This narration examines the duration of China’s economic crisis, noting its unique challenges with no clear historical precedent. It compares China’s real estate bubble collapse to Japan’s 1991 crisis, highlighting Japan’s healthier household finances and lower debt levels. China’s high household debt (66% in 2023) and real estate-heavy asset structure contrast with Japan’s, exacerbating deflation. Fiscal pressures and declining trust mirror the Soviet Union’s final days, while overcapacity recalls the 1929 Great Depression. Japan mitigated its crisis by shifting household debt to the government, but China’s restrictive policies worsen private and public finances. Demographic issues, like the one-child policy and youth unemployment (20-40%), compound the problem. The crisis, rooted in a flawed political system, may require generational turnover—potentially 40 years—for resolution, with recovery only feasible after systemic change.
Narration Body:
00:00:00 Intro 00:26:20 A Crisis Without Precedent 01:19:09 The Real Estate Bubble: China vs. Japan 02:13:16 Japan’s Financial Resilience 03:19:19 Deflation’s Deep Roots 04:13:05 Japan’s Policy Playbook 05:41:11 China’s Policy Missteps 06:55:03 A 40-Year Horizon 07:45:00 A Flawed Political System 08:45:06 Learning from the Soviet Collapse 10:49:04 Diplomatic Missteps and Overcapacity 11:17:06 No Solution Without Collapse
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Shong. Welcome to Digging
into China, where we explore China in
depth to review unique perspectives.
Today, we are diving into the question
of how long China's economic crisis
might persist. As the saying goes,
history offers lessons for the future.
But China's current situation is nearly
unprecedented with no existing economic
model fully capturing its complexities.
When it comes to the collapse of asset
bubbles, China bears a striking
resemblance to Japan's experience in the
past. In terms of the Communist Party's
fiscal pressure, declining government
efficiency, and eroding public trust,
the parallels are strong with the Soviet
Union in its final days. Meanwhile, the
issue of over capacity echoes the United
States during the Great Depression of
1929. Given that standard economic
models struggle to provide a
comprehensive explanation of China's
circumstances, we'll adopt a comparative
approach. By examining the similarities
and the differences between China's
economic crisis and those of other
nations, we can construct a logically
coherent model to better understand the
situation. Let's begin by comparing the
collapse of China's real estate bubble
with Japan's. In terms of debt levels,
when Japan's real estate market crashed
in 1991, Japanese households were in
robust financial health with a strong
savings. This cushioned the fiscal
impact of the asset bubbles collapse,
preventing an immediate crisis.
According to the OECD economic surveys
Japan 1991 report, Japan's central
government debt in 1990 was
approximately 38% of gross national
product GMP, rising to 45% when
including offbudget obligations such as
those tied to Japan national railways,
comparable to the liabilities of China's
stateowned enterprises. Japanese
household debt, however, remained
notably low. The same report highlights
that the Japanese household's net
financial assets as a share of GMP grew
significantly from 50 and a half% in
1980 to 92.8%
by 1989. After accounting for
liabilities, a large portion of these
assets was held in savings and low-risk
government bonds, reflecting a cautious
approach to debt. Exceptionally
cautious, even by conservative
standards. By contrast, US household
debt during the same period ranged from
35% to 45% while Japan's household debt
stayed below 20%.
Even so, Japan faced deflation after its
asset price collapsed due to a credit
contraction with the debt to disposable
income ratio at just 30%.
China, however, starts from a far more
precarious position. Official data pegs
its debt to disposable income ratio at
133%,
a figure that dwarfs Japan's. What about
China's household debt today? According
to 2023 IMF data, it stood at a 63.7%
climbing to 66%
now. That year marked both the end of
China's stringent COVID lockdowns and
over the collapse of its asset bubble,
making it comparable to Japan's 1991
crash. Yet, China's household asset
structure is heavily distorted due to
limited investment options with 80% of
household wealths tied to real estate
close to Japan's 65% in property and
land. However, the ability to repay debt
reveals a vast disparity. Chinese
household income constitutes less than
onethird of GDP while Japan's reached
2/3. Even with a robust social safety
net, still Japan fell into a
deflationary spiral. Japan's so-called
loss of 20 or 30 years weren't primarily
due to households being overwhelmed by
the bubble's collapse, which crippled
the consumption and investment. Rather,
it stemmed from worsening economic
expectations, prompting people to
tighten their belts voluntarily. China's
deflation, however, is different. It's
not a lack of desire to spend, but the
real estate bubbles collapse,
obliterating consumption capacity, a low
social safety nets, limited disposable
income and high debt. Japan's government
mitigated this by shifting household
leverage to the public sector with the
Bank of Japan lowering long-term
interest rates even to negative levels,
effectively subsidizing household
balance sheet as the lender of last
resort. Japan's strategy of suppressing
long-term interest rates shifted the
cost over time by discounting household
liabilities, reducing their actual debt.
