On this episode of "International Reporters Roundtable," UFOs come into focus. From ancient drawings to sci-fi novels, fuzzy photos to pilot anecdotes, now the United States Congress is seeking answers on the phenomenon.
In May 2022, Congress held its first public hearing in half a century on “unidentified aerial phenomena,” or UAPs as they’re now called. Not since the excitement and fear surrounding the mysterious Roswell crash landing has there been so much attention paid to this matter. Meanwhile, sightings and secrecy have mounted, eroding trust in our institutions.
Then, this July, a House Subcommittee invited two former military pilots and an intelligence whistleblower to testify about encounters, recovered “non-human” biologics, and government cover ups. Are these visitors from outer space or covert military machines? Either way, they say, the stigma has to go.
What are the risks, is our security at stake, and how should we think about space in the 21st century—both the threats and opportunities?
As the space race heats up with Russia's failure and India's success, and China's activities continue to take us by surprise, guests Brandon Weichert, Greg Allison, and Art Harman join us to discuss unidentified aerial phenomena, and other secrets in space.
In this episode of International Reporters Roundtable, UFOs,
from ancient drawings to sci-fi novels, fuzzy photos
to pilot anecdotes.
And now, the US Congress.
Are these mysterious flying objects
covert military machines or visitors from outer space?
How should humans handle space in the 21st century?
Guests Brandon Weikart, Greg Allison, and Art Harmon
join us to discuss unidentified aerial phenomena
and other secrets in space.
Welcome to International Reporters Roundtable.
I'm your host, Cindy Drewcare.
Our conversations bring together journalists
and experts from around the world.
They help us uncover hidden information
and details of conflicts, alliances, and connections
in a deep dive discussion.
Today, in this vast universe,
it's hard not to wonder if we're alone.
It's also hard not to wonder if the government knows more
than we're being told.
That suspicion dates back to 1947, Roswell, New Mexico,
when Rancher found some unusual debris at a crash site.
Military intelligence came and investigated
and announced that they had recovered a flying disc.
But the next day, the story changed.
It was a weather balloon.
But the details for those who are looking closely at it
never seemed to add up.
Finally, in the mid-90s, the military came out and said
that the balloon was a cover story
for classified technology, a spying project.
Many don't believe that either, and suspicion still abounds.
In the years since, military and civilian pilots
have reported countless encounters with aerial technology
that they can't explain.
But there is one constant.
Talking about UFOs carries a stigma.
Tim Foyle, hat territory.
Your career and reputation will suffer.
But that may be changing.
In May 2022, Congress held its first public hearing
on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena, or UAPs,
as they're now called, in half a century.
In April, the chief of the new Department of Defense
All Domain Anomaly Resolution Office, Sean Kirkpatrick,
told Congress that the DOD is currently tracking
over 650 UAP cases.
And then just in July, a House subcommittee
invited two former military pilots
and an intelligence whistleblower to testify
about encounters, recovered non-human biologics,
and government coverups.
They say the stigma has to go,
and we need to take this seriously, or what?
What are the risks?
Is our security at stake?
How should we think about space in the 21st century,
both the threats and the opportunities?
Time to meet our panel.
Our guests today are Brandon Weikart,
a return guest on the show.
Brandon is a geopolitical analyst who lives by the creed,
I'm against fashionable thinking.
A prolific writer, he's currently the senior editor
at 1945.com, and contributes to the Washington Times,
Asia Times, and American Greatness.
Brandon has three books, including Winning Space,
How America Remains a Superpower.
He regularly briefs military business
and academic audiences on how high tech
impacts international politics.
Brandon, welcome back.
Greg Allison, a rocket scientist and space activist
for over 45 years.
Greg has his own space tech company,
A2Z Aerospace Services.
In his career, he's done work
for the International Space Station,
the National Space Society,
and he's won awards for his engineering,
including Project Halo or High Altitude Liftoff.
He also studies how to defend Earth from asteroids
and the construction of large-scale space stations.
Greg has two YouTube channels, including Galactic Greggs,
where he talks about space history
and prospects for life in space.
Finally, we have Art Harmon,
a space policy expert for 13 years.
He's the founder and president of the Coalition
to Save Manned Space Exploration.
He advised the Trump administration,
including recommending NASA return to the moon by 2024,
which is now official policy.
A former legislative director,
he knows the inner workings of Congress.
He's an award-winning filmmaker and photographer too,
and a Mars Society speaker,
and you can find his writings in The Hill,
Red State, Politico, and The Epoch Times.
All right, welcome everyone.
