德拉克講海軍歷史 二戰中哪國海軍擁有最好的魚雷?
王者风范
22粉絲
25 次觀看·2025年10月20日
Hello there
This month, the fine folk over on Patreon asked, among other things,
who had the best torpedoes in World War II.
And since we've already done an anti-aircraft gun comparison
and a surface gun comparison,
I thought, OK, well, let's do a torpedo comparison as well.
Now, with this, there are a few different categories,
much like with the anti-aircraft gun comparison
where we looked at light, medium and heavy.
It's obviously unfair to compare, let's say,
a Japanese long lance, which is a 24-inch heavy torpedo
with a dinky little 18-inch air-launched torpedo.
So, we have four broad categories
and one of them has a slight sub-category element to it.
So, the smallest category is what I've dubbed heavy torpedoes,
that is, torpedoes used in World War II
with a diameter greater than 21 inches.
Then you have electric torpedoes,
because, of course, electric torpedoes
have very different characteristics at that time
and perhaps still now,
to torpedoes that use more conventional fuel.
We then have the 21-inch torpedo,
so that is the standard heavyweight torpedo
fired by destroyers and submarines and so forth.
And then, finally, we have a category
for lightweight torpedoes.
Now, the vast, vast, vast majority of them
are 18-inch torpedoes or thereabouts.
So, when you come to size measurements,
it's either 18, 21 or 24 inches,
plus or minus a little bit,
because, of course, some people use metric.
But in this category,
we have essentially air-launched torpedoes,
which means the slightly oversized US Mark 13
gets involved in the discussion.
But we also have a subcategory in here,
because there were four models
of 18-inch surface-launched torpedo.
And because of the slight differences
in surface-versus-air-launched torpedoes
in terms of design,
like the fact that, obviously,
with a surface-launched torpedo,
you can make it considerably longer and heavier
than an air-launched torpedo in general, at least,
because you don't have to worry about
casting it through the air,
I put those four in their own little subcategory.
So, we're going to look at pretty much all of them.
The scoring system is a little bit simpler
than it is with the guns
that we've looked at previously,
simply because there isn't things like
an elevation rate and so forth for a torpedo.
So, instead, we are scoring the torpedoes
based on the following.
What their charge weight is,
because, you know, lots of explosives,
a bigger hole in the ship,
but also what that charge is equivalent to in TNT.
Now, for some torpedoes,
that's just the same number
because their warhead is TNT,
but various torpedoes
have different types of explosives in them.
The Japanese have an explosive
generally in most of their torpedoes
called Type 97.
The Germans use various mixtures
which include hexanite.
Let me tell you,
figuring out an average TNT equivalent
for that was a bit difficult
because they use multiple different mixtures
with multiple different TNT equivalent rates.
So, I've ended up using the one
that was the most commonly used.
And then, of course,
you have the ever-so-wonderful Torpex,
which is considerably more powerful than TNT.
So, obviously, to a certain degree,
someone's managed to fit
an amount of explosive in a torpedo
that deserves scoring.
But if somebody's managed to fit,
say, a 600-pound TNT warhead
and someone else has fitted
a 500-pound Torpex warhead,
well, the Torpex warhead
is actually more powerful
even though it weighs less,
so that also needs to be scored.
Then we have their speed
at their slowest setting
and their corresponding range,
if, indeed, they have such a setting.
And then their speed
at their fastest setting
and the corresponding range.
And, obviously,
they have to also have
a fast setting to score on that.
Almost all torpedoes
will have a fast setting.
A lot of the air-launched ones
don't have a slow setting.
And the reason I say
almost all have a fast setting
is because, let's be honest,
the electric torpedoes
are not particularly quick.
And in each of those categories,
each torpedo gets a score
of between 0 and 10,
where 0 is the torpedo
with the least amount
in that category,
and 10 is the one with the most.
So the one with the slowest speed
in the fast speed setting
would obviously get 0.
The one with the higher speed
would get 10.
And everything in between
I've rounded it
to single decimal places.
I did consider adding
a category of explosive per weight
to reflect the efficiency
of packing explosives
into a torpedo.
However, I decided
to discard that
largely on the grounds
that it could unfairly
bias the results
towards torpedoes
that might therefore
have a really, really high score
but weren't actually
all that effective.
For example,
the CHI-10 suicide torpedoes
carried a very large amount
of explosive
but turned out to be
very impractical weapons.
Or you could have
a hypothetical torpedo
that carries an awful lot
of explosive
but only goes about 50 feet
but would still score
10 out of 10
because it's 80% explosive
in that category.
So I left that one out.
Other scores
that you could add to this
to finesse the results some more
would be things like reliability
or a variety of homing methods
or detonation methods,
things like that.
