Does terraforming a tidally-locked planet make any sense? Are the images we got of our galaxy's supermassive black hole fake? Can we observe gravitational waves that came before the CMB? And in Q&A+ who is currently working on space elevators? Answering all these questions and more in this Q&A show.
00:00 Start 00:31 [Poshact] What's the feasibility of terraforming a tidally-locked planet? 03:26 [Jay Drummond] Why it's okay for space companies to dump rockets into the ocean? 05:50 [Scott Smillie] Is the image of Sag A* not real? 08:44 [Richard R] Do we expand the observable Universe if we launch a telescope 1 ly from Earth? 10:02 [michael blacktree] Can we observe gravitational waves before the CMB? 13:11 [Uğur E.] When do we start orbiting our SMBH after leaving the solar system? 15:06 [drZab] Should we be building a big spaceship in orbit?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
Does terraforming a tidily locked planet
make any sense? Are the images we get of
our galaxy's super massive black hole
fake? Can we observe gravitational waves
that came before the cosmic microwave
background? And in Q&A plus, who is
currently working on space elevators?
Answering all these questions and more
in this question show. It's time for the
question show. Your questions, my
answers as always, wherever you are
across my channel. If a question pops in
your brain, just write it down. I'll
gather them up and I will answer them
here. All right, let's get into the
questions. Posh, what is the feasibility
of terraforming a tidily locked planet?
It all depends on what you're hoping to
do with your terraforming process. But,
you know, the the biggest issue with a
tidily locked exoplanet is that it is
tidily locked, that it is showing the
same face to the star all the time. And
what you end up with is half of the
planet is in eternal sunlight and then
half of the planet is in eternal
darkness. And then you've got winds that
are redistributing the air from the cool
side to the bright side and vice versa.
So one side of the planet would be
habitable, the part that's facing the
star, and the other part would be
uninhabitable because it would be
incredibly cold, completely frozen.
Wouldn't be as cold as if it had no
atmosphere, but it would be very cold,
you know, more than 100° below zero. And
so and no sunlight. And so life wouldn't
be able to exist on the on the dark
side. And people have thought in the
past that that the near side is going to
be uninhabitable, that it also is going
to be like a superheated desert. But now
it really looks like the simulations
show that the near side is going to be
more like a jungle. So it's going to be
very humid. It depends on the amount of
water on the planet, but it's going to
be very humid. there's going to be a lot
of clouds that you will have, you know,
and depending on how far away it is and
how much sunlight it's getting and more,
you know, there's all kinds of it
depends. But you could easily end up
with a world where half of it is in
eternal sunlight covered in jungle and
then half of it is eternal darkness and
that would be interesting and weird and
doesn't mean that life couldn't get a
foothold. Now, now we as human beings
might show up and go, "Yeah, the eternal
sunlight is fine with us. You know, it's
always daytime. It's never night. That's
all right. Um, plants grow and they
just, you know, you know, we know that
plants can grow in eternal light.
They're not super happy about it. They
like a little bit of rest, but there are
plenty of people that are that put
plants under grow lights 24/7 and the
plants can survive. So, it doesn't feel
like any of that is completely
uninhabitable. But if you did want to
terraform it and you wanted to stop it
from being tidily locked, you would
probably bring an asteroid close by.
Asteroid would fly by very close. it
would cause a gravitational jerk to the
uh to the planet and maybe started
spinning just a little bit. But the
problem is that you are fighting the
inevitable tidal locking from the star.
