LIVE: House Oversight and Government Reform Hearing: Addressing the Crisis of Unaccompanied Alien Children–Part I

Live News Network
1.4K followers
5 Video Views·Jul 23, 2025
The House Oversight and Government Reform Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement holds a hearing titled "Catch and Release, Lose and Forget: Addressing the Crisis of Unaccompanied Alien Children—Part I" at 2 p.m. ET on July 23.
Witnesses include Joseph Cuffari, inspector general of the Department of Homeland Security.
Today, the subcommittee convenes to hear the Inspector General of the Department of Homeland
Security regarding his office's alarming report detailing the Department of Health and Human
Services' failures to properly track, process, and safeguard nearly 448,000 unaccompanied alien
children who entered the United States illegally over the last four years. The Biden administration's
open border policies led to severe ramifications in which unaccompanied alien children
were destined to be trafficked and exploited. President Trump has taken decisive action
to close our southern border, virtually eliminating the flood of illegal immigrants entering our
country. The executive has taken action and now it's up to us, the sitting members of Congress,
to conduct essential oversight and codify security of our border that cannot be exploited
by future administrations. Yet the ramifications of the past four years continue to unfold
with lasting consequences and impact on hundreds of thousands of young lives.
The failures of the previous administration led to unaccompanied children who have been lost in
the system, the system that was established to protect them and to protect the citizens of our
country. I've been meeting with Inspector General Khafari for years and I've always
been incensed at the failures and the prior administration's
attitude towards ignoring the responsibility to track and properly process tender age illegal
unaccompanied minors. We're talking about children of God that have been waived into our country
for 14 years and younger and improperly processed with the into virtually unvetted sponsors
destined to be trafficked into some horror. The findings of the report we're going to discuss
today are a double-edged sword. While some vulnerable children have likely been trafficked,
exploited and subjected to forced labor, the report also found that older teens
had been in some cases convicted of crimes in their country of origin and were gang members.
While the hard-working men and women of ICE may want to do their best,
the sheer volume of cases enabled the prior administration's open border policies
to simply overwhelm the system. The Inspector General's report states that as of September 2024,
ICE has just over 1,000 staff to monitor over seven and a half million non-detained cases.
It's literally impossible for ICE with the 1,000 member staff to personally interact
with these millions of tender age illegal unaccompanied minors. The Inspector General
shared with my staff that almost 300,000 kids have unserved notices to appear for their court date.
Of that number, 58,000 are age 12 and under. I say again for Americans listening,
300,000 kids have failed to appear for court. 58,000 are 12 and under.
We have no idea in many cases where those kids are. We're going to talk about that today with
IG Khafre. I'm glad that ICE under the Trump administration has accepted
all of the IG's recommendations contained in their report. Inspector General Khafre is an
honorable man, and I know him personally to be incredibly focused on identifying, locating,
and rescuing these children. I look forward to his testimony as we continue to examine this issue
to ensure these children are properly identified, cared for, and protected.
I recognize my colleague, Ms. Lee, the Ranking Member, for five minutes or the time she may
consume for our opening statement. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Over the last six months, President Trump,
Kristi Noem, and Stephen Miller have unleashed a brutal, reckless, and lawless regime that targets
innocent members of our communities, parents dropping off their kids at the school or attending
church, legal immigrants who have been welcome in this country for decades, international students,
and even children who are U.S. citizens. They are behaving without humanity, justice,
or decency. Children are increasingly the target of President Trump's anti-immigrant crusades.
DHS has failed to be transparent and publish any data since January, but looking at the court cases
has shown that children have been increasingly and disproportionately marked for deportation
by Donald Trump. Over 53,000 children have been ordered for deportation since the start
of this administration. These are mostly elementary school kids or younger. How often
the court cases end in deportations has also climbed under Trump, especially for kids. Over 75%
of children 11 or younger are now being ordered for deportation as a result of their immigration
court proceedings. Are these little kids the dangerous criminals Trump vowed to go after?
President Trump is also kidnapping and illegally removing U.S. citizens, including multiple
children with cancer. We're talking about unprecedented actions without due process
against U.S. citizens. The Trump administration removed one 10-year-old girl, a U.S. citizen,
who was recovering from brain cancer with her parents, even though she needed medical care.
Another four-year-old boy was illegally removed, also a U.S. citizen with a rare form of cancer.
