Triathlon Bike Fit Vs Road Bike Fit

sport and travel
205 followers
#sport #travel #running #marathon #cycling#training #race #triathlon #swim #bike #run #adventure #inspire
Ah, the age-old debate for triathletes. Do you get a road bike with clip-on aero bars
or a fully-fledged triathlon bike? Is it worth the investment or can you get a lot out of your
road bike? Well, with some expert help today, we'll be weighing those options up and how
you can set their positions up. Of course, the road bike is a very versatile bike. In fact,
most people probably started out with the road bike because it's perfect for those everyday rides,
adventures, club rides, bike races, commuting, and even some of you may have done a few triathlons
on your road bike, but now you have the triathlon bug and you want to go that little bit faster.
Do you just whack a set of clip-on aero bars onto your road bike or do you take the leap and invest
in a dedicated triathlon bike? Of course, the second option may not even be an option. You
may simply need to make the most out of your road bike, which is exactly why we're here today.
I've come to meet with world-renowned bike fitter and physiotherapist,
Phil Burt. He's worked with some of the best cyclists and triathletes in the world. Today,
I'm going to be quizzing him on this road bike versus triathlon bike debate and how he goes
about setting them both up. Thanks, Phil, for joining us today. I imagine you've seen
your fair share of road bikes with clip-on handlebars over the years. Obviously,
the road bike primarily isn't designed for clip-on aero bars on there, but they do serve a purpose.
They reduce your frontal area, get you more aerodynamic, but as I say, a road bike isn't
really designed to have them on. Absolutely right. That's the fundamental thing,
is that when they designed this bike, they expected these to be here and you to be adopting
that position. I completely understand why somebody might want to try these before they
invest in a full-on time trial bike and have to be running two very expensive bikes.
If we understand what the issues are around using aero bars on a road bike and then maybe
some hacks and how you can mitigate the problems it concerns. For me, fundamentally, what it is,
is about the design of the bike. What you'll notice here is the seat tube here is angled.
Normal road bikes, somewhere between 72, 74 degrees angle, that's meaning that the saddle
is going back here. It's all the way back. A road bike is a more relaxed position. Remember, again,
bike fit and bike positions are really rotation around the bottom bracket. Frenchman with his
onions here, time trial, a team of two here. What this does, it means that when you put this
on here, it really closes, and we'll get you on the bike to show you this, it really closes up
your hip and back. Whilst you might be more aero, it compromises the engine room and power production,
but there are some things you can do to mitigate that and get around it a little bit. I often say,
though, ultimately, it's like putting lipstick on a pig. It's a quick fix. It's all right,
yes, it's quite controversial. Probably did myself out of any aero bar deal there.
It can work, but I want people to understand is what are the problems with it and what they
might feel when they do it, because they might put them on and go, oh, God, I've paid for these,
I'm more aero, but I'm feeling this, this, and this, and how they can then get around those
things as much as the bike will allow, if that makes sense, yes?
Mark Threlfall Well, shall we jump on and see
what we can do to make it work? Conor Dunne
So, Mark, this is you on the top of the hood in a row position, and what we have here is
a really quite nice bike position, maybe sitting a tad low, but I know the saddle's been in the car,
we'll get some numbers in a second, yes? The way this works is that saddle position there
and the hoods here mean that your upper body's fairly in a good place, it's in a good angle.
At the moment, if we now go down into the drops, into the aero bars, yes, when you come down here,
you can see what happens, and you do pretty well, but the main thing I notice is now we've got a
lower back angle, your arms are going into the hoods pretty well, but for me, it's the hips
getting so close there, can you see that? How does that feel? Do you feel that when you're there?
