How Toys Ruin our Relationship with our Kids

Minimalist style
323 followers
#MinimalistStyle, #SimpleLiving, #MinimalDesign, #LessIsMore, #CleanAesthetic, #ModernMinimalism, #MinimalVibes, #DeclutteredLife, #MinimalistHome, #MinimalFashion, #ScandinavianDesign, #NeutralTones, #ClutterFree, #MinimalArt, #SleekDesign
If your kids are crabby, irritable, annoying to be around, you feel like they come to you too much
asking you to help them do things, they're not able to pick up, they just seem like they get
offended easily, I have a very simple solution for you and that is to get rid of all of their toys.
I know, we don't think that toys and screens are the culprit or the root of the problem,
but I'm telling you as I have worked with hundreds and thousands of other moms,
as they have significantly reduced toys and screens and clutter, their relationship with
their kids has done a complete 360 to the point where moms who were feeling kind of frustrated
and overwhelmed by their kids really enjoy their time with them again.
Now we just have this shelf of toys, it's a very small amount, we have some car tracks
and a couple bigger things that they like to use to play, that's it. Our kids don't need
any of it, like they just need their imaginations, they're brilliant.
Because of this my two-year-old can play happily in his room by himself,
he can turn anything into imaginative play and loves creating from what he already has.
We just as a family are able to interact better because we can run around the house,
you don't have to worry about picking up the toys prior to any family activities,
you're not going to step at them and then get all the grumble for that, so it has been wonderful.
Last spring we decluttered about 50% of our playroom doing something similar to that of a
room hush, we had so many toys we couldn't even actually hush it. The room transformation was
quite shocking, but it did have our kids doing literal cartwheels when we were done with it
because they were so excited to have the space back to actually play in the playroom.
And so today I want to help you understand how did we get here, why you don't have to feel
guilty or bad if your kids have kind of fallen into this category of a little bit
frustrating at times, right? But the very simple solution is very doable. I have a step-by-step
process to take you through this, even if you have kids that are super attached to their things.
Well hi, I'm Dawn from The Minimal Mom. Our family has been minimalist for 10 years now,
which means I have done tons of toy decluttering. And I get, I want to try and not be ranty on this,
I get a little passionate about this subject because I have seen how totally reducing the
number of toys that we have has radically transformed our kids and my relationship
with them. And now I've seen that in tons of other women as well. As they have significantly
reduced the toys, they come back and they're like, oh my goodness, my kids are content.
They play on their own. They play together. They don't fight so much. They're not always asking
for new things and different things. And if you've been wanting to cut back the screens,
this makes it so much easier to do that as well. So let's talk about the three main reasons how we
got here, where we are, and then the simple solution to get ourselves back out again.
Okay. Now, as usual, I will put timestamps along here if you want to jump around. There's also
some really interesting research on addiction and our kids that I want to share too. So coming up
ahead. Okay. Three reasons how did we get here? Number one, marketing. The toy industry is a
and they spend so much money marketing to us as parents and to our kids. And what are their main
points when they're selling it to us? This toy will either make your kids happier or smarter
or better at something or more popular. You have a problem. Your kids aren't playing well. Toys are
the solution. If you get toys and they're still not playing well, it means you haven't found the
right toys. Silly. You just have to buy more toys, right? But keep this in the back of your mind and
around. Have more toys solved your problem or have they just led to more chaos and overwhelm?
