The Fragonard Project: The Swing

Rococo Art (c.1720-1780)
4 followers
32 Video Views·Jul 13, 2025
Between 2019 and 2021, five of the Wallace Collection’s eight paintings by Jean-Honoré Fragonard were cleaned and restored. This project has led to new discoveries about Fragonard’s working methods and provides the possibility for new interpretations of his work. Join our Head of Curatorial and Curator of French Paintings, Dr Yuriko Jackall, as she discusses this project and gives her reading of The Swing and its place in Fragonard’s career. She will also describe the long shadow of Fragonard’s influence, and how the ups and downs of his glittering career indelibly shaped the way in which we understand his art and the rococo aesthetic today.
You've undoubtedly already seen the painting, The Swing, in one form or another.
We're told by the 18th century writer Charles Collet that starving artist Jean-Honoré Fragonard
was approached by an unnamed gentleman of the court with a commission so scandalous
that another painter had already rejected it outright. Collet's account came directly from
Gabrielle François-Doyen, the painter who had passed on the project, and it went as follows.
A gentleman of the court sent for me in order to commission a painting.
He was at his pleasure house, or petit maison, with his mistress when I presented myself.
I should like, he said, to have you paint madame, pointing to his mistress, on a swing that a bishop
would push. You will paint me in such a way that I would be able to see the legs of this lovely girl,
and better still, if you want to enliven your picture a little more.
Although he refused to deliver the desired composition, Doyen did suggest a witty addition.
The lady's shoes should come off and be caught by a band of flying cupids. It is rare for such
unusual and specific instructions to have come down to us, and it seems at first that Fragonard
stuck painstakingly to his brief. Most of the desired elements were there, from the frothy
billowing skirt, to the arched stocking foot, to the cushioned swing. Even Doyen's proposal is
partially incorporated. A tiny shoe flies through the air under the watchful eyes of the statue
menacing cupid. This painted detail was modeled upon the statue with which the sculptor Falconet
had shown to considerable acclaim at the Salon of 1757. On the surface, it is difficult to imagine
a more fitting representation of the final years of France's Ancien Régime than the scene of love
in a secluded rural setting, captured at the crucial moment just before a pink satin shoe drops.
And indeed, during the so-called Rococo revival of the 19th century, with its nostalgic outpourings
of affection for the wit and opulence of courtly life, the swing was held up as emblematic of the
lost aristocratic pleasures and the bygone playfulness of the pre-industrial era. It was, in other words,
made synonymous with the Rococo style, typically described as a highly decorative aesthetic
founded upon the principles of asymmetry, illusion, and wit. In the 20th century, the painting's
risque glamour and mischievous playfulness were harnessed by just about everyone, from fashion
designer Vivian Westwood to shoe designer Manolo Blahnik to cheesemaker Petit Munster. Today, from
our 21st century vantage point, the discussions that we're now able to have about art complicate
how we see the swing and the Rococo lifestyle it embodies. Social tensions run high, concerns about
sustainability trump luxury, and the voyeuristic act inscribed at the heart of the painting
can be seen to fly in the face of the advances wrought by the Me Too movement. In 2011, the
installation artist Yinka Shonibare restaged the central female figure as a headless form,
clad in African print wax textiles. This was a literal allusion to the fate of the French
aristocrats who lost their lives to the guillotine, but may also suggest the head-turning extravagance
of the Ancien Regime that had resulted in a loss of reason, of morality. The decision to
clothe his headless protagonist in African prints mirrors the decorative quality of the original
dress, while emphasizing the constructed nature of the wearer's identity, which is perhaps defined
on terms that are not her own. One might imagine that the degree to which the woman possesses agency
or not would give rise to heated debate, given the unbridled intensity with which the man looks
up the woman's dress, the seeming complicity of this woman who has kicked off her own shoe,
the disingenuous way in which the artist has served up and papered over the problematic scene
in incongruously pretty pastel hues. But here's the funny thing I've noticed about the swing.
People don't actually look at the painting. I'm showing the swing as it used to hang
in the oval drawing room, slightly lost in a sea of beautiful works by François Boucher.
