Plot Twist: Ex-SpaceX Employee exposed new Inside SpaceX Problem Caused Starship Explosion... === 00:00: Intro 00:36: New revelations about S36’s problems 06:15: Atlas V’s Kuiper-2 mission 10:22: China Zhuque-3’s static fire test === #greatspacex#elonmusk#spacex#nasa#starship == Advertisers who want to place ads on our channel, please contact the email manager: [email protected] === SpaceX Starship SN Be the first to sponsor us Thank you. https://www.patreon.com/GreatspaceX?fan_landing=true Our video content is referenced by video sources at these sites: https://www.space.com/space-exploration/launches-spacecraft/atlas-v-rocket-launches-2nd-batch-of-satellites-for-amazons-project-kuiper-megaconstellation-video https://spacenews.com/landspace-performs-9-engine-static-fire-test-for-reusable-zhuque-3-rocket/ === Plot Twist: Ex-SpaceX Employee exposed new Inside SpaceX Problem Caused Starship Explosion... SpaceX employees have just revealed more details about the issues that led to the failure of Ship 36, and there are several key points that are worth discussing. In other news, United Launch Alliance’s Atlas V has successfully completed its second mission for Amazon’s Project Kuiper. Meanwhile, China has carried out a new test of its well-known Zhuque-3 rocket engine, which has often been compared to other leading designs in the industry. Let’s explore all of this and more on today’s episode of Great SpaceX. Plot Twist: Ex-SpaceX Employee exposed new Inside SpaceX Problem Caused Starship Explosion... The Ship 36 incident continues to capture widespread attention. The more we uncover about what happened, the more it reveals about deeper issues, not only with this particular vehicle but also with the Starship program as a whole. Recently, several new revelations have come to light, this time from a former SpaceX employee named Morgan Wyatt Khan. According to Morgan, many of the issues leading up to the Ship 36 explosion may be tied not only to technical challenges but also to poor workmanship and substandard procedures at the Starbase facility. One of the most discussed components recently is the Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel, or COPV. SpaceX and Elon Musk have both identified a failure in this system as the likely cause of the explosion. Independent analysts have also pointed to a COPV rupture, which likely compromised the structural integrity of the ship, severed fuel lines, and ultimately triggered the devastating explosion. Plot Twist: Ex-SpaceX Employee exposed new Inside SpaceX Problem Caused Starship Explosion... However, the question still stands: why is the COPV failing in the first place? While previous discussions have explored complex technical reasons and broader design challenges, Morgan’s account offers a new and concerning angle. He claimed that during what he called the "Tent era" at Starbase, some workers would routinely slam COPV bottles into the retrofitted brackets in the payload section. According to Morgan, he was responsible for handling issue tickets related to these actions and was forced to assess the resulting damage. This practice is especially dangerous. Even when COPVs are not pressurized, rough handling can easily cause micro-cracks or internal damage. Any hidden defect could result in catastrophic failure once the vessel is pressurized or exposed to cryogenic temperatures. According to Morgan, the damage was so severe that at one point, the entire program had to halt operations while they waited for new COPVs to arrive. And unfortunately, the careless treatment of these components did not end with delivery.
SpaceX employees have just revealed more details about the issues that led to the failure of
Ship 36 and there are several key points that are worth discussing. The Ship 36 incident continues
to capture widespread attention. The more we uncover about what happened, the more it reveals
about deeper issues not only with this particular vehicle but also with the Starship program as a
whole. Recently, several new revelations have come to light, this time from a former SpaceX
employee named Morgan Wyatt Kahn. According to Morgan, many of the issues leading up to the
Ship 36 explosion may be tied not only to technical challenges but also to poor workmanship and
substandard procedures at the Starbase facility. One of the most discussed components recently is
the Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel or COPV. SpaceX and Elon Musk have both identified a failure
in this system as the likely cause of the explosion. Independent analysts have also pointed
to a COPV rupture, which likely compromised the structural integrity of the ship, severed fuel
lines, and ultimately triggered the devastating explosion. However, the question still stands,
why is the COPV failing in the first place? While previous discussions have explored complex
technical issues and broader design challenges, Morgan's account offers a new and concerning angle.
He claimed that during what he called the Tent Era at Starbase, some workers would routinely
slam COPV bottles into the retrofitted brackets in the payload section. According to Morgan,
he was responsible for handling issue tickets related to these actions and was forced to assess
the resulting damage. This practice is especially dangerous. Even when COPVs are not pressurized,
rough handling can easily cause microcracks or internal damage. Any hidden defect could result
in catastrophic failure once the vessel is pressurized or exposed to cryogenic temperatures.
