學者角鬥士 淺談 西班牙刺劍VS日本武士刀
王者风范
22粉絲
33 次觀看·2025年10月20日
Spanish vs. Japanese
Reach isn't everything, but it's something
Hey folks, Matt Eaton here, scholar gladiatorial
Now, this isn't one of those musketeer vs. samurai videos
or anything like that, but quite simply
Recently, a Spanish rapier came into my possession
Beautiful thing here
And this dates to about 1700
Perhaps the end of the 1600s
It's a very nice piece
And I'm very lucky to have it in my collection
And I'm also very lucky to have
This 17th century Kanban era katana here
Now, as I've mentioned in many previous videos
Japanese swords do vary a lot in length
And curvature and weight and spine thickness
And all sorts of other things
So it's not that all Japanese swords are the same
However, that being said
There is a general range of nagasa or length of blade
That we find on Japanese swords in this period
And this is an important and interesting period
Because this is the period, the 17th century
When the Japanese were coming into conflict
But also trading with and also receiving emissaries
And missionaries and all sorts from Europe
Primarily from the Netherlands, Spain, Portugal and England
Those were the main countries who had interaction
With the Japanese in this period
And not only in Japan
You have to remember also that the Japanese in this period
Were engaged in trading abroad
But also piracy
And in fact, there are several accounts
And I'll probably look at these in future videos
Several accounts of Spanish, Portuguese, Dutch, English and others
Encountering Japanese bandits, pirates
Whatever you want to call them at sea and also on land as well
Sometimes in China, for example
So the fact is that these swords did come up against
Rapiers, side swords and basket-held swords
And other sorts of swords that were used in that period
And it has to be said that most European accounts
Doesn't matter whether they're Spanish, English or whatever
Are quite respectful and in some cases in awe
Of the Japanese fervor particularly
If not always skill but sometimes skill as well
With the sword
They were particularly aware of the fact that the Japanese
Were fearsome in hand-to-hand combat
But a point that I want to illustrate is that
In single combat at least
Master combat is slightly different
And I'll get to that in a second
In single combat a typical Japanese sword
Of which I consider this of the 17th century
Is at a really great reach disadvantage against a rapier
Let's put the sire down for a second
So I can pick up the rapier
So as a simple kind of parameters
The blade length let's say from
Usually you measure just the cutting edge on a Japanese sword
But let's say from the suba or guard
All the way to the tip
Because that's how we usually measure European swords
The blade length on Japanese swords at this time
Of most katana
Obviously we're not talking about wakizashi
Which are even shorter
But if we're talking about most katana at this time
Most katana have blades of between about
25 and 28 inches
There are some that are longer
And when they get shorter than that
They basically become wakizashi
So you do find long swords
But in this period
They aren't particularly long for a number of reasons
So you're looking at a blade much like this one
Which is very often around 26 or 27 inches
In contrast the Spanish rapier
And this isn't a particularly long one
The Spanish rapier here has a blade of nearly 40 inches
And that's measured from the cross guard
Rather than top of the dish
So we're comparing like with like
Because that's where the hand sits essentially
So we have an enormous amount more blade
Projecting like a foot's length more blade
Projecting on the rapier's tip than the katana's
Now they are very very different weapons
So on one hand with the rapier
Although we can cut with it
We're predominantly sticking the point
Into the chest and face
And other parts of the opponent
So we're stabbing them with the tip
While you can thrust with a katana
And it is done in Kenjutsu and Kendo
And historically back in the day
You can thrust with it
Primarily they are specialised for cutting
They're not great thrusting
They're actually quite effective thrusting weapons
If you can get close enough
But they don't have a great reach
And they're not particularly nimble in the tip
Compared to something like a rapier
So predominantly they're cutting
Now an interesting feature of the katana
Unlike certain European swords for example
Is because they maintain their width to the tip
And because of the fact that they don't have
An awful lot of distal tape
And they're not particularly thin up here as well
They do cut very effectively towards the tip
So with a European sabre for example
Often we'll have a centre of percussion
Which is about here
However with a Japanese sword
We can still cut very effectively towards the tip
So in a sense this does mean
That although they're only
Let's say a 26, 27 inch blade
Relatively short
They actually have fairly good cutting reach
Because with a European sabre or back sword
You might have a 33 inch blade
But actually its centre of percussion
Is down at let's say 27 inches
Which is about the same as the katana
So actually the katana makes quite effective use
Of the reach that it does have
But nevertheless it can't reach further
Than the blade it has
So it can only reach to a maximum
Of 27 inches in this case
In contrast the 40 inch
Or 39, 40 inch reach of the rapier
Is far, far longer
So from a very basic point of view
The rapier and you know
The English had similar rapiers
And the Portuguese and so on and so forth
But the rapier has a far greater reach
Than the katana
Which means that in an average encounter
The main problem that the katana wielder
Is going to have
Is getting past the point of the rapier
Now there's a couple of ways of doing that
One of them is to essentially kamikaze charge in
Take a thrust in the body
And chop down your opponent anyway
We'll come back to that in a second
The other is to cross this blade
And then close in
And this is very much fighting
Like fighting against a spear
So a swordsman fighting against a spearman
