China's fake self driving taxis

China Insider TV
242 followers
166 Video Views·Jul 9, 2025
"[07/16/2024 uploaded]
==========================
My social media:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chinainsiderwithdavidzhang/
X or Twitter: https://twitter.com/DavidZhang360
==========================
⭐️ Support me and my work ⭐️
Donate to support me: https://donorbox.org/china-insider-with-david-zhang
My sponsors:
🫐 Blueberry Creative 🫐
👉 Use this link for 15% off on all products code ""David""
https://lanmeiyoupin.shop/en
⭐️ Free shipping over 70 USD (US Only)
==========================
Subscribe for the latest:
- Daily News and Analysis on China's political landscape.
- Exposing Communism in China
- Expertise in the geopolitics of US-China"
This is China's latest tech failure. They're doing a copycat of Waymo, which is RoboTaxi,
or self-driving taxi. But it's a failure on a much larger scale, which I'll discuss in detail
in the second half. But first, let's talk about the faking part. Trying to rival Tesla and Waymo.
Except they aren't all that self-driving. This is the driving center where remote drivers
And they can take over if anything goes wrong. Although this isn't unique,
Waymo has something similar. What is interesting is what percentage of
dividing between the actual autonomous driving, powered by AI, and mapping, versus a remote driver
taking the actual control, is something that I don't think we'll ever get an answer to,
but knowing their habits of faking numbers, we can't exclude the possibility that the remote
driver is the one doing the actual driving. Which I'll highlight some evidence to suggest
this might be the case. This is China's Google, Baidu, and one of their subsidiary companies
developed the service called ApolloGo, which again is to rival Alphabet, or Google's parent
Waymo. And currently, it's being launched in a testing phase in the city of Wuhan,
rolling out about 400 plus cars. Their goal is by the beginning of next year to go up to
about 1000 or so. It's already having problems on the road. Baidu claims that there hasn't been
any major accidents, but photo proof contradicts that claim. And videos also tell a different story.
In this video, we see these two autonomous robotaxis meeting head on, and neither of
them want to yield to the other car, so it just became a standstill. And then,
also another video here, multiple of these self-driving cars refused to go,
so it created this traffic jam situation. And of course, there are other crashes or random
sort of behaviors that's been encountered since this program came out. In this video,
the cars allegedly stopped due to a crash in the system, and so the traffic police can't really do
anything about it because there's no driver, and they're simply shutting down in the middle of the
road, and the passengers inside allegedly can't get out. And this video shows the car, this robotaxi
was ordered to come pick him up, but it decided that the best way to stop is in the middle of the
road. And this guy complains about how the mapping and the driving situation is still not optimal,
clearly that's a software issue.
Which, again, brings me about that claim, if the softwares aren't doing so well,
one of the advantages that China has is the 5G network, so the remote driver can really take
over any time and you wouldn't notice it because obviously if you're the passenger inside the
vehicle, everything seems the same, as there's no driver. The question is, if the software and
the AI training module isn't in place to optimize essentially what companies in the west have been
trying to do for many years, through their development, training, etc, to build the
database, why roll it out in China in such a short amount of time and essentially just
try to compete against a service that's still not established in the United States? Well,
the only answer I can give is nationalism. They need to compete for the sake of competing,
and they need to win it for the sake of nationalism. We see that from the videos and photos,
there seems to not be enough remote drivers, so they're watching 2-3 cars per person,
and obviously, that's not a lot of attention span for each car, especially if they're told to
take over the driving for one of them, they can't simultaneously focus on the other ones,
and so it really creates a situation where I believe some of these videos that we're seeing,
these malfunctions are caused by remote drivers unable to multitask. Now, this is not to blame
them, but it's the situation. So, it begs the question, if they're doing this fake self-driving,
if remote driving is really the common occurrence still, then what's the point of branding this as
a self-driving car in the first place? Or simply, why do you need to have it come out now?
And really, the bigger question is, if all you did was get rid of the driver in the car,
what's the point? In this video, this is not from Apollo Go, but this is from BYD,
who is also working on their own autonomous driving module, and it has just crashed on
the side of the road. Again, it's a reflection that the technology is not there yet.
