Old vs New Toyota Prius- You Won’t Believe How Much The “Boring” Prius Has Changed!

Family Auto
135 followers
#automobile #autos #cars #4wheels #luxurycar #sportcar #highspeedcar #testdrive #toyota #tesla #porsche #hyundai #rollsroyce #royall #suvs
Over the past year we've been lauding, cheering for the new Prius and that's because it is an
all-new vehicle and it's radically different than everything else but we wanted to talk about
how it compares to one of the most popular Prius that is out there and that's why I brought Brendan
because he knows about this vehicle and he's all about used cars. What is this? So this is the
third generation Prius. This particular model is a 2010. These came out in 2009 and were sold all
the way through 2015 and even though that new Prius is super cool, I want to make the argument
that this is the best generation Prius you can buy for the money. It's great for birth control.
So here's the important part about both these vehicles. Extremely efficient and this vehicle
in particular had a couple different variants but this one has several more so we are talking
about some significantly different vehicles but here's the cool part. They're both extremely
efficient. They're both very reliable. At least we think this one will be reliable and then one
final part about this. That's going to be a lot less expensive than that. So prior to this new
generation of Prius coming out, the Prius was never considered a pretty looking car but I will say I
think this third generation of those first four generations is probably the least ugly of all of
You do have kind of your basic hatchback kind of design and I think in the back it actually
finishes off like a traditional hatchback unlike some of the other two. This just looks
like a normal everyday car. What do you think Nathan? I really dislike it but there are two
things I like about the car. For one thing, unlike the new one, it has a rear wiper. I mean that is
really important to me. You guys can argue all you want about snow sliding off the back of
aerodynamic glass. This really helps in winter conditions which is by the way what we're having
right now. Secondly, apparently this has adjustable aero. Look at that. Oh yeah. After over its course
of life, the classics have kind of worn out there. Yeah this vehicle does have a lot of miles on it
but actually it's in fairly good shape considering the amount of miles. There are a couple things
about these. Early on in my career, I tested the second gen Prius and I was always
astounded by how efficient it was and when I asked one of the designers, you know, hey
what was your, you know, how were you inspired? What was your inspiration? He didn't say it verbatim
but he basically said a suppository. Oh gosh. Yeah he was talking about fluid dynamics. Was the designer saying it?
Well he said aerodynamics and fluid dynamics and he was talking about that and everything really did
sound similar to that to me. So that's why I, to me, to my eye, these are just really unattractive
especially at the front end. Those headlights are dreadful. You have to admit that. Well you're
ruining this car for me. You're combining suppository with fluid and it just, now this
car is ruined for me. Thank you. And a loose rear end. Yeah. Well let's move on to the new one which
is much better. I'm here to tell you that longer, lower, and lighter is better. It is better for at
least exterior design because it just looks fabulous. Look we've waxed on and on and on about
how good looking this car looks. Even Brendan who loves vehicles that were made during, you know,
disco era, feels that this is a pretty good looking car. But there's a couple things that you have to
keep in mind. This was built for a purpose. It's very slippery, it's aerodynamic, and it's also
built so it can have several different powertrains underneath it. As a matter of fact this one
is the very top of the line so it has a plug-in hybrid system. So we're not comparing hybrid
against, you know, plug-in hybrid. But the point is is that you can get a regular version of this
with just a hybrid powertrain and there's even an all-wheel drive version of this as well.
But here's the thing Nathan, although this car looks way better than any other Prius that's ever
been made, you do have a big sacrifice that you give up with those good looks that we're going
to get to. There is no sacrifice, I disagree already, because it's sexy. Sexy means sacrifice
is okay. Well I mean you also don't have a rear wiper. Yeah that sucks. All right it's not as low
as a Corvette but I would say it's about as low as our Mustang which means that a large fat person
like me has to duck and crunch in order to get in. I will admit that that is something that the older
Prius, Prii, the older Prii did not have as much of an issue with. As a matter of fact they're
relatively comfortable to get into. Now with that being said, the front seats are comfortable.
The overall layout, I've really learned to like it. I didn't love it at first but I don't know,
it's kind of got a retro future feel to it, kind of like the outside, and at the same time they
actually have real buttons in here and I'm grateful for that. With that being said, there's also a lot
of things on the screen that pop up and these things that are on the screen, well, it's okay.
It's not a big deal to me one way or the other. It's going to keep making that noise for a little
bit. I apologize. I like the seats. Now bear in mind that this is the upper model so this is
fake leather but it's a very squishy comfortable leather. It's a lot better than vinyl, I gotta
tell you that. And finally, lots of places to put drinks. This is actually where you would put your
cell phone for charging. Isn't that cool? A little slot right there and no sunroof. You know why?
