S „kormidelníkem“ projektu Archa 21 Janem Piňosem jsme si povídali o jeho vlastní zkušenosti s komunistickým režimem (1:30) a jeho paralelami v době covidové (6:10). Představil projekt Archa 21, jehož cílem je nabídnout pozitivní hodnoty občanské společnosti (9:32), v rámci kterého spolu s odborníky z různých oborů chystají diskuzní retrospektivu oné doby covidové (24:58). Otevřeli jsme také téma selhání vědy a autocenzury médií (31:10) i nebezpečí současného způsobu života na Západě (39:50).
I feel that what I experienced in the first half of my life, before November 1989,
which was of course much stronger at the time than it is today,
so unfortunately I feel that we are experiencing a number of these risks again today,
in fact, in the form of some kind of passive normalization.
We talked to Janko Pinos about his own experiences with the previous regime
and its current parallels, especially in the COVID era.
It was somehow intuitive for me from the first days, it was clear to me that it was completely overtaken,
that the reaction of the states was completely overtaken
and somehow a red check was flashing, what is going on behind it.
He recently joined the ARCHA21 project, which aims to empower and strengthen the civic community from below.
And so our project, the civic crisis, is actually aimed at empowering people.
This is a key concept.
We want to empower people so that when another crisis comes,
or even for the current time, which is already difficult as it is,
so that people are more aware, more resilient,
not to be manipulated by all kinds of disinformation, including state disinformation,
but simply to be more self-sufficient and stronger in themselves.
I am very glad that in today's interview I can welcome Jana Pinos,
ecologist and civic activist. Good afternoon.
Good afternoon, thank you for the invitation.
Mr. Pinos, we first met at the conference of the Great COVID Silence,
which took place in Beskydy, and was organized by the ARCHA21 initiative.
And you were at the origin of this initiative.
And since you are the civic activist in the invitations,
when I was studying your materials, I realized that this is not a coincidence,
but that it basically accompanies you for a large part of your life.
And I would say, and maybe I'm wrong, you have to tell me,
that you are sensitive to some social pressures,
or when something in society develops unhealthily,
which can probably change what was happening with you,
respectively, not just at home, but what was happening in the previous regime,
still in Czechoslovakia, which you experienced.
So could you tell me what your personal experience is like?
Yes, it is true that I am very sensitive to injustice,
I am sensitive to pressure, control, manipulation, fear,
evoking fear, precisely the mediumship of manipulation,
and then it leads to the control of people.
And I perceive that what I experienced in the first half of my life,
before November 1989, which was, of course, much stronger at the time than it is today,
so unfortunately I perceive that many of these charisms
we experience today again, in fact, in the form of some kind of passive normalization.
And this passive normalization is dangerous,
precisely because it is passive and hidden,
and that it does not realize many people, especially young people.
Thanks to the fact that my parents were anti-regime before November 1989,
they severely tortured my mother,
they threw her out of high school because she led a scout unit,
my father as a music composer,
and later, after the revolution, a professor at the Janáček Academy of Musical Arts,
so he went into the revolution as a professional assistant,
and he was not allowed to travel from 1968 to 1989,
and yet he was an excellent music composer and teacher.
So I grew up in such a family,
and I got it out, both thanks to my genes and my parents,
so I am such a lifelong rebel against injustice,
and I would say that some kind of leitmotif of my life is the defense of justice,
but at the same time of life as such.
I know it sounds pathetic,
but at the beginning of my seventies,
I picked up a book by Erich Fromm called The Art of Loving from my parents' library.
As a teenager, I probably thought that I would learn something completely different there than what the book was about,
and there Erich Fromm uses two basic terms,
biophilic and necrophilic,
and biophilic is everything that promotes life,
and necrophilic is what actually destroys life.
Well, I somehow, it actually pressed into me,
pressed the reading here,
and thanks to my life, that I actually grew up in nature,
my mother brought me up in nature,
and I fell in love with nature,
and sports,
so it somehow connected in me,
that being on the side of life is the right way,
somehow intuitively,
and thanks to that I studied natural sciences,
but I never wanted to become a scientist,
it was clear to me that I studied before November,
that I have no career with my approach to the current regime,
and I didn't want anything,
and even after November 1989,
when I had quite a bit of it,
as an activist in 1989,
so I had a bit of it on the political path,
but it wasn't my path at all,
I stayed as an ecologist,
further in such a soft descent.