But I ended up
not doing that
on a couple of grounds.
Firstly, some things
like reliability
are a little bit subjective
looking at Mark 14 and Mark 18
but also an awful lot
of them, even if you can
come up with an objective
way of scoring them,
vary quite considerably
during that torpedo's lifetime.
So, for example,
if you were to look at
the 1942 Mark 14,
it would score terribly
on reliability,
whereas if you looked
at the 1945 Mark 14,
it would score quite well
on reliability.
At which point,
do you give it an average
and just say it's OK?
Do you take the 1942 variant,
which is unfair
to the 1945 torpedoes?
Do you take the 1945 torpedoes,
which is hilariously
unfair to everyone else
because of the terrible
reliability added in 1942?
Do you create three or four
different entries for the Mark 14
based on which year it's in?
And bearing in mind
some of these torpedoes
switch from TNT to Torpex
or TNT to some other
explosive equivalent
midway down the line,
so you have to create
separate categories for those anyway?
At which point,
everything gets ridiculously complex
and therefore, again,
I decided not to do it
because this is a relatively
simple analysis.
And it also brings up
a couple of interesting points
because as you'll see,
there are a few torpedoes
that on a purely technical basis
score very highly,
but when you consider them
in overall performance terms,
you know, also which ones
we use the most,
you might think,
well, maybe one or two
other torpedoes should be
bumped up a rank or two.
And obviously,
that in and of itself,
while you're going through this video,
is quite an interesting case study
in the difficulties
of creating properly accurate
ranking systems
for these kinds of weapon systems,
because ultimately,
if you go too simplistic,
you end up with weird outliers,
and if you are overly detailed,
you open yourself up
to an awful lot of subjective bias.
So it'll be interesting to see
what you think of this list
and also what factors
you think could be
relatively objectively scored
to improve the list
if you don't think
it's necessarily 100% on the ball.
Now, with that said,
we're going to start off
with the torpedoes
that have the least number of entries
and move our way on
to the ones with the most entries.
Oh, and just before we begin,
one quick note.
You may notice
that a tiny handful
of World War II-era torpedoes
are missing,
and that's because
they're what I've dubbed
highly specialist torpedoes
that don't really fit
into this kind of comparison ranking.
So, for example,
there's an absolutely tiny
lightweight, air-dropped
Italian torpedo
whose main purpose
was to go circling around
in convoys and cause havoc.
It's an extremely interesting concept,
and, you know, weird torpedoes
probably deserve a video
of their own at some point,
but at the end of the day,
it's this tiny, tiny lightweight thing,
so therefore it cannot carry
a particularly large explosive charge,
and it can't go particularly fast,
and it can't go particularly far,
so it would automatically rank
as pretty much the worst
air-dropped torpedo of all time,
but that's when you're comparing it
with full-sized air-dropped torpedoes,
which have a more conventional
fly-towards-target drop torpedo
pointing-towards-target
hope-it-runs-true-at-a-distance-
and-blows-things-up,
which is a completely different use case
to the Italian torpedo,
which was supposed to be
parachuted into the middle
of a bunch of ships,
and therefore,
as a completely unfair comparison
because of scientific use cases,
I've excluded it from the list,
and because it's pretty much
a unique weapon,
therefore obviously
it doesn't get included,
so if there are
one or two odd ones
that you think I've left out,
that's probably why.
Anyway,
first we have the heavy category,
so this is torpedoes
with a diameter
substantially greater than 21 inches,
and in this entry,
we only actually have
four torpedoes,
two of which are variants
on the same theme,
and again,
you'll notice
one or two variants
have been left out
because one of the categorizations
for best torpedoes
of World War II
is that it has to be
torpedo actually used
in World War II,
so torpedoes from the 1910s
that aren't in use
in the Second World War
don't get included,
but also variants
that are perhaps created in 1945
and only really see
experimental testing
or post-war deployment
also don't count
because they're not torpedoes
of World War II.
So in last place
is the British 24.5-inch Mark I
as found on the battleships
Nelson and Rodney,
and it's not necessarily
all that surprising.
It's the lightest of the torpedoes
in this category,
albeit only by a handful of pounds
in the case of entry number three,
but it's also by far the oldest.
Its in-service date being 1925,
whereas the others
start coming into service
in the mid-1930s and thereafter.
The third place entry
is the Japanese Type 90,
and then the top two places
are unsurprisingly taken up
by the Japanese Long Lance,
the Type 93,
in its Model 1 and Model 3 forms,
and they lead the field by,
yeah, let's just say
quite the considerable margin.
Now that's not to say
that the British torpedo is bad.
It's got a 20,000-yard range
at 30 knots
and a 15,000-yard range
at 35 knots,
which compared to
pretty much any 21-inch torpedo
is absolutely monstrous.