Because it's the future and because there's solar panels up there. Now Brendan's going to struggle
to get into the back seat here so we're going to enjoy that. Go on in, buddy. Now climbing into
the back seat you'll see that I am also robbed of quite a bit of headspace. Now I'm not a particularly
tall gentleman. I'm only five foot nine and my hair is pressed right up against this ceiling.
Your hair makes you five foot ten like that. There we go, yeah. And I have to kind of tuck my
toes underneath Nathan's front seat in order to fully fit in here. Now my knees don't touch so
you know it's not a bad place to be but it's certainly not as spacious as an old Prius.
All right so climbing into the 2010 Prius you will see that it is very easy to get into
unlike the new generation Prius and I have plenty of headroom in here
and I will say the seat is actually not too bad. You know it's not what you would think with
seat comfort of an economy car but it's also not necessarily like a Mercedes S-Class. It's just
kind of in between but the way that this is laid out I've always thought was kind of funky. You
don't have anything directly in front of you to tell you your speed. Your screen is up there. Your
entertainment system is here. You do have a big cubby underneath here to store a lot of your
things and that is also where your heated seat is down there and you do have a little singular cup
holder here that's currently housing the keys. You know you don't have a place to really put
your phone unless you want to hide it in that inconspicuous space down there. You do have a
second cup holder back here but you are sacrificing some of your armrest space.
All right I have to admit it's a lot more comfortable. I mean yeah I'm sitting behind
you and you have dwarf legs but I'm still able to put my feet under this front seat easily and
my feet are much larger than yours. I'm a lot taller than you are and you know if I lean all
the way back yeah I'm hitting the roof but I slouch so it's no big deal. The seats themselves I
gather on the older side this vinyl isn't as nice as that vinyl I would say but otherwise yeah it's
a comfortable place and it's a lot easier to get in and out of. So hiding under the hood of this
generation is a rat's nest. Yeah not quite it's a little gross under here but that is their 1.8
liter four-cylinder engine. The previous gen had a 1.5 so this one got a bit more power at 134
horsepower and then it was also assisted by a 27 horsepower electric motor which made for a total
combined power output of 161 horsepower to those front wheels and the other nice thing is is this
thing got 50 mpgs combined. I mean if in the city 51 on the highway 48 but 50 mpgs for a car that's
pretty good. Yeah that actually outperforms the new car when it comes to just the engine doing
the work. Now there's a couple things so first of all this has the older battery technology that
Toyota insisted was a much more robust setup and that was nickel metal hydride and those
nickel batteries were indeed really hardy not as much of a reputation for you know fire or anything
like that and they were just super super strong but they weren't as power dense as the lithium
ion batteries which are currently being used in the Prius Prime. Another thing to mention is that
you do not have a mode that allows you to drive at highway speeds using all electricity or anything
like that as a matter of fact this doesn't really have a rating so to speak running on all electric
mode and that's no surprise really but at the same time that is something that other people
at the time were starting to look at. General Motors with the Chevy Volt which is very similar
actually to this car. Well this did actually have a mode where you could drive in all electric but
it just wasn't useful on the highway like yours was it was just kind of for like in town and city
driving. But at the retirement zone where Roman is you didn't want to wake him up at noon. Exactly so
you can kind of creep out but let's take this thing out for a spin now it's showing 239,000
miles so I'm curious just how well one of these has held up over time. So let's talk about some
of the technology that was in the third generation Prius starting with this center mounted screen.
Now you can see it is kind of a nice looking screen but the difference is is that it's really
tucked back far away from the driver and it's in the center as opposed to directly in front of the
driver and that was kind of controversial back in the day because so many people were used to having
their driving information directly in front of them and this they had to kind of shift where
they were looking constantly. What do you think? Well Toyota wasn't the only one but Toyota was
one of the first automakers to make this common practice where they were taking the information
that was in front of you and shifting it to the middle. Other vehicles were built this way
and a lot of people hated it frankly. They could not stand having all their information
in the center of the vehicle. Now this did two things. One this allowed according to Toyota
your eyes to not have to drop to the front of you in order to see what was going on.