As I mentioned in the intro,
in late July, we had this congressional hearing on UAPs.
The room was packed,
the testimony and questions were very serious.
The main take-home from that hearing
was that there's phenomenon out there
that we cannot explain.
But because of the stigmatization of reporting,
there is no systematic collection of these reports,
and they're from highly credible people, as I mentioned.
A lot of them are military and commercial pilots.
And whether it's adversarial technology
or some other worldly phenomenon,
this puts pilots and the rest of us at risk, they say.
I wanna hear from each of you
what your impressions were of that hearing,
and if you agree that the over-classification,
as they put it, of this UAP information
actually is a problem.
Brandon, I'll start with you.
Well, yeah, it is a problem.
Obviously, there's something going on
that we can't quite explain.
And so for the sake of everybody's safety in the air,
we should have a much clearer line
of understanding and collection.
I'm not, as you know, sold that this is little green
or gray men from Zeta Reticuli.
I think this is experimental military technology
where the left hand isn't communicating to the right hand,
testing this stuff in our airspace.
But I do think we need a clearer understanding
of what it is, and it would be nice
if our pilots did not feel like they were threatened
every time they got into an airplane
and were flying the friendly skies as it were.
Right, because some of those encounters
have been pretty close, so we're not talking about,
you know, seeing something very far away.
Art, what are your thoughts on the hearing
and whether we're over-classifying things?
But I'd echo what Brandon says.
You know, if we do have such advanced technology,
much of it should, because the Chinese probably have it,
and the Russians may have it, and so forth.
So how about getting it into the public domain
so it can be commercialized?
If we can not be tied to conventional rockets
to go to the moon and space,
if we can literally have the flying cars
that many of us grew up dreaming about,
those things would add to the quality of life
and be healthy for all.
Get rid of the stigma.
Yep.
And Greg, same to you.
Well, I agree with both Brandon and Art
in that if this technology is available,
if anybody has it, given the pervasive spy network
that China has, they definitely have it.
Also given that their society is more secretive,
they can have a larger program and keep it under wraps.
If in our society, the United States,
we have this technology and it's both deep, varied,
that only the Congress can get their fingers on it,
then it's not a very big program.
But people have been looking into this,
these technologies, for decades.
So it is quite possible
that we have human-derived technologies like this.
So who is it?
What are they?
There's a lot of anomalies here that are yet to begin.
So, Brandon, why do you think it is so stigmatized?
Do you think it's like a purposeful,
that they were suggesting in the hearing,
you know, it's purposeful government disinformation
because they don't want this to be out there?
Yeah, I think that that's exactly what it is.
I think if this is, in fact,
advanced U.S. military technology,
go back to Roswell, as you mentioned
at the beginning of the program,
that was the only, these things were flying over
the only nuclear weapons facility
in the world at the time, in 1947.
And so, you know,
we were probably testing experimental craft,
or maybe even the Soviets were.
We know at the end of the Second World War,
we got our hands on, as did the Soviets,
the Nazi scientists from Peenemunde,
where they were developing really exotic technologies
at the end of the war for Hitler.
And we just scooped up all that information
and all that science,
and we brought it back to Los Alamos and the United States.
And we were, for 70 years,
playing with really sophisticated designs experimentally.
And so it's probable that whatever was taken down,
beginning with Roswell,
was some advanced military program,
either belonging to us or the Soviets at the time.
And we don't want to talk about it
because we don't want, as Art was saying we should do,
the military didn't want to share it with the public
and risk maybe that technology proliferating
in an uncontrolled way.
But Art, what do you think about that?
Because it has been 70 plus years.
So wouldn't the technology have advanced, you know,
well beyond whatever we were playing with in 1947,
yet it's still the same situation?
Art, what do you think?
Well, it certainly would have.
Let me give you sort of a little personal example.
Look up the name Thomas Townsend Brown,
look up asymmetric capacitors.
So this is something that the fellow
Thomas Townsend Brown first noticed
an electric propulsion effect back in the 1920s, I believe,
and into the 40s and, I'm sorry, the 50s, 60s,
he worked even with the government on it.
And you can see some videos online of his propulsion system.
So I built some of those in my basement, literally.
Hook up 40,000 volt power supply
and I could get things moving around in a fascinating way.
So, you know, that's what I can do on my workshop.
What can government scientists have done
with that technology back then
and advanced it with billion dollar labs?
Okay, we're hitting up on a break now.
So we're gonna take a short break
and then we will come back
and talk to you all a little bit more.
Welcome back.
This is International Reporters Roundtable.
I'm your host, Cindy Drew Care.
