Why 50,000 Chinese Students in California Are Worried About Their Visas | Joshua Philipp

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
28 Video Views·Jun 27, 2025
American universities are known for their openness to global collaboration. But some partnerships may carry more than academic goals. In this episode, investigative journalist Joshua Philipp looks at how foreign-backed programs on U.S. campuses have intersected with national security concerns, from research funding to curriculum decisions.
50,000 Chinese students are attending
California's universities on student visa.
There are talks of potentially revoking
some of these student visas.
Our guest today is Joshua Phillip,
who's an investigative reporter with Epoch Times.
He's here to tell us what's happening
on university campuses here
and why the Chinese Communist Party has invested so much
to gain influence inside our universities.
He also will share with us his journey
of finding all this out.
One of the greatest national security threats
to the United States.
One of the greatest threats our country faces
would have gone unreported.
I decided, yeah, I'm willing to die for this.
And if they kill me, it'll make it better known.
And so I decided, yeah, I'm not gonna stop, no matter what.
I'm Siamak Khorrami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Josh, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Hey, always a pleasure, Siamak.
Great to be here too.
Yeah, it's awesome.
We wanna talk to you about a phenomenon that's happening
that could impact California universities big time
and Chinese students here.
There's talks of revoking visas
for Chinese students nationally,
and there's 50,000 students here in California
that could potentially lose their visas.
It's interesting because I saw Trump make the announcement
and it seems the case that they're,
I mean, I don't know what the criteria is gonna be,
but they did suggest they were gonna start revoking
the visas of, I mean, it seemed all Chinese students,
but they said, especially those with ties
to the Chinese Communist Party.
So I don't know if that means all of them
or some of them or what it means,
but that also comes in the heels of
the Trump administration trying to pull
the ability of Harvard to have foreign exchange students.
So there, it seems like it's impacting all of them.
I think this is one of the issues
where people are still waiting to see
how broadly they're going to implement this.
But I can tell you, I mean, this is the other side of it.
All of them, there's a number of students that are here
legitimately, they're trying to study,
but some are linked to the CCP.
And I know many of them.
I've met many Chinese students
who are very not supportive of the CCP.
I know a lot who are just totally non-political
and just wanna study here.
And so as a journalist,
I've researched Chinese spy networks quite a bit,
including the Chinese spy networks.
I can say without a doubt,
there are some organizations operating
in American universities that are openly controlled
by the CCP, funded by the CCP, directed by the CCP.
These organizations, from what I mean, this is provable,
they even monitor and harm other Chinese students.
So, you know, if you were saying you're gonna go after
like the actual provable, dangerous Chinese organizations
at universities that are even to an extent
persecuting other students,
like even on human rights grounds, I think absolutely.
The other argument would be that the problem is so big
that even if you just went after one network,
maybe they just, you know, hide it better.
So maybe from a national security standpoint,
that's what they're looking at,
but I can understand both sides.
It is a bit extreme, I think,
but I can understand both sides.
Can you tell us, in your work,
you have actually studied how these networks work.
Can you tell us what they look like?
Okay, so let me break down a couple of them.
I think most people by now have heard
about the Confucius Institutes.
Basically, the Chinese Communist Party goes to universities
and it's not even just universities now.
They do this kindergarten through high school
all the way up through college.
But a lot of people are not familiar
with the Confucius Institutes.
The Chinese Communist Party goes to schools,
big time universities, and they say,
let us do a foreign Chinese language and culture class
at your university.
We'll pay for the building.
We'll pay for the teachers.
You don't have to do anything.
In other words, it's like,
we will pay you to let us build
an educational institution at your school.
You'll get money from it.
You'll have more options for your students.
You'll have new language and culture classes.
Who wouldn't want that from a certain standpoint?
If a non-hostile country were to do that,
it would be a fantastic thing.
Who wouldn't want it?
It turns out, though, that it comes with strings attached.
The Chinese Communist Party, through that,
can say, well, now that we're here,
if you hold an event we don't approve of,
we're pulling out.
If you have a speaker on Chinese human rights,
we're pulling out.
If you have a student group at your school
that holds an event about human rights in China,
we find that offensive, we'll pull out.
And so what happens is the university then has
to restrict the freedom of speech to the students.
They have to restrict what kind of conversations
they can allow on their campuses.
And it creates, through that financial channel,
a type of what I would call transnational repression.
The university then has to censor human rights issues,
the speech of students and everything else.
So do they come to the university and tell them,
because we have the center here,
you're not allowed to have certain events?
I don't think they tell them that from the get-go,
but there have been documented cases
where universities have, for example, held events
about human rights abuse in Tibet, for example,
or held events about organ harvesting
of Falun Gong practitioners, for example.
And not only do the Confucius Institutes,
the Chinese regime behind it,
not only do they say, don't hold this event
or try to pressure them,
they do threaten to pull funding out of the schools.
And then there's also other problems.
There are normal Chinese citizens,
former Chinese expats or something like that
in the United States who wanted to become teachers
at those school programs.
Like, oh, hey, I speak Chinese.
They need Chinese language teachers.
Why don't I do it?
They go there and they find that
because the CCP is involved in the hiring process
that they can't get the job.
And so these institutions discriminate based on religion,
they discriminate based on political views,
and it's all in the interest of the Chinese Communist Party.