And when did the signals start flashing,
when did you start catching it,
during the COVID period?
Well, right from the start,
because I think I have quite a good intuition,
and I didn't need any expert information
to somehow look at it,
I actually somehow intuitively,
from the first days,
it was clear to me that it was completely overtaken,
that the reaction of the states was completely overtaken,
and somehow a red checker flashed to me,
a red checker flashed to me,
and I didn't even belong to the people
who were sewing masks at the beginning,
I was actually more afraid of what would come,
and I felt that it was coming from the very beginning,
in the end, already in mid-March 2000,
the first repressions began,
and the restriction of civil liberties.
But at that time I still had ecological work,
until the end of the year,
until November 2021.
It was only in the spring of 2021
that I wrote such a long essay,
which was even published by me at the time
in official media,
on the website Česká pozice,
which is part of the People's News,
I published a long text,
about 30 pages long,
based on what was known at the time,
a year after the outbreak of the COVID infection,
so I wrote what I thought about it,
I drew from various sources,
among other things from Karla Janečka,
who also spoke at the time,
and he had beautiful blogs on Aktuálně,
but we didn't know each other yet.
And then, when the wave of discrimination
and pressure on vaccination began,
it was really too much for me.
So I ended my ecological work
and joined doctors, pedagogues, psychologists
and other people,
and we founded the Initiative 21,
because it was at the end of 2021,
we officially founded it on December 21,
so we called it Initiative 21.
And then later, as it turned out,
it had some consequences for what I do now.
So I kind of turned away
from my persistent ecological work,
which I had been doing for 30 years,
and I jumped to various humanitarian,
community and many other projects,
even abroad, but a little bit,
but actually ecological work
was the leitmotiv of my life
after 30 years.
But because I started in some district
in 1987,
I returned to what I was doing
at the very beginning
that I actually defend more,
let's say, freedom,
and at all, let's say,
civic freedom,
and the civic society.
So at the beginning of my ecological work,
I put aside my dearest...
And the 1.20 stayed with you a little bit,
because from Initiative 21
you moved to ARCHE 21.
We will certainly talk about it
more in a moment,
but before we get to that,
I would like to ask,
I know that you let yourself
do a survey,
the results of which
are published on the web
of ARCHE 21.
Could you say something more
about what led you to it,
what is your opinion,
and mainly, what are the results
of that survey?
Well, that survey is actually
part of the project
I am working on now,
ARCHE 21,
a project initiated and funded
by Karel Janecek,
and which is actually related
to my personal case,
to my work at Initiative 21.
And we actually asked
the agency Median
in London during the winter,
and we published the results,
or Median published the results
of November 17th in London,
symbolically.
It was our gift
for November 17th,
and it was basically a hard gift,
because that survey showed
what we all feel,
perceive,
what the state of society is like in Trieste,
because according to that survey,
90% of people
with their basic
sense of life
are distrustful,
distrustful of each other,
distrustful of politicians,
distrustful of the media.
Many people,
about two thirds of people,
expressed the opinion
that the COVID period
accelerated the division of society.
About 50% of people
admitted
that they are afraid
to speak frankly
or openly about
what they feel at home,
at work, because they are afraid
of further worsening
of mutual relations,
or they are afraid
that they would lose their job.
But at the same time,
that survey also brought hopeful results,
surprisingly hopeful,
that most people already feel
this crisis
and the most aware
and the most active
that they have had enough
and that they would like to do something.
And even
about 15% of people
expressed the desire
to actively share
on activities that would
change this
bad social situation.
And a much larger percentage of people,
I don't remember,
it was about 50%,
40% to 50%,
expressed that
projects that would
improve this situation,
that they would at least care about it,
that they would care about it in some way
and not that they would
actively get involved in anything.
One surprising result,
probably the most and most important
for our specific work, brought the breakthrough
that two thirds of people
would like to do
some survey
during the COVID period,
during those three years,
with the goal to learn
something from it.
And that was a surprise for us,
because this is actually the goal
of my current work
and my colleagues,
the team of Archi21.
And because we feel from all sides
that COVID is a time
that people would like to forget,
forget it for a number of reasons
that are understandable,
but are bad.
People don't want to recall
unpleasant memories,
they don't want to admit
that maybe they were too scared
and so on.
This confirmation
in that media breakthrough
was a wake-up call for us,
it was a wake-up call for us,
although on the other hand
I don't want to overestimate it,
because no number
that speaks
about specific
positive activities
is always overestimated.