You could just glance down from the street and then you would see all your basic information
so they thought it was a safety thing. Second thing is that when this vehicle was built in
other countries it was relatively easy to take the instrumentation that was already up there
flip a few things around and make it so it could be right hand drive. That's their excuse. However
it was hated and as such a lot of vehicles went away from that but not all. Today there are still
vehicles that actually have their information near the center or at the center so that is
something to keep in mind. Personally speaking once you get used to it it's not a big deal but
I would rather it in front of me. But moving on down to the center now this one I think is a
fairly well optioned model having the navigation screen with satellite radio. You do get aux in
this generation. I don't think there's much bluetooth audio although you do have a phone
button here. Yeah I think it might have bluetooth. This was kind of in that transitionary period
where some cars just had phone for just talking and some cars had them for audio as well but you
do have in here a automatic climate control and then the interesting buttons that I like down
here is where you have the EV, the eco mode, and the power mode. And this was kind of that first
Prius to offer that EV mode where you can drive in electric only and it gave you a few other driving
modes as well such as eco mode and a more powerful mode and maybe that's the one we'll push when we
go down the test track. All right so getting out and driving this 2010 Prius I have to say Nathan
I have ridden in the back of many of these as far as ride sharing goes because I feel like
this is the official taxi or ride sharing car but I've never actually driven one of them and
but I'm just curious to feel how it drives. I mean it seems like it doesn't feel like an
economy car it does feel like it's a little more premium than that. From day one with both the
Prius and the Yaris and even the Eco if you remember that one I used to look at those vehicles
and think to myself they need to have on the side of them written car kind of like the way you have
really cheap beer plain label beer or deodorant which just says deodorant you know plain label
because to me they were very nondescript in terms of what they did they were just
simple basic transportation but this on top of that what people don't realize is what's going
underneath which is actually quite a bit of tech. Well let's let's fire up some of that tech I'm
gonna put it here in power mode and I've got a little test strip here that you know a fast car
I can get up to about 40 miles an hour the the slowest cars can do maybe 15 but let's see what
this uh this old Prius can do with 239,000 miles. All right it's not a rocket but no it's not a
you know so it's it'll be relatively efficient and get you up to speed and I don't think it's
going to be dangerously slow but it certainly doesn't have any sporting tensions at all
or intentions at all. It's as smooth as cool whip. But you know what Nathan I see over here
I see an old Prius that looks like it hasn't been well cared for this car has clearly been
well cared for to be able to make it with this many miles. Yeah I mean it's a lot of miles. Should
we check out a really gross one that hasn't been well cared for? Sure. And I'm curious to see if
it'll actually start. So Nathan we've been driving around a well-kept high mileage Prius I wanted to
see though if you have an abused high mileage Prius is it still a good car to buy? No so uh
interesting thing about this is a 2008 right? Yes this one's a 2008 so this is the second generation.
That's right uh really got the whole shape on you know and everything else this car that's how it
really got started in my mind but there is something important about this vehicle. When I met
Roman Micah big boss man at TFL this is what he drove and he insisted he insisted that this would
be the next Volkswagen Beetle. He said that this car its popularity its utility its usefulness its
MPG will make it the next Beetle his words and he was wrong but one thing about Roman that was
correct is that he managed to actually have that car in Colorado and used it as a daily driver
which is nuts considering that these older ones weren't great in snow. All right so I got the key
here and I'm gonna hop in this guy and oh I don't want to be in here for very long it doesn't smell
pleasant. I've got the key in and um well it is very dead. You had the clutch pushed in? There is
no clutch. I do have my foot on the brake pedal and I'm holding it. Oh god it stinks in there it just
started to waft out. I wouldn't stay in there Brendan. Yeah I'm not letting you ride back with
me after sitting in this. That thing is unpleasant. What is wrong with some of you? Why do you
mistreat your cars so much? Oh gosh well I mean so it's just the battery is dead in it that doesn't
necessarily bode to the reliability of it but seeing as to uh how somebody mistreated this car.
This poor thing was really mistreated. I would run I would run away from any car that looks like this
including a Prius. Really hard to see what's going on in there. Yeah it looks like a much more
complicated engine that's for sure. Well it certainly is too so a couple things just straight
up 220 horsepower combined and this vehicle's overall capability really has to do with the fact
that it has a fairly large 13.6 kilowatt hour battery and that battery which is lithium-ion
you can charge it separately or the car can charge it itself as well. As a matter of fact
as I mentioned before there is a solar panel on the roof that will give you up to according to
Toyota 1,000 miles additional per year. Not as simple as the other one I should say. There's
definitely a lot more screens I mean I'm seeing three just in my vicinity here if you include
the backup camera. Yeah you I guess you could include that as well but uh this does not come
standard on the base Prius by the way. By the way you know who uh was one of the first automakers
to put these out there? General Motors. Interesting. Yes okay so let's talk about what we got going on
here. Infotainment screen right here has all of the information that the vehicle could possibly
produce. That means that your driving information can pop up here on the screen
uh based on I want to make sure my gloves will actually work on this. Hey I kind of do.
Uh so you can use you know trip information here if it doesn't let my gloves. All right let's do
it this way. There we go. So you can get a lot of this information and the reason I'm pointing this
out is because this is one of the big changes over the years that's happened with these types
of vehicles. They're giving the driver more data and stuff that you just couldn't get out of their
older tech you can get now. And by doing that it really does help certain types of people who
really need to know what their solar panel is doing and how much power it's actually produced.