It always wants to get back to being
tidily locked. And so if you were able
to figure out, you know, how to bring a
lot of asteroids to do flybys, you could
slowly start to speed up the rotation of
the planet, but the star is always going
to be trying to drag it back down. So,
it's going to be kind of endless. And
so, I don't think it's worth it. I think
you just you you adapt to this weird
cool jungle world. You know, it's got
these these more temperate climates
around the the terminator between the
night side and dayside. It's a weird
fascinating world and you just roll with
it. Jay Drummond, why is it okay for
space companies to dump failed rockets
into the ocean? Wouldn't this be
considered pollution in any other
industry? Are there rules or efforts to
recover that debris? Well, it depends on
the rocket system. So now um the like
say the Falcon 9 which is like the most
common rocket uh the first stage booster
lands and is reused so you don't get the
loss of the first stage booster. The
upper stage generally goes into orbit so
it's not crashing into the ocean. So the
amount of booster rockets that are
actually crashing into the ocean now is
very low. The space launch system has
launched once and crashed into the
ocean. You will occasionally get other
launch providers, Atlas, you know, stuff
from United Launch Alliance a couple a
year. Europe, their Arion rockets, land
in the ocean, their first stage, but you
know, they only launch a couple of times
a year. The Chinese are definitely well,
they they drop them on villages. I mean,
they drop them in on land. Um, but they
do they do drop some in the ocean. So
you know I think the entire industry is
moving towards reusable technology at
this point especially you know if
Starship actually works then the entire
stack is reusable the first stage is
reusable and the upper stage is
reusable. So, so that's the direction
that the entire industry is inevitably
going. And when you think about the
number of, you know, the amount of of
rockets that are actually dropped into
the ocean compared to the amount of
ships that are sunk, the amount of
garbage that is dumped into the ocean,
the amount of plastic that drifts down
rivers and goes into the ocean. I mean
there are some big polluters of our
oceans right now that you know if this
is a concern we should solve that
problem immediately. So I think you know
like like all things right now the
problem is tiny. The amount of debris
that's dropping in the oceans is is
minuscule compared to the the kind of
garbage that's already happening. But
like all things, it's a tragedy of the
commons problem and that if you just
keep turning a blind eye to it, then
people will keep doing it and eventually
it's going to become a bigger and bigger
problem and lead to serious pollution.
But you know, you'd be looking for a lot
more rockets to be launching for that to
be even hold a candle to some of the
other environmental disasters that are
being unleashed on planet Earth right
now by by various uh people who aren't
having to pay the consequences of what
they're doing. Scott, simile, I heard
that the picture of Sagittarius A was
modeled after what the researchers
thought it should look like and not a
true representation of the black hole
itself. Can you clear this up for me?
So, I'm assuming you're talking about
the image from the event horizon
telescope uh that shows the the black
hole at the heart of the Milky Way. And
it's real data, right? They really did
take radio dishes around the world, turn
them into a virtual telescope and point
them all together at the super massive
black hole at the heart of the Milky Way
and then all of them acted like a
telescope that was the size of planet
Earth. And it is the highest resolution
telescope that has ever been made
because you know you've got a telescope
that is thousands of kilometers across.
But the first thing to understand is
that the they were gathering their data
in the radio waves. So not visible
light, but they were gathering radio
waves. And so like what does it mean to
see radio waves? You know, when you're
looking at pictures that come from James
Web, they're in infrared. What does it
mean to see in infrared? You can't see
in infrared. You can feel infrared. And
if but if you want to be able to see
infrared, you've got to wear special
infrared goggles or you've got to take a
picture with an infrared camera and then
look and then have the infrared camera
shift the wavelengths to uh wavelengths
that you can see. So that's part of it.
And the other part of it is that it's
just it's was an enormous amount of data
that was required to be able to crunch
down to be able to produce that final
image. And the image is not even the
event horizon of a black hole. It's the
shadow of the event horizon of the black
hole. But the features that are in
there, the way the gas is moving around
the black hole, the orientation, like
all of the things that are in that
picture and the things that helped the
astronomers be able to confirm their
calculations. So there are real data in
that picture that astronomers are able
to use, but obviously they had to
colorize it because you can't see radio
waves. So you know there is uh you know
people always have this concern when uh
you know whenever there's an image
that's taken in a wavelength the like
James web right that's taken in a
wavelength and people are like well
that's not actually a picture that's not
actually a photograph no obviously but
it's real data and and the data is being
presented to you in a way that you can
see it with your eyeballs that are
designed you know that evolved to see in
in the visible wavelengths. And so it's
the same process. It's time to shout out
the new $5 patrons and above. Peter
Wilson, Dwayne Shia, One Step for
Animals, Bob Herd, Chris McNab, Dan Jake
Hopkins, Emanuel Bala, Ryan M. Pearson,
and Austin Tanner. Join the club at
patreon.com/universe
today. Richard R. If we launched a space
telescope one lightyear away to orbit
something, would that expand our
observable universe by one lightyear?
Kind of. So what would happen is that if
you took a telescope and you sent it to
another star system that was a lightyear
away, it would be at the center of its
observable universe and we would be at
the center of our observable universe
and so things that are happening. So if
you sort of imagine right the two stars
are side by side and then we've got a
side of the universe and ours is one
lightyear further and then they've got
their side of the observable universe
and theirs is one lighty year. So if
things are coming their way first then
they'll see it and then we'll have to
wait a year before it becomes part of
our observable universe. But if we see
stuff then they'll have to wait a year
before it becomes their part of the
observable universe. You know, you can
sort of run this analogy with sound,
right? Imagine you have two friends. You
have one friend move uh 500 meters away
from you and then there's a loud sound.