Let's return to our panel on UFOs
with our guests, Brendan Weikart,
Greg Allison, and Art Harmon.
Greg, I'm going to go to you.
Do you think, actually, I'm gonna ask all of you this,
so get prepared.
Not asking if you think we have had encounters,
but do you think there is other life out there?
Greg?
Well, I think there is a high probability
of other life out there through,
if nothing else, the effect of spermia,
whereas an impact hits Earth,
a material gets ejected,
and we now believe that some organisms,
like diatoms, could survive for prolonged periods
in deep space, especially within our own solar system.
And as the sun goes around the galaxy
every quarter of a billion years,
we may have seeded life from other places.
We may have gotten our life from other places,
because the rocks on Earth,
almost as soon as they cooled, had life on it.
It looks like in the fossil record,
but life, a single cell, is a very complex thing.
But all that life might be microbial.
That's how life on Earth's history was.
So having a complex life,
especially a technical civilization,
is a very difficult proposition.
It takes a long time, and there's no guarantee.
There's no guarantee that we will ever
develop a sustainable civilization in space,
which I hope we do, before we extinguish ourselves.
Just look where we're at with all the wars
around the world today,
and all the other things available to us.
We may not be able to survive ourselves,
and it may be characteristic.
When you look out in space,
you don't see the big megastructures,
the Dyson spheres.
I used to know Freeman Dyson,
and things like that, that you would expect to see
if there were large civilizations.
However, if the civilizations are using technology
that draws energy from vacuum space,
which may be possible, vacuum space is the theme,
it's got properties like inductance and passive properties,
which are the primitivity and permeability,
actually, inversely, of free space.
That governs things like the speed of light
going through space.
If you can learn and have the technology to control that,
you can see the kind of things we see in the atmosphere
with these anomalous phenomena,
unidentified anomalous phenomena, known as UAPs.
As for the Bifold-Brown effect,
which Art mentioned earlier,
I, too, had started a company
called Transdimensional Technologies.
We've played around with that.
I think, principally, that is ionic wind,
but still, that has applications,
and there are people today looking
to launch an aircraft to do that.
But a very sophisticated lab
might find they could put tensions on free space
with similar technological approaches
that might produce the kind of things we're seeing.
So these technologies may be available,
they may be human-derived.
I do support the idea of humans settling in space.
That's been an all-time passion of mine.
All right, well, we'll get to that.
Brandon, let me ask you, if you agree with Art,
or if you agree with Greg,
that there's a chance
that there's other intelligent life out there,
given how gigantic the universe is
and how little of it we've explored,
how much resources do you think is worth putting into
trying to discover that as humans?
Well, I think it's an important question.
So the scientific community has been invested
for many years now in trying to answer that.
But my fear is that if there is other life out there,
either it's extinguished itself,
which is why we're not seeing any traces of it,
because they reach a certain point,
and we're seeing this, I think,
in things like the Russo-Ukraine War,
where we're flirting with nuclear devastation for,
you know, I'm still confused why,
but that could be happening on all of these planets
where there are advanced life.
Or what Stephen Hawking said before he died,
maybe we don't want to be broadcasting our position
to the cosmos, because maybe if there is life out there,
they're descended from predators,
and they're going to treat us the way that Cortes
and the conquistadors treated the Aztecs.
And so maybe we shouldn't be broadcasting.
But in either event,
I do think it is interesting to ask this question.
I don't, though, think that this should be
the primary thing we focus on.
I'm much more interested in, A,
defending the United States from a space-based attack
from one of our human or Earth-based rivals,
and then, B, building out, as Greg was saying,
the infrastructure needed to support
American-led permanent space colonization
and the creation of the space mining industry
led by the United States.
Okay, well, we'll get into that a little bit more,
but let me ask you, Art,
if the government does know more than they're letting on,
let's pretend the government knew that we had,
you know, encounters with other intelligent life out there,
do you think they should make that public,
or would that cause too much chaos, panic, et cetera?
Or it'd certainly cause panic,
and shock a lot of people's
foundational beliefs about humanity.
I would say, well, if God created man in his image,
could he have done that elsewhere in the universe?
I don't know.
But it's sort of a great mystery,
you know, what are the probabilities
of other civilizations?
Also, we have things like SETI,
and it looks for certain radio waves.
Well, if we were looking for
life across a mountain or something,
and we're looking for smoke signals,
that was a high technology in 1700,
or in the Roman eras, smoke signals.
And so, if we're looking at that,
and some other civilization was light years,
so to speak, beyond that,
and had means of communications we have no idea about,
then we're just kind of wasting our time with SETI,
looking at radio frequencies that we know of,
and we think they would know of.
