德拉克講海軍歷史 【戰列艦迭代雜談】- 如何合理的對主力艦進行分類
王者风范
22粉絲
7 次觀看·2025年11月21日
大家好,歡迎來到這部影片,是由Squarespace贊助的
今天我會很輕鬆地向大家分享一些資訊,透過我的博客
我已經在網站上設定了博客
希望大家會聽到這部影片,關於戰鬥船的發展
也希望你們已經聽過關於世界大戰的兩艘飛彈
我們可以在這裡輸入各種資訊
但現在我只會把戰鬥船的文字放在這裡
然後我會輸入另一個文字格式
這個格式會讓你下載戰鬥船各種類型的文字格式
或至少大部分的文字格式
所以你只需要輸入文字格式就能看到
你可以輸入一個URL連結
或者很輕鬆地輸入文件
這裡有一個文件,是一份excel文件,以防你會疑問
然後輸入戰鬥船文字格式
我會輸入一些文件來連結
然後我會決定,等一下
我連結完之後,我認為文件不太合適
所以我會放一個spacer進去
然後我會選擇image it
你可以做到後來,如果你想要在博客中間的部分
所以現在完成了
你現在可以在網站上下載文件
所以如果我做了這麼多小小的教學
你認為你能建立一個網站
可能是為了航空歷史的原因
但你永遠不會知道
你可能會想建立
因為其他原因
那麼你可以前往squarespace.com.com
你可以獲得免費的試驗
然後當你準備好
那個小連結會給你10%
你的第一個網站或頁面
所以再次感謝Squarespace贊助這個視頻
接下來是主題
對,所以
關於戰鬥船
至少從早期1890年代開始
你會經常聽到船
分成四個廣泛的類別
免費戰鬥船
戰鬥船
超級戰鬥船
和快速戰鬥船
現在這是一個有用的短時間
對於近期的時間
主要是感謝華盛頓海軍協議
但是它可以
並且導致
幾個灰色的區域
和一些不合理的比較
在某些情況下
在這個系統下
華盛頓海軍協議
和華盛頓海軍協議
基本上都是超級戰鬥船
如華盛頓海軍協議
和華盛頓海軍協議
但是很明顯
在這兩個組別之間
存在著一種不合理的差異
同樣地
1930年代復古的
國王喬治五世
華盛頓海軍協議
和亞馬達
都存在著相同的區域
同時
也存在著不合理的
不合理的航母
但是
具有嚴肅的設計
而在某些情況下
至少是雙重設計
所以
例如
1920年代的南達科特
在哪裏
它不是一個快速的戰鬥船
它絕對不是
任何想像中的快速
這實際上
會使它在
目前的系統下
變成超級戰鬥船
但是
對於那件事的對比
對於德州和俄亥俄羅斯來說
更加愚蠢
那對比
對於科羅拉多和尼爾森來說
但是
我們必須承認
這些都是超級戰鬥船
存在著
灰色的區域
在某種類型
開始變成另一種
也讓我們遇到
一些人
使用了
半戰鬥船
或是一小堆戰鬥船
實際上
它們實在太強大
才能與主要的
戰鬥船組成
但是
它們也明顯地
低於
幾乎任何戰鬥船
所以
在回想了
這件事
一段時間後
我開始設計了
我自己的
比較粗糙的
系統
在我腦裏
你可能聽過我
在之前的視頻中
這個系統
使用了
總共有七個
類型
其中五個
分成
第一
和第二代
的
類型
讓你得到
12個
我認為
這些
分成了
主要是
戰鬥船和
後來的
更多的類型
但是我覺得
它們的組合
比
總體的
能力
和時間
更好
所以在這個系統下
如果你想到
一艘戰鬥船
系統
你可以很容易地
放在
近代船
和船
有相似的
能力
而不是
像N-3
那樣
對抗
Britannia
因此
我會
為你介紹
DRAX
12點
戰鬥船
系統
是
第一代
預設
第二代
預設
半預設
第一代
預設
第二代
預設
第一代
預設
第二代
預設
我稱之為
第一代
和第二代
華盛頓
戰鬥船
雖然你可以稱之為
後世紀一戰
戰鬥船
或類似的
主要是因為
巨大
或超級
戰鬥船
看起來有點傻
這接著
是一對
不包括
第一代和第二代
的
協議戰鬥船
和
協議
期間
戰鬥船
雖然
我可以建議
一對
不包括
協議戰鬥船
跟
我們上一代
的
協議
期間
戰鬥船
你會很高興知道
每個範疇
被定義為
一系列的
資格
雖然
這些資格
會越來越簡單
隨著時間
所以
我們來
一步一步
看一些
每一代
的課程
例子
然後
你可以告訴我
你同意
或者
你
稍微不同意
什麼
特定的課程
你可能
改變
每一代
老實說
某程度上
更廣泛的
課程
在
前代
大致是
戰鬥船
的數量