And so even from a normal legal standpoint,
even in terms of the Civil Rights Act in the United States,
that shouldn't be allowed, right?
But what is big about these universities
is a lot of people are familiar with that.
They're not familiar with the many, many,
many other programs.
In the lower grades is what are called
the Little Red Schools, just like Confucius Institutes,
but a different name.
They have, for example, different programs aimed directly-
They're called the Little Red Groups?
Little Red Schools, yeah.
And they're in the K-12?
In American schools.
I don't know the exact grades,
but they're lower school grades.
They're very active, for example, like Arizona and stuff.
The CCP is behind that.
They do that as well.
They have organizations that target,
for example, researchers.
People might've heard of the TORCH program.
That's a program where the CCP will target researchers
receiving government grants at American universities,
including grad students and so on.
They have open spy programs
that try to recruit these people.
I mean, almost too many to list.
But when you talk specifically about Chinese student spies,
one of the main operations they have,
there's an organization run by the Chinese consulates,
directed by it, and funded by them.
And they're called
the Chinese Student and Scholar Associations.
So these Chinese Student Scholar Associations, right?
These are openly, openly, in their own writing,
funded by the CCP, directed by the CCP,
operated by the CCP, and can be used by the CCP
for a lot of terrible things.
I'll get into some of the nuts and bolts of it,
but as a bit of background to this,
I've been exposing this going back to 2008.
A lot of my research as a journalist,
I mean, I started at Epic Times when I was still a student.
I just stuck with it.
A lot of my research started with my investigations
into what's called the United Front,
the United Front Work Department,
which is one of the main branches
of the Chinese Communist Party focused on foreign espionage.
What you're saying is these, they're on campus.
These are student groups.
Yes.
But they're actually funded by the Chinese Communist Party
and they actually work for the Chinese Communist Party.
How does that work?
In their own words.
When I was exposing the Chinese Communist Party's operations
of subversion, I was doing a lot
of on-the-ground investigations.
Some of these were into, you know,
Chinese CCP-tied organizations,
like community groups and friendship associations
and business groups that were tied directly to the CCP.
Because going back to 2008, the Beijing Olympics,
a lot of these organizations were coming to the surface.
They were protesting against any critics of the CCP.
If a news outlet said anything about the bloody Olympics,
as they called it at the time,
because the CCP at the time was very much,
very publicly persecuting Tibetans especially in China.
They were suppressing all Chinese dissidents
and they were launching attacks through these networks
against any groups abroad.
So if there was a Chinese group in the United States,
New York, San Francisco, there were actual cases of it.
If there were any Chinese groups anywhere
who were, you know, holding public demonstrations
against the bloody Olympics,
because the CCP was increasingly becoming
like authoritarian at the time,
they were finding that they would have
these large groups come out, Chinese students,
Chinese business, you know, business associations
and what he called Tongs.
And they were criticizing people,
sometimes beating people up, attacking people,
spitting on them, cursing at them, threatening to kill them.
And I was at the time investigating who are these people.
Now, I've talked a lot about my research into the Tongs,
the Chinese associations tied in
with the CCP's united front work.
But one thing that's not talked about as much
and I even haven't talked about it as much
are the Chinese Student and Scholar Associations.
A lot of those Chinese student protesters,
they're part of the Chinese Student and Scholar Associations
and that's the exact name they use.
Chinese Scholar Association.
Chinese Student and Scholar Associations,
that's their official name.
Now, this is where it gets interesting.
If you really research them, this is what you find.
If you go to the Chinese Communist Party's embassy website,
they have an academic branch of the Chinese embassy
and on their official website,
they list all of these associations
and they list every university they're part of.
They have it public.
What's also interesting, they have since pulled that offline.
They deleted the webpage.
Now, I don't know what their intent is.
My personal belief would be that they don't want people
knowing that the Chinese embassy is openly funding
and operating these organizations
and maybe they're trying to cover their tracks.
I saved the archive.
And so this is, even though deleted, it still exists.
What are they trying to achieve?
So you mentioned that they have this,
the Confucius Institutes,
that they try to teach the Chinese culture,
but I'm sure it's kind of the type of culture
they want to show,
but what else do they want to achieve using this?
So this ties into something pretty big.
It ties into a few things.
If you want to break it down, big picture,
it is intellectual property theft.
A lot of universities have research programs
funded by taxpayers.
Even Pentagon, we have military-funded research programs
being done at major American universities.
We have medical research
funded by taxpayers at universities.
We have technology research.
And a lot of these universities, they get research grants.
Those research programs are open to foreign students.
And the CCP, you have to imagine if you have, for example,
a Chinese-controlled grad student,
part of the Chinese Student Scholar Associations,
or even just targeted for it,
they can get their professors, oftentimes,
the Chinese Student Scholar Associations
is not just students, it's also professors,
professors and faculty at universities,
and even external figures in the public,
which include the Tong leaders.
So the actual subversive networks,
it's the entire leadership behind this.
So it's the professors, it's the students,
and then there's the community, some community leaders.
And faculty.
And so what happens is this,
is they can pick the students they want
and then give them access to these things.
They can push them into it.
So on one side, you have, of course, the research programs.
Those are valuable for, imagine, and this happens,
American taxpayers fund a weapons program.
And then those Chinese students
working with this organization go back to China
and they bring the research with them.
Even if they don't steal it, which they often do,
they go with the knowledge.
