Do you really know your breast cancer risk? Many women think they do – trusting family history, regular checkups, and mammograms to keep them safe. But what if these measures leave dangerous blind spots, leading to later, more aggressive diagnoses? Today's episode is a powerful wake-up call.
Joining us is globally renowned OBGYN, Dr. Thaïs Aliabadi. Known simply as “Dr. A” to her global following, she's OBGYN to royals and celebrities, and a leading voice on women’s health featured on The Kardashians, The Doctors, and Dr. Phil. Dr. Aliabadi shares her own shocking story: how, despite following all the rules, she uncovered a hidden cancer risk that standard screening completely missed.
Today you'll learn why your lifetime risk may be higher than you’ve been told, how diet and lifestyle could change your trajectory, and the essential steps to take today to safeguard your health. This is information every woman needs - don’t wait until it’s too late.
There's definitely an epidemic of breast cancer.
And on average, every woman has a 12.5% chance
of getting breast cancer in their life.
Could the food you eat influence your risk of breast cancer?
Absolutely.
And it can push you up from 12.5 to as high as 80%.
And the goal is to diagnose it as early as possible.
Dr. Thais Alyabadi is a world-renowned gynecologist.
She's helped countless women catch aggressive forms
of breast cancer before it threatens their life.
Biggest misconception is,
I don't have family history of breast cancer,
so I'm not gonna have breast cancer.
The food we eat, chemicals we're exposed to,
stress, anxiety, pushes your lifetime risk really high.
Does a mammogram always catch breast cancer?
25% of cancers can be missed on mammogram.
Here I was thinking, I'm never gonna get breast cancer
because I did everything right in my life.
Mammogram was negative, ultrasound was negative,
but I was diagnosed with breast cancer.
And when someone tells you you have cancer,
your brain shuts down.
And that's why I want every single person
to know her lifetime risk of breast cancer.
Is there an accurate way to measure
your lifetime risk of breast cancer?
The best formula to use that women can do it at home,
it's...
Welcome to ZOE, Science and Nutrition,
where world-leading scientists explain
how their research can improve your health.
Thais, thank you for joining me today.
Thank you for having me.
So we like to kick off our shows at ZOE
with a rapid-fire Q&A with questions from our listeners.
So the rules are, you can give us a yes or a no,
or if you absolutely have to, a one-sentence answer.
You want me to give that a go?
Sure.
All right.
Are cases of breast cancer rising in younger women?
Yes.
Does a mammogram always catch breast cancer?
No.
Is there an accurate way to measure
your lifetime risk of breast cancer?
As accurate as it can get, yes.
Could the food you eat influence your risk of breast cancer?
1,000%.
And you get a whole sentence now.
What's the biggest misconception
about the early detection of breast cancer?
I don't have family history of breast cancer,
so I'm not going to have breast cancer.
And that's not necessarily true?
It's not true at all.
Very recently, a close family friend was diagnosed
with a very high genetic risk of breast cancer
and decided to opt for a double mastectomy as a result.
And that was really shocking to me
because it's just not something that I had even considered
that someone might do based upon like a genetic risk
from a test and definitely completely changed my view
about breast cancer.
And I could see that like sort of everything
that I thought I'd understood about it,
which was probably not very much, is all wrong.
So I think today I hope we're going to sort of walk through
everything we need to know about early prevention
based upon what's going on today
and maybe not the sort of outmoded ideas
that I might've had and many of us might've had
because it's clear that the science has really moved on.
So I'd like to start maybe with what the guidance is.
And I understand that guidance is different
in different countries.
So we're here in the States,
so maybe U.S. guidance about mammograms
and the age at which you should have a mammogram.
Well, the general guideline in the U.S. right now
says that a woman should start her mammogram
at age 40 or 10 years before her first degree
relative with breast cancer was diagnosed with cancer.
But I'm trying to change that
because that does not include the high-risk patients
who fall into a category that might need to start
the breast imaging as early as 25 or 30.
So not all women fall into that age 40 or above category.
Even age 40 sounds like it is earlier than the-
Yes, majority of the countries, yep.
So has that shifted?
Did it used to be later than 40?
Yes, it used to be 50 and in some countries
it still starts at 50.
In the U.S. for low-risk patients, it's 40.
You can do it up to every two years.
I think patients need to do it once a year,
but I want every single person to know
her lifetime risk of breast cancer.
And based on that risk,
then we go backwards and start the imaging.
So not all women fall into that 40 and above category.
So we're definitely gonna talk a lot,
I think, in this show about screening,
but this is the first time we talked
about breast cancer on the podcast.
So what causes breast cancer and why is it so dangerous
that we sort of focus on breast cancer
versus any other type of cancer?
So first of all, after skin cancer,
breast cancer is the number one cancer in women.
So it's very important.
One out of eight women will get diagnosed with breast cancer.
On average, every woman has a 12.5% chance
of getting breast cancer in their life.
And I always use the airline example.
If I told you you're about to board a plane
that has a 12.5% chance of crashing,
you would think twice boarding that plane.
I mean, I wouldn't get on the plane for sure.
Right?
But when I say to patients,
you have 12.5% chance of getting breast cancer,
they're like, oh, so I'm fine.
And that's a starting point.
Then we don't really know what causes breast cancer, right?
But one thing we know, there are different factors.
We talked about nutrition already.
Obesity is a risk factor.
Having an early period, late menopause,
having dense breasts, having family history of it,
having children after age 30, drinking alcohol, smoking,
all of this will add to that risk.