It also carries a very large warhead,
743 pounds of TNT,
which is enough to overwhelm
the torpedo defenses
of most World War II-era capital ships,
although some are rated
for slightly more than that,
but it is massively superseded
by the others.
Now, interestingly,
the Type 90
has a slightly larger warhead
It's 827 pounds,
but being Type 97 explosive,
it's actually equivalent
to about 885 pounds of TNT.
Its slow speed setting,
35 knots, 15,000 yards,
is actually pretty much identical
to the British torpedo,
and although it can only travel
about 7,500 or just over yards
at its fast speed setting,
its fast speed setting is 46 knots.
And then you have
the two Long Lance variants.
They are substantially heavier.
The Model 3 considerably so.
They have much, much larger warheads,
about 1,060 and then 1,720 pounds
in the Model 3,
and, of course,
that gets bumped up slightly
for them being Type 97 explosive.
They both have a default
slow speed setting of 37 knots,
which is a couple of knots faster,
and, of course,
can go massively further on that.
The original flavor Long Lance
is capable of almost 44,000 yards
in theory,
and the Model 3 of just under 33,000,
and they can both travel
at 49 knots or possibly more
at high speed,
but the interesting thing is
that the original flavor Long Lance
can actually go further
just under 22,000 yards.
The Model 3 can only do
only about 16,500 yards,
but, of course,
carries about two-thirds,
again, more explosive.
Now, as we go through the categories
that have considerably more entries,
I'm not necessarily going to go through
every single torpedo
because we could be here all week,
but if you want to see
exactly which torpedoes I included
and what the breakdown is,
it's actually, well,
you can either look on the screen
or there is now an article
on the website
which has the spreadsheets
and possibly some other data
if I choose to throw that in as well.
So we move on
to the electric torpedoes.
Now, the interesting thing is
when you say electric torpedo,
in a World War II context,
almost everybody thinks of the G7E,
the German electric torpedo,
which, to be fair,
some people did copy,
but you might be surprised to find
that in terms of conventionally
launched electric torpedoes,
almost everybody had one.
The U.S. had one.
The British had one.
The Germans obviously had lots.
The Japanese had one,
and so did the Soviets.
But out of the 11 different torpedoes
or in some cases torpedo variants
that you will find being commonly used
or at least to a certain degree
commonly used in World War II,
the Germans are in the weird position
of, spoiler alert,
occupying the bottom five
and the top places.
So how does that work then, Drack?
Well, the G7E variants,
T5, T11, T4, T10,
and T5A and B
are all in the bottom five,
almost all of them scoring
actually less than 5 out of 10,
with the T5A and B models
scoring 5.4 out of 10,
and that's not necessarily
because of any particular deficit
in range and speed.
In fact, the T10 has
the highest slow speed,
joint highest slow speed,
at 30 knots,
and the T5A and B
has the highest range
at 8,750 yards.
What's letting them all down
is their warhead.
All of those torpedo variants
are carrying a 440-pound charge,
which, using the most commonly
used German explosive mixture,
seems to be equivalent
to about 484 pounds of TNT,
because it's a hexanite
and other explosives mixture,
which, honestly,
against any kind of
modern torpedo defense system,
really isn't going to cut it.
Now, to be fair,
one of the reasons
these torpedoes are quite effective
in reality is that
they are not used,
for the most part,
against ships that have
torpedo defense systems
and used against merchant ships
and small escorts,
which can't have them,
but in an objective scenario
of we're shooting this
potentially at even a capital ship,
that is really what's
letting all those models down.
Then we have the U.S. Mark 18,
which carries actually
the single largest charge
once you take into account
the TNT equivalent,
because it doesn't carry
the single heaviest charge period
in terms of weight.
It's a 600-pound warhead,
but being torpex,
that's equivalent to 900 pounds,
which is enough to overcome
almost any torpedo defense system
out there,
at least, again, on paper,
and it's a relatively swift torpedo
at 29 knots,
but also a very short-range torpedo.
In fact, the shortest range
of all the electric torpedoes
are only 4,000 yards.
And then we have the German G7E T2
early model,
which has the joint highest top speed
at 30 knots,
but, again,
a relatively disappointing range
of just under 5,500 yards,
and although it's got
a TNT equivalent warhead
of about 675 pounds,
which is OK.
It's still towards the lower end
of the ones that are scoring higher.
Then we have the British Mark 11,
which is a late entry into the war,
only introduced in 1944,
but it carries a 710-pound TNT warhead,
which actually makes it
in the top three for explosive power,
and it's just using pure vanilla TNT,
and it's got a relatively decent range
of around 5,500 yards,
so it scores 6.5 out of 10.