And then what do we find?
We find, well, two years later,
the thing that we paid to have researched at X university
is now being developed by the Chinese military.
Very commonly happens, very often.
Aside from that, that brain drain,
you have the issue, of course, of just Chinese narrative.
They want to defend narratives
and they want to push narratives.
For example, they will try to use their influence
to protest against any kind of maybe student event
or public debate or anything.
Anything that would make
the Chinese Communist Party look bad.
Human rights issues, Taiwan independence,
Hong Kong democracy, you name it, right?
Trade issues, even tariffs now probably.
Those types of things.
If they hold an event on that, the faculty, the students,
the key figures in the community will work together
and they'll protest it.
They'll lobby the dean of the university.
They'll complain to the professor.
They will go to the organizers of the event
and say, how dare you hold this
because it's offensive to the feelings of the Chinese people.
Like they use that, right?
And so they, on one side, prevent that.
On the other side, they can then rally their own networks
to hold positive events.
So they can get, for example, all those Chinese leaders
to hold like friendship meetings
or China-US economic engagement meetings
and things like that.
They can have business opportunity meetings.
They can have people come and facilitate,
travel to China where they get business,
Chinese students to go to,
or normal students in the US to go to China
for like Chinese business exchange things,
things like that.
They manipulate it.
So they destroy certain narratives and they prop up others.
But the big one, I think, is something else.
The most serious threat on a national security level,
even beyond brain drain and losing
like government-funded weapons research programs to China
because of this, the biggest threat is embedded spies.
Because what the CCP can do,
if they go to Harvard, for example,
and Harvard, there was a great
Wall Street Journal article recently.
They said the Chinese Communist Party leadership,
they call Harvard their party school.
They say that Harvard has trained a massive number
of Chinese Communist Party officials.
And so they target it, right?
The biggest threat you have is they come
to these universities and then they are raised,
grown through these networks, tied in.
The event funding comes from the Chinese consulates
or the Chinese consul general and the tongs.
The support networks are all the Chinese spy networks.
And they can take these Chinese students
and drag them up through the ranks effectively
and then say, what business do we want you in?
Maybe a Chinese student studies law.
Maybe they want some, maybe they want a Chinese spy
working in the justice department.
They can oversee the development of that Chinese student.
They can write letters of recommendation
and that student, through them pushing,
can then apply for a job in the justice department.
Maybe they want a Chinese student in the FDA
because maybe they want to have something
to clear the way for Chinese trade
unlike pharmaceuticals, same thing.
They can have the entire CCP network
support their development.
They can have them write letters of recommendation.
They can do engagement programs.
Look how influential the student is with China.
And they can push that student along as a career
into a government position.
They can do that in local politics.
They can do that in key businesses.
They can do that in law enforcement.
They can do it, maybe they want to have someone
join the military or join the FBI
or maybe even run for political office, for example.
This is the method the CCP uses to place spies,
agents of influence or otherwise within our government.
Doesn't it take a long time?
They're just doing that, right?
Well, let's put it this way.
I've been researching this since 2008.
And in 2008, it had already been going on for a while.
That was, what, 20 years ago, almost.
This has been going on at least 20 years.
Because when I was researching it, it was at that time.
How many students are now old enough
to have gotten official positions in our own government?
A lot.
And every year, every single year,
they're graduating and going into new jobs.
And every single year, it's not just one university.
If you go by the Chinese embassy website,
the one they deleted, the one they deleted,
which we have the archives of,
if you go by the actual Chinese government website,
the embassy website, they list them.
And there are dozens upon dozens, I mean, tons of them,
just a long list of American universities.
And imagine how many, look, one spy is a problem.
One Chinese agent in a government position is problematic,
especially when you get to like middle-level bureaucracies
and they have a lot of power.
One of them is problematic.
Imagine 10.
Imagine 20.
Imagine 100.
Imagine 1,000.
By this point, they would have trained thousands
upon thousands upon thousands.
Now, Josh, there is another side to this
because there is a lot of good Chinese people
that are not tied with any of this
and they probably worked very hard to get to those careers.
And I feel terrible for them.
I mean, I was actually talking to a Chinese friend
about this recently and she was telling me
that she has a nephew who's from China.
He's currently studying at a university in the US.
I won't say where because he might get targeted
if we say it.
He's afraid of losing his visa.
He's afraid of getting sent back to China.
I personally know some Chinese dissidents
who came to the United States to study
and they defected while they were here.
I know a lot of them.
I know, and the woman who told me
that her nephew was here studying,
she told me that when she came here as a student
and she came here as a student also a long time ago now,
she said when she came here,
a Chinese agent pulled her aside
and said, remember, you serve the motherland.
And she told me, because I was like,
well, what do you think about all this?
She's like, good.
She said, good.
She said, because every Chinese
who comes here and studies knows
that the CCP will try to pressure you to become a spy.
Now, that doesn't mean every one of them is gonna spy.
You have a lot of, I mean,
I'd probably say the majority of them don't do it.
But every one of them-
It's how the CCP works.
And especially if you do something the CCP wants.
Like, if you come here
and you don't do anything of special interest to the CCP,
maybe you don't get
to these government-funded research programs,
or they don't think you have the potential
to get a job in the US government,
they might not care about you.
If you do decide you wanna go back to China,
they will interview you.
