Thriving Cities: Bay City
Jul 28, 2025 #Gretchenwhitmer #Politicians
Everyone hopefully knows that Dylan is our meeting fair senior, he's our local friendly contact in Michigan.
So, while the governor and myself will be coming in and out and through in Michigan a lot,
Dylan is the person who's going to be running the media friendly contact for the administration.
I'm sure everybody knows that.
I also just learned that I'm the first person in technology here today.
We really appreciate it.
I started my career as a software tester.
I don't know if I'm going to be bugged though.
Yeah, that's what my parents did.
Thank you everyone for being here.
Governor Whitmer and I, we see it as one of our key responsibilities to move Michigan forward in terms of improving the quality of our people.
A significant number of people in Michigan live in Michigan cities.
So, we thought that it would be a good idea to really take a tour to visit some of the largest cities in the state
and cities that represent the first set of interests in Michigan.
The question is about how do we make our cities thrive?
What do we mean by thriving cities?
How do we create thriving cities in Michigan?
This is really just about improving the quality of life in cities in Michigan.
So, this is something that is very, very important.
This is a 16 or 17 hour documentary.
I say hour, but I don't remember how many cities it's going to be.
This is a lot.
We're going all across the state of Michigan.
This is the fourth stop here in Bay City.
We did our first meeting in Detroit.
We did our first meeting on Friday.
We did our first meeting in Staten Island earlier today.
And now we're here in Bay City.
And we're going to continue to travel all across the state with Governor and or I when we're facilitating conferences just like this.
Stakeholders that include elected leaders and also people who are doing the work on the ground,
like building communities and making life better in schools.
So, when I say doing the work on the ground to make life better,
I'm talking about really five key areas for improving quality of life.
In no particular order, they are improving life for kids in cities,
generational economic opportunity,
environmental quality and justice,
transportation and mobility,
and affordable and amenable housing.
So, what can we do in more and more of those five areas to move the ball forward?
And we think if we aren't able to do that, we won't improve quality of life.
And our goal at the end of this process,
which is going to take us through the rest of September,
through all of October,
and maybe we'll get into November as well.
Our goal is to emerge from this process,
having had these 17 key conversations,
to emerge with a set of ideas,
a set of practices or programs or policy ideas
that can be implemented at any level.
At the city level, at the municipal level,
at the state level in terms of legislative action,
at the state level in terms of executive action on behalf of our administration,
or things we can advocate for at the federal level.
What can we do at any level?
What are the levers that we can pull?
What are the things that can be done?
Now, there's an email address here on the screen,
and that is an open email address
because adjacent to this meeting process,
we also have a public meeting process.
So, for people who are not able to participate in these meetings,
one, we are live streaming them on Facebook every week.
And people can also email this email address
with any ideas they have,
policies, suggestions,
additional data, information
about how you want to contribute to this process.
I'm sure that others can contribute as well.
There also is a link on our site
on my webpage
about how to put together
a public comment about what I can do.
So, I'm sure we'll be sharing those
directly online
as well.
This is a conversation about, again,
how can we improve quality of life?
So, every person
who RCPs this meeting,
which in turn is involving me,
they actually complete a survey.
And in the survey, we ask you to rank
those five buckets,
those five issues
in terms of what was most important.
And so, I'm going to respond in terms of
75% of people
said that generational economic opportunity
was either the number one
or number two
most important.
And this,
these quotes on the screen are kind of a subset
of what people said,
this idea that
each generation can do better than the
generation before it.
Stubborn issues and subgenerational
problems. Are people of color
able to participate in economic
development? These are questions
that we're honestly prepared
to talk about with thousands
facing or standing between generational economic
opportunity and people.
So,
this slide is just meant to be a little bit of a summary
of the fact that there are good things
happening in basic education.
All of you
certainly know this in terms of
waterline infrastructure investment.
There are $26 million in improvements
in terms of infrastructure.
Bay City schools, free meals,
welcoming schools. There are really
fantastic things that are happening here
and people doing the work on the ground
and communities.
I want to take a step back
and tell a story.
This is a story of a woman named Jacqueline
Spillmore. She's a woman in
Detroit. I think her story
highlights what we mean
when we say that there are challenging
opportunities.
