3 big negatives - Syntropic style agroforestry

FFG - Food Forest Garden
176 followers
What's ripening YouTube? So I had a recent comment on a video and the question that came up was
what are some of the negative aspects of syntropic agroforestry? So I've been thinking about that for
a couple of days and this is the kind of conversation that I have with
people that I work closely with. We talk about, you know, for better or for worse what's, you know,
where are we going? Which way should we go? And so I have a couple in mind of negatives
for syntropic agriculture. I think the first one and probably the most challenging one for me
originally was just access to the information. For those of you that know about syntropic
agriculture, it was developed in Brazil and so most of the source material was
written in Portuguese and that was a real challenge to try to, you know, I don't know,
I saw videos about it on YouTube and got really excited but I couldn't understand anything they
were saying. And so, you know, I went way out of my way. The first course that ever came up
in English that I knew about was in Costa Rica and I flew to Costa Rica and took the course and
really enjoyed it. It was a big paradigm shift. I think that might be the biggest negative is that
just most people don't understand it. So even now, you know, as I'm developing my own project
and projects for clients, what I've seen is that people, you know, most people haven't taken the
course obviously because it's too new. And so I'm speaking a different language. I'm talking
about things that are not fully understood and I don't even think that the people, like maybe you
guys as a viewer, I don't think most of you understand that you don't understand what I'm
talking about. So that's a big negative and we're trying to fix that. That's why we have a course
coming up. I just announced that a couple videos ago and I hope to see some of you guys here because
I really want to have peers in this field because I think it's really exciting. And yeah, I need
more. I need more people. You know, I've got my little core crew here and I've been teaching
them and, you know, and that's been great. There's my dog Hula. She's out on the island. We're
trying to dig a pond and then the rain filled it up. So that's the biggest negative right
away. The other one that comes into play is that it is more work. There's more to do when you
take, like if you're comparing to a monoculture, I guess I should say, if you're comparing to a grove,
what I have here is a polyculture. So, you know, and there's a lot going on but
what it really is is a food forest in a linear pattern with more intent.
So a lot of, you know, the popular way to do a food forest is just to have
one of everything and do everything and have the full diversity and
I've definitely grown out of that. I really like to do things more purposeful
and so I have specific main crops and I have shorter term crops and I have longer term crops
but there is more work involved if you compare it to a grove. A grove,
like in this case here, I would plant these coconuts. I might put some mulch around them
and some irrigation and fertilize and that's it. That's all I got to do but then this land
right here would just be sitting here until these coconuts start producing
and that might be five years, it might be six or seven years, eight years.
You know, land's expensive. It's really hard to occupy a piece of property
and just sit there and wait. One of the beautiful things about Centropic
and other types of farming too, you know, polyculture farming or
whatever, is that I can grow things in the meantime. So what I'm doing is,
while my long-term crops are developing, I have short-term crops and that's
what I've been, that's what I've done at my farm. If you watch my old videos,
you know, you can start with annual vegetables and go all the way out to longer term tree crops or
whatever you want to do. In my context, because I don't have an irrigation system on this farm,
I'm doing things that need less and so annuals don't typically fall into that realm.
But we do, you know, we've had big crops of bananas, pineapples, sugar cane,
fair amount of papaya, sweet potatoes, turmeric and a lot of that stuff. Honestly, the biggest,
best part of that is the propagation material because I use it on other properties,
on other projects and so, you know, that's kind of been the type of crop that I produce. But I can
do all of that while the trees are developing. In this case, you know, this row of mango trees,
some of these are, you know, like that one's only two or three years old, this one's four or five
years old and down the line the oldest ones are about, I think, six or seven years old. You know,
it takes a while to get to that production so doing a little extra work and cultivating the
ground in between can get you extra benefit in the short term and so you can get a return,
especially if you're trying to produce your own food. So that's another negative, I guess,
is that there's more work involved. One of the positives about doing a main crop type of
agroforestry is that the work pieces, you know, if you do rows of mangoes and rows of avocados and
rows, the maintenance becomes more understandable and more digestible and more transferable,
which is one of my big interests is being able to pass tasks on to my crew for them to be able to
take it on and understand. Like in this case, you'll see this row is, we've got coconuts,
dwarf coconuts, dwarf bananas, we've got napier grass growing on both sides and because it's a
consistent pattern, I can ask one of my guys, hey, go cut all the napier grass and lay it in as mulch.