They'll say, oh, so what did you,
and it might be something friendly.
You might get a call
from just a local business leader, for example.
Might not even be the Chinese spy agent.
It's not like the head of the local Chinese police
is gonna call you up to meet.
Maybe they will, depending what it is.
But for the most part, no.
You might get a call
from a local Chinese business leader in China,
saying, hey, I heard you studied in America.
I'm very interested in what you learned.
How would you like to have lunch with me?
My treat, or dinner with me, my treat.
You'll go there.
You'll sit down at the table.
They'll wine and dine you,
and say, so what did you study?
Oh, you were in a research program?
Oh, so interesting.
I'm also researching this.
Let me show you what I did.
And they might not ask you, give me your research.
They'll volunteer what they do.
Say, oh, look what we're doing.
We're developing maybe new camera technology.
Maybe medical research.
Medical research is probably a better example.
We're developing this new medication.
And we're kind of stuck at this point right here.
We can't figure out.
The student, oh, I researched that.
I worked on a program working on that exact issue.
The student wants a job, obviously.
If you're applying for a job,
don't you want to make a point?
Oh, I worked on the very thing you need.
Applying for any job, of course you're gonna do that.
But what the student doesn't know
is that guy already knew the student was working on that.
That guy already knew.
So it's all orchestrated.
It's orchestrated.
And that's how it works.
Now, on one side, you call that brain drain.
You call that just how it works in every country on Earth
when they have foreign students come here
and they go back to their own countries
and they get jobs in the industry they learned
because obviously they studied it.
But when you have a country doing it
through their intelligence operations,
where they're doing this intentionally,
and to the point where they're using it
as a type of business warfare against us,
trying to undermine our own economy
by undercutting us on the markets,
or using it to build weapons and so on,
then it's problematic.
And for the CCP, this is the modus operandi.
This is how it operates.
This is how the whole system works for them.
So how can people know the difference?
Is there a way for people to find out who is who
or the administration to monitor who's?
Well, this is the problem with the Chinese Communist Party.
If you listen to some really loud public voices
about the CCP, a lot of people who understand the CCP
say the only solution is total disengagement.
And that may sound extreme,
and maybe that's what Trump's even doing on the,
because what does that look like?
Well, it looks like Trump basically banning
the visas of all Chinese students.
That's what disengagement looks like.
It looks like us restricting certain sales
of Chinese technology or products on our markets.
It might look like sanctions
against very large Chinese businesses like Huawei and ZTE.
Those are two of the biggest ones we saw with that.
But the argument they have is that it's not,
the problem is not the Chinese people.
And this is the big issue you have.
The problem is not the Chinese people.
The problem is how the Chinese Communist Party
manipulates them.
The problem is the Chinese Communist Party's
authoritarian laws that manipulate
even their access to our open system.
And for the Chinese Communist Party,
there's no such thing as an independent business.
There's no such thing as an independent researcher.
There's no such thing.
They all belong to the government.
No, they all do.
But even though they look like
they have opened up the economy, right?
It's all run by the CCP.
Now that doesn't apply so much
for like the really small businesses
or the very small researchers.
Like if you're not good at what you do,
if you're not successful, they might not care.
But as soon as you reach any level of prominence,
the CCP is gonna come knocking at your door
and saying, time to join the party or you're done.
Join the party where it's the Gulag or Finch
or you're out of business
or we're gonna take over your business.
That happened to Jack Ma, Alibaba, for example.
They pushed him out, took over his business
because he criticized the CCP.
If you're a medium or large business,
you have to have a Communist Party cell.
You have to make all of your data,
all of your research viewable,
accessible by the Chinese Communist Party.
If you do foreign investment,
all foreign investment is regulated by the CCP.
You can't even invest without the oversight
of the Chinese Communist Party,
at least not on a large scale.
And so anything that is of interest to the CCP,
they control, no exceptions.
And when you're dealing with a country like that,
where there is no such thing as independence,
there is no such thing as an independent researcher
or an independent scholar or an independent business leader,
how do you deal with that
when the country is openly hostile towards yours
and is trying to steal the things
when you're trying to be nice to people
on an individual level?
Because you know that not all of them are bad.
You know, there are plenty of good people.
How do you deal with that?
And that's the challenge America has.
For those students that are not part of the CCP,
they're not connected and they're here to genuinely study
and wanna have a better life in America,
what is it like for them to navigate all of this?
Well, you're gonna get pressured.
I mean, if you're not doing anything important,
maybe not so much.
Like there are plenty of Chinese students
who come here and study and they just do their own things
and maybe they integrate more with the society
and not a big deal.
But if you become successful,
if you have a breakthrough,
if you get involved in anything
that is relevant to the CCP's interests,
then they will want you.
Even aside from maybe research programs
or business opportunities,
even if you develop good connections,
they'll want your connections.
And to the point of, again,
Wall Street Journal had a great article
talking about how the CCP regards Harvard University
as their party school.
And they said, it's not even just Harvard,
it's all the top universities.
Why is that valuable?
Well, aside from the fact that they can use it
to get involved in all these programs,
that they can use it to infiltrate parts of our government,
they also develop connections.
They get to know the future business leaders in America.
They get to know the future government officials in America.
They get to know the top investors
and everybody else who has any say in our country
because those universities do tend to work
as the kind of direct channels
into different areas of influence within the society.