需要
分類
在那段時間
無論如何
第一代
戰鬥船
應該有
鋼彈
或者
哈維
或
普通的
鋼鐵
一個高度
免費船
相對於
前代
鋼彈
或
基礎
鋼彈
船
一般來說
他們會
持有
30-35
尺寸的
雖然
我使用
一般來說
可能有
一或
兩種
例外
一般來說
他們
會有
四個主槍
一般來說
他們會有
雙槍
一前一後
但當然
有些宗教
例如
法國
可能有
其他種類
主槍
尺寸
應該是
11尺
或以上
除非
他們
具有
第二級
或
其他
低級
戰鬥船
所以
皇帝軍
就是
皇帝軍
和
一般來說
他們
會有
四個主槍
雙槍
一前一後
但當然
一或
兩種
例外
他們
主槍
尺寸
應該是
11尺
或
以上
這意味著
第二級
戰鬥船
應該有
南美大陸
大陸
美國
銀河
在
美國
在
Andrei Pervozhani Classes, or Isingals, or the Russians
And Asahi, Mikasa, and Kotori Types, or the Japanese
You'll be glad to know the lists get a lot shorter after this period
You then move on to Semi-Dreadnoughts
These should have a large number, 8 or more, of secondary guns of 8-inch caliber or greater
There should be no further secondary armament that has a primary doctrinal role for engaging capital ships
i.e. below this they should have only anti-torpedo weapons
And their main gun caliber, of course, is still 11 inches or above
So this results in the three most common suspects for being Semi-Dreadnoughts
The Lord Nelson Class, the Danton Class, and the Satsuma Class
But also covers the Austro-Hungarian Radzecki Class and the Italian Regina Elina Class
Largely on the basis of that impressive secondary battery
Then we move on to First Generation Dreadnoughts
These should have a main gun caliber of 11 or 12 inches
With 8 to 10 main guns, which can be fired in either an 8 or 10 gun broadside
Their secondary battery should be primarily designed for anti-torpedo boat work
They may or may not have wing or N-echelon turrets
And they can utilize either turbine or vertical triple expansion engine propulsion
So this would give you Dreadnought, St. Vincent, Bellerophon, Neptune, and Colossus
So yes, the entire 12-inch lineup of the Royal Navy falls under First Generation
South Carolina, Florida, and Delaware in the U.S.
