Should you pay off your mortgage early or keep the loan and invest the difference? In this video, we break down the 4 key angles you need to consider. We’ll walk through real numbers, lay out fair assumptions, and help you understand the hidden opportunity cost behind paying off “cheap” debt. But beyond the math, we’ll also talk about how emotions and peace of mind play a big role in making the right decision for you.
00:00 Opening 00:55 Consideration 1: Think about possible returns 02:55 Consideration 2: It’s about your mindset 04:07 You have 3 options. What are they? 05:14 Consideration 3: Don't forget about CPF 06:31 Consideration 4: What if you change your mind? 08:11 Some ground rules for our comparison 09:02 Financial calculation for your 3 options: Which is the winner? 10:27 Conclusion
When it comes to your home loan, there are generally two schools of thought.
The first says that you should pay off your loan as quickly as possible,
but the second says that you should not,
because that money can be put to better use elsewhere.
If you clicked on this video, then you're probably wondering
are there any benefits to paying off my mortgage early?
And how much can you actually save by doing so?
I've asked myself this question many times
and I've done the maths behind all the different options.
In general, there are four different angles to consider
and I'll walk you through the pros and cons of each angle.
We'll also go through a case study that compares the two different mindsets.
One where you pay off your loan early
and the other where you hold on to the loan but invest your spare cash.
You'll then compare all this against the status quo of doing nothing
and simply continuing your monthly payments.
By the end of this video, you'll understand exactly
how much each choice could cost you or even earn you.
Then you can decide for yourself if paying off your loan early is the right move.
The first angle to consider is the investment angle.
By paying off your mortgage, you're giving up access to cheap money.
Money that could be invested elsewhere for potentially higher returns.
For example, blue chip stocks or even the S&P index funds
which is a basket of the top 500 largest stocks in the US.
The S&P 500 has historically returned an 8-10% annually.
Far above the typical average mortgage rate of about 2-3%.
And the S&P 500 is just one of your options.
You could also invest in other equities,
buy a second property or even use the funds to start a business.
But all these investments come with risk.
The counter argument is simple.
Market returns are not guaranteed but your mortgage interest expense is.
If you choose to invest your spare cash,
then yes, on one hand, you may be able to generate a return.
But don't forget that on the other hand,
the interest expense that you will incur is almost guaranteed.
If you're investing in the US market,
then there is the additional risk of FX or foreign exchange
that you may want to consider as well.
And if you choose not to pay off your loan today,
there is also the risk that your interest rate may go up in the future.
So financially, the real question is this.
Would you rather chase potentially higher returns or lock in a guaranteed savings?
But let's be honest about it.
Paying off your loan early is not always purely financial and logical.
Even if the maths look good on paper,
sometimes how you feel matters more than the numbers.
Therefore, in order to truly decide whether to pay off your loan early,
we also need to look at the psychological side of this decision.
If you're new here, my name is Daryl.
And in this channel, we talk about real estate in Singapore.
If you're watching this video,
then you're probably interested in optimizing the finances for your home.
And you may also be interested in some of my other videos
which talk about the two different schools of thought
regarding property investment in Singapore
when it comes to stocks and real estate,
why some people fail to make money from their real estate,
whether it is cheaper to stay near the MRT or to buy a car.
So remember to like and subscribe if you want more such unbiased property videos.
The second angle is the psychological angle.
Having liquidity gives you a peace of mind.
With more cash on hand, you can cover any lifestyle needs that come up unexpectedly.
Yes, you still have monthly mortgage installments,
but they are usually manageable and spread out over time.
But having liquidity also means that you owe the bank money.
That monthly payment can weigh on you mentally.
The counter argument is that paying off your loan
provides psychological relief from those monthly obligations.
Maybe you're retired, want to reduce your monthly costs,
or just want to reduce the uncertainty.
In that case, paying off your loan early may be the right choice.
So emotionally, it boils down to this.
Would you rather sleep better at night knowing that you are debt-free
or feel safer knowing that you have cash available?
But now let's take a step back.
Imagine you're halfway through a 30-year mortgage on a $1 million loan.
After 15 years of steady payments, you owe about $592K.
Because after 15 years, you might finally have the amount required
to pay off the loan outstanding.
At that point, you face 3 options.
Therefore, in order to decide whether paying off your loan early is a bad decision,
we need to explore all these 3 different options and see how they unfold financially.
The first option is to do nothing and continue with the status quo.
Paying off your loan as scheduled over the remaining 15 years.
In this case, you incur interest costs on the outstanding loan balance.
The second option is to use your savings to pay off the loan entirely,
which means you save directly on the interest you would otherwise have to pay.
And this is what many of us are thinking about.
Now there is also the third option which is to keep paying the loan and the interest,
but keeping your remaining funds invested elsewhere.
Stay till the end where we will break down exactly how much interest you would pay in
each scenario and the theoretical gains your investments could make.
Now that we've laid out the 3 different options,
paying it off, keeping the loan, or keep the loan but invest the cash,
the options ahead become less confusing.
But in Singapore, there is often one twist that people often overlook.
And that twist is the CPF.
Depending on whether you're using cash or CPF to service your loan,
the impact of your decision can look very different,
especially when it comes time to sell your property.
Therefore, in order to understand whether paying off your loan early is a terrible decision,
we now need to explore the CPF angle.