The judge in that case said the Trump administration had, quote,
just deported a U.S. citizen with no meaningful process. Over 500 immigrant children have been
removed from their families and homes and thrown into government custody. Let's call this what it
is. Just like his first time as president, Donald Trump and Stephen Miller are separating
kids from their parents. It's unconscionable. And as the Trump administration detains more human
beings, detention facilities are becoming even more overcrowded and dangerous. The conditions
that children and innocent people are being held in have been called unsanitary and inhumane.
The government has some bare minimum standards in place for children in government custody,
but Trump has attempted to roll those protections back or simply violated them,
all while denying members of Congress their lawful ability to conduct oversight at these
facilities. Republicans are complicit in this. And increasingly, children are being held in
ICE facilities like Alligator, Alcatraz, or newly reopened family detention centers like the one in
Dilley, Texas. This administration is using every resource at its disposal to target
innocent people for kidnapping and disappearance. And we call it that because a deportation implies
that you have gone through some process, implies that you are following some standard that is set
in U.S. law, a particularly due process. We know that this administration is even using
data collected to identify sponsors for unaccompanied children to target those same
sponsors, often the parents or other family members for deportation, putting the very people
who are able to help these kids who are in danger. These are unspeakable injustices that demand
oversight. And we have a witness here today who bears the responsibility of conducting such
oversight. Mr. Kothari is the inspector general who is supposed to be rooting out misconduct at
the Department of Homeland Security. Instead, he's working with Republicans to twist the facts so
people ignore the cages and the kids with cancer and other despicable actions. He himself is guilty
of committing serious misconduct against the American people. This included spending taxpayer
money retaliating against whistleblowers who called him out for delaying a report about Donald Trump
actually losing children. This was when Trump's first administration separated immigrant kids
from their parents and then failed to keep track of them. As many as 1,360 of those kids were never
reunited with their parents. Inspector General Kothari has made clear that he is interested
in protecting Donald Trump, not lost children, and that he has no problem lying to Congress to further
his goals. On this issue, he has absolutely zero credibility. So when the Trump administration
creates a culture of terror in which children are afraid to go to school or children are afraid to
speak to authorities for fear that they or someone they love will be snatched and deported, children
suffer. These policies leave children at greater risk of trafficking and exploitation. I expect
my Republican colleagues to care about this because their constituents certainly care about
child sex trafficking, whether it's through the immigration system like this hearing alleges
or by a U.S. citizen facilitating other powerful U.S. citizens. It's time for them to prove it.
Right now, Speaker Johnson is helping Donald Trump block the release of all the files relating to
child sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein. If you want to take a stand against child trafficking,
let's do it together. When powerful people exploit children, they must be held accountable for their
actions. And if they try to mislead the public and hide evidence, we can't let them get away with it.
So we can't allow individuals, especially those at the highest level of our government,
to protect child sex traffickers. So today, that's why I will be offering a motion to subpoena the
Department of Justice to release the Epstein files. Numerous members of this committee and
this subcommittee have called for answers and transparency. So let's do something about it.
Rep. Biggs has said we want to get to the bottom of it. Rep. Mesa stated, I believe we need answers
on Epstein. If 1,000 kids were trafficked, how is there only one accomplice? Rep. Perry has written
to Pam Bondi on Epstein saying the American people deserve answers and justice, particularly
in matters involving grave allegations of criminality and misconduct by influential
figures. Rep. Boebert said we deserve the truth about the Epstein files. Yesterday, our government
operations subcommittee approved a motion directing Chairman Comer to subpoena Jelaine
Maxwell to appear for a deposition before this committee. But Ms. Maxwell is currently serving
a 20-year federal prison sentence for her role in sex trafficking children with Jeffrey Epstein.
She could have a motivation to protect powerful people to get a lighter sentence. We need the
actual Epstein files to get the full truth. So I hope my Republican colleagues will join me in
supporting a motion to subpoena the Department of Justice to release the Epstein files. With that,
pursuant to Clause 2K6 of House Rule 11, I move that the subcommittee issue a subpoena to the
Department of Justice for the full, complete, unredacted Epstein files to be delivered concurrently
to the majority and minority of the subcommittee on federal law enforcement of the Committee of
Oversight and Government Reform. The Ranking Member has introduced a motion. The committee
will hold this motion in abeyance until the end of today's hearing. The committee will now proceed
with today's hearing. I thank the Honorable Joe Kifari for joining us today.