And it can push you up from 12.5 to as high as 80%
if you have a gene mutation.
Are we seeing higher rates of breast cancer today
than in the past?
I am for sure.
We are seeing more cancer in younger patients in general,
all cancers considered, but especially breast cancer.
But part of it is also detection, right?
Earlier detection, we've gotten better at doing mammograms,
ultrasounds, MRIs,
and we can diagnose these cancers a little bit earlier.
So we are finding more of them,
but you're saying part of it might be
we've got better technology to find them.
But I've been in women's health for 30 years
and there's definitely an epidemic of breast cancer.
I was diagnosed with breast cancer
and my risk factors were very little.
It's rare to have this combination of physician and patient
and I think we'd love to talk about that.
Do we know why there might be an increase
in rates of breast cancer or this is?
I think stress, nutrition, alcohol, sedentary lifestyle,
generally speaking, and I speak for American women,
the food we eat, the chemicals we're exposed to,
lack of exercise, anxiety,
I think it's a combination of factors.
So we don't really know why someone gets breast cancer,
but I can tell you in my case,
it was probably diet and stress and lack of sleep.
But every patient has a different risk factor.
And this is real, like the food that you eat
can increase your risk of cancer?
Yes, I believe so.
I think I was brought up with this idea
that cancer was sort of this random thing
that came from outside and there's nothing you can do,
but you're describing something
where your lifestyle has a real impact on it.
100%, in my case, I think if for the past 30 years,
I had slept eight hours a night
and I had time to exercise regularly
and I didn't have to eat hospital food
or swallow my food in three minutes between surgeries,
I would have probably had a lower chance
of being diagnosed with my breast cancer.
I absolutely believe in that.
Imagine a version of you in six months,
someone who's made a few changes
and feels dramatically better because of it.
That's why we make this show,
to give you the science and tools to get there.
But to keep doing that, we need your support.
If you've gotten value from this episode,
please hit subscribe.
You'll get a front row seat to the latest science
and we'll keep doing the work to bring it straight to you.
Okay, now back to the show.
We've mentioned this word mammogram,
but actually what is a mammogram
and why is that typically the first step for detection?
Mammogram is an x-ray of the breast
and it's the most effective method we have right now.
It's not perfect,
but it's the most reliable we have right now.
It basically detects tumors and calcifications
in the breast years before we can palpate it.
So when it comes to breast cancer or any cancers,
the goal is to diagnose it as early as possible.
Early detection is key.
If you have an early stage breast cancer, stage one and two,
you're more likely to be cured of it
than if you go to higher stages
or if you have breast cancer in the rest of your body.
So the sooner we detect it, the better it is.
Sometimes patients say, well, I'll do a breast exam
and I'll see if I have a lump.
By the time you feel a lump,
that mass had been there probably a few years
and could have been picked up by mammogram.
Now, the limitation of a mammogram is A,
patients who have dense breast tissue,
the sensitivity of a mammogram goes down.
In women ages 40 to 49,
25% of cancers can be missed on mammogram.
And after 50, 10% of breast cancers
can be missed on mammogram.
So mammogram alone is not enough for patients at high risk
or patients who have dense breast tissue.
And it's for that reason that sometimes doctors
might order a breast ultrasound in case of a dense breast,
or they can order an MRI in addition to mammogram.
So if I understand this right,
what you're saying is like the mammogram
picks up the cancer when it's much smaller
than you would be able to find yourself.
And that means you're much more likely
to treat it successfully because as it gets bigger,
the danger of not being able to treat it gets worse.
Right.
And you're also saying like the mammogram isn't perfect.
So I want patients to know that I don't want them
to replace mammogram with any other imaging.
So as a screening tool, we use mammogram.
For patients with dense breast tissue,
instead of a 2D mammogram, we prefer a 3D mammogram.
Dense breast tissue, so our breast tissue
is made out of glandular tissue
and fibrous tissue and fatty tissue.
The more of the glandular and connective tissue we have,
the less fatty it is, the denser it gets.
As the breast tissue gets more dense,
or in 50% of women have dense breast tissue,
it makes it harder for the radiologist
to see or detect any cancers on mammogram.
Basically on a 2D mammogram,
which is a 2D X-ray of your breast,
in patients with dense breast tissue,
the radiologist will see an area of white.
And it's really hard to comment about, you know,
whether or not there's a lesion in there.
For those patients, we recommend a 3D mammogram,
which is basically, imagine flipping
through the pages of a book, millimeter at a time,
you can flip through pages of the breast
and really look and make sure we're not missing any lesions.
So 3D imaging is more accurate
and it's a better option for dense breast tissue.
We also add a breast ultrasound
for patients with breast tissue that are dense.
And basically the ultrasound can detect lesions
that the mammogram can miss.
Would a woman know if she had dense breast tissue?
That's a very good question.
So patients touch their breasts and they're like,
I think I have dense breast tissue.
It doesn't work that way.
It's an imaging diagnosis.
So if you want to know whether or not
you have a dense breast tissue,
you want to look at your mammogram report
or your breast MRI report.
And the radiologist will always comment
about the density of the breast.
Majority, 50% of patients have dense breasts.
So half the people who are going in for this mammogram
have a dense breast and you're saying that
that is where it's a lot harder
for the mammogram to pick this up.
Bravo.
And also of those 50%,
a percentage of those patients have extremely dense breasts.
The younger you are, the more dense your tissue.
The older you get, the more fatty your breast tissue becomes.