Then we have the Russian electric torpedo,
the E-T-80,
introduced in 1942.
It's scoring 7.5 out of 10,
although it has the second lowest
operational range.
It has a 29-knot top speed,
so only one knot off
of being one of the fast ones,
and part of the reason
it probably has that short range
is because it's absolutely packed
with TNT,
882 pounds of it,
which gives it the second most
effective warhead
in this entire category,
and the heaviest actual warhead
of any torpedo.
It's only just pipped
to the post for the top spot
by the U.S. Mark 18
because of the use of Torpax,
and those therefore high marks
in both charge,
charge equivalent in TNT,
and speed offset to a certain degree
the fact that it's actually
a fairly short-range weapon.
In second place,
we have the Japanese Type 92
electric torpedo,
which,using Type 97 explosive,
has a decent-sized warhead
just under 710 pounds
of TNT equivalent
at 29 knots.
It's also quite a bit faster
than a lot of the German G7E variants,
and it's in the top tier
with ranges.
It's got the third longest range
at just over 7,600 yards,
which is pretty good
for an electric type,
but the overall winner
is the late variant
of the German G7E T2 torpedo.
Although its warhead
is similar to the early model
of the T2,
because obviously they have
the same torpedo,
only equivalent to about 675 pounds,
which,as we said,
is not going to trouble
the better capital ships
of World War II.
It does have a 30-knot top speed,
and at 8,200 yards,
it has one of the best ranges.
In fact,
only pipped to the post
by the T5A-B,
which is also a G7E variant.
So that combination
of very good range
exceptionally good top speed
and decent warhead
nets it a score of 7.7 out of 10,
and therefore the podium position,
although it's interesting to note
the Type 97 is at 7.6 out of 10,
and the ET-80 at 7.5,
so it's a very close-run thing.
The British Mk 11 is at 6.5,
the T2 early version is at 6.3,
and the U.S. Mk 18 is at 6.2,
so again, a very close pack
in 4th through 6th,
and then everyone else
drops off quite badly.
And then the second most numerous category
is our lightweight torpedoes,
which are mostly airdropped,
although some of them
can also be launched from submarines,
and of course we have
our separate little surface category,
and this entry is quite considerable.
We have 20 torpedoes
in our main category,
and then those other four,
obviously the only large one
is the 21-inch category,
and thanks to the fact
that almost all nations involved
have multiple torpedoes in this category,
you'll find that actually
the nations that podium finish,
that have the top three air-launched torpedoes,
also actually have entries
in the bottom six category,
and in one case,
it's actually two different models
of the same torpedo.
So just picking over some highlights this time,
the absolute worst airdropped torpedo of the war
is the German F5.
Now oddly enough,
the F5 is a relatively speaking
modern entry into the category
being introduced into service in 1939,
which is somewhat embarrassing
when it's therefore outdone
in categorization by some torpedoes
that were developed considerably earlier,
and of course also at the same time as it,
but honestly,
anyone who knows anything
about airdropped torpedoes
of the Second World War
wasn't going to be exactly surprised
to see that coming,
it's got a fairly pathetic charge,
441 pounds,
485 pound TNT equivalent,
so it's not going to be troubling
the torpedo defenses of anything
with substantial torpedo defenses
or even a bunch of perhaps
the World War I ships
with refitted bulges.
It's also one of,
although not the slowest,
at 33 knots,
and has a very short range,
although again,
not the worst,
but near at it at 2,200 yards.
It also doesn't have
a slow speed setting,
but as we said,
airdropped torpedoes usually don't,
so it only scores 1.9 out of 10.
We then have a rash of torpedoes
that are all in the 2 range,
2.6, 2.6, 2.8, and 2.8.
That's the Japanese Type 91 Mod 1,
which is mainly on there
for having the tiniest charge in existence
at 331 pounds of Type 97 explosives,
so only about 355 pound TNT equivalent.
It's really pathetic,
to be perfectly honest,
and it's also fairly short range,
although it's quite high speed
over that range.
It's just going to sort of ding you
if it hits you,
and that's about it.
Then a couple of British
air-dropped torpedoes.
They're actually relatively swift,
and weirdly enough,
they're some of the few
that have a slow and fast speed settings,
and if you consider their
slow speed and range,
for example,
the Mark 12 has a 37-knot slow speed
and a 3,500-yard range.
If you slotted that
into the upper echelons,
that would actually still be
4 knots faster
and considerably longer range
than the F-5,
but its high speed setting
is what it's been counted on
because that's the fairest one
across the board.
40 knots, decent speed,
but 1,500 yards at that speed,
not particularly brilliant,
and again,
not a particularly large warhead,
just 440 pounds of TNT.
