The annals of World War II aviation history are filled with aircraft that soared to legendary status: we all know the P-51 Mustang, Messerschmitt 109, Supermarine Spitfire, F6F Hellcat, IL-2 Sturmovik - the list goes on and on. But for every outstanding warbird - there were one or two duds, some that failed at the testing stage and others that unfortunately made it to frontline units. Today we’ll look at a handful - the SB2C Helldiver, the American dive-bomber that often made its pilots and designers question their life choices, the Messerschmitt Me-210, the German heavy fighter that didn’t like to fly in a straight line and the Breda Ba.88, the Italian thoroughbred that performed in combat more like it was inbred.
The annals of WWII aviation are filled with aircraft that soared to legendary status.
We all know the P-51 Mustang, the Messerschmitt 109, the Supermarine Spitfire, the Hellcat,
the Shturmovik, the list goes on and on.
But for every outstanding warbird, there were one or two duds along the way, some that failed
at the testing stage and others that, unfortunately, made it to frontline units where they could
show off their deficiencies on an operational scale.
Today we'll look at a handful, the American dive bomber that often made its pilots and
designers question their life choices, the German heavy fighter that didn't like to
fly in a straight line, and the Italian thoroughbred that performed in combat more like it was
inbred.
Ladies and gentlemen, I'm your friend Mike Brady from Airliner Designs and today we'll
be taking a nose dive into three poorly designed aircraft from WWII.
1943.
A young pilot can see the enemy carrier up ahead.
He rolls his big plane into a lazy dive and lines up on target.
But then the thing begins to shake so much he can't even see what he's aiming for.
It sounds absurd but this was the reality for many pilots of the Curtiss SB2C, officially
nicknamed the Helldiver but fondly remembered by pilots as the son of a b**** second class.
Yeah, they loved it.
Designed to be faster, stronger and deadlier than what had come before it, the Helldiver
looked promising on paper but would ultimately make its pilots pray for an early retirement.
It was developed as a replacement for the venerable SBD Dauntless, which had been developed
from the archaic Northrop BT-1 and 2 from back in the mid-30s.
The SBD performed admirably though, especially at midway, but with a relatively small payload
and sluggish performance it was clear the old Dauntless needed a successor.
What followed was a design and manufacturing nightmare that would see an aircraft rushed
through production with even its own designers keenly aware of its deficiencies and desperately
trying to work them out.
A 1938 specification had called for an aircraft with a crew of two, boasting a more powerful
Wright R2600-20 twin-cyclone engine, a top speed exceeding 290 mph, a large bombay capable
of carrying 1,000 pounds of ordnance and to be shut with hydraulic doors, folding wings
for easier carrier storage, something the old Dauntless bafflingly didn't have, and
room enough for a variety of heavy equipment like cameras and an impressively sized radio.
As if that weren't already enough, the aircraft's frame had to be heavily reinforced for that
dive bombing, but also light enough to be able to operate from aircraft carriers with
all the requisite arrester and catapult hooks.
If that sounds like it's asking a lot, you'd be right, it is.
But both Brewster and Curtis Wright submitted designs which, curiously, look a lot like
each other.
Curtis's first prototype, the XSB-2C-1, was in production when, in November 1940,
the Navy placed an order for 200 aircraft even before the thing had flown.
This kind of thing wasn't unusual at all in the world of government military procurement
at the time, but it would prove to be a catastrophic decision, because when the XSB-2C-1 did finally
take to the skies, it had qualities that could only be described as worrying.
This new giant aviation plant is completing its first warplane.
At Columbus, Ohio, the Curtis Wright factory is the nation's largest for the building
of dive bombers for the Navy.
But there was no backing down now.
The huge Navy order had resulted in a drive to hire 14,000 workers and build an entire
entirely new production plant just for this plane.
From the outset, the Helldiver was beset by problems.
The prototype first took flight December 18, 1940, and flights revealed major structural
instability issues.
The aircraft's tail vibrated violently, stability was terrible, and the performance
was just sluggish.