While they can't compete against Tesla's FSD, or potentially Waymo,
in the matters of the software side of things, what they do have as an advantage is that in China,
they can do things with a lower production cost on the cars, and they can roll out cars faster,
implement it in a more systematic way, given the fact that this is China, and they do also have
the advantage of that 5G network. Obviously, there's also other concerns with what if the
car is surveilling you, what if it's recording you, or what if there's certain situations where
you're locked down inside the car. Very possible scenarios, but just to stick with the topic,
when you implement this on a larger scale operation, you need the support of the government,
at least on the municipal level. It won't take months, or even one or two years, it will take
maybe half a decade for this to come out across China. Huge risks, which I'll talk about next,
but compare that to the situation in the United States, for example, Waymo is in a limited number
of cities, and they're still in this very, very limited traffic region in which you can operate
on. I think this hurdle will be much lower for China, once you basically see that, I mean,
Baidu is the premier data company in China, so there's much less hurdles for Baidu than it is
for Google to get their self-driving cars approved in the United States. Let's talk about the bigger
question. What happens if autonomous driving, self-driving cars, or robo-taxis become the
mainstream? What you're essentially doing is, for the sake of competing for nationalistic points,
you sacrifice an entire industry and a huge population that works in that industry.
If you get rid of the Uber drivers or the taxi drivers, you replace them with an autonomous
vehicle, then in a society where you rely on the creation of technology for the betterment of that
society, it might work, provided that the same society can provide an alternative for those
people that may lose their jobs because of that. There's a term called creative destruction. I
think it was an Austrian economist, can't remember his name, I think it was Schumpeter, sorry if I
pronounce that wrong. He coined this term creative destruction. The idea is that old technology
will become obsolete because of new innovations, and in turn, you basically destroy the past,
but you create something new. Let's take that and examine if the same principles would apply
in the Chinese society, which by the way, the current economy is not supporting creative
destruction. It is not creating a betterment out of existence that is supporting this structure.
Things are going down. Many people that lost their jobs, high paying wage jobs,
are looking to go into a lower level of paying jobs, such as maybe you used to work in tech,
now you're working as a delivery driver. Delivery drivers, which could also be replaced by
autonomous delivery vehicles, it's already a saturated market because you have so many people
who are getting into that market from a level above or a few levels above. Everybody's looking
for these lower end paying jobs simply because there are no other jobs available. Again,
so I'm trying to reiterate the point that for the sake of competing for nationalistic purposes,
they're willing to sacrifice, at least from the trajectory that it looks like they're going on,
sacrifice that population's opportunities and livelihood to achieve that. Again, I'm not
saying this is going to happen overnight, but if this is the trend, the great leap forward 2.0,
essentially trying to use these industrial results to compete against the other side
at any expense, really, there's no regard for the potential disaster it could cause.
All it's focusing on is getting those numbers. The central question for all of this is what is the
inclusive value in terms of creating, I guess you would say, a functionality in the society,
or you could say that by introducing AI-driven taxis, what is it actually achieving for society?
Is it doing any harms or is it benefiting? At the current stage in China, it's doing more harms than
good. Think about it, people aren't just going to increase their number of travels, spending more
money just because you replace the driver with a robot. It doesn't work like that because
transportation is you're going from A and B, you're not going from A and B repeatedly throughout the
that's not what people do. It's not like the technology difference is going to increase or
drive the economic output in that particular part of the industry. No matter if you're using
spaceships or you're using steam trains, it's still getting from point A to point B.
The point is, as an emerging technology, you're supposed to have ample opportunities to demonstrate
to the public, to society that this is beneficial in what ways, but if at the beginning of it,
people are already seeing the flaws with how you're going to be cutting jobs,
then that's not really the point here. We go back to the Waymo, which is supposed to be the rival.
They waited six years before they got an approval to start implementing a very limited number of
testing zones and then slowly being able to operate on the road. China is deciding to skip
that six years and go from zero to 100. While they can do that, it really doesn't make sense
from a longevity perspective. So when you're just skipping the integral part in the middle
for the result, you inevitably get something that we've all seen that's been happening in China.
Whether that's with chips, 5G, with EVs, or with any other technology advancement,
China seeks those really quick and fast ways to surpass the other side, but in the long run,
you see all those problematic things start to surface, and this is just the latest one.
