Augmented reality pioneer Louis Rosenberg warns that the Metaverse could be far worse for society than social media.
Major corporations are spending billions to bring the Metaverse to consumers. They envision a world where virtual and augmented reality will touch all aspects of our lives, from shopping and socializing to business and education.
There is no doubt, the Metaverse is coming… and yes, it will be magical. But at the same time, it could greatly distort our world, spreading misinformation and polarizing society far worse than any form of media to date.
It's not the technology that’s dangerous. It's the prospect that large corporations will be able to use the Metaverse to manipulate our experiences on behalf of the highest bidder, persuading us in ways that will make social media seem quaint.
But it’s not too late. Louis Rosenberg explains what we need to do.
The metaverse has exploded into the mainstream over the last 12 months.
We believe the metaverse will be the successor to the mobile internet.
They're in the metaverse.
What the heck is the metaverse anyway?
For many people, it's the first time they've considered the implications,
both positive and negative.
Personally, I've been thinking about the metaverse for over 30 years,
and while I'm still excited about the positives,
I'm increasingly terrified about the dangers.
And believe me, I wasn't always the one sounding the alarm.
In fact, this is me in 1992.
Back in the early 90s, I was a researcher at Stanford and NASA and the U.S. Air Force,
where I developed the world's first augmented reality system.
The research was a success,
showing we could boost human performance
when merging the real and virtual into a single reality.
But more importantly, I got to see how excited people were
when they climbed out of the system with huge smiles.
Now, 30 years later,
major corporations are spending billions to bring the metaverse to consumers.
They envision a world where virtual and augmented reality
will touch all aspects of our lives.
There is no doubt the metaverse is coming,
and yes, it will be magical,
but at the same time, it could greatly distort our world,
spreading misinformation and polarizing society
far worse than any form of media to date.
It's not the technology that's dangerous.
It's the prospect that large corporations will be able to use the metaverse
to manipulate our experiences on behalf of the highest bidder,
persuading us in ways that make social media seem quaint.
But it's not too late.
Here's what we need to do about it.
This is the classroom from More Perfect Union.
Have these people all lost touch with reality?
In a way, yes.
This is virtual reality.
First, let's talk about what the metaverse is.
In today's world, we view digital content from the outside looking in.
In the metaverse, we'll experience digital content from the inside
interacting with it all around us,
and we'll do it together in shared environments
populated by our friends, family, co-workers, everyone.
It can be fully virtual where people are avatars.
I would call that a virtual metaverse.
It could also be layers of virtual content overlaid on the real world.
I would call that an augmented metaverse.
My view is that within 10 years,
most people will spend at least two hours a day in the virtual metaverse
using it for shopping, socializing, entertainment,
and targeted business applications.
It will be very popular for short-duration activities,
like television today.
At the same time, I believe that within 10 years,
the augmented metaverse will become the central platform of our lives.
When people walk down the street,
they won't be staring down at their phones.
They'll be seeing content splashed all around them,
embellishing our world with layers of information.
Whether virtual or augmented,
the metaverse has the potential for remarkable creative applications.
But there are also great dangers.
Social media platforms already track your behaviors online.
In the metaverse, they'll track much, much more.
Where you go, what you do, who you're with,
where you look, even how long your gaze lingers.
The platforms will even monitor your facial expressions
and vocal inflections and vital signs.
I know this sounds creepy, vital signs,
but smartwatches can already do this.
And before long, the sensors will be built into your earbuds,
tracking your heart rate, your respiration rate, your blood pressure.
And they'll use this data to predict your emotions.
Yes, this is a privacy concern.
But to me, that's just a small part of it.
The bigger issue is what the platform providers
will do with this intimate information.
And what they will do is target you.
After all, that's the big tech business model.
Create a profile of people's behaviors
and then sell it off to the highest bidder.
We only have to look at the billions of dollars
of venture capital money flooding into metaverse products
to see that these tools of deception
will be used on behalf of large corporations.
It will be an advertising revolution.
With AR and VR, marketing won't be the overt pop-up ads
of today's internet, but subtle simulated additions
to our world that look and feel real.
Think of the film, The Truman Show.
In the movie, Jim Carrey lives in a completely fake world.
The whole world revolves around him.
Within the world of The Truman Show,
advertising is presented as just another
naturally occurring part of the reality.
All natural cocoa beans from the upper slopes
of Mount Nicaragua, no artificial sweeteners.
What the hell are you talking about?
The metaverse will trap all of us
within our own unique Truman Show,
with platform providers pulling the strings,
crafting experiences all around us
on behalf of paying advertisers.
