HistoryHit 歷史學家Dan Snow點評電影里的250年戰場演化P.1
王者风范
22粉絲
2 次觀看·2025年8月5日
用長線戰鬥 讓所有人的肚臍都能帶到戰場
你會看到 即使是1860年代
男人仍然在戰爭中前進 肩對肩
正如他們的祖先在戰爭中所做的
有趣的武器用途
我們有現代的手榴彈和手榴彈
應該是英國人提供的
但你也會有邊緣武器
例如他們的劍
還有更加傳統的武器
用在阿拉伯族
我是Dan Snow
我今天要來看看
世界上最棒的戰爭電影
是關於戰場的變化
在過去的250年
《國王》
首先 注意到男人的線條
幾乎所有人都在兩側
擁有黃色的肩膀
一個順滑的肩膀
能夠擊中目標
在100米 甚至300米
但你嘗試使用它
在50米的距離
向著彼此移動
彼此近距離發射
然後你看到那些鋼彈
那些鋼彈
拿在肩膀上
當你發射了幾枚手榴彈
你會進入對手
並對手發射冷鋼彈
英國人穿著著名的紅色褲子
其實在戰爭的時候
很多人都穿著綠色褲子
因為他們是從美國出生的
但這並不重要
這就是紅色褲子的英國人
他們穿著紅色褲子
因為那是最便宜的褲子
最便宜的褲子
也許你不會看到血
對你的同伴來說
發射
你會看到Mel Gibson
飾演殲滅戰士
他叫做Benjamin Martin
他有三、四個不同的角色
混合在一起
他是一個普通人
他會發射炸彈
炸彈是英國人的弱點
主要是基於一位叫Francis Marion的角色
他被英國人稱為蜘蛛人
這是一個很棒的18世紀戰爭場景
你有軍隊
帶著平滑的蜘蛛人
帶著橡皮筋在上面
進行戰鬥
他們會在近距離的位置發射炸彈
那些蜘蛛人
你可能會擊中200米的敵人
但大多數你會擊中
100米甚至50米的敵人
然後向他們發射炸彈
直到他們眼睛的白色部分
發射
在長線發射炸彈
讓所有人的蜘蛛人都被擊中
那些蜘蛛人的炸彈
會成為一個強大的範圍武器
那裡有一個很棒的畫面
你會看到蜘蛛人在滾動
在地上滾動
你會嘗試把蜘蛛人從地面滾動
他們可以把所有人的檔案都摧毀
這個英國軍官
被描述為絕對邪惡
他的名字叫Tavington
我們認為他基於Tarlton
Tarlton確實是一個
極端的英國軍官
絕對沒有疑問
他指揮了一群人
他們其實是美國人
他們在美國出生
恩森在這場戰爭中非常重要
戰場被煙消滅
很混亂
你會看到有很多人在那邊滾動
很多人被包圍在一個小區域
那些顏色讓那些人
去決定自己的位置
那些顏色可能是國際色
例如美國的旗
也可能是軍隊色
告訴你你的隊伍在哪裡
你就可以加入你的隊伍
維持一些和諧
所以是真的
旗是非常重要的
有趣的是
你可以看到一些
美國人
顏色人物
描繪在美國人身上
有幾個人
他們都是奴隸
和前奴隸
為美國人戰鬥
但其實
有更多顏色人物
為英國人戰鬥
英國人發表了宣誓
維吉尼亞總統
發表了宣誓
說任何前奴隸
或逃離奴隸
或奴隸
簽名為國王
都會得到他們的自由
你得把旗翻過來
我夢寐以求的
早在70-81年
美國戰爭的主要行動
其實是在南部的殖民地
是在北加州和南加州
英國人認為
那裡有很多忠誠的國家
他們稱之為土耳其人
他們會保留
他們對國王的忠誠
那裡是富裕的殖民地
如果他們能夠
掌握他們
就能破壞
美國獨立運動的背後
所以真的
有兩種戰爭
正在發生
一種是不平等的戰鬥
在鄉村和農場
河流和森林
另一種是
兩艘軍隊
正式對抗
所以你會得到
一種全面的戰鬥
另一種就是
酷酷酷酷的
謀殺和襲擊
在這些殖民地
我需要準確度和精準度
準備好
這就顯示了不平等的戰鬥
一種是軍事戰鬥
一種是殲滅
在英國的弱點
來自森林
攻擊
擊殺
然後退出
這些在卡羅來納州
需要供應
他們需要槍支
很多槍支
看起來
那些車子爆炸了
他們需要傳達訊息
帶來來回回
他們需要食物
這些供應
都需要被紅色的軍人
他們都代表著
這些弱勢的小分子
看看這個森林
對英國來說
這些當地的軍人
這些當地的殲滅者
都很瞭解這片土地
他們懂得在森林裡運作
知道路途
知道土地的堅固性
那些分散人士
沒有機會
在美國大革命時期
這種類似的殲滅戰鬥
對英國來說
是非常殘酷的
一件事就是
從A到B
去佔領那裡
但一旦他們離開那裡
殲滅者就會回歸英國
那些反對派
就會回歸英國
佔領那裡
代表著
那些想要獨立的人
所以在美國大革命期間
在各個時期
你會看到
這種低級的戰鬥
這種在英國軍隊的力量
逐漸減弱
因為被封鎖的部隊
被殲滅
食物被毀
這就意味著
封鎖大革命的成本
對英國來說
已經太大了
英國無法繼續
發送
軍隊和士兵的數量
去警察和穩定
這個巨大的土地
一件事就是
在戰鬥時
擊敗敵人的軍隊
另一件事就是
控制土地
榮耀
這就是Matthew Broderick
他在扮演Robert Shaw
他是一個隊長
你可以看到
他的肩上有兩個屁股
表示他是一個隊長
在這場戲中
我們將被殺
因為他們在這裡
集中了這麼大的力量
一旦發動攻擊
就會變得瘋狂
Massachusetts men
passed through here this morning
How grand it is
to meet the men
from all the states
East and west
down here
ready to fight for their country
as the old fellows
did in the revolution
This is the training of the army
of the platonic
the big huge US army
that was recruited and trained
to both protect Washington DC
and then also defeat
the rebellion in the south
and also defeat
the southern confederate states
Now the roads are choked
with the dispossessed
We fight for men and women
whose poetry is not yet written
but which will presently be
as enviable
and as renowned as any
Last night
we heard of yet another defeat
but we are not disheartened
I am honored to be part of
such a splendid company
They have made me captain
of which I am enormously proud
Shaw was from an affluent
liberal progressive family
in Massachusetts
They were passionate
about the cause of emancipation
about freeing their fellow Americans
African Americans
from the yoke of slavery
A deep man, he says,
believes that the evil eye can wither
that the heart's blessing can heal
Look at that leather cartridge box there
Lovely, that would have hung on
over the shoulder
carrying about 40 cartridges
40 rounds of ammunition
My dearest love to father
Your son, Robert
And now they're marching into battle
This is the Battle of Antietam
Terrible battle
Still the bloodiest day
