Western Hunter Gatherers and the Evolution of Blue & Green Eyes…
Chapters: 0:00 Western Hunter Gatherers and the Ice Age 2:21 Cheddar Man 3:31 Appearance 5:27 Eye Color 6:31 Larger Sample Size
Who were the Western Hunter Gatherers, what did they actually look like and how common were blue and green eyes amongst them? In one of my last videos on the Origin and Reason for Blue Eyes, I noted that Western Hunter Gatherers largely had lighter eyes and they are an extremely early example of the trait of blue and green eyes being common in Europe, a trend that has continued until today. In this video, I want to expand on this, delving more into who the Western Hunter Gatherers were, what did they actually look like and how common were blue eyes amongst them?
Now Western Hunter Gatherers were one of three main groups in ancient Europe following the last ice age, along with Scandinavian Hunter Gatherers and Eastern Hunter Gatherers, with Scandinavian Hunter Gatherers formed from a mix of Western and Eastern Hunter Gatherers. Western Hunter Gatherers are general grouped as hunter gatherers who lived in modern Britian and Ireland in the west to the Carpathian Mountains in the east that run through the likes of Romania and Slovakia.
So this is all to say that this is the context when the Western Hunter Gatherers lived, I imagine quite a challenging and difficult time to live. But what did they look like?
Sources:
Western Hunter-Gatherer - Wikipedia
Olalde I,. Derived immune and ancestral pigmentation alleles in a 7,000-year-old Mesolithic European. Nature. 2014 Mar 13;507(7491):225-8. doi: 10.1038/nature12960. Epub 2014 Jan 26. PMID: 24463515; PMCID: PMC4269527. Derived Immune and Ancestral Pigmentation Alleles in a 7,000-Year-old Mesolithic European - PMC (nih.gov)
Posth, C., Yu, H., Ghalichi, A. et al. Palaeogenomics of Upper Palaeolithic to Neolithic European hunter-gatherers. Nature 615, 117–126 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05...
Simões LG, et al. Genomic ancestry and social dynamics of the last hunter-gatherers of Atlantic France. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 Mar 5;121(10):e2310545121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2310545121. Epub 2024 Feb 26. PMID: 38408241; PMCID: PMC10927518. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Posth, C., Yu, H., Ghalichi, A. et al. File:Genetic ancestry of hunter-gatherers dated between 14 ka and 9 ka (WHG highlighted).png - Wikimedia Commons Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license. CC BY-SA 4.0 Deed | Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International | Creative Commons
Geni File:Cheddar Man upper body.JPG - Wikimedia Commons Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International CC BY-SA 4.0 Deed | Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International | Creative Commons Werner Ustorf File:Cheddar Man, National History Museum, London.jpg - Wikimedia Commons Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license. CC BY-SA 2.0 Deed | Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic | Creative Commons
Robert A. Rohde from published data and is part of the Global Warming Art project. File:CLIMAP.jpg - Wikimedia Commons Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. CC BY-SA 3.0 Deed | Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported | Creative Commons
Who were the Western hunter-gatherers? What did they actually look like?
And how common were blue and green eyes amongst them?
In one of my last videos on the origin and the reason for blue eyes,
I note the Western hunter-gatherers did have lighter eyes,
and they serve as an extremely early example of lighter eyes being very common in European populations,
a trend that has continued up until today.
In this video, however, I want to delve more into the Western hunter-gatherers.
Who were they? What did they look like?
Now, Western hunter-gatherers were one of three main groups in Ancient Europe
following the last Ice Age,
along with Scandinavian hunter-gatherers and Eastern hunter-gatherers.
Western hunter-gatherers are generally grouped as people who lived
in modern Britain and Ireland in the West
to the Carpathian Mountains in the East that run through the lakes of Romania and Slovakia.
They are thought to have formed into an archaeological group around 14,000 years ago
during the Late Glacial Interstadial,
and they were around until around 5,000 years ago.
