Cultural expertise and witchcraft in Africa - Soazick Kerneis
1 Video View·Aug 4, 2025
Explore the legal challenges linked to witchcraft case law in Africa with Soazick Kerneis, a history of law professor and Director of the Center for the Study of History and Anthropology of Law at the University of Paris Nanterre. Delve into the difficulties of proving witchcraft, the role of cultural expertise, and the impact of colonisation. Watch now to gain unique insights into this fascinating intersection of law and culture.
I'm not an expert, I'm an academic. I teach History of Law at the University of Paris-Nanterre.
And one of my topics deals with alternative dispute resolution.
And I've been fascinated by the current legal issues linked with witchcraft, mostly in Africa.
And I will review some of the difficulties linked to the proof of witchcraft
and I would be very grateful to collect your opinions related to the question of expertise
in this case. Since the end of the 70s, witchcraft has become a real problem for society, mostly in
Africa. The main question is whether the law can grasp the disputes linked to witchcraft.
The answer is difficult because it obviously leads to a confrontation of different ways of thinking.
Is it possible for the law to take into consideration invisible actions? In sub-Saharan
Africa, following French colonial law, many states penalise witchcraft and if a charge is made,
the judge will have to make a decision. But what about the definition of witchcraft?
Of course, it is impossible to give a definition and it is often pointed out
that there is a serious break with the principle of penal law.
But another difficulty concerns proof. How to prove witchcraft? This is where expertise comes
in. Which experts are called and for what kind of expertise? Expertise can be given
by skilled scientists trained in Western knowledge. This is often the case in the
context of international organisations, institutions in charge of refugees.
Islam seekers sometimes invoke the persecution of a witch. The claims are often inconsistent
and have no meaning for the people in charge of the application because there is a deep gap
between the representation of the applicants and the basic concepts of Western law,
whether it be individual responsibility or causality. The applicant knows he has to
prove the veracity of his story and to show he is telling the truth. So that sometimes
he exhibits objects, fetishes and often his body as well with scars resulting from heavy actions.
The cultural gap is then obvious. When questioned, the applicant speaks of spiritual attacks.
But can spiritual attacks constitute acts of torture? When the lawyers relate the client's
stories, they speak of sex, sacrifice, occult rituals, a discourse built on colonial stereotypes.
The claims usually fail as the commission considers that it is only superstition without any
reality. These cases illustrate the epistemological misunderstanding posed by witchcraft.
The rejection of the application illustrates the devaluation of the subjective knowledge,
to use Michel Foucault's expressions, that cannot be grasped by a dominant legal culture.
The expert is most often a doctor who concludes to a persecutory delusion, bringing the case
back to knowledge established in Western countries. Cultural experts may have been
asked about the meaning of the scars or lesions on the body, or whether to check if the claimant's
account corresponds to knowledge shared in his country of origin. But as Roberto Benedetti
suggests, an author I have used here, the question is whether international law should be open to
cultural otherness, whether the legal protection of human rights should take into account the
applicant's cultural tradition. In other words, should the anthropologist expertise lead the
judge to consider that the formula, it happens spiritually, may suggest a form of torture,
a persecution that opens to isolation. In Africa, post-colonial studies have rooted the idea that
law should take into account cultural identities. In sub-Saharan Africa, accusations of witchcraft
have increased considerably in recent years. Many states denounce the laxity of colonial justice,
refusing to condemn on the grounds that there is no proof, only representation, only supposition,
would be a colonial attitude opposite to African reality. The law should be decolonized by giving
it a cultural dimension and considering African realities. Justice as well should be decolonized
by calling on local knowledge. The magistrate from the Republic of Cameroon thus urges African
juries to ban colonial means of proof and encourage them to follow up what has been used
in the past in these cases. It is easy to see the impact of the Indian anthropologist
Shiv Viswanathan, who insists on the idea of cognitive justice. Against the sole knowledge
of experts trained on the Western model, it is necessary to emphasize the plurality of knowledge
and to value traditional expertise. The idea is, therefore, that since witchcraft is an African
reality, its proof can only be provided by local experts who are the custodians of traditional
knowledge. In fact, in countries such as Cameroon, South Africa, Republic and Northern Gabon,
police stations and courts may call upon traditional healers, diviners and witch doctors
who intervene as experts at the courts. Using witch doctors as experts is yet dangerous.
When they begin their expertise in court, they do not hesitate to claim they are witches,
I am a witch, and it is quite surprising that the expertise of a witch is used by a judge
to condemn a witch. Many scholars also denounce the position of authority acquired by these witch
doctors. They have offices, sell their services to the highest bidder, drive often big cars,
big Mercedes, and are proud to say they have been educated in the West. Their role is now crucial
as they belong to the judicial staff. They are the ones who prosecute, they are the ones who
push for a confession, and they are the ones who testify before the judge. Many lawyers
criticize the preponderance of witch doctors, pointing out the loss of meaning of law.
Law means a register of truth linked to the reality of facts. So that rather than experts
with you, isn't it better to involve an anthropologist who can enlighten the judge
on the cultural context of witchcraft? More generally, anthropologists and legal historians
as well must point out the ravages of witchcraft today and show that it is not an African reality,
but rather a by-product of colonization that must be analyzed in terms of domination.
Installing the witch doctor is to give power to a witch. Is it really useful? Thank you.