So it gets easier and easier to detect usually
as patients get older.
That's why we don't like to order mammograms
in a 25-year-old because you're not going to see anything.
Their tissue is so dense that an ultrasound
or an MRI would be a better method of imaging
unless they have a gene mutation
like the BRCA gene mutation.
So I think what you've told us is
like a mammogram is essential,
but it doesn't necessarily tell you everything.
And you've also, I think already shared
that you have your own personal story about this.
I wonder actually if having sort of provided
some of that context, you'd be willing to tell us
about your own story of diagnosis of breast cancer.
Of course.
So I was 48 and I had gone
for my mammograms every single year.
And every time I would go, they would find something.
I had a biopsy maybe when I was 40 years old
and even when I was younger.
And it was always benign, benign, benign.
When I got to age 48, I went for my mammogram
and they picked up some calcifications.
They had me go back for a biopsy.
They did a biopsy.
And this time my biopsy came back
as atypical lobular hyperplasia.
I have no idea what that means.
These are basically atypical cells in the breast
that can increase your lifetime risk of breast cancer
but they're not cancer.
So my doctor said, well, we're going to remove it.
She did an excisional biopsy.
They take a lump out of your breast
and she told me to go and come back in six months.
Mind you, at the time I was 48,
I had been a vegetarian for five to seven years.
I've never smoked.
I've never done drugs.
I rarely drink alcohol.
I had no family history of any cancers,
let alone breast cancer.
I had no gene mutations.
I was never on hormones.
So in my world, I was not going to get breast cancer.
At that point in 2017, I had started
basically calculating everyone's lifetime risk
of breast cancer through this tool
that I used in my office that's public.
So when they told me I had this atypical tissue in my breast,
I sat behind the computer
and I started calculating my own lifetime risk,
which I had no reason to do it before
because I knew I was in that range of 12.5.
I started answering the questions
and it's a tool we use basically to ask for your height,
your weight, your family history,
your density of your breasts,
whether you've been on hormones,
what age you had your period,
what age you had your first child,
and the list goes on and on.
So I answered all the questions and I pressed calculate
and this number came on my screen, 37.5%.
I almost fell off my chair.
Here I was thinking, I'm never going to get breast cancer
because I'm like the poster child
of someone who's not supposed to get cancer.
I did everything right in my life,
well, except sleeping at night.
You know, I called my doctor and I'm like,
you know, you told me to go and come back in six months,
but 37.5% is a very big number for me.
37.5% is your risk of getting breast cancer
at some point in your life.
Right.
So that's like four in 10.
For sure, one in three.
And I called my doctor, I'm like, listen,
I have three little kids at home.
I love my husband.
I love my life.
I have the best job.
I just, I have everything.
I don't want to get breast cancer.
And 37% is a very big number for me to swallow.
Is it possible to remove my breast?
And she's like, no, you're crazy.
You know, one thing you learn in women's health
is everyone always calls us crazy.
Every time we comment and my doctors were women
and they still called me crazy
because I didn't have family history
and because I didn't have any gene mutation
and because I was so healthy, they're like, no, don't worry.
This is crazy.
Why would you remove it?
And she said, you know what?
Worst case scenario, come back when you're 50,
we'll talk about this again.
But right now you're 48, you're going to lose sensation.
I went home and I just couldn't deal with it.
It's that example, right?
Would you board a plane that has a 37.5% chance of crashing?
I wouldn't, I would run away.
And you know, so anyways, I started asking a lot of people
and everyone called me crazy.
Finally, after a year, I found a surgeon
at a different facility from my hospital
who was willing to do my surgery.
Against her advice, I remember the day before surgery,
she's like, this is crazy.
Are you sure you want to do this?
I'm like, well, I'm doing it for my children.
I don't have time to get breast cancer.
And you know what her reply was to me?
She said, why are you so worried?
We have really good chemo for breast cancer.
And I was like, you know what?
You can't even argue with that.
I said, I really want my breasts off.
We're listening, we're not doctors.
Why was that answer not so good enough?
What were you thinking when you explained that
that made you feel that didn't make you feel comfortable?
As a physician, as a gynecologist in medicine
for many, many years, until you are diagnosed with cancer
or you have a loved one diagnosed with cancer,
you have no idea the trauma that goes with that.
It's not just this word you can throw out there and say,
oh, you have cancer.
Oh, we have good chemo for it.
It's a trauma that you will take with you
for the rest of your life.
It shakes you to your core.
So for me to have someone tell me,
well, if you get breast cancer, we have really good chemo.
As a mother of three children,
I couldn't even listen to that.
The whole point was I didn't wanna get cancer
to go down the path of needing chemo.
And if you're lucky, the chemo will work.
It's not easy when someone tells you you have cancer.
So at this point, I didn't know I had cancer.
I begged my doctor to just do it
and not to argue with me anymore.
So they did a double mastectomy
to remove all my breast tissue
and replace it at the same time with an implant.
And this was prophylactic double mastectomy,
meaning I didn't have cancer,
but I wanted to do this
to reduce my risk of breast cancer significantly.
So basically you go from 37 1⁄2%,
which was my lifetime risk, to less than 5%.
So I did that.
I bled out during surgery
because unfortunately my surgeon was not very experienced.
And I did my reconstructive surgery.
I was really, really sick when I woke up.
My blood pressure, I think at some point was like 70 over 30
until a friend of mine visited me who was a physician
and basically got really upset
and had them give me blood transfusion.
And that's when I perked up.