The Late Glacial Interstadial was a period during the last Ice Age
defined by abrupt warming in the Northern Hemisphere
and a corresponding cooling in the Southern Hemisphere,
as well as a period of major ice sheet collapse
and corresponding sea level rise known as Meltwater Pulse Ia.
It represented the first pronounced warming since the end of the last glacial maximum,
a period where ice was at its greatest extent
between somewhere around 26,000 years ago and 20,000 years ago,
with ice sheets covering most of Northern North America
and Northern Europe amongst other regions of the globe.
This is a map of what Britain and Ireland looked like during the last glacial maximum,
with large parts of the landmass under thick sheets of ice.
Thus, this period of warming during the Late Glacial Interstadial period
meant that hunter-gatherers moved into parts of Northern Europe
that were previously uninhabitable for large parts of the Ice Age.
I should note that there was a brief return to glacial conditions
during the Younger Dryas period,
a period which lasted from around 12,900 years ago to about 11,700 years ago.
But after this, the globe started warming for good
and we're eventually out of the Ice Age for good.
So this is all to say that this is the context in which the Western hunter-gatherers lived.
Quite a challenging and difficult time, I'm sure, for many people.
But what did Western hunter-gatherers actually look like?
Well, this is Cheddar Man.
He is a hunter-gatherer who lived around 10,000 years ago
and was found in a cave in Somerset, England in the early 20th century.
He is one of the oldest, almost complete skeletons ever found in Britain.
Now this is a facial reconstruction of what Cheddar Man may have looked like
using DNA analysis that the National History Museum was involved with.
Before we move on to discussing eye colour,
I should note that this facial reconstruction was done for a Channel 4 TV programme in 2018,
and it sparked some controversy at the time
because of how dark his skin pigmentation was depicted as.
As some felt that this wasn't an accurate depiction of what he would have actually looked like,
and it was more of a publicity stunt for the TV programme.
Some of the DNA results indicated that Cheddar Man's skin pigmentation
was most likely in one of the two most highly pigmented of five categories,
dark or dark to black, and probably not in the lightest categories.
Yet some researchers involved in the study did later clarify
that they couldn't be sure what his skin pigmentation was.
This is an earlier model of the Cheddar Man
done by researchers from the University of Manchester in 1998,
but this reconstruction was done before DNA testing was available.
The indication that Western hunter-gatherers had a darker skin pigmentation
than many modern Europeans is not an isolated case however.
A 2014 study that looked at a male hunter-gatherer from Iberia
who lived around 5000 BC
and indicated that he probably had a dark skin pigmentation and dark brown hair.
There probably was some variation in skin pigmentation
amongst Western hunter-gatherers however.
A more recent study that looked at 10 Western hunter-gatherers
from modern day France found some diversity during the late Mesolithic in France.
They observed that while most individuals carried the dark skin and blue eyes
characteristic of Western hunter-gatherers,
2 of the individuals out of 10 likely had pale to intermediate skin pigmentation.
Now considering that most of Northern Europe
was pretty much uninhabitable during large parts of the last Ice Age,
it would make sense that Western hunter-gatherers had a darker skin pigmentation
than many modern European populations such as myself that lives in Scotland today.
But obviously during the last glacial maximum as we saw in the previous map
that showed Britain and Ireland during the last glacial maximum,
Scotland was pretty much uninhabitable for most of that period.
So it would make sense from an evolutionary perspective
that if hunter-gatherers had to live further south during the last glacial period,
the last glacial maximum,
that they had a darker skin pigmentation than many modern Europeans today.
The main evolutionary theory as to why lighter skin developed in the first place
is because it's better at making vitamin D from sunlight.
However others argue it's purely a genetic reason
and it was simply the result of a lighter pigmented populations migrating into Europe
from Western Anatolia and the Pontic-Caspian steppe.
Perhaps it's a combination of the two.