Jacqueline was born in Detroit.
That's her in the top left corner
and the baby in the back in the sink.
I appreciate that. I'm a little evil
but it all matters.
Jacqueline grew up in
Detroit. She went to a combination of Detroit public
schools. She grew up here
and played
basketball. Jacqueline
had a baby when she was 16.
She had to run.
Jacqueline
did not let that slow her
down. She ended up
continuing on finishing high school
and going to the University of Michigan.
The picture on the right
is of her
graduating from
the University of Michigan.
The next
picture of that is of Jacqueline
graduating from law school.
She went through that
push through. $280,000
worth of debt later as she graduated from law school.
She's gone on
to be an activist and a leader in the community.
That's her and President Obama.
The bottom second to the
left image is of Jacqueline
leaving the organization that she went to, Detroit
Public Schools. It's a really interesting
service organization really where
hundreds of people
come together, they'll pay
$5, everyone goes and
has a meal together.
That collective $5 that was put in
the pot, they then use that to
fund a community project.
It's a very interesting community
localized crowd
funding project that
President Obama was really putting
together.
The picture of the last photo
that is Jacqueline's
daughter graduating from high school.
Her daughter is now a senior at Michigan State.
This is an example of a woman
who has pushed through and persevered
and has really embodied
the resilience that so
many Michiganders embody.
She's been able to overcome
opportunities and challenges.
I think about
a woman like her
and people like her across the state,
what could they do if they just
didn't have these kind of challenges?
If she wasn't fighting poverty, if she wasn't
dealing with student debt, what are the things
that we could possibly do?
Obviously, we have to reflect on
what we need to do.
These are the kind of stories we're trying
to enable and we're talking about.
We're having access to high quality
plant-based food.
This is a story.
Our cities
also have challenges.
Bay City is
not unique in that
we still have vacant downtown storefronts.
There has been
the high bacteria levels
in Bay County beaches
and what should be done
with the Bay City bridges?
I think that
those are very important issues.
What can we do to invest
in those areas?
The challenges that we have to deal with.
The last one I'm going to talk about
is land and water.
There's work to be done.
We're looking at those five
buckets I talked about before.
Housing, economic opportunity,
environmental quality,
efficiency, and mobility and transportation.
This slide is just showing
the percentage of respondents who chose
these as their number one issue.
Similarly to
Saginaw,
we have generous economic opportunity
being number one. We have efficient cities
and affordable and available housing
being right up there.
Now, yes.
In some sense,
we know all the issues that we have.
This is kind of
asking you a question.
We want
to do that really focused
conversation.
I'm going to go through the next few slides
and talk a little bit
about the issues
that are specific to Bay City.
Then we're going to come back
and we're going to have a broader conversation
about, first of all,
what are going to be our biggest practices,
programs, and policies to help
improve generational
economic opportunity in Bay City.
For those who
think of affordable housing,
transportation,
and mobility,
we also want to give you a sense of
why is that? Why is environmental quality
such an issue?
How do you connect that
to generational economic opportunity?
We can still have a conversation that feels like it has
some sort of shape.
On housing,
we talked about affordable housing.
The definition
of affordable is that
an individual
is not spending more than 30%
of their monthly income to pay for
their housing. These are some
average prices for
what it costs to
rent or to own.
What those bottom two
numbers are, average wage and minimum wage,
especially if you had the average wage
in Bay City, you'd have to work
53 hours a week
in order to afford
to own your house.
If you were minimum wage,
you'd have to work an additional 63 hours a week
to own the house.
All that means is that
Bay City does not meet that threshold
of people on average spending
40% or less of their income
on their house.
That was just putting some numbers around
what it really means.
We're talking about economic
opportunity.
$36,000, that is
still
lower than the state's
average income, but it's better than
a lot of places.
The unemployment rate
of 10%, let me be clear about what that means.
It's a relatively small
unemployment rate.
This number
is for people
who are 16
or older, who are
not retired,
and who are currently actively
looking for work.
Amongst that population,
the unemployment rate is 10%.
I know there are other ways
to measure unemployment.
