ONLY ONE CAN BE TRUE: Opposing Histories of the Israel Palestine Conflict – with Rabbi Michael Skobac
In this lecture Rabbi Michael Skobac explores the complex and often conflicting Israeli and Palestinian narratives, offering a clear, fact-based defense of Israel’s perspective
His discussion uncovers the roots of the Israel Palestine conflict, challenges anti-Israel biases, and reveals why Israel’s cause is just and defensible.
You will learn evidence-based arguments to counter widespread misinformation to dismantle common myths that highlights Israel’s legitimate claims to statehood and security.
The major issue at the heart of the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, between Israel and the Palestinians, is whether the Jewish people have any right to have an independent state in the Land of Israel or whether they are illegally occupying the land that belongs to the Palestinians.
In this lecture, Rabbi Michael Skobac explores the three critical foundations upon which the legitimacy of the State of Israel’s claim to be the rightful owner of the Holy Land rests, which include: • The evidence from the Bible and Quran • The historical connection of the Jewish people to the land • The proof of International Law over the last century
In this four-part lecture, Rabbi Michael Skobac refutes the lies about Israel and Zionism in these sessions:
3. ONLY ONE CAN BE TRUE: Conflicting Narratives in the Israel-Palestine Conflict
4. THE TRUTH BEHIND THE LIES ABOUT ISRAEL: From Apartheid to Genocide
Since Hamas’ barbaric Oct 7 murderous attack, murdering, raping and burning alive over 1,200 Israelis, taking 250 hostage and Israel’s ensuing invasion of Gaza, the Jewish state has faced an international onslaught aimed at painting Israel as the “real” villain in this conflict.
An unprecedented wave of antisemitism was unleashed worldwide, with enemies of Israel and Zionism using their current platform to denigrate and delegitimize Israel. ,
Many Diaspora Jews cannot respond to the above depicted accusations. This 4-part seminar provides the essential knowledge to separate fact from fiction, dismantle the lies and proudly proclaim “This Land Is Mine. G-d Gave This Land To Me.”
In this series, Rabbi Skobac discusses: a). ISRAEL’S RIGHTFUL PLACE: Refuting the Claim that Israel was Created Illegitimately b). ISRAEL’S DEFENSE REALITIES: The Truth about Israel’s Security Measures c). THE QUEST FOR PEACE: Who Really Stands in the Way? d). ANTI-ISRAEL PROPAGANDA: Dismantling the Lies in Media and Politics
Since 1989, JEWS FOR JUDAISM is has been a trailblazer in global Jewish outreach.
Jews for Judaism wins back to Judaism those Jews who have been influenced by these “Seven Threats to Jewish Survival”:
• Evangelical Christian Missionaries convert 1,000’s of Jews worldwide annually • Destructive Cults induce Jews to abandon family, friends and careers • Eastern Religions are now the spiritual choices for many Jews • Jewish Apathy and Ignorance cause many Jews to assimilate, abandoning Judaism • Intermarriage is exploding at a 75% rate in many locales • Anti-Israel propaganda and lies brainwash millions globally and deter Jewish support for Israel • Antisemitism is promoting global Jew-Hatred and alienating Jews from Judaism
JEWS FOR JUDAISM strengthens preserves and saves Jewish lives through its worldwide Internet outreach, social media, free educational programs, educational literature and counselling services that connect Jewish people to the spiritual depth, beauty and wisdom of Judaism.
To help non-Jews discover the Torah’s path to G-d, Jews for Judaism provides educational programs to help them embrace the Torah’s Seven Noahide Laws for Gentiles.
JEWS FOR JUDAISM keeps Jews Jewish and saves Jewish lives, like Mel and Leah:
“Thank you for your clear messages with such strong arguments. They leave no doubt Jesus is definitely not the Jewish Messiah. Without your lectures, we might still be in a church. We’re so glad Jews for Judaism exists and helped us return.” – Mel & Leah Y.