So, if there is life out there,
and if it's intelligent life,
and if it is trying to communicate with us,
yeah, Brandon's right,
we don't necessarily want to say, hi, guys.
There's also the issue of quantum communication,
which we and the Chinese are in a race for developing.
That might be the thing that we can actually figure out,
because that's a very sophisticated form of communication,
much more so than radio.
And I think that as we develop the technology
over the next century,
we probably will start using that
to try to figure out at the quantum level,
can we detect or make communication
with anybody else using the technology?
That's probably the technology, though,
that would maybe give us an answer.
Can you explain a bit more about what that technology is?
Yeah, so basically, it's based on quantum entanglement.
Basically, two particles can exist in two,
I'm sorry, one particle can exist
in two different places at the same time,
and then we can come in and use a technological process
to basically transmit data across that subatomic level
and instantaneously,
and it's a lot of data we can transmit.
This is pretty much the next wave of major communication.
This is related to quantum computing,
which they think could be bigger
than your silicon-based computing,
of course, if they have to make it work.
China and Google are two of the groups
that are really leading the development of this product,
as is IBM with their D-Wave,
but basically, this is the new frontier in computer science,
and from that investigation into quantum computing,
they have spun off in China
and created quantum internet and quantum communication
using the same principle,
and it could basically transmit lots of data in real time,
large quantities of it across any distance
almost instantaneously.
At least that's how it's being sold.
Greg, if we make contact using this technology,
and I'm thinking back to what you were talking about before
about different civilizations,
what do you think, and I have a reason for asking this,
but what would you, if we made our first contact,
what would you want to inquire about?
What would be a priority to find out?
Well, I gotta agree with the astronaut
that answered you previously on this.
I'd wanna know how they survived
the development of their technologies
and didn't extinguish themselves,
because I think that's one of our biggest existential
threats is that we will do ourselves in,
as mentioned earlier, that given the, I think,
given the Russo-Ukrainian War
and the tensions with China, tensions with Iran,
there is a lot of potential that we won't extinguish,
that we will self-extinguish, many other threats like that.
So we've gotta learn how to survive,
to get out of this childhood of technology
of our civilization we're in today
and have a mature civilization that can survive, thrive,
and just explore the universe,
settle the cosmos, bring the cosmos to the world.
In terms of the technology, the qubits,
the quantum entanglement,
that may be a step in the direction
that we can communicate with,
and there may actually be higher levels
of technology available if we really understand
the nature of back in space.
And I think that we're very premature in that,
especially having the technical means
to harness any understanding of that, we're very mature.
But if we got there, then that would be amazing.
So if there's something out there,
we might find it there, I don't know.
All right, what would you want to know
if we make our first encounter?
I'd wanna plunder their technology.
How about you, Brandon?
Well, the first thing I wanna do
is determine if they are, in fact, a threat,
and I'd also wanna know if the Chinese
were in contact with them,
because if the Chinese were in contact with them,
that could be a big problem for us.
Maybe they like the Chinese more than us, so.
I asked the question because about a decade ago,
I was able to talk to astronaut Tom Jones,
who's been on four shuttle missions,
and he said at the time,
I basically asked the question,
what should we first ask?
And his answer surprised me,
because I would have thought your first questions
would be something like, where are you from?
How many of you are there?
Yeah, what's your technology?
How do you move around?
Those kinds of things.
And he thought that we should ask
basically what Greg was saying.
How have you survived as a species?
How have you not killed yourselves?
And what do you say exactly?
How'd you survive the development of nuclear weapons,
assuming they had nuclear weapons,
and ecological crises,
and survive wars and famines on your planet?
How did you make it to this stage
where you're capable of destroying yourselves,
but resisted the temptation?
To me, I was like, that's a very odd first question.
That seems like very next level.
Of course, the answer is in the idea
of going out into space and colonizing it.
That's how you survive all these crises,
because all the resources are there,
and the ability to be redundant.
I think maybe the answer,
we don't even need to wait to ask aliens.
We can just ask ourselves,
what's the most logical way to avoid a calamity,
spread out the society,
and develop the resources in orbit and beyond?
Okay, well, let's discuss that when we come back.
We're gonna take another break,
and then we'll return to our panel
with a discussion on future of space exploration.
Welcome back.
This is International Reporters Roundtable.
I'm your host, Cindy Drew Care.
Let's return to our panel on UFOs
and international space exploration.
So let's pick up where we left off
and talk about what we should be doing
out there in space right now.
There's a race currently to go to the south pole of the moon.