Somewhere between Manolo Blahnik and Disney movies, it seems to have taken on the dubious
honor of being flattened into a chocolate box poster, an image. Everyone knows it appears in
the film Frozen or in a Mariah Carey music video, but they forget it's an actual work of art.
One that has been called one of the greatest paintings of all time.
One that hangs on the walls of a national museum. I wasn't planning on working on the swing.
I came to the Wallace just after organizing the exhibition, Fragonard, the Fantasy Figures,
at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC. And I felt that I had said what I had to say
about this artist, at least for the moment. Nonetheless, I was fascinated by the strange
push and pull between the swing's status as an icon and its complete detachment from anything
that concerns us today. From a curatorial and educational perspective, it was a fascinating
challenge. How does one speak about a work like this to young people, specifically to young women?
How does one make relevant and interesting a painting like this, and by extension the Rococo
period in general? Proposing responses to these questions has been something of a driving force
for me over the past three years. A few months ago, we began the final phase of a project
involving the swing that has been a long time in the making. It was the culminating stage of
a capital initiative to improve the so-called inner loop galleries at the Wallace Collection.
These are the second floor drawing rooms that display the majority of art collections of 18th
century French art. Paintings by the likes of Watteau, Lancret, Gros, or Boilly. Furniture by Riesner,
porcelain by the South Manufacturing. The project has entailed cleaning the silks and the curtains,
sanding out the chandeliers for rewiring, and installing new directional LED lighting throughout
nine galleries of art. And I'm showing you here a before picture, before the works occurred of our
small drawing room where Watteau reigns supreme, followed by an after picture which shows how much
more evenly the light is now distributed over the works of art. This push has also involved
extensive conservation, whether to preemptively protect or to restore our works of art.
Most logistically challenging was when Francois Boucher's enormous canvases, the rising and setting
of the sun, came off the wall to be gently surface cleaned, a process that entailed building a
temporary platform over our main staircase. Over the past couple of years, the generous support of
a group of benefactors has also enabled us to conserve four works by Fragonard, thereby ensuring
that the artist was looking his absolute best in his representation at the Wallace Collection.
The fifth and final painting by Fragonard on the list for treatment was, of course, The Swing.
We thought hard about how to go about approaching this work. Happily for us, a grant from Bank of
America enabled us to purchase the equipment necessary to conserve the work on site in one
of our upstairs furniture conservation studios. While we typically need to outsource our painting
conservation projects, keeping The Swing on site was of crucial importance, given its status and
importance to the collection. Thanks to the work of former head of the National Gallery's
Conservation Department, Martin Wild, The Swing went back on the wall earlier this month. It's now
hung with our ensemble of paintings by Fragonard, a total of eight works that span the entire
evolution of his career, from his student days up until the last years of the Ancien Regime.
Up until now, these works have been dispersed over three different galleries,
but visually and conceptually, it has felt much more impactful to install them together.
Looking at The Swing, if people have gotten out of the habit of seeing The Swing,
this is also because the painting has not looked its best for a very long time. In the 19th century,
the Goncourt brothers complained about its condition, stating,
what remains after harsh cleaning and repainting has the true air of a passing copy.
And it has been more than 30 years since the Wallace Collection's former director,
John Ingemels, mentioned in print the thick discolored varnish that until recently covered
its surface. In the past, one way to keep the work on the wall was to re-saturate its surface
through the addition of more and more varnish. And the removal of these layers has resulted
in a dramatic change. Cleaning has brightened the colors and sharpened the details immeasurably,
reminding us of the sheer force of this artist's technical prowess.
What was less expected was that the newly visible details inject more ambiguous and
complicated dimension to the painting than has previously been thought. Nothing has surfaced to
make us doubt the circumstances of the commission, nor its careful stipulations. The agreed upon
details, woman, dress, swing, shoe, are all present. But there's also enough to suggest
that the painting was designed to open itself to other narratives, several, in fact. The man
who activates the swing is now clearly visible. His face, as he looks up toward the woman, is
unmistakably aged, the evident discoloration of his teeth and skin in sharp contrast to the
luminous complexion of the young woman. He has been described as a bishop, an obscure accomplice,
even as a gardener whose abandoned rake lies in the foreground. The shimmering blue touches on
the fabric of his suit suggest a richer fabric than has previously been thought.