Number two is our own childhood and upbringing. So very early on when our kids were little,
I would go to garage sales. I would find toys that I wanted when I was younger and I would
buy them for our kids, right? I just, there was this like little tykes dollhouse and all the
dolls and minivan and all that. And my cousins had it and we always wanted it. So when I found
it at a garage sale, score, right? I got it. They'd never played with it. So you have to look
at how your own childhood and upbringing and how you viewed toys growing up. How does that play
into the toys that you have been purchasing for your kids? And then number three, when it comes
to screens is that it has never been easier as a parent for us to allow our kids to check out. We
all know that the easiest thing at the end of the day when our kids are being crabby is to let them
go on a screen. And again, how did we get here though? Well, I think what happened is because
we have overloaded our kids with toys, they aren't playing well on their own. They're irritable and
crabby. I'm going to share some research about that too. Then there's this easy solution out
there. So duh, every parent is going to take it. There's nothing wrong with you. If you have been
plugging your kids into screens, I have fallen into that this past like several months as well,
because there are days when it is just easier. But the good news and what I want to encourage
you with is we can unwind that in about two weeks. Kim John Payne, the author of Simplicity
Parenting, he says two weeks with reestablishing these screen habits with your kids and you can
have it worked out of their system. Now there's some other things we're going to do ahead of time
to prepare for that, but just know that you might be thinking like, oh my goodness, this is going to
be a huge battle. Do I really want to undertake this? No, we have simple solutions and you can
make a big difference in your house and with your kids in a pretty short amount of time. Okay,
so now this has been my experience with our own kids that as we highly simplify their toys,
they played better, they were more content, more creative, got along better. They're learning
problem solving skills. I mean, everything that you would hope for your kids, they're learning
emotional regulation. Everything that you want can be achieved or enhanced by highly simplifying
their toys. But I don't want you to just take my word for it. I want to read you some of the
research as well. In many European countries like Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, every year they
reserve three months for kids ages three to six to play without toys. No arts and crafts, no
building blocks, not even books. And nothing remains apart from furniture, a few blankets,
pillows, and plenty of space. It seems stark, but the founders of the Toy Free Nurseries say it
allows children to develop their creativity and social skills when not satisfied by toys. One of
directors says, in Toy Free time, they don't play with finished toys. They develop their own games.
They play more together so they can better develop psychosocial competencies. And there's research
here in the U.S. too that backs up this theory as it shows that kids under five can't concentrate
when surrounded by too many toys. So much so they can't focus on one toy long enough to learn from
it. And now there's some interesting theories around addiction too. And so they actually did
an addiction study group. It was set up by public health officers and they argued that it's an
essential need for children to play and in doing so taking possession of the world and developing
personal skills. Since life skills such as strengthening a person's communicative capacities
or self-confidence need to be promoted from early childhood on, it goes without saying that addiction
prevention has to commence at a very early age. They theorize that if adults constantly stimulate
children with toys, kids don't learn to develop coping mechanisms when bored, frustrated, or lonely
as boredom can make them reach for toys instead of developing their imagination. So the theory goes
that when they're adults, instead of having internal mechanisms to channel frustrations,
they rely on external crutches like drugs, alcohol, materialism, or even gambling to escape their
discomfort or their suffering. Now this is a little bit controversial. Some will say, yes,
this theory seems to make sense that kids, when they're surrounded by a lot of toys, if they're
feeling sad, unhappy, agitated, they just go from one toy to the next. Instead of learning how to
self-soothe or to learn that through being creative we can solve problems. And so as we remove the toys
we'll talk about a really simple and safe system for doing that. It is incredible all of the skills,
the social skills, the personal skills that our children are learning. And so again, it sometimes
seems maybe overly simplistic. Oh, just get rid of all the toys and then now your kids are going
to play better and they're going to be more enjoyable to be around. They're going to be
smarter, better problem solvers, better able to regulate their emotions. Like it seems overly
simplistic, right? Just get rid of the toys. But I'm telling you, again, this is what I've
experienced with our kids and also what I've heard from hundreds and hundreds of other moms.
So this is our playroom. What I did before this video was ask my kids, they were both five,
to put away their toys. I didn't move anything. This is what they did. This is how they put them
away. But this room, we have been in this room for, we were in this room for four hours this
morning. After breakfast we just came in here and they played. They play longer, they play better.
