THEWOR~1.

Observable Universe
8 followers
28 Video Views·Aug 4, 2025
The theory clearly works. You don't get to negotiate with Newtonian gravity.
The fact that it has these flaws, if you want to put it that way, these shortcomings,
these mysteries, like, just indicates there's something deeper. And in this case,
the deeper thing is a revolution.
Does the invention of dark energy and the incorrect vacuum energy prediction
indicate something is fundamentally wrong with our scientific theories?
And again, our panelists, which have three minutes, I'll begin with Claudia Durham.
Hi, thank you. Thanks. Thanks a lot, Jacob. That's really great to be here.
Thanks for being here. So let me just start by saying that we may think of
the vacuum energy or the cosmological constant problem or dark energy as being a new problem
that just comes up from observations or from a discrepancy between quantum mechanics and gravity.
But in fact, it's much older than that. You correctly say it's 100 years old. It's even
120 years old puzzle. So it's really been with us since modern physics, since the past century.
Already Lodge said in 1907, so before general relativity, he understood that in the vacuum,
there was a possibility of creating electron, anti-electrons, particles, anti-particles.
So in nothingness, there must be some kind of energy out there, which already at the time,
he understood in 1907, must correspond to some source of energy. Now, at the time before
general relativity, that energy was thought to be nothingness and had no relevance to reality.
But since the inspection of general relativity in 1915 by Einstein, it's understood that even
nothingness, even something which may be seen as just a zero level of energy, does have an effect
on gravity, does have an effect on our geometry, and therefore has some element of reality.
And so this is really where the puzzle started coming in and understanding whether this vacuumness,
this energy which is present everywhere in this room, but also in the middle of nowhere in the
universe, may have an effect on the evolution of the universe. And already in 1920, thanks to
Nernst in 1927, thanks to Lenz, it was understood that if we just took into account the effect from
electrons, which we know are particles, it's not something that I'm just making up,
they are particles, we understand their mass extremely well, they should have an effect on
the curvature of space-time, which was meaning that at the time, already in 1927,
it would stretch space-time so much that we shouldn't even be able to see the moon.
That's already been stated in 1927, and by the time balance. It's often credited to Pauli,
but that's something already quite old, and really very much at the beginning of quantum mechanics.
So this has been with us for a long, long time. I would say it's slightly misleading to say that
it's necessarily 120 orders of magnitude discrepancy with the standard model,
because it's only if we consider that there should be particles out there,
which have a mass all the way up to the Planck scale, all the way up to the scale of quantum
gravity, and they would backtrack on our geometry, that there would be 120 orders of magnitude
discrepancy. So the discrepancy with the standard model is not at all that high. And in fact,
there's not necessarily a discrepancy, because it's nothingness, in some sense, the energy present
in there. If we use our current tools of quantum mechanics, and really quantum field theory,
they should say that there's an infinite amount of energy out there. So we need to understand how
to make sense of this infiniteness. And with the tools that we have at our disposal at the moment,
we earned an impression that we should still have a level of energy present in the vacuum,
which is far too high, as compared to our current observation, that should lead to an
accelerated expansion of the universe. Thanks, Claudia. Bjorn, please go ahead.
Thank you. So I would argue that dark energy is a symptom of a deeper malaise within the whole
structure of the cosmological model. And dark energy is not the only invention to make this
theoretical framework kind of build up. Cosmology is unlike many other sciences,
it really operates at the limit of knowledge. And as your introduction made clear, we're talking
about orders of magnitude that are so vast, that it really boggles the mind to think about how
the scales of it all. Now, to put this just in context, the Einsteinian general relativity
model we have for the universe is, if we look at the empirical evidence we have,
the confidence we have of how far it reaches beyond our own solar system and into our galaxy,
it's been estimated that that would account for about 0.1% of the total of the universe,
in which we're reasonably confident that the Einsteinian model actually holds.
I mentioned this at the outset, because it's important to understand the scales and the
intrepid endeavor of these very esteemed physicists on the site here, anyone working
on cosmology, are up against a giant mystery. And just the very idea that we are able to
know it all fully and have a universal mathematical model that will map it all out,
is a core belief in the history of science and a core belief in cosmology itself that
runs the discipline. However, when you come up against discrepancies like these ones that are
debatable, but inventions like dark energy, it becomes clear that this theoretical framework
of cosmology is really built up on multiple theories. It's not just one theory, I've
previously, I tend to refer to it as a kind of a Jenga tower, it's like a wobbly tower of multiple
building blocks on top of each other. Dark energy is one of the more recent ones to account for
this fundamental observation and the discrepancy with the existing theoretical model. So all of
these endeavors and these inventions, they are really there to make the model work,
because they save the overall theoretical framework. There's a deep reluctance within
cosmology and almost an impossibility to actually rethink the model from the core,
because cosmology has become kind of dependent on some of the core assumptions.
So that would be from the outset, I think, a reason to question how well we actually know
the kinds of things that we claim to know. Thank you, Bjorn. Raphael?
Thank you so much. It's a pleasure to be here. I would perhaps say that I would hope that there
is something fundamentally wrong with physics. We should be so lucky. That's how physics makes
progress. And I want to maybe compare this allegedly so terrible prediction to other
situations that physicists have faced in the past that led to a lot of progress.
So for example, when Newton invented the gravitational force as a way of unifying
the heavens and the earth and explaining why the apple falls and how the planets move,
I mean, that was a great breakthrough. But you could legitimately complain that he just made
something up, this force. What is this thing supposed to be? What is it really? It's a
mathematical construct. It's a formula you use to calculate stuff, but it gets us to the moon.
And we still use it for almost all situations in which we want to know what gravity will do.
Worse than that, he had to infinitely fine-tune his theory. He had to say that the thing that
gravitates and the thing that resists pushing, the inertial mass and the gravitational mass,
are exactly the same thing. They're proportional to one another. We don't see that in other
theories. The electrical charge is not the same thing as the inertial mass, and that's why
some people feel electricity. Some people, yes. Some particles feel electricity and some don't.
And so we could have had all these complaints that the theory is rotten to the core.
We just usually don't frame it that way. We frame it as an opportunity to think about what might
come next. The theory clearly works. You don't get to negotiate with Newtonian gravity.
And so the fact that it has these flaws, if you want to put it that way, these shortcomings,
these mysteries, just indicates there's something deeper. And in this case,
the deeper thing is a revolution. Einstein discovered that gravity is, at a more fundamental
level, the curvature of space and time, and that things just try to move as straight as they can
in that curved space-time. And in that language, it's not a force at all. And we know that language
is better because it describes more different things, but also everything that Newton was able
to describe. But in that, we see that the language that we use, even in our most successful theories,
is always temporary. And the shortcomings of a strong theory that makes lots of predictions
are an opportunity. Another example was at the end of the 19th century, people had this wonderful
theory called thermodynamics, and it explained the steam engine and a lot of other things,
and it was clearly extremely successful. But again, it had a fatal flaw. It predicted that
this table should radiate an infinite amount of energy. It's about the same level. I mean,
so this is why this is maybe not the worst prediction in the history of science that
we're talking about today. To continue watching this video, click the link in the top left or
in the description below. With a free trial, you can enjoy the full talk and thousands more.
Thank you for being part of the conversation.