Certainly, he does not wear the black robes of a clergyman, but he also does not seem to be a
manservant, pressed into entertaining his superiors. At the same time, his improved wardrobe does not
promise a better outcome for him. Water bubbles over the surface of the bench and will soon drench
the elegant black hat that rests beside him. If he seems oblivious to the impending damage to his hat,
the little white dog at his feet seems all too aware. Previously, this small animal had appeared
simply excited in parallel with the animated movements of the woman on the swing. Now he
seems furious, eyes blazing, jaw hanging open. Perhaps he belongs to the older man rather than
the younger woman. And if there is a little stream at the foot of the bench, which the presence of
water flowing from under putti on a dolphin suggests, we're made to understand that the
dog is in an unstable position. His front paws rest on the trellis, but his hind legs are balanced
at the edge of the stream, if they're not already in it. On the other side of the painting, the
figure lying under the sign of Balcony's menacing cupid has also benefited from cleaning. His
gray suit has gained a smart blue lining. His face has attained an unmistakable flush of pink.
And his figure has achieved a new physicality. Whereas previously his outstretched arm seemed
merely to hail the beauty swinging toward him, we see now that it also holds the rose bushes
out of the way so that he can see her more clearly. And as one realizes how encompassing
these bushes are, another question surfaces. Are the two men conscious of each other? In fact,
it may well be that the woman and the dog are the only ones in the painting fully aware of
what's going on. And as for the woman, as layers of varnish were removed, it became clear the
lengths to which Fragonard went to make sure that she was in the very center of the composition,
framed at every side by twisting lines that converge on her dynamic figure.
She's now more sensual, less doll-like than had been realized, with the contours of her body now
clearly on display, and a gentle undertone of blue evoking the pulse of blood under her flesh.
The elegance of her dress is matched by the opulence of the swing on which she sits.
The seat seems to be upholstered in soft velvet affixed to a gilded wooden base.
But the ropes that bind the seat to the tree are coarse and thick, and what's more, they're starting
to fray. And the surprising contrast between the elegant seat and the coarse ropes is echoed in her
gesture, which initially seemed to playfully imitate that of Falcone's Cupid, but now seems
a gesture of a different sort, because her little finger is raised as well as her index finger.
This hand movement is reminiscent of the earthy gestures then associated with Naples,
and popularized by Fragonard's contemporary, Jean-Baptiste Greuze, in paintings of Italian
peasant life. It seems specifically incongruous with the mannered elegance of this lady's dress.
And what about the space where this all takes place? There seems to be a fountain in the
background, perhaps reminiscent of the fantastic water theater of the Villa d'Este, where Fragonard
spent a summer drawing in the company of fellow artist Hubert Robert and their patron, the Abbé de
Saint-Nom. Against this distant fountain is silhouetted what may be an embracing couple,
hinting at some kind of outdoor gathering, hinting of the pleasurable activities that will follow
the game of the swing. And because typically we would be doing this lecture in a lecture theater
with a pointer so that I could show you all what exactly I'm talking about, I just ask you to look
slightly to the right of the pedestal on which Menace and Cupid sits, and you can see the
embracing couple. And then directly behind that embracing couple, you see this sort of enormous
fall of water, which I think comes from a sort of jet d'eau, one of these huge fountains that
Fragonard would have seen in Italy. For me, some of the broad questions raised by this painting can
be summarized as follows. Are we meant to read anything into the color of the woman's dress?
In the 18th century, pink was closely associated with a royal mistress, Madame de Pompadour.
But it was also worn regularly by male protagonists. The young man in the swing wears pink flowers in
his lapel. Who are the three main characters and what is their relationship? How does their dress
relate to their status within the painting and to their walk in life? How playful is this painting,
really? And finally, to what extent should this work be read in conjunction with 18th century
Libertine literature? Specifically, the descriptions by the likes of Crébillon or Vivant de Nont
of sophisticated parties in the estates of Chateau outside of Paris. To explore these strands further,
I invited five scholars and five artists or art practitioners to participate in a series of
forthcoming conversations entitled Swing Time, serendipitous conversations about the Rococo.
