A detailed look at how to identify and date the various parts of a mediaeval English Gothic building.
This session looks at how the master masons of the Middle Ages moved away from the Norman or Romanesque style of construction, and began to develop the uniquely English styles we now recognise in countless towns and villages across the country.
Beginning with its origins in Norman architecture, I talk you through the main developments of window tracery, through the Early English, Decorated and Perpendicular periods, building up your knowledge of what to look for and how to read these ancient and beautiful buildings.
After watching this video you too will be able to work out the age of a church, and impress your friends with your knowledge of mediaeval ecclesiastical design.
Perhaps the perfect image to reflect that very English music by the composer
Vaughan Williams is this very English scene looking out over very English
countryside. For anybody who's grown up in this country these are very familiar
images indeed. The site of a church, an ancient medieval church, surrounded by
very old trees, perhaps a farmstead nearby, perhaps a little village huddling
around the church itself. These wonderful ancient buildings dappled
with sunlight, their walls covered with lichen and in their graveyards and
surrounded by the graves and the tombstones of the locals. But how is it
that we make sense of these buildings? How do we try to understand these
complex buildings which sit in our landscape looking harmonious and very
much at one and unified within the familiar scenes and yet which were built
over a long period of time often in different styles and with parts of them
being replaced by later designs, later styles, later fashions. Hello and welcome
to another session of Lockdown Learning with me Paul Holland. Today we're talking
about Gothic architecture, that fantastic style that was developed in
the late Middle Ages based on the pointed arch particularly. Today's
session is concentrating specifically on English styles, partly to look at not so
much how different it is from the other styles, the French and the German and the
Spanish, but specifically to look at how in England there were three different
stages, three different styles that developed and how we can recognize them
from each other. They're very distinct and they're very English as well. Gothic
is the period of architecture, probably the first period of architecture in
history, where we really have a distinctive difference between the
nations. There's definitely a German, definitely a French Gothic style,
there's definitely that's different from the Spanish, from the Italian and England
particularly developed its own insular forms, its own particular varieties and
characteristics, but it does fall into three very distinct stages and not only
is this lovely to be able to recognize when you're out and about and you can
spot the different stages, they're very very distinctive, they're very easy to
recognize, it also means once you get quite good at this that you can date a
building or at least a part of a building often to within about 50 years
of its actual time of construction, which is quite a nice thing to be
able to do as you're out and about. So let's have a look at how this whole
style developed. We're going to take it right the way back to Norman
architecture because there's plenty of churches in this country where we can
still spot Norman, here it is. This is the style which on the continent is called
Romanesque and it is absolutely dominated by the round arch and it's at
this point really that it's worth mentioning that most of what we'll be
looking at today in this session is based on the arch and therefore the
window and the doorway because that's the real key way of identifying a
particular style from English architecture from the from the Middle
Ages and so although there's a few other little bits and pieces that you can look
at and we look at that towards the end it's it's the arch and the shape of the
arch and the window in particular that we'll be concentrating on. It's worth me
also mentioning that we will be mainly looking at ecclesiastical architecture
so it's churches, it's cathedrals. Why is that? They're the only things that
survived. The poor people of the period lived in very flimsy houses made of wood
or wattle and daub. They certainly haven't come down to us. The rich lived
in their castles. They probably, not only are they often quite ruined
nowadays, they just didn't get as much attention lavished on them as the
churches. Perhaps because of the religious fervor of that period it's the
churches that were given the most attention and therefore it's to those
that we look for the finest of the architecture from this period. So let's
have a look again at that round arch, that semicircular arch that the Normans
brought across with them when they came in the 11th century. This is why we call
it Norman architecture not Romanesque. The arch has been in use since Roman times.
It's made with a single point if you have your pair of compasses and it forms
a semicircle. It's as simple as that and you can see from this particular photo
this is the outside of the building that we saw before and you can see the
basic structure of it is made up of round arches. As you can see they've been
filled in and the ones at the bottom have had extra new sort of later windows
inserted into them but the basic structure of this building is Norman and
you can see that from the round arches. And in fact not all buildings survived
intact from this period but little bits do survive. So sometimes you'll walk into
a church and you'll notice that the entrance hasn't been replaced with the
latest Gothic. It was kept in place and therefore you can identify as Norman
from this period. And particularly if the stonework is old and looks really quite
weathered and if it has these dog-tooth patterns and zigzag patterns around the
top then that identifies it as Norman. Even if it's just a little doorway set
into the wall of a church then you are standing in front of something that is
just under 1,000 years old. They become quite elaborate as the centuries
progress. This one's in Malmesbury and and it's a very fine example of a
Norman doorway and as you as you look more closely you can see as well as the
geometric and zigzag patterns you've got lots of very elegant swirling
designs and lots of sculpture based on the Holy Scripture. So now we come to
Gothic which began in the 13th century. Lots of people still not quite sure why
it started. Some people think that the Crusaders having visited the Holy Land
brought back the idea of the pointed arch. The pointed arch is just generally
much more flexible. You can have wide ones and you can have narrow ones so
that makes it a much more flexible element of design. So here on this
diagram you can see that the Norman vault is unfortunately restricted by the
fact that it's a semicircle and the semicircle always has to be the same
height whereas a Gothic vault using the pointed arch can vault, it can span
across wider and much more narrow spaces making it much much more flexible.