Let me introduce him. Before I introduce Mr. Kifari, for the record, without objection,
Representative Crane of Arizona is waived onto the subcommittee for the purpose of
questioning the witnesses at today's subcommittee hearing, without objection.
Introducing our witness today, Joseph V. Kifari, was confirmed by the United States
Senate as the Department of Homeland Security Inspector General on July 25, 2019. Dr. Kifari
previously served as a Policy Advisor for Military and Veterans Affairs for Governor Doug Ducey of
Arizona and previously for Governor Jan Brewer. He served more than 40 years in the United States
Air Force on active duty in the Reserves and in the Arizona National Guard. He began his military
service after graduating from high school and enlisting in the United States Air Force in 1977.
He served in a variety of leadership positions with the Air Force Office of Special Investigations
as well as with the Department of Defense Office of Inspector General. He was a commander
in the Air Force Office of Inspection Commanders with MacDill Air Force Base in Florida,
England Air Force Base, Louisiana, Naples, Italy, and with North Atlantic Treaty Organization.
In 1989, he received the AFOSI Outstanding Officer of the Year Award.
He also served for more than 20 years in the Department of Justice
in a multitude of roles dating back to 1993. In 2013, he retired from his position
as Assistant Special Agent in Charge for the Office of the Inspector General in Tucson, Arizona.
In other capacities, he has augmented the United States Senate and the House Intelligence
Committee and the DOJ Office of Overseas Prosecutorial Development. Dr. Kapari earned
a Ph.D. in Management in 2002, an M.A. in Management in 1995, and a Bachelor of Science
in Business Administration and Management Information Systems in 1984. And today he sits
before us. I welcome Inspector General Kapari to testify before us today.
Pursuant to Committee Rule 9G, the witness will please stand and raise his right hand.
Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give is the truth,
the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God? Let the record show that the
witness answered in the affirmative. Thank you. You may take your seat, Inspector General Kapari.
I recognize the Inspector General for five minutes to summarize his opening statement.
Thank you, Chairman Higgins, Ranking Member Lee, and Ranking Member Garcia. Members of the
Committee, thank you for inviting me here today to discuss my office's recent audit report entitled
ICE Cannot Effectively Monitor the Locations and Status of All Unaccompanied Alien Children
After Federal Custody. DHS plays a critical role in administering and enforcing our national
immigration laws. Among the most vulnerable populations DHS encounters are unaccompanied
alien children referred to as UACs. A UAC is a person as to when they entered the country and
were encountered by DHS. They have no lawful immigration status in the United States. They
have not attained 18 years of age and has no parent or legal guardian in the country available
to provide care and physical custody. Each year thousands of UACs have entered the United States
and are placed into federal custody. Federal government has a responsibility not just for
enforcing immigration laws but for ensuring the safety and welfare of these at-risk children.
While ICE's immigration enforcement priorities typically weigh the risk an alien poses to the
public but with UACs the agency must also ensure a vulnerable child does not become the victim
of trafficking or otherwise exploitation. Our audit revealed significant gaps in how ICE monitors
and manages the cases of UACs once they're released from federal custody. The lack of
reliable location data persistent delays in issuing notices to a peer and limited interagency
cooperation has led to potentially tens of thousands of children effectively disappearing
from DHS's oversight. This is not simply an administrative or paperwork shortcoming. It's
a systemic breakdown that carries real risk to the children themselves, to the integrity of the
immigration system, and to the public trust in our immigration system and law enforcement
institutions. In 2023 my office initiated this audit after two key events. The first was a change
in a 2021 memorandum of agreement between DHS and the Department of Health and Human Services.
Specifically the parties removed the requirement for HHS Office of Refugee Resettlement to provide
ICE with biographic and biometric information and all potential sponsors and adult members
of that household which were then used for vetting. The second was significant media reporting
involving UACs which were potentially in dangerous conditions following their placement into a
sponsor's care by HHS. Early into the audit it became clear that the uncertainty surrounding
the whereabouts of such a large number of UACs warranted a management alert to flag this matter
for the Department of Homeland Security as well as Congress and we issued that in August 2024.