The best thing I ever did for my kids was simplify their toys. The best thing I did
ever, hands down, was get rid of most of their toys. Okay, so again, just one more time, I just
want to reinforce this, that studies show that children in environments with fewer toys exhibit
improved attention, imagination, and cognitive development. And independent play fosters
problem-solving skills and emotional resilience. So that's the benefit. And that's why I want to
encourage you that it is worthwhile to highly simplify your kids' toys. Now, what is the best
way to go about it? So I already mentioned the book Simplicity Parenting by Kim John Payton. And
he is a child psychologist. He has worked with hundreds and thousands of families as well. And
here's what he recommends. So he recommends that you look at all of your kids' toys and the goal
is to initially cut them in half. And we do that by getting boxes, bins, whatever you have around.
And we are just going to pack stuff away. So you're going to look for toys that your kids have
outgrown, that are broken, missing pieces, or toys, again, that don't encourage imaginative play. So
if you look at a toy and it lights up and it beeps and it sings and it does the imaginative work
for your children, these are not toys that are going to encourage them to play on their own
for long periods of time. And so pretty much anything that has batteries, you might consider
letting that go as well. And then leaving out the more open-ended toys like the Legos, blocks,
magnet tiles, and those types of things. So initially we work to cut the number of toys
that we have in half. And we tell our children, you know, we're just going to pack these away.
We're going to see how it feels. You have the ability to grab a black trash bag, like throw
away stuff that you clearly don't want or need. But the stuff that you're not sure about,
go ahead and just let your kids know we're going to pack it away.
I was really hesitant at first because I was really overwhelmed and because I was really,
really afraid of making a mistake of not picking the right type of blocks or the right toys that
my kids would use. And I pretty quickly learned that, I don't know, within a couple of hours,
that it didn't matter. Whatever I picked was fine. My kids were going to figure out a way
how to play with whatever was left. That activity gave me so much confidence,
and not only in my decluttering, but also in my ability to help my kids be and function better.
I've noticed that I've become so much more patient as a mom. And I love that it has taught me that
it's okay to make mistakes. You probably will make mistakes, but you can problem solve and
you can really make the spaces the best for your family and function the way that you've always
wanted to if you will just try it. Now here's another question that comes up with that.
Do I do this with my kids or without? So Kim John Payne says,
it is absolutely okay for you to do this without your kids. You worry that they're going to come
in and be like, what did you do? And where are all my toys? And you're going to break
trust with your kids. But again, that was not my experience at all. They loved the open space.
Kids are minimalist at heart and they thrive in highly simplified spaces. And so the concern is
that we're going to traumatize them and somehow harm them. But again, we're just telling them,
oh, don't worry. If they do notice that certain toys are gone, oh, don't worry. They're in a box
in the garage or in the basement or in this room. And if you ask for a toy by name and you really
want it back out, then I will gladly go and get it for you. But Dawn, my kids are so attached to
their stuff. I'm going to give you a little tough love here. That's just an excuse. Now I know some
kids are more attached than others, but we have a couple of good tools that we can use to help our
kids that are a little more attached to things work through their stuff as well. So we have our
treasure bin and our memory box. So I recommend that for each member of your household, including
yourself, that everybody has a memory box. And this is where the most special of special things
go. The outfits they wore home from the hospital, the blanket my mom made for each of the kids,
little outfits and things that were special to them. Certificates are in here, little trophies
or awards. Now you'll notice we can't keep everything, but we can keep the most special
stuff. And the idea is to curate a special collection of things for our kids that eventually
they can have. So I see this as a gift. We're not going to give them boxes and bins and
huge amounts of stuff when they're ready to leave home. And I have a lot of input about what goes
into here. As the kids have gotten older, they choose and select things too. But in the beginning,
it was mostly me deciding the things that were going to go in here. But I also noticed that we
needed a spot for all of our kids' little treasures. And so we have one who is especially attached to
everything. And so that's where we first came up with the idea of the treasure bins. And the idea
is that he can put anything in here that he wants. Drawings that he was working on, pop socket,
paint, I don't know. Anything that is special to them, this is where it lives. And so I don't have
a lot of input in what goes in here. I let each child decide what they want to put in their treasure
bin. Now for our youngest, he is especially attached. He has two of these bins. And our
only rule is that the lid has to be able to fit on. But what this has done is it's given a home
to all of that random stuff that would otherwise float around the floor and the flat surfaces. And
also I'm using this to help teach him how to manage inventory. Because we can keep the most
special things always, but we can't keep everything. So when this starts to overflow,
then we look in it. And usually by going to the bottom, you can find stuff that you can get rid
of. Now this is something we practice. In the beginning, he didn't want to get rid of hardly
anything in here. We would find like a few things to get rid of. The lid barely fits on again. And
I had him thinking, there's not really room to grow, right? But it didn't matter because we just,
we're going to practice it. And so now as we do this, we go through it every few months,
three to six months, maybe to make more room. It has gotten a lot easier for him to part with
And we have a system and we're practicing it. And I know, especially for those moms who have
kids that are neurodiverse, that they can also have just some different attachments to things.
