Parthenon Marbles: An Art Controversy | AmorSciendi with Christina Boszik

Artifact Archives
9 followers
Okay Cherubs, these are marbles that once lined the great structure of the Parthenon in Athens.
The Parthenon has endured for over 2,000 years, and in that time it's been used as a pagan temple,
a church, a mosque, and a museum. It's been refitted and altered. It's had a powder keg
blow up inside it, it's been through an uncountable number of wars, and somehow it's come out of the
other side of those experiences still standing. And now it serves as a symbol of general antiquity.
It's our symbol of the classical past and the western intellectual tradition.
And these marbles once lined that building to form what is called a frieze, and they connected
all four sides of the Parthenon. The interpretation of the frieze's narrative has caused a great deal
of speculation, since there are no surviving primary descriptions of it. There's really no
way to tell what the story is, but it's hard to look at them without a sense of awe, and whatever
your level of knowledge, it's fun to guess at the meaning of something so beautiful. It's part of
why people seek out antiquities like this. Though there are many interpretations of the frieze, it
does not mean the characters in the story are completely lost to us. What can still be made out
underneath the guise of time is as follows. This is the eastern side of the frieze, commonly referred
to in scholarship as the peplos scene. We see a priest is handed, or is handling, a piece of cloth.
Perhaps this cloth is a peplos, a woman's full-bodied shawl, and is either giving or
receiving it from a small child. The peplos was an important ritual object in the Panathenaic
procession, a great festival of Athens which honored the goddess Athena. Flanking the scene
are 12 gods of Mount Olympus, notable by their scale and prominent position. The gods look on
to the festivities and see a glorious assemblage of Athenians. Altogether there are approximately
378 humans and deities and over 200 animals. The city of Athens seems to be depicted on a momentous
day as a unified picture of ancient Athenian culture, whether it be for the Panathenaic
procession or some ritual that is unbeknownst to modern society. It is a grand display of a single
celebration. But here's the thing, even though these marbles are important to the entire world
and even though they tell a unified story, they can't be viewed together. You'd have to travel
over 3,000 kilometers. Side note, I happen to live in a country that uses kilometers now.
Of the surviving 160 meters of sculpture, 80 meters are in a British museum. One block in the
and other pieces of the frieze can be found in museums in Palermo, Würzburg, Vienna, Munich,
Copenhagen, and the Vatican Museum. Only 50 meters of the frieze are located at the Acropolis Museum
in Athens. Athens famously wants to unify the panels and it's one of the great controversies
in the history of art. The marbles were cut from the Parthenon in 1802 by Lord Elgin with some vague
and perhaps misinterpreted permission by the Ottoman governors in Athens. So on one side people
argue that this has become part of the story of the sculptures. The horses of St. Mark's Square
in Venice for example have been moved around the world from city to city and to study them is to
study the history of the Mediterranean. Their story is part of history's story and it adds meaning to
the sculptures. So if we look at the issue like this, if the marbles are returned to Athens it
would set a dangerous precedent that all cultural items be returned to their place of origin.
It would destroy museums which collect and display artifacts from different times and
places in meaningful ways to help us extend our empathy and recognize a shared past.
You should watch the art assignment video in defense of museums if you haven't seen it yet.
Artifacts are transferred from culture to culture and often times it's not done according to any
universal ethical code. In fact, that's impossible. Cultures across time and space don't have universal
ethical codes. So should the paintings housed in the Met in New York City be returned to Europe
because many of them were purchased from a desperate population forced to sell their
cultural artifacts? When visitors walk into this room of the British Museum and ask,
how did these get here? Why aren't they in Athens? They will learn about the history of Greece,
the Ottoman Empire, and British imperialism. They will learn about the interconnectedness
of the world through its artifacts. But on the other side of this argument,
the marbles were taken under particularly questionable circumstances. Lord Elgin's
plan was to make copies of the marbles and then send the originals back. He got his permission
from the Ottoman Empire, who were occupying Athens at the time. Additionally, there's an
aesthetic argument here. Greek art became so influential through its symmetry and its
storytelling, among other things. To split this piece of artwork into pieces and distribute it
between different cities is to destroy the element that makes it important to those cities
in the first place. Imagine if Raphael's school of Athens was split in two, or even taken from
the room it was intended for. Clearly, we owe it to the concept of beauty itself to keep these
artifacts together. At the moment, no one can look at this work as a unified piece. No one can see
fully its beauty and its full story in one place. So, those visitors in a British Museum who ask
how something from the Parthenon ended up in Britain, hear the story of British imperialism
and this controversy. They will learn how beauty was sacrificed to the empire. I believe that
artifacts like these tell a meaningful story of the history of the world and I believe in
the role of museums to help tell that story. I also want that story to be one of compassion
and respect. There's a word in Greek, phyloxenia, which when broken down means friend of a foreigner,
though in google translate it'll go simply to hospitality. In my opinion, the British Museum
could choose compassion and have the story of this artifact reflect the phyloxenia of 21st century
England. I want museum goers in Athens a few hundred years from now to learn the story of
these marbles in their museum and hear the story of how England chose compassion and aesthetics
and the unification of something beautiful over the tradition of paternalistically overseeing
other cultures. I think that would be a much better story. But that's just my opinion,
I'd love to hear yours. Let me know in the comments below and if you like this video,
please consider subscribing. Thank you for watching.