The total unemployment rate
will go up or down.
That is the population chosen.
You've got to hold that constant
in comparison
to the city.
In education,
28% of adults in Bay City
have some post-secondary degree.
What we mean by that is that
28% of people have an associate's degree
or higher. This does not
count professional certifications
or technical certifications
in that number.
This is strictly talking about
associate's degrees, bachelor's degrees,
master's, etc.
To put this in perspective,
in order to include
those professional certifications,
right now the state of Michigan as a whole
has 45% of adults
have some sort of attainment
or some kind of credential after graduating high school.
The governor in the state address
set a goal
to move that from 45% to 60%
in the next couple of years
by investing in skills training
as well as
making some serious
investments.
Talking about
environmental equality and justice,
that means a number of things.
I like to think about it as
understanding how
both the present and the history
in terms of environmental impact
on companies
or the choices that people have made,
the fact that those
negative
environments have
historically, unfortunately
come into close contact
with people who are
just to interact.
Also looking at air quality
pollution, rates of asthma,
the fact that environmental policy
has a higher energy cost to many people,
and also the fact that it's encroached on
the ability for people to recreate
the public space.
Talking about kids
in cities, these are some numbers
that show
the graduation rate,
high school dropout rate
in the state when it comes to those numbers.
The percentage of children living
at or below the poverty line,
the percentage of children unqualified
for free and reduced lunch in the city.
This just shows
that there's still some work to be done
to improve what we see
with access to the internet.
And then
we're talking about transportation, mobility,
roads, bridges,
traffic, public transportation,
infrastructure, thinking about
that more. I care specifically about
public transportation. I was a transit
rider before I came to Tennessee.
I've been exclusively in the city of Detroit,
so I know a lot about bus infrastructure,
how much
coverage
there is.
Our administration
did put a bunch of proposals on the table
to try to address a number of these things
that included
significant investment in education,
to
prevent people spending allowance
to support more money in terms of
career and technical education,
social needs,
access to systems,
etc.
We've got to deal with our education
payment responsibilities,
for transit and mobility,
additional resources for
projects that can make
transportation and public transit
more easily accessible
to people with disabilities
or to the elderly,
making that if we can have transit
students that work for those communities,
they will, by default, work for
the population of those other
communities as well.
In terms of water, we put forward
CCP resources on
water cleanup projects,
service line replacements, research to mitigate
PFAS contamination,
as well as money to install
hydration stations in old school buildings,
recognizing that
the place where children are often
the most likely to be exposed to
methane and water
for the most part.
We address that
in every school in the state.
I already talked about the
ReConnect program to give adults
a pathway to
college, a social study, or some sort of
professional
training or certification.
We have some infrastructure
plans that really will
help us to fix our roads
and bridges, importantly.
Our city's agenda needs to be responsive.
It needs to
recognize that every city
is different, that every city
has different challenges and different priorities
and different needs.
The purpose of this tour is to have a community
conversation with you who are all doing work
in more and more of these areas
and give you about what's most
important and what you want to see happening
from a program perspective, a policy perspective,
or a practice perspective
at any level
and what you stand to do going forward
on any of these issues
in our city, making our city stronger.
With that,
I would like to
open it up.
Again,
number one and number two,
we have four people responding
from generational economic opportunities.
I would like for someone to
kick us off with an idea
or something specific
that can be done in your eyes
to help
expand access to generational economic
opportunities.
I'm the shy one, so I'll start.
I'm the shy one.
I'm going to speak for
Trevor and myself, starting
from the economic development perspective.
When you showed the clips
up there of the announcements and things
that are going on, the one thing that you
did not see there was an announcement
of new jobs coming in this area
in this region.
I guess a very specific thing,
and we're trying to help ourselves.
Literally a week from tomorrow,
we have invited leaders from the
MD&C and MDAR on a tour of the
entire Great Lakes Bay region. We're busing them up
from Lansing. They're going through all eight counties.
They're going to be going through Bay City
because we want the decision makers of the MD&C
and MDAR to really see where the opportunities
are, what's going on here.
One thing I can tell you from the economic development
perspective, and we get it, is that
after the recession, a major
focus went on
Detroit, as well as SHU.