You hear the sound first and then the
other person hears the sound because the
sound has to travel from the location.
But it doesn't make the observable
universe one lightyear further. It just
you now have independent observable
universes around you. Michael Blackree,
would we be able to detect gravitational
waves from before the CMBB and would
that tell us anything useful about the
early universe? Theoretically, yes. So,
the limit that we can see in the
electromagnetic spectrum is the cosmic
microwave background radiation. This was
a time that was 380,000 years after the
beginning of the universe. And that is
the limit that is that that is the
earliest in time that we can see. Um
there's no way for us to see with our
telescopes earlier than that. But
gravitational waves and nutrinos can
move through that opaque material that
was there earlier on. And both were
almost certainly being generated and
sent out into space. And so with both a
nutrino telescope in theory, we should
be able to detect nutrinos from earlier
than the cosmic microwave background and
gravitational waves. And the greatest
thing would be able to detect the
gravitational waves, the aftershocks of
the big bang itself because that was a
time of large amounts of mass moving
around. And there have been researchers
who tried to see the um these they're
called primordial gravitational waves.
And researchers have tried to see them
like some kind of influence of these
gravitational waves on the cosmic
microwave background that it's that you
know as these gravitational waves were
moving through this earliest material it
would have like changed the the
polarization of this early material and
we would see this signal in the CNB but
it hasn't happened yet but people are
still trying. You're probably familiar
with the LISA mission, the laser
interferometer space antenna. And this
is where you're going to have three
satellites flying in information, and
they're going to be firing lasers back
and forth at each other, and they're
going to be tens of thousands of
kilometers apart. And as a gravitational
wave sweeps past them, then it will
change their distance a little bit from
each other, and they will be able to
measure that change in distance, and
they'll be able to to detect the
gravitational wave. And while the
groundbased gravitational wave
observatories kind of top out at merging
black holes, LISA should be able to
detect merging super massive black
holes. But LISA was thought of as like
the first step of a much larger
gravitational wave telescope, something
called the Big Bang Observer. And this
would be a constellation of 12 Lisas
flying in this sort of docahedron
isohedrin 12-sided die. Um and then as
the gravitational waves swept by they
would sort of shift their distance from
each other and it theoretically could be
sensitive enough to detect these
aftershocks from the big bang itself.
And if we could, that would be
mindbending
because it would be this deep insight
into the exact conditions that were
happening early on in the universe. And
unfortunately, we probably won't see a
gravitational wave observatory with that
kind of capability into the 2050s,
2060s. So, uh, people have this on the
books. There are papers. I've reported
on it, but we're a long, long way away
from that actually becoming a reality.
But wouldn't it be amazing? Ugger E.
When we're in the solar system, we orbit
the sun. After we leave the system, do
we start orbiting the black hole in the
center of the Milky Way, right? So we
are on the earth and the earth is
orbiting around the sun and the earth is
going 30 kilometers per second around
the sun and that if you get into earth
orbit it takes I don't forget like 7.5
km/s to get into earth orbit and then
you need about another 12 km/s to escape
the solar system. And so once you escape
the solar system, you are now moving
through interstellar space. You're you
have escaped the gravitational well of
the sun and you are now orbiting like
the rest of the stars in the Milky Way
around the center of the Milky Way. And
yeah, at the center of the Milky Way is
the super massive black hole. But the
super massive black hole is not the
dominant force of gravity in the Milky
Way. It really accounts for less than 1%
like a tenth of a percent of the mass of
the Milky Way. The dominant force of
gravity in the Milky Way is the dark
matter halo that all of the stars and
all of the gas and even that super
massive black hole are embedded within.
And this giant dark matter halo is
turning and we all of the stars inside
the dis of the Milky Way are embedded
within that halo and turning with it. So
yes, if you were to like form a rough uh
circle that the path that you would be
taking around the Milky Way uh at the
center of that is a super massive black
hole. But to say that you were orbiting
around it, it is not the thing that is
holding you in place. It is the sort of
some gravity of all of the stars in the
Milky Way, all of the gas, all of the
dust as well as that halo of dark
matter. Dr. Zab, instead of building
space stations or sending many starships
like SpaceX wants to do, would it make
more sense to build a real spaceship and
assemble it in orbit? I don't know what
is a real spaceship. Um, you know, the
plan is that Starship is a reusable
spaceship. And so you launch it from
Earth, you fill it with fuel from
multiple Starships and then you launch
it towards some distant destination. And
because the Starship is reusable, then
you can just continue to reuse the
spaceship itself. The only cost is the
cost of the fuel and theoretically a
full tank of fuel for a Starship is, you
know, a few hundred,000. It's not that
expensive. Um, now I'm sure reality is
going to end up like it turns out it's
way more expensive than we ever thought.
