or um cocaine but the
stronger statistical relationship has
been uh uh disc discovered revealed
confirmed with uh cannabis so that is
another important risk factor now there
are other environmental or developmental
risk factors some are related uh to even
even to
the to the
intrauterine uh stage of development in
the second trimester of pregnancy uh
different and in in the second trimester
different um diseases like for instance
in uh infections by influenza or other
ill diseases of the mother confer an
increased risk of having a child with
schizophrenia so that that that is an
important factor also OB cetric problems
uh during the uh the the delivery of of
of of the child uh have an important um
statistical relationship with
schizophrenia so we have the
prenatal uh risk factors and the perinal
risk factors uh and the genetic risk
factors and we also have the um of
course the uh the use of of Canabis I
just recalled the story of nit n also
was
diagnosed also had
schizophrenia and as I found in uh
literature uh his psychiatrist uh linked
his disease with the very painful for
him um experience seeing uh cruel
attitude to the horse in the city so it
was very traumatic experience for him
which uh triggered later psychotic
episodes and now my question about
cruelty what is the role of cruelty
causing
schizophrenia yes so um I think there
there is many research on on that topic
uh relating what we would call
um uh adverse childhood experiences and
uh more more specifically
um um child
abuse child
mistreatment uh forms of physical
violence
uh even sexual violence in children or
or very young persons and the later
development of Psych of psychosis in as
as a general term um so yes it it is
also a a risk factor no as in all of
these cases I would said that none of
these risk factors are necessary and
sufficient conditions to develop
schizophrenia it looks like
schizophrenia is a multiactor
factorial condition in which you can
have a developmental problem perhaps
linked to prenatal or perinatal problems
or genetic risk factors and then uh the
adverse child experiences or the child
abuse the psychological trauma um the
experiences of psychological trauma
traumatic experiences in um early ages
can interact uh to form this specific uh
clinical problem no with this specific
characteristics for instance some
authors have thought that the content of
the delusions and the content of the
hallucinations as being negative
offensive uh uh and and and criticizing
the patient can be related to the to the
uh thisa experence the traumatic
experience and and and it is a plausible
uh hypotheses no so I I think we we need
to bring together all this uh risk
factors all these sources of analysis
and research and we need to engage in a
multidisciplinary research no because
some sometimes we see research that is
coming only from the field of
neurobiology or only from the field of
psychology yes I agree with you and
schizophrenia is not a pathology or one
gene or one protein or one uh network uh
currently like five hypothesis exist uh
uh which try to explain the pathology
the mechanisms of this pathology
actually uh which of them is your
favorite do you prefer depic Theory or
GIC
theory yes as I said no I I think uh we
don't have um a strong unified theory
linking all the facts together but my
guess by looking at the scientific
evidence is that um there is a genetic
risk there are uh developmental problems
linked to uh prenatal perinatal
obstetric and early age um risk factors
leading to uh a different uh kinds of NE
neurodevelopmental problems probably at
the level of uh neuronal migration no as
you know um neurons have to uh to
migrate during uh the prenatal
development so there might be problems
in neuronal migration leading to what we
call abnormal synaptic pruning and this
abnormal syap synaptic pruning can lead
also to problems at the level of brain
systems no for instance uh the large
studies that have been conducted by the
Enigma Consortium in all around the
world uh evaluating almost uh 10,000
patients with schizophrenia with very
strong uh neuroimaging methods revealed
that there were uh different um
abnormalities structural abnormalities
not in every patient with schizophrenia
but in a significant amount of them and
more specifically that this uh and
disturbances in the structural aspects
of brain systems uh involved mainly uh
the frontal loes of the patient
bilaterally uh and also the the temporal
loes specifically the hypoc campus the
amigdala the lateral temporal cortex and
the medial frontal cortex seem to be uh
seem to to show abnormalities ranging
from the mild to the moderate um size
effect in those International
collaborations so so so I think there is
a plausibility for um neurobiological
abnormalities contributing to the to the
clinical syndrome and uh also that all
these uh issues are leading to a
disregulation in dopaminergic systems
well yes there are uh large uh
metanalysis uh of uh studies in that
have been done in patients not not in
animal models but in patients with um
the these technologies that are called
um positron emission tomography right so
the metanalysis shows that an abnormal
synthesis in in in dopamine an increased
synthesis in dopamine in the in the
Statum which is a part a subcortical
part of the brain um in in that area of
the brain there is an increased
synthesis before uh or in the transition
to psychosis uh in patients with
schizophrenia so so that is a a I would
not even call it an hypothesis but a
fact no that has been shown by
research but my warning is that all
these facts that we are putting together
are uh are facts that have been shown at
the group level at the group level no
when we compare groups of patients with
schizophrenia against groups of healthy
people or people without schizophrenia
so uh it is quite possible though even
that um some patients do not have that
uh abnormalities so that is why none of
these are diagnostic markers so and and
that is why also there are still some
controversies around this this clinical
problem uh that there is not a consensus
to call this a neurological disease
though it is still considered a
psychiatric or a mental illness uh and
with a strong neurobiological facts and
all sorts of neurocognitive and clinical
facts but I think that the most H honest
picture is to say that it is still under
research and my particular take is that
perhaps it is a category in which we can
see many different kinds of problems
some will be diseases even genetic
diseases and other will be perhaps uh
more forms of neuro Divergence now like
they call or
psychological U diversity perhaps
unfortunately we don't have much time
but it is a great pleasure to talk with
you and you mentioned um autoimmune
psychosis I think we need to schedule
another meeting where you will tell
about
ioses and where you will tell uh about
Milan creativa right so I I I'm eager to
hear about your
book um but for
now please tell which three
things uh help you to stay so
enthusiastic energetic uh in this field
because neuros Psychiatry is a quite
hard uh profession
because each day you working with uh
someone's pain so what helps you to stay
so viate and Alive three things okay I I
I I will say three things about this and
related specifically to psychosis and
and schizophrenia no the first message
the first message would be for for the
patients or for for the uh for the
relatives no for those who suffer
directly or very close this this problem
I I would say that there there are
reasonable uh there are reasons to have
hope no in in which sense that not all
cases of
schizophrenia uh are um leading to um to
a pervasive form of uh cognitive
dysfunction of Dementia or or uh
uh disability leading to U leading an
impossible life no uh many patients
recover many patients improve many
patients have meaningful lives uh in in
different forms so uh of course I think
that the medical and psychological
treatments are will help uh um will help
in in in this matter right um
but I think there are reasons to have
hope uh the second message would be to
colleagues no uh I think that we need to
take schizophrenia seriously both at a
scientific level but also at um at the
level of personal relationship no with
our patients to treat them as persons
never as objects of of uh of inquir only
as persons no uh but also we need to
take schizophrenia seriously from a
scientific uh perspective because the
story is not over and uh we we need to
to be very serious rigorous in their
research and the third message would be
for those that are considering studying
this kind of problems engaging in a
career in neurology psychiat
Neuroscience
psychologist I I would say that this
field is um really stimulating it is uh
a fascinating field uh fooled with uh a
lot of intellectual challenges also uh
challenges for for us at the level of uh
emotions at the level of our own
personalities so it is a challenging
field but very stimulating and we can
make a small difference perhaps uh but
but we can make a difference by making
research or or clinical work or even
philosophical work so so that would be
my
message thank you very much Jesus