People, of course,
look a little better than they are
and rather admit
the worse things,
that society is terribly divided,
so they admit it.
But if it is really possible
to argue that two thirds of people
would like to do a survey
during the COVID period for learning,
for the next crisis,
I have a little doubt
that it would really be so,
but we'll see.
And half a year later,
after the survey,
I was at your event,
where you basically
presented ARCH21
and how you talked
about the negative emotions
that these people brought,
which also appeared
in the survey.
So you had several
interactive things,
and I have to say
that I really liked it.
One of them was
the first breaking
the wall of negative emotions.
We'll show it later
in the video.
And there you
actually had a wall
of art,
and people could
break all those negative emotions.
And then when they broke them,
there were values
behind the wall,
on which ARCH21 was exhibited.
And I see that you have
material for that here.
I have a puller with me.
So,
from breaking the bad,
you offer the good,
which should somehow
darken the society.
And people had the opportunity
with the individual values
that you will definitely
introduce in a moment,
they also had the opportunity
to throw such balls into the tubes.
Each value had
its own tube,
and people could throw in there
what they thought was the most important.
I mean, if I'm not mistaken,
two most important and one less important.
So you had it
invented beautifully, interactively.
And if you could now
present us the values
that ARCH21 carries,
and which, at least I think,
are intended to
not only darken the society,
but also preserve it.
Well, I just want to say
about the text, about the document
as such.
ARCH21, which was
created half a year ago,
we compiled the text,
consulted with people,
and it is
so special in that it is
actually a view from the future.
We are convinced
that people need hope,
and that they already have
really full teeth
of the social
situation in which we are.
And so we allowed ourselves to write
the document as a view from the future.
As if all the problems
that we feel here today
are already solved.
That is, I quote something from it,
it sounds really
visionary,
but I think that
progress and oversight
is extremely important,
not only from the point of view
of the solution, but also from the
psychological point of view.
Well, the core of ARCH21
is 12 values.
We discussed them,
which they will be,
we characterized each one in some way,
and for us, those 12 values
are some kind of pillar
of renewal,
and we understand that renewal
as
awakening and
raising awareness
of those 12 values of each person.
To be honest,
our team and Karel Janeček
do not rely at all
on a solution from above,
on a political solution.
I think that politics
today is already proving
every day that
trends will emerge,
whether I look from right to left,
from left to right, or even to the center,
which is still missing
political parties.
So it is necessary for
everyone to start
on their own. And so
our project, which is civic,
is actually aimed at
empowering people. This is a key concept.
We want to empower people
so that when
more crises come, or even for
the current time, which is already difficult
as it is, so that people
are more aware,
more resilient,
not to be so manipulated
by all possible
disinformation, including
state disinformation,
and just to be
self-sufficient and stronger
in themselves. Which is not a revolutionary
idea of such attempts,
there have been many in history,
but I think that for this time it is very
necessary, and I do not know of any other project
that would at this time
in the Czech Republic
strive for something similar.
Well, I would already get to
so the key value is
courage for us, because
we think that fear is the
psychological and psychosocial
cause of the bad
social state we are in.
Because on the basis of fear
people are manipulated and then
they let themselves be controlled.
So we actually, as the first project,
made an Advent calendar,
which we called, let's say,
Courage, and it was
24 video performances,
or audio performances,
and here
it is dedicated to Peter Pithart
inside, because Peter Pithart was actually
the first person we turned to
when we started with this project in the winter.
And he was also at that action
at that fight. And he also fought
with us now, yes, too.
So we made this Advent calendar,
and I don't know, maybe now
when I opened it, a piece here
from Mr. Pithart. Can I read it?
You can.
Our society is evidently failing
in all aspects,
not only economically.
Please help us with all that,
with getting to know,
naming all that
is in the vault of our subconscious
and unconscious,
and that it is nicely packed there.
Believe me, it will also mean
healing of the sick society,
so that we feel
comfortable and safe here
when some next pogrom comes.
As if it comes,
that's what pogroms do.
But we will be prepared,
better than last year.
You know we will.
I belong to the group of people who decided
that they will try to open the door
to our subconscious.
To find the key to it,
first of all to wander in the dark,
but not to be discouraged.
If not for anything else,
then for hundreds of thousands of children
whose souls are suffering and don't know why.
In every society,
children are above all
in our future.