The program kicked off on November 8th with a conversation about the color pink
with curator Valerie Steele and artist Flora Yukonovich. These speakers represent a diverse
range of professional and lived experiences, but they all engage with the Rococo in their
daily working lives and shape their own visions of it. For instance, Turner Prize nominated artist
Catherine Yass, who will be speaking on Monday, 23rd November, is currently gathering material
for her own artistic response to the painting. Our other speaker for the same talk, Rosalind McIver,
is working on male fashions and identity in her upcoming show for the Victoria and Albert Museum.
The talk on fashion features haute couture designer Samy Nouri, who arrived in France
as a refugee from Afghanistan, trained with John Galliano and Jean-Paul Gaultier,
and now runs his own atelier in Paris. French specialist of libertine literature and
member of the Académie Française, Chantal Thomas, is also a novelist who places women at the heart of her
works, such as Les Adieux à la Reine, or Farewell My Queen, about the last days of Marie Antoinette
at the Château de Versailles. I hope that bringing together their diverse voices in these talks,
which are free thanks to the Bank of America grant, will open up larger conversations about
the relevance of the painting and the Rococo aesthetic in general. Now, in the time remaining
to me, I want to focus in on my reading of the picture and begin to sketch out the direction
that I'm taking in my own forthcoming response to this complex work. As we've seen, the conservation
project has revealed the extent to which Fragonard lovingly enriched his painting with sumptuous
detail. In the process, it has given us more information about the players who make up this work,
whether human, animal, or statuary. But there are also those who are named but unseen,
who have left their mark within and around the territory of the painted surface.
This starts not with a name, but with a place, the Petit Maison, or pleasure house, to which the
unnamed gentleman of the court invited the artist Joyen. The term Petit Maison translates
literally to little house. In the 18th century, such diminutive structures with beautifully disposed
gardens proliferated in the outskirts of the French capital, in suburbs such as Bercy, Passy,
Plichy, or Montrouge. And I'm showing you here an example of one such pleasure house, the Château de
Bagatelle in the Bois de Boulogne, which was built in 1775 by the Comte d'Arcoy. And of course, it's a place that has
other significance for the Wallace collection, as has been discussed by various colleagues of mine
over the years. Thanks to their locations, the Petit Maison were easily accessible from Paris.
But they also offered secrecy and privacy, a space for the types of interactions that could blossom
away from the curious and insistent gaze of Parisian society. In these secluded spaces,
desire was given free reign. In fact, the liberty novella La Petite Maison by Jean-François de Bastide,
published in 1758 and again in 1763, so just four years before Fragonard's painting The Swing,
La Petite Maison describes the seduction of a young woman as the direct result of her visit
to an admirer's Petite Maison. She finds herself overwhelmed not by his charms, but by the sensory
pleasures aroused by the unmistakable luxury of the house itself. And so this is an illustration
given to a 19th century edition of the book, and it shows this very sort of enclosed interior with
beautiful furniture and boiserie and lighting. It's a space of seduction and of luxury.
Despite their diminutive size, these houses were synonymous not just with pleasure, but
indeed with luxury. And in fact, one satirical text dating from the 1750s suggested their
liquidation, so selling off all of the Petit Maison around Paris, could solve France's national
debt crisis. The author went on to remark, one only needs an income of 30,000 livres
to maintain a large house. To maintain a Petite Maison, one needs 100,000 livres at the very
minimum. They are usually havens of pleasure and wealth. As a result, such houses were the
preserve of wealthy aristocrats, the very upper echelons of the bourgeoisie, and the nouveau riche
tax farmers, or garmiers généraux, as they were called. This brings us naturally to the
mysterious patron, the unnamed gentleman of the court who commissioned the swing.
In 1860, this man was identified by the art historian Roger Portalis as one Saint-Julien,
a collector who owned other key works by Fragonard, notably the Collin-Maillard and
La Bascule, so Blind Man's Buff and The Seesaw, both scenes of play in a garden setting.
But in 1989, this theory of Saint-Julien was debunked by none other than John Ingemaus,
who pointed out rightly that Portalis was partially basing his assertion on a non-existent sale.