Mark Threlfall Yes, I do. It just feels very cramped up,
my knees are coming into my chest. I'm feeling already, and very quickly, it's just like my
breathing, I feel quite tight. Conor Dunne
Big thing about this is because that angle's like that and you drop down, it closes up the hip
exponentially. One thing, and the road bike probably runs a higher, an ordinary road bike
crank length will be higher than a TT one. One thing we might talk about is if we either bring
this up at the top to open you back up, your diaphragm then can descend, that's the problem
you're feeling at the moment, your diaphragm's so squished up, you can't go down, so you can't
breathe, and your hips are getting tight, you'll find it hard to run off the bike. You probably,
if you just stop at the top of the pedal stroke, right here, you've got a bit of a dead spot in
power production because the hip can't extend quickly. When you go down there, you feel yourself
rocking there, that's the top of the hip, hip gets closed, and it can't close up anymore,
so it just rocks you to one side. You can make this work if you wanted to.
We either bring you up on rises here, and that would open up the hip from there,
but that defeats the point, maybe, of having aero bars on in the first place.
I would say, if we shrink the crank length right down, if you stop at top dead center,
that will open up the hip at the top. Dropping five mil will give you four degrees back, at
least. You might go really strict to quite a smaller crank length, remember, it's only going
to change your gear, it's not going to change your performance. Open up the hip, stop the rocking,
make you feel better, allow you to breathe, stop those knees coming quite as high. It's quite a
dramatic effect. I think the hack there is, what I would ordinarily do is change the crank length,
and then, normally, you can put the saddle even higher and move it forward a little bit.
I was going to say, because I haven't moved the saddle at all since putting the clip-on
aero bars on, I want your advice a little bit on that. How much do you move it by?
Conor Dunne Well, let's do it. I reckon,
record you on the hoods, record you in this drop position with the retool,
yes, put it in our logos and numbers, and then, yes, let's set this saddle height up.
We can't change crank length today, but maybe we can do that after the interview,
but we'll put you up and forward and see how you feel. Remember,
retool all bike fitting systems, they give us the data, the data isn't the bike fit,
it's an interpretation of that and how you feel about it. I think something I call comfort filter
that I'd encourage all people to consider is that's your subjective interpretation of how
something is working for you. Don't let that be dismissed. Ultimately, how you feel is the most
important thing, isn't it? Conor Dunne
Absolutely. Right, let's do it then. Conor Dunne
Shall we get that recorded then? What you can see is that's beforehand,
and then this data is going to come in here. Knee extension was really quite good, 37. You
see that's gone down, and then see hip angle closed, how much that's gone down.
Conor Dunne Oh, wow, yes.
Conor Dunne That's massively changed
between the two positions. Then what you see down here, the normal thing is beforehand,
that's you on the hood. It's still really good, but you see how your tilt's gone up quite a bit,
your knee's moving in and out. That's because the hip's getting closed. As you come to the top of
the pedal stroke, you're having to move out. It's still all right, but then you see how much more
hip lateral travel you're having to do, so double already. I think what we should do now is just see
if I can make you feel more comfortable by lifting the saddle moving forward and just tilting the
nose a little bit, because by dropping the nose on the saddle, in my mind, we have design sales,
I don't know of any saddle that should be used nose up. It should always be level. Often,
that tiny amount of tilt will really open up the pelvis and give you a similar feeling
to dropping crank length. Should we do that now? Conor Dunne
Yes, let's do it. Let's see how I feel, Mark. I'm more comfortable.
Conor Dunne You can just tell straight away. That's
not a million miles away from your time trial position. The hip's opened up more. How does it
feel? Mark Threlfall
Yes, it feels way better. Conor Dunne
Just by increasing that saddle height, moving the saddle forward and tilting it,
we've managed to open up your pelvis and open up the hips. I think if you combine that with a
dropping crank length, this would almost work as a bit of a bodge job TT position.
Mark Threlfall Before I could feel as I came up to the top,
there was just this dead spot in the power. Now, I feel like I've got control the whole way around.
I definitely probably could tweak the saddle height a little bit more. Obviously,
we've just eyeballed it now and get just a little bit more comfortable around the crotch.
Conor Dunne Yes, and that's a road saddle. If this is
a time trial position where we need a bit of a softer nose or split nose saddle to make it work
in that position, the difficulty you have there is you need a saddle really that's a bit of an
all-rounder because it needs to maybe support this position and then drop in the thing. There's
quite a lot of options out there that can help you. Mark Threlfall
What's quite cool is I guess over the years, clip-on aero bars have developed quite a bit.