So many people called me crazy
that I hired a videographer to follow my journey.
So that videographer came to every office visit.
And I don't remember this,
but when I opened my eyes
from 10 hours being under anesthesia,
the videographer was there.
And the first thing I told him,
I said, go home and tell my children,
I will never come home telling them I have breast cancer.
Tell them mommy did it.
I was so proud of myself.
As I was getting blood transfusion,
my patient goes into labor
and I forced my husband to drive me to Cedars.
And I delivered that baby with the help of the midwife.
But that's another story on the side.
That says something about your work-life balance perhaps.
Baby Monty was born on the same day as my blood transfusion.
Anyways, a week later, I was so happy.
I felt like this heavy weight was off my shoulder.
And I get a call from my plastic surgeon, not my surgeon.
And I don't know if you know this,
but doctors do not call with path reports,
pathology report.
If your doctor calls you and says,
I just got off the phone with the pathologist,
I can guarantee you nine out of 10,
you're dealing with cancer.
So as soon as my plastic surgeon called and said,
you know, I just got off the phone with the pathologist.
The first thing I said was, do I have cancer?
And he said, yes, in three little areas of your right breast.
And mind you, all this time,
they were biopsying my left breast and my cancer,
three areas were in my right breast.
And for all of the people on the planet
who've been diagnosed with cancer,
when someone tells you you have cancer,
your brain shuts down and you stop listening.
There's so much you don't know,
but the word cancer means you're gonna die, right?
It doesn't matter if you're a doctor,
if you're a surgeon, if you've treated cancer,
doesn't matter.
When it comes inside your home,
all I could think were my children,
how I fought for a year to have someone remove my breast.
And for all the times, my friends, my colleagues,
my doctors, the radiologists at different centers,
they all called me paranoid and anxious and crazy.
And at that moment, I was so angry at them.
You know, because the first thing I told myself
is these people went out of their way to kill me.
And I'm just talking now as a patient, not as a doctor.
I'm a doctor, I understand now everything that happened.
Things get missed on MRI, we're not gods,
we all make mistakes.
The one thing that really upset me
was the number of times people called me crazy
for wanting to remove my breast.
It's my body, it's my breast, it's not gonna affect you.
I'm paying for it, remove it.
And that's how women get treated in medicine.
You know, I've dedicated my life to saving women.
I've practiced for 23 years.
I have never lost a patient under my care to cancer.
You can't tell me that's luck.
But yes, I tend to be aggressive.
Call me aggressive, I take it as a compliment,
but I never call someone crazy, ever.
If someone comes to my office and says,
doctor, something's wrong with me, I don't feel well.
I never dismiss them.
And I guess the lesson learned here
is you have to be your own advocate.
It doesn't matter if you're a doctor.
So my mission in life now is to educate.
You know, the first step of becoming your own health advocate
is to educate yourself.
I always say, if you know your name,
your last name, your date of birth,
you also need to know your lifetime risk of breast cancer.
It's a must.
You cannot go through life not knowing what that number is.
Firstly, Thais, thank you so much for sharing that story.
It's very powerful to hear it,
and I appreciate you sharing it with me
and with everyone who's listening.
How does the story finish?
Was everything okay because you'd had this?
Were you still at risk?
Usually when you have breast cancer surgery,
they need to sample your lymph nodes.
As part of staging for breast cancer,
you need to know if cancer is in the lymph node.
Because they didn't think I had cancer,
obviously my lymph nodes were not examined.
So I had to go to Dr. Giuliano,
who I absolutely love and adore,
one of the top breast cancer surgeons in the world.
I made an appointment with him
to go and get my lymph nodes checked.
Two weeks after my surgery,
at this point I had removed my breast tissue
and they had put implants,
and my breasts looked really good.
And I was looking at myself in the mirror
and I called my husband.
I'm like, I don't look like I had a double mastectomy.
I look like I had an augmentation,
meaning having an implant with some breast tissue.
He's like, what are you talking about?
I'm like, I feel breast tissue everywhere.
He's like, there's no way.
You were under for 10 hours.
There's no way.
I called my doctor.
I'm like, are you sure you removed all my breast tissue?
She said, of course, but we leave 5%.
I'm like, I understand, but I'm a gynecologist.
I can grab it.
This is not 5%.
The crazy doctor that I am,
the aggressive doctor that I am,
I put myself in an MRI machine two weeks after my surgery.
And the same doctor, MRI doctor who called me crazy
the day before my mastectomy for why I was doing it,
comes in and she's like, why are you here?
I'm like, I had my double mastectomy.
I feel like there's breast tissue left.
She's like, no, I reviewed it.
It's perfect.
So I looked at her, I'm like, I'm sorry,
but you also missed my cancer on my MRI
so you can understand why I'm nervous right now.
I want a second opinion.
She's like, of course.
I go get a second opinion from another center.
They said your MRI is completely negative.
There's no breast tissue left.
My husband looked at me and said, don't, you're going crazy.
Let's just go home.
It was a Friday afternoon.
On Monday, I go to Dr. Giuliano.
I'm sitting on the exam table.
He walks in, he's like, Thais, I'm really sorry.
I'm like, why?
He's like, all that breast tissue they left behind.
At this point, can you believe it?
And I'm just one patient.
And I'm like, what are you talking about?
Two radiologists on Friday told me
my breast tissue was completely clear.
There's no breast tissue left.
He takes me to a third radiologist who says,
you have breast tissue here, here, here, here, here, here.