In our final report which was published in March of this year my team found that between fiscal
years 2019 and 23 ICE did not effectively monitor the location and status of all UACs
once released or transferred to HHS custody. In the meantime in that time ICE transferred more
than 448,000 UACs to HHS most of whom were released as sponsors. Of that population
ICE did not issue more than 233,000 notices to appear to the UACs to generate an assignment in
their immigration court. Our auditors discovered that more than 31,000 releases addresses of
sponsors were blank, undeliverable or missing apartment numbers. We also learned more than
43,000 UACs who were served with notices to appear failed to actually appear for their
scheduled court date. As I stated at the beginning of my testimony ICE's posture for monitoring UACs
was insufficient. The shortcomings leave children vulnerable, exploitation, trafficking, forced labor
or involvement in criminal activities. Without sustained data sharing coordination at the federal
level and staffing and overall policy guidance to DHS they will not be able to guarantee that
UACs are safeguarded from harm while in the United States. We made six recommendations to improve ICE's
monitoring all of which they accepted. In closing thank you for the opportunity to testify. I look
forward to answering your questions. Thank you Dr. Khafari for being here. I recognize myself for five minutes
for questioning. Inspector General Khafari I'd like to clarify for the for the record that
that you and I have been working together since uh 2019 pretty closely have we not
we have had many many telephone conversations and and back during the the horrible COVID era we had
we had virtual meetings and we've had many personal meetings have we not good sir
right so let me clarify for the American people watching that in all of my interactions
with the federal government there's been I've had hundreds and hundreds of interactions
with uh with men and women that were embedded and serving within the executive branch.
The very small handful of of those individuals that I that I came to understand and know
I could have absolute confidence in and at the top of that list is Joe Khafari.
He was always accessible and honest and candid yet careful to protect the integrity of his
office because I through the years I asked him some very challenging questions and Joe Khafari
was squared away. He's here today no doubt he's gonna face some kind of fire but I'm telling
America and Americans can tell when a man's telling them the truth Joe Khafari is squared away
and he's an honest and dedicated man. So when I ask you
Inspector General Khafari are you personally invested in helping the the federal government
identify locate and rescue these scores of thousands hundreds of thousands of missing
tender age children in our country? I am both as an adult father as well as a grandfather.
And will you share will you share with the committee what that progress looks like
regarding say the 200,000 uh young teenagers that have been identified and how the 50,000
of those were chosen to go after? Would you will you take us uh explain that process to it?
Uh chairman from what we uh received in a briefing from ICE they have formed a team
of ICE agents, HSI, Homeland Security investigators. Pardon me but that team was is under the
under the Trump administration? Yes sir. Okay continue please. It was formed in February of
Thank you. 25 by Secretary Noem. She designated this unit to go out and identify locate and
provide health and welfare checks on unaccompanied alien children who had been transferred from
DHS custody to HHS. So a necessary component of that was for ICE and HHS to work together
which we understand they are. They are also working with other federal law enforcement
agencies like the FBI and the U.S. Marshals Service to go out and they are selecting a
group of 200,000 round numbers of unaccompanied alien children. They have gone to around 50,000
and how was that subset with 50,000 doors knocked on identified knocked on how was that
that 50,000 subset targeted out of the 200,000 initial selection? Those were identified by HHS
as households where a sponsor had two or more unaccompanied alien children designated to that
address. So so listen to that America. They identified easily 200,000 kids that were at risk
and disappeared into the system. Of those under the Trump administration they've identified 50,000.
Why? Because if 50,000 and that had multiple sponsors had multiple kids coming to the same
address. So out of those 50,000 what happened Joe? They were able to from what we understand
they were able to identify and physically locate 12,000 unaccompanied alien children.
And how many sponsors were arrested? The number that we were given is about 400. About 400.
You see where this is going America? Mr. Capari thank you for your testimony. Unfortunately my
time has expired and I'm happy to recognize the ranking member Ms. Lee for five minutes
for questioning. Thank you Mr. Chair. An appreciation of the hearing that we're having
today about such an important topic as child sexual trafficking and sexual abuse. I look
forward to our colleagues joining us of course in releasing the anywhere their mouth especially
unaccompanied ones entering this country alone and scared deserve our utmost attention and oversight.
In normal times inspectors general act as the first line of defense ensuring that agencies
follow the law and act in the public interest. They're fiercely independent or they should be
fiercely independent. They serve no democratic or republican administration and presidents are
