Can the government demand that you publicly declare your loyalty to the country? That was the question confronted by the Supreme Court in 1943 in the landmark case of West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette. Kurt Lash, Professor of Law at the University of Richmond, discusses why the answer to this question was so significant then and remains so now.
Transcript: West Virginia v. Barnette: Forcing the Pledge of Allegiance? Presented by Kurt Lash
Can the government demand that you publicly declare your loyalty to the country?
Can you or your children be punished for refusing to publicly salute the flag?
Your first reaction is probably an indignant, Of course not.
But what about times when it seems like support for the government is critically important, for example during times of war?
That was the question confronted by the Supreme Court in 1943 in the landmark case of West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette.
As World War II raged in Europe and Japan, the West Virginia Board of Education passed a rule requiring children to salute the American flag at the beginning of the school day. The purpose of this rule was to instill patriotism in the students.
Though its intent was benign, failure to comply would result in the child being expelled, the parents fined, and possibly jailed.
Marie and Gathie Barnett, members of the Jehovah's Witnesses church, strongly objected to the rule. They believed the salute and the pledge that went with it violated the biblical injunction in the Book of Exodus to never bow or honor any graven image:
You shall not make for yourself an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. You shall not bow down to them or worship them.
When the Barnetts took their complaint to the federal court, the school board had every reason to believe the school would win. Only three years earlier, the Supreme Court ruled against the Jehovah's Witnesses in a similar case, Minersville v. Gobitis 1940.
In that case, the Supreme Court ruled that public schools could compel children to salute the flag and say the pledge. If Jehovah's Witnesses wanted their children excused from saluting the flag, Justice Felix Frankfurter wrote, then they would have to convince local majorities to vote in favor of special exemptions for objecting families.
In Barnette, however, the Court came to the opposite decision, deciding in favor of the Jehovah's Witnesses by a 6-3 vote.
So, what changed in just three years that caused the court to change its mind?
First, the publicity surrounding the earlier Gobitis case had sparked animosity against the Jehovah's Witnesses. Some Americans believed their refusal to salute the flag was disloyal and even traitorous. This led to church burnings and other acts of violence.
Whatever hopes the Court might have had that political discussion would lead to empathy and compromise were dashed in the face of discrimination and intolerance.
Second, since its decision in Gobitis, two members had left the Supreme Court. The justices who replaced them were less inclined to leave constitutional rights to the tender mercies of a public inflamed by the crisis of a World War.
So, three years later, the Supreme Court decided to revisit the issue. This time, a majority ruled that forced salutes and pledges violated the First Amendment's protection of freedom of speech.
In his opinion, Justice Robert Jackson rejected the idea that constitutional freedom depended on the votes of local school boards.
One's right to life, liberty, and property, he wrote, to free speech, a free press, freedom of worship and assembly, and other fundamental rights may not be submitted to vote; they depend on the outcome of no elections.
Can the government demand that you
publicly declare your loyalty to the
country? Can you or your children be
punished for refusing to publicly salute
the flag? Your first reaction is
probably an indignant, "Of course not."
But what about times when it seems like
support for the government is critically
important? For example, during times of
war. That was the question confronted by
the Supreme Court in 1943 in the
landmark case of West Virginia State
Board of Education v. Barnett. As World
War II raged in Europe and Japan, the
West Virginia Board of Education passed
a rule requiring children to salute the
American flag at the beginning of the
school day. The purpose of this rule was
to instill patriotism in the students.
Though its intent was benign, failure to
comply would result in the child being
expelled, the parents fined, and
possibly jailed.
Marie and Gayy Barnett, members of the
Jehovah's Witnesses Church, strongly
objected to the rule. They believed the
salute and the pledge that went with it
violated the biblical injunction in the
book of Exodus to never bow or honor any
graven image. You shall not make for
yourself an image in the form of
anything in heaven above or on the earth
beneath or in the waters below. You
shall not bow down to them or worship
them. When the Barnett took their
complaint to federal court, the school
board had every reason to believe the
school would win. Only 3 years earlier,
the Supreme Court ruled against the
Jehovah's Witnesses in a similar case,
Minersville v. Goidas. In that case, the
Supreme Court ruled that public schools
could compel children to salute the flag
and say the pledge. If Jehovah's
Witnesses wanted their children excused
from saluting the flag, Justice Felix
Frankfurter wrote, then they would have
to convince local majorities to vote in
favor of special exemptions for
objecting families. In Barnett, however,
the court came to the opposite decision,
deciding in favor of the Jehovah's
Witnesses by a 6 to3 vote.
So what changed in just 3 years that
caused the court to change its mind?
First, the publicity surrounding the
earlier Goida's case had sparked
animosity against the Jehovah's
Witnesses. Some Americans believed their
refusal to salute the flag was disloyal
and even traitorous. This led to church
burnings and other acts of violence.
Whatever hopes the court might have had
that political discussion would lead to
empathy and compromise were dashed in
the face of discrimination and
intolerance.
Second, since its decision in Goitis,
two members had left the Supreme Court.
The justices who replaced them were less
inclined to leave constitutional rights
to the tender mercies of a public
inflamed by the crisis of a world war.
So 3 years later, the Supreme Court
decided to revisit the issue. This time,
a majority ruled that forced salutes and
pledges violated the First Amendment's
protection of freedom of speech. In his
opinion, Justice Robert Jackson rejected
the idea that constitutional freedom
depended on the votes of local school
boards. One's right to life, liberty and
property, he wrote to free speech, a
free press, freedom of worship and
assembly and other fundamental rights
may not be submitted to vote. They
depend on the outcome of no elections.
For the court, forcing school children
to parrot words of praise written by the
government was antithetical to
everything for which America stood. If
there is any fixed star in our
constitutional constellation, Jackson
continued, it is that no official, high
or petty, can prescribe what shall be
orthodox in politics, religion, or other
matters of opinion.
Jackson's eloquence, however, did not
persuade his colleague Felix Frankfer,
the justice who had written the majority
opinion in Goitis.
Frankfurter had been placed on the court
by Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
Frankfurter agreed with FDR's
philosophy. that courts should defer to
the decisions of political majorities,
whether local school boards or the
legislation of the New Deal. In Barnett,
however, the majority of the court
insisted that federal courts exist to
protect basic constitutional freedoms,
especially in times of national
emergency. Even when local patriotism
and national unity seem critically
important, even then we remain a free
people. It was for such freedom that so
many Americans were at that very moment
giving their last full measure of
devotion. The Supreme Court knew this.
And so just to drive the point even
deeper into the national consciousness,
the court delivered its decision in West
Virginia Board of Education v. Barnett
on June 14th, 1943,
Flag Day. I'm Curt Lash, professor of
law at Richmond University for Prager
University.
Thank you for watching this video. To
keep PragerU videos free, please
consider making a taxdeductible
donation.