And so through their interpersonal connections,
they then can use that for espionage,
which they do very aggressively.
But to your point of your average Chinese student,
let's say they don't do any of that.
They come here, they fall in love with America.
Maybe they wanna go back to China,
but they don't do anything big.
They just wanna work a normal job or whatever else.
What is life like for them?
Let's say they get interested.
Maybe they're on YouTube here
or maybe they get an American cell phone
and they turn on YouTube and they're like, what's this?
What is June 4th?
And like, never heard of that.
The Tiananmen Square Massacre, right?
Yeah, what is June 4th?
Why are Americans talking about June 4th?
You might've seen Marco Rubio was talking about,
Nancy Pelosi was talking about it,
condemning the Chinese Communist Party
for the June 4th massacre.
In America, this is a bipartisan issue.
So if you're in America as a student, you're gonna see it.
So a Chinese student may be watching TV
or hanging out with their friends
and the friends are like,
oh, what do you think of the Tiananmen Square Massacre?
The Chinese student's like, what?
Never heard of it.
And why is that?
It's because in China, you can't, it doesn't exist.
If you wanna ask Chinese AI deep seek,
hey, say June 4th, it can't do it.
It can't even do it.
And so what happens?
This Chinese student turns on the internet
and they watch this video and they're like,
oh my gosh, the Communist Party, the CCP,
they massacred Chinese students?
Did this really happen?
Why did I never hear about it?
And then you have the risk that they have that scene
from the Matrix, Neo takes the red pill
and he's like, suddenly wakes up out of the pod
and realizes the world isn't what he thought it was.
They go through it and they're like,
they covered up this, this is not true,
this is not true, this is not true.
And they have that moment, I've been lied to my entire life.
And for some of them, it's a shocking moment.
I remember I had a friend,
she was telling me in Chinese school,
they had slogan class and they tell you all these stories
about famous Chinese Communist Party heroes.
She said that when she was a kid,
she really idolized some of them.
And when she came to study in America,
she found out all the stories were fabricated,
they were fake and she never knew.
And so for the CCP, that's like,
oh, okay, you've crossed the danger zone thing.
You've gone over the line
and now you are a threat to the party
because you know the truth.
Then what happens?
Well, the Chinese student can keep it to themselves.
They can, you know.
Which a lot of people do that, probably.
A lot of them do it because they don't.
For Chinese, they call it not getting involved in politics.
It's not like us where, you know,
again, we're a free society, you can vote
and stuff like that.
For them, not getting involved in politics
means it's none of your business
and you keep your mouth shut, basically.
You know what I mean?
But let's say, for example, they realize,
hey, the CCP has been abusing the Chinese people.
Maybe they find out about organ harvesting of Falun Gong.
Maybe they find out about slave labor
of like, you know, Muslim Uyghurs.
Maybe they find out that the American government
is talking about this.
Maybe they see that American Congress
signed the Falun Gong Protection Act,
you know, condemning the CCP for organ harvesting.
Like, wow, the American government is talking about this.
Because Falun Gong is a big issue in China, right?
They don't allow any, you can't even say.
One of the biggest on the human rights front.
But let me, I'll talk about that too
because, you know, for them, that's a big issue.
So what happens then?
Maybe that Chinese student then says,
hey, there's an event coming up at my school
where they're gonna talk about organ harvesting.
Or there's an event coming up at my school
where they're gonna talk about, you know,
genocide in Tibet, cultural genocide in Tibet.
Or anything like that.
And so they wanna go.
The student goes to the event.
They might see that, you know,
the Chinese Student Scholar Associations are protesting.
But like, I'm gonna go anyway.
They will have their name reported
to the Chinese consulate.
Those other Chinese student groups,
they work as the eyes and ears of the CCP.
They're spies, effectively, right?
You would normally call that being a spy.
So they'll monitor,
they also monitor the other Chinese students.
They watch them.
They will take photos, they'll take,
and I've seen this firsthand at protests,
human rights events.
They'll take photos of them.
If you're standing with banners, right?
You know, you see a lot of people protesting.
They'll go up to every person,
and they'll take a photo of them.
And they do it, they project it,
because they want, they're sending a message.
They want them to know and see that they're-
They're trying to intimidate them.
They'll go up to them like this,
put the camera right in their face and take a photo.
And they'll go down the line, person by person by person.
They'll do that to take pictures of the audiences.
They'll take pictures of, you know, the speakers.
They'll do it to everybody.
If you dare to become not only an attendee,
where you've dared to listen to this,
but you dare to speak out, they will target your family.
And what'll happen is this.
You might get a call from your mom back in China,
and she says, hey, the Chinese police
came to our house today and says
that you're engaging in, you know, terrorism.
You know, because this is what they call it, right?
They actually call it terrorism in China.
So if you go protest, it's essentially-
Yeah, you're terrorizing the Communist Party.
You know what I mean?
By calling them out for abusing the Chinese people.
They might call it terrorism.
Or you're getting involved in foreign spies,
or you're getting involved in foreign hostile activities.
We need you to come back.
Maybe they'll revoke your visa on the Chinese side.
Maybe you'll lose your ability to stay
in the United States.
Maybe every door in China that used to be open
to you has now closed.
Your social credit score, wrecked.
You might never get a job again.
Your entire hope of a future, decimated.
And that's what they face.