[Music]
There's a very well-known passage in the
Talmud from tractate Shabbat 31a
where a non-Jew comes before the sage
Shamai and says to him, "Convert me to
Judaism
on the condition that you teach me the
entire Torah while I'm standing on one
foot.
Shami has almost no patience for this
fellow and pushes him away with his
builder's measuring rod that he was
holding in his hand.
The same person comes before the
rabbitic sage Hillel
and he Hillel took him up on the
challenge
and said, "You want me to convert you to
Judaism on condition that I teach you
the entire entire Torah while you're
standing on one foot?"
Well, here goes. Hill says to him, "That
which is hateful to you, do not do to
another person.
If something bugs you, if something
annoys you, if something bothers you,
don't do it to someone else." And Hill
says that's the entire Torah.
The rest the rest of the Torah is
commentary.
Now, you have to go and study it.
So we see from this story
that explaining the core of Judaism
is not that complicated.
At least according to Ill,
it is really quite simple.
At the same time,
it's not really that simple. And so
Hillel tells this would be convert that
there's a lot more that needs to be
studied after you've gotten the short
elevator pitch presentation.
The truth is that there are many things
in life that are both simple and
complex.
Understanding God
is not that complicated.
When we think about the creator
and supervisor
of everything that exists,
our simple understanding of God is very
accessible.
Of course, we can enter into
infinite complexity
when thinking about God. The most
profound cabalistic teachings insist
that our minds
are not capable of grasping God at all.
The same dichotomy is true about our
topic for tonight. Understanding the
basic narratives of Israel and the
Palestinian Arabs is not that
complicated.
But when you get into the weeds,
the issues and interpretation of history
is a bit more complex.
Because of our limited time for this
presentation,
we're not going to attempt
to wind our way through all of the
complications.
I'm going to keep things fairly simple.
And if the topic interests you,
you need to study it more in depth.
My plan for tonight is to begin with a
very brief synopsis
of the Palestinian narrative.
Following that, I will trace a more
comprehensive outline of the issues from
an Israeli perspective that will address
the main points of the Palestinian
narrative.
As we move along,
I asked Chhat GPT
to generate a statement of the
Palestinian narrative which I'll now
share with you.
The Palestinian narrative centers on
their historical presence in the region,
particularly during the Ottoman Empire
and the British mandate.
Palestinians view themselves as the
indigenous inhabitants of the land whose
ancestral connections
span centuries.
They contend that the establishment of
Israel in 1948
led to the Nakba,
the Arabic word for catastrophe,
during which hundreds of thousands of
Palestinians were displaced,
their villages destroyed, and their land
confiscated.
From the Palestinian perspective,
the 1947
plan,
the partition plan of the United Nations
was unjust as it allocated a significant
portion of the land to a Jewish minority
at the expense of the Arab majority.
Now, I believe that we can propose that
the Israeli narrative
rests upon two points that are really
one.
First, Israel's right to have a country
in their ancestral homeland is rooted in
at least three anchors, as we discussed
last week.
And despite Israel's extremely strong
case,
the Palestinian Arabs
and initially all the neighboring Arab
states
refused to accept an independent Jewish
state on any land.
This strident rejectionism
has been the essential cause of the
conflict in the Middle East since the
very beginning.
I'll just share one quote to illustrate
this.
Zuhair Musheen, who was on the executive
council of the Palestinian Liberation
Organization,
explained in a newspaper interview that
quote, "The creation of a Palestinian
state is only a means
for continuing our struggle against the
state of Israel, for our Arab unity. In
reality today, there is no difference
between Jordanians, Palestinians,
Syrians or Lebanese.
Only for political and tactical reasons
do we speak about the existence of a
Palestinian people. Since Arab national
interests demand that we posit the
existence of a distinct Palestinian
people in order for us to oppose
Zionism.
Now it's important to understand that
one of the reasons for this entrangence
according to Islamic law
is that land conquered by Muslims
becomes eternally Islamic land
and any occupation
of such land by non-Muslims is
considered illegal by Sharia law and
requires that Muslims must fight until
they're able to regain control over
these lands.