Long story short, I don't wanna give you a headache,
but I had to, I begged for a second double mastectomy
because I had a lot of atypical cells in my breast.
And now I also had breast cancer
and he was gonna do my lymph nodes anyway.
And I begged him, I'm like, Dr. Giuliano,
can you do another double mastectomy on me?
It took six hours.
They did my lymph nodes.
They removed my implants, did another double mastectomy,
put my implants back in.
And when I woke up, he came to me, he's like,
I'm so glad you're so stubborn.
I'm like, why?
And he said, they had left 35% of your breast issue behind.
They tell us fat is bad, that low sugar means healthy.
Additives, nothing to worry about.
The packaging, the buzzwords, the health halos.
But the truth?
Our supermarkets are filled
with ultra processed food in disguise.
Food engineered to look wholesome while harming our health.
The result is a crisis in how we eat,
how we feel, how we live.
Zoe was built to change that.
We run the world's largest nutrition study,
independent of big food and grounded in science.
And now we've built a free app
to reveal what the labels won't.
Snap a photo of your food,
see how processed it really is.
Instant scores, no guesswork.
So you can make smarter choices for better health.
Unwrap the truth.
Download the free Zoe app.
My understanding of this lifetime risk assessment number
was basically the thing that made all of that happen, right?
Otherwise you would not have found out
about this cancer until much later.
And I think you have another story
that you can tell us about,
which is a patient of yours who's gone public
about her story, which is actress Olivia Munn.
And I understand that for her also,
this lifetime risk assessment number was critical.
Could you maybe give us a high level outline of that?
And then we'll talk through into what this can mean
for people who are listening today.
And I have so many stories like Olivia Munn,
but I'm so proud of her because she used her platform
to bring awareness to it.
Someone like me or my patients, we don't have a voice,
but she obviously does.
And she made a huge difference.
Basically, she just had her baby.
She was done breastfeeding.
I did genetic testing.
She didn't have any gene mutations.
I sent her for a mammogram and ultrasound.
Her mammogram was negative.
Her ultrasound was negative.
I calculated her lifetime risk of breast cancer
because of her family history, dense breast,
age at first child, the whole list that I just mentioned.
And her risk was about 37, 38%, similar to mine.
So I called her to my office and I said,
you fall into the high risk category.
You have to do an additional MRI.
And she said, of course, she's so smart.
She's just an amazing woman.
So she went, she did her MRI.
And of course they called her.
They're like, we saw something.
They biopsied it.
It came back cancer.
Then I sent her to Dr. Giuliano.
Dr. Giuliano had the MRI reread
and they found another cancer in the other breast
with the second read.
So at this point she had multiple breast cancers,
small, but very, very aggressive,
negative mammogram, negative ultrasound,
negative genetic tests.
She's had a standard mammogram.
She's also had like a genetic test
for whether she's at high risk.
All of that says it's fine,
but you then run this lifetime risk assessment
and said, actually your lifetime risk assessment
is really high.
So I want to go and do this other test, this MRI test.
And that has picked up this like very early cancer,
but also this like, you know, very dangerous cancer.
So everything would have been completely different
had we not done the MRI.
Unlike me, she had a very aggressive cancer,
but because we caught it so early,
she came to my office and she's like, what would you do?
And I said, listen, at your age,
I just delivered your baby.
You have a tiny little child at home.
You have bilateral breast cancer, very aggressive.
You have family history of it.
Take your breasts off.
And she's like, I want to do what you tell me.
I'm like, if I were you, obviously I did it for myself,
but that's what I recommend.
And thank God she did it.
She had amazing results.
Dr. Giuliano did her mastectomy.
She had reconstructive surgery.
You know, it took her a minute to recover from the trauma.
Again, you have a little baby at home.
Someone tells you you have cancer
when your mammogram and ultrasounds are all negative.
But I think in spring of last year,
she decided to share her journey,
which basically, I think, honestly,
she started a revolution,
not only in this country, but around the world,
basically bringing awareness to early detection,
this lifetime risk assessment, genetic testing,
and all things breast cancer related.
So I'm so proud of her.
You know, everything happens for a reason in life.
And I always say,
when something traumatic happens to you in life,
go down that path and you'll see
why you were placed on that path.
And I think both, you know, Olivia and myself,
we found our calling.
Thank you for sharing both of those stories,
which I think are very powerful.
Before we move to talking about
how you do this lifetime risk assessment,
I just wanted to ask about the genetic risk,
because this is the experience that happened
with my family friend,
where there was something that's very high genetic risk,
which was what triggered the decision
to have this mastectomy.
Because in both these stories,
the genetic test wasn't positive.
Like how important is genetic testing?
Very, very good question.
So less than 5% of breast cancers
are associated with a genetic mutation, less than five.
So majority of people who get breast cancer
do not have a genetic mutation.
So please don't tell me, I don't have it in my family,
I'm not gonna get breast cancer.
That's completely false.
Two, if you have any kind of cancer in your family,
if it's pancreatic cancer, if it's prostate cancer,
if it's colon, uterus, ovary, breast,
ask your doctor for a genetic test.
In the United States, the genetic tests are about $249.
That's it.
You know, I always compare it to going to Disneyland.
You go to Disneyland, every ticket costs that much.
I'm saying one genetic test,
one time in your life can save your life.
Why am I saying this?
For example, if you have a parent with pancreatic cancer
or ovarian cancer, you could have a gene mutation.
Most people recognize the BRCA gene
that's associated with pancreatic,
breast and ovary and melanoma.