Huge emphasis on Grand Rapids.
It should. On Lansing,
it should. We often see
governors, leaders from the
MD&C, advocating
on behalf of our big communities. What we
haven't seen is
a governor coming and saying, you know what?
I went and I found a lead, and we're coming
to Bay City with this label. This next
facility is going to come here.
This community is important. I'm telling
you, if a factory came in
with a thousand jobs into Bay City,
there would be statues of you
and the governor put up.
It would have that kind of impact.
So, what I would say from
our standpoint is, this is us
lighting ourselves on fire,
saying, these areas
up here desperately need your attention
that when there's a project
that's looking at the state of Michigan,
that it's just not always the big
three counties or lanes near Grand Rapids.
That an area like Bay City,
you want to talk about this, I see it all the time.
I'll go to Meijer, and I will run into
that employee who's gone
and governor, they are talented.
They are smart. They have so much
potential, but they're working at Meijer
because that's the job available for
them here.
You know, I grew up here
and left for 18 years
and came back, and looking at Bay City
today, folks like
Jen and her family who have made massive
investments to revolutionize our
downtown, to build the infrastructure,
to build all these amazing things,
the thing that this community
is desperate for, and clamoring for now,
jobs. Where can we get
the jobs? That's the next piece, because then the
jobs will offer more
for the kids that are here, the
universities that we have here, that will help
rebuild the neighborhoods. It will build
the tax base. Our commissioners
will have more money to invest in
the infrastructure, on the pipes,
on those things. I can tell you,
and I think that's probably why it's number one for all of us,
we just left our board meeting,
which you've been to before,
we were talking more in crops
than it's now, on attraction, because
all we know is that this
region definitely needs better
jobs, more jobs, etc.
So in terms of programs, things you can do,
we want to see
things like good jobs for Michigan
to be real. We would love
to see maybe
smaller programs that are there, so it's
not such a high volume
of jobs. We're not going to bring
in the thousands of jobs that you see
in a Detroit announcement. So maybe
there's a similar program like good jobs
for Michigan that benefits a
smaller community, like at Bay City,
Saginaw, Midland. But definitely
continued investment
on economic development policy,
on incentives, on things that will
help Trevor bring jobs here.
But just in general,
just the administration understanding
that cities like this
outside of the major areas,
the site selectors just automatically
come to Detroit. Jobs just come to
Detroit. Having the big three there,
not that they don't work, but things just
kind of show up to them a lot of times.
Ooh, they do not just show up
here. We have got to work hard
to get people from the outside to
recognize why this community makes
tons of sense for their
company, ag processing facility,
etc. I think
everyone would say that is a thing that this
community is desperate for.
Folks like Trevor and I
have literally put our capital
as professionals in this community
on helping us accomplish
or the community will never take that
next dark step for being
that thriving city that we want
Bay City to be, Saginaw to be.
I appreciate that.
What I hear,
and I appreciate what you're doing,
this field trip
between DC and
I think
and I would imagine or assume
that part of that has to do with
the asset management
that you mentioned about
what the
critical importance of assets are
and what makes them attractive.
I think that that is something that
all of our communities are trying to assist
you and have you
to be able to accomplish that.
You say that these are the assets
that you need to be able to use
in a fantastic way
to make this happen.
I think this community
is really on the verge of
tipping over into greatness.
One of the things that
I feel very cautious about
is
we've got lots of
vibrancy going on in the downtown
and we need to not leave the neighborhood behind.
I think we can
very easily become a community of
have and have not, and I want to make sure that
we take care of our neighborhoods.
I think housing, we need to become
more collaborative
and we need to work
not in our silos
but in a
one direction moving forward.
I think in education,
you're in that field, Laura.
You're in the education field.
Our statistics,
we operate with a college access network.
We have one in Bay County that
actually existed before the Michigan
college access network.
It's been around for a while, but we really need to
go up to that next level.
Our stats show that Bay County
is at 33.4%
in post-secondary training, but that
does include the specialty training.
We really
need to grow that.
We need to work with
ReConnect Michigan and just other programs.