This is the meaning of the chant, from
the river to the sea, Palestine will be
free.
They don't only envision liberating the
West Bank and expelling the Jews living
there.
This chant refers to literally every
inch of the land of Israel. They don't
accept a Jewish state on any part of the
land.
If all of Israel was to squeeze itself
into someone's mansion, and that was the
entire state of Israel, it would still
not be accepted.
Now, the Palestinian narrative implies
that prior to the largecale return of
the Jews to the area that began in
around the year 1880,
there was a large thriving Palestinian
Arab community living there that were
eventually thrown out.
I want to repeat that the Palestinian
narrative implies that prior to the
large scale return of Jews to the area
in the 1880s,
there was a large thriving Palestinian
Arab community living there
that were eventually thrown out.
And this is a serious distortion of
history.
There are three things that we need to
bear in mind.
Number one,
as we documented last week,
there was already a sizable Jewish
population
living in numerous communities
throughout the land of Israel for many
centuries.
Number two, as I will soon describe,
travelers to the area, travelers to
Palestine for about 300 years prior to
the Jewish immigration that began in the
year 1880.
Those travelers report that to a great
extent,
the land of Palestine was largely
desolate and depopulated.
And number three,
the people living in the land came from
many different ethnic groups.
Many Greeks who fled Muslim rule in
their country came to live in Palestine.
A Christian historian writing in the
19th century reported that there are
villages throughout Palestine populated
entirely by settlers from other parts of
the Turkish Ottoman Empire including
Bosnians, Drews, Caucasians and
Egyptians.
The 1911 edition of the Encyclopedia
Britannica
has an ent has an entry by Oxford
scholar Robert Mallister describing the
population of Palestine as comprising
widely different ethnological groups
speaking no less than 50 different
languages.
The actual population of Arabs living in
Palestine when Jewish immigration began
in 1880
was actually quite small.
In 1857,
the British consul in Jerusalem, James
Finn, reported that the country is to a
considerable degree empty of inhabitants
and its greatest need is a body of
population.
Other historians and travelers at the
time describe the Arab population as
decreasing
in the area. In 1847, Admiral Lynch from
the United States Navy reported that the
population of Jaffa was about 13,000
people. He said this included 8,000
Turks,
2,000 Greeks, 2,000 Armenians,
700 Marinites, 300 Jews, but no Arabs at
all.
Mark Twain visited the Holy Land
and described what he saw in the year
1869.
He writes that Palestine sits in
sackcloth and ashes. Nazareth is
forlorn.
Palestine is desolate. In the valley of
Jezrael, there is not a solitary village
for 30 miles in either direction.
There are two or three clusters of
bedawin tents but not a single permanent
habitation. The Sea of Galilee and its
surrounding areas are no less desolate
of the Galilee. Mark Twain wrote that
there is a desolation here that not even
the imagination can grace. We never saw
a human being on the whole route that we
took.
Twain's observations were not unique.
For several hundred years prior to the
beginning of serious Jewish immigration
in 1880,
numerous biblical scholars,
archaeologists, ctographers, diplomats,
writers, and surveyors visited and
toured the Holy Land.
They produced detailed records of what
they saw in books, in travel logs, and
in periodicals.
Without exception,
they presented accounts of the
demographic
and physical condition of the country
totally at odds with the narrative
repeated by Arab leaders today.
In 1785,
Constantine Vuln described the ruined
and desolate state of the country. In
1843,
Alexander Keith wrote that since Vuln's
day, the conditions have only grown
worse, and the land had not yet reached
its last degree of desolation and
depopulation.
French poet Alance Damat Damatin wrote
that outside the gates of Jerusalem we
saw indeed no living object and heard no
living sound. We found the same void,
the same silence
that reigns in towns and highways in the
entire country.
The plane of Chaon, the Jews who came
later in 1880
cultivated
was described by Reverend Samuel Manning
in 1874
as a land without inhabitants that might
support an immense population.
