The HMS St. Lawrence was unlike any other warship ever built. Constructed during the War of 1812, she remains the first—and only—first-rate ship of the line to sail exclusively on freshwater.
In this episode of Guide 264, we explore the remarkable story of this forgotten giant: why the Royal Navy built such a massive vessel on Lake Ontario, how she helped secure British naval dominance, and why she never fired a shot in battle.
Discover the history, design, and strategic importance of one of the most extraordinary ships ever commissioned by the Royal Navy.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores the unusual history of HMS St Lawrence, the only freshwater first-rate ship of the line ever built. Constructed by the British during the War of 1812 to secure dominance over Lake Ontario, the vessel represented an extreme escalation in naval arms racing, ultimately serving as a strategic deterrent rather than a combatant before being decommissioned after the war.
Generally speaking, a first-rate ship of the line was a huge investment,
something that only the richest or the most desperate of nations could afford to build
at the height of the age of sail. Such was their cost that not only would they often
spend much of their peacetime career in ordinary, a period term for being in reserve,
but they would also be kept around for decades without replacement assuming they survived,
and would be deployed to areas that they could do the most good on a grand strategic scale
which usually meant you had to base them in ports from which they could sail around the world
to wherever they happened to be needed the most in that particular year.
Thus, building a first-rate on a lake, more particularly one where the ship would be
confined to that lake, was madness, unless of course you happened to either be absolutely
desperate or trying to prove a point. Enter the War of 1812. Whilst the high seas were
host to the US Navy's famous six frigates and other ancillary vessels and the Royal Navy ships
sent to try and counter them, the great lakes to the north of the USA and the south of Canada
also saw a series of vicious battles erupt over the three years that were covered by that
particular war. The heart of the action was Lake Ontario, where the British and American forces
had started out with a handful of customs vessels, a couple small sloops and other such craft
that would only just about have been rated as harbour and messenger ships out in a seaborne
environment and were a long, long way off from even being considered a small sixth rate.
But as the war progressed, both sides began building ever larger ships to try and gain
the upper hand. First, larger sloops and brigs, then small frigates, then larger fifth rate frigates
and then even fourth rates, where the line between a large frigate and a small ship of the line
becomes a bit blurred. But early in 1814, the British decided to make a leap that they hoped
would skip the next obvious stage of escalation to third rate ships of the line and instead laid
down HMS St Lawrence. This would be the world's first and, as it turned out, only freshwater
first rate. Whilst HMS Victory might have been the most famous first rate of the period,
she was, by 1814, over half a century old. Other navies had built larger ships of the line,
Victory herself had been temporarily decommissioned and was being used at this point as a prison ship
and the Royal Navy was building the new, larger and more heavily armed Caledonia class 120 gun
ships of the line. The new ship was therefore sort of a halfway house between the older and
newer designs, with a few changes also made to allow for her unique situation.
She'd be a few hundred tons heavier and about 10 foot longer than Victory,
but also about 10 foot shorter and a little bit lighter than a Caledonia.
In keeping with Royal Navy tactical thinking of the period, she would carry the traditional
first rate armament of largely 32lb cannon on her lower gun deck, 28 in total, plus four 24lb
long guns and four 32lb carrenades, then 36 24lbs on her middle gun deck and then 32 32lbs plus a
pair of 68lb carrenades on her upper gun deck, as opposed to the older ships of the line which
often carried 18lb or longer guns on this level. This gave her a total battery of 112 guns.
However, because she could only sail Lake Ontario, she did not need the large amount of supplies,
stores or even accommodation for a voyage lasting months. Thus, she needed less hold space
and unlike ocean-going ships of the line, there was no foc'sle deck, quarter deck or poop deck.
If you look at a ship like Victory, you can see all three gun decks are well within the hull,
with an upper deck running the full length of the ship above this and the various sub-length decks
above that, whereas on the St Lawrence, the upper gun deck was also the main deck, open to the
elements in normal circumstances, with nothing but the masts and yards positioned any higher.
At a distance, especially with the banded Royal Navy paint job of the time,
this could give the impression of a slightly odd looking third rate,
or possibly even a larger fourth rate frigate. Needless to say, her arrival on the scene in
September 1814 gave the British undisputed control over Lake Ontario. The US Navy forces
didn't dare come out to try and challenge the St Lawrence until they had an equivalent of their own,
and so they promptly started building a pair of such ships, as well as making efforts to
blow up the British vessel with something of a cross between an early torpedo and an early mine.
This failed, and the British started work on two further vessels of their own,
albeit that they'd already stripped a trio of third rates out at sea of various bits of their
rigging and other equipment, and then hauled it across land in order to provide the St Lawrence
with her means of propulsion. But, as it turned out, her most notable achievement would be to
survive a lightning strike to the mainmast whilst patrolling the lake, as the war came to an end
before any further first rates could be completed by either side. With the war over, and the ship
unable to leave the lake, there was precious little reason to keep such an expensive unit active,
and the following year she would be decommissioned. The 1817 Rush-Bago Treaty resulted in the disarming
of the lakes, which made it even less likely that she'd be called back into service,
but she was held in a disarmed state just in case until 1832, when even this cost was then seen as
unnecessary and the hull was sold and eventually turned into an instant pier and storage facility,
where she would quietly rot away and sink, although her keel and the lower part of her
framing actually survives in place and has since been designated a National Historic Site by
Canada, and what's left of her today can still be seen with the appropriate permits and permissions.
That's it for this video, thanks for watching,
if you have a comment or suggestion for a ship to review, let us know in the comments below.
Don't forget to comment on the pinned post for drydock questions.