So that's an excerpt from a conversation
with Peter Pithart from Podzim.
So that was this Advent calendar.
Let's give ourselves freedom.
There were a number of nice, respectful people
from the field of culture,
science, sports.
Let's give ourselves courage.
So the first planet,
the first value
is courage.
Jan, I don't think we have space
to read the texts here.
And to paraphrase them,
I will just say it.
Courage, freedom.
And it always starts,
in accordance with the manifesto,
which, as I said, is visionary,
it always starts positively.
So courage begins.
We live courageously, we believe,
we have regained personal strength
and courage for our dreams.
Freedom.
We live freely, we defend our
civil rights and freedoms.
We accept life's risks as challenges.
Health.
The third planet is health.
The third value.
We live healthy.
Health, body and spirit are connected.
We care for them ourselves.
We rely only on official medicine.
The next value is harmony.
We consciously strive for equality
between body and spirit,
mind and heart.
We know that harmony is the key
to a healthy life.
Then there is responsibility.
We are responsible.
We rely primarily on ourselves.
We do not transfer responsibility
to others and to the state.
We care for relations with people
and nature.
Then there is justice,
another key value often mentioned
by Karl Janáček.
We are just.
We are in solidarity with those
who need support and help.
We are fearless and active
against injustice and injustice.
There are many reasons for that.
Joy.
We live creatively and with joy.
We give our precious energy
only to life's capable directions
and creative activities.
We look at life with oversight.
Affection.
We are affectionate, we perceive situations,
wishes and needs of others.
We seek what unites us.
Self-sufficiency.
We are independent and self-sufficient.
We decide for ourselves
based on quality information
and our own judgment.
We do not accept superficially
other people's opinions.
I think that the audience
can easily recognize
that everything that is here
is how we live, almost in opposition
to what is written here.
So it really is a brave
visionary view,
but we hope that
we will get to it.
There are opportunities.
We stick together,
we look at the weaker,
we stop them and help them.
We communicate with people
who share our values,
but we look for and expand
understanding elsewhere.
Strength.
Connectivity is strength.
We have raised our heads
and there are enough of us.
We stand for our beliefs
and we know how to defend them.
We are not afraid to stand up
and live by ourselves.
And the last value and planet
that the arch flies around
is the Earth.
The Earth is our beloved home.
We are part of the connected
network of all earthly life
and we protect it as the most
precious treasure.
We are interested in the real,
non-virtual world.
It is full of surprises.
We are interested in the real,
non-virtual world.
It is clear that people,
especially young people,
spend hours and hours
on the Internet
and on social networks.
Yes.
I would stop at one value.
Not that I would be
interested in this
the most,
but for me it is
self-sufficiency.
As you mentioned
about the information
about self-sufficiency,
three or four weeks ago
you organized the first
of a series of discussions
that you are still planning
within the Arch.
It took place on May 30
and was called Hlavy spísku ven.
There were many
interesting speakers,
experts in medicine,
but also philosophers.
For example,
there was an immunologist
Karel Drbal,
Dr. Vladimir Čížek,
who is a well-known
psychologist Kamila Haronova,
a philosopher-journalist,
a writer Petr Šourek,
among others.
You started
this series
As I mentioned,
please tell us
what is the goal
of this series
and where will the next discussions lead?
We would like to
show
the problems
in the selected
social areas
of mental health,
physical health,
science, media,
interpersonal relations,
institutions, etc.
We would like to draw
attention to them,
to what is happening today
in these key areas.
But we would also like to
look at the current situation
All these problems,
or digital addiction
in children,
have somehow deepened
and accelerated during the COVID period.
During the last three years,
something significant has happened.
A number of farmers have disappeared,
which has affected the economy.
We had the longest closed schools
in Europe.
This has affected the children's
attachment to technology,
and thus to their
frightening mental health.
So, gradually,
during the winter,
winter, and spring,
we will discuss these eight
currently selected areas.
And based on
the selection of experts
and partners from these areas,
we will be given the best
expert resources available,
but at the same time,
we will be complemented by our experience from practice.
And from this, we will
come up with a synthesis.
We will address the experts on the other side,
but not the extreme ones.
So, we will not invite Mr. Konvalinku,
we will not invite Mr. Hořejší,
but we will not defend ourselves, of course,
against the opponent's opinion.
And based on the collected
resources,
comments,
and experience,
we will be at the table
where the experts will be.