You can get risers for them. There is a fair bit of adjustability.
Conor Dunne I think that's right. These are
plastic, aren't they, almost? I think if we had a bit of a rise and a little bit of an angle on
this and maybe a bit more length, I think that'd be quite good. It's almost what I call a rest aero
position. When you go on flat straight, you go down there and just concentrate on really pedaling
hard in a nice aero silhouette. Then you're back on the hoods.
Mark Threlfall You're saying that. I'm actually
looking at myself in this mirror ahead of me. I'm like, this looks all right. It's not too bad.
Conor Dunne It doesn't look bad.
Mark Threlfall I mean, you could do things like
get narrower handlebars if you want to get a bit more aero.
Conor Dunne Well, I was going to say,
the biggest thing before people should move to this is make sure the handlebars are the
ultimate. I noticed these are 38s, which are really just going from a 40 to 38 makes a massive
difference in aerodynamics because it's like if you don't want to be any wider than you need to
be. I think that's actually working quite well for you. I think we have to recognize the animal in
front of us, Mark, which is a very well-trained individual who hasn't ridden in a long time like
this. Now we've modified that saddle position to open up the hip and make it work best for
that. It's getting you ready. If you drop the crank length five mil on this bike,
it then would work. They asked me if that would work for the road position and the
time trial position equally so. Mark Threlfall
Cool. All right, we're talking off which, let's swap over to TT bike.
Okay, Phil, on to the triathlon bike, TT bike. What are the obvious differences here then?
Phil Threlfall The big difference between a time trial
bike, if you ask me, is actually not the front end, it's the seat post angle. On a lot of TT
bikes, it's almost in line. This one's a little bit more relaxed. Basically, what you're able
to do is put the saddle a lot higher and a lot further forward. We're allowed to come forward
over the bike, bring our pelvis over the bike, and get into that really strong pedaling position.
Mark Threlfall It's almost like a track start position,
isn't it? You feel like it's parallel. Phil Threlfall
Yes, and that allows you to drop down and get, yes, this is where the aero bars really start
to work. You've got a lovely long position here, almost torpedo-like, elbow just underneath your
shoulder, looking pretty strong there. The most important bit here, what I like is a nice
extended knee angle without closing up the hip too much. We could manipulate, like I say,
in my world, obviously, the crank length should be five mil less, if optimal, on the road bike
on the time trial bike because it allows us to sit in that position for longer. You're really
good at handling it, having said that. Mark Threlfall
It'll be interesting to see maybe a play around with this one, but yes, another day.
Phil Threlfall Another day. You've got to consider a
time trial bike as almost like a scalpel to perform an operation. That operation is going
to be pedaling as hard as you can and cutting through the air as fast as you can. I think
sometimes people need to take a step back and get as good as they can on a road bike,
first of all, to do that because this is really hard. If you talk some of the best,
Bradley always said the best time trial position or team pursuit you ever met was Ed Clancy. Now,
he lives way up in the Peak District. He'd ride this for two hours into the velodrome,
do a session, and go home again. In other words, you mold yourself to it. If you go down a minute,
the hardest thing that most people find when they go into a time trial bike is their neck aches
because it is like looking at the ceiling. If we asked everyone at home now to look at the ceiling
for the next half an hour, nearly everyone would say, my neck feels a bit sore afterwards. That's
time trialing. It is fundamentally quite a difficult thing to absorb for the body,
but we need to make that as comfortable in all those things, so having the right saddle,
having the right crank length, having the right front end setup here that allows you to have the
high hands position. If you ask me, bringing that front end up helps out with the neck muscles
a hell of a lot because it decreases the total effort that's going in from the upper body.
The whole thing, comfort often is hijacked as a word, and it makes it feel like we're being lazy
and sitting down. It's nice, but I'm comfortable to perform as best as I can. Does that make sense?