If most of your loan is paid to CPF,
the impact is minimal because the CPFOA interest rate and the HDB loan rate
are both very similar at about 2.5 and 2.6%.
That means the delta between paying it off and paying the interest
would not be affected much.
Furthermore, for many of us, the CPFOA is not exactly liquid as well.
But CPF has the concept of accrued interest.
If and when you eventually sell your property,
you may need to repay this accrued interest to your CPFOA from your sales proceeds,
which can then complicate matters depending on what you intend to do afterwards.
So CPF adds another layer to the decision.
Because while you're not using cash upfront,
accrued interest and resale complications could appear down the road.
But beyond investment returns, liquidity and CPF,
there's one last consideration that many of us often overlook.
And that is reversibility.
What if you paid off your loan early today and then in a few years
realized that you actually need the money back?
Maybe for your child's education, a medical emergency,
or maybe even for the down payment of another property.
Therefore, in order to understand whether paying off your loan early is a terrible decision,
we also need to consider whether you can undo this decision
and how that depends on the type of property that you own.
The fourth and the final angle is reversibility.
If you own a private property and pay off your loan
and then later decide that you actually need the funds,
either for a major life event, for your child's education, or maybe something similar,
the good news is that you can actually access those funds again.
This is done through options like a cash out refinance,
taking an equity term loan or what we call gearing up.
But unfortunately, it is not as simple as like withdrawing your money from the ATM.
These loan options require bank approvals and must comply with MAS regulations as well.
And also afterwards, you still have to pay a monthly installment
on the amount that you extracted.
This whole process is also not immediate, so it's also best to check with your bank in advance.
Basically, yes, you can get your funds back without having to sell your home.
But this option only applies to private properties.
For HDB owners, the situation is different.
The money that you've committed to your HDB flat is essentially locked in
until you sell the unit.
I haven't seen a way for HDB owners to extract equity from their unit without having to sell it.
But if you've seen otherwise or no different, let me know in the comments below.
So yes, reversing your decision is possible if you own a private property.
But it is not instant and it is not frictionless as well.
For HDB owners, it is even less flexible.
Now that we've covered all the four different angles,
the financials, the psychology, the CPF aspect and the reversibility,
let's now dive into the numbers.
But before we run the comparison,
we also need to be clear about the assumptions that we are using.
Therefore, in order to understand whether paying off your mortgage early is a terrible decision,
we must first establish some ground rules.
After all, on this channel, we are all about being unbiased.
First, we're using an average interest rate of 2.5% over the 30-year loan tenure
for a loan quantum of $1 million.
Second, an 8% annual return on the S&P 500 with a simple compounding is used.
Historically, it's been around 10-12%.
We also won't factor any FX fluctuations between the US dollar and the SING dollar.
Third, we're not factoring in any brokerage or platform fees for the S&P 500 option.
Fourth, we're also assuming that you're disciplined enough to invest the full $592k immediately
and leave it untouched for 15 years.
Fifth, we're assuming no additional top-ups or withdrawals will be made from the S&P 500 investment.
With all these assumptions in place, we now have a level playing field.
Now, let's walk through the numbers for each of the 3 options that we talked about earlier
and see just how much they could actually cost you or earn you.
If you had chosen option 1, doing nothing,
you would have incurred around $133k worth of interest.
That is a direct hit on your profit and loss as an interest expense.
If you had chosen option 2, which is to pay off the loan with whatever funds you have available,
you would have saved that $133k worth of interest.
So in effect, your net expense would be zero.
You wouldn't incur any interest cost.
Now, if you went with option 3, continuing to pay the loan while investing your savings,
yes, you would still have to pay the $133k worth of interest.
But theoretically, your investments would now be worth around $1.8 million.
That means that after deducting the $592k of your initial investment,
your profit from the investments would be around $1.28 million.
And because we were incurring the interest expense while investing our money,
we also need to come back and deduct the $133k worth of interest that we incurred.
All in all, you would still be up by about $1.15 million on this option.
And the reason this number looks so big is because of the compounded growth over time.
At an 8% return annually, your investments don't just grow,
they grow on top of their own growth.
In the early years, yes, your gains can feel small.
But towards the later years, the compounding really kicks in.
And that's when your money starts working harder than you do.
So it's not just magic, it's just time and discipline doing their job.
Paying off your mortgage early often sounds like the reasonable and responsible thing to do.
And in some cases, it actually is.
It can provide you with certainty, a sense of control and a peace of mind.
But when you run the numbers like we have seen, the trade-off becomes very clear.
You are choosing guaranteed savings over potential growth.
And that choice comes with a significant opportunity cost.
In a low interest rate environment, a mortgage isn't just debt,
it becomes a financial tool.
One that can help you to stretch your dollar,
maintain liquidity and put your money to work elsewhere.
That doesn't mean that everyone of you should just go all-in when it comes to investing.
It only works if you know what you're doing, discipline,
a long-term focus and are also comfortable with the market volatility.
If you are, then holding onto a loan while investing the so-called cheap money
may just be the smartest financial decision that you can make.
But here's an important reminder, don't get too fixated on just the numbers alone.
Financial decisions, especially when it comes to your home,
are rarely purely financial and logical.
Your comfort level, your goals, your peace of mind matters just as much.
If you've enjoyed this video, then you're probably thinking about
how to optimise your finances when it comes to your home.
So check out my next video which is just a qualitative comparison between
buying stocks and investing in a second property.