in American history
23,000 men killed or wounded
This shows the U.S. Army
marching towards the rebels
in their neat lines
perfectly turned out
Now this scene is extraordinary
You see that even by the 1860s
men are still advancing into battle
shoulder to shoulder
just as their forebears had done
in the Revolutionary War
Tactics were changing
weapons were certainly changing
but not as quickly as you might think
It was still a case of
get the men as close as possible
to the enemy
fire volleys
and then go in
with the bayonet charge
The Confederate artillery
in this period
would have been firing round shots
which would have bounced off the ground
and caused terrible casualties
Also case shot, canister shot
basically boxes
full of musket bullets effectively
that turned into
kind of giant shotguns
if you like
spraying shrapnel
but also explosive shells
howitzers
which are indirect fire weapons
firing explosive shells
So you can start to see
some of those explosions
that Hollywood directors love so much
and they always put far too many of
on the battlefield
The minority of shots fired
would have been explosive shells
but there were some
Most would have been solid shot cannon
You can see them
waving the U.S. flag there
the banner trying to rally troops
And I think this scene
could be from
the so-called cornfield
at the Battle of Antietam
where attack after attack
went in
and was decimated
by Confederate musket volleys
and also artillery fire
It's such a great depiction
I remember seeing this
for the first time
It's a terrifying depiction
of a civil warrior
a battlefield
the wounds
A lot of men
would have just gone to ground
and just prayed for survival
just like Matthew Broderick
in this scene
The Battle of Antietam
in September 1862
would have looked quite like
battles of previous generations
the Battle of Waterloo
or the battles of the
American Revolutionary War
Long lines of men
moving into action
carrying muskets
with bayonets on top
and cannon artillery firing at them
But what that disguises
is that technology was changing
It was starting to change
quite rapidly
Those muskets were now lethal
at much longer ranges
They had rifled barrels
So they were more accurate
and you could shoot them further
than the muskets
of previous generations
The artillery too
was really developing
in its lethality
And so
the traditional tactics
of advancing the line
blasting the enemy
at close range
and then closing
to fight with the bayonet
was on its way out
But the problem
with the US Civil War
it was a transitional moment
and it was taking a while
for tactics to catch up
as technology advanced
That's not unusual in war
It happens in the First World War
It happens in the Second World War
It's happening in Ukraine today
As technology changes
you have to change
the way you fight
There's only one way
of doing that
and that's through trial and error
So what you're looking at here
at the Battle of Antietam
is thousands of men
killed or wounded
as commanders and theorists
came to terms
with the new battlefield
This is astonishing
It's one of the greatest scenes
I think in Hollywood history
This is when the 54th
Massachusetts Infantry
won the first units raised
with African-American soldiers
It's commanded now
by Colonel Shaw
They're now assaulting
Fort Wagner at night
in South Carolina
I'm really interested
in how we see
the evolving battlefield
at this point
Look at this fort
You've got stakes