All that on top of the usual teething troubles with new aircraft, like electrical failures
and engine problems.
In February 1941, the thing crashed when its engine failed on approach.
This would normally give designers pause for thought, but with production starting very,
very soon, Curtis's engineers had to quickly rebuild their plane and get it back into testing
as soon as possible.
They took the opportunity to rework the design, lengthening the fuselage, and enlargening
the tail to combat those severe instability issues.
They had just 10 months to iron out all the kinks and begin deliveries of finished production
models.
That's just not a lot of time, so you can only imagine Curtis's dismay when, in December,
when they should have been delivering production aircraft, the rebuilt prototype disintegrated
mid-flight during a high-speed dive, forcing test pilot B.T.
Hulse to bail out to safety.
Now that should have been ringing some alarm bells, except that the US Army ordered 900
more of the things.
The first production, SB2C1, rolled off the production line six months late in June 1942.
This was around the same time the Grumman TBF Avenger went into service, even though
design on that had started two years later than on the Helldiver.
Despite the issues, war production just couldn't wait, and with the Japanese tearing through
the Pacific, the Navy was desperate for bombers.
Flaws be damned.
Navy pilots weren't thrilled.
Professor of Aeronautical Engineering Otto C. Koppen exclaimed,
If they build more than one of these things, they're crazy.
One thing became immediately apparent.
The Helldiver was a pig to fly, and many pilots missed the old SBD Dauntless, which in some
cases actually performed better.
So what had gone wrong?
The Helldiver's fuselage was fragile.
So fragile that repeated structural failures occurred during the rigours of carrier operations.
And in dives on target, pilots had to be mindful not to overstress the airframe, lest they
find themselves unintentionally testing the limits of free-fall physics.
Some of those early carrier pilots never quite knew if a dive was going to end with a bomb
drop or an unscheduled swim in the Pacific.
The SB2C had been crammed full of impressive features like that big radio, the hydraulic
bomb bay doors, and many more, but it meant its empty weight ballooned out from around
7,100 pounds on the prototype to 10,000 on the production model.
The original engine was kept, meaning it had to strain against the mass of a lot more airplane.
Now, big, ponderous, sluggish, heavy aircraft do not usually good carrier planes make.
Inevitably, the landing gear had a mind of its own.
Pilots and ground crews dreaded it, and it became notorious for failing at the worst
possible moment.
In an aircraft designed for carrier landings, this was not ideal.
Fleet Air Arm pilot Eric Winkle-Brown recalled that Yorktown's skipper, then-Captain Joseph
Clark, watched in horror as the ship's Helldivers came in for landing and either broke up, missed
arrestor hooks, or had their gear collapse.
According to Brown, Clark even petitioned the Navy to cancel the Helldiver altogether.
In addition to this, for an aircraft designed to dive-bomb enemy targets under heavy AA
fire before scooting nimbly away, the SB2C handled like a drunken rhinoceros.
It was slow to respond to control inputs, making it difficult to manoeuvre in combat,
and its massive nose gave pilots poor visibility when lining up on the carrier.
In action, pilots attempting to pull out of a steep dive had to fight the aircraft every
step of the way.
On top of all of that, the cockpit configuration was a hydraulic horror show.
Nearly every function, from the gear and flaps to the bombay doors and wing folding, naturally
relied on hydraulics.
The interior of the aircraft resembled, according to Ticonderoga pilot George Walsh, a jungle
of wires and hydraulic tubes.
This wasn't unique to the Helldiver at all, but coupled with poor workmanship from Curtis,
it meant that frequent leaks, failures, and unexpected malfunctions could naturally have
dire consequences.
So why did the Navy decide to stick with it, rather than give it a one-way flight to the
scrapyard?
Well, the frantic Pacific War effort meant that carrier-based dive-bombers were needed
en masse, and replacing the Helldiver mid-war would have caused bad delays, and shut down
production lines staffed by thousands.
Curtis Wright was working pell-mell on churning them out, and cancelling the program just
wasn't logistically feasible.