If you identify businesses
that are on your target
list, if there are certain types
of skills that they need,
how can we help through that college access
network get those people trained
so that those employers will have those positions?
We want to see those connections.
I think attraction is hard.
I think it's easier if we start to
retain and teach
kids that are coming out of high school and coming out of
the local community colleges and universities
that we're a great place to start a business.
We're a fantastic place.
I need more MEP engineering grants.
Please, someone, start one.
Manufacturing for robotic construction.
There are a lot of opportunities here.
I appreciate everything that the Alliance
is doing and the staff.
The cultural
shift on a cooperative
economy versus a very competitive economy
that people want to compete for jobs
versus collaborate with one another
in order to grow all sectors
and do better for everyone is definitely
a challenge when it comes to the mindset
of this area and my experience.
I'm like Matt. I came home to this area
after being away for a long time,
and I came back and started a business,
which is
challenging. We work in real estate.
We've done a lot of investment in
downtown Bay City, and we struggle a lot with
commercial companies
who want to be here. We utilize real
estate and space a lot differently.
Where's that middle ground
in between building
out on the highway and continuing to sprawl
for large manufacturing facilities
versus being able to find
companies that can inhabit our old buildings
and build new within our
cities and our city limits and rebuild
that tax base and pay for our roads and
infrastructure and also create the kind
of place that talent wants.
Business needs talent,
talent wants place,
and place needs business.
A program
that I really think
is incredible
that could maybe model in other
sectors is the DNR Summer Youth
Employment Program.
DNR Summer Youth Employment
Program provides funding to a
community organization in our region.
It would be the First World Community Center in Santa Ana.
What they do is they're bringing
about 40 kids from that immediate area.
These are all kids that would probably
not have
a job or might not have an opportunity
to keep them out of trouble. This is basically a full-time
job, and they're actually paid for it.
They work three days a week in the field
doing conservation and stewardship
oriented projects, cleaning up parks and whatnot.
Then they spend a day
essentially in the community center
learning college application skills
or resident building skills or whatever
it might be, computer skills, things that they
might be lacking behind them
in school. Then one day a week
they often get to go on a field trip and learn
about another community or go to a state park
or something along those lines. All that's included
in this program. Our organization,
the Saginaw Basin Life Conservancy, we're
working on void remediation all across Saginaw
so we clean up non-structural voids and plant
flower gardens and things like that. We're doing
restoration projects here in Bay City with some
really cool ones coming up.
That's been huge for us because they need something to do
and they need a space to do it
so what we do is we create
opportunities for them to come in and do it.
It's really symbiotic. We facilitate all this
stuff. Their crew comes in and does all the work.
They're learning on the job.
We've created jobs for some of them to come
and work for us the following year. Three, four, five
of them will come and work for us as a summer job
the following year on their way either into
college or local college, maybe trade school.
So it's really neat because
they're doing work in their own neighborhood.
Often sometimes it's like, well I live over there
or I grew up over there and I'm cleaning up
a rusted out car in a
vacant lot over here. Their own neighborhood
looks better so you're kind of
rendering community pride,
potentially retention there,
maybe not feeling so
disinvested about their own community.
There's a lot of that and skepticism about
staying there, but I don't know.
There's a lot of really positive energy out of that group
that binds them together.
If you can take something along those lines,
I just really think that that is a very excellent
and not very expensive program.
They could potentially be in
a manufacturing tech space.
Can you imagine 40 kids that are working with an outbound
and they're going in and doing odd jobs and things
and starting to learn in there.
We've got kids that have come through our program and now they want to be
equipment operators and arborists.
They want to go to Michigan State for group science
and things like that.
It's just overwhelming.
It's added this whole level of
equity building in these communities,
environmental justice, all of the things
we talked about. That model is
extraordinary and probably the best state program
that I've ever interacted with in 20 years.
I'm from Cleveland City.
My co-host is a
two and four year old.
I got 25
year olds
in my family.
My co-host
is
when I think about
how much has changed
since I graduated high school
and my thought is
when they graduate high school
and then they have to decide a career
and go on to law
and into the future.
I am from North Carolina
so basically I never
left here. I stayed.