Who would who would have guessed? You
know, it's not like we're seeing the
Falcon 9 prices come down to the just
the very cost of the fuel. But this goes
back to my old issue is that we don't
have a lot of infrastructure in orbit
right now. So, I can imagine some future
where we do have some kind of orbital
space station, an orbital shipyard that
can 3D print various bits and pieces
that are required for a spaceship. Then
you can send up just the parts that have
to be manufactured on Earth. And because
the thing was built in space, has never
come down to Earth. It doesn't have to
have a shape that can handle landing on
Earth. So, the idea is very elegant and
it's the kind of thing that a future
version of humanity will eventually get
around to. Right now, we are just just
barely learning how to do this and so
it's just baby steps right now. Did you
know you can watch the same video with
no ads and get a bonus question over on
Patreon completely for free? We call
that Q&A plus. And this week's bonus
question, what's happening with space
elevators? And I'll put a link in the
show notes to that episode. All right,
those are all the questions that we had
this week. Thank you everyone who put
your questions into the YouTube
comments. everybody who joined us for
the live show. And just another reminder
that the last live show of the season is
going to be happening on Monday at 5:00
p. p.m. Pacific time. So, if you're
going to be around and you want to
experience the full 2-hour live stream
experience, you should come and join us.
Now, I'm going to talk about the
Alpocalypse.
But first, I'd like to thank our
patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrew Gross,
Barely Griffing, Brian Bod, Carwin,
Chuck Hawkins, Commander Bailock, Sin
Nelson, David Gilin, David Matz, Dustin
Cable, Evan Pro, Greg Phy, Hudson Ward,
James Clark, Jeremy Matter, Jim Burke,
Jordan Young, Marcel Smiths, Michael
Pcell, Monzo, Paul Robuck, Rank Haidu,
Rob, Sean Sergeant, Steven Fler, Munley,
Vlad Shiplin, and Wolf Gang Clots who
support us at the master of the universe
level. And all our patrons, all your
support means the universe to us.
So people who run websites like me, I
run the website Universe Today
experienced something pretty
catastrophic in May. And the name for
this going around is now the AL
apocalypse, the algorithm apocalypse.
And this is when Google rolled out their
new AI search feature. And so if you do
a search on Google now, you get the AI
boil down of the facts that you're
looking for. And now they're rolling out
a new version of that which essentially
replaces the search results with an
interactive AI conversation.
And the effect of this has been dramatic
for websites, which is that nobody uses
Google to get to your website anymore.
And for a lot of people, this is the end
that for a lot of websites, they're
done. Social media isn't sending traffic
to websites anymore. Google isn't
sending traffic to websites anymore. you
you know even if you're producing
amazing content no one's going to find
it and you know like it's not you know
we don't deserve we don't you know
aren't supposed to get anything from
Google it's not our right um but it is
going to make it very difficult for
people to gain new audience and so you
know while we're going through this
process a lot of the websites that you
enjoy are going to disappear they're
just going to go offline uh and that's
just the reality but the way you can
prevent that a little bit is that these
aren't going anywhere Right? These
websites are still going to be there.
It's still on the internet. It's just
that the methods that we have all become
accustomed to to finding these things
are subverting the traffic to other
directions. And so there are a lot of
great technologies that you can use to
maintain steady contact with the
creators that you enjoy. And the tool
that I recommend is RSS, which is a real
syndicated service. R anyway, um RSS.
And you can get an RSS reader. Now,
Google used to have an RSS reader, but
they killed it. Uh, I like Feedley, but
there are a lot of RSS readers out
there. And all of the websites that you
enjoy are going to have an RSS feed that
you can subscribe to. And then you
whenever they write a new article,
whenever they make a new post or
whenever they review a new game or
whatever it is that you enjoy from that
content creator, you'll get a
notification and then you can go and
check that out because none of this
stuff is going to find its way to you
anymore. not in social media, not
through Google, not through news, none
of this stuff. You're going to be cut
off if you rely on those. So, take the
power back into your own hands. Curate
your own uh the way that you interact
with websites on the internet and make a
direct connection with the people who
create. This is the way the web was
supposed to be. This is how it started.
And it just became worse with all of
these middlemen and all these layers in
between. So, RSS go back. And of course,
Universe Today, we have an RSS feed and
you should definitely check that out.
All right, uh we'll see you next time.