Inevitably it would have also led to a political scandal.
In fact a committee was set up to figure out just what the heck was going on with all those
delayed and poor designs, and they were scathing of the Helldiver.
Curtis was just trying to keep up with the insane demands of the Navy.
In fact President Guy Vaughan would later say it was, quote, one of the biggest of the
wartime crosses we had to bear.
Later versions, like the SB2C3 and C4, saw incremental upgrades including more powerful
engines, a reinforced fuselage, and those improved dive brakes, but regardless the Helldiver
remained unpopular among pilots and crew.
Even the British Royal Navy rejected the aircraft in favour of other models.
Legendary pilot Winkle Brown weighed in on it when he recalled that the Fleet Air Arms
Squadron Number 1820 had formed up on Helldivers, but the aircraft was shipped back to the UK
and the squadron was disbanded.
We were not tardy, he said in discovering the reason.
The handling characteristics of the beast were such that it would never have been allowed
near a British carrier deck.
In tests 1820's squadron lost crews and aircraft, and three of the Helldivers failed to pull
out of their dives.
Brown concluded that it was the worst aircraft type he'd ever flown in turbulence, and that
the control surfaces made aiming the thing very difficult.
From the summer of 1942 on, the Curtiss team desperately set about trying to rectify the
issues.
The end result was an airplane with an outrageously sized tail to help with its horizontal control
problems and a heavily reinforced airframe.
It took over 600 production aircraft and nearly 900 major design changes to create a version
of the Helldiver that could perform.
All that shaking during dives, which made it impossible for some pilots to even sight
their target below, was a result of the dive brakes, which were really just the aircraft's
flaps which could be split up and down.
The huge tail assembly was sitting so closely behind the wing that it was buffeted heavily
from the disturbed airflow.
In the end the flaps were perforated with holes to try and help reduce the effect.
Look, okay, it wasn't all bad news.
Many pilots called it the beast, but quite a few pilots eventually came to like it and
became quite proficient with it.
By the war's end, Helldivers had helped sink mighty Japanese warships like the battleships
Musashi and Yamato, but its legacy was forever tarnished thanks to all the engine and landing
gear failures, the in-flight breakups and the generally temperamental performance.
The aircraft's design was eventually fixed with the C3, 4 and 5 models, but its reputation
is unfortunate because ultimately, and somewhat incredibly, it flew over 18,000 combat sorties
and it's thought to have sunk more than 300 Japanese ships.
It's all very well and good to condemn the Helldiver today, but ask the crew of the Japanese
warships Shimakaze, Wakatsuki, Asashimo and many, many others and they'd probably give
you a very different opinion on the Helldiver's capabilities.
In the post-war era, the Helldiver was phased out and Curtis Wright's reputation had suffered
irreparable damage.
Not only thanks to the Helldiver saga, but for also supplying defective engines from
their Ohio plant for two years.
Lagging badly behind the competition in the fierce world of technological developments,
Curtis Wright shut down its entire aircraft design division in 1948 and even though they're
actually still around today, they only make parts.
The Helldiver is a curious plane because even in the face of anecdotes from pilots, ranging
from humorous quips about its brick-like handling to grim tales of fatal carrier landings, 7,140
were built.
That's over a thousand more than the Junkers 87 Stuka for goodness sake.
So that's the complicated legacy of Curtis' beast.
It wasn't the worst aircraft of World War II, but it certainly wasn't a pilot favourite.
This gorgeous footage was sent to us by the good folks over at the commemorative Air Force.
They still fly an SB2C-5, one of the later variants with the bugs worked out of it.
She's a favourite at air shows and she's painted up to look like a machine from the
USS Franklin.
Ultimately, the Helldiver did prove itself in combat, but that's probably more of a
testament to the grit and determination of the brave carrier pilots who did their best
with what they had at hand.
Now this next one kind of hurts because it's just so damn pretty.
The Messerschmitt Me 210 was developed by the legendary company which didn't have a
reputation for failure, but this offering from the German design team would prove to
be a stinker, with such poor performance it was pulled from units and completely redesigned.