So some members of the family could have a melanoma.
Others could have the pancreatic cancer.
Do the genetic test.
It doesn't always have to be breast to do a genetic test.
Are you saying that everyone should do the genetic test?
If you have family history.
If you have a family history, you'd be pushing it.
If someone in the family has it,
you're saying you should definitely do it.
Absolutely.
But if you don't have it in your family,
it doesn't mean you're not gonna have breast cancer.
You still need to calculate your lifetime risk
of breast cancer, especially if you've had a breast biopsy
that showed atypia.
And atypia means?
Atypical cells in the breast that are not cancer yet.
If you're a man listening to this,
is this story about genetic tests only relevant for women
or is it something that you would be saying
that men should be doing as well?
Absolutely.
It's for men and women.
For example, if you told me I have three daughters at home
and my mom had ovarian cancer,
I would ask you to do genetic testing
because if you don't have it,
then your children are protected at least from your side.
But then we have to also ask your partners,
you know, family history.
So it's for men and women.
In that case, it sounds like the man himself
is not likely to get risk.
So today, if you're a man worried about your own cancer risk,
do these genes make a meaningful difference?
So you're saying for either side?
Absolutely.
It can cause prostate, it can be pancreatic cancer,
it can be colon cancer.
So it can be all sorts.
Melanoma can affect all of us.
And majority of the time in the US,
believe it or not, insurance will pay for these patients
to do genetic testing.
I think in my practice, 93% of patients are covered annually.
So I'd love now to get into this lifetime risk assessment
because I think you've definitely
provide a whole new perspective
on sort of taking more control over this yourself
and understanding what you can do.
So I imagine there's a lot of listeners right now
who are saying, okay,
how can I calculate my lifetime risk assessment?
So the best formula to use that I use all the time,
it's probably the most accurate, easy to use,
women can do it at home.
It's the Tire Cusick Risk Assessment Tool.
I actually put a copy of it free of charge
on my CMD podcast page.
People can go there,
they can calculate their lifetime risk.
You basically have to enter some personal information
about yourself, height, weight, age at first period,
age at first pregnancy, whether or not you're menopausal,
if you've been taking hormones, family history,
density of the breast.
And once you answer all the questions,
you hit calculate and it'll tell you
what that risk score is.
And I have videos explaining what each category is
and what kind of imaging they need to do.
Well, firstly, we will put a link in the show notes,
both the assessment tool and also to your site
to help to understand that.
Is this something that generally anyone listening to this
can do themselves?
So I heard you mentioned things like the breast density
and you've also told me
that I can't figure that out for myself.
But if they can pull their mammogram images and ask,
I would say, if you are young,
you probably have dense breast, right?
Younger patients have dense breast tissue.
I want everyone to calculate their lifetime risk
of breast cancer by age 30.
30 is when we start imaging.
If you have strong family history of ovarian, pancreatic
or breast cancer, two of the 48 cancer-causing genes
are BRCA1 and 2.
Those patients need to start breast imaging at age 25.
So you calculate your lifetime risk of breast cancer.
And if you can't do it, ask your doctor to do it.
A lot of times, believe it or not, especially in the U.S.,
the radiologists will do that for you.
The problem is the radiologists don't sometimes
get all the information about you.
Like, you know, first pregnancy or, you know,
some personal history they don't have,
but they try to calculate that
tyrocusic risk score for you.
But it's something patients can absolutely do on their own.
It's pretty simple and straightforward.
Once you calculate that risk score, then, you know,
we talked about average risk being 12.5.
Low risk category is anyone under 15%.
So if your lifetime risk of breast cancer is less than 15%,
you fall into the lower risk category.
In America, you can start your breast imaging at 40
or 10 years before your first degree relative
was diagnosed with breast cancer.
And if you have dense breast tissue,
you have to ask your doctor for a breast ultrasound.
So that's for 15% and below.
From 15 to 20%, that's the intermediate risk category.
This is when, basically in my practice,
I treat every patient differently.
But knowing that they fall into that intermediate risk,
I might start their mammogram a little bit earlier,
maybe get a baseline at 35.
If they have dense breast, I do an ultrasound with it.
And if they have any family history,
I start the imaging 10 years before the age
of that family member who was diagnosed with breast cancer.
And the most important group for me are patients
who fall into the high risk category,
which is 20% or higher.
20% or higher patients need to start
their breast imaging as early as 30.
By the way, this will never happen in your country,
in the UK.
That's the problem, right?
Early detection.
So everyone gets pushed, like, you know,
much, much later, forgetting that we're missing
these high risk patients at a very young age.
And that's why sometimes people are shocked
that so-and-so at age 38 got stage four breast cancer.
And, you know, sometimes when I watch TV
and I see these actresses at a young age getting diagnosed
or dying from breast cancer,
someone probably didn't do genetic testing on them
and didn't calculate their lifetime risk.
So that's how important it is.
And so one of the things I guess I'm taking away
from this is, in a way, the progress of science
and medicine today is meaning that we can be more
personalized about this than before.
You're not saying every single woman should be being
screened at 30.
You're saying we can really differentiate now
low risk and high risk.
And then if you're in this high risk group,
you should be screened really aggressively.
And indeed, you're talking about the fact that you're,
you know, your own decision was my risk is so high
that I'm going to take this like very serious
preemptive surgery because of your confidence
in that level of the personalization
and understanding of the risk.
So this is quite a profound shift in terms of something,
I guess it's something we're really passionate about,
which is this ability to sort of take control
of your health and personalize it
before you're really sick.