You've also got the F-5B light,
which again is not much
to write home about
compared to the F-5.
Its main advantage
is that it is considerably faster,
40 knots,
but actually carries a smaller charge
to make up for that,
so unsurprisingly
also in the bottom tier,
and then scoring 3 out of 10,
we have the early models
of the U.S. Mark 13,
and reliability issues aside,
its 404 pounds of TNT
is not a particularly impressive warhead.
It does have a very impressive range,
5,700 yards,
the longest range
of any airdrop torpedo in the category,
but it only does that at 30 knots,
which means that actually
quite a lot of its faster targets
can just outrun it.
France, of course,
didn't really get much of an opportunity
to innovate and bring in
its latest torpedo design,
so unsurprisingly its 26V
and various derivations
there of which are
mid-1920s airdrop torpedo
are next on the list.
Perhaps the main thing
that's surprising is the fact
that at 3.2 it's actually scoring
considerably better
with a 1926 era torpedo,
albeit somewhat modified
during the 30s,
than some of these other torpedoes
like the F-5B
which was introduced in 1941,
if you can believe it.
Then we have another model
of the Type 91, the Mod 2,
then several Italian torpedoes,
the F-200 5.46
and the SI-200 5.36,
then the German F-5B heavy torpedo,
which is mainly bumped up the list
by the fact it now actually has
a somewhat scary warhead
at just over 600 pounds TNT equivalent,
so it could start troubling
some of the more modern ships out there.
It's also one of the rarer ones
with a high-speed and low-speed setting,
still got 2,200 yards high-speed range,
which isn't particularly brilliant,
but it's got up to 40 knots
for that high-speed run,
and it's actually got
quite an impressive 6,500-yard
plus slow-speed setting,
albeit at the pedestrian rate of 24 knots,
even Queen Elizabeth
could outrun that thing,
and it's kind of a mid-tier torpedo,
although it's starting to enter
the higher-end categories.
We've then got various versions
of the Soviet 45-36 torpedo,
two more variants of the Japanese Type 91
because they kept modifying it,
the Mod 3 and the Mod 3i,
and then we enter our top five.
So in number five position,
we have the British Mark 15 torpedo,
which is a mid-war torpedo,
which,thanks to the introduction of Torpex,
carries one of the heavier
TNT equivalent warheads
at just under 820 pounds of TNT,
so able to breach,
at least on paper,
almost any torpedo defense system out there.
It also has a high-speed
and low-speed setting,
and its high-speed setting
is 40 knots at 2,500 yards,
so a little bit better in range
than a lot of our lower entries,
not that much to write home about,
but that 40-knot top speed is pretty decent.
It's mainly that big warhead, though,
that's giving it that fifth-position place.
Then we have the Type 91 Mod 4,
which has a fairly large warhead again,
679 pounds,
so heavier by weight
than the British Mark 15,
but actually less in TNT equivalent,
thanks to being Type 97 explosive,
netting it a TNT equivalent charge
of just over 720 pounds,
but it's very swift through the water
at 42 knots,
which is the second-highest top speed
of an airdrop torpedo,
but only at 1,640 yards range,
which is the second-lowest range,
but that combination of high top speed
and a fairly large warhead
have netted it fourth place.
Then in third place,
we have the Mod 10 version
of the Mark 13 torpedo,
so that's the American torpedo,
again,a mid-war introduction here,
and that's because it has
the second-highest warhead
in TNT equivalent.
It's only 606 pounds worth,
I say only,
that's still quite a lot,
but thanks to TORPEX,
that's a 909-pound TNT equivalent warhead,
which is a lot of boom,
so that's breaching
almost any torpedo defense system.
It's a relatively pedestrian 33.5 knots,
but it can go 4,000 yards,
which,if you'll remember,
combined with various improvements
that the U.S. made
for being able to actually drop the thing
from a long distance,
means that it scores third place
with a score of 5.4 out of 10,
0.2 points above
the earlier Japanese one
and 0.3 points above
the British Mark 15.
Now,of course,
this is where subjective evaluation
could bump it up higher,
because,as we said,
we are comparing just the torpedoes
at this point,
much like when we compared
main battery guns,
we compared the guns,
not the turret systems
that they were in,
because,obviously,
guns can be mounted
in lots of different turret systems,
and so you could now,
at this point,
be making an argument
that with the combination
of that high and high speed drop
that the Avengers could do
in the late war,
perhaps that would improve
the Mark 15's chances
and put it at the top of the podium,
but it's still in third place
at this point.