The Corbets for the French
The Espanyas for the Spanish
The Minas Gerais for the Brazilians
The Kuwaches for the Japanese
Nassau, Helgoland, Kaiser, and Koenig for the Germans
A Second Generation Dreadnought would have a main gun caliber of 12 inches
Should have at least 12 main guns
And should be able to fire those in a full broadside
Which means they should either have no wing or N-echelon mounts
Or if they do have N-echelon mounts
These should be able to fire over quite a broad arc
Rather than the very limited arc or typical of the type
And generally speaking, they should have turbine propulsion
Although one or two exceptions might be made
So Second Generation Dreadnoughts would be the Wyoming class for the Americans
The Dante Alighieri, Cavour, and Duilio classes for the Italians
The Gangut and its derivative designs for the Russians
The Taggarthof in Austria-Hungary
And the Rivadavia and Agincourt
Obviously Rivadavia being a class and Agincourt being a solo ship
Or the Argentinians and Agincourt
Through its various ownerships but eventually ending up in the Royal Navy
That brings us on to First Generation Super Dreadnoughts
This is a fairly simple one
They should have a main gun caliber that's somewhere between 13 and 14 inches
And they should have 8 to 10 main guns
This gives us a list of the Orions
The WWI-era King George V and the Iron Dukes for the British
The New York class for the Americans
As well as the Nevadas
The Britannias for the French
Almarante le Torre for the Chileans
Erin for the British
Although technically was originally supposed to be Turkish
And in terms of uncompleted designs
The Erzatz Monarch class for the Austro-Hungarians
Second Generation Super Dreadnoughts
Look for main guns with a caliber of 13 to 15 inches
But if you have a 14 inch or under armament
You should have at least 12 guns
Or if you've got a 15 inch armament
Then of course you can go with 8
So this would mean that
There would be the Queen Elizabeth and Revenge class
Is in this category for the British
The Fusos and Ises for the Japanese
The Pennsylvania's, New Mexico's and Tennessee's
For the Americans
The Barden or Bayern class for the Germans
And in terms of uncompleted but partially built designs
The Francesco Caracciolo and Normandy classes
For the Italians and French respectively
Would also fall into this category
Then we have what I've tentatively labeled
First Generation Washington Battleships
Although as I say that is a term
A title that's open to change of terminology
With a categorization of having 16 inch guns
And having 8 or 9 of those guns
With a displacement up to around 35,000 tons
So in this category
You essentially have 3 ships or 3 classes
The Colorado's, Nagato's and Nelson's
Then we move into second generation
Washington era battleships
These have either 16 or 18 inch guns
If they have 16 inch guns
They should have at least 10 of them
And if they have 18 inch guns
They should have at least 8 of them
And of course their displacement
Is going to be over 35,000 tons
This is the only category where
None of them were actually ever completed
So it would include the 1920's version
Of the South Dakota class
The N3 for the British
Obviously the South Dakotas are American
The TOSAT key and number 13 classes
For the Japanese
And yes this does technically mean
We've left the Leon class of the French Navy
Without a specific classification
I suppose you could maybe stick it into
Second gen super dreadnoughts
But it's a real mess of a design anyway
And then we move forward
Almost a decade and a half
To the start of the treaty battleship era
These should have a speed of 27 knots or greater
A standard displacement
Of around about 35,000 tons or less
Generally speaking
They should be armed with 14 to 16 inch guns
Although a few smaller calibers
Can also be accepted
And of course they would be built
Under the Washington Naval Treaty
And expanded London Naval Treaty restrictions
So this would include
The King George V 1930's edition
The North Carolinas
The 1930's South Dakotas
The French Richelieu and Dunkirk classes
And if you want
You could probably include
The Scharnhorsts as well
Then you have a very small categorization
Of treaty period battleships
Which are battleships built
During the period of the
Washington and London Naval Treaty restrictions
But that have a displacement
Significantly in excess of 35,000 tons
But also where the powers in question
Tried to pretend that those ships
Were roughly adhering to the 35,000 ton limit
And this only has actually two entries
That were actually built
The Bismarck class and the Littorio class
Although there are quite a number
Of other design studies
Which would also fall into this categorization
And then we have our final class
The post-treaty battleships
Which would be ships built
Or potentially planned
Without the 35,000 ton limit in mind
Either through escalator clauses
Or flat out ignoring the treaties
Or potentially not even being part of them
In the first place
And quite specifically also
Not claiming to adhere
To the displacement limit as well
So this would include
The Iowas, the Yamato's, HMS Vanguard
And then in terms of ships
That were not completed
The Lion class, the Montana class
The Super Yamato class, the H-39's
The Alsace class
And the Sovetsky Soyuz class
So that's my proposal
If you can think of
A slightly better set of names
For first and second generation
Washington era battleships
Or a better pair for
Treaty and treaty period battleships
Let me know
If you think a slightly different
Classification system should be used
Again let me know
If you'd like to add or delete points
From each of those bullet points
For each section
Again comments below
Or if you think one or more battleship classes
Should be moved around
Within the classifications
That I just gave
Again let us know
I'd like to hear what your thoughts are
On this particular issue
And as per the beginning
If you want to look over
All of those classification systems
Without having to listen back
To the video again and again
There is now an article on my website
Where you can read everything at your leisure