There's talk of going to Mars.
What do you think, I'll start with you, Greg.
What do you think should be our first priority?
I think our first priority should be
to get a base on the moon
that we can establish and defend
so that the Chinese don't beat us to that.
If the Chinese were to put up a device
known as a mass driver,
which is an electromagnetic engine,
and a coil gun that accelerates payloads,
they could launch telephone-sized payloads
of iron or something like that
that's melted from the winter surface straight to Earth
in a rapid fire rate,
and they would hit with the power of like seven V-2 rockets,
you know, seven tons of TNT at least.
On the other hand,
the economic opportunities in space development
from getting these materials are beyond belief.
There is, as Brandon has said,
the resources there are enormous.
There's energy, there's materials.
We should literally break out of the limited resources issues
that we're dealing with here on Earth today
and move to another level
where humanity across the board could prosper,
and maybe we'd get out of this zero-sum,
small-pi mentality and quit fighting amongst ourselves.
Much of all this is enough for everyone.
Maybe that is the key to surviving,
but we're not there yet.
We've got to get there.
The sooner we get there, the better.
And so I totally support the moon, asteroid, Mars.
I haven't even got concepts
for the colonizing the atmosphere of Venus,
which I think will be easier than Mars because of it.
I got that on video.
You can see it on black and gray.
Art, do you think space mining is the number one priority
or space defense?
How important is the mining aspect?
I know that's one of your areas of interest.
Well, it's, you look at China.
China is intending to mine the moon for rare earths,
for helium-3, for fusion and so forth.
This is going to be a huge multi-billion dollar industry
in coming years and decades.
Question is, will we be there or not?
But the most critical thing to do
is what I've been advising decision makers to do
for some time, and that is to get to the south pole
of the moon and establish a base
so that we don't get locked out by the Chinese.
And so if they are on the south pole of the moon,
where there's water ice, you've got water to drink,
you've got oxygen to breathe,
you've got hydrogen, oxygen for rocket fuel, et cetera.
So that is the place where humanity will be able to live.
The Chinese have said, literally,
that the moon and Mars and even orbital space
are like the South China Sea.
Brendan, how important is it to go to Mars?
There's a lot of talk and effort around that,
especially, you know, Elon.
Well, yeah, and you have to look at this
from a geopolitical or geostrategic point of view.
The earth and the moon form one system
with the orbits between the two.
If you dominate the orbits around the earth, that's great,
but if you can also dominate the moon,
you have the ultimate high ground
for controlling life on earth
from a strategic point of view.
From the moon, you then leapfrog to Mars.
Now, Mars is important.
There's a prestige angle.
I think that at this point,
China will beat us to the planet Mars
because they're more serious about it than we are.
But I think that when you look at it
from a geopolitical angle or geostrategic angle,
Mars is the beating heart of the asteroid belt.
The asteroid belt is where all those minable resources are
in perpetuity.
And so if you have a base camp
that's very close to the asteroid belt, such as on Mars,
you can then easily and more cheaply
get to the asteroid belt, mine it for its resources,
get those resources back to the markets on earth
a lot easier than having to go from earth
to the asteroid belt and back.
It takes years to do that.
We can create an entire infrastructure
linking the earth moon system to the Mars asteroid belt.
The problem is, as Art was talking about,
China has a head start on us.
And in fact, they're starting to partner,
it looks like, with the Russian space organization,
which is going to be doubly problematic
for the United States.
And that's not even talking about injecting
whatever exotic technology we've been seeing
in our skies, these UAPs.
God help us if those are, in fact,
Chinese and or Russian craft
that they can then mass produce some new propulsion system
that's beyond what we have.
This is a real nightmare scenario
unfolding before our eyes.
And the problem is many of my former colleagues
on Capitol Hill, they're not even aware of it.
And when you talk to them, their eyes sort of glaze over.
They used to mock me as the space guy.
I know that Art has dealt with this too,
where there's sort of this disbelief among lawmakers.
And we need them to wake up to the fact
that this is a real threat.
And hopefully the UAP investigations that are going on,
if anything, awakens Congress to the fact
that there's a lot going on above our heads
and we need to be much more clued in.
Art, why do you think there's such reluctance?
I mean, it does seem, you know,
actually very easy to imagine, you know,
it's just the next frontier of competition
between the great powers.
Why wouldn't the U.S. take that seriously?
Well, in the 1960s, we did.
In the 1960s, we had an absolute deadline.
You know, it was, you know, go in this decade.
And we made that and it benefited our technology.
It leapfrogged us ahead of any other country
in technology for decades.