And you're saying that actually we are now able
in this area to use this information and, you know,
everything that we've learned over decades
to be able to no longer treat everybody
in exactly the same way.
Absolutely.
And for the high risk patients,
when they start as early as 30,
we usually alternate mammogram and ultrasound
with an MRI a few months later.
Because in high risk patients,
mammogram alone can miss breast cancer.
So you add MRI to make sure you basically
bring that 80% detection to much, much higher,
especially for high risk patients.
What are the things that tend to push somebody
into this high risk?
Because you said that you were really high risk.
And now I'm hearing, you know, your number was 36%.
You're now saying even at 20%, 37, I apologize.
Even 20% was high risk.
But you also said, I haven't been drinking,
I haven't been smoking.
So what were the things, you know,
somebody's listened to this.
The most common reason why people get pushed
above 20% is family history.
That's probably obesity, early period, late menopause.
Patients who don't have children are at a higher risk.
Pregnancy is protective.
Breastfeeding is protective.
If you have children after 30, that gets affected.
Genetic mutations, dense breast tissue.
Patients who have extremely dense breasts,
it pushes it way high.
There's so many different factors.
In my case, it was just that atypical lobular hyperplasia,
which is the atypical cells,
that pushes your lifetime risk really high.
Every person's risk factors are different.
The last thing I want to add is for very high risk patients,
which in my world, that's 35% and above.
Sometimes, you know, I had a patient yesterday,
her lifetime risk is 30%,
but every single woman in her family had breast cancer.
So someone like her, I would be more prone
to treat and reduce that risk.
If you have a very high lifetime risk,
let's say 30 to 35% and above,
you only have three options the way I look at it.
Number one, you alternate mammogram and ultrasound
with an MRI every six months, and you do a lot of praying.
And you pray that you don't get breast cancer.
And you pray that your doctors will diagnose it.
Breast imaging, I'm really excited
about artificial intelligence reading these images
because hopefully we're going to have more accurate reading
so someone like me, where my lesion was sitting on my MRI,
doesn't get dismissed.
That's number one.
Number two, patients have the option
of taking a medication like tamoxifen.
I don't know if you've heard of it,
but you know, once you get diagnosed
with estrogen-receptive positive cancer,
a lot of us have to take tamoxifen
to basically block the estrogen receptors.
And taking tamoxifen every day for five years
can significantly reduce your risk of breast cancer,
maybe by 50% in the next 10 years.
So that's an option.
And the third option, which is what I opted for,
is a double mastectomy if you don't really want
to do that imaging every six months,
which is pretty tough to go through.
MRIs are not easy to do.
Breast MRIs, you need a contrast.
Mammograms are not easy.
And honestly, to go through it
and have to wait for the results
and be anxious twice a year about it is pretty challenging.
And that's why, you know,
it's a very, very personal decision.
I never tell someone do it or not do it.
I just tell them what I would do if I were them.
But with a strong family history or a high lifetime risk,
I think double mastectomy is a good option.
The problem with double mastectomy
is A, having access to a doctor.
Not everyone can afford it.
Not everyone has access to a good reconstructive surgeon.
So I understand those limitations.
It's not for everyone,
but at least I want them to know
that there are medications they can take for five years
to reduce that risk significantly.
I would like to move to listener questions.
So first question is,
can the food you eat influence your risk of breast cancer?
Absolutely.
I think obesity is one of the underlying conditions
for breast cancer.
So, you know, processed food, animal products,
you know, we talked about smoking, alcohol,
all of that can affect it.
Absolutely.
Does taking hormonal birth control or HRT
increase your risk?
And how big a concern should this be?
It's not a concern.
It probably can very, very slightly,
but not significant enough.
Having said that, it's individual.
Patients need to talk to their doctors.
Every patient has a different risk factor
that needs to be dealt with.
For example, if someone has a lifetime risk of,
I don't know, 50% for breast cancer.
For the vast majority of people who are listening to this,
it sounds like you're saying that that's safe.
It's very safe.
It can slightly increase their risk,
but not significant enough.
Having said that, for example,
I don't want someone whose grandmother had breast cancer,
whose lifetime risk is 20% not to take hormone replacement
during menopause and have, you know, poor quality life
with hot flashes and vaginal dryness
and all these other symptoms
because they're scared of taking hormone replacement.
I think that's really interesting
because I know there's a lot of debate about this.
And so it's interesting hearing you being so strong
about the risks here.
I assume you're saying that somehow you view the benefits
from these to really outweigh the risks.
Yes, especially if anyone's gone through menopause.
I mean, I'm sitting here having a hot flash.
I can't take hormone replacement.
I'm on anti-estrogen, the opposite of it.
But if you have the option, it's life-changing.
So you don't have to have a hot flash doing a podcast.
Well, firstly, thank you for sharing that.
One of the things we talk a lot about on the podcast
is how much no one is willing to talk about menopause.
So I appreciate it.
And you're performing great.
So I think you should be feeling good about it.
Final question from listeners, are all lumps,
whether you feel them in your breasts or armpit, worrisome?
As a patient, I would say you can't decide.
Let your doctor decide.
Some lumps are concerning, majority are not.
So you can have a swollen lymph node
because you got a flu shot on that arm that day,
or you got your COVID vaccine.
You can have a cyst, which are very, very common.
Fibrocystic changes of the breasts are very, very common.
Fibroadenomas are benign tumors of the breast
in younger women.
But generally speaking, cancer tumors don't really move.