In 1937, even before the legendary Bf 110 had actually fully spread its wings, Messerschmitt's
design team embarked on creating its successor.
The goal was to produce a more advanced, versatile aircraft capable of excelling in roles like
heavy fighter, reconnaissance and light bombing duties.
See in those days, just before the war's outbreak, the Luftwaffe and many air forces
around the world had grand ideas for what future aerial combat might look like and what
kinds of aircraft would dominate the skies.
In the first war, heavy fighters with tail gunners like the Bristol F2B had proved themselves
to be a worthy adversary, so a modern equivalent made total sense.
The Bf 110 Zerstörer or Destroyer was conceived in 1935 to be a powerful fighter with a one-hit
punch, packing cannons and machine guns into the nose that didn't need to converge like
guns mounted on wings do.
It was meant to serve as a bomber destroyer or a long-range harasser, and when the war
began, lessons were quickly learned though.
The 110 did pretty well over Poland, Norway and the Low Countries, but then came France
and the Battle of Britain.
The 110 was trying to fulfil a close escort role for German bombers, which was something
it really wasn't designed for, and it proved tragically bad at it when faced with swarms
of nimble, single-seat British fighters.
In the French campaign, 60 Bf 110s were shot down in just over three weeks.
In August 1940, at the height of the Battle of Britain, 30 were shot down in a single
day.
The Zerstörergruppen, or units operating the 110, began the battle with 237 aircraft
and by September 1940, they had just over 30 left.
But Messerschmitt and the German Air Ministry, the RLM, weren't entirely convinced that
the Zerstörer concept wasn't worth pursuing.
In 1938, the RLM had issued a specification for a replacement for the 110, capable of
a whole lot of things – air-to-air combat, ground-attack dive-bombing and fast reconnaissance.
Arado entered its AR-240 design, but ultimately the contract went to Messerschmitt.
Who else, after all, would be better suited to replace the Bf 110?
Just like the Helldiver, a thousand were ordered even before the first prototype had flown.
Messerschmitt's engineers envisaged a platform that would improve on the 110 and bring an
edge to the war in the air.
But what came out of the production lines resembled less a high-performance warbird
and more a high-maintenance, unpredictable nightmare of a machine.
The 210 featured a sleeker fuselage than the 110, redesigned tapered wings for higher speeds
and innovations like a bombay within the nose to reduce drag.
On paper, it promised impressive performance, aiming for speeds in excess of 380 mph even
with its twin Daimler-Benz DV601 engines that had been used on the 110 before it.
There were some genuinely clever additions too.
The 210 mounted twin defensive guns in little electrically-controlled barbettes either side
of the fuselage that couldn't shoot off the 210's tail, and a pair of airbrakes
were mounted to the wings to assist with diving.
That, and the plane just looked spectacular.
It borrowed a lot from the 110, but the RLM must have been thrilled by this modern-looking
aerodynamic aircraft that offered excellent pilot visibility thanks to its short nose.
The ME 210's first flight on September 5, 1939, quickly dispelled any illusions of grandeur.
Dr. Hermann Wuster, test pilot, hated it.
He said performance was totally unacceptable.
There were severe stability issues, with the aircraft exhibiting unpredictable yawing and
a tendency to snake through the air even during level flight.
Its pitch handling was verging on dangerous.
Messerschmitt's designers must have been shocked.
They rushed back to the drawing board and redesigned the prototype's tail, fitting
a single big fin to fix the yaw, but it didn't do much to help.
The situation escalated from concerning to dangerous when the second prototype, the 210
V2, was lost in September 1940.
The aircraft entered an uncontrolled spin, forcing the pilot to bail out.
Chief test pilot Fritz Vendel later remarked that the 210 possessed
Harsh.
But also, just like the Helldiver, the ME 210 was issued to front-line units.
Germany was at war, and production was well underway, with ME 210 A-0s and A-1s just rolling
off the production lines in 1941.
For those brave and perhaps unsuspecting souls who piloted the 210, the experience was like
trying to ride a mechanical bull with wings.
