Exclusive
Jane Pierce: The Saddest First Lady

American Legends
362 followers
Jane Pierce arguably has the saddest story of any first lady in American history. As the wife of fourteenth president Franklin Pierce, she prayed daily that her husband would lose the election, since she detested the political life he pursued off and on throughout his life. Differing with her husband on matters of politics, abolition, abstinence, and religion, she was a deeply devout woman who believed the tragic death of their sons was caused by her husband’s ungodly political career.
#americanlegends #firstladies #whitehousehistory #presidentialfamilies #19thcenturywomen #quietstrength #presidentialhistory #classicamericanhistory #history #historyandculture #historyfacts #historyandcuture #american #uncoveringhistory #uncoverthetruth
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right
from our history pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous
and some are obscure, but each person deserves to be discovered
because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better
The position of being First Lady of the United States
is one of great honor. It's the highest rank which
a woman has ever achieved in the United States to date,
and it's a very important position serving as the helpmate of the
Commander-in-Chief of the free world. One would think that any woman who was
the wife of an important politician would want to have this role,
yet many First Ladies were somewhat reluctant to take this
position, and some of them even ardently prayed that their husbands would not be
elected. Today we're going to talk about one of
the most reluctant of all First Ladies, the wife of the 14th President, Jane
Pierce. Exploring the history of every
President and his wife, it's been so fascinating to learn more
about who each President was as a man and who
his family was. Now, many Presidents were widowed
before they reached the White House, and
one never married at all, yet each President
whose wife joined him in the White House
clearly relied on that woman for her advice and her support.
Some First Ladies, of course, were more politically active than others, like
John Adams' wife or James Madison's wife,
whereas others preferred to remain more in the background.
Yet we know that most First Ladies were glad that their husbands achieved
these positions, or at least they were happy to support them as best
they could, even though life in the public eye was very
difficult, as acknowledged by the first First Ladies, Martha Washington,
right down to her next several successors.
However, of all the Presidential couples, from George Washington up to Millard
Filmer and his wife, the first 13, each couple seemed basically suited to
each other, even the ones where the wife died before
her husband became President. Sadly, that doesn't seem to be the case
with Franklin Pierce, the 14th President of the United States.
He was born in New Hampshire in 1804, and he came from a family of a father
who was a strong soldier in the Revolutionary War and
would eventually become a politician. A strong Democratic family. As Franklin
Pierce was a young man, becoming active in even the
Senate by the age of 28, he was still unmarried, which wasn't that
unusual for a man of that time. Many of the
Presidents were at least that old by the time they got
married, but apparently that was a distressing
fact to Franklin. He wanted to get married and have a
family, and I guess he hadn't found the right woman up to that point, which is
very surprising because he was known as Handsome Frank. In fact,
I would go so far as to say he was the handsomest President up to
that point. He also was noted for being very
charming, having a winning way with words.
Surely he could have found many an eligible young lady
who would have been very happy to marry him out of the
daughters and sisters and nieces of his political comrades in the Democratic
Party. Yet that was not the woman he ended up
choosing to be his bride. In November of 1834, he married Jane
Appleton. She was 28 at the time, which was
considered an old maid in those days, and she came from a very different
background than he did. She was the daughter of a Congregationalist
minister. She was from a strong Whig family, the
opposing political party. She was a total abstainer, not believing
in any alcohol, and it's known that she did not like
Franklin Pierce's drinking because he not only thought drinking was
acceptable, he drank a lot, even as a young man. No one
knows for sure when and how they met. It's said her brother went to the same
college, but one fact which is very rarely stated
was the fact that her father, in addition to being a
Congregationalist minister, was president of Bowdoin College where he
went, so obviously that's how they met. Of course it was several years after he
left college that they ended up marrying. Maybe they'd been going together a long
time, secretly, or maybe their families arranged
it. It seems unlikely because they came from such different backgrounds.
Perhaps it was one act of defiance in the young lady's life because it is
known her family was not very supportive of it.
What we know about Jane is that she was a very
frail, often sickly, sensitive, and fragile woman. She also is noted to have had
depression at times in her life, but she was very modest, very virtuous,
and extremely religious, very devout. You can see from every painting or
photograph of her that she was very slender and fragile. She looks very
fragile, having a rather spare build. Because of
her strong Puritan belief, she didn't think that anything that
happened was an accident. She believed very much in predestination
and the idea that God decides
everything that happens, and when bad things happen,
it's a form of punishment for something you've done wrong.