According to Morgan, the damage was so severe that at one point, the entire program had to halt
operations while they waited for new COPVs to arrive. And unfortunately, the careless treatment
of these components did not end with delivery. Morgan went on to describe poor installation
practices as well. He stated that COPV distribution pipes were often loosely tightened,
lacked proper sealing, and in some cases were held in place with cross-threaded bolts of the
wrong size. These oversights suggest not just a lapse in quality control but also a lack of proper
training or experience among workers involved in these crucial tasks. He also speculated about the
exact failure that might have occurred with Ship 36. In his view, it is possible that the COPV
plumbing was never properly sealed. This could mean that the hardware was not fully integrated
or that seals were broken, missing, or incorrectly installed. Loose or missing components could also
have played a role. Another question that has come up is why the problem did not appear earlier
during cryogenic testing or the single-engine static-fire test. Morgan said that stress and
strain limiting factors could be choke-holding the stack up on hardware. He also pointed out
that the stainless steel used in Starship construction is particularly vulnerable to
which could further contribute to sudden failures. When subjected to extreme temperature changes,
stainless steel can contract rapidly, which may even lead to damage to the heat shield tiles.
But technical challenges aside, perhaps the most concerning point Morgan raised is how management
at Starbase has been handling these issues. In his view, problems are not being addressed with
the seriousness they deserve. The combination of sensitive systems and a rushed or careless
approach has created a situation where major failures become increasingly likely.
The S-36 explosion is a prime example of this. A single flaw in one component cascaded into a
full system failure, costing SpaceX a critical prototype and delaying the program's timeline.
And while COPV is the current focus, it is only one of the many systems within Starship that require
close attention. Issues with engines, flaps, tanks, and plumbing have all emerged at different
stages in recent tests. These revelations raise broader questions about the overall workforce,
culture, and management structure at Starbase. While Musk and Shotwell continue to lead SpaceX
at the highest level, their direct involvement in Starbase operations appears to have decreased
over time. Some suggest that their more frequent presence could help reestablish higher standards
and restore stronger oversight to the team working on Starship. Before anything else,
SpaceX must now turn its attention to the aftermath at the Massey test site.
Damage must be assessed and repaired, and new testing systems may need to be constructed to
move forward. But more importantly, the internal practices that contributed to this failure must
be thoroughly reviewed and improved. Sensitive systems like COPV need clear protocols, better
installation practices, and rigorous checks. Broader systems should also be audited to prevent
recurring issues. Lessons must be learned not only from the explosion of Ship 36, but also from
the earlier problems seen in flights 8, 9, and other recent test flights. If handled well, this
could be a turning point. While the explosion was undoubtedly a major setback, it could also serve
as a much-needed wake-up call. SpaceX now has the opportunity to reassess, regroup, and come
back stronger. With better systems, improved oversight, and renewed attention to detail,
the company can still achieve the goals of reusability, orbital refueling, lunar missions,
and eventually, Mars colonization. What do you think of these newly revealed causes behind the
Ship 36 failure and the broader issues facing Starship? Is this the time for Musk and SpaceX
to refocus and raise the bar across the board? If you agree, comment Let's Do It down below.
And as always, like the video and subscribe to our channel to continue following the incredible
journey of SpaceX. COPV. This is quickly becoming a significant keyword when discussing Starship at
this stage of its development. Yes, it is the very component responsible for the recent Ship 36
incident. And it is not the first time this part has been brought up during the long and complex
journey of Starship's evolution. So why does SpaceX continue to face challenges with this
component? And more importantly, what steps might they take to fix it moving forward?
Starship is without a doubt one of the most unique and complex rockets in the world. It is made of
many intricate parts and systems, all of which must work in perfect coordination. Because of
this complexity, maintaining flawless performance across every flight is incredibly difficult.
Over time, we have seen different systems run into issues, from engines and flaps to fuel tanks.
Most recently, another system has entered the spotlight, the COPV. COPV stands for Composite
Overwrapped Pressure Vessel. It is a lightweight, high-pressure container typically made of aluminum
and wrapped in a carbon fiber composite. Its role is to store gases such as nitrogen or helium,
which are used to pressurize different parts of the rocket. On Starship, the COPVs are located
inside the payload section, or nose cone, and help support critical operations like nitrogen purging
and engine spin start procedures. Their lightweight design is key to maintaining performance,
which is why after Flight 9, several COPVs were seen washed up along the beach.
However, despite their advantages, COPVs are quite complex and vulnerable to failure under
extreme conditions. On X, Elon Musk explained, preliminary data suggests that a nitrogen COPV
in the payload bay failed before its proof pressure. It appears that during the recent
test, the internal pressure exceeded the container's limits, causing the COPV to rupture.
The resulting force was powerful enough to blow a hole through the windward side of the vehicle
and damage key structures, including fuel lines and the forward dome. This allowed fuel to leak
out, ignite, and ultimately cause the massive explosion that destroyed Ship 36. What makes the
situation even more challenging is that this appears to be an entirely new failure mode.