Has to first essentially cross the spear
And then charge in and get close enough
In order to deliver their attack
The spearman meanwhile
All they have to do is keep distance
And keep stabbing the person with the shorter weapon
So to an extent the person with the katana
Is always going to have a somewhat unpleasant time
Probably getting full of lots of small holes
Some of which may kill him of course
Because a thrust despite the fact
It's a very narrow blade
A steel spike into your chest cavity
Abdomen, throat, face or an artery
Is going to spell death at some point
You might not die instantly
But you're going to die at some point fairly soon
Obviously a katana cut is no small thing either
But in order to deliver that
They have to get past the rapier
And this is not easy for a number of reasons
One is reach but the other is nimbleness
Because of course not only
Does this blade have a great amount of reach
But it can also disengage very very easily
Because of the balance
And because of the way that it's held
As soon as anybody tries to cross or strike this blade
You can simply move it around to a new place
And deliver your point where it needs to go
And this can parry as well
So even if you attempt to thrust the Japanese opponent
They parry your blow and start charging in
You can of course parry their cut
You can quite happily parry
This steel bar with this steel bar
They're both steel bars
This can parry this
And this one is not going to cut through this
Unlike you might see in some movies or anime
So quite simply
The Japanese swordsman is not going to have a pleasant time
Against the rapier
However here's the good news
For the katana fans out there
And for the Japanese martial arts aficionados
All is not lost
Because in single combat
I personally like for like
If the two fighters are the same
They're both familiar with their weapons
They've got similar levels of fitness and expertness
My money is generally going to be on the rapier guy
For all of the reasons I've just mentioned
As a dueling weapon
I think the rapier is vastly superior to the katana
Unless Steve Noddy talking about hand protection as well
Massive difference there
But in a melee
On board a ship
On land
In a big skirmish
In a battle
It's a different kettle of fish
Now in Europe it was noted
That rapiers weren't necessarily great battlefield weapons
The reason being that
As soon as you devote the direction of your weapon
In one direction with a thrust
You are not occupying space
And there are numerous treatises in Europe
That tell you against multiple opponents
To keep cutting
Because cuts occupy space and traverse space
And the very act of cutting and offending
Also keeps other people at bay
Or sweeps aside other weapons
That might happen to be coming your way
A thrust however is mono-directional
And totally committed to one line of attack
And during that time
If someone happens to cut or thrust you from over here
You're going to get hit
With this kind of weapon
First of all of course you're going to be cutting
Which means you're going to be traversing space
The whole time that you're moving it
Which is more likely to deflect
Incoming attacks and protect you
But moreover
In a massed melee
It will often come close
Now I've talked about length advantage
Generally speaking
A spear has an advantage over a sword right
However if we're now fighting in a small room
Well at that point the sword
Probably has an advantage over the spear
Because the spear can't maneuver
Even in a reenactment context
Quite recently I have totally experienced this
Where the enemy side
The opponents were pushing in quite hard
Pushing our line back
And my spear became basically useless
Because I couldn't use it
Because it was too long, too unwieldy
And even the back end of it was getting in the way
And getting caught up with people behind me
And at that point my long sword
Pulled off my side
Half-sworded with
Became a much more practical weapon
So in these types of tight encounters
On board ships or in melees on the land
A shorter weapon that can traverse space
Suddenly becomes really into its element
Whereas a rapier
Whilst in one-on-one
Might be absolutely fantastic
Really loses most of its advantages
It can't cut very effectively
It can get caught up
Because it's so long
It's quite difficult to disengage it
You can't get the point into an opponent
Who's really close in front of you
Because you can't pull the hand back far enough
Because you've got too much blade sticking out
So to conclude
You can see where I've gone with this
Essentially my argument
Is that one-on-one
Basically due to reach
But also hand protection
Nimbleness and everything else
The rapier has a really big advantage
Against the katana
There have been people in modern times
Some people I know as well
I won't name and shame them
Who have gone katana versus rapier
And frankly
Whilst you can get from
Some very skillful katana people
They usually get really quite fatally skewered
By rapiers on the way in
And even if the rapier person messes up
You can backpedal
You can parry
You can find space again
To get your points in again
So it's not like a one-shot wonder
You can have several goes at it
And it's very difficult for the katana to deal with
And also because it doesn't have very much hand protection
But in a melee
In a battle
Boarding ships
Below decks
In rooms
In buildings
That is when I really think
The katana comes into its own
So I do think
This is a completely fantastic sword
As is this
They just have very very
Different strengths and weaknesses
But we should remember
That these two weapons
Completely plausibly
Could have met
Those hundreds of years ago
300 years ago
Because they are of the same period
And they are from cultures
Who absolutely
Did encounter each other
And I just think it's fascinating
To hold them next to each other
And think what stories they could tell
If they were able to
Thanks a lot for watching
I have been Matt Easton
And I will always be
See you soon
Cheers folks
Thanks for watching
We've got extra videos on Patreon
Please give our Facebook a like
And subscribe if you haven't already
Cheers folks