She did not like Washington society, nor did she like politics.
And I think it's easy to see why a woman of her
sensitive religious nature would find politics evil.
Even in those days, when it wasn't as corrupt as it is now,
politics involved a lot of smooth talking and promising and
backstabbing. I think most of the men we've discussed so far being
presidents tried to be honorable gentlemen.
Yet, even if everyone was honorable, you see many times when
two best friends would end up becoming bitter enemies because
of one political issue. She saw that as very evil.
Also, she was a strong abolitionist. She thought slavery was extremely wrong
and it should be abolished. Whereas Franklin, although he agreed that slavery
was morally wrong, did not think it was a political issue
which could be effectively solved through the abolitionist means. He saw it
as something that would have a better chance
of dying off if it was kept peaceful, rather than
rooting it out by making it unlawful, as most northern abolitionists
wanted to happen by this point. The Pierce family had three children,
three sons, all of whom died young. One of them died in infancy.
One of them died at the age of four of typhoid fever. And he died of this
fever shortly after his father was elected to
the senate. Jane saw this as punishment for his
seeking the role in the senate. When he was eventually
nominated for president in the year 1852,
it must be noted that he didn't want this position.
He wasn't actively seeking it. Around 1842,
he had left the political scene to pursue his private law practice
and then eventually be in the militia. And Jane was much happier when he was
with the family, acting as a lawyer, rather than
in Washington, being in the senate, being in the house of representatives.
She didn't like that and she thought it was not the right thing for any of them.
But he was this dark horse candidate who ended up
getting the democratic nomination for president in 1852.
Jane was devastated by this. Franklin didn't think he had a very good chance
of winning, but he was willing to go along with it
and accept the nomination. He didn't do a lot of campaigning. In
that time, it was still considered very undignified and vulgar for
a candidate to appear to be seeking a high public office.
Other people had to do the campaigning for him, his party, his supporters.
He couldn't be out there saying, vote for me. It just didn't look good.
But every day, Jane would pray ardently that
he would not be elected. She's quoted as saying,
how much better it would be for him on every account.
From this, we see it wasn't just her own beliefs or her own wishes
which made her want him to not be in politics.
That one quote, which is really the only quote that remains
from her, shows that it wasn't just her wishes.
She truly thought it wasn't good for her husband either.
A letter from her son, Benny, around this time
refers to the fact that he knew his mother was very unhappy at the fact that
her husband might end up in the White House
and that he too was disturbed by that idea.
Nevertheless, after he was elected president,
the family was taking a train together either to Washington or to some other
area shortly before the inauguration. There are
differing reports on that fact. Their train car was derailed and
it crashed. Only one person died aboard that car
but it was Benjamin or Benny, their 11-year-old son and their only remaining
child. Franklin saw the horrific accident and
tried to cover the boy's body with a cloth before
his wife could see but she too saw the lifeless body of their son and
she was forever changed by this incident, as was Franklin.
It was a terrible tragedy which would be horrific for any parent but it
was so much the greater weight on Jane because of her belief that this
was divine punishment. Their son was killed
because her husband had been elected president
and one can only imagine that, although I don't think Franklin completely
believed that himself, he was definitely a Christian but
not as much of a fundamentalist Puritan as his wife.
But having been married to a woman who believed that for
over 20 years or for almost 20 years, surely he couldn't be immune to such
ideas. I'm sure many a time the thought entered
his mind, maybe Jane was right and this is punishment
and it's no wonder that thus he was prone to very heavy drinking and
alcoholism for the rest of his life. For the first two years as first lady,
Jane did not go downstairs. She stayed in her room
all the time. She was known as the shadow of the White House because
she never would go to public events. She was in total mourning.
Despite her strong Christian beliefs, at this time she consulted
a few mystics and even attempted to use a Ouija board to communicate with her
son and it was around this time that that
sort of mysticism and spiritualism and the use of the Ouija board became
very popular because of the extremely high
death count in the United States. The Civil War soon after but
so many children died, so many people died in the prime of their lives that
there became this fascination with communicating with people beyond the
grave and she definitely would write letters
to her son, not expecting him to get them necessarily but
just to pour out her feelings and her regret at having not been as good a
mother as she thought she should have been.
In her stead, her maternal aunt served as the hostess of the White House.