The aircraft's tendency to enter sudden stalls and spins became legendary and made
every flight a test of nerves and skill.
The Messerschmitt 210's handling quirks were so notorious that pilots began to question
its very existence.
One Luftwaffe man mused that
For some units training on the 210, the casualty rate over Germany was as bad as it had been
in combat on the Russian front.
Despite the series of unfortunate events, production of the ME 210 pressed on, and took
an astounding 16 prototypes and 94 pre-production models to address the worst of the flaws – a
stark contrast to the 5 prototypes and 28 pre-production units required for the brilliant
Focke-Wulf Fw 190.
The aircraft's deficiencies were so pronounced that production lines reverted to manufacturing
the very Bf 110s that the Messerschmitt 210 was meant to replace.
And ultimately, the Bf 110 would remain in service and use until the end of the war.
In fact, Willy Messerschmitt's own reputation suffered significant damage.
He resigned as head of his own company and became the technical director.
Hermann Göring, head of the German Luftwaffe, supposedly once quipped that his own tombstone
should read
Good one, Hermann.
The 210's issues were many, but the worst of the behaviour stemmed from its relatively
compact size, that the fuselage was around a metre too short.
It suffered from severe directional instability and a high tendency for sideslip.
Its wing design and tail configuration, intended to improve that high-speed performance, inadvertently
created aerodynamic quirks that resulted in uncontrollable yaw and roll at moments you
just didn't want those things.
Messerschmitt's engineers had tried to cram all those advanced features into the ME 210
at once, like those airbrakes, the bombay doors, the electric gun turrets.
They were all quite clever, but the airframe itself was proving to be the aircraft's undoing,
never mind how advanced the systems were that had been packed into it.
In a fascinating bit of wartime trivia, the Japanese had actually shown great interest
in the ME 210, and one was even purchased and delivered via U-Boat in 1943.
The Japanese Kawasaki company's engineers reviewed the thing, and they too found it
to be unmanoeuvrable and likely to enter an unrecoverable spin.
Then the landing gear was damaged, so with no spare parts the 210 was dismantled for
scrapping, but what parts the Japanese did like were made use of in the development of
the Rikugun Ki-93 and the Tachikawa Ki-74.
You can only hope the Japanese kept their receipt and got a refund.
Interestingly the 210 found a fan in the Hungarian Air Force.
In fact more than 260 of the type were licensed built in Hungary, the CA-1, and they saw service
on the Eastern Front.
This plane filtered the uprated DB-605 engine, lengthened the fuselage, and changed the taper
of the wings.
To that they installed heavier firepower, including 40mm Bofors automatic cannons, which
was a very scary weapon indeed.
It found some success with the Hungarians, who generally liked it, but still considered
it a handful to fly.
But the Luftwaffe was finished with the ME 210 and wanted Messerschmitt to fix their
mess.
In an effort to salvage the project and maybe save some face, Messerschmitt's engineers
went back to the drawing board.
In March 1942, Messerschmitt 210s altered with longer and deeper fuselages and slatted
wings among other things to reach frontline units, and they seemed to perform alright.
They saw service in the Med, bombing with Kampfgeschwader units and doing heavy fighter
stuff with Zerstörergeschwader units.
Messerschmitt was heartened by this and they decided to press on with making the changes.
New versions with uprated DB-603 engines and modified, longer fuselages performed quite
well.
Crucially, the wing lost its taper and became straighter.
In autumn 1942, the Messerschmitt 210's improved version was tested and then approved
for production just a few months later.
In a clever bit of spin-doctoring, this brand new aircraft was referred to as the Messerschmitt
ME 410.
Ultimately, the design turned out to be pretty good.
The 410 was used for a bewildering array of roles, from the original heavy fighter job
to the ubiquitous Schnellbomber role that the Luftwaffe was so obsessed with.
There were the U-1, A-3 and B-3 recon variants, the U-4 armed with a single impressive 50mm
cannon, and the menacing B-2-U-4 which packed a 50mm gun and two MK108 30mm for bomber hunting.
