Google spustil novou iniciativu nazvanou „Informační intervence“. Jde o plán obalený v myšlence ochrany před dezinformacemi a škodlivými výrazy – a způsob, jak toho dosáhnout, jak kontrolovat ještě více, co můžeme vidět a říkat online.
Na jejich oficiálních stránkách je tato nová iniciativa označována jako „soubor přístupů podložených behaviorálním vědeckým výzkumem a ověřených digitálními experimenty s cílem vybudovat odolnost vůči online ubližování“. Google v podstatě používá stejné techniky a metodiky jako Pavlov na svých psech. Zatímco Pavlov se snažil, aby jeho psi slintali, Google se vás snaží přimět, abyste souhlasili se vším, co fact-checkeři považují za dezinformace.
This right here is called Operation Jigsaw.
The ingenious engineers from Google came up with a new plan.
It's a plan wrapped up in an idea, as it always is,
which is supposed to protect us from disinformation and offensive expressions.
And the way they're going to achieve that is, of course,
by constantly monitoring what you and I can see and say online.
What you're looking at right now is a website of a new initiative
by the Google company called Informační zásahy.
On their official websites, this new initiative is labeled,
I quote,
a set of approaches based on behavioral scientific research
and verified by digital experiments
with the goal of building a resistance to online insults.
When you say behavioral scientific research,
you're talking about Pavlov and his attempts on dogs.
That's a pretty good comparison, because in this new initiative,
Google basically uses the same techniques and methods
as Pavlov on his dogs,
just that you and I are users.
While Pavlov is trying to make his dogs bark,
Google is trying to convince you to agree with everything
the Czechs really consider disinformation.
But let's go back to the core of this new initiative,
this Informační intervence,
which is led by one of Google's subsidiaries.
It's a company called Jigsaw.
And as you can see on their website,
Jigsaw is a subsidiary of Google.
They are under the full leadership of Google.
According to their announcement, their goal is, I quote,
to apply a technological solution to the fight against extremism,
online censorship and cyber attacks,
as well as to protect access to information.
It all sounds very harmless.
Who wouldn't want to protect the population
from cyber attacks and extremism?
However, as with most things,
the devil is hidden in the details.
Let's take a look at the research published in the journal Nature,
which, by the way, claims that focusing people's attention
on the correctness of information
can reduce the spread of disinformation on the Internet.
By the way, Jigsaw collaborated with the authors of this article
to create the Informační intervence initiative.
And what is this initiative about?
Well, in March of this year,
Jigsaw published an article
in which it recapitulated its online social experiments
and in the end it wrote, I quote,
to remind users of the Internet
to stop and think about the correctness of information
But there is no silver bullet
how to fight against online disinformation.
For this reason, we are exploring a number of approaches,
including how to target people against disinformation,
and this is by building basic skills
in the field of information literacy.
And of course, the use of the word target
in their announcement is not necessarily accidental,
because they wanted to create a direct parallel
and basically say that they are a vaccine against disinformation.
But within that article,
they did not highlight any specific steps
that should be taken.
Everything was very conceptual.
Let's move from the publication of that article
a few months in advance.
Here it is much clearer what is included
in a number of approaches that should be used
in the fight against disinformation.
The four methods that Jigsaw will use
to limit the presumed disinformation.
These are the challenge of accuracy,
methods of direction, feedback from authors,
and also something called pre-banking.
We have four new methods here
that we can look forward to.
Let's go through them one by one.
The first method of Jigsaw's operation
is the challenge of accuracy,
which is a small pop-up window
that appears when you scroll through the content
that was really marked by Google
as potential disinformation.
The declared purpose of the challenge of accuracy
is to remind users there
to share only the content they are convinced
is informationally correct.
Here it is specifically stated
how the challenge will work.
The user goes through their social media
and comes across content
with potential disinformation.
Then a challenge appears in the pop-up window.
An explanation is displayed
why the user sees the warning.
The challenge is directly to greater attention
to think twice
about the desired following content to read.
If you have ever used the Internet,
then you have encountered something similar
on platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
With Jigsaw's operation,
we can look forward to this warning
on YouTube as well,
just like everywhere else where Google is active.
This includes almost all web pages
that are indexed by its search engines.
But let's emphasize that on the current web
of this initiative,
Google does not predict which web pages
these challenges will concern.
This will be determined first.
Let's move on to the second method
that Jigsaw's operation will use.
It is the direction method.
This is how Jigsaw's operation describes it.
I quote,
The direction method is intended
to address people who are vulnerable
to the influence of violent extremist groups
and tries to direct users
who are looking for extremist information
to the curator's content
which will be returned by the extremist department.
Here is how the method will work.
The user will look for a keyword
that indicates that he could be interested
in something that is considered
to be extremist propaganda.
Of course, the keyword is
the fact checker of Google.
Google will then capture this keyword
and make it so that the form of advertising
will offer users approved information
on the subject of their interest.
And after clicking on the ad,
the person is redirected to the content
that is contrary to the report
of extremist narratives.
And now, what type of so-called
extremist narratives are they targeting?
Well, we have a smaller answer.
Specifically for the direction method,
Jigsaw cooperates with the organization Moonshot.
You can see their web pages
at the top of the screen.
And on their website, they declare
that Moonshot cooperates
with other technological companies
in the implementation of advertising
that eliminates what they mean
by online insults, including
quotes, excesses of the white race,
hatred of women and, of course,
conspiracy theories.
If it's about what exactly
conspiracy theories can be considered,
Google decides about it,
as well as about most things.
The next method of Jigsaw's operation
is called the author's feedback.