And again, that's because of these eyes and ears
of the CCP at these universities
that are somehow allowed to do it.
We let them do it, publicly.
And I don't know why that's allowed, actually.
And so then what else happens?
Well, you mentioned Falun Gong, of course, right?
So the Chinese Communist Party does horrible things.
There's two stories of China.
One story is the story of the Chinese Communist Party
in its own words.
The other story is the story of the Chinese Communist Party
in the words of the Chinese people.
And it's very different stories.
The real story of the...
So if you go to a lot of universities
and you listen to what's being taught
by visiting Chinese professors,
and you'll be shocked by how many government officials
and military leaders and everybody else think this
because it's what they were taught in school.
They believe in the century of humiliation
as they call it.
So what's the story with this?
In China, right?
The Chinese Communist Party came to power
because the Kuomintang was fighting against the Japanese,
right, the KMT.
They were the real government of China.
They fought the Japanese a lot of the...
During World War II, they were the ones fighting it.
The CCP was like a group of bandits.
They would go in afterwards
and kill whoever lost the battle, basically.
You know what I mean?
Or they'd sit on the sidelines and do nothing.
Or they'd put on the uniforms of the KMT
and go and commit acts of terror, massacring villages
so that people would think the KMT did it.
That was the Communist Party of China.
Bunch of scoundrels and thugs, basically.
After the war, KMT was decimated.
The CCP sat on the sidelines.
And so other than a couple of very minor battles,
most of it was fought by the KMT.
CCP comes out and then beats the KMT, of course,
because they had not really fought the war.
It was on the other side of it.
Then what happens, right?
The Chinese Communist Party goes...
Unfortunately, America tries to create peace there.
Maybe fortunate or unfortunate.
That allows the CCP to regroup.
Civil war in China, KMT's pushed back to Taiwan.
The CCP takes over China.
Up until Jimmy Carter, like the 70s and stuff,
we recognized Taiwan as the government in exile.
They're the real government of China.
The CCP is the unofficial government.
That only changed under Jimmy Carter.
And then what happens, right?
During that time, what does the CCP do?
CCP takes power.
They destroy Chinese culture.
They launch the Cultural Revolution.
If you have flowers in front of your house,
they might kill you for it.
They tell you to kill your teacher.
They tell you to kill your parents or whatever,
kill your landlord.
You have the Little Red Guard,
who are just a terrorist organization,
massacring people, killing people,
just committing horrible acts.
You have famines caused by bad CCP policy,
like killing all the sparrows, which eat the bugs,
and so the bugs eat all the crops.
You have programs of getting all the iron,
and so people melt down their farming equipment
and give it to the CCP,
and they have nothing to toil their fields with.
Crops fail, people starve to death by the millions,
just millions upon millions.
Then you have other programs.
You get into the Cultural Revolution,
where they destroy all of Chinese traditional culture.
They destroy the memory of who they were.
And then you have other things,
leading up to the Tiananmen Square Massacre,
when people think communism is dying in Europe,
maybe it'll die in China too,
and the CCP runs them over with tanks
and massacres them with guns, right?
And so what does the CCP do?
Then they do reform and opening up,
hey, we're different now, right after the massacre.
Then they launched the persecution of Falun Gong, 1999,
just 10 years after that.
And they begin a persecution
of 70 million to 100 million people.
They never changed.
It is, nothing has changed.
They still have slavery.
They take people's organs while they're still alive,
for profit, a for-profit killing of religious believers.
The CCP has never changed its nature.
But what it did, in terms of narratives, was this.
They say, oh, that was the century
that we're recovering from the century of humiliation.
The Chinese people were savage,
and the Communist Party freed them from it, right?
That's the narrative.
So that's what they're teaching.
This is what they teach at school.
They teach this at American universities.
The CCP-
So that history, the 100 years of all this stuff
that you talked about, and a lot of-
Well, they blame it on the West,
because, of course, you had the opium wars.
You had other things.
America wasn't part of that,
but they try to drag America into it now.
Up until the Korean War, they never,
they would acknowledge that America never invaded China.
Up until the Korean War, when, of course,
we went to war with North Korea and the CCP.
But until then, that was not the narrative.
They would say, oh, well, China was humiliated.
We went through all this pain,
and the CCP freed us from it, right?
That's their narrative, when, in reality,
the CCP was the greatest abuser of the Chinese people,
probably in history.
You're talking, just under Mao Zedong,
50 to 100 million people,
different estimates killed by the CCP.
Some say, conservative estimate,
50 million to 70 million people.
Then what happens, right?
Well, Falun Gong persecution.
The CCP launches a persecution against people
who believe in truthfulness, compassion, and tolerance.
People who do nothing other than effectively practicing
what looks like Tai Chi, healthy movements.
If you've ever seen those videos of people
doing the slow movements at the parks,
it's Qi Gong, they would call it.
Tai Chi is a form of Qi Gong.
And what do they do?
Well, too many people practice it.
The CCP regards it as a threat to their power.
They decimate it, as they've done in every other instance.
And then what happens, right?
Well, the CCP, as a means to protect itself,
to protect itself against the Chinese people
trying to bring back their culture,
trying to protect itself against the coming back
of normal morality, or just out of jealousy,
they were never a threat to the country by any means.
They launched one of the largest persecutions
the world has ever seen.
And then what does the rest of the world do?