Imagine that you're walking down the street in a metaverse
and maybe you see people walking the other way,
drinking a particular brand of energy drink.
And eventually you start to think,
wow, that brand is really popular.
What you don't realize is that whole experience
was manufactured on behalf of a paying advertiser
and targeted specifically at you.
In other words, you form ideas about your world,
about your community, without realizing
that most people are not seeing what you're seeing.
It was just designed for you.
And it doesn't need to be something benign
like energy drinks.
It could be political messaging or misinformation.
For that, let's consider another 90s blockbuster
about the nature of reality, The Matrix.
In that film, there are computer programs
who move in and out of the world as agents of The Matrix.
They look like humans, sound like humans,
and move through the world like any other human.
Similarly, the metaverse will be populated with AI avatars
that engage you in promotional conversation.
And you may not even realize that they're not real people.
Some people think, oh, I'll be able to tell the difference.
I'm not stupid.
Well, take a look at the following faces here.
Which of these images do you think are real human beings
and which are computer-generated faces?
I'll wait for your answer.
Okay, think you got it?
Well, the fact is all of these faces are computer-generated.
A study this year from Lancaster University
found that most people are not able to distinguish
between computer-generated faces and human faces.
And not only that, the People Survey
found the computer-generated faces to be more trustworthy
than the human faces.
You might think, okay, fine, this is all scary.
I'll just choose not to take part in the metaverse.
Problem solved, right?
No, it will feel no more optional
than internet access feels optional today.
You won't unplug your AR system
because it would make important aspects of our world
inaccessible to you, putting you at a disadvantage
socially, economically, and intellectually.
The fact is the technologies we adopt
in the name of convenience rarely remain optional.
Don't get me wrong, the metaverse has the power
to enrich our lives in wonderful ways.
I am confident that AR and VR will enable surgeons
to perform faster and better, construction workers,
engineers, scientists, artists, everybody.
But the metaverse also will make us far more dependent
on the insidious layers of technology
that mediate our lives.
Sounds like a dystopian future, right?
Well, it's not too late to change things.
Right now, the metaverse is where social media
was 20 years ago.
The industry is so enthralled by the utopian possibilities,
nobody is focused on regulating the dangers.
Of course, we can all see how hard it is
to undo the damage of social media now.
We can't repeat this mistake with the metaverse,
which means pushing for meaningful regulation now.
Of course, the big question is what should we regulate?
I believe we should focus on metaverse platforms.
That's because they are uniquely positioned
to A, monitor user behaviors at profoundly intimate levels,
and B, manipulate our experiences
in extremely persuasive ways.
First, let's talk about limiting how they monitor us.
The metaverse platforms need to be able to track
what you're doing, where you're going,
and what you're looking at
in order to simulate the virtual world around you.
But they don't need to store this information
and build personal profiles of your behavior over time.
We need to place limits on behavioral profiling
in the metaverse, maybe even ban it outright.
Otherwise, they'll be characterizing our whole lives
and eventually will be able to predict
exactly what you're likely to do in almost every situation.
The platforms will eventually track your facial expressions,
your vocal inflections, your posture and gait,
all with the goal of assessing your emotional state.
They shouldn't be allowed to perform
emotional profiling over time.
If they can profile your emotional reactions day after day,
they will be able to characterize how you will react
in a wide range of situations.
That data could be used to persuade
and manipulate consumers more effectively
than any form of media to date.
Finally, platforms will push to monitor vital signs.
They should not be allowed to store this type of data
for anything other than health and wellness applications,
certainly not to characterize your reactions
to advertisements.
Now let's turn to manipulation.
We need to regulate advertising in the metaverse,
requiring transparency.
So consumers can tell the difference
between a virtual product placement
that is put there specifically to target you
and everything else in your world.
The same concerns extend to AI avatars
that will engage us in promotional conversation.
Platforms should be required to make AI avatars
look different and sound different
and act different than other people.
And consumers should be able to see
who paid for each promotional conversation
and what was their specific agenda.
Unless this is regulated,
we could all end up living in a metaverse
that looks and feels natural,
while behind the scenes, powerful corporations
are manipulating our perception of reality
for the highest bidder without us even realizing it.
That's not the future we want,
which means regulation is both necessary and urgent.
Politicians need to pay attention to this issue now.
Like it or not, the metaverse is here,
but what the future looks like is up to us.
Thank you for joining us in The Classroom,
a series by More Perfect Union.
We're taking on right-wing propaganda
and telling the stories
that corporate-backed media ignores,
while seeking out solutions
for a better future for all Americans.
So join us, like and subscribe.