So,you know,
if you want to see that,
perhaps come up with an objective way
of scoring the delivery systems,
but then,of course,
we're now into more scoring aircraft
at that point,
which I'm not so capable of doing,
in any case,
a very late entry into the war,
but just about in use,
the second place goes
to the British Mark 17 torpedo,
which has a near-equivalent warhead
to the late model Mark 13,
6 pounds less,
but it's Torpex,
so at 900-pound TNT equivalent,
again,very powerful,
somewhat faster than the Mark 13
at 40 knots,
but only over
2,500-yard range,
so under conventional
torpedo drop conditions,
that's not necessarily a problem,
but could be a problem later on
unless you want to adopt
the U.S. approach to torpedo drops,
and then at the absolute pinnacle
of everything
is yet another version
of the Japanese Type 91,
this time the Mod 7,
because it has
one of the highest top speeds,
in fact,
only the French torpedo
has a higher top speed.
It's 42 knots through the water,
it's got the heaviest warhead,
by far,
it carries 926 pounds
of Type 97 explosives,
so 990 pounds of TNT equivalent,
which is just about
capable of defeating
any torpedo defense system
in the Second World War,
so we've got,
near enough,
we have the biggest,
in fact, torpedo warhead,
a top entry,
although not quite
the top entry for speed,
and that's what's putting it
in the podium position,
but of course,
as I said,
640 yard top maximum range,
well, to be fair,
that is within the drop range
of most torpedo bombers at the time,
but it is considerably less
than the British and American entries
in this top five,
so you may want to take that
into consideration,
especially since
it's only introduced in 1944,
and therefore,
if you were,
as with the Mark 13,
going to add in
the efficiency of,
if not necessarily,
the delivery system,
i.e. the aircraft,
but the drop system,
i.e. the distance and speed
it can be dropped,
that could hold it back
if that scoring category
was also added in,
and then very briefly,
we have the four entries
for surface-launched
18-inch torpedoes,
and in this case,
there's actually only
two nations competing,
the Soviets and the Italians,
at the number four position,
we have the Soviet 45-36N,
which has the lowest speed,
actually,of all of them,
at 41 knots,
and a mid-tier range,
3,280 yards,
of the surface-launched
18-inch torpedoes,
and a fairly small warhead,
but one that pretty much
everybody shares in this category,
at about 440 pounds of TNT,
slightly higher on the pecking order
is the Italian Si-205.36,
which has the same warhead size,
a slightly less range,
at 2,200 yards,
but it gets there
three knots faster,
at 44 knots,
which is just enough to give it,
well,the Soviet one
gets .8 out of 10,
this one gets 1.1 out of 10,
then we have the Italian
W-200 5.25,
again,exactly the same warhead size,
but is now two knots faster still,
at 46 knots,
and can go 4,400 yards,
so it's the longest range
and highest speed
of all the surface-launched
18-inch torpedoes,
and it's only really let down
by that relatively small warhead,
and then the Soviet 46-36NU torpedo
takes the top spot,
it's got the joint lowest speed
and range,
41 knots,
3,280 yards,
with the 45-36N
that was at the bottom,
but it's the only one
with a bigger warhead
than 440 pounds,
at just over 620 pounds of TNT,
and so might actually trouble something
with a half-decent
torpedo defense system,
which was enough to push it
to the top of the category,
and then we are now
onto our biggest category,
which is the 21-inch torpedo,
which is the most common
surface- and sub-launched
type of torpedo
that you'll find
in the Second World War,
this has no less than 34 entries,
and so somewhat similar
to the air-launched torpedoes,
we're going to look at the bottom five,
quickly speed run through
everything that sits in the middle,
and then look at the top five,
so the bottom five places
we actually have two entries
from the U.S.,
two from Italy,
and one from the U.K.,
now the bottom two entries
are perhaps unsurprising
the U.S. Mark 9 and Mark 10 torpedoes,
because they're also
World War I vintage torpedoes,
and pretty much the only reason
they're on this list
is because, well,
the U.S. was actually using them
in some of its older submarines,
certainly at the start
of their involvement in World War II,
but their geriatric-era design
means that unsurprisingly
they have very small torpedo warheads
for a 21-inch torpedo,
395 pounds and 485 pounds,
respectively,
although the World War II-era
Mark 9s and Mark 10s
were known to have
Torpex warheads installed,
which does push their
TNT equivalent charge up considerably,
but they,
unlike almost every torpedo
in this category,
don't have a slow speed setting,
which marks them down,
and their top speed
isn't really much to write home about either,
34.5 and 36 knots,
respectively,
that's pretty much,
well, the lowest
and second lowest entries,
and their range is also quite bad,
5.5 thousand yards for the Mark 9,
which is the slower of the two,
and just 3.5 thousand yards,
although there is one
that's slightly worse than that
further on,
for the Mark 10.