Moreover, those who took up the identification in Portalis' wake went on to confuse La Bascule,
a representation of two lovers and a seesaw, with L'Escarpolette or The Swing, and say that
the La Bascule, which was indeed listed in one sale by Saint-Julien, although not the one,
as Ingemaus pointed out, to which everyone was referring, that this painting was in fact
L'Escarpolette, whereas it's a different work altogether. So Ingemaus set the record straight
in 1989, but he was unable to propose another name in place of Saint-Julien, and the identity
of the patron continues to this day to remain maddeningly elusive. Barring the discovery of
new archival material, it may prove impossible to clinch definitively, although I do hope not,
but we'll see. Nonetheless, a closer look at the two names that have always been associated with
this painting does give us, as we wait for a new discovery, does give us flickers of understanding
about the personality conjured up in Collet's anecdote, the gentleman of the court wealthy
enough to own a petite maison. So I suggest that by looking at these two names, we can start to
at least understand the motivations of the collector, even as his identity still remains
a mystery. The first name is, of course, the man who for so many years was identified as the
commissioner of the swing, Saint-Julien. His full name, David-François Beaulieu-Baron d'Argentin,
Seigneur de Saint-Julien, who is shown here in a portrait by Carmontel, approximately two years
before the swing was commissioned, at which time the sitter was about 52 years of age.
One reason the identification has continued to resonate is that Saint-Julien held the powerful
charge of presseur du clergé de France, that is, collector of taxes on behalf of the French
church. He would therefore have had a ready interest in the goings-on of France's powerful
first estate, and perhaps he would even humorously wish to see a bishop painted into his picture.
The second name associated with the painting is that of another tax farmer,
François-Marie Ménage de Pressigny. We know that this gentleman is the first certain owner of the
swing because the work was catalogued in his collection in 1794, at the height of the terror.
This was the year in which all of his possessions were seized by the French
revolutionary government. Ménage de Pressigny himself was executed by guillotine on the charge
of having adulterated tobacco with water and other substances. We know that Ménage de Pressigny
had a connection to Fragonard because he owned the painting of which I'm showing you here,
the engraving. You can see at the bottom that in the letter of the engraving, the dedication
of the engraving, that is, Nicolas Delunay, who has engraved it, has made the dedication to
Ménage de Pressigny in his status as the owner of the work. Would either of these men have
owned a petite maison? They certainly had the financial wherewithal to do so. Saint-Julien's
position in the church made him wildly wealthy. He was known for having the most sumptuous dining
room in the French capital, a room, it was said ironically, in which 120 priests could gather to
discuss articles of faith. Saint-Julien was also known for having made numerous improvements to his
wife's estate, the Château de la Fontaine Française in Burgundy, of which I'm showing you the gardens
here, to the point that he transformed the venerable edifice into a palace so sparkling,
so luxurious, and so new that the lady in question is said to have taken one horrified look
at the transformation of her former ancestral home and departed for Paris post-haste.
Madame de Saint-Julien was quite resistant to the work that her husband undertook, rather
over her head it seems. Nonetheless, he had his way and transformed the estate, and a description of
the garden of the Château de la Fontaine Française, written in 1783, has come down to us. And so I quote,
Art, taste, opulence seem to have exhausted themselves in making a palace of delight.
The parks, the waters, the symmetry of the clearings in the woods, everything was done to make the
outdoors agreeable. The gardens are huge and designed with art. At each step we see interesting
and new objects. Here a humble linden tree, further on a bower of lilac and honeysuckle,
where the queen of flowers appears in all her glory and mixes her perfume with those of her
companions. These are charming spaces where one dreams of pleasure and where desire awakens in
the face of nature. So it's pure conjecture, but it's certainly tempting to imagine that the man
responsible for such a garden could easily have engineered the Italianate water theater and hidden
bowers documented with such striking painstaking detail in the swing. Now as for Ménage de
Cressigny, he was also, as we've seen, an extremely wealthy tax collector who was known to have been
unhabituated parties held at Petit Maison belonging to his friends. It was said of these gatherings
that the champagne arrived in casks, the firework displays regularly illuminated the gardens,
and the revelry went on until dawn. As is faithfully recorded in the police records of the
era, this gentleman also maintained his own establishments of his own Petit Maison at number
25 where he carried on an infamous affair with a young dancer from the Paris opera,
until that issue grew tired of his irascible character and left him at the end of eight days.