You've got a water obstacle
You've got trenches
This is a low-lying fort
Very different to a castle
in previous eras
This is a fort
designed for powerful
big heavy rifle guns
that can pour devastating fire
over big distances
This is the beginnings
of a sort of modern siege warfare
I think that we associate more
with the 20th century
The American Civil War
was a harbinger of things to come
and you see that here
This could be a scene
from the First World War
Matthew Broderick
said after making this film
he didn't have to act
because it was just so
the set was so scary
the bangs on the set
but here he is leading a charge
It's an officer's job
to restore momentum
to the battlefield
and he does so
He leads from the front
He's terribly wounded
mortally wounded at this point
He takes the flag bearer with him
because the flag is the heart and soul
of the unit
He thinks people will follow
the flag up that hill
and there he is killed
At this point
one of the more remarkable moments
in U.S. Civil War history
takes place
A man called Sergeant Carney
seizes the flag
Denzel takes the flag
and is immediately killed
But Sergeant Carney
seizes the flag
He carries that flag
to the ramparts
of this Confederate fort
and the men launch
a suicidal attack
desperately trying to take the fort
The general commanding them
said don't fire your muskets
on the way up
Use your bayonets on them
when you get to the guns
He wanted to be a shock attack
He wanted to run up the beach
storm over those ramparts
and take the positions
with cold steel
And you can see
the huge odds they face
climbing up this rampart
They do close with the enemy
The American flag
was present on the parapet
of those defenses briefly
before the 54th were driven back
This scene is a stunning depiction
of the Union assault on Fort Wagner
which was part of a huge battle
to try and capture
Charleston, South Carolina
one of the most important cities
one of the most important harbors
in the Confederate States
Fort Wagner was just one of
several forts
protecting this harbor
and each one had to be
individually captured
Fort Wagner was a fort
but not as you might recognize it
or think of it
from previous generations
of fighting
It wasn't high
with great stockades or battlements
It was low-lying
It was designed
as an artillery position
So big guns
could dominate Charleston Harbor
and sweep rain death down
on any troops
that dared to assault
its fortifications
You need to think of it
a little bit more
like a First World War
trench system
There were deep ditches
There were obstacles in them
There was water
and there were trenches
from which the Confederates
had a very, very strong
defensive position
Courage, the tenacity, the skill
demonstrated by the 54th
convinced the U.S. Congress
to raise more units
of African-American troops
and something like
180,000 African-Americans
volunteered to sign up
to fight for the Union
against the Confederacy
Lawrence of Arabia
This is Lawrence of Arabia's
foundation myth
This is the attack on Aqaba
It was an important Turkish base
but its main defenses
were all pointing out to the sea
and Lawrence attacked it
from the desert
with his Arab tribesmen
This scene looks incredible
but it's pretty much made up
In fact, Lawrence brilliantly
shot his own camel
in the back of the head
in real life in this scene
That is not portrayed in the movie
Interestingly, as trench warfare
mechanized warfare, industrial slaughter