14 years after Mark Twain, the imminent
English cgrapher Arthur Stanley wrote
about Judea that it was hardly an
exaggeration
to say that for miles and miles there
was no appearance of life or habitation.
We see from these and many similar
accounts
according to noted professor of law Alan
Dersuitz
that the myth of a stable and settled
Palestinian Arab Muslim population that
had lived in villages and worked the
land for centuries
only to be displaced by Zionist invaders
is simply inconsistent
with the recorded demographic data. And
yet this myth has been promoted for
decades and its promotion has not
abated.
Relying on the well-known propaganda
technique of repeating the big lie
relentlessly
has paid off because it's been swallowed
uncritically
by so much of the Western world. In
1974,
PLO leader Yaser Arafat declared to the
UN that quote, "The Jewish invasion
began in 1881.
Palestine was then a verdant area
inhabited mainly by Arab people in the
course of building its life and
dynamically enriching its indigenous
culture.
However,
a much more realistic
and stunningly accurate assessment
was provided by Sir John William Dawson
in 1888 when he said, and when I read
this quote, I got chills.
He said, "No nation has been able to
establish itself as a nation in
Palestine up until this day. No national
union and no national spirit has
prevailed there. The mly impoverished
tribes which have occupied it have held
it as mere tenants, temporary land
owners, evidently waiting
for those entitled to the permanent
possession of the soil.
Now, this incredible statement echoes
exactly what the Torah and its Midrashic
interpreters wrote centuries earlier
about the land of Israel. Leviticus
chapter 26 describes how the Jewish
people will be exiled from their land if
they violate their covenant with God.
Verse 32 in that chapter says, "I will
make the land desolate
so that your enemies who settle in it
shall be appalled by it."
This curse
according to our sages contains a hidden
blessing
that during the years of national exile.
The land of Israel will not yield its
produce to others
and this will ensure that no other
nation will be able to establish itself
on the promised land.
Of course, our prophets forecast that
one day God would return his people to
their land.
And this promise is repeated numerous
times in the Hebrew scriptures.
And one of the things that the prophets
say about this time when the people
return to their land is that once again
when the people of Israel return to
their ancestral homeland,
the land will begin to yield its fruit.
For example, in chapter 35 of Isaiah
verse 1, the prophet says, "The
wilderness and the wasteland will
rejoice over them. The desert will be
glad and blossom like a lily."
And this is again repeated numerous
times where the Tanakh, the prophets of
our Bible teach us that when Israel
returns to the land after their exile,
now the land will begin to produce to
yield its fruit.
as opposed to what the Bible says about
what will be in the land of Israel when
Israel is not there. When we've been
exiled,
the land will refuse to produce to yield
its fruit to the occupiers of the land
of Israel.
And this is exactly what happened. As we
all know, the agricultural
accomplishments of the Jewish people who
returned to their ancestral homeland
have been legendary, literally getting
deserts to bloom.
what Israel has produced in all areas of
science, of medicine, of business,
technology, agriculture, high-tech and
more is the stuff of dreams and the envy
of the entire world.
Consider the fact that in the 12
centuries
in the 12 centuries of the Arab presence
in Palestine
before the return of the Jewish people
in modern times, the Arabs built only a
single new town in 12 centuries, the
town of Raml.
So in 1891,
Sir Sir George Adam Smith, author of the
historical geography of the Holy Land,
wrote, quote, "There is no indigenous
civilization in Palestine that could
take the place
of the Turkish
except that of the Jews, who have given
to Palestine anything it ever add a
value to the world.
Significantly,
the Jewish return to their homeland in
the final decades of the 19th century
didn't drive Arabs out or diminish their
numbers. Quite the opposite.
Waves of Zionist immigration to
Palestine had a major impact on the
country. The Jews built roads, towns,
farms, hospitals, factories, and
schools. And this development caused a
rapid a rapid growth of the Arab
population.
Many Arabs began to immigrate to
Palestine because of job opportunities
and the better quality of life
available now because of the growing
economy and infrastructure created by
the Jews. In 1939, President Franklin
Delanor Roosevelt observed that Arab
immigration into Palestine since 1921
has vastly exceeded Jewish immigration
during this period.