The benefits are tremendous.
But so many in Congress, for example,
they see NASA more as a budget to be plundered
for their own pet projects.
There was one person on a committee that said,
can you give me one reason why we shouldn't spend
all this money for the poor?
Well, actually, space research benefits everybody,
particularly in things like medical and other fields.
So, but so many just don't see the big picture
and that's dangerous.
Okay, we're gonna take another break.
And then I wanna come back and talk about
not the public sector, but the private sector in space
because that's a, could be a real game changer.
So let's take a break.
Welcome back to International Reporters Roundtable.
I'm your host, Cindy Druker.
And we will now return to our panel discussion.
And we're going to talk about the private sector in space
with Brandon Weichart, Craig Allison, and Art Harmon.
So one of the big game changers that we see now
is the private sector's role in space.
And that's fairly unique to the US.
Most of the other countries,
it's still mostly the purview of government.
What does that change?
Because there's, on the one side,
we were talking before the break about,
perhaps the US government and Congress
not taking seriously enough what we need to do in space
to defend ourselves and get ahead of the Russians
and Chinese.
But then we have these private actors
who are obviously going after it a lot more aggressively
than NASA, than the government.
Greg, I'll just start with you.
What are your thoughts?
How does this change the game?
The private sector has a lot to offer
because each company has its own vision,
its own way of doing things.
And they're often led by visionaries
who, unlike the government,
everything's just a job, it's a process.
These visionaries want to accomplish things,
be it business or otherwise.
In the case of Elon Musk and even Jeff Bezos,
they have dreams and they see where space can go.
So, and if they're trying to find a way
to sustain it on an economic basis,
not on the basis of what comes from the taxpayer dollars,
although the cost of corn there is so big,
they're using NASA to stimulate that.
So there is taxpayer money involved in it,
at least initially,
but if we can get to the point of mining space,
then the returns will be enormous,
including for those poor people
who are on Earth and worldwide.
It creates everybody's vote
in terms of standard of living worldwide.
But the key thing is in nature,
you don't have a plant creating one seed
to base its entire future on,
like you might get with a government agency.
So this moment's nature,
and you have many seeds created
through all these different enterprises
that gives us a shot at a future,
hopefully a better future,
because we have many experiments going at once.
I do think we may be a little too limited
in our approach to management innovation.
Having selected only one contractor for the lander,
now we're bringing in a second.
Maybe we should have had a third,
because there is a certain risk involved.
And I'm really skeptical that the system
that currently selected as the number one first try
is gonna be able to be successful.
I've got some various issues with that.
But the fact that we are trying different things,
and we need to be more robust,
we need to take this serious,
because there is a serious threat that the lawmakers,
as other speakers here have pointed out,
are not taking seriously
because they don't get the big picture.
So we need to communicate this big picture
of the threat and opportunity.
There is threat if the Chinese beats us there,
if the Russians beats us there.
And by the way, they got a 100 megawatt
nuclear power plant Chinese does for space development.
But we've got to look at these risks.
There's also risks of asteroid impacts
that space addresses.
So if you're not getting hit by an asteroid
and have the ability to stop it,
but also mine that asteroid,
gives you an economic return that's unbelievable.
What about the issue of space junk?
It seems like as we send more things out into space,
and there's more actors in space,
we found a new frontier to pollute.
How big of an issue is that, Brandon?
Well, it's called the Kessler syndrome,
and there's a great 2014 movie
starring Sandra Bullock and George Clooney,
which the premise is all about Putin tests
of anti-satellite weapon in orbit,
and it creates a cascade of chain reaction
of one piece of debris hitting the other,
bouncing into the next,
creating this sort of destructive wall of debris.
That's the Kessler syndrome on display.
It's a big problem,
especially since humans have been operating
and polluting, as you say,
the Earth orbits for the last 60, 70 years.
But there are methods to get rid of that,
that, for instance, in 2014,
the Obama administration put the kibosh
on a NASA plan to put a laser
on the bottom of the International Space Station
that would've physically moved,
the laser would've been able to move the space debris
out of the way of incoming ships.
They stopped doing that plan
because of the fear that it was going to be considered
by Russia and China as a weaponization of space.
And as I said at the time,
and I wrote in my book, Winning Space,
the Chinese and the Russians,
through dual-use technologies like co-orbital satellites,
they're already weaponizing space.
We're behind the ball on that one.
And then there's other technologies
like those co-orbital satellites,
which could physically, with grappling claws,
identify a cloud of debris
and physically remove the debris from orbit.
But we're not doing any of that.
There's a lot of plans,
but there's very little execution.