Now, again,
with these longer distances,
you might argue,
especially in a sub-launched torpedo,
which these are,
that perhaps it doesn't matter so much,
because most submarines
didn't really launch
torpedo attacks on targets
from outside of maybe
1,000, 1,500 yards,
but some of them were
launched beyond that,
and of course,
your range to target
versus your range to torpedo travels
can be different,
because you might be,
let's say,
1,000 yards from your target,
but if your target is moving,
then your torpedo
might have to go considerably further
than 1,000 yards,
at which point,
especially a 3.5 thousand yard range
might begin to be a bit problematic,
but anyway,
that's why they're at the bottom.
Then we have the Italian
SI-270I torpedo,
which has,
for this entry category
at 595 pounds of TNT,
a pretty small warhead.
It does have a slow
and fast speed setting,
but the range is
joint bottom at 3,300 yards,
although it gets there at 42 knots,
and it's also got
a not particularly impressive
slow speed setting,
toodling along at just 26 knots.
Just above it is the Italian
W-270F torpedo,
which has a fractionally
smaller warhead,
but is just a little bit faster
on its slow speed setting
and not faster on its
high speed setting,
so just edging out
its compatriot there,
and then the top of the bottom,
as it were,
is the British Mark 7 torpedo,
a surface launch weapon
introduced in the mid-1920s,
so perhaps unsurprising
why it's all the way down here.
It has quite the chunky
740 pound warhead,
which,
given everything else
we've heard about so far,
for the most part,
sounds pretty impressive,
although it's only about
mid-range for these torpedoes,
the 21 inches,
but it's only going at 35 knots,
and it's going 5,700 yards,
so not particularly quick
and not particularly far
for this set of entries.
So that's your bottom five,
and then we've got
the Soviet 53-27,
then the U.S. Mark 8,
another old torpedo
from World War I,
the early model
of the U.S. Mark 14,
which mainly is down in this area
because of its 507 pound TNT warhead,
which isn't particularly brilliant.
I mean,
the other statistics
also aren't fantastic.
It's got a decent fast speed,
but not a particularly brilliant range.
Then early models
of the British Mark 8 torpedo,
which is a 1927 vintage weapon,
the Soviet 53-36,
the first models of U.S. Mark 15,
so the Mod 0,
so that's their main destroyer
launched torpedo
of the Second World War,
then the French 24V and 24M,
they're again mid-1920s torpedoes.
The fact that in both
the 18-inch air-dropped category
and this 21-inch
sub- and surface-launched category,
the French mid-20s torpedoes
are...
OK,
they're not top podium
or even in the top half,
but they're maybe
the top of the bottom third
makes it quite interesting
to see what could have happened
if the French had introduced
modern torpedoes during the war,
but of course,
they were knocked out early on.
In any case,
we then get the Soviet 53-38 model,
the Italian Si-270M,
the U.S. Mark 11,
the U.S. Mark 12,
the British Mark 10 Star,
the Italian W-256.5,
another Italian,
the W-270 Veloce,
the Italian W-256.72,
then the American Mark 14 Mod 3,
the Japanese Type 89,
the German G7AT-1,
the Soviet 53-38U,
then the British Mark 9 torpedo,
and now we're starting to get up
towards the higher end of things,
the Soviet 53-37,
the U.S. Mark...
sorry,
U.K. Mark 9 Star,
the French 23D-23DT,
which just edges out
on a top six position.
It's in seventh,
even though it's a 1925-era torpedo.
It's not got the world's
most impressive warhead
at 683 pounds of TNT,
but it can go a surprisingly long
14,200 yards at 35 knots
on its slow speed setting,
and a creditable 9,840 yards
at 39 knots at its higher speed setting.
39 knots at fast speed
is not really all that much
to write home about,
but that's a fairly long distance
for it to go.
And then we're into our top six.
At the sixth place position
is the U.S. Mark 15 Mod 3,
so the more advanced version
of its surface-to-launch torpedo.
Now that mainly gets in
because of a truly ridiculous
warhead size,
and you'll notice
all of the subsequent torpedoes
have very, very large warheads.
In this case,
it's because it's 823 pounds of torpex,
so just over 1,200 pounds TNT equivalent,
which is one heck of a boom
if it hits you.
Now, to be fair,
it's got a fairly high
surface-running speed of 45 knots
at fast setting,
but its range is actually pretty bad
at 4,500 yards.
It's one of the lowest ranges,
which is why it's just out of top five.
So our top five positions
for surface- and sub-launch torpedoes
are taken by, surprisingly,
because the Germans are way, way back,
in fifth place,
the British Mark 8 Star,
which is essentially
almost the same torpedo
as the one that would take out
the Belgrano in 1982.
Compared to early iterations
of the Mark 8,
it's now rocking a torpex warhead,
which gives it just over 1,200 pounds
of TNT equivalent
on an 805-pound base charge.