In 1938,
historian William Ze wrote that at the
very beginning of the 20th century,
there were about 40,000 Jews living in
Palestine and about 140,000 others.
Immigration
prior to the arrival of the Jewish
people was non-existent. No one was
moving to Palestine.
But when the Zionists arrived and began
developing the land
and there was an introduction of
European standards of wages and life,
this acted like a magnet in the entire
Near East.
Abruptly,
Palestine became an Arab center of
attraction. By 1922,
after three decades of Jewish
development,
the numbers of Arabs living in Palestine
mushroomed to 488,000.
It is precisely
in the vicinity
of Jewish villages that Arab development
became most significant.
For example, Arab Hifa
profiting by the Zionist boom grew from
1922
to 1947
by 290%.
Jaffa grew by 158%
and Jerusalem the Arab population grew
by 131%.
The Arab rural set settlement in the Tel
Aviv district increased by over 135%.
A study of the Jewish settlement of
Rishon Lion, first established in 1882
by the Jewish immigrants, showed that
the 40 Jewish families that settled
there had attracted more than 400 Arab
families, many of which were Bedawin and
Egyptian.
These Arab families moved into areas
around the Jewish settlement and formed
a new Arab village there.
Another reason for the dramatic influx
of Arabs into Palestine
was the improved health care that came
with the presence of Jews. Infant
mortality
was reduced and life expectancy
increased as well. combating malaria
and improved water supply and water
sanitation
drew many Arabs to the area.
In fact, almost all of the people
calling themselves Palestinians today
are the descendants of these immigrants.
To summarize here,
based on census figures, official
reports, eyewitness accounts, and basic
math, it is beyond reasonable
dispute
that the myth of Jewish refugees
displacing
a large, stable, long-term Arab Muslim
population that had lived in Palestine
for centuries is clearly false.
There are many Arab leaders who
acknowledge that this claim is based
upon fantasy. Palestinian leader Musa
Alami acknowledged in 1948 that quote,
"The people are in great need of a myth
to fill their consciousness and
imagination."
King Abdullah of Jordan also admitted
that the story of the Jewish
displacement of Palestinians was
fictional, saying, quote, "The Arabs are
as prodigal in selling their land as
they are in weeping about it."
Now, let's consider now the second
element of the Palestinian narrative
that the establishment of Israel in 1948
led to the Akba, which saw hundreds of
thousands of Palestinians displaced,
their villages destroyed, and their
lands confiscated.
Last week, we learned that after the
First World War, one of the results was
that the Turkish Ottoman Empire, who was
on the losing side of the war, was
dispossessed of the land that they held
in the Middle East. The League of
Nations assigned these lands to France
and to Britain as mandates. They would
administer until new nations could be
established. The League of Nations
mandate for Palestine and the San Remo
Conference established the Balffor
Declaration as international law.
However,
in a sorted betrayal of their mandate
responsibilities,
Britain lapped off 77%
of the land that was supposed to be part
of the Jewish state and set up another
Arab state on the east side of the
Jordan River in 1921 that became the
Emirate of Trans Jordan.
Reluctantly,
Israel was willing to work with what was
left to them on the west side of the
Jordan River.
But the local Palestinian community
there begrudged them even that.
Haj Amin al- Husini
led the Palestinian Arabs for three
decades.
He violently refused to accept Britain's
intention to set up a Jewish state, even
of diminished size. And he incited
anti-Jewish riots in Jerusalem in the
1920s
where women and children were massacred.
He instigated many more riots throughout
the country and puggrums
in the 1920s and the 1930s including the
vicious massacre in Kevron in 1929 where
69 Jews were murdered.
Husini was ultimately deported by the
Britain, by the English,
but he quickly linked up with Adolf
Hitler in Germany where he led the Nazi
Arab office. He sought to implement
Hitler's final solution in the Middle
East. He became a co-founder of the Arab
League in 1944.