This is where the private sector
and the public sector should work together.
And this is what Mariana Mazzucato calls
the moment when John Maynard Keynes
shakes hands with Adam Smith,
because there's a lot of public sector rules
that could be used to help private sector companies
looking to get into the space trash business
to help them get into that
so that they can get this stuff out of our way
and we can have a brighter future of safe space operations.
Do you see that that's what's on the horizon
or what is a big need right now
for the private sector to come in?
It is a need, and certainly that's the Chinese model.
They figured it out very early on.
You have to use the money of your state
to fund and help the private sector work on these projects.
Now, our private sector is much more innovative,
and they wouldn't need, I don't think, as much money
or they wouldn't need the kind of direction
from the public sector that goes on in China.
Basically, what we should be doing,
and this is something John McCain was trying to do
when he was still alive,
is basically set aside a bunch of taxpayer dollars
and tell companies,
hey, look, we need help with this problem.
You guys figure out how to do it,
and if you have the best working product,
you get the prize, you get the money.
And that's probably how we should go about it.
But the way we're doing it now
is we're not doing anything at all,
and China's eating our lunch,
and now they're partnering with Russia,
which is now a nightmare scenario for us.
Art, do you have thoughts on that too?
I know you've spent a lot of time
in the halls of Congress.
Well, I would echo what Brandon says,
but I'd also add that it is possible
that both Russia and China have decided
that in a time of war,
that they may get a benefit
from creating a Kessler effect intentionally,
even though it would destroy
their satellite communications
if that allowed for destroying the United States
as a viable world power.
That they might do that intentionally.
And also, they don't rely on satellites
as much as we do, at least not yet.
And so that's also another reason
why China and or Russia
would be more willing to destroy
our satellite constellations,
because for us, it lights out.
For them, they're still kind of low-tech in that way,
and they've conditioned themselves
to fight a war without satellite and GPS assist.
Greg, I want to add.
I would add one thing,
and that is that SpaceX is, in a way,
a bit of a solution,
because they can launch constellations
faster than they can be taken down.
Sorry, there's a bit of delay here.
So, Greg, you want to jump in?
Yeah, I was just saying,
that's our Achilles heel,
because our entire military force structure
that requires the data fusion,
massive data fusion,
all these interoperability systems we have
where all our forces can interoperate
is our greatest strength,
that and our GPS guidance for our weapons systems.
If you take all that out,
then our military is almost dead in the water,
and they all know that,
but it's very difficult to do.
They may think that the benefit ratio
lies in taking us out that way.
If they do, then they may do it,
and then we're out of space.
Art, what do you think about the current state of,
right now, there seems to be a difficulty
in speaking about difficult topics like UFOs
or lots of stuff we saw during COVID.
Do you think that our current climate
for scientific inquiry, endeavor, exploration
is healthy and is going to lead us
to the answers we need?
No, no.
It's Galileo 2023.
There's scientific authoritarianism
that punishes anyone that speaks out of turn
and says something unpopular.
Yes, we saw that with COVID.
Yes, we see that with UFOs and lots of other things.
As long as people are prevented from publishing
if they say the wrong thing,
then we have no real science,
that is it's supposed to be.
Brandon, do you have thoughts on that?
I completely agree, and I'm not a scientist,
but I went through this with my last book, Biohacked.
It was ready to roll in March of 2020,
and I couldn't get a publisher to publish it
because it was talking about the science
behind COVID and gain-of-function tests.
Finally, I found a publisher who did it,
but it's very difficult.
Art is right, especially if you're a scientist.
I'm married to one.
It's publish or perish,
and if you can't publish your findings and your research,
good luck getting grants
and good luck being successful as a scientist,
and your research dies with you,
and that's how they control the research.
This is why I think it is so important
that those UAP hearings not just focus on little green men,
but we focus on the technology
that David Grush and others are describing
that they claim we are getting our hands on.
It is metamaterials of the kind
that I think that we have more than enough capability
to develop, but for whatever reason,
our government and our official science community
doesn't either wanna talk about it
or put the resources behind scaling it up,
and I think that's a detriment
not just to our national security,
but it's a detriment to our well-being as human beings
because the technology we're talking about,
as Art mentioned at the beginning,
could very well change life for the better for everyone,
and so I think that the censorship is the first step
toward going back into a medievalism or dark ages,
and we know, for instance, by the way,
there's a report floating around
that one of the major science,
and I'm forgetting which one it was now,
but one of the major medical and scientific publishers
in America that publishes things like Science Direct,
and I think Nature as well,
is actually been purchased in 2017
by a Chinese shell company,
which would indicate why it was so hard
to get any information, for example,
about COVID to the public through those respectable journals
because they were being heavily influenced
by the Chinese Communist Party,
which did not want the true origins of COVID coming out.