I really hope that we can create an environment
that my children, they don't have to
do that, you know, water,
they can somehow make some
money if they can stay in the community
and play in the community.
By creating
that environment that they can
be nostalgic about.
You know,
think about what I
grew up,
my life all around
and my parents didn't care and I felt safe
and I just
want them to be able to have
a safe
and
a safe feeling about their career.
Innocentness is
something that
we have,
as you described,
make spaces that are welcoming
that are safe
that are accessible
to everyone.
So,
you know, I'm trying to think about
there are probably
you know, ideas
that people program
at the state level
to help them
but what does it look like
for the state
to be able to help
those people?
I think we're already
going in the right direction
and I think that we have a community
that people come here
they like it,
a lot of people have seen that
I know
another city
commissioner always talks about
how we remember
the choices that we made.
So,
I think that we have a nice
quality of life
that we don't always have the opportunity
to do that
and I
wouldn't mention
that
all the time
but
it's pretty important
for a lot of folks to have that
opportunity.
So,
you know,
I love it that
in the last job I had
in Minnesota,
I had that all the time.
So,
you know,
that's just what we kind of
volunteer. We do that service
in the state and
if we could,
if we ever went for something like that,
then we're ready to go.
Yeah.
And another thing, Governor,
kind of our education piece,
I think, what are the college regions
here in the state?
From 45 minutes from this talk,
we're home to Delta,
MidMichigan Community College,
Sion Valley State University,
North Fork, CMU,
Michigan State Supply Chain Program
is number one in the country and they're sitting in
Alma College.
We have 60,000
college kids within
45 minutes of this exact spot
that we're in right now. This is as much
college down the college route as anyone else.
One shame on us, we don't sell it enough.
We're working on that.
But people always talk about, you know, if I meet with companies
where do you have the talent? And I laugh. We got it.
60,000 kids every
doggone year right here.
We just need to give them more of a reason
to stay here. We actually have this
excess of talent. We, all these
kids come up from Metro Detroit and
Lansing, Grand Rapids and they're at SPSU
and at CMU. Phenomenal kids.
We got to give them better
reasons to stay. We give them more reasons
to stay, more things that are going on.
There comes that next boom
where we can explode, where we can go,
how we can get that next step.
But we have so many
of the pieces right here
in place.
There's another thing that I mean,
for a long hard decade we've been
seeing within the urban
centers is the school choice
substantial policy.
If you look at Bay City public
numbers and what that has done
to the flight out of the city
and you can see that
around all of the state. I'm sure
you see it in Detroit.
And it's taken the amount of
schools we have and
expanded how that money
is divided across the whole state
which has just brought down
the level of education overall.
It's kind of fast and negative.
In fact in my opinion
and if you want to change
what happens in the urban centers
get rid of it.
I would agree with that.
My thought too is
here in Bay County
we have five school districts.
Is that correct?
Five school districts?
And it's something
a lot of people disagree about.
A county the size of
Bay County and a city the size of
Bay City, five school
districts is a model from 50 years ago.
And is there any incentive
from the state for
consolidation or
some sort of stricter
community's moving towards consolidation
and I could see a school district
for a day longer.
What's that?
The school of choice
is so spread out.
Diane mentioned
collaboration.
The school of choice now
you're competing.
I work for Bay City School.
I get calls from John Lennon
and other school districts
for information, for help
with urban-civil-mining.
I don't know. Why should I help you
in the way of stealing our students
or building your program?
My response is Mr. and Mr. State
don't practice together.
Why am I going to help
a competitor
build a program that could
take students away from our district?
Say go, we should go to King Madison.
I didn't
at first come to comment
but I've witnessed
the DNI program
and how they
collaborate with
and it's actually
a very good
model of how to get people
who do the educational
to say we need that
because it looks a lot like
the model that
the government
puts in
homeless or unemployed
and they sort of
mine buildings
to take back to that district
that program.
You put new homes
or new homes for low-income families
and then the other part of the
retirement is finishing
and high school is starting
college situation
for a teacher
and career at NASA
I would like to
place in this area
something that
people can accept about
the way that
I'm a person with a
disability now
and I'm rejected all over the place
so I think it's going to
have to start with acceptance.