Hey, go check every coconut and cut all the, you know, dead dead fronds off or whatever. Go
check the bananas. We're going to thin those out and pull pull pups for the nursery and then we're
going to thin them to their main leader or their main trunk. That's something I can do.
If it's a food forest and also by the way, the bananas are all the same type, but in a food
forest situation, you might have 10 types of bananas and 13 types of fruit trees and
it's hard for a business, which is what I'm, which is what I've developed now. It's hard for
a business to send a crew to go do the, do the maintenance, you know, which is usually pruning
and harvesting, hopefully pruning and harvesting. And if everything's all cattywampus, different,
different varieties of things, it makes it really complicated. And what I'm trying to do is get to
a level of efficiency so that I can have a bigger impact for my clients and for agriculture,
regenerative agriculture in general. So those are the negatives I can think of. One was,
it's hard to get the information, which we're working on. Number two is more work,
but there's a reason for that. There's more work because we're trying to do more.
You know, there's the old, the old adage of you reap what you sow. So if you don't want to get
more, you don't have to give more. And that's, that's totally fine. I prefer to maximize the
benefit from my land to a certain extent. There's always more you can do. There's always more you can,
you know, play around with, you know, everyone's going to have their own context.
And so what, what you'll see in my videos is my context or the context of my clients.
What I don't want you guys, the viewers to do is to assume that what I'm doing is right for you,
because we're not the same people. We're not the same people and we're not in the same exact
location. So the things that I'm doing here, some of them are very specific to this site.
Some of them are very specific to my own needs and wants and goals.
And, and you can see, I still have food for us. This is, this is an area that we haven't got into
to do our pruning. We've, we had a hurricane and knocked out a lot of stuff. We've got a big store
of biomass in here and we're going to start harvesting that. I'm giving you the full walk
around today. I guess I haven't, I haven't really done a, uh, an actual farm tour in a long time.
Check this out. Here's a little Rasapote. I don't know if you can see that or not.
Little Rasapote has got a bunch of big flowers on it. I'll tell you what's really interesting.
This, uh, I don't remember what type of Garcinia this tree is, but it stood up to category four
hurricane like a champion. And it's also put, it's also survived through like severe drought
versus this. Macadamia fell over, my Bunyapine fell over. A lot of things got pushed over,
but that, that Garcinia is a beast. I don't know, I don't know exactly what it is.
But anyway, that was a response to the question. I appreciate the questions.
Um, hopefully I answered that one well enough. There's probably other negative, oh, another
negative I can think of. Here's a bonus one because Centropic agriculture is, is new for
this area. Figuring out, uh, what service plants to use has been basically placed right there on
my shoulders. It's taken me a long time to figure this out. What, what I can grow here well,
and then where to get it and, uh, and how to get enough. So that's why I have like
this whole field. You see all the Napier back there. There's Teutonia. I've got some plantings
like this that I actually just let them grow out so that I have the propagation material,
because not only do I need it on my property, but I need it for clients' properties. And
I also send some of this stuff out in the mail. You know, if you guys have been on my website,
um, from time to time we'll have something available because we're cutting it
and, uh, yeah, getting, getting the materials taken forever. Um, but now we have, like you'll
see, you know, we use canna lilies as one of our biomass. These have all been cut down. So they're
just coming back up now. Um, we use the Napier grass. We use Teutonia, you know, when I first
started, not all that stuff was available. Now it is. So I guess that's the third one,
not being able to find the material. So hopefully that helps. See you guys next time.
