Trump ‘LOOKING AT’ PARDONING Gretchen Whitmer KIDNAP Plotters | RISING
President Trump said this week that he'll consider pardoning the men charged
with plotting to kidnap Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer.
Here's Trump on Wednesday.
Will you pardon the people who are accused of conspiring to kidnap Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer?
I'm going to look at it. I will take a look at it. It's been brought to my attention.
I did watch the trial. It looked to me like somewhat of a railroad job.
I'll be honest with you, it looked to me like some people said some stupid things, you know,
they were drinking and I think they said stupid things.
But I'll take a look at that. And a lot of people are asking me that question from both sides, actually.
A lot of people think they got railroaded. A lot of people think they got railroaded.
And probably some people don't. One more. Go ahead.
Whitmer responded yesterday to Trump's thoughts on the matter. Here she is.
Well, you know, very disappointed that they're even considering it, frankly.
You know, when the president was shot at in Pennsylvania,
I was one of the first people on either side of the aisle to condemn it.
We have to condemn political violence no matter where it comes from, no matter who it's aimed at.
Two men, Adam Fox and Barry Croft Jr., were among those convicted in the plot.
Court documents say the plotters were angry about Governor Whitmer's COVID-19 restrictions
and planned to take her from her vacation.
There's one aspect in this case that has raised some questions, however.
As The New York Times reported in 2022, defense filings show that the FBI deployed
at least 12 informants and several undercover agents during the debacle.
The defense argued that these undercover informants and agents entrapped Croft and Fox.
But a federal appeals court upheld Fox and Croft's convictions earlier this year.
The two had claimed the trial judge prevented them from using an entrapment defense.
Interesting case, this one, Amber.
There was fairly widespread use of informants in this case, as you suggested.
I, as a general matter, always think that raises legitimate ethical concerns
as well as concerns about the ultimate finding in the trial.
In this case, I think that these guys were guilty, as has been upheld in appeal,
and I am not at all persuaded by any evidence that I have seen
that the actions of informants were the catalyst that got these guys over the line into illegality.
And this did come up when they appealed the decision, and a government lawyer in that appeal
talked about Mr. Fox saying that he said we need to take our tyrants hostages
before he had ever met a government informant,
and Barry Croft had been saying the same thing for much longer.
So I would argue that although the use of informants is often ethically complicated,
there was genuine... I mean, these guys were involved in the militia
that was doing training exercises and other things.
There had been an armed protest in the Michigan state capitol, I believe.
I think when there's a threat like that, police and law enforcement have to figure out what to do about it,
and I don't really see this as some giant miscarriage of justice.
I think at best you could say that these individuals were popping off with generalities about distaste for government officials,
but it was really the FBI informants, and I'm loath to even call them that,
because in this case they really did drive the entirety of the plot.
They were the ones who actually gathered these separate individuals together into a group.
They then created a Facebook page for it called the Michigan Three Percenters,
and dubbed Adam Fox the new leader of that group.
The FBI informants were getting paid tens of thousands of dollars
and being encouraged by their handlers to push these people along
to the idea of killing or kidnapping specific government officials.
So after their initial meeting, which the FBI informants orchestrated,
they were the ones who encouraged them to go to that protest at the state capitol,
and in fact, when they showed up, it was the FBI handlers who told the police at the Michigan state capitol
to stand down and allow them to go inside to give the impression that they were there to do some kind of armed takeover.
Then you fast forward, and in the text messages and in the testimony from the FBI informants
during the court trials of these individuals,
they admit that they were the ones who first brought up the idea of kidnapping the Michigan governor.
At first, all of the other people in the group who were not FBI informants said that they didn't want to do that,
that they didn't like the idea, that they didn't want to hurt anybody,
they just wanted a constitutional republic.
The FBI informants kept pushing, and apparently it got so distasteful to the members of the group
that in August, before the plot was attempted to be carried out, the group started to disband.
And the FBI informant who went by Big Dan was again told by his handler,
you have to make sure that these people don't separate, that we get them back together,
and we carry this out to the end.
So Big Dan again orchestrates some big meeting for these guys to get back together
and starts driving them to the governor's vacation home, which he suggested as the kidnapping spot.
They had another FBI informant on the bridge where boats could come in and out
to see if police would be able to respond there.
A second FBI informant decides to show the group a video of him carrying out a bombing of a vehicle
to prove that he would be able to bomb the bridge to prevent police from getting to the home
if some alarm were triggered, and telling them that he had the money to pay for all of the explosives.
And it was only after all of that that these individuals were picked up and indicted by the FBI.
So I think it's one thing to have an FBI informant sitting in on a group
and listening to people and following them as they are engaging in these actions.
It's another thing for them to suggest crimes, to drive people, to encourage the planning of a crime.
And so the fact that this was almost entirely driven and advanced by the FBI informants
is what makes this, I think, reasonable for Trump to consider pardoning them.
I think that where we disagree, it seems to me, at the core of the issue
is the extent to which you say it was driven by FBI informants.
I would argue that that's not the case.
I mean, you have characterized a lot of it there in terms that, you know, obviously support your interpretation.
I would argue that these guys, particularly Fox and Croft,
because it is worth noting that there were people acquitted in this case, right?
There were, I believe, 14 people were originally charged.
There were nine people either convicted or pleaded guilty, and five were acquitted.
Yeah, and Fox and Croft initially had a mistrial, and then they brought the charges again.