And when he spent time in Egypt, he
became a mentor to the PLO's Yaser
Arafat.
The British were not able to handle the
tensions that were growing in Palestine.
Israel was furious that they were
curtailing Jewish immigration to
Palestine, especially when the Jews of
Europe were in extreme danger because of
the rise of Nazism and Hitler. And
Israel was upset that England was
dragging their feet on the finalizing of
their statethood.
So with violence growing,
the British decided to pack up and
leave.
and placed the problem in the hands of
the United Nations.
On November 29th, 1947, the General
Assembly of the United Nations voted to
partition
Palestine and create two independent
states,
one Arab and one Jewish.
We should bear in mind that this was the
second partition
of Israel. The first again was when
Great Britain took 77%
of mandatory Palestine slated to become
the Jewish homeland and created Trans
Jordan.
So now when the UN proposed dividing the
remainder of the land,
the leadership of the Jewish community
welcomed the decision and expressing its
willingness to live side by side with an
independent Palestinian state. But the
Palestinian leadership rejected the UN
partition plan and two days later on
December 1st, 1947,
they took up arms against the Jewish
community.
For four months,
local Palestinian Arabs attacked and
ambushed outlying Jewish villages and
vehicles driven by Jews.
Hundreds of Jews were killed,
but Israel for four months did not
retaliate. They hoped that the
Palestinian Arabs would eventually
accept the UN partition plan.
But this didn't happen. And in April
1948, the Jewish community launched a
counter offensive. On May 14th,
1948, the Jews proclaimed
the independent state of Israel.
On the very next day, the armies of
Egypt, Trans Jordan, Syria, and Iraq
invaded Palestine.
Lebanon later joined the war.
Prior to this, Abdul Rahman Hassan Azam,
who was the secretary general of the
Arab League, warned prior to 1948
that if Israel established a state,
quote, he said, it would lead to a war
of extermination.
and he boasted that it would be a
momentous massacre which will be spoken
of like the Mongolian massacre and like
the Crusades.
We have to appreciate that not only was
Israel vastly outnumbered in 1948,
but their armed forces were extremely
primitive
and they had very little equipment
and many of the fighters were refugees
from Europe and survivors of the
Holocaust.
The war ended in 1949 and for Israel to
have not only survived
but to emerge victorious was nothing
short of miraculous.
When the hostilities ended, Egyptian and
Trans Jordanian forces controlled
the bulk of the territory designated for
a Palestinian Arab state by the UN
partition plan. Trans Jordan annexed
Judea and Samaria which became later
known as the West Bank of the Hasheite
Kingdom of Jordan and Egypt maintained
Gaza under military administration.
Both of these areas were recaptured by
Israel during the Six-Day War of 1967.
It is significant and worth bearing in
mind that for all of those years between
1949
and 1967
when Egypt controlled Gaza and Jordan
controlled the West Bank area, there was
no talk of establishing a Palestinian
state. The Arabs living there never saw
themselves and didn't see themselves at
that time as a distinct unique
Palestinian nation with a distinct
Palestinian national identity. They saw
themselves as they always had as pan
members of the Arab people.
They had no objection being ruled by
Egypt or Jordan
and they didn't clamor for independence.
And this brings us to speak about the
Nakba and the Arab refugee problem that
was precipitated by the fighting during
the war of 1947 to 1948.
We should state at the outset that if
the Palestinians
had accepted the UN partition plan in
1947,
a Palestinian state would have been
created side by side with Israel and
there would not have been a single
Palestinian refugee.
So, how can Israel be blamed for the
Palestinian refugee problem?
And the other immediate cause of the
refugee problem was the war of
extermination
launched by the Arab states against
Israel in 1948.
And if this war had not been taken
place, we wouldn't have the refugee
problem that we have today.
So once again, how can Israel be blamed
for the refugee problem?
What was the position of Israel
regarding the Arabs living within its
borders?