I mean, crickets, silence.
And I would say a lot of that,
well, you know, and I should give some credit,
you know, American, there have been a lot of public officials
that have really done incredible work stepping forward.
But the problem we have is because of the interconnectedness
of industry, of businesses and otherwise,
or universities, for example, or Hollywood,
working with China, or media,
not wanting to lose their visas in China.
Most people won't touch these things.
A lot of them won't touch these things.
Because if you touch it, if you talk about it,
they kick you out.
And so, you know, it goes back to the question then,
is it responsible for us to let them do that?
Is it better to say, okay, fine, we'll engage with you.
Maybe it'll make you change.
Maybe you'll become better if we let your students come here.
Maybe it'll make you better
if we build our factories in your country.
I think we can look at the experience and say, no,
not only has it not made China more free,
not only has it not helped the Chinese people
be less persecuted by the CCP,
not only has it meant they become less communistic,
not only has none of that happened,
they still carry out massive genocides
and persecution as we speak.
Not only has none of that happened
in terms of them changing,
they have manipulated those open systems
to make us complicit in it.
They've manipulated those open systems
to make us shut our mouths,
to make professors not dare to talk about
human rights in China,
to make it so that Ennis Cantor Freedom and the NBA
writing a human rights message on his shoe
gets punished by the NBA for doing it.
That Hollywood films censor.
It's come here.
We've allowed them to not only be quiet,
make us be quiet,
we've allowed them to let us even become complicit
to an extent where Chinese Communist Party censorship
against the abuse of the Chinese people themselves
is somehow regarded as offensive to China.
How is that?
That if you talk about,
it's like if your neighbor is beating his wife
and you criticize him for beating his wife
and he says, well, you're being mean to my family.
I think you're the one being mean to your family
if you're beating your wife.
You know what I mean?
That's the relationship they have.
And so you can't talk about Chinese human rights issues
without the CCP trying to attack you for it.
By now, you should know
that we are part of the Epoch Times newspaper.
Having this paper associated with us,
we are able to get story ideas and a lot of sources.
Now this week's paper had one amazing story
about what's happening with the Tijuana sewage crisis.
We actually have been covering this crisis on the show.
Now we are hearing that the sewage is actually going airborne
and miles and miles away into the San Diego coast,
up to even La Jolla.
There's also another story that's fascinating in the paper.
It's about equitable grading.
Remember, California Insider,
we covered equitable grading from all perspectives,
from the parents to the teachers,
the people that actually created equity grading program
and superintendents of schools who implemented it.
Now San Francisco just rejected the equity grading method
for the school district and the paper has the story in it.
We have a special deal for you.
You can subscribe for a dollar a week
for the digital edition.
You can also get the print.
You will be surprised by the quality of journalism
that goes into this paper.
Now let's go back to the interview.
So you're a journalist, right?
And do you feel any threat yourself
for doing this kind of work?
To be honest, yes, but it may sound funny,
but I'm kind of used to it.
It doesn't sound odd.
In my work as a journalist,
I mean, basically this is how my career happened.
Back, you know, geez, 20 years ago now,
2000, almost 20 years, 2006, I've been with Epic Times.
I was still a student at the time.
So I was actually going to school, Southwestern College,
you know, in San Diego, right?
Just community school.
And I was in a journalistic program there,
you know, just starting my studies.
Basically, here's what happened.
The professor at my school said,
okay, guys, if you can get articles published
in a local media, I'll give you an A.
And so I was submitting articles
to like all kinds of like local Chinese newspaper,
local, not Chinese, local, you know, San Diego newspapers.
I was very much into human rights at the time.
So I sent an article to Epic Times, 2006.
They published it.
I said, fantastic.
I actually actually got in the San Diego Reader too,
total different story.
I was just doing like local events,
just small things back then, just fun, you know,
light stories.
I mean, I was a student, right?
So I wasn't doing anything impactful.
Epic Times liked my work though.
And so, you know, they asked me,
hey, do you want to write again?
I said, yeah, I want to write again.
So I started writing for them more.
That went on until about 2008
and they offered me a summer internship.
I mentioned earlier, 2008 was also leading up
to the Beijing Olympics, the bloody Olympics.
The Chinese Communist Party, all of its agents,
again, the Chinese Student Scholars Associations,
the United Front, the Tongs, they were all out in force.
They were again, you know, San Francisco, I believe LA,
but they were also really active in New York.
In New York City, you had huge groups of these people
coming out, I mean, hundreds of them.
And they were beating people up.
They were attacking people.
They were spitting on people.
They were threatening to kill people.
I had a Taiwanese woman tell me,
they told her they could make her disappear.
Her son is in the U.S. Army.
They told her they could make her disappear.
And so, you know, I got assigned to go cover that.
And what happened was this,
you had Chinese human rights activists.
It was mostly democracy activists,
house Christians and Falun Gong practitioners
who were being attacked by these CCP agents.
And I mean, I'm out there and, you know,
all the protesters are like,
those people attacking us are Chinese spies.
And, you know, at that time, I thought spies,
you know, I knew spies from the movies.
I was thinking refined, you know,
drinking like Cognac and stuff like that and playing poker.
I didn't think like-
Like James Bonham.
I was thinking like, you know,
yeah, I was thinking refined people.
These were like just really trashy looking people.
They looked like a bunch of gang members.
