No modern U.S. Supreme Court decision has aroused more passion than Roe v. Wade. A judicial earthquake, it shook the country to its social, political and constitutional core. Stephanie Barclay, Professor of Law at Georgetown Law School, examines the impact and implications of this controversial case.
Transcript: Roe v. Wade: The Battle Over Abortion Presented by Stephanie Barclay
Perhaps no modern U.S. Supreme Court decision has aroused more passion than Roe v. Wade, the 1973 case that announced the constitutional right to abortion.
A judicial earthquake, it shook the country to its social, political and constitutional core.
The aftershocks continue to this day.
Socially, it revolutionized how people thought about, talked about, and experienced abortion. In the words of UC Berkeley Professor Kristin Luker, “it changed everything.”
Politically, it gave rise to two opposing movements: pro-life and pro-choice.
Constitutionally, it suggested that the Court had the power to create rights that lacked any meaningful support in the text of the Constitution.
Roe concerned a Texas woman named Norma McCorvey—then kept anonymous under the pseudonym “Jane Roe.” McCorvey wanted to have an abortion but was prevented from doing so because of Texas’ abortion law.
In 1970, “Jane Roe” sued Dallas County District Attorney Henry Wade to overturn the Texas law. Her case, Roe v. Wade, reached the Supreme Court, and in January 1973, the Court ruled 7-to-2 in favor of Roe, declaring that Texas had violated Roe’s constitutional right to privacy.
That right had been loosely established in previous court cases, most notably Griswold v. Connecticut (1965). What the Court did in Roe was to expand the right to privacy to include the right to have an abortion.
The Court based its decision on the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, primarily to guarantee the rights of people who had recently been freed from slavery.
At the time of ratification, roughly three-quarters of the states had statutes criminalizing abortion. When Roe was decided over a century later, the majority of states still had statutes placing strict limits on abortion, with many allowing exceptions in cases of rape, incest, or to save the life of the mother.
The Roe decision invalidated that entire legal framework.
To justify its reasoning, the Court cited the clause in the Fourteenth Amendment stating that no person shall be deprived of “life, liberty, or property, without due process of law…”
But this raised a new question, one specifically related to a woman’s pregnancy. Under the Fourteenth Amendment, is an unborn child a person?
If the child is a person, does that child have the rights articulated in that very same Amendment, including the right to life?
The court said no. An unborn child is not a person.
Writing for the majority, Justice Harry Blackmun reasoned that wherever the word “person” is found in the Constitution, it “has application only post-natally.” All of its references are to those already born. That fact “persuades us,” Blackmun wrote, “that the word 'person,' as used in the Fourteenth Amendment, does not include the unborn.”
This raised another question. At what point in a pregnancy does an unborn child become a “person”?
The Court effectively answered that question, too.
It decreed that until the unborn child had reached the point of “viability” — the beginning of the third trimester, when the child can survive outside the womb — the state can’t protect the unborn child’s “potential life.”
However, in an internal memo to his colleagues, Blackmun admitted that this trimester viability timeline he had developed was “arbitrary.”
Perhaps no modern U.S. Supreme Court decision has aroused more passion than Roe v. Wade,
the 1973 case that announced the constitutional right to abortion. A judicial earthquake,
it shook the country to its social, political, and constitutional core.
The aftershocks continue to this day. Socially, it revolutionized how people thought about,
talked about, and experienced abortion. In the words of UC Berkeley professor
Kristen Luker, it changed everything. Politically, it gave rise to two opposing movements,
pro-life and pro-choice. Constitutionally, it suggested that the court had the power
to create rights that lacked any meaningful support in the text of the Constitution.
Roe concerned a Texas woman named Norma McCorvey, then kept anonymous under the pseudonym Jane Roe.
McCorvey wanted to have an abortion, but was prevented from doing so because of Texas'
abortion law. In 1970, Jane Roe sued Dallas County District Attorney Henry Wade to overturn
the Texas law. Her case, Roe v. Wade, reached the Supreme Court, and in January 1973,
the court ruled 7-2 in favor of Roe, declaring that Texas had violated Roe's constitutional
right to privacy. That right had been loosely established in previous court cases, most notably
Griswold v. Connecticut in 1965. What the court did in Roe was to expand the right to privacy
to include the right to have an abortion. The court based its decision on the 14th Amendment,
ratified in 1868, primarily to guarantee the rights of people who had recently been freed
from slavery. At the time of ratification, roughly three-quarters of the states had
statutes criminalizing abortion. When Roe was decided over a century later, the majority of
states still had statutes placing strict limits on abortion, with many allowing exceptions in cases of
rape, incest, or to save the life of the mother. The Roe decision invalidated that entire legal
framework. To justify its reasoning, the court cited the clause in the 14th Amendment stating
that no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. But this
raised a new question, one specifically related to a woman's pregnancy. Under the 14th Amendment,
is an unborn child a person? If the child is a person, does that child have the rights articulated
in that very same amendment, including the right to life? The court said no. An unborn child is not
a person. Writing for the majority, Justice Harry Blackmun reasoned that wherever the word
person is found in the Constitution, it has application only postnatally. All of its references
are to those already born. That fact persuades us, Blackmun wrote, that the word person, as used in
the 14th Amendment, does not include the unborn. This raised another question. At what point in a
pregnancy does an unborn child become a person? The court effectively answered that question, too.
It decreed that until the unborn child had reached the point of viability, the beginning of the third
trimester when the child can survive outside the womb, the state can't protect the unborn child's
potential life. However, in an internal memo to his colleagues, Justice Blackmun admitted that this
trimester viability timeline he had developed was arbitrary. Thus, to reach their conclusion,
the court engaged in legal gymnastics that few of Roe's supporters were even willing to defend.
As constitutional scholar John Hart Ely put it, Roe was not constitutional law and gives almost
no sense of an obligation to try to be. If abortion wasn't a major political issue before
Roe, it soon became one after Roe. Many Americans, deeply disturbed by what they saw as the devaluing
of innocent human life, organized in opposition to the decision. Many other Americans fiercely
defended the decision. They saw abortion as a civil rights issue, that the government should
not interfere with a woman's right to choose or to control her own body. Thus, a new political line
divided America. That line extended to the court. Every potential new justice would be asked to
explain their stance on this pivotal question during their confirmation hearing. Would they
uphold or overturn Roe? Thus, the court, designed to be the most apolitical branch of the government,
found itself at the center of an enduring political battle. Later Supreme Court decisions
modified Roe in significant ways. Eventually, the lower courts had conflicting guidance
about what rule actually governed abortion decisions. In 2021, 26 states expressly asked
the court to overrule Roe entirely. The court did so the following year in the case of Dobbs v.
Jackson Women's Health Organization. This decision returned the abortion issue to the political
process. The people, through their representatives, can once again determine what standards can
govern their individual states. Abortion still remains a hotly debated topic. That's unlikely
to change anytime soon. But in Dobbs, the Supreme Court made clear that the democratic process
is the best way to resolve difficult moral questions left open by the Constitution.
I'm Stephanie Barkley, professor of law at Georgetown Law School for Prager University.
Thank you for watching this video. To keep PragerU videos free,
please consider making a tax-deductible donation.