Her name was Abigail Ken Means and she, as well as another close friend
of Jane's, acted as the hostess but there wasn't
a whole lot of entertaining going on at the White House because
Franklin was also in mourning and it wasn't that joyous of a time for
celebration for either of them. At the New Year's Eve celebration in
1855, Jane made her first public appearance.
Even then she still was very subdued and noticeably grief-stricken but
everyone was extremely sympathetic of how she must be feeling at that point
and very glad to finally see her in a public setting.
After leaving the White House, Franklin and Jane
went on a tour of some more tropical climates. They went to
Spain and they went to the Bahamas but all this traveling
couldn't really give either of them peace. Throughout her life, Jane had
suffered from tuberculosis and it ended up getting worse
so she would die a few years later and Franklin was
a widower for the last six years of his life. Because
of her grief-stricken state and her opposition to her husband's
even being in office, Jane is not regarded very highly as a
First Lady. In fact, she's regarded as one of the
least effectual and having tried the least. But I think
that one quote from the wife of Robert E. Lee
says a lot about who she really was. Mrs. Lee said,
I have known many of the ladies of the White House, none more truly excellent
than the afflicted wife of President Pierce.
She was a refined, deeply religious and well-educated lady.
Another quote about her is, no story in the history of the White House
is more melancholy than that of Jane Pierce.
I hearken back to that one quote from her
where she said that her husband would have been
so much better off if he were out of politics.
For I feel that that is a great key to not only her life
but her relationship with Franklin. Clearly she was a woman of strong
principle who tried to influence her husband for the
better. Just how much Pierce drank throughout his
life isn't that clearly known. It especially may have been exaggerated
by his political opponents. It definitely is known that he was an
alcoholic after leaving the White House as he was grief-stricken from his son
and his wife dying and having lost the presidency, upset about the Civil War.
But perhaps he did try to be more temperate because of his wife.
And perhaps that is one reason why he was more
equal on some regards of slavery because of his wife's influence.
Maybe one of the reasons that Jane thought politics were so bad
and Washington was so evil that that environment encouraged him to drink
more. Maybe she saw this group mentality
brought him down. From his quotes you can see that he was
a very sensitive, intelligent, and devout man in his own way.
He wasn't a coarse man or one given to
revelry. He was very sensitive and refined.
So perhaps she saw that he wanted to be liked.
He wanted to be a good politician. He wanted to get along with others.
And he didn't have the childhood background that she did in being
against alcohol. That wasn't what his family believed.
So he didn't have that strong foundation on which to rest.
And I think that his pride may have kept him from wanting to do something just
because his wife told him not to. Yet she thought if he's not in those
circles when he's just a lawyer he won't have those temptations. So no
doubt that's why she was especially sad to see him
continually drawn into political life. And also she saw that he had
this sensitive nature with he wants to be a soldier yet
then people mocked him. It probably was more than just
religious fanaticism which made her think that it was punishment.
She doubtless saw that he had a better life
and better success when he stuck to being a good family man and a lawyer
instead of trying to do these other things like being a politician or
a soldier. Because people would always misinterpret what he tried to do.
They did when he was a general and they did when he was a president.
He tried so hard yet it was never enough. It was never the right thing.
And he was often blamed for things which weren't entirely his fault.
And Ulysses S. Grant who would go on to of course
be president and a very famous general in his own right
served alongside him during that Mexican-American war.
And in his memoirs which were written after
Pierce had died he said of all the volunteer militiamen alongside whom I
fought Pierce was the bravest. He was not a
coward. He was such a brave valiant soldier.
He truly was. But I think that in her own quiet wise way
Jane wasn't trying to keep her husband from doing what was his destiny or
keeping him from doing what he wanted to do. No doubt
she really loved him because her family didn't even want to marry him. It must
have been true love which brought them together.
And it saddened her and made her depressed
to see the man she loved being destroyed
by himself and by those around him. So I think
Jane is again the most melancholy story. Such a sad beautiful story that they
both have. It sounds like a movie and it surprises
me that there hasn't been some dramatic classic film about the story of
handsome Frank in the shadow of the White House.
Jane Pierce throughout it all remains an example of someone who was
still intelligent, gracious, devout
and long-suffering. Despite all these difficulties she did stick with her
husband to the end. Through the White House, through the
death of three children and through the difficult days after his
presidency. It must have been love which kept her
with him all that time. Thank you for spending this time with me
and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.