Then there was a spread of high-altitude versions, with special turbo-supercharged variants of
the Daimler-Benz DB-603 engine and much longer wings.
Hell, just for the fun of it, there was even a torpedo bomber version.
So the Luftwaffe finally got its nice new Swiss Army knife of a heavy fighter just in
time for Germany to begin being bombed day and night by the USAAF and the RAF.
Ironically, it was the old Bf 110 that would emerge as the hero of Germany's night fighter
units with aces like Heinz-Wolfgang Schnaufer racking up impressive victory tallies, but
the 410 proved itself, in the right conditions, to be a very dangerous opponent to US bomber
crews during the day, with some mounting the Werfergranate 21 mortars that could swat B-17s
and B-24s clear out of the sky.
The Messerschmitt 410 was a success, it's just hard to believe its origins came from
such an inglorious failure.
Messerschmitt's designers were clearly on the right track with the 210, it's just surprising
to see them stumble so badly.
Like Curtiss, they had a track record of producing sound, successful designs.
You can only imagine that maybe political interference and the harsh realities of wartime
production timelines might have got a bit in the way.
The Me 410 is one of my favourite fighters of the war, I mean, just look at it, it's
spectacular, but you definitely wouldn't have caught me in the cockpit of a 210 any
time soon.
And finally, we turn to Italy's Regia Aeronautica for yet again another beautiful looking airplane
whose sleek airframe was actually hiding some pretty worrying behavioural quirks.
Breda, Italian manufacturer, established by Ernesto Breda way back in 1886, had a long
and impressive history of making all kinds of things, like rolling stock, locomotives,
machine guns, trams, you name it.
But they also began to manufacture aircraft, and had a crack at designing them themselves.
In the lead up to the second world war, probably their most successful design had been the
BA-65, a monoplane ground attack aircraft that was… okay, I guess?
They went on to be decimated by the RAF over North Africa, but we'll come back to that
in a minute.
But before the war had even begun, Italy's air force was keen to replace sluggish old
kites like the 65, so Breda got to work.
They had a crack with the BA-75, which looked suspiciously similar to the plane that had
gone before it, but presumably performance was quite poor because only one prototype
was ever built.
Now look, I love Breda's prototypes, they kind of look like a mishmash of so many others
that have almost been AI generated, like the BA-201, which looks like the result of smushing
together a Junkers 87 Stuka, a BF-109, and a Hawker Hurricane.
Or the BA-46, just a long, thin, stretched Junkers 52.
They even made their own Constellation.
They're all wacky and goofy and kind of fun, but the design submitted in 1936 to the Regia
Aeronautica was none of those things.
It looked mean.
Enter the BA-88, a genuinely cool looking plane that totally broke the mould on Breda's
design ethos.
The Air Force's specification had called for a fast, heavy fighter slash ground attack
aircraft, not dissimilar to the BF-110 I suppose.
The first prototype built by Breda was incredibly slick and genuinely quite impressive.
It featured a thin, tapered fuselage flanked by two enormous radial engines and a small
single tail behind.
When the prototype first took to the sky, it cracked a top speed in excess of 300mph
and went on to break a string of world speed over distance records.
Part of the secret to its success was the focus on streamlining.
The undercarriage could fold away during flight, sure, but so could the tailwheel.
That was pretty clever.
Testing and refining resulted in a prototype that filled with a pair of 1000hp Piaggio
P-11 engines, a licensed version of a French engine which was itself a licensed version
of the British Bristol Jupiter from 1918, and a twin fin tail, presumably to improve
the field of fire for that defensive tail gun.
But then something weird happened.
Breda's brilliant invention, the darling of Mussolini's propaganda machine, began
to misbehave.
It turns out the plane had been trimmed and configured specifically for speed trials and
test runs, not for combat and actual loading.
The BA-88 Lynx proved surprisingly sluggish in flight.
It was a handful to control, something that got exponentially worse the more equipment
was added, like radios and weapons.