Musk also said, if further investigation confirms that this is what happened,
it is the first time ever for this design. SpaceX later confirmed in their official update,
there is no commonality between the COPVs used on Starship and SpaceX's Falcon rockets.
That clarification is important, especially considering that Falcon 9 had its own COPV
related issues during the CRS-7 mission in 2015 and the Amos 6 mission in 2016.
So the question now is, why has the COPV become a recurring issue in SpaceX's Starship development?
To begin with, one of the primary reasons lies in the inherent complexity of COPV design,
especially when it comes to composite materials. These vessels are engineered to hold extremely
high-pressure gases, and that requires intricate layers of composite wrapping.
When manufacturing or handling is not flawless, this complexity can introduce a range of
vulnerabilities. For instance, small flaws such as improper liner bonding, uneven fiber application,
or imperfections during the winding process can compromise the vessel's structural integrity.
In some cases, the composite layers can warp under stress, creating pockets that may trap
liquid oxygen or pressurized gas. This situation can become highly volatile,
and under the right conditions, may lead to catastrophic failure.
The second contributing factor is the significant difference between the COPVs used in Starship and
those used in other vehicles, including SpaceX's Falcon 9. SpaceX and Musk have repeatedly emphasized
that Starship's systems are unique. Given that Starship is the largest and most powerful rocket
ever built, the pressure and thermal loads are vastly different from those of Falcon 9.
Starship must handle greater engine thrust, larger propellant volumes, and stronger structural
vibrations which create harsher environments for all components, especially COPVs.
Another major challenge stems from Starship's use of cryogenic fuels. Unlike Falcon 9, which
uses a combination of liquid oxygen and kerosene, or RP-1, Starship uses both liquid oxygen and
liquid methane, both of which must be kept at extremely low temperatures. This further
stresses the composite materials of COPVs, increasing the likelihood of cold-induced
brittleness, delamination, or cracking, all of which could lead to failure under pressure.
More critically, Starship is designed for full reusability and long-duration missions,
such as in-space refueling, lunar landings, and even Mars colonization. That means every component,
including the COPVs, must be capable of enduring multiple cycles of pressure, temperature variation,
and physical stress. This demand for durability and reusability introduces a new layer of
engineering challenges that are very different from those faced with Falcon 9. Elon Musk has
even pointed out that the recent incident on Ship 36 is the first time a failure has occurred
with this specific COPV design. This makes it clear that although Falcon 9 experienced two
major COPV-related issues in 2015 and 2016, the knowledge from those events is not directly
transferable to Starship. Starship's size, mission objectives, and operational environment make it a
different kind of vehicle altogether. Therefore, new solutions and testing regimes are needed.
Beyond the technical pressure, there is also significant time pressure. SpaceX's rapid
development approach means that Starship is being built and tested in fast cycles, often with limited
time between design, construction, and launch attempts. SpaceX accepts that failure is part of
the process and uses data from each test to improve future designs. However, this fast pace can also
mean that problems emerge before previous issues are fully understood or resolved. In 2025 alone,
Starship has already encountered multiple challenges, including harmonic vibrations,
unexpected propellant mixing, loss of vehicle control during flight, and now the COPV failure.
While this iterative development method can produce results faster, it also exposes the
system to a higher risk of unexpected failures. Each flight is intended to build on lessons from
the last, but with the pace accelerating, the risk of skipping over important insights also increases.
Moreover, Starship is under additional pressure to achieve extremely ambitious goals. It is not
just another rocket, it is the backbone of future missions involving two-stage landings,
in-orbit refueling, and participation in NASA's Artemis program and Mars colonization plans.
These goals force aggressive timelines and sometimes lead to shortcuts in testing or
refinement. The need for fast progress can mean some parts, like COPVs, are not stress tested
under the full range of conditions they will encounter during flight.
Another contributing factor is the gap between test conditions and actual flight conditions.
Some aerospace experts have suggested that Starship's integrated testing process may be
insufficient to identify certain failure points. Since components like COPVs may pass bench testing
but fail under full stack, cryogenic, or vibration loaded conditions, issues might go undetected
until they cause major incidents. A more isolated and rigorous testing campaign could possibly have
caught the COPV flaw that doomed S-36. It is also important to remember that Starship is still a
developmental vehicle. NASA does not yet have the same oversight over its COPV systems as it does
for Falcon 9 missions. This means that SpaceX largely manages Starship's component testing
and quality control internally. Given that, some theorize that the COPVs on recent prototypes may
not have been installed or secured correctly, increasing the risk of mechanical failure during
operations. Furthermore, locating the COPVs in the nose cone near pressurized fuel lines only adds to
the risk. If one fails, it could trigger a chain reaction affecting multiple systems at once.