So much for the type of personality who might have commissioned the swing.
What of the artist who was invited to the Petit Maison, the one who ultimately refused the
commission? The solid Gabrielle Francois-Doyen is shown on my slide with all of the trappings of
conventional academic painting beside him. Homer's The Iliad is within easy reach, and I'm not sure
how easy it is to see here, but you can just make out the title if you look right under his,
the way in which he's holding his portfolio, and actually his, the drawing stylus that he's
holding seems to be pointing at the volume. So Homer's The Iliad is within easy reach, and the
sketch on the easel shows a scene involving the Parisian goddess Sibel. Today, Doyen is perhaps
best known for declining the opportunity to make the swing, but in 1767, when he was summoned to
the pleasure house of the unnamed gentleman of the court, he was justly famed for a very different
type of art, and that is, that pertains to the work that I'm also showing on this slide, The
Miracle of the Ardennes, which I will be discussing now. The public salon exhibition, the biennial
event at which artists displayed their greatest achievements in order to court the interest of the
public, the monarchy, and the church, had just opened a couple of months before, so before 1767,
and Doyen had emerged from this event covered in glory. His contribution to the salon of that year,
so 1767, The Miracle of Ardennes, was not only one of the largest works shown, but also one of the
most meaningful to the people of Paris. It represented Saint-Jean-Vievre, the patron saint of the city,
interceding on behalf of those stricken by an epidemic plague known as the Mal des Arts Blancs,
what we know today as ergot poisoning from ingesting fungus-infested bread. Following
the closure of the salon, it was taken to one of the transept chapels in the church of Saint-Roch
under Rue Saint-Honoré, where the painting remains to this day. That he was fresh from this triumph
doubtless explains Doyen's scandalized response in the face of the unnamed gentleman's request.
I admit, Doyen later told Collet, that this proposition, which I should never have expected
given the nature of the painting that he wanted me to do, confused and petrified me. But in fact,
before he made a name for himself as a history painter, Doyen had been heavily infatuated with
one Adelaide Louise-Pauline Huth, a well-known actress at the Comédie-Française and a notorious
courtesan. These feelings so completely overpowered him, that at one point it was publicly said that
he languished in a state of love-induced laziness, having lost all will to work. This fact should
certainly not call into question our understanding of Doyen's motives in turning down the commission
for the swing, but it does go some way toward explaining why the patron would have thought to
call upon Doyen in the first place. Not only was he an up-and-coming painter of high-minded art,
but he was also known for his open admiration for one of the most beautiful women of Paris.
In other words, on paper he appeared equipped to paint two of the commission's major requirements,
the pretty mistress and the bishop. Yet, as we know, the bishop never made it into the painting
and what is present on the canvas tells a rather different story. The swing is made with enormous
care, this much is evident from close looking, and it's finished to a high degree, even one might say
with an obsessiveness that we don't typically associate with Fragonard's highly gestural style.
But it must be said that none of the beautifully painted figures come off as particularly
sympathetic. The besotted older man with his grimacing mouth and age-spotted skin is oblivious
to everything around him, even the distress of his little dog. The young woman, who soars over the two
men, appears to have tremendous agency. It is, after all, her movements that attract attention,
and the pointed toe and outstretched leg imply that she's showing herself consensually rather
than being spied upon. But her hand gesture suggests that she uses her moment in the
spotlight to poke fun or to play the two men off against each other. And while she's clearly in
command of her sexuality, it's still from the vantage point of a child's toy. Similarly,
contradictory adjectives can be applied to the young man who lurks in the lower left of the
vigorous and amorous, but also callous, voyeuristic, and even potentially ridiculous.