Its slow speed setting is 41 knots,
which is the second highest speed
for the slow speed setting
of any torpedo in this category,
although it only goes about 7,000 yards doing so,
and it has a high speed setting
of 45.5 knots going 5,000 yards,
so, again, not going particularly far,
but doing it at a fair old clip,
and this is, as I said,
a sub-launched weapon.
Above that is the British Mark 9 Double Star,
so this is in fourth place,
again introduced during the war
with a torpex warhead
exactly the same size as the Mark 8s.
It has a slower speed setting,
or a slower, slower speed setting,
I should say,
only going at 35 knots,
which isn't particularly much
to write home about.
It's mid-tier,
but it's slow speed speed,
but it goes 15,000 yards,
which is quite good,
and perhaps more surprisingly,
it can go 11,000 yards at 41 knots,
which is its high speed setting,
so its high speed top speed,
again, is mid-tier,
but it has the longest range capability
of all of these 21-inch torpedoes,
which is why it's earned itself
its number four spot.
The top three
is a full podium occupation
by the Japanese,
perhaps unsurprisingly,
you probably saw that one coming.
The first entry,
or number three entry,
is the Type 96 torpedo,
and this is on the podium
partially because of
its absolutely ridiculous warhead.
It's got a 1,213-pound warhead base,
which makes it the joint
largest torpedo charge
just by sheer weight of explosive,
and with a Type 97 explosive in there,
that means it's just shy of
1,300 pounds of TNT equivalent,
so that means everything in the top six
is going to blow through
any torpedo defense that you have.
Interestingly enough,
it's a very rare example
of a 21-inch torpedo
that doesn't seem to have
a slow speed setting,
it just has an insanely fast setting
of 49 knots at 4,900 yards,
so not a particularly long range
submarine launch torpedo,
but more than capable of crossing
almost all submarine engagement distances
and going at an absolute clip
while it's doing so.
It also uses oxygen
as opposed to compressed air.
Second place is the Type 95 Mod 2,
a late war introduction by the Japanese,
which interestingly enough
is picked to the podium post,
the top post in first place,
by its immediate predecessor,
the Type 95 Mod 1,
which is six years older.
Now you might think that's a bit odd,
and when you initially look
at the warhead sizes,
you're even more odd
because the Mod 2 carries
the same 1,213-pound warhead
as the Type 96,
which is just short
1,300 pounds of TNT equivalent,
whereas the Mod 1 is a mere
893 pounds or 955 pounds
of TNT equivalent,
and they both have the same
speed setting for low speed,
which is 46 knots,
but because of that
extra explosive weight,
the Type 95 Mod 1
is considerably longer range
than the more heavily
explosively laden Mod 2,
capable of going 13,100 yards
compared to the 8,200 yards
of the Mod 2,
and they're both capable
of 50 knots or potentially more
at top speed,
but again,
thanks to carrying
a slightly smaller warhead,
the Mod 1 can go
almost 10,000 yards,
the Mod 2 can only go 6,000 yards.
So from a purely objective perspective,
while 955 pound TNT equivalent
is still going to blow through
practically anything it comes across,
but the Mod 1 can go considerably further.
Of course the Mod 2
is going to do more damage,
but both being
sub-launch torpedoes,
there's a potential
for very long range shots
not getting there.
And that wraps up
all of the torpedo comparisons,
although you might already
be furiously typing
at your keyboards,
as we said earlier
with these sub-launch torpedoes,
that well,
does it really make a difference?
6,000 versus almost
10,000 yard launch range,
how many World War II submarines
actually launched attacks
at 4, 5, 6,000 yards
for this to actually
make any kind of difference?
But as I said
at the beginning of the video,
this is one of the issues
with looking at a purely
technical analysis
of which torpedo
can go the furthest,
the fastest,
carries the most explosives,
et cetera, et cetera.
It's entirely possible
to argue, and indeed, obviously,
because the Japanese
introduced it as a Mod 2,
they presumably did believe
that the Mod 2 was superior,
being happy to sacrifice
the range at the top end,
or just hitting
with considering more boom.
But, as I said at the beginning,
if you'd like to suggest
modifiers and additional
things that could be added in
that can be measured objectively
or perhaps you think
less weighting
should be given to range
or something like that,
again, chime in below.
As I said,
the data sheets are available
on the website
trickandfall.co.uk
link in the video description below,
so you can play around
with them if you want
and come up with
your own rating systems.
I'd be very interested
to see them.
But, well, there you go.
That's it for this video.
Thanks for watching.
If you have a comment
or suggestion for a ship to review,
let us know in the comments below.
Don't forget to comment
on the pinned post
for dry-doc questions.