From an evolutionary perspective,
it would make sense that Western hunter-gatherers always had to live further south
during large parts of the last Ice Age.
It would therefore make sense that they probably had a darker pigmentation,
skin pigmentation than many modern European populations.
What is more clear however,
is that many Western hunter-gatherers had lighter eyes,
both blue eyes and green eyes,
as well as probably dark brown hair.
Cheddar Man for instance had blue eyes,
is thought to have had blue eyes,
and the hunter-gatherer from Iberia probably also had lighter eyes,
as the study from Iberia noted.
Further examination revealed that this individual carried the RS-129,
13832C,
SMP,
and the associated homozygous haplotype
spanning the Hersey II-Ocher II locus
that is strongly associated with blue eye colour.
This study then added,
our results indicate that the adaptive spread of light skin pigmentation alleles
was not complete in some European populations by the Mesolithic,
and that the spread of alleles associated with light blue eye colour
may have preceded changes in skin pigmentation.
So what is beginning to emerge is a picture of what Western hunter-gatherers actually look like.
They probably to a large degree had lighter eyes,
either blue or green,
dark brown hair,
and a darker skin pigmentation than many Europeans today.
Now I know what some of you may be saying though,
it's quite a small sample size what we have looked at so far,
only essentially two hunter-gatherers.
Well a study from 2023 looked at a much larger sample size
of 356 ancient hunter-gatherer genomes from Europe
spanning between 35,000 and 5,000 years ago.
They again found evidence that Western hunter-gatherers
tended to have lighter eyes,
either blue or green,
and darker skin,
which was the opposite to how Eastern hunter-gatherers looked,
as they write.
On the basis of the genetic variation of present-day Europeans,
this could imply phenotypic differences
between post-14,000-year-old hunter-gatherer populations across Europe,
with individuals in the Oberkessel cluster,
which this study calls Western hunter-gatherers,
possibly exhibiting darker skin and lighter eyes,
and individuals in the Seidelkino cluster,
which this study calls Eastern hunter-gatherers,
possibly lighter skin and darker eye colour.
As far as how common lighter eyes were amongst Western hunter-gatherers,
as well as other related hunter-gatherer groups,
it seems that they were probably pretty common,
as the allele associated with lighter eyes was above 90% in many cases,
as this study noted.
For the SMP associated with light eye colour,
HERC2OCA2 RS12913832,
individuals from the Oberkessel cluster,
which again are Western hunter-gatherers in this study,
the Baltic hunter-gatherers and Scandinavian hunter-gatherer groups
show high frequencies of this derived allele,
above 90%,
which is responsible for green or blue eye phenotype.
The Seidelkino cluster,
Ukraine hunter-gatherer,
and Iron Gates hunter-gatherer groups
show low occurrence of this allele,
between 10% and 25%.
So it seems that blue and green eyes
were pretty common amongst Western hunter-gatherers,
and lighter eyes seem to have developed before lighter skin
in parts of Western and Central Europe.
So this is all to say that from the information we have at this moment,
it seems Western hunter-gatherers largely had,
although there was some variation amongst the population,
lighter eyes, either blue or green,
dark brown hair,
and a darker skin pigmentation than many modern Europeans.
And they formed a genetic bedrock in many parts of Europe,
and many Europeans still trace a percentage of their ancestry
back to them.
They soon mixed and were replaced in many instances
by future waves of migration that swept across Europe.
They probably introduced genetics associated with
lighter skin pigmentation as well.
Early European farmers from Anatolia soon entered Europe,
before massive migrations of Western steppe herders
from the Pontic-Caspian steppe,
connected to the Yamnaya culture that I've previously made videos on,
swept across Europe as well.
Yet how common are blue eyes today,
and what was their origin?
To find out, please click here.
Thanks for watching, please subscribe and hit the bell,
let me know your thoughts in the comments below,
and I'll see you next time.