So again, by giving it a spot to live and putting a container around it, it is very helpful. And
another thing that we really tried to reinforce with our kids too, is that nothing lives on the
floor in their bedroom. And so I would often reinforce like, Hey, if it's on the floor to
me, that means you've lost value for it. You pick it up, you keep it. I pick it up, I keep it.
But these two containers have made it so that the most special of special things have a home
and they're tucked away safely. And then the other stuff, we can decide more easily if we
want to keep it or let it go. Okay. And real quick, let's also talk about this fear of
traumatizing our kids. I have been accused many times of being a cruel or mean or unfair parent,
because we got rid of all of our kids' toys and forced them to live with hardly any toys at all.
And obviously that couldn't be further from the truth. I'm like you, I'm a mom who cares very
deeply for my kids and only wants what is best for them. And as we have simplified and decluttered
and got rid of more and more toys, I've seen all of the benefits for our family and our kids,
especially. And so I value that. And I believe that it's been this big lie that kids are happiest
when they're surrounded by all these toys, right? But again, we don't ever want to do anything to
harm our relationship with them. So that's why we do it in a loving and kind and respectful way.
We're not ripping toys out of their hands and saying, no, you can't have that anymore, right?
We're looking at the data. We're getting rid of the toys that they don't play with, that they've
outgrown, that are broken, that never facilitated a creative play anyways. You know, we often joke
that on Christmas, the kids have more fun playing with the boxes than the actual toys. We joke about
it, but it's actually true. When you look around at the toys that actually keep your kids engaged
and that they really enjoy playing with, you know, like which ones are special and which aren't.
Now, doesn't mean they won't be attached to some toys that are annoying or don't, or aren't conducive
with creative play, but over time we continue to simplify and simplify more. Okay, so we're highly
simplifying our kids' toys, which then leads to them being able to play more creatively and to get
engrossed in play, which then makes it much easier to reduce the time that they spend on devices.
But what's kind of the goal, or how do we set up this play space now if we don't have a lot
of toys in it? So what I want you to think about is setting up the space so that it's conducive
with creative play. So again, that's where having the open-ended toys, blocks, legos, magnet tiles,
super helpful. So those have continually made the cut in our home. But then beyond that, I also love
to provide very, very simple supplies to build and create. So cardboard boxes, scissors, masking tape,
and markers. It is amazing the hours of play that our kids have gotten out of those very simple
materials. And the temptation, especially as we're scaling back toys, can be to go to the dollar store
and stock up on all the craft supplies. And you know, I want to make sure that if they want to
be creative, they can be creative. And I'm going to caution you that even all of these extra craft
supplies that you can get now actually are not drawing out our children's true creativity.
You want to see the the true pure creativity of your children. These are brilliant brains and
minds that they have. Give them very basic simple tools and see what they create. Like our kids
always had access to the recycling bin and masking tape, cardboard, scissors, and that was the bulk of
it. Another thing is to understand that we can train kids to play independently on their own,
whether they're an only child or don't have a sibling close in age to play with, or if they
have siblings to play with. And I'm going to link to another YouTube video of a gal who walks through
this step, but basically we are just letting them play on their own for longer and longer times. So
we might say, oh hey, I'll come back and play with you, but first I have to go put the laundry in,
or I have to do this for 15 minutes and then I'll come back. And then we keep stretching out that
time. So first we set up an environment that's conducive with creative play. They don't have all
these toys around to feel overwhelmed and overstimulated. And then we increase the amount
of time that we're expecting them to play on their own to the point where it is not unreasonable at
all for your kids to play for two and three hours at a time on their own. When they are fully getting
engrossed in creative play, using their imaginations, getting along well with their siblings, learning
how to problem solve on their own, not expecting you to solve the problem of boredom for them,
it is magical. You want to see a completely different side of your kids? Let them get
engrossed in creative play. They are going to be so content and happy. And it is beautiful, right?