They looked like thugs.
And so I was like, those aren't spies.
They're like, no, they're spies.
This is what the Chinese Communist Party does.
They send these people.
And I was like, okay,
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.
But I mean, I didn't have any concept
of this stuff at the time.
I started noticing patterns.
When these groups were coming out,
they'd have banners, you know, condemning,
you know, condemning anybody criticizing
the CCP for human rights abuses.
And on the banners would be names
like the Fookian American Association
or the Shandong Association
or the Peking Association, you know, things like that.
On their bullhorns would be the names
of these Chinese associations.
And I was like, what are these?
I start researching them and I find out
these organizations all have ties to the Chinese consulates
that they're meeting with like, you know,
heads of the Chinese Communist Party
that when the CCP leaders come and visit,
they have speeches and events
with these Chinese organizations.
I'm like, wow, what are these?
I start to find out these are what do you call tongs,
T-O-N-G-S.
Then I start to find out that underneath
some of these tongs are the Chinese mafia.
And so I was like, oh, well, that explains
why they look like a bunch of gang members.
It's because they are a bunch of gang members.
Under the Fookian American Association,
under that they had the Fook Ching gang.
They're one of the largest transnational
organized crime groups in the world.
They're human traffickers, drug traffickers,
sex traffickers, you name it.
They ran what was called the Golden Venture.
It was a huge, one of the largest
human trafficking incidents
and the most deadly ones ever recorded in America.
Huge Chinese ship ran aground off the coast of New York,
crashed, people drowned.
It was cold, freezing waters.
A lot of people died.
That was the Fookian, that was the Fook Ching gang,
which operates under the Fookian American Association.
They were one of the largest groups involved.
They're also one of the closest groups
in New York to the CCP.
And then I found out direct involvement
from the Chinese consulate general at the time,
Peng Keyu, meeting with them.
And so as I started exposing this stuff,
they started to know about me.
And I remember walking around
and I'd hear them whisper stuff, right?
Like it started getting a little weird.
There were several times when,
one time, for example, I was covering a court case
where an individual who had attacked,
another Chinese individual,
you know, attacked a human rights advocate, right?
I was standing trial, you know, got charged for it.
And they had CCP agents in there.
One of them turned around in their seats
and started whispering, I will kill you to me.
Another time I was walking down the street,
you know, covering this stuff, I got surrounded.
It was probably around six people,
six or so people surrounded me
and started threatening to kill me.
I had a contact tell me,
because I was able to get some people to come forward.
I mean, it was really hard,
really hard to get people to come forward.
I had some people have meetings with me.
One incident, I had a person say,
okay, meet me on the corner of this street,
you know, at like, you know, nighttime.
A car will flash its lights twice.
Get in the car, we'll drive somewhere
and we'll, I'll tell you everything.
And I mean, it was that kind of reporting.
I had one of my contacts that I managed to get,
he told me the CCP, because I published an article,
he didn't care.
He said that one of these guys told him
they hired a hitman to chop off one of his hands.
And he said that morning he woke up
and the tires of his car were all slashed.
And so this-
How did you keep going?
Well, you know, I'll be honest,
I did a bit of soul searching.
And so I had to go through a moment where
I had to think, is it worth dying for?
Because at that time, when I was exposing these things,
there was not a lot of public reporting on it.
You know, these days you can see reporting
on the secret Chinese police stations.
That's what I was exposing in 2008.
And I didn't know it yet.
In Chinese spy operations,
I didn't know what I was exposing.
I didn't even realize how big it was at the time.
But all I knew was I was onto something big.
There was almost no reporting on it.
There were almost no government reports on it.
And I had a lot of people threatening to kill me.
And I remember I kind of went into the cave, so to speak.
You know, I was in my house
and I was really thinking, I was like,
man, am I willing to die for this?
For something that I was writing about.
And a lot of people didn't even believe me at the time
because no one had ever heard about a lot of this stuff.
It's better known these days, but at that time it was not.
And I said, am I willing to die for this?
And I had to really think about it.
But I decided, yeah, I would be willing to die for this.
Absolutely.
And I realized the reason was a couple of points.
One, if I folded and gave up,
I would be sending a message to them
that anybody who comes after me,
you can threaten them like you threatened me
and they'll fold, that this is a working solution.
And so I'd be setting up the next person to fail.
And I was not willing to do that.
I would be willing to die just for the sake of that,
nothing else, if that was the case.
The other side was, I realized that if I don't cover it,
nobody else was.
There was nothing really exposing this stuff at that time.
And I was onto something, you know?
And I mean, lo and behold,
we've seen since then the effect of the work.
If I just gave up, then people would not know
about what I believed at the time,
and I think has now been shown to be
one of the greatest national security threats
to the United States.
One of the greatest threats our country faces
would have gone unreported.
And I decided, yeah, I'm willing to die for this.
And if they kill me, it'll make it better known.
If they kill me, it'll make headlines everywhere
and people will know what happened.
And so I decided, yeah, I'm not gonna stop, no matter what.
Well, it's great that you continued.
Joshua Philip, investigative reporter from Epoch Times.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Hey, always a pleasure.
Thank you, C-Mac.
Let us know what you think of the Chinese Communist Party's
influence in universities and beyond.
You can always email me at siamakacaliforniansider.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami, this is California Insider,
and we'll see you next time.