Because the first one you mentioned
was the reason
why we chose
the chronicles of COVID events,
the absurdities
that took place here after three years.
Thank you.
You are recording a very beautiful
material for me,
I took it from the conference.
It captures
a book of milestones,
specific dates
or periods
when what happened,
when the first lockdowns were announced,
when schools began to close,
when vaccination began,
and so on. Great material,
I think.
Who is such a collector
or likes to remember things,
it's really well collected.
If you read it after two years,
you almost want to believe
that we really experienced it.
And you get goose bumps
that really all this
was happening, so it's in a concentrated
pattern of a few dozen
of the most significant restrictions
that we went through.
But I would go back
to the fact that this first action
was just such a hub
where eight
invited experts
thought about
what we went through during COVID,
but it wasn't yet
the expert analysis.
So the first topic
we will start with,
we naturally chose
mental health,
because we think it's something
that bothers us the most,
because in the end
even our physical health
depends on mental health
and mental health,
especially children and the younger generation,
is completely reversed.
And there are clear parallels
with COVID, what happened
thanks to specific steps
captured in this chronicle,
what specific effects it had on children.
So our schools were closed
absurdly for 282 days.
We were the longest
in all of Europe,
and that's one of the absurdities
that we have to point out,
that schools were closed,
children were forced,
or children were vaccinated,
and at the same time
children were not
subjected
to any kind
of COVID infection
and were not
such carriers
as to have
schools closed.
Simply children here
became victims of the fear of adults,
and that's something
that Karolina Ček often says,
that it should never be repeated,
that a civilization that sacrifices
children to its fear,
the fear of adults,
has no chance
at all to survive.
And that's absolutely logical.
So we're going to do
this process
step by step.
We'll start with mental health.
I think one of the first topics
we're going to focus on
will be the collection of science,
because the entire Western society
has always relied on
a model, on science,
and at the same time science
has become a servant of the system
because of COVID,
up to the honorable exceptions
that need to be crushed
before them.
I even remember
that Karolina Ček,
as an experienced scientist
at the time,
said here at the conference
that he also saw a little
what it all
entails
at the moment,
and that it is necessary to look at science critically.
Or the media.
What happened to the media?
I worked for years and years as a press reporter.
I had contacts with dozens of
journalists, eight of them.
I met several of them a week.
I was an environmental spokesman
and I'm not saying
that the situation until 2019
was ideal in the media.
It wasn't from afar,
but for reasons other than
some kind of
pressure from the system
or some kind of
self-censorship
or self-censorship of journalists.
And what happened during COVID
to some extent,
when the main media
became a tool
of government propaganda
and ceased
to be critical, ceased to seek reality.
It was really scary.
And for me personally,
it's really painful.
Because some journalists,
when I write to them today,
who were close to me
or even friends,
when I sent them an invitation
to this event,
dozens of them,
on May 29,
did not respond at all,
did not invite me at all.
And that's interesting,
because today there is already
a little bit of a shift there.
And by the way, we are
the Epoch Times among the media
that was not afraid to
inform critically,
but unfortunately we also
paid for it on social networks,
which led us to hard restrictions.
So then the first
auto-censorship is really
very motivating.
Yes, yes, yes.
Even the journalists themselves,
the more courageous ones,
admit that it is even worse
than some pressure
from the publishers
and chief editors,
so much worse, more devastating
is the normalizing pressure
of their own auto-censorship,
that the journalists
who want to calm
their life and relations
at work and in the environment,
and especially life in Prague,
simply do not dare
to express themselves
as they would like to
and write about what they want.
Or the topics they wrote about
ten years ago,
if they do not return
to the same topic,
then it is no longer possible.
By the way,
today I am going
to give a lecture.
You certainly know the journalist
Schellenberg from America,
also an ecologist,
former journalist,
and he was one of the people
who, together with Elon Musk,
when he took over Twitter,
collaborated on
exposing a number
of censorship mechanisms
that were shared in America,
including COVID.
So I'm really looking forward
to the lecture.
Well, it's just that we're
lagging behind again.
After all, some Western countries
have already looked
under the thick cover
of three years with COVID,
what was going on,
and some information is already
released more, publicized,
but we are here just
completely behind the scenes.
But one more thing I would like
to point out at the last
of your conferences,
or debates,
which we talked about,
the original one from the series,
I liked one point there,
that it was mentioned
that at the beginning
of the pandemic,
that it actually came
or became such a
social thing
that put people
together,
that there was some consistency
how people sewed those masks
and so on, but then
the state got involved,
and there it started,
on the contrary, the consistency
that worked there
then changed a little.