All right, well, I'm glad you brought up-
We have a virtual-
Go ahead, Greg.
Yeah, we have a virtual ministry of truth
today, and that's a big threat.
It's like, you know, that's the tool of communism
in South Carolinian society,
and stigmatization does the same thing,
and it limits the free exchange of ideas
because people may have something,
they're just afraid to show it or talk it
because it will adversely affect their career,
and as a professional engineer
and working in the fields of science
and also in public policy,
this affects our freedom of speech,
our First Amendment is sacred to political discourse,
and that's all been heavily controlled in society today
between the government, the agencies, and social media,
and they have a certain bias in that link,
which affects a lot of people,
and it's like certain things just can't be said
without a whole lot of backlash,
so you're at risk when you go out there
and try to have public discourse,
look, in a free and open society,
everything should be able to be talked about,
should be able to be put on the table,
and it should float or rise or sink on its own merit
because in a good open discourse,
the truth should rise to the top,
and people should be able to see it and judge it,
but if you can't even bring it to the table,
if you can't even start the discussion,
then you have defeated the process, get go,
and our politics in our society
and our technical progress are all limited
by this new ministry of truth, if you will,
which I say exists in a virtual form today.
We've got to settle that
and get back to wide open discussion
so that people can actually discern
what's going on for themselves
without the ministry of truth
determining what you can know today.
So this discussion underscores even more
how remarkable the recent hearing was
because we had three high-level,
highly-credible witnesses who came forward
and said, you know, put their careers on the line
as they have, you know, leading up to that point
to come out and say what they think
and what they know about UFOs, what they've seen.
So we're just about out of time here,
but I have to ask one last very important question
to each of you.
What is your favorite space movie?
Brendan, you touched on gravity earlier.
Is that your favorite one or what's your favorite?
No, no, my favorite space, like hard science fiction,
probably movie would probably be the 2001 film
was a great film, but in terms of like science fiction,
I gotta say, like, I still love the aliens,
the sequel to the original alien.
That was pretty cool.
But, you know, it's a hard question to ask me on the spot
because there's so many out there that I just love, so.
All right, Art, you've had a couple of minutes
to think about it, yours?
Well, 2001 actually was sort of my moment
seeing that as a kid, that it's like, you know,
here's this grandeur of space and routine flights
and so forth, and of course,
that's kind of what I hope to have grown up in.
Unfortunately, we kind of abandoned the forward progress
from the 1960s and never got to routine flights by 2001
or now, you know, the commercial type.
But other than that, you know, in the science fiction realm,
oh, I love Star Wars and things like that, too.
You're disappointed you're not in space, I get it.
All right, Greg, your favorite.
So, Frederick Orduway III, the technical science director
for the movie 2001 Space Odyssey was a friend of mine.
And so, and I happened to favor that movie from the get-go
because they took a real serious engineering approach
to it until they got to the star child, you know,
that part's got to get away with.
But at least in early on, Hubert wanted this to look real,
like it could happen, like it was real.
They even destroyed a lot of the stuff
that was set in a lot of props
because he didn't want people to understand, you know,
just how they developed this stuff.
But it was visionary and the whole idea, you know,
they were doing this in the early 60s, you know.
So this is the future that could have been.
If we'd had that future, if we'd gotten to that point
by this time, then we wouldn't be worried
about our survival as a species.
We would have untold wealth and material resources.
The fact that we've limited ourselves
and denied ourselves this future,
it could have been, that is telling.
And we're still doing that.
We've got to wake up and shake this off
and look at what's possible.
We're freezing to death in a coal mine century,
which is early 60s.
And it's right in the P.C. Falcon space.
We need to go out and get it.
So that's why I like 2001.
It also has some very boring NASA meetings in it.
And let me tell you, that's typical in NASA.
So that was also realistic.
So I do like 2001, the space odyssey.
The ending, oh, that's a little weird,
but still the movie itself, I think,
was a testament for his time way ahead of time.
I guess I know what our audience is going to go out
and watch right after this episode.
We are out of time.
I want to thank you all so much for joining us today.
Brandon Weikart, Art Arman, and Greg Allison.
Thank you.
Finally, to all of you brave journalists out there
honoring our journalistic golden rule,
seek the truth and report it.
Thank you.
I'm Cindy Drouker.
Thank you for joining us
on International Reporters Roundtable.
Until next time.