So uh 71 watts or 70 now power generated. It's kind of cool for certain types of geeks. I think
those with the engineering mindset would totally geek out and just sit in their car playing around
with all the different features for hours. Now this screen does give you a lot of information
including in this case how much you have in terms of battery life and everything else. Now in this
case we've pretty much blown through the battery so we can't use it very much but as we drive the
vehicle there's still a reserve in the battery and that reserve prevents it from completely
discharging meaning that main the maximum power can always be maintained. Well and I will say
that I like down here too where your uh cooled seats and your heated seats are still physical
buttons. Yeah. And even some of your climate controls are still physical buttons where a lot
of cars are moving them up into the screen and you have to kind of search for them and hunt for
them. But you know what else this car does? What's that? It watches you. I don't like that part.
Cameras on you? Yeah yeah this this thing right here monitors to make sure you're watching the
road and that you're not passing out and if it thinks that you're not paying attention it'll
actually yell at you. I have four modes. Four. I have custom, sport, eco, and normal. No snow modes
because I don't need them. Well it seems like you have the same amount of modes as the other one.
The only addition is this custom mode. And what is this custom so you can kind of configure it how
you want? Uh yeah pretty much. So you can kind of lay in a few things some parameters and save them
and that's the custom mode. But it really isn't anything worth writing home about. I just wanted
to say I have four modes. And now that I'm in its power mode, actually it's sport mode, that'll allow
me a little bit better acceleration supposedly. Well and the as far as the view out front goes.
Now I'm I'm kind of a 90s car guy and Nathan I'm going to throw to a really weird car. Do you
remember the Oldsmobile Silhouette? Of course I do. Yeah the view out of this feels a lot like that
where it seems like the dash goes on forever and that the windshield is like unreachable from
someone sitting in the seat. Because it is such a raked windshield. Yeah the rake on this windshield
is really close to that of supercars. It's just overdone. Aerodynamics is part of it and looks
as the other. I will say that the setup of having that massive dashboard going way out in front of
you actually has a technical reason as well. And that has to do with the fact that you have a safe
zone in front of you between you and the windshield. So when the airbag ignites after I
crash into that barrier by going 90, it will prevent us from hopefully going through the
windshield. More importantly making contact with it. That's the hope. Makes sense. But I will say
I actually kind of like the Oldsmobile Silhouette and its spaceship feel. And so I kind of like...
The Silhouette is a minivan he's talking about. Yes I know I'm talking about... I'm weird right? I get it.
Well no the trans van is the only way to go. That was the only one. That was the Pontiac
Trans Sport. That was cool. The other one that was the Cadillac and minivans. Yeah.
Otherwise no bueno. But you got it here lined up on the test track. I think clearly it's going to
be faster than ours. But I want to see if it gives you that pushback in the seat feeling that
everybody's talking about. I don't think it's going to be a pushback per se. But here we go. Ready?
Yeah. Three, two, one, and let's go. Hey. Yeah broke some traction. Broke some traction, spun the tires.
I'd say that's fairly quick. Woohoo. And got some good brakes too. Oh yeah. 46 miles per hour
and I wasn't really going crazy with it. But yeah the biggest issue with both the car that you
enjoy and this one is that there's absolutely no steering feel and the steering itself is super
light and over boosted. And that to me is sort of a crime in this car because this car looks sporty
so you kind of wanted to have a little bit of a sporting feel. And I wish it would be a little
bit heavier in the old one which would have given it I think a little bit more of a feel of precision
even though there's absolutely nothing to do with precision with the way it handles. First of all
we've got to get this out of the room. This puppy here runs about $44,000 but this is the absolute
top of the line and it's the Prius Prime. If you go all the way down to a regular Prius you're going
to save thousands and thousands of dollars. Yeah whereas this one being a used Prius now this one's
got a lot of miles at 239,000. If you were to go out and shop for your average mileage one let's
say around 120,000 miles you could expect to pay about 10 grand at a dealer maybe a little bit less
if you're buying private party. Now with this one being such high mileage I would expect not to pay
more than maybe five thousand dollars at a dealer and maybe even less private party. So it is an
incredible value as you can see it has held up really darn well even with that amount of miles
and I would have absolute confidence in driving this thing cross-country. I mean that's pretty
good 50 mpgs and driving it cross-country with heated seats for 5,000 bucks. 114 mpge my friend
but there's an important thing here obviously between the two of them that is the fact that
this is where the popularity really kicked into high gear and this is where it's going and as much
as I absolutely hate to say it because I've never been a big fan of the Toyota Prius because it's
never been particularly interesting or fun they did a really good job and they built a hell of a
car. Yeah I will say this is definitely better at being more interesting but I think this is better
at just being a car for cheap and transportation to get you to and from. What do you guys think
I'd be curious to know in those comments section below for your money would you go for the third
generation or that first generation but for everything else check out all tfl this has
been Brendan and Nathan take care guys