You're going to have to accept everyone
not just the people
that understand you
and not just the people
that have just been told
sicknesses
because not even
a week ago I was diagnosed
with a similar illness
I think it's absurd
to think about that
but I see people
in these communities
talking about how wonderful this is
and these are all the programs
that we have
and you've got to get your
community in action
you've got to get your neighborhood in action
about acceptance of every single person in your neighborhood
and you've got to
teach your children
and that's going to have to start at your house.
Anybody for
a translation?
I think
it's correlated
to go back to education
that the nostalgic idea
of neighborhood schools
and you want to go to a neighborhood school
and you want the feeling of it
but I love
the neighborhoods that we have. If you go to
South End, the neighborhoods have alleys
and there are streets
and it's narrow streets that we can't build
and design like that anymore because
all your engines are so big and the curb
has to be so round and you would lose
a lot of backspace
on the street that we have
in those neighborhoods that
actually have a better safety
ratio but now the sidewalk
is all rubbled up
and it's not easy to walk on them
because the norms are conservative
and it's a completely different experience
so kind of getting back to
things that we do want
you have to think of it
in the neighborhood
I don't know how
in the education space
how it affects the neighborhoods now
but I do see how
when I grew up it was you went to
the hot school district
and then now
SSL Hampton can't
re-bond and they're in financial hardship
so people are jumping over in Western
the hot school so we're seeing
people just kind of go based on
the new infrastructure
and what's been updated because
parents always want the special kids
so making somehow
universal and getting
those neighborhood schools and really rebuilding
that connectivity that you have with your neighbors
and spending more time on your front door
is a really great thing to do for you
So I have one specific
from the transportation piece that we see
because we try to discuss it quite frequently
and it sounds
absurd because you've seen
it so much and how hard it is
to get regional transportation
in metro Detroit
but we're hamstrung by some of the laws
so it doesn't allow
a Saginaw transit system
to go outside of the borders of
Saginaw County, it doesn't allow the folks
from Bay County to go outside of Bay County
and so they've had to try to be
creative, they'll try to meet at a
county line, they'll try to meet at a
university
So it's an archaic system
but probably changing that law that
you know, people in Bay City may need to get Saginaw
they need to get Saginaw for work
for healthcare, yeah
we don't live in a world anymore where
we get the dotted lines of Bay County
so our bus can't run past there
it probably also just doesn't
make sense
having the four unique
especially here, three unique systems
there's probably got to be a better way
for Bay, Saginaw and Linden folks
to bounce between their communities
so I think, yeah
they don't have to answer, we have got to
think a little bit smarter about
and it's just not
some people struggle to get work
we hear a lot in the healthcare space
and what happens here, you may be
a Bay City resident and have to get to a specialist
in Saginaw and they're being
readmitted to the hospital over and over again
because they never get to Saginaw
they've got to get to their follow-up appointments
so our healthcare
costs are increasing
and then you have the education piece
that was one of the beautiful parts of now
a downtown Delta campus in Saginaw
so many of those Saginaw kids couldn't even get out
to University Center, at least now they can go there
but it's impacting
jobs, healthcare, education across
the board, but that law in particular
for a community like ours is archaic
we have to change how we look
at county by county public transit
and does it make more sense regionally
but you know as well as I
way better than we do actually
regional transit is a very very
difficult discussion but there are some laws
hindering us here in this region
I appreciate that
and this is something that
we're diving in is
we believe in other
aspects of the building that
we've been collaborating on
transportation infrastructure
we've been talking about
that kind of infrastructure
I'm 36, I want to ride a motorcycle
I actually decided to do that
when I came and so
that's something that's been around
for a very long time
when I came, my parents were not here
they were in South Delta
my dad actually fled South Delta
so I think
transportation costs
and housing
are highly correlated
because
we don't have
reliable transit systems
across the entire region
and it's a requirement here
to really have a car
and to insure that car
that's money that is
almost anticipated
and expected
in addition to your housing costs
I develop
and build apartments downtown
and people say they must be so nice
they must be so expensive
we're actually about 80% to 100%
AMIO rents
but that's where our market
is
that the transportation