They're stuck.
So if something is mobile, it's probably nothing.
But I would always tell my patients to call me, come in,
let me examine, and let me decide
if I need to order a breast ultrasound or imaging.
The one thing I will tell you,
no one is too young for breast imaging.
Got it.
So even if you feel like you're just too young
for this to possibly be cancer, go and see a doctor.
I've had a 22-year-old with breast cancer
with no gene mutation.
Any lump needs to be evaluated by a gynecologist
or a primary care doctor.
And you're saying that most of the time,
the doctor is gonna tell you you're fine,
so don't immediately panic.
But on the other hand, don't ignore it
because you can't judge for yourself.
There isn't some magic way that you can figure out
at home whether this is okay or not.
No, I would say trust your doctor.
So I'd just like to finish with asking you
what advice you have for women who are struggling
to advocate for themselves in the doctor's office,
because you're telling a story where you found this hard,
and I think it's pretty clear to anyone listening to this
that you're a pretty powerful and strong-willed doctor
with all this advice and knowledge and all the rest of it,
and you found that hard.
And many people listening won't have any of that.
They may indeed be in health systems
where they've got less ability to just sort of have control.
What would you say to anyone listening to this
who's saying, well, how can I advocate for myself?
I would say I hear you, I get you.
It happened to me.
It's not easy.
It starts with education.
That's why I started my podcast.
That's why I'm on this podcast.
Basically, you have to educate yourself.
In order to be your own health advocate,
you have to educate.
The problem is once you educate yourself
and you empower yourself and you know what you have to do
and you go to your doctor,
you have to find the doctor who actually listens,
who has the time, who takes you seriously,
who doesn't call you crazy,
who doesn't dismiss your symptoms.
If you're lucky enough to find that doctor,
the problem with the healthcare system,
we're overwhelmed with patients.
We don't have time, right?
So if you're lucky enough to find a doctor
who's listening to you and really taking you seriously,
then the next step is being able to afford
the prescriptions that they write for.
Does your insurance cover your MRI?
Does your insurance cover your ultrasound?
My MRI after I was diagnosed with breast cancer was $3,000.
Do you understand that?
Being able to afford the treatment
is the next limiting factor.
So there's so many levels that we get stuck
in this healthcare system,
but I would say educate yourself.
If something doesn't feel right, get a second opinion,
get a third opinion, find a doctor who specializes in that.
If you have a breast lump and you have family history of it,
if you need genetic testing,
find someone who will take you seriously
and listen to your complaint.
Thais, thank you so much.
We'll always try and end with a quick summary.
So I'm going to try and do a summary
and I'd like you to just correct me where I got this wrong.
When I think back across the show,
I think the biggest thing I take away is
do a lifetime risk assessment for breast cancer
by the time you're 30.
And if you're after 30, like do it immediately.
It's I think the biggest story because, you know,
your own story is so powerful about this idea
that you felt like you're doing everything right,
you're low risk, you're literally a doctor
who is looking after women who can have breast cancer.
And then you suddenly did this and you're like,
I'm at 37% and suddenly that transformed
the way you're thinking about it.
Then this story is sort of fighting to get the treatment
that you're basically saying you feel people at this level
should very seriously consider because if not,
they've got other very intrusive solutions.
And then when you did it, you're like, thank God I did
because actually it turned out you already had cancer
and thank you for telling that story,
which I can tell is still really understandably emotional
and raw and anyone listening to that would have felt that
and I can understand this also,
this idea of having one's children and all the rest of it.
So it's really powerful.
I think the other big takeaway from this is therefore,
you need to be more of your own health advocate
because probably in health systems,
whether it's in the States or the UK or anywhere,
they're not really designed today for this level
of differentiation of risk, like the ability to tell
that somebody might be this very low risk, right?
Below 10% or they're above 30%.
And so sort of our screening is designed
for sort of this average level.
And it's therefore going to probably spend too much time
on people who are very low risk and not enough
on the people who are high risk.
And this is, it seems to me your big message
is that we can really determine a lot more now
about who's high risk and it doesn't require
some incredibly complicated imaging to figure out this risk.
Actually, you're saying that you can go onto a website
and fill in this information and give you this answer.
The other thing I took away was this story
that if you have any family history of cancer,
take a genetic test, you're like,
it costs the same as going to Disney World
for the day or something, and it could save your life.
And I think you talked about this,
this BRCA, this BRCA gene, for example.
Which is two of the 48 cancer-causing genes.
There are many cancer-causing genes.
People say, oh, I've been tested for BRCA.
That's not enough.
You need the full panel.
There's CHECK2 that gives you 50% chance.
PALB2 gene mutation that gives you a 50% chance.
So there are other gene mutations
that can increase your risk of breast cancer.
And then the final thing I took away
was you were actually really quite strong
that for most women, hormonal birth control or HRT
is safe, that although there is like a statistical increase
in the risk to do with breast cancer,
your view is that this is on absolute terms is very small.
But opposite of that, I do worry about alcohol.
I do worry about smoking.
I do worry when patients are overweight.
I do worry about lack of exercise.
So those factors are so much more important.
Sleep, low stress, all of that is much more important
than worrying about that birth control pill
that you took for two years in your life.
And where does food fit in that list?
Very important.
I let you have a full podcast on gut microbiome
and our health in general, right?
Our gut microbiome is linked to our insulin resistance.
As we get older, insulin resistance
can cause us to gain weight.
Weight gain can cause everything is related.
So it all starts with food.