For one thing, he's lying in the midst of thorny rose bushes to catch a glimpse of a woman. For
another, the bright flesh on his cheeks, which outshines even the complexion of the young woman,
is probably the result of rouge. Makeup was an affectation in which men of the period engaged,
but those who did risked being called poutimètre, or fops, and described in terms of artifice and
luxury. For Enlightenment philosopher Denis Diderot, a poutimètre was a man who wore rouge,
wigs, and dressed in the latest fashions. Diderot had harsh words for François Boucher,
Dragon Arts teacher, whose pink-cheeked painted figures appealed precisely to such a lot.
And so I quote Diderot, Boucher's elegance, his affected winsomeness, his novelistic gallantry,
his coquetry, his taste, his facility, variety, brilliance, his made-up complexions,
his debauchery, necessarily captivate poutimètre, little women, young men, the crowd of those who
are strangers to real taste, to the truth, to just ideas, and to the seriousness of art.
How could they resist the ostentation, the libertinage, the brilliancy, the pom-poms,
the bosoms, and the bottoms of Boucher? All in all, one wonders just what the unnamed gentleman
of the court thought of this work, not the one he commissioned, but the one he ultimately received.
He expected a lighthearted confection, showing a bishop abetting a love affair.
Instead, he received a bittersweet tangle of emotions, staged between three antiheroes,
a work that seems to be as much about betrayal and impending loss, and a rather sharp dig at
artifice, as about the pleasures of a summer's evening. And so here at last, we catch a glimpse
of the artist, not of the steady, reliable Joy Young, who had been asked to take on this painting
initially, but rather of the complicated, volatile one who did. Rotund, well-fed, lively,
always alert, always cheerful. These are terms used by Fragonard's biographers to describe him
in the 19th century. Are they accurate? In physical terms, Fragonard was known to be diminutive,
just under five feet, six inches, with gray eyes that appear to twinkle benevolently
in his own drawing of himself, a self-portrait now in the Musée du Louvre.
But in reality, we know very little. Fragonard left nothing in writing. He did not seem to have
kept a journal, and if he wrote letters, they do not survive today. Few archival documents exist
to provide insight into his thoughts, his doings, his motivations, his spending habits, his circle
of friends. Rare commentaries by the artist's contemporaries in the 18th century seem to
contradict the 19th century image of the jovial artist, painting a picture in which he emerges
as anxious and painfully self-aware. Mariette, the famed drawing collector, wrote tartly of his
timidity, his maddening habit of erasing his works and starting over again and again.
The powerful arts administrator Charles-Nicolas Cochon wrote of his excessive self-distrust.
A peeved client, the wealthy financier Bergeret de Grandcourt derided Fragonard as weak, a coward,
a milquetoast, an imposter, in the wake of their disastrous trip to Italy in 1773.
There is one thing we know for sure about Fragonard. Over the course of his career,
he made a habit of disregarding the wishes of powerful patrons, even to the point of stoking
severe disagreements. The list of casualties include the royal mistress, Madame de Berry,
whose commission he put off making to the point that it literally became irrelevant,
and the aforementioned financier Bergeret de Grandcourt, whose disagreement with Fragonard
resulted in a court battle, no less. It also includes the beautiful dancer, Mademoiselle
Guimard, whose spectacular fallout with Fragonard in the early 1770s would become stuff of Parisian
legend. So I'll go into a few details about that commission. Fragonard was asked to produce four
large mythological panels to decorate the grand salon of Guimard's new Hotel Particulier in Paris.
Following a disagreement over price, Fragonard left the job undone, and Mademoiselle Guimard
hired the much younger Jacques-Louis David to finish the work. And it's David's portrait of
the dancer that's shown here. Fragonard clearly remained resentful over the entire experience,
with the following results duly recorded in the Correspondance Littéraire of 1773.
And so I quote, the Hotel of Mademoiselle Guimard is almost finished. The salon is entirely decorated
with paintings. Mademoiselle Guimard is represented as Trepsichore, the Muse of Dance,
with all the attributes to characterize her thus in the most seductive manner. These paintings were
not yet finished when, for some reason, I don't know why, she broke off relations with the painter
Monsieur Fragonard. Their quarrel was so violent that he was fired, and she found another artist.
Since, curious to know what had happened to the job in the hands of his successor,
Fragonard found a way back into the house. He managed to get to the salon without meeting anyone.