had taken over in the First World War
in many other fronts
here in the Middle East
there was still mobility
There was still the ability
to launch cavalry charges
camel charges
go on horseback
strike where the enemy was weak
And that was seen as quite attractive
in a world of muddy
trench line battlefields
This is one of the reasons
that Lawrence becomes so glamorized
in the Western media
because there is still the ability
to launch these kind of attacks
It still looks like warfare
from a previous era
You see that machine gun there
that's capable of firing
hundreds of rounds a minute
a lethal, lethal weapon
Had they been expecting the attack
as this movie suggests
they would have been able to
mow down that cavalry charge
as many cavalry charges
have been mowed down
in the Western front
But Lawrence attacking
with the benefit of surprise
both tactical surprise
i.e. they just turned up
and attacked
but also strategic surprise
that no one was expecting
an attack to emerge
from the desert
They were expecting the attack
to come from the sea
And this was a huge success
Aqaba could now act as a base
through which the British
could feed supplies
to this Arab revolt
And they get one of the heavy guns
with armor-piercing shells
pointed out to sea
waiting for a British naval attack
that never came
It was a nightmare to shoot
It famously took longer to produce
than Lawrence spent with the Arabs
during the First World War
It took years
And when the director
went on location
in some parts of the Middle East
to shoot
he could still see
the rusting carcasses
of Turkish trains, wagons, supplies
left there in the desert
Lawrence, not this
Go round
Damascus, Lawrence
Damascus
No prisoners
Lawrence wrote in his account later
By my orders, we took no prisoners
for the only time in the war
They were enraged
by the treatments
the Turkish treatment
of a village
just south of Damascus
where men, women and children
had been slaughtered
and women had been horribly mutilated
And Lawrence says
he was so enraged
they fell upon a Turkish detachment
and killed everybody
What I like about this scene
is you do see the people
on camels and horseback
but you see the logistics
You see sheep, you see wagons
The Arab army was capable
of surviving long periods of time
in the desert
They were experts
at surviving in this appalling
unforgiving landscape
You see the Turkish
trying to mount machine guns
but rapidly
that Turkish column
are surrounded
It's an interesting use
of weaponry here
We have modern rifles
and pistols
probably supplied by the British
but you get edge weapons as well
You get their swords
and more traditional weapons
used by the Arab tribesmen
Lawrence's Arabia
is one of the epics
of all time
One of the most classic
movies ever made
I don't think it's
particularly accurate
It's not particularly historic
In terms of the details
and the role of Lawrence himself
who's celebrated in this movie
above the role, for example
of his Arab colleagues
But I think it's a depiction
of war in the desert
of striking railroads
of living and fighting
in that hostile environment
It's fantastically realistic
Thanks for watching this video
on the History Hit YouTube channel
You can subscribe right here
to make sure you don't miss
any of our great films
that are coming out
Or if you are a true history fan
check out our special
dedicated history channel
historyhit.tv
You're going to love it