And it's based on the two-point arch. In other words you're using your pair of
compasses now twice to make two separate arches which intersect like this. So
whatever the origins of the pointed arch and when it arrived in Europe it must
have looked really quite new, quite jagged and jarring. It caught on very
quickly and was very very swiftly adopted throughout the church building
at the time. So in England we tend to divide our Gothic period into three
distinct periods. This was begun by the early 19th century architect Thomas
Rickman. Since then people have tried to change the system. Some people say it
doesn't quite work. Actually on the whole it works quite nicely and that is
because you have early English taken up the 13th century then decorated in the
14th century and perpendicular in the 15th century. Early English tends to be
very simple, very plain, quite elegant but ordered. There tends to be little
decoration and it tends to be quite two-dimensional. Decorated is much more
flamboyant. It's much more interested in complexity and curves and shapes and
geometrical design. And finally perpendicular which is really very
uniquely English. The other two previous styles you can see their equivalents on
the continent in the French rayonnant style and the flamboyant style but
perpendicular is is very distinctively English. It doesn't exist at all on the
continent. It's based on much more use of horizontals along with verticals to
create panelling and also the use of a flat arch or a four-point arch which
which we'll look at when we get to it. So let's have a look at some examples of
the beginnings of early English. This first picture is a little bit of a fake.
It's basically the locals have decided that they wanted to replace their
Norman arch with a pointed arch so they've taken apart the old Norman arch
which you can see is Norman from the zigzag patterns and they've cut it in
two and they've put it together to make a pointed arch much much more
fashionable which is which is good fun and you see that in a few churches
around the country where they've reused the Norman materials. But by the time we
reach the the height of Gothic this is a picture from the town of Stamford. This
is St Mary's in that town. This is a very fine town church and you can see the
architects really playing with the new pointed arch all the way up the walls
there of the tower sometimes using circles sometimes using extra sort of
cusps at the very top there of the photo. All of those on on the on the left face
of the tower are blind arches they don't have windows behind them so you can see
the architects using these designs now purely for embellishment and for
decoration. And if you look at the tower from a distance here it is you can see a
very unified very beautiful composition leading up to those three windows at the
top of the tower with their lancet arches. So what we tend to find in early
English architecture is a repetition of the lancet arch and that means those
very tall thin single arches. Okay we saw them on the side of the tower you can
see them going all the way up the front of the tower. When you go into the
countryside and you find smaller village churches that couldn't afford such
complex architecture you can still identify this as early English. Look at
the windows they are single lancet windows very plain nothing particular to
distract your attention from the the simplicity and the elegance. Very often
in early English you see them grouped in threes or even more and this is the
beginning of what we call tracery so you have two or three or four lancet windows
put together and then you've got some space above which you you add an extra
window or hole or a circle in and then you can add more of those and then
suddenly you've ended up with one large window with lots of lights. Those
vertical pieces of stone that separate the individual lancet windows are now
called mullions and mullions are going to be one of the big features that
you'll notice as we move towards the decorated style. So here's a lovely
example of a decorated window from the 14th century this is in Westenbert
school chapel and you'll notice if we look at it more closely that what
started out as three individual windows has become one large window with
beautiful complex tracery at the top and because the tracery here is quite
curvilinear there's lots of sort of flame shapes lots of swirling shapes we
can identify this is quite late decorated so you can put this into the
second half of the 14th century so something from 1350 to 1380. So here are
some more examples of decorated windows as you can see they've all become much
bigger now they let much more light in but the tracery has become much more
complex and it seems to just enjoy the sheer exuberance of making patterns and
interlocking shapes and swirling forms. So this is Malmesbury which we saw
earlier on you can recognize hopefully the Norman entrance at the end of the
path that huge semicircular arch but if you look at the rest of the building
most of the windows here show elements of the decorated style and just looking
at a few of them more closely you can see that the architects are reveling in
the complexity and the and the playfulness if you like of of the new
style of architecture and just to the side of the building this is one of the
main windows you can see a really fine example of decorated late decorated
curvilinear style actually the stuff at the bottom has those circles within
circles that's much more geometric that that's a real feature from the early
decorated period so the beginning of the 14th century but this this architect has
combined them beautifully with lots of other sort of complex patterns above them
so the whole thing forms a really superb unified whole and you can see
endless variations on these patterns and this next example is quite interesting