Seeing in a corner a palette and some paint, he thought spontaneously of a way of getting his
revenge. With four strokes of the brush, he erased the smile on the lips of Trepsichore,
giving the portrait an expression of anger and fury, but without altering the resemblance to
La Guimard. His sacrilege completed, he left as quickly as possible. By an unfortunate chance,
Mademoiselle Guimard arrived a few minutes later with several of her friends who wanted to
ascertain the talents of the new painter. Imagine her indignation at seeing herself so disfigured.
But the angrier she became, the more the portrait resembled her."
This incident occurred four years after the swing, but just before the making of the swing,
Fragonard had experienced another such confrontation, although this time not exactly
one of his making. In the years leading up to 1767, he had been tipped as the new leader of
the French school, the up-and-coming artist who was going to take paintings to new heights by
continuing in the tradition of history painting, compositions taken from the Bible, classical
mythology, or history, and designed to instill moral values in the hearts and minds of beholders.
Of course, as you all realize by now, Gilliam was very much a history painter
by making his religious painting now in the Church of Saint-Roch. In 1765, Fragonard presented his
requisite admission piece to the Royal Academy, the work of art submitted as the first step in
the long initiation process to become a full-fledged artist. Fragonard's submission,
an ambitious, highly imaginative, large-scale history painting known as Coratius and Calirhoe,
was an immediate and brilliant success, and that, of course, is the work that I'm showing you here.
The painting was purchased for an astounding promised payment of 2,400 livres by the king,
who also commissioned a companion piece. A few months later, Coratius and Calirhoe was
exhibited in public at the Salon of 1765 to the enthusiastic praise of Diderot, who discussed
the picture at length in his Salon review and predicted that Fragonard would become France's
next major history painter. For Fragonard, the immediate material result of this brilliant success
was that he was given lodgings in the Louvre, along with the other established artists of his
day. But financial stability was not forthcoming. He received an installment towards the promised
2,400 livres from the crown in August 1765, but he did not receive a final payment for another
eight years until January 1773, and this, notwithstanding, repeated pleas on his behalf
from the secretary of the Academy. The situation became so dire that the contemporary novelist
Sébastien Mercier, writing in the 1770s, noted that the artist was even obliged to pawn his clothes
to make ends meet. It was at this critical moment that he received the scandalous commission for
the swing, and he never looked back. From then on, rather than working within the parameters
of the French Royal Academy, Fragonard took on private commissions and broke away entirely from
the clear-cut moralistic messaging of official art. From thenceforth, he refused every crown
commission he was offered. Even when asked to paint two subjects of his own choosing for the
dining room at Versailles in 1770, he did not relent. To conclude, given Fragonard's bumpy
track record with clients, given the fact that he went on to skewer Mademoiselle Guimard precisely
by turning on its head a portrait of her, given the wide gap we can surmise between the players
represented on the canvas and those we can glimpse behind the scenes of the swing,
it seems fair to say that at some point in the course of its making, the swing took a rather
sizable detour. It went from being a work carefully planned out by a patron to a work in which the
artist expresses his own voice. For it seems clear to me that the swing is the painting Fragonard
wanted to make, rather than the work he was asked to make, and the voice that comes through as a result
seems defiant, even brave. Fragonard has painted a work that is dizzying in its impossibility to
pin down, and he has done so with a technical prowess designed to stop the viewer dead in his
tracks. Perhaps in bringing to bear the full force of his artistic prowess on the swing, Fragonard
intended to send a message. Perhaps he wanted to subtly let the academic art world know what it
would be missing henceforth. It is certainly possible to see the painting as an end, as a final
sign-off from a disgruntled history painter, but the painting is also emblematic of what was to be
gained by breaking away. Following the swing, Fragonard's stories were no longer inspiring ones
of gods and kings, but just as significant was his new manner of telling them. Ambiguous, confusing,
insinuating. After he stepped away from the academy, there is nothing straightforward about anything
Fragonard did. In its determined aversion to clear narrative, the swing is in many ways the ultimate
anti-history painting. It is an experimental work that teases us with its ambiguity, that lingers
in the mind, that makes us think. In this sense, perhaps, it should be read not simply as the
embodiment of the recognition, but as the dawn of modern art. Thank you.