It turns out the specification issued by the Regia Aeronautica had called for some bizarre
features like, say, a strength sufficient to sustain 12 Gs.
Trained pilots with anti-G suits and the correct technique can survive around 9 or 10 Gs in
short bursts.
Astronauts in rockets at liftoff are subjected to about 3 Gs sustained.
What the Italian Air Force expected the BA-88 to be doing at 12 Gs is beyond me, especially
when you consider that although the plane might be able to survive those 12 Gs, the
poor pilot and gunner inside wouldn't exactly be so fortunate.
To answer this call for bewildering G tolerance, Breda had built the Lynx with a main structure
comprised of steel tubes welded together like a truss, kind of like you might expect to
see in an older fighter from the First World War, but instead of having a fuselage covered
in canvas like those older fighters, the BA-88 had an all-metal stressed skin.
The result was a heavily over-engineered structure that added a ton of weight at a time when
most aircraft manufacturers were relying on monocoque structures instead, where it's
the skin itself that does much of the structural heavy lifting.
But by 1940, as some of the Lynx's design deficiencies were finally letting themselves
be known, Italy found itself at war with France, and the BA-88 was heading into combat.
Pilots could at last get their hands on the aircraft that had won speed records for Italy.
It must have actually been really exciting.
Only when they throttled up and tried to lift off for the first time, they must have been
shocked by how sluggish the thing was, how reluctant to climb.
Even with a modest combat load, the BA-88 was lethargic, but heavily laden with bombs,
the thing wouldn't even climb at all.
Even worse still, Italy's air force was destined to fight North Africa, where the
arduous conditions of desert fighting would require the already struggling Piaggio engines
to be stifled with sand filters.
They ran extremely hot and inefficiently, but still, the Lynx struggled on.
Early on, BA-88 pilots encountered little resistance, but even so, the deficiencies
were so bad, their planes still had to be pulled from service within just 5 months.
There are cases where BA-88s couldn't even lift off from the tarmac.
Speeds fell far below those original 300mph, more like 155, where they would obviously
be sitting ducks for the likes of the RAF Spitfires, Hurricanes and P-40s if they could
even get off the ground.
One attack on Sidi El Barani had to be called off because the BA-88's task with the mission
couldn't gain enough altitude or even maintain an adequate formation.
So it was that the once promising Lynx was pulled dramatically from service.
The remaining airframes actually did find some use, as target decoys for patrolling
British aircraft.
In fact, a shipment of brand new BA-88s that arrived from Italy went straight to the scrap
heap.
Amazingly, Breda didn't give up on their beloved Lynx.
Through 1941 and 1942, they redesigned and tested variants with lighter loads, different
engines, longer wingspans, you name it.
But the end result was still a poor, sluggish, mopey pig of a plane that just wouldn't perform.
A newly improved model, the BA-88M, was delivered to an air force unit for testing…
Exactly one day before Italy surrendered.
Go figure.
Incredibly, the failure of the BA-88 left Italy with nothing but the tragically outdated
biplane Fiat CR-32 and the good old Breda BA-65, which the Lynx was supposed to have
replaced.
They were, of course, decimated by the RAF.
So what about all those record-setting flights the BA-88 had set back before the war?
Well, it is possible it had done the job in its pre-military configuration.
In fact, the FAI, the World Air Sports Federation, ratified the record for speed over a kilometre
in 1937.
But you do have to wonder if somehow the fascist government was able to simply make up the
figures to build hype for their new plane, and then had to suffer the consequences when
the truth of the matter revealed itself, with the pathetic Lynx struggling to even lift
off the ground.
Breda had begun their manufacturing careers with trains.
It just seems fitting that the Lynx seemed to handle like one in the air.
Can you tell I was proud of that joke?
So there you have it!
Three poorly thought out aircraft from a conflict that brought us so, so, so many similar stories.
From the sadly underpowered Blackburn Botha, to the spontaneously combusting Heinkel HE-177.
Join us next time here on Airliner Designs when we explore more of World War 2's worst
aircraft design failures.