Meanwhile, the Bank of Japan's bond
duration structure lengthened, meaning
its investment portfolio took losses.
This dynamics is evident in the balance
sheet of households and the central
bank. Household debts net present value
decreased significantly while the bank
of Japan absorbed the temporal cost
reflected in its rising portfolio
duration. Japan's household balance
sheet burdened by bubble era debt saw
their liabilities devalue while the
government's fiscal deficit and the
central bank's debt to asset ratio grew.
In contrast, the Chinese Communist Party
has restricted declines in long-term
interest rates, particularly for 10-year
government bonds and limited capital
flows. During a crisis of confidence,
local governments have resorted to
aggressive tactics such as cross
regional fines known as overseas
fishing. The result is a simultaneous
deterioration across the private sector,
households, and government finances, a
self-inflicted wound of wanting
everything and achieving nothing. Worse
still, while Japan faced a gradual
generational population decline, China's
is a cliff edge drop exacerbated by the
one child policy and the modern youth
reluctance to marry or have children.
Any one of these issues would challenge
any government. But in China, the
Communist Party's missteps are
converging simultaneously, a situation
beyond the mere description. Under the
Communist Party and Xi Jinping's
leadership, China's balance sheet
problem isn't about the repair, but
about indebted population being
naturally phased out, or as the saying
goes, debts die with the data. Rather
than framing China's exit from this debt
deflation spiral as a financial issue,
it's a demographic one tied to
population age and life expectancy. The
party claims China's average life
expectancy is 74 years. Fine, let's
accept that. The post80s and post90s
generations, the man bearers of real
estate debt suggest a 40-year timeline
for generational replacement. But what
will cost benefit transfers to look like
under the party's governance?
Generational turnover will increase
non-performing loan rates in Chinese
banks and the balloon government debt.
The Communist Party unlikely to absorb
these costs will probably shift them to
younger generations post 2000s, post
2010s and even post 2020s through
measures like a higher taxes, reduced
welfare and the steep social security
contributions. Thus, 40 years marks only
the timeline for balance sheet turnover,
not economic recovery. Given the party's
path dependent behavior beyond the
burdening younger generations, their
options are limited. Mass money printing
already underway act as a senorage tax
passing costs to households. China's
economic issue isn't merely an exhausted
model, but a political system and the
Communist Party's rule reaching its end
on government efficiency and
credibility. Parallels with the Soviet
Union's final days are evident. The
Communist Party's strategies draw from
the Soviet collapse where Gobbach of
reforms resembling China's late 1980s
price dual track system and a partial
political lossing aimed to boost
economic vitality and attract Western
investment. These failed exposing the
Soviet regime's irredeemable state. The
Communist Party under Xiinping takes the
opposite attack, citing the Soviet
collapse as a lesson that no man stood
up. They view Gobachov's path as no cure
for communist states, but assume the
opposite is. Yet reality isn't a binary
of hardline versus compromise. This
aligns with the she's linear thinking.
But the real world problems are complex
involving diverse interest, stakeholders
and execution challenges. She's binary
framework where if a fails, negative A
must succeed is flawed and likely more
destructive. The Soviet model left a
framework for Russia's partial revival
under Putin, but the she's approach
risks ensuring the Communist Party's
complete collapse. Economically, the
party further weakens the private
sector, offering empty promise on issues
like overseas fishing. This affects
livelihood as the private sector drives
80% of China's employment, a core issue.
High unemployment erodess disposable
income and debt repayment capacity. Even
shifting costs to younger generations
requires their full employment and value
creation. But official youth
unemployment is 20% with nonprofit ATM
estimates at 40%. Cost shifting fails,
hastening the party's demise. Its linear
approach ensures outcomes opposite to
its goals. The harder it pushes, the
faster it unravels. She's persistent
with this linear mindset guarantees the
party's swift end. on over capacity.
China relies on exports contingent on
international diplomacy. Recently,
foreign minister Wi claimed in Europe
that Russia must not lose the Russia
Ukraine war as China can't bear the cost
likely stunned EU officials especially
as China seeks non-American markets to
absorb excess capacity. In conclusion,
China's debt problem from a balance
sheet perspective is intractable. Not a
matter of 30, 40, or even 80 years. As
it's not purely economic, recovery
becomes analyzable only when the
Communist Party fails, marking the point
when solutions become calculable. Thank
you so much for watching. If you find
this video helpful, please like it, drop
a comment below, and hit the subscribe
button right here. It really helps
YouTube suggest my video to others. I'll
be back with more content soon. Until
then, be well.