And that's nothing, there should be no mom guilt or anything. If our kids are engrossed in
imaginative play and they don't need us to facilitate it, that is the goal. Man, that is a happy and
content child right there. They don't need us interfering. We started simplifying when they were
pretty young. I was watching what they were playing with and just kind of taking away the duplicates
and then what was staying at the bottom of the bins. Now that it's been three years since I
started that, they are getting a little bit more involved in what they can keep versus what will go.
We start doing it by kind of asking the questions of, I see you have a lot of cars, like do you
think you could bless somebody with some or just part with one? And we'll get rid of a couple at
that time. Otherwise, we do the wonderful trick of you pick it up, you keep it, or I pick it up, I keep it.
This has been very eye-opening for me because it shows how much they actually value their toys.
If they're willing to pick it up or if they kind of say, you know what, I don't want to take care of
that. Mom can pick it up and she can keep it. It has made such an impact on just me personally.
I'm able to feel like I can manage our house more now that I don't have to control as much
inventory for the kids. It gives me a lot greater peace just inside knowing that everything is kind
of picked up or at least that doesn't fall on my shoulders anymore. We definitely get along a lot
better. Our kids interact a lot better. They play longer and I just want to say to any mom out there
who is considering it, give it a try. Definitely give it a try and you will not regret it and you
will not go back. Okay, so what do you say when your kids come up to you and say, I'm bored?
So they've heard me say like that's not my problem to solve. I've heard some moms say like
that's above my pay grade. But ultimately, I think it's helpful just to have some tasks that you would
have them do. So I'm like, oh great, the dishwasher needs to be emptied. Oh, you know, I noticed there
was stuff in the yard that needed to be picked up. So just have tasks ready to go. Even young
kids can understand this, that they get to choose whether they're going to be put to work or they
get to go and solve this problem of boredom on their own. And I've often said that creativity
lies just past boredom. So often we are going to have to let our kids get bored before we truly see
that real creativity come out and where they do get engrossed in play. Also, whenever possible,
we try to send our kids outside to play. There is something about being out in nature that is
so good. Well, it's good for all of us, but we know it's so good for our kids too. Now, I know
it depends on neighborhoods and ages and all of that. Not all of us have the luxury of just saying
go outside and play, right? But if you are able, make sure they have all their proper attire and
gear so that they can go out and play no matter what the weather is doing outside within reason,
of course. But that again, that is where I see our kids the happiest, most content. They're being
creative. They're out in nature and it is just so good for them. And they're happier because of
that. And of course, as parents, that's what we all want for our kids. All right. So overall,
I hope you feel encouraged that you have the tools you need to radically change how you've
done toys and screens in your home. I highly recommend the book Simplicity Parenting by Kim
John Payne. It is so good. He also talks about if we have picky eaters, how to get them to eat more,
how many activities should our kids actually be in. Spoiler, he'll say that if we have a busy day,
like you go on a play date or you have a soccer tournament, kids need two days to recover from
that. Two quiet days at home after a day of activity. Isn't that wild? I mean, you think
about the pace we have been trying to keep with our kids. But as we've continued to simplify and
pare things back, it is so fun to see how much happier and more content our kids are. All right,
I will stop for today. We have lots of videos about decluttering though. So obviously getting
your kids stuff in order is important, but the rest of your house too. It just pays dividends.
So I'll link to some of our playlist of our most popular videos here. It would be great if you
would subscribe so we could spend more time together, but I love you. I hope you have a
really good day and I'll see you again soon.