Yes, it is true that people
will shut up,
when there is a crisis,
so the good core,
the good heart in many people,
which completely dominates,
I believe,
that those who are really
serious harmful, that there is a
negligible percentage here,
people adapt, people always
end up with DAV,
so when the DAV is dominated
by good intention and good activity,
people join in,
but unfortunately it happens very
briefly and always in some
tight situations, but pay PAMBU for it,
because at least
it can be seen that in those
difficult situations people
pull for one reason, and the good heart
shows what in those difficult
situations, on the contrary,
as a state repeatedly fails.
This is something that is
amazing to observe,
how in difficult situations
people themselves
supplement the roles of the state,
which is extended.
I experienced it, for example,
in Nepal earthquake in 2015
with direct transfer, when I was there
and I saw how
the civil society,
whether Nepalese non-profits,
or foreign visitors,
or foreign advisers,
non-profits came together and helped
amazingly, while the Nepalese government
was totally decomposed,
was not even able to transport
hundreds of tons of humanitarian aid
from the airport.
So that's just
my personal experience
talking about how people
help each other in difficult situations
while the state is
decomposed. And this brings me back to
a broader context of what we do,
because I think that
everything that is happening around us
on many levels,
and there are many examples
of it,
could be named
from ecological,
economic,
humanitarian,
interpersonal relations,
so it clearly shows
that
the way,
the overruling way of life
of the Western society is unbearable
and that we are really
facing radical changes.
And naturally, people
are afraid of these changes,
and at the same time,
and this is even more important,
there are many industrial
and financial groups here
that are directly defending these changes,
because they are, of course,
addicted and want to keep
this old paradigm as long as possible.
But still,
nothing will wake us up
from this change,
and the change is painful,
that's true,
but I believe that
there is a chance for every crisis,
and the deeper the crisis,
the greater the chance.
Unfortunately, people do not change
voluntarily in their
absolute majority,
they change only by the pressure of the crisis.
I would like to quote
one aphorism from Stanislav Jelzilek,
probably from the 60s,
a Polish aphorist,
who said that the effect of pressure
depends on the material,
some become bigger,
others smaller.
I think that's quite a bit more than not,
and so I would like
to encourage everyone
to become
the bigger ones
and to take advantage of the opportunity,
and above all, not to be afraid.
And here I come again
to courage,
which is probably the main
simple instruction,
and I think that courage
can be found in the details,
for example, to find the courage
to apologize to someone
I hurt, or to find the courage
to say, I got involved,
I got involved in this and that
and such things
can start the process
of courage
and at the same time
finding
relationships between people.
And in what do you think
the greatest danger lies
in the Western way of life
today?
Well, I think it lies
on the one hand in its instability,
simply
8 billion people cannot live
the way
the richest people live,
not at all,
but not to get to the level
of an average American
who actually consumes
5 globes, while we have
only one of our consumption,
an average European, 3 globes,
and the world of development
0.00 nothing.
There is simply a huge social injustice
and at the same time a huge pressure
on the ecosystem of the country,
which no longer has enough resources
for all of us.
So that's actually
a concrete expression,
an answer to your question
and a more philosophical
answer to it is that I think
that the Western society basically
acts as some
technocratic machine,
literally Orwellian.
Its essence
is the creation of fear,
control
and domination.
And these three, and manipulation,
fear, manipulation, control,
domination, and these are
the key words around which
everything we are experiencing
and what we are healing,
all those threatening
measures that started
during COVID, but they did not end.
But I think
that
people have not created
life, so they cannot
even destroy it.
It is something that overwhelms us.
And here I have such a beautiful
poem by D. H. Clarence,
which I would read to it
at the end,
which is hopeful.
So, please.
It speaks of the triumph of the machine,
but the machine will never win.
For thousands of centuries,
capradins, white tongues,
and cantus developed
spitting into the sun
until one sad century,
when the machines won.
They rolled us back and forth
and shook
with a crooked nest
until the egg broke.
They shake their bellies
until the geese leave
and the wild swans do not fly away
and do not sing us
a swan song.
Hardly,
the machines were rolling on the ground,
but exactly which heart
will never win.
Thank you.
Jan Pinyas, thank you for accepting
the invitation to today's conversation.
Thank you very much for the invitation.