it shows the transition from decorated to the last style the perpendicular on
the right so there's a decorated window on the left with a complex pattern
inside the arch but the one on the right is perpendicular so what makes the
perpendicular style distinctive well it comes down to those vertical pieces of
stone that I mentioned those mullions if you look at this window which is a
perfectly good example of a simple village church perpendicular window
you'll notice that the mullions go right to the top they're uninterrupted more
or less uninterrupted and in most perpendicular windows from the very
bottom all the way up to the top of the arch and the tracery is complex and it
weaves in and out of those vertical mullions but they're always there and
they provide if you like a sense of uniformity and stability that unifies
the whole window and it could be argued that because those mullions go right to
the top they bring a complete unity to the window and and that that is in some
ways quite satisfying some people find that the decorated style although it's
it's wonderfully playful and fantastical with all of its curves and shapes in
actual fact the exuberance becomes almost overbearing whereas in the
perpendicular style there's there's a wonderful sense of unity and uniformity
which you'll see in some of the examples that we come up with next they also tend
to let a lot more light in and one of the reasons for this is that the
perpendicular style begins to develop something called the four-point arch so
here's the four-point arch and as you can see now although it's still pointed
it's much more shallow so it has two very tight arcs at the corners at the
spring of the arch if you like at the bottom where it springs from the
verticals and then the the whole thing is finished off with two much more
shallow arcs now these much more shallow arches are really suited to
perpendicular if you look at this church you'll see that the perpendicular style
is is actually quite interested in the horizontals we've not just got mullions
now going vertically up the windows we've actually got these transoms going
horizontally across as well and will increasingly find that in perpendicular
architecture and because there's this emphasis on the horizontal and because
these transoms and mullions create if you like panels square rectangular
panels then we increasingly see much more of a sort of square shape
rectangular shape within the patterns of perpendicular architecture and that's
probably why it's called perpendicular as well so if we look at a few examples
of perpendicular churches now you'll be able to see exactly what I'm talking
about the mullions going right to the top of the windows of the arches and the
arches being quite wide still quite varied there was a lot of discussion in
I think the Victorian times or the early 20th century in which critics said that
the perpendicular was very boring it was very mass-manufactured if you like for
that period but actually I find there's a huge amount of variety just look at
the arches on the right-hand side of the picture for example they are now
back to two-point arches but they come to corners instead of round springs so
they're segmented arches but they're still gothic they've still got a huge
amount of character to them here's an example from the north of England this
is Cartmel Priory just look at the size of that huge perpendicular window on the
left but it's equally suited to the smaller window in the middle there which
is again a segmented arch I don't think that's even a two-point arch I think
that's a single point arch so there's a lot of inventiveness in the
perpendicular period which I think people often overlook and you can also
see can you on that left-hand picture a huge horizontal line a transom which
just breaks up the amount of glass and somehow softens the whole effect in a
way that that just suits the English temperament of restraint we tend not to
go from dramatic soaring verticals like they do on the continent we tend to try
to temper that a little bit with a lot more horizontals you don't just find the
perpendicular windows in the large projects the big cathedrals and churches
you find them all across the country most little parish churches had new
windows fitted in the latest perpendicular style and that's why in a
way this is probably the most familiar for you as you wander around the
villages of England and very often they were inserted into much older buildings
which I think we've already seen haven't we in binham priory here in
Norfolk where although the structure is Norman they've inserted new windows the
interiors of these churches are also very often light and airy particularly
those ones built in Norfolk and the West Country that what the Cotswolds these
are often called wool churches they were built with the money made from wool in
the Middle Ages a huge sheep producing areas and and wool was exported all
across Europe and the money was used to build these fantastic town churches
which as you can see let a huge amount of light in there's more glass than
stone really and the windows at the back again massive windows very flat arches
letting as much light in as possible there's also in the perpendicular style
a real interest in moldings again these are very much emphasizing the horizontal
this is very typical of the perpendicular style so you have a lot of
elements running around the church and around the windows and you've also got a
lot more paneling and in some parts of the country like in the east where they
use flint this paneling is is wonderfully executed in two dimensions
you can see on the left there the mixture of stone and flint and then all
the way along the bottom the base of the of the of the church you've got this