Yeah, they brought the charges again, and they were convicted.
And then they sought to appeal, claiming that they were not allowed to raise these issues of entrapment,
and the convictions were upheld.
Which is true, because they were not allowed to include.
The prosecution showed their text messages, but the defense was excluded
from showing the text messages in response from the FBI informants
and from showing the text messages from the FBI handlers.
But the point I would make is that the intent, in my view, from those two guys in particular,
was already threatening to Gretchen Whitmer and was already antagonistic,
not just to her policies, but it's not as if these guys are some sort of
vaguely dissatisfied right-wing guys who were lured in, in my opinion, by informants.
They had the impulses or the desire to do these things.
There was then an argument about to what extent informants, I think you used the phrase,
sped the process on or not.
I don't share your characterization of those events, and I think that's why the convictions
in these cases were not just found by a jury in the first place.
Well, Big Dan did testify in court, though, that he was the one who first asked for the plan
and came up with the idea of kidnapping Gretchen Whitmer.
Adam Fox, before he was brought into this group of disparate people that were identified as the FBI
as potentially becoming extremists, was living in the basement of a vacuum cleaner shop,
had no money to his name to the point that he had to go to a Mexican restaurant next door
to brush his teeth and wash his face.
The FBI informant, Big Dan, had on multiple occasions offered him credit cards and gift cards
that he could use to buy weapons and ammunition to take on government officials,
and every single time he declined.
And both he and other members of the group, after the first several times the kidnapping plot
was brought up, said, we don't want to do that.
And yet the FBI kept pushing, not to mention the handler in this case, who was responsible for Big Dan,
broke FBI protocol because he had a security company on the side where he was posting
private information about the upcoming arrest in a Facebook group to promote his security company.
So there was a vested interest by the FBI handlers and informants in this case
to make sure that they were keeping this group together and pushing them to try to commit
some type of act of domestic terrorism or extremism, even despite their initial reluctance
and unwillingness to do it.
So you kind of go from people who were expressing things that, frankly,
were similar to left-wing chats about the guy who killed the two people outside of the Jewish event
talking about, like, we need to genocide the white people.
And it's like, would I have supported the FBI picking that guy up over that?
No, because people in private chats all the time say things that sound extreme because they're venting.
But the only time that a specific plan was created, it was spurred by the FBI informants
creating the plan first and then dragging these other guys along with them.
But the reason the FBI informants were part of the picture to start off with
was because these guys had set up a, not the three percenters, but a separate militia,
the Wolverine, the second word's escaping me at the moment.
I do think that it's not quite fair to characterize this just as people saying inflammatory things
or having extreme political opinions.
Extreme political opinions are, generally speaking, protected speech.
The reasons these guys came to the attention of the FBI in the first place
was that prior to any informants being turned or inserted into that organization,
that organization appeared to be gearing up for actual action of some kind.
Which is why I would say, regardless of whether that was on the left or the right,
those kind of plans do rightfully draw law enforcement attention
as to how they can be scrutinized or surveilled or otherwise disrupted.
Right, but there was no specific plan, which is exactly the point.
They had people basically playing around with guns and cosplaying as a militia.
And it's, I think, very reasonable to say that there would have never been an attempt
to kidnap the Michigan governor unless the FBI informants had been involved in it.
So if you thought that these guys were potentially going to become radicalized,
or already were, and were going to create a plot to do something bad,
to do something violent, then okay, have an FBI agent watch them.
Have them report back to their handlers about what these guys are saying.
But it is not appropriate for the FBI to, out of whole cloth, come up with a plot
and then tell these guys, I've got the money to do it, I've got the resources to do it.
I know you said you don't want to, but come back in, these are your brothers,
these are your friends, and actually provide the specifics,
the details of the supposed plan that the militia was going to do anyway.
Setting aside that specific debate, which we can continue having about
how exactly to characterize their actions, would you not think that the proper remedy,
let's posit that your interpretation is correct,
is the remedy not in the courts rather than a presidential pardon?
Well, I mean, ideally, the courts would have found these guys not guilty,
but they didn't.
And so that's what the presidential pardon is for,
is when you think the justice system got it wrong,
that's an executive power remedy to fix it.
But your argument is that there has been a miscarriage of justice, right?
Yes, I think so.
And that is something that I think benefits more from going through the appellate process
rather than just having a president come in and going, okay, that's done.
I mean, that would be ideal, but it doesn't always work that way, does it?
You can make the same argument for the people that Joe Biden pardoned
for low-level marijuana offenses.
You could say, yes, based on the law, those people committed a crime
and they are serving sentences that are laid out by federal law, right?
But then Joe Biden has the right to say, I think that that law is unjust,
and so I'm going to provide them with a pardon.
Yes, but you're probably going to have to go here,
but Biden's argument there is that the law is unjust.
That's separate, it seems to me, from saying the law is valid
and those people were wrongfully convicted.
Do you understand the distinction?
Well, I do, but I think in this case the miscarriage of justice
was the fact that they were not allowed to present certain evidence
in their defense on the entrapment point.
And that really is the underlying argument as to why these guys
were wrongfully convicted, is that they were not able to present
the proper defense in order to hold the FBI accountable for what they did.
Fair enough. I'll let you have the last word.
I appreciate that, as always.
FBI Director Kash Patel takes a swipe at James Comey.
That's next.