Its goal is to influence
what people, i.e. you and I,
can actually write online.
The author's feedback works
in such a way that when you write
something, Google's artificial intelligence
detects toxic expressions online
and in real time gives the writer
feedback by removing
a significant part of the incriminated text.
Here is specifically described
how this feedback will work in practice.
The person writes a comment
that the AI identifies as toxic,
which is a rude, disrespectful
or inappropriate comment
that will probably directly
leave someone out of the discussion.
The AI detects a toxic expression
using machine learning technology
that allegedly identifies
all types of offensive language,
including the one you write
and you still have your hands on the keyboard.
And as an author, you will be notified
that the comment was identified
as risky or offensive
and will challenge you to correct
your text before publishing it.
If you now look at the image
of the image on their website,
it looks like you will still
be able to ignore the feedback
and publish the comment
by pressing the button
and sending it.
Although it is not entirely clear
how long it will be like this.
Maybe in the near future
you will be forced to change the text
or simply give up
the attempt to send the content.
Let's go to the fourth method.
It's called pre-banking.
Google explains what it means on their website.
I quote.
Pre-banking is a technique
that is supposed to prevent
attempts to manipulate the Internet
by making the individual more attentive
and informative
so that they can recognize
and return misleading arguments.
They gain the ability
to be misled in the future.
Now a little digression.
I always appreciate how those
who create these programs
always assume that people
are talking to them are lying.
It seems that they never think
that they may be the ones who
mislead people, but I am also
someone to judge it.
Let's move on.
How exactly pre-banking actually works
is described here.
Let's say you click on a video
that is in conflict with the narrative.
Before you see the video
in the form of an ad,
a short video appears
that should inform people
about what to pay attention to.
Through it, you will be informed
about possible attempts
of online manipulation with you.
It's a bit ironic that an ad
that tries to manipulate you
informs you that you are being manipulated.
But let's put that aside.
In the ad video, you will see
an example of a manipulative technique
or a narrative.
And then you will be presented
with official arguments
that will overturn the claims.
As soon as this process takes place,
AI will start evaluating
how well people who watch
this ad video were able to
invent manipulative techniques.
And if you would like to see
a real example of how such
exaggerated videos can look like,
here is one from the web
Finally, we have a vaccine against COVID.
But maybe you come across people
who still want you to be afraid.
They will use tactics
to manipulate smart
and honest people like you.
Sometimes these people talk
about the damage caused by the vaccine.
It's a video showing doctors
commenting on some statements
of people who are against mass vaccination
and pointing out their claims
I think most Americans
are already quite familiar
with all the techniques
that technology companies use
to control the narrative
and also reduce the content
they disagree with.
However, we have just described
four methods of the Jigsaw operation.
It seems that they will be
the next methods that big
technology companies will use
to suppress free online communication.
And as always,
just like everything else
at this time,
under the guise of our safety,
safety from disinformation
and harmful content.
But the main question
in these scenarios is always the same.
Who exactly determines
what exactly is disinformation,
what exactly is conspiracy theory,
extremist content or toxic language?
Because the one who decides
the answers to these questions
basically decides
what you and I can see.
And also what we can say on the Internet.
And that's a huge power.
And to predict that this program
will be conducted in some unilateral way
is quite a big deal,
especially because the employees
of the company itself,
i.e. Google,
gave 96% of their political gifts
to one political party.
So we can look forward to this now.
If you want to read more about Operation Jigsaw
and this whole disinformation initiative,
you can find several sources
in the description below this video.
And I would also like to thank
Mr. Eric Schumacher,
who helped to put together
a lot of this research and also make sense of it.
And finally, I would like to know
your opinions on this initiative.
Do you agree with Operation Jigsaw?
Do you agree with this initiative
that Google is implementing?
I personally have a slightly different opinion on it.
On the one hand,
it would be purely positive
if these big companies
could really stop spreading
real extremist ideologies.
I want to say that it is a well-known fact
that, for example, the rebels of the Islamic Caliphate
are actively recruiting people
and radicalizing them online.
In fact, just this weekend,
a young Islamic radical attacked three police officers
at Times Square with a machete.
And it would be great
if this could somehow be prevented.
But the question is,
can this really be prevented?
Because the guy at Times Square
was apparently a FBI agent
and the attack was successful.
So what?
Google will launch Operation Jigsaw,
which will push for freedom of expression
for ordinary citizens like you and me.
And then it will be bypassed
by some extremist,
which will lead Google
to emphasize its censorship regime even more.
And other extremists will again find
some excuse, which will lead
to further restrictions on freedom of expression.
When will this end?
We will no longer be able to speak freely online
and all of this will take place gradually
in the name of our own security.
It's like with weapons.
Some madman will shoot shopping centers
and then suddenly you and I
will not be able to have weapons in our own homes.
So there are positives and negatives here.
Stopping extremism
and at the same time suppressing freedom of expression.
However, there is another dimension
of all of this.
And it seems that we can take the motives
of the Google company for granted.
So they really do it to stop extremism.
Or is it that the extremism
that they are trying to stop
does not necessarily have to be the Islamic one,
but rather, let's say, another election
like in 2016,
when Donald Trump will be called to the White House?
I would like to know your opinions on this matter.
Do you consider the positives
over the negatives?
And what do you think
is the real motive of Operation Jigsaw
and all of the disinformation initiatives
launched by companies like Google?
In the coming weeks,
we will have several great episodes
that will go much deeper.
I hope you will look forward to them
even if Operation Jigsaw tells you otherwise.
I am your host Roman from Epoch Times.
Stay informed and stay free.