paneling which echoes the paneling of the windows as well and they also enjoy
using battlements the no military purpose at all but you see in this
period a lot more use of battlements or embrasures I think this is quite a good
picture to show how Gothic architecture works really well in terms of having
different size arches and different forms of arches and even sitting at
slightly different heights but somehow working well together and forming a
really unified composition and those wider flatter arches that we see in
perpendicular reach their their final expression if you like in these square
windows which effectively are still perpendicular they're very late
perpendicular don't forget that the perpendicular style goes right through
beyond the 15th century into the Tudor period and for that reason it's not just
the 15th century it's into the 16th century at the time that the Italians
and the French were rediscovering the delights of the Greek and the Roman
styles of architecture in the Renaissance the English were still
producing these wonderful works of late Gothic architecture you've probably
spotted in a couple of the pictures that I've put up how the perpendicular
style seems to enjoy making a feature of the tower some stunning spectacular
examples around the country particularly recommend the Somerset Towers anywhere
towards the west of Wiltshire and into Gloucestershire and all the way down
towards the West Country you've got a superb collection of hundreds and
hundreds of perpendicular towers which again seem to make a real feature of
this panelling so the panelling that you can see in the big windows there is
echoed in the panelling of the stonework all around the tower one of my favourite
churches is in in North Norfolk this is Terrington St. Clement and it just it
just forms such a wonderful unity despite the fact that there are so many
variants and and different forms within this particular building and there's a
just a glimpse that you can see of a massive east window there on the right
hand side huge perpendicular thing letting the light in but the light if
you think about it is coming from every single direction including above the
nave where it meets the chancel if you can see right in the middle of the
picture at the top you can see another huge window which actually you can't
really appreciate until you're inside the church just finishing here with a
picture of Gloucester Cathedral from the cloisters in which you can see a huge
amount of perpendicular reworking of an originally Norman Cathedral there's lots
of hints of that if you look at the tops of those pinnacles on the left you can
see some Norman or transitional early English elements and you can see a
Norman chapter house on the left with the semicircular arches but then the
rest of the building has had these huge windows inserted all of them are
wonderfully perpendicular and the tower as well is a fine example of a
perpendicular Gothic tower. Something else you might want to consider when you
walk inside the church is the roof. Many early churches even a lot of later
churches just kept it very simple with a wooden roof sometimes embellishing them
with hammer beam elements and as you can just see there some angels resting on
the top of the individual hammer beams so this is very typical of an English
church a wooden roof is lighter it's cheaper but they do burn down given that
candles were used inside so so very often the roofs were replaced with stone
vaults and increasingly in English architecture possibly because we weren't
building as high as in France and Germany therefore you can see the
details more possibly we began to really embellish our vaults we put lots of
lovely little details on we added extra ribs so that you didn't just have the
basic vault but you have these extra ribs linking them and interlinking these
are called Lyon vaults and the English are particularly famous for them and
they arrive in the decorated period primarily so from the from the 14th
century onwards and they become increasingly complicated until you reach
wonderful Lyon vaulting that you can see here in the nave of Norwich Cathedral
and then finally just to finish it off obviously the final expression of this
is in the perpendicular style with fan vaulting because they look like fans and
here's an example or two still using the panel if you like as the basic
element so it's a kind of modular system of paneling all the way down good that's
English Gothic architecture hopefully explained in a way that means whenever
you come across a church in town or country you'll be able to identify which
bits are from which period just a word of warning quite a lot of churches were
remodeled during the Victorian times this often results in them actually
having quite sort of Victorian forms of what you've just been studying here with
me and obviously quite a lot of Victorian churches were built from
scratch especially for the big cities where they're growing populations during
the Victorian period the 19th century with growing urbanization so it's always
worth spotting the nature of the stonework does it look does it look
actually machine cut does it look too perfect if it is it's probably Victorian
but the Victorians generally especially the good architects were designing their
churches based on specific styles from the Gothic period so you can still
identify the style even if you've got to be a little bit wary that it's not
actually as old as you thought it was when you first glimpsed it from a
distance good I hope that was interesting I hope you are confident in
reading your church architecture now in England at least if you enjoyed it
please subscribe and I look forward to seeing you in another session of lockdown
learning check out what else is on my playlist for art history and a number of
other bits and pieces thank you goodbye