costs that people also face
in addition to their housing costs
that's really
where I think it hurts that
low income that we're seeing
for $36,000
and you have to pay it for
a vehicle loan, insurance
plus housing costs, groceries
and everything else
I think that's really hurting
We had an employee
that came out of that
he wasn't programmed
he worked for an intermediary
for us for a couple of years
and right now his car is in the shop
and I'm paying for the repairs to it
because it's less expensive for me to spend a couple hundred dollars
for his car to get back on the road
and try to make him more mobile
because he lives on the south side of Saginaw
and I literally had a full time employee
drive him all the way to the south side of Saginaw
pick him up, bring him back to work in Bay City
and drive him back there
and he also had an opportunity
he came out and he's such a hard worker
he came out to a volunteer opportunity
that we had the other day
just assisted our staff
and the City of Bay City
Parks and Recreation Department
came down to Saginaw to help us clean up vacant lots
as an exchange for some work we're doing
just to be friendly
which is pretty cool
DPW for the City of Bay City said
who is that guy? So I tossed
he's a real man
and he's just the sweetest kid
he's just the sweetest kid, you've never seen a harder worker
we have to call him down on stuff
hey call him down and toss
so he said boy I'd love to hire this kid
to come work for me for some of my stuff
because our season is paring down
he's got about 6 more weeks where he needs that
he needs the money, there's no real viable way
for him to get that job
and it's just
the only way for him to get that job
right now is for me to fix his 1995
grand am
for him because he doesn't have a lot of money
because he's also helping take care of his
sister
and all these massive stories
that are intertwined with everything else
but I'll be daring if I'm going to
let that opportunity for him
because I'll be honest
we could use a hundred million bucks
for Tuna's birthday
that's for the real elephant
I could use two and a half billion dollars
we overextend ourselves
to make sure some of the costs
end it
but I'm spending as much
on everything around
supporting him as an employee
then I could have two
of him
if there were some
easy pathway programs to help
organizations like ours
bring people to a program like that
and on top of that
one of my full time
staff is a former admissions counselor
at SPSU
I ended up setting him all up to go back
to school now
and he's going to go through a variety of different programs
to be able to afford it
he's going to work part time in the admissions office there
these are things that wouldn't be possible
but it's been an extraordinary amount of effort
to continue to create this one person
and if there was some way
to potentially offset or coordinate
with other non-profits
to do more of that
I don't know exactly how to put the silver bullet on it
I didn't expect to be talking about that today
but the more I think about it
I'm going to start putting in the help
because I'd love to have five or six of him every year
but I can't afford it
I guess I'd like to say
a quick thank you
I've seen you basically several times now
this is fantastic
seeing Senator Daley here with you
is great, seeing the announcement today
that the budget was first
bipartisanship, great
working together, finding solutions, great
we just appreciate you spending the time here
like you have in Bay City
you and the governor have taken it very seriously
you've been here
it's noticeable, Senator Daley lives on the pier
we see him here, it's noticeable
wherever you guys can work together
to find solutions
for our community, that's what we care about
we get the political world
and how it works
but our community honestly doesn't have time for that
we want solutions
we want people working together
it's great seeing both of you here in the room
it's great seeing both of you here in Bay City
it's great
I wanted to
talk to you
I mentioned
when the smaller group was here in the beginning
I'm still learning about the community
I live in two towns
so I spend a lot of time
I'm here to learn
and listen
I appreciate you being here
we work together a lot
so I want to thank
if we could all speak now
I want to thank all of you
for making the time
to engage
in this process
it's not the end of the process
we're going to be having
these conversations across the state
in the next couple of months
but we want you to stay here
to come up
please send a plea
for people that you know
we can
inquire this
we can do a lot of
statistical policy
changes
we want to compile
all of those
there's going to be some learning
and so
I want you all to
this is what we hope
it looks like
thank you
and now you do every day
great
so with that
I thank you for participating
in this process
thank you very much
we're just happy that Boston
and the faculty
that you've been here
everybody's happy
you're all good
so we've been
since I was 12
we're probably the only
guys that graduated
yeah
we always get a lot of science
and product design
we're going to do a lot of
yeah
that's good
yeah
that's good