If someone's refined the road bike position or they've just decided, heck, I'm loving this sport,
I'm going to get a triathlon bike, what are the key things to look out for? I've seen a lot of
people jump onto triathlon bike and there's just this feeling that they need to be super aero,
and actually, they're probably worsening their performance as a result.
Yes. There is a point where you go, I know this because I've spent lots of time in boring wind
tunnels and everything, but generally true, the lower you are the front, the more aero you get,
but that goes to a certain point and then it's detrimental. You pop up, your head's there,
you're not sustainable. That point comes sooner. If it's not your job every day,
to mold yourself into this position, hey, guess what? That point comes quicker the lower you go
the front. I think if you haven't got access to all that expert guidance about what is it,
wind tunnel testing cost a fortune, but most people these days can probably afford to test
power. What I would be doing is tinkering with the back end and working out what the most powerful
position is, which in my mind is normally the ideal saddle height, which is higher than you
normally think, but the right saddle for you in the right position. Generally higher, further
forward on a time trial bike, and I think as we did a minute ago, just tilting that nose down ever
so slightly. In my ideal world, the nose is how it should always be, one to two degrees tilted down,
just opens up that pelvis. Now, as you get over it, I'm really powerful, pedal as hard as you can.
Get that right first of all. Most people these days have the ability to measure that. You can
actually change that and sit on it and go, does that feel easier to produce the same power or
am I more powerful? You'd be surprised. Drop the crank length. Do I now say, am I more powerful?
Then we come to the front end. Okay, how can I make myself as aero as possible? It's a lot
harder to calculate that in terms of objective data and stuff like that.
Super. I guess my final question for you then is, when is the time to get a triathlon bike?
It's a very good question, Mark. What I think is,
I think having a play around with, even though I'm not a big fan of aero bars for reasons that
we discussed on the road bike, per se, that bike's not built to do those things. We talked
about little tricks you can do with the saddle height, the type of saddle, the saddle tilt to
the front end and crank length can make that, in some ways, replicate what being on a time trial
bike would feel like and look like. If you go and do that and go on that journey and you're like,
you know what, I like this, then a time trial bike will be built for that job and you will have even
more of an opportunity to explore your most aero, most powerful position for sure. If you don't get
along with that at all, I suppose it's a horrible catch-22 question. Is it because the clip-on aero
bars won't allow me to get comfortable? Actually, in fact, I do need a time trial bike with the
right crank length and right saddle to allow me to be in that aero position. That's probably where
I would say, of course, I would say this, but that's maybe where you go seek some objective
outside help through a bike fitter. You can look at your position and go, first and foremost,
we see a lot of people come in here, going to buy their dream bike, road bike, time trial bike,
and they just come in and say, I don't want to buy the wrong bike and I would like your advice.
We really enjoy doing that, narrowing it down and going, well, look. Some bike companies,
of course, will let you spec certain things like crank length and handlebar width. If you're doing
that right from the beginning rather than having to take them off and all the costs of replacing
that, it can help out. It's one of those things, having written books and communicated like we are
today on videos, there's so many variables, it can sometimes be a bit blinding on which ones
to concentrate on. Sometimes that's maybe seeking a bit of outside help. It could be from just a
coach or a trusted friend or someone you trust with their advice in terms of bike setup.
Mark Threlfall Yeah, brilliant. I think that's
really good advice. Thank you for that. Well, again, so much information from Phil
Wurtz. Thank you ever so much to him for that. If you'd like to find out more about Phil and
the services he offers, then do go check out his website. I'll put that in the description
down below. We also have a previous video with him in which Belinda, behind the camera right now,
got a bike fit with him. If you'd like to check that out, also pop that description
down below. Really interesting to hear from him around that comfort versus aero debate and that
switch over from a road bike to a TT bike. I suspect a few of you might have a few questions
on the aero bars on my road bike. If you have got any queries or questions around that,
drop me a question in the comment section down below and I'll try and get back to you and let
you know what they are and how I got them on there. If you enjoyed today's video, please
give it a thumbs up, give it a like, and don't forget to subscribe. See you next time.