There may be even more underlying factors yet to be revealed. If you have any thoughts or additional
ideas on why Starship's COPV system continues to be a challenge, feel free to share them in the
section down below. Then, don't forget to like the video and subscribe to our channel to continue
following the ongoing journey of SpaceX's most ambitious project. Now, once the root causes of
the incident are identified, the next crucial step will be determining potential solutions and
implementing the necessary corrective actions. The first and perhaps most significant solution
is to thoroughly investigate and possibly redesign the COPV system. This will depend heavily on the
findings of the ongoing investigation. If a fundamental flaw is discovered, SpaceX may need
to completely overhaul the current COPV design. This could involve reinforcing the outer casing,
improving structural integrity, or even adjusting the internal layout. Special attention will need
to be given to the liner joints, which might be upgraded to ensure they can handle repeated stress
without compromising durability or reliability. The second step involves enhancing the testing
process itself. SpaceX will likely need to expand its test protocols, incorporating both isolated
and integrated evaluations of the COPV system. Testing standards should be increased to push
the limits of pressure and thermal conditions in order to detect vulnerabilities early.
Alongside this, quality control procedures must be tightened across every stage of production,
from design and manufacturing to installation and system verification. Personnel involved in these
stages may also require updated training, which could be implemented during the downtime while
the Massey test site undergoes cleanup and repair. With S-36 now lost, S-37 is expected to be next
in line, and its COPV system will be closely scrutinized while it remains inside Megabay 2.
Finally, SpaceX may explore alternative technologies to reduce reliance on the COPV system
altogether. One option could be to utilize engine-supplied air for certain pressurization
tasks, potentially lowering the operational demands placed on the COPVs. However, this would
introduce new engineering challenges, including the design and integration of a supporting system,
which may add complexity to the overall architecture. It can be said that even a single
incident involving one part of Starship is enough to reveal much about the challenges SpaceX still
faces. Starship, a rocket widely considered to be the future of the aerospace industry,
remains a highly complex and ambitious system. This complexity makes it extremely difficult for
even its creators to maintain complete control over every aspect of its development. The recent
issue involving the COPV stands out as a powerful example of the broader challenges within the
Starship program. This component, while seemingly minor, has emerged as a focal point for both
technical analysis and potential design improvements. In the weeks and months ahead,
the COPV will likely receive heightened attention as engineers assess failure points and begin
implementing more robust solutions. If SpaceX can overcome this setback, it'll position the
company for an even stronger return, pushing toward its long-term goals of reaching the moon,
Mars, and beyond. So, let us see how SpaceX responds in the days ahead.
And now we shift to China, where the Xuchui-3 rocket is quickly emerging as the centerpiece
of the country's push for reusable launch technology. Built by private firm Landspace,
the Xuchui-3 builds on the methalox foundation of its predecessor, the Xuchui-2, but introduces
major upgrades aimed at reusability following the path forged by SpaceX's Falcon 9 and Starship.
At midnight Eastern, June 20th, a major milestone was achieved. Landspace successfully conducted a
static fire of the Xuchui-3 booster at the Jiuquan Satellite Launch Center. All nine Tianchui-12A
engines ignited in sequence, burned for 45 seconds, and shut down as planned. With 7,542
kilonewtons of thrust, the test confirmed the vehicle's heavy lift potential and readiness for
its first orbital flight. The test mirrored a full launch cycle, which involves pressurization,
multi-engine ignition, gimbal control, steady burn, and shutdown, using the same stage intended
for flight. Landspace hailed it as a key step toward making China's reusable rocket ambitions
a reality. The inaugural flight, set for the third quarter of this year, is expected to carry
a prototype of the Haolong cargo craft, developed to support the Tiangong space station. Interestingly,
new specs put the Xuchui-3 at 66 meters tall, which is 10 meters shorter than earlier figures.
This could indicate reduced payload capacity for earlier flights, but it doesn't diminish
its role as a serious challenger in the global launch market. China's efforts with Xuchui-3 reflect
a broader strategy to compete with the West, not just through state programs, but now with commercial
ventures as well. The race is no longer defined by governments alone. Companies like Landspace
are rising fast. With SpaceX facing delays after Ship 36's explosion and ongoing COPV concerns,
the pressure to rebound quickly is real. China's progress adds urgency. The next few months will be
pivotal. As we watch Xuchui-3 edge closer to orbit, the modern space race continues to intensify,
and the next leap could come from either side of the Pacific. This has been Kevin with GreatSpaceX.
Don't forget to like the video and subscribe if you haven't already to stay updated with yours
truly on the latest milestones in SpaceX's journey. Thank you so much for watching and
always remember, curiosity, imagination, and inspiration will follow you so long as you
keep looking up.