David Bengurian,
Israel's founding father, wrote in 1937
that quote, "We do not wish and do not
need to expel Arabs and take their
places. All of our aspirations
is built on the assumption proven
throughout all of our activity that
there is enough room in the country for
our ourselves and the Arabs. 10 years
later, despite much violence and
conflict, Bengurian's core beliefs about
living in peace with the Arabs had not
changed. In a speech on December 13th,
1947,
he said, quote, "In our state, there
will be Jews and non-Jews as well, and
all of them will be equal citizens,
equal in everything without exception."
Tragically, about 600,000
Palestinian Arabs fled their homes
during the conflict.
The Palestinian claim is that they were
forced out by Israeli soldiers.
For the most part,
this is totally untrue, as we'll soon
discuss. But it's first worth
mentioning, first worth mentioning that
as a result of Israel's war of
independence,
850,000
Jews living in Arab lands were forced to
leave their homes and had to leave most
of their possessions behind.
These refugees are never spoken about.
When the refugee issue
of 1948 is discussed, no one speaks
about the refugees from Arab lands. This
is mainly because Israel successfully
absorbed many of these refugees and
integrated them into Israeli society.
However, the Arab nations never absorbed
their fellow Arabs who fled Palestine.
They've been maintained as refugees, not
granted citizenship in the countries
they went to
and instead have been exploited as a
wedge issue against Israel.
So why indeed did Palestinians flee
their homes in Palestine and become
refugees?
So it is true
that in a very small number of cases
they were encouraged or forced to leave
from areas where Arab forces were
launching attacks against Israel.
It happened in a small number of cases
that Israeli forces
had Arabs leave their homes from areas
where Arab forces were launching attacks
against Israel. But this was for the
safety of these people. It was never in
order to confiscate their property. But
there are other reasons that explain why
the bulk of Palestinians fled. Number
one,
in the early days of the local fighting
in 1947, before the Arab nations got
involved,
Palestinian local leaders in some
locations, including mayors and judges
and landlords and religious leaders left
their places
and many citizens followed them.
They probably left because they saw a
conflict was going on. They wanted to
move to a safer place.
And that's the truth about a huge number
of the Palestinian refugees. Many of
these people simply fled their homes on
their own on their own initiative. They
didn't need any encouragement in order
to get out of the way of the fighting in
populated areas. And in truth, this is
what always happens during the war.
During wars, people get displaced
because of the war.
Number three,
the Arab armies expected a quick victory
over Israel and they were surprised to
meet stiff resistance.
When the Arab armies began to fall back
to retreat from their initial victories,
Palestinian civilians panicked and then
fled.
Number four,
Arab radio stations
broadcast false rumors of grizzly
Israeli atrocities
which frighten some people into fleeing.
And finally, number five, overconfident
Arab leaders encouraged these
Palestinians to leave their homes until
the Israelis would be crushed and then
they would be able to return to their
homes. The term Nakba first became
associated with the Arab-Israeli
conflict in August of 1948
when Constantine Zurich, a Syrian
academic and diplomat who was based in
Beirut, published a book entitled The
Meaning of the Nakba, the meaning of the
catastrophe. And in this book, he blames
Arab leaders for the Nakba due to two
things. Due to their military failures
and to their urging Arab citizens, Arab
civilians to flee until after the
fighting is over. And he said in this
book that was the cause of the Nakba and
not a grand premeditated Zionist scheme
to displace the local Arab population.
So even though Zurich
preempts this idea of Israel and the
Zionists and the Jews having a plan to
displace the Arab population and get rid
of them and Zurik says that's not what
happened
but this claim later became a standard
component of the Nakba narrative.
So what I tried to do tonight was to
share with you a simple first level
take on the competing
Arab and Israeli narratives concerning
the crisis, the conflict in Israel.
And I want to repeat that the story is
much deeper and much more complex
and there is a more nuanced and more
detailed study that needs to be made.
But I think at least for the basic level
for the level number one to get the gist
of what the narratives are, I think
that's what we were able to accomplish
tonight.
[Music]
Heat. Heat.
Heat